Improving business processes in a globally dispersed make-to-order supply chain. Case study on outbound logistics in a Multinational Corporation

The purpose of this thesis is to find out how outbound logistics process can be improved by reducing unnecessary waste in a globally dispersed make-to-order (MTO) supply chain. The research problem was addressed by a multinational corporation that aims to find a solution for reducing unnecessary waste in their outbound logistics process. The focus is on customized products that are delivered via sea transportation. Theoretical framework for improving outbound logistics processes in globally dispersed MTO supply chain was created based on business process management, Porter’s value chain theory, value stream mapping and current reality tree. The empirical research was conducted by using constructive approach due to its ability to research a practical problem and to improve the existing practices. The data was collected from ten semi-structured interviews and three non-participant observations. By analysing the data and applying the theoretical framework, five types of waste were detected in the process that were seen to derive from six root causes. Practical solution was constructed to reduce the waste in the process by combining the existing literature with the ideas raising from empirical data. The results of this thesis suggest that a MNC with a globally dispersed MTO supply chain can improve its outbound logistics process by applying activities that enhance internal and external integration, collaboration and coordination, and increase predictability of the process. This research has practical relevance both for the case company as well as for other MNCs with globally dispersed MTO supply chains that aim to improve their outbound logistics processes. This research contributes to the BPM and CRA research by providing an evidence for their applicability in the new context.

Developing Supply Chain Process Management and Measurement in Global Manufacturing Company

The objective of this research is to create a current state analysis of pulp supply chain processes from production planning to deliveries to customers. A cross-functional flowchart is being used to model these processes. These models help finding key performance indicators (KPIs) which enable examinations of the supply chain efficiency. Supply chain measures in different processes reveal the changes need processes that affect the whole supply chain and its efficiency and competitiveness. Structure of pulp supply chain differs from most of the other supply chains. The fact that there are big volumes of bulk products, small product variations and supply forecasts are made for the year ahead make the difference. This factor brings different benefits but also challenges when developing supply chain. This thesis divides pulp supply chain in three different main categories: production planning, warehousing and transportation. It provides tools for estimating the functionality of supply chain as well as developing the efficiency for different functions of supply chain. By having a better understanding of supply chain processes and measurement the whole supply chain structure can be developed significantly.

Offshoring and outsourcing under demand uncertainty -a supply chain management analysis

Outsourcing and offshoring or any combinations of these have not just become a popular phenomenon, but are viewed as one of the most important management strategies due to the new possibilities from globalization. They have been seen as a possibility to save costs and improve customer service. Executing offshoring and offshore outsourcing successfully can be more complex than initially expected. Potential cost savings resulting from of offshoring and offshore outsourcing are often based on lower manufacturing costs. However, these benefits might be conflicted by a more complex supply chain with service level challenges that can respectively increase costs. Therefore analyzing the total cost effects of offshoring and outsourcing is necessary. The aim of this Master´s Thesis was to to construct a total cost model using academic literature to calculate the total costs and analyze the reasonability of offshoring and offshore outsourcing production of a case company compared to insourcing production. The research data was mainly quantitative and collected mainly from the case company past sales and production records. In addition management level interviews from the case company were conducted. The information from these interviews was used for the qualification of the necessary quantitative data and adding supportive information that could not be gathered from the quantitative data. Both data collection and analysis were guided by a theoretical frame of reference that was based on academic literature concerning offshoring and outsourcing, statistical calculation of demand and total costs. The results confirm the theories that offshoring and offshore outsourcing would reduce total costs as both offshoring and offshore outsourcing options result in lower total annual costs than insourcing mainly due to lower manufacturing costs. However, increased demand uncertainty would make the alternative of offshore outsourcing more risky and difficult to manage. Therefore when assessing the overall impact of the alternatives, offshoring is the most preferable option. As the main cost savings in offshore outsourcing came from lower manufacturing costs, more specifically labour costs, the logistics costs in this case company did not have an essential effect in total costs. The management should therefore pay attention initially to manufacturing costs and then logistics costs when choosing the best production sourcing option for the company.

Supply Chain Adaptation of Finnish Companies in Chinese Institutional Environment

Within the last few decades of operations and supply chain management, the field has seen the rise of so called best practices, methods that will help supply chains obtain their business goals and gain a competitive edge. These methods were thought to be universal. This however is not always the case, as the surrounding business environment could have a significant impact on what will be effective in gaining competitive edge. Contingency theory states that the success of a supply chain is determined by both internal capabilities, as well as external context aligning. This creates a strategic fit, which is a major determinant of success. In order for supply chains to reach this strategic fit, they must adapt. As China has seen rapid growth and over the last few decades become one of the major economies of the world, Western companies have tried to establish themselves there, only to find that the Chinese market is extremely difficult to operate in. The aim of this thesis was to investigate from contingency theory perspective, what are the institutional factors that affect supply chain management of Finnish companies operating in China, and how do Finnish companies adapt their supply chains to better fit the Chinese institutional environment. A theoretical model was created for this thesis, in which supply chains possess resources, which can be combined in a meaningful manner to create capabilities. Both resources and capabilities are affected by the surrounding institutional environment, which forces supply chains to adapt in order to find a better strategic fit. A total of six Finnish managers from three large and three small companies operating in China were interviewed. The results indicated that the Chinese business environment is significantly different, than that of Finland or Western countries in general. Three institutional factors were identified: Confucian though, fast-paced business environment, and managing labor force. These three institutional factors made the relationship and delivery capabilities particularly important, as well as human resources, reputation, physical resources and technological resources. In conclusion, it was discovered that the Chinese institutional environment is heavily affected by Confucian thought, as well as the rapid market growth. These are the two most important institutional factors that shape the Chinese market. If supply chains wish to be successful in China, adaptation regarding these two institutional factors should yield good results.

Supply Chain Adaptation of Finnish Companies in Chinese Institutional Environment

Within the last few decades of operations and supply chain management, the field has seen the rise of so called best practices, methods that will help supply chains obtain their business goals and gain a competitive edge. These methods were thought to be universal. This however is not always the case, as the surrounding business environment could have a significant impact on what will be effective in gaining competitive edge. Contingency theory states that the success of a supply chain is determined by both internal capabilities, as well as external context aligning. This creates a strategic fit, which is a major determinant of success. In order for supply chains to reach this strategic fit, they must adapt. As China has seen rapid growth and over the last few decades become one of the major economies of the world, Western companies have tried to establish themselves there, only to find that the Chinese market is extremely difficult to operate in. The aim of this thesis was to investigate from contingency theory perspective, what are the institutional factors that affect supply chain management of Finnish companies operating in China, and how do Finnish companies adapt their supply chains to better fit the Chinese institutional environment. A theoretical model was created for this thesis, in which supply chains possess resources, which can be combined in a meaningful manner to create capabilities. Both resources and capabilities are affected by the surrounding institutional environment, which forces supply chains to adapt in order to find a better strategic fit. A total of six Finnish managers from three large and three small companies operating in China were interviewed. The results indicated that the Chinese business environment is significantly different, than that of Finland or Western countries in general. Three institutional factors were identified: Confucian though, fast-paced business environment, and managing labor force. These three institutional factors made the relationship and delivery capabilities particularly important, as well as human resources, reputation, physical resources and technological resources. In conclusion, it was discovered that the Chinese institutional environment is heavily affected by Confucian thought, as well as the rapid market growth. These are the two most important institutional factors that shape the Chinese market. If supply chains wish to be successful in China, adaptation regarding these two institutional factors should yield good results.

Paineellisten reaktoreiden projektitoimituksen optimointi

Diplomityössä tavoitteena on saada selvitys, jonka avulla yritys löytää toimitusprojekteistaan parannusta ja huomiota vaativat osa-alueet projektimuotoisten toimitusten kustannusrakennetta ja optimointia tarkastelemalla. Näin yritys voi tulevaisuudessa kehittää projektitoimituksen osa-alueita niin että se voi vastata asiakkaiden asettamiin vaatimuksiin sekä haasteisiin entistä nopeammin ja tarkemmin. Tutkimuksen lähtökohtana ovat projektiajattelu sekä siihen liittyvän toimitusketjun prosessit, joiden avulla lähestytään tutkimuksen ongelmaa ja selvitetään koko toimitusprojektin kehitystä vaativat alueet. Tutkimuksessa vaaditut tiedot saavutettiin vapaamuotoisten haastattelujen, yrityksen dokumentteja tutkimalla sekä yhteistyökumppanien avulla. Projektitoimituksen kokonaisvaltainen kehitys vaatii yhteistyötä ja huomiota toimitusketjun jokaisessa osa-alueessa aina raaka-ainelähteiltä loppukäyttäjälle asti. Näin voidaan saavuttaa tietojen avoimuus ja täsmällisyys, jotta päästään parhaaseen lopputulokseen projektitoimituksen osalta. Erityisesti kustannusrakenteen jakauma tuleehuomioida tulevaisuudessa tarkasti tehtäessä projektitoimitukseen liittyviä ratkaisuja. Esivalmistusasteen tarkastelu asetettiin työn alussa yhdeksi tärkeimmäksi tutkimuskohteeksi. Tarkastelussa havaittiin, että valmistusasteen valinnalla voidaan vaikuttaa lähes puoleen reaktorin kustannusrakenteen mukaisista kustannuksista kuten työ-, kuljetus- ja asennuskustannukseen. Myös materiaalikustannukset ovat suuressa roolissa reaktorinkustannusrakenteessa, joten tähän tulee kiinnittää myös huomiota. Muita tutkittavia tekijöitä, jotka pääasiassa vaikuttivat materiaali- ja asennuskustannuksiin työssä olivat paineastiastandardin ja paineluokan sekä valmistuspaikan valinta. Lisäksi huomioitiin toteutuneiden toimitusten eroavaisuuksia teoreettisiin ratkaisuihin ja etsittiin näistä mahdollisia kehitys- ja kustannussäästökohteita.

Value added logistics in supply and demand chains. Smile. Part 1. eBusiness between global company and itslocal sme supplier network

VALOSADE (Value Added Logistics in Supply and Demand Chains) is the research project of Anita Lukka's VALORE (Value Added Logistics Research) research team inLappeenranta University of Technology. VALOSADE is included in ELO (Ebusiness logistics) technology program of Tekes (Finnish Technology Agency). SMILE (SME-sector, Internet applications and Logistical Efficiency) is one of four subprojects of VALOSADE. SMILE research focuses on case network that is composed of small and medium sized mechanical maintenance service providers and global wood processing customers. Basic principle of SMILE study is communication and ebusiness insupply and demand network. This first phase of research concentrates on creating backgrounds for SMILE study and for ebusiness solutions of maintenance case network. The focus is on general trends of ebusiness in supply chains and networksof different industries; total ebusiness system architecture of company networks; ebusiness strategy of company network; information value chain; different factors, which influence on ebusiness solution of company network; and the correlation between ebusiness and competitive advantage. Literature, interviews and benchmarking were used as research methods in this qualitative case study. Networks and end-to-end supply chains are the organizational structures, which can add value for end customer. Information is one of the key factors in these decentralized structures. Because of decentralization of business, information is produced and used in different companies and in different information systems. Information refinement services are needed to manage information flows in company networksbetween different systems. Furthermore, some new solutions like network information systems are utilised in optimising network performance and in standardizingnetwork common processes. Some cases have however indicated, that utilization of ebusiness in decentralized business model is not always a necessity, but value-add of ICT must be defined case-specifically. In the theory part of report, different ebusiness and architecture models are introduced. These models are compared to empirical case data in research results. The biggest difference between theory and empirical data is that models are mainly developed for large-scale companies - not for SMEs. This is due to that implemented network ebusiness solutions are mainly large company centered. Genuine SME network centred ebusiness models are quite rare, and the study in that area has been few in number. Business relationships between customer and their SME suppliers are nowadays concentrated more on collaborative tactical and strategic initiatives besides transaction based operational initiatives. However, ebusiness systems are further mainly based on exchange of operational transactional data. Collaborative ebusiness solutions are in planning or pilot phase in most case companies. Furthermore, many ebusiness solutions are nowadays between two participants, but network and end-to-end supply chain transparency and information systems are quite rare. Transaction volumes, data formats, the types of exchanged information, information criticality,type and duration of business relationship, internal information systems of partners, processes and operation models (e.g. different ordering models) differ among network companies, and furthermore companies are at different stages on networking and ebusiness readiness. Because of former factors, different customer-supplier combinations in network must utilise totally different ebusiness architectures, technologies, systems and standards.

Supply network risks and costs in Finnish project business

This report summarizes the results of the survey HAVERI – Supply network risks in business. The survey was conducted in Finland during the spring and summer of year 2013. The survey is part of a large two-year research project started in June 2012 in Finland (on-going 06/2012–07/2014). The project is launched and financed by TEKES, the Finnish Funding Agency for Technology and Innovation, and executed together with the researchers from Lappeenranta University of Technology and Tampere University of Technology. The overall goal of this on-going research project is to find out the decision-making practices in the project-oriented companies in their purchasing decisions especially in the mechanical engineering and construction industries in Finland. The objective of the survey was to gain cross-sectional data concerning the challenges, risks and cost factors in Finnish project business companies. The results show that Finnish companies rely on their experience and supplier references in their risk management. In general, the understanding of the total cost structure varies among the industries and companies. The main cost factor in risk management was costs before the actual purchase decision. Overall, it seems that the monetary value of the whole project and capability of purchasing personnel are the main influencing factors on risk management activity in project purchasing.

Value added logistical support service: logistics cost structure and performance in the new concept. Part 3

The aim of this study is to present an Activity-Based Costing spreadsheet tool for analyzing the logistics costs. The tool can be used both by customer-companies and logistics service providers. The study discusses the influence of different activity models on costs. Additionally this paper discusses about the logistical performance across the total supply chain This study is carried out using ananalytical research approach and literature material has been used for supplementing the concerned research approach. Cost structure analysis was based on the theory of activity-based management. This study was outlined to spare part logistics in machine-shop industry. The outlines of logistics services and logisticalperformance discussed in this report are based on the new logistics business concept (LMS-concept), which has been presented earlier in the Valssi-project. Oneof the aims of this study is to increase awareness of different activity modelson logistics costs. The report paints an overall picture about the business environment and requirements for the new logistics concept.

Information and Material Flows in Project Business

Tavoitteena diplomityössä oli kuvata projektiliiketoimintaa harjoittavan yrityksen informaatio- ja materiaalivirrat toimitusprojekteissa. Selvitys haluttiin tehdä tulevia kehitysprojekteja varten. Diplomityö toteutettiin kahessa osassa: laatimalla aiheeseen liittyvä teoriakatsaus ja kartoittamalla todellinen tilanne yrityksen sisällä.Teoriaosassa kuvattiin tarkastelualue ja projektiliiketoiminnan erityispiirteitä sekä käsiteltiin tietojärjestelmiä ja materiaalivirran hallintaan liittyviä asioita. Yrityksen informaatio- ja materiaalivirtojen nykytila kartoitettiin laatimalla vuokaaviot kolmen esimerkkituotteen toimitusprojekteista. Kaaviot laadittiin yrityksen sisäisten dokumenttien ja kvalitatiivisten haastattelujen pohjalta. Kaavioiden sisältöä täydennettiin taulukoimalla kaavioissa esiintyvien dokumettien sisältöä. Työn tuloksena muodostui kuva tiedonkäsittelyn nykytilasta myynti- ja toimitusprojekteissa, pelkistetty visio tulevaisuuden tietojärjestelmien rooleista sekä ehdotuksia tulevia kehitysprojekteja varten.

LAIPPATEHTAAN TOIMITUSVARMUUDEN JA LÄPIMENOAIKOJEN KEHITTÄMINEN AIKAPERUSTEISEN PROSESSIJOHTAMISEN KEINOIN

Yritysten sisäiset prosessit ovat usein pysyneet samanlaisina jo vuosia, ellei vuosikymmeniä. Tulevaisuuden haasteet löytyvät mitä suurimmassa määrin yritysten omista, monessa tapauksessa vielä tunnistamattomista prosesseista. Näiden haasteiden pohjalta, tämän diplomityön perusajatuksena on prosessijohtaminen. Diplomityön tutkimusongelma on laippatehtaan vaihteleva ja usein liian alhainen viikoittainen toimitusvarmuus, pitkät tilaus-toimitusketjun läpimenoajat ja alihankintalaippojen maahantuonnin vaikutus tehtaan toimitusvarmuuteen. Työn tarkoituksena on tutkia, kuvata ja analysoida tehtaan tuotannonohjauksen ja prosessien nykytilanne. Kirjallisuustutkimuksen ja analyysien pohjalta tavoitteena on tehdä ja toteuttaa erilaisia kehitysvaihtoehtoja toimitusvarmuuden, läpimenoaikojen ja tuotannon seurannan kehittämiseksi. Työssä analysoitiin Ferral Components Oy:n tuotannon nykytilaa, joka on perinteisesti ollut standardituotteiden varasto-ohjattua toimintaa. Analyysin perustietoina käytettiin yrityksen tuotannonohjausjärjestelmästä saatavia tilaus-toimitustietoja pääosin vuosilta 2003 ja 2004, joiltakin osin myös vuoden 2005 tietoja. ABC-analyysin tuloksena saatiin selville yrityksen tuotteiston rakenne ja sen pohjalta päätuoteryhmien tilaus-toimitusketjut. Päätuoteryhmien tilaus-toimitusketjujen selvittämisen jälkeen voitiin analysoida niiden nykytilanne. Nykytila-analyysin tulokset osoittivat, että tilaustoimitusketjut eivät ole suorituskykyisiä käytettyjen menetelmien ja mittareiden valossa ja kehitystarvetta on olemassa. Nykytila-analyysin, kirjallisuustutkimuksen ja projektikokousten avulla löydettiin kehityskohteita prosessien luomiseksi, sekä niiden kehittämiseksi. Pääasiallinen kehityskohde löydettiin analyysin pohjalta määritettyjen tilaus-toimitusketjujen eriyttämisestä omiksi ydinprosesseikseen. Ydinprosessit kuvattiin etulehtien, prosessikaavioiden ja tekstisivujen avulla. Lisäksi ydinprosesseille hahmoteltiin uusi prosessien mukainen tuotannon layout ja määriteltiin prosessien seurantaan soveltuvat mittarit. Lopuksi listattiin ydinprosesseille nykytila-analyysin pohjalta havaittuja kehitysideoita ja niiden mahdollisia positiivisia vaikutuksia sekä tehtiin taulukkolaskentaohjelmalla taulukko varasto-ohjattavien tuotteiden hälytysrajojen määrittämiseksi.

Puutuoteteollisuusyrityksen tilaus-toimitusketjun liiketoimintamallien kehittäminen

Tämä diplomityö on osa Puutavaralogistiikan läpinäkyvyyden kehittäminen – hanketta (PuLK-hanke), joka tähtää puutuoteteollisuudessa toimivan yrityksen tilaus-toimitusketjun läpinäkyvyyden lisäämiseen. Hanke on aloitettu kohdeyrityksen tarpeesta parantaa tilaus-toimitusketjun toimintaa uusien toimintaympäristön haasteiden edessä. Tämän työn tavoitteena oli selvittää kohdeyrityksen tilaus-toimitusketjun nykytila sekä tuottaa hankkeessa myöhemmässä vaiheessa toteutettavan systeemiteoreettisen mallinnuksen alkutiedoksi sopiva ylätason liiketoimintamalli. Nämä tehtiin kolmella eri lähestymistavalla, joiden avulla saatiin muodostettua kattava kuva nykytilasta sekä selvitettyä tarvittavalla tarkkuudella liiketoiminnan ylätason malliin vaaditut tiedot. Tärkeimmät käytetyt menetelmät olivat liiketoiminnan mallinnus, swot-analyysi kyselytutkimuksen tuloksista ja kirjallisuustutkimus tuettuna haastatteluilla, tutustumiskäynneillä ja yhteistyöosapuolien resurssien käytöllä. Liiketoiminnan mallinnus osoittautui hyödylliseksi työkaluksi paljastaen toiminnan epäkohdat koko ketjun tasolla niin, että korjaavien toimenpiteiden toteutus helpottui. Systeemiteoreettisen simulointimallin muodostaminen aloitettