Intellectual Capital Measurement in IT industry

The goal of this research – which is to critically analyze current theories and methods of intangible assets evaluation and potentially develop and test new methodology based on the practical example(s) in the IT industry. Having this goal in mind the main research questions in this paper will be: What are advantages and disadvantages of the current practices of measurement intellectual capital or valuation of intangible assets? How to properly measure intellectual capital in IT? Resulting method exhibits a new unique approach to the IC measurement and potentially even larger field of application. Despite the fact that in this particular research, I focused my attention on IT (Software and Internet services cluster – to be exact), the logic behind the method is applicable within any industry since the method is designed to be fully compliant with measurement theory and thus can be properly scaled for any application. Building a new method is a difficult and iterative process: in the current iteration the method stands out as rather a theoretical concept rather than a business tool, however even current concept totally fulfills its purpose as a benchmarking tool for measuring intellectual capital in IT industry.

Analyzing dynamic intellectual capital: System-based theory and application

This research report presents an application of systems theory to evaluating intellectual capital (IC) as organization's ability for self-renewal. As renewal ability is a dynamic capability of an organization as a whole, rather than a static asset or an atomistic competence of separate individuals within the organization, it needs to be understood systemically. Consequently, renewal ability has to be measured with systemic methods that are based on a thorough conceptual analysis of systemic characteristics of organizations. The aim of this report is to demonstrate the theory and analysis methodology for grasping companies' systemic efficiency and renewal ability. The volume is divided into three parts. The first deals with the theory of organizations as self-renewing systems. In the second part, the principles of quantitative analysis of organizations are laid down. Finally, the detailed mathematics of the renewal indices are presented. We also assert that the indices produced by the analysis are an effective tool for the management and valuation of knowledge-intensive companies.

Intellectual capital management in international and Russian software companies

The importance of the company’s intellectual capital (IC) increased during the last decades due to knowledge-based economy development. Despite the clear understanding of the IC importance, researchers agree on the fact that many difficulties in management of intangibles still exist from the both theoretical and practical points of view. The goal of the study is to conduct a comparison of IC management approaches used in international and Russian software companies. To carry out a proper comparison and identify similarities and differences, software firms are explored from the point of view of IC, and then be compared in the context of international and Russian sectors. At the end of the study, current IC management findings in international and Russian software companies are presented, and comparison of IC management is done. It was investigated from the comparison that international and Russian software companies have similarities and few principal differences in several IC management areas. The comparison of IC management approaches between international and Russian software companies provide helpful information to both, researchers and practitioners.

Modelling the simultaneous effects of intellectual capital and knowledge management on the organisational performance of Finnish companies

The aim of this study was to contribute to the current knowledge-based theory by focusing on a research gap that exists in the empirically proven determination of the simultaneous but differentiable effects of intellectual capital (IC) assets and knowledge management (KM) practices on organisational performance (OP). The analysis was built on the past research and theoreticised interactions between the latent constructs specified using the survey-based items that were measured from a sample of Finnish companies for IC and KM and the dependent construct for OP determined using information available from financial databases. Two widely used and commonly recommended measures in the literature on management science, i.e. the return on total assets (ROA) and the return on equity (ROE), were calculated for OP. Thus the investigation of the relationship between IC and KM impacting OP in relation to the hypotheses founded was possible to conduct using objectively derived performance indicators. Using financial OP measures also strengthened the dynamic features of data needed in analysing simultaneous and causal dependences between the modelled constructs specified using structural path models. The estimates were obtained for the parameters of structural path models using a partial least squares-based regression estimator. Results showed that the path dependencies between IC and OP or KM and OP were always insignificant when analysed separate to any other interactions or indirect effects caused by simultaneous modelling and regardless of the OP measure used that was either ROA or ROE. The dependency between the constructs for KM and IC appeared to be very strong and was always significant when modelled simultaneously with other possible interactions between the constructs and using either ROA or ROE to define OP. This study, however, did not find statistically unambiguous evidence for proving the hypothesised causal mediation effects suggesting, for instance, that the effects of KM practices on OP are mediated by the IC assets. Due to the fact that some indication about the fluctuations of causal effects was assessed, it was concluded that further studies are needed for verifying the fundamental and likely hidden causal effects between the constructs of interest. Therefore, it was also recommended that complementary modelling and data processing measures be conducted for elucidating whether the mediation effects occur between IC, KM and OP, the verification of which requires further investigations of measured items and can be build on the findings of this study.

Assessing intellectual capital in a research institute environment in steel industry

Diplomityön tavoitteena oli tutkia aineettoman pääoman hallintaa terästeollisuuden tutkimuslaitosympäristössä, sekä luoda mittaristo kuvaamaan sen tilaa ja kehitystä. Työn rajausten mukaan aineeton pääoma jaettiin Annie Brookingin jaottelun mukaan, ja tarkasteluun valittiin teollisoikeudet sekä henkilöstövoimavarat. Empiirinen osa työstä perustui pääasiassa haastatteluihin sekä Case –yrityksen sisäisiin julkaisuihin. Näitä pyrittiin tulkitsemaan kvalitatiivisten tutkimusmenetelmien oppien mukaan. Tutkimustulosten perusteella voidaan todeta teollisoikeuksien hyödyntämisen olevan suhteellisen vähäistä terästeollisuuden parissa. Syitä tähän on työssä käsitelty melko laajasti. Henkilöstön kehittäminen pitkällä tähtäimellä sekä tiedonkulun tehostaminen henkilöstön keskuudessa ovat puolestaan asioita, joihin kiinnitetään kyseisellä teollisuudenalalla kiitettävässä määrin huomiota. Työn loppupuolella esitelty aineettoman pääoman mittaristo tarjoaa yritykselle työkalun, jonka avulla voidaan monipuolisesti arvioida tätä yrityksille nykyisin elintärkeää asiaa. Lopullista ratkaisumallia se ei aineettoman pääoman mittaamiseen tarjoa, mutta luo kuitenkin tärkeän ensiaskeleen kohti tulevaisuuden yhä kehittyneempiä mittausmenetelmiä.

Intellectual capital, knowledge management practices and firm performance

Researchers have widely recognised and accepted that firm performance is increasingly related to knowledge-based issues. Two separately developed literature streams, intellectual capital (IC) and knowledge management (KM), have been established as the key discussions related to knowledge-based competitive advantage of the firm. Intellectual capital has provided evidence on the strategic key intangible resources of the firm, which could be deployed to create competitive advantage. Knowledge management, in turn, has focused on the managerial processes and practices which can be used to leverage IC to create competitive advantage. Despite extensive literature on both issues, some notable research gaps remain to be closed. In effect, one major gap within the knowledge management research is the lack of understanding related to its influence on firm performance, while IC researchers have articulated a need to utilise more finegrained conceptual models to better understand the key strategic value-creating resources of the firm. In this dissertation, IC is regarded as the entire intellectual capacity, knowledge and competences of the firm that can be leveraged to achieve sustained competitive advantage. KM practices are defined as organisational and managerial activities that enable the firm to leverage its IC to create value. The objective of this dissertation is to answer the research question: “What is the relationship between intellectual capital, knowledge management practices and firm performance?” Five publications have addressed the research question using different approaches. The first two publications were systematic literature reviews of the extant empirical IC and KM research, which established the current state of understanding regarding the relationship between IC, KM practices and firm performance. Publications III and IV were empirical research articles that assessed the developed conceptual model related to IC, KM practices and firm performance. Finally, Publication V was among the first research papers to merge IC and KM disciplines in order to find out which configurations could yield organisational benefits in terms of innovation and market performance outcomes.

Aineettoman pääoman mittaaminen ja tietämyksen hallinnan kehittäminen metsäteollisuusyrityksessä

Tieto on aina ollut yksi yrityksen tärkeimmistä resursseista, mutta vasta nyt siihen on alettu kiinnittää enemmän huomiota. Tiedonjohtaminen ja tietämyksen hallinta ovat haastavia ja osin hankaliakin toimintoja, koska on vaikeaa johtaa sellaista, mitä ei voi kuvata. Tietojohtamista voidaan kuitenkin ajatella prosessina, joka koostuu useammasta alaprosessista, kuten tiedon hankinta, tiedon luominen, tiedon varastointi, tiedon jakaminen ja tiedon soveltaminen. Kun ongelma-alue pilkotaan pienempiin kokonaisuuksiin, on siihen helpompi vaikuttaa. Tässä diplomityössä kehitettiin Stora Enso Publication Papers Oy Ltd Varkauden tehtaalle toimivia työkaluja/-menetelmiä tiedonjohtamisen ja tietämyksen hallinnan tueksi. Työssä luotiin yrityksen tarpeita vastaava mittaristomalli ja keskityttiin siinä erityisesti aineettomaan pääomaan liittyviin mittareihin. Jotta voidaan mitata jotain, on se ensin pystyttävä kuvaamaan. Siksi työssä käsiteltiin myös prosessijohtamista ja analysoitiin hieman yrityksen prosesseja sekä kehitettiin yritykselle uusi "tietojohtaminen" -prosessi. Mittariston ja prosessin luomisen lisäksi työssä esitettiin muutamia toimivia työkaluja/ menetelmiä tiedonjohtamisen ja tietämyksen hallinnan avuksi. Työn teoriaosuudessa tutustuttiin ensin prosessijohtamisen yleisimpiin teorioihin ja tarvittaviin käsitteisiin. Tämän jälkeen luotiin teoriapohja mittariston rakentamiseksi määrittelemällä käsitteet tieto ja aineeton pääoma sekä käsittelemällä muutamia mittaristomalleja, mittariston rakentamista ja aineettoman pääoman mittaamista. Tutkimuksen empiirisessä osassaanalysoitiin yrityksen johtamismalleja sekä määriteltiin prosessijohtamisessa käytetyt termit teorian pohjalta. Pääpaino työssä oli mittariston rakentamisessa ja tiedonjohtamisen sekä tietämyksen hallinnan tehostamisessa. Mittaristomalli luotiin useamman teorian pohjalta painottuen kuitenkinselvästi Balanced Scorecard -menetelmään. Työn tuloksena oli kattava mittaristomalli, aineettoman pääoman mittareita sekä uusia työkaluja/-menetelmiä tiedonjohtamiseen ja tietämyksen hallintaan.

Modeling and measuring organizational renewal capability

Globalization and new information technologies mean that organizations have to face world-wide competition in rapidly transforming, unpredictable environments, and thus the ability to constantly generate novel and improved products, services and processes has become quintessential for organizational success. Performance in turbulent environments is, above all, influenced by the organization's capability for renewal. Renewal capability consists of the ability of the organization to replicate, adapt, develop and change its assets, capabilities and strategies. An organization with a high renewal capability can sustain its current success factors while at the same time building new strengths for the future. This capability does not only mean that the organization is able to respond to today's challenges and to keep up with the changes in its environment, but also that it can actas a forerunner by creating innovations, both at the tactical and strategic levels of operation and thereby change the rules of the market. However, even though it is widely agreed that the dynamic capability for continuous learning, development and renewal is a major source of competitive advantage, there is no widely shared view on how organizational renewal capability should be defined, and the field is characterized by a plethora of concepts and definitions. Furthermore,there is a lack of methods for systematically assessing organizational renewal capability. The dissertation aims to bridge these gaps in the existing research by constructing an integrative theoretical framework for organizational renewal capability and by presenting a method for modeling and measuring this capability. The viability of the measurement tool is demonstrated in several contexts, andthe framework is also applied to assess renewal in inter-organizational networks. In this dissertation, organizational renewal capability is examined by drawing on three complimentary theoretical perspectives: knowledge management, strategic management and intellectual capital. The knowledge management perspective considers knowledge as inherently social and activity-based, and focuses on the organizational processes associated with its application and development. Within this framework, organizational renewal capability is understood as the capacity for flexible knowledge integration and creation. The strategic management perspective, on the other hand, approaches knowledge in organizations from the standpoint of its implications for the creation of competitive advantage. In this approach, organizational renewal is framed as the dynamic capability of firms. The intellectual capital perspective is focused on exploring how intangible assets can be measured, reported and communicated. From this vantage point, renewal capability is comprehended as the dynamic dimension of intellectual capital, which consists of the capability to maintain, modify and create knowledge assets. Each of the perspectives significantly contributes to the understanding of organizationalrenewal capability, and the integrative approach presented in this dissertationcontributes to the individual perspectives as well as to the understanding of organizational renewal capability as a whole.

The Management of Intellectual Capital in the Early Phases of Project Marketing

This study aims at enhancing understanding and deriving new constructs about the management of intellectual capital in the early phases of project marketing. The research methodology employed is deductive; conceptual reasoning is based on existing literature. The study's knowledge base is drawn from the bodies of literature dealing with project, relationship, and industrial marketing, as well as from the literature dealing with mechanical engineering, network approach, systems selling, R&D, project portfolio, strategic, financial, and knowledge management. As a result, three processes, 32 summaries and 19 conclusions give to the management of intellectual capital meaning in the context of project marketing. These conclusions and synthesis are proposed to improve the existing concepts and models in project marketing.

Developing the measurement and management of knowledge: applying the constructive research approach in a knowledge intensive service environment

Intellectual assets have attained continuous attention in the academic field, as they are vital sources of competitive advantage and organizational performance in the contemporary knowledge intensive business environment. Intellectual capital measurement is quite thoroughly addressed in the accounting literature. However, the purpose of the measurement is to support the management of intellectual assets, but the reciprocal relationship between measurement and management has not been comprehensively considered in the literature. The theoretical motivation for this study rose from this paradox, as in order to maximise the effectiveness of knowledge management the two initiatives need to be closely integrated. The research approach of this interventionist case study is constructive. The objective is to develop the case organization’s knowledge management and intellectual capital measurement in a way that they would be closely integrated and the measurement would support the management of intellectual assets. The case analysis provides valuable practical considerations about the integration and related issues as the case company is a knowledge intensive organization in which the know-how of the employees is the central competitive asset and therefore, the management and measurement of knowledge are essential for its future success. The results suggest that the case organization is confronting challenges in managing knowledge. In order to appropriately manage knowledge processes and control the related risks, support from intellectual capital measurement is required. However, challenges in measuring intellectual capital, especially knowledge, could be recognized in the organization. By reflecting the knowledge management situation and the constructed strategy map, a new intellectual measurement system was developed for the case organization. The construction of the system as well as its indicators can be perceived to contribute to the literature, emphasizing of the importance of properly considering the organization’s knowledge situation in developing an intellectual capital measurement system.

Knowledge, processes and relationships in organizational change: Understanding how to facilitate management of intellectual capital in diverse organization structures and cultures.

This study examined relationships of organizational dependencies, change management and developed intellectual knowledge resources, in different intellectual capital based development programs on ICT-sector. Study was carried out in a research context, where high degree of external organizational contingencies existed and lots of changes in several development programs had taken place in the last years. From a scientific perspective the main contribution was that evidence between relationships of organizational dependencies, change model portfolio and developed knowledge resources could be suggested. From managerial perspective the primary implication was that in situations where sustainable competitive advantage is pursued by means of increasing knowledge based productivity of labor, firms should seek to pursue organizational settings where external dependencies have minimal amount of effect.

Social capital and health : variations, associations and challenges

Although social capital and health have been extensively studied during the last decade, there are still open issues in current empirical research. These concern for instance the measurement of the concept in different contexts, as well as the association between different types of social capital and different dimensions of health. The present thesis addressed these questions. The general aim was to promote the understanding of social capital and health by investigating the oldest old and the two major language groups in Finland, Swedish- and Finnish-speakers. Another aim was to contribute to the discussion on methodological issues in social capital and health research. The present thesis investigated two empirical data sets, Umeå 85+ and Health 2000. The Umeå 85+ study was a cross-sectional study of 163 individuals aged 85, 90, and 95 or older, living in the municipality of Umeå, Sweden, in the year of 2000. The Health 2000 survey was a national study of 8,028 persons aged 30 or above carried out in Finland in 2000-2001. Different indicators of structural (e.g. social contacts) and cognitive (e.g. trust) social capital, as well as health indicators were used as variables in the analyses. The Umeå 85+ data set was analyzed with factor analysis, as well as univariate and multivariate analysis of variance. The Health 2000 data was analyzed with logistic regression techniques. The results showed that the Swedish-speakers in the Finnish data set Health 2000 had consistently higher prevalence of social capital compared to the Finnish-speakers even after controlling for central sociodemographic variables. The results further showed that even if the language group differences in health were small, the Swedishspeakers experienced in general better self-reported health compared with the Finnish-speakers. Common sociodemographic variables could not explain these observed differences in health. The results imply that social capital is often, but not always, associated with health. This was clearly seen in the Umeå 85+ data set where only one health indicator (depressive symptoms) was associated with structural social capital among the oldest old. The results based on the analysis of the Health 2000 survey demonstrated that the cognitive component of social capital was associated with self-rated health and psychological health rather than with participation in social activities and social contacts. In addition, social capital statistically reduced the health advantage especially for Swedish-speaking men, indicating that high prevalence of social capital may promote health. Finally, the present thesis also discussed the issue of methodological challenges faced with when analyzing social capital and health. It was suggested that certain components of social capital such as bonding and bridging social capital may be more relevant than structural and cognitive components when investigating social capital among the two language groups in Finland. The results concerning the oldest old indicated that the structural aspects of social capital probably reflect current living conditions, whereas cognitive social capital reflects attitudes and traits often acquired decades earlier. This is interpreted as an indication of the fact that structural and cognitive social capital are closely related yet empirically two distinctive concepts. Taken together, some components of social capital may be more relevant to study than others depending on which population group and age group is under study. The results also implied that the choice of cut-off point of dichotomization of selfrated health has an impact on the estimated effects of the explanatory variables. When the whole age interval, 35-64 years, was analyzed with logistic regression techniques the choice of cut-off point did not matter for the estimated effects of marital status and educational level. The results changed, however, when the age interval was divided into three shorter intervals. If self-rated health is explored using wide age intervals that do not account for age-dependent covariates there is a risk of drawing misleading conclusions. In conclusion, the results presented in the thesis suggest that the uneven distribution of social capital observed between the two language groups in Finland are of importance when trying to further understand health inequalities that exist between Swedish- and Finnish-speakers in Finland. Although social capital seemed to be relevant to the understanding of health among the oldest old, the meaning of social capital is probably different compared to a less vulnerable age group. This should be noticed in future empirical research. In the present thesis, it was shown that the relationship between social capital and health is complex and multidimensional. Different aspects of social capital seem to be important for different aspects of health. This reduces the possibility to generalize the results and to recommend general policy implementations in this area. An increased methodological awareness regarding social capital as well as health are called for in order to further understand the cfomplex association between them. However, based on the present data and findings social capital is associated with health. To understand individual health one must also consider social aspects of the individuals’ environment such as social capital.

Aineettomien riskien hallinta – case Itä-Suomen Biopankki

Aineeton pääoma nähdään organisaation keskeisenä kilpailutekijänä ja voimavarana. Se voi kuitenkin joissain tilanteissa olla organisaatiolle myös rasite tai jopa menestymistä heikentävä tekijä. Tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli laatia biopankin riskienhallinnalle malli, joka huomioi toimintaan vaikuttavat aineettomat riskitekijät ja toimii strategisena johtamisen ja toiminnan kehittämisen työvälineenä. Tutkimus toteutettiin tapaustutkimuksena, jossa käytettiin konstruktiivista tutkimusotetta. Biopankille luotiin konstruktio, riskienhallintamalli, jolla pyrittiin ratkaisemaan reaalimaailman ongelma ja samalla luomaan kontribuutiota tieteenalalle. Biopankki on uudentyyppinen organisaatio, joka kerää, hallinnoi ja säilyttää biologisia ihmisperäisiä näytteitä ja niihin liittyviä tietoja tulevaa tutkimusta varten. Toiminnan riskien taustasyyt ovat usein aineettomia, kuten toimintakulttuuri, asenne, osaaminen tai motivaatio. Tutkimuksessa löydettiin uusia biopankin toimintaan kytkeytyviä aineettomia riskejä koko aineettoman pääoman alueelta ja määriteltiin riskitasoihin perustuva lähestymistapa riskien hallintaan. Konstruktio aineettomien riskien hallintamalliksi sai selkeää vahvistusta tutkimuksen aineistosta, ja se voi toimia organisaation kehittämisen pohjana. Riskikartan luominen ja riskien arviointi ovat tekohetken poikkileikkauksia tilanteesta. Organisaation toiminta ja siihen kohdistuvat riskit ja mahdollisuudet muuttuvat ja kehittyvät. Riskien tunnistaminen lisää tietoa organisaatiosta ja sen toimintaympäristöstä, mikä luo puitteet myös uusien mahdollisuuksien tunnistamiselle. Sopivan riskienhallintamallin avulla voidaan löytää kilpailuetua suhteessa muihin organisaatioihin. Kilpailuetuna voi toimia myös muita parempi riskinkantokyky esimerkiksi toiminnan joustavuuden kautta.

Henkilöstöraportointi ICT-alan pörssiyrityksissä

Tämän tutkimuksen aiheena on tarkastella ICT-alan pörssiyritysten henkilöstöraportoinnin nykykäytäntöä. Tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on selvittää vapaaehtoisen henkilöstöraportoinnin laatua, laajuutta ja eroavaisuuksia yritysten vuoden 2004 vuosikertomuksissa ja muissa julkaistuissa henkilöstöinformaatiota sisältävissä raporteissa. Tutkimus jakaantuu kahteen päätavoitteeseen. Tutkimuksen ensimmäisenä tavoitteena on esitellä, mitä erilaisia lähestymistapoja ja malleja yrityksen henkilöstöinformaation mittaamiseen ja raportointiin on kirjallisuudessa esitetty. Toisena tavoitteena on selvittää ja kuvata sitä, millaista tutkimuksen kohdeyritysten henkilöstöraportointi tällä hetkellä on. Tutkimus kuuluu laadullisen tutkimuksen piiriin ja on luonteeltaan deskriptiivistä ja ymmärtämään pyrkivää. Lisäksi tutkimuksen voidaan todeta olevan empiirinen - tutkimusmenetelmänä käytetään valmiita aineistoja. Tutkimuksessa tarkastelun kohteeksi valittiin 25 ICT-alan yritystä, jotka on noteerattu vuoden 2004 lopussa Helsingin pörssin päälistalla. Tässä tutkimuksessa henkilöstöraportointia tarkasteltiin henkilöstövoimavarojen laskentatoimen ja osaamispääoman lähestymistapojen kautta. Tutkimuksen perusteella voidaan todeta, että kirjallisuudesta löytyy paljon erilaisia malleja henkilöstöinformaation tuottamiseen, kuten henkilöstötilinpäätös ja erilaiset osaamispääomaraportit. Henkilöstötilinpäätös on organisaation henkilöstöpääoman julkiseen raportointiin tarkoitettu asiakirja. Osaamispääomaraporteissa ei keskitytä pelkästään henkilöstölukuihin, vaan henkilöstön rinnalle haetaan tietoa taloudellisista ja aineettomista prosesseista, asiakkaista ja toimintaympäristöstä. Mallit eivät ole toisiaan poissulkevia, vaan täydentäviä. Osaamispääoma voidaan jakaa inhimilliseen pääomaan sekä sisäisiin ja ulkoisiin rakenteisiin. Henkilöstölaskentatoimi tukee inhimillisen pääoman mittausta ja hallintaa sopivin muutoksin. Tutkimuksen perusteellavoidaan todeta, että ICT-alan pörssiyritysten henkilöstöraportoinnin yleinen taso on kohtuullisen hyvä, mutta henkilöstöraportoinnin laatu ja laajuus vaihtelevat suuresti yritysten välillä. Osa yrityksistä käytti enemmän kvantitatiivista tunnuslukupohjaista raportointia ja osa panosti laadulliseen selostuspohjaiseen informointiin. Ensisijaisena henkilöstöraportointimuotona aineiston yritykset käyttivät vuosikertomusta. Yrityskoko selitti henkilöstöraportoinnin laajuutta. Tutkimustulokset osoittivat, että mitä suurempi sekä liikevaihdolla että henkilöstömäärällä mitattuna yritys on, sitä kattavampaa sen henkilöstöraportointi on.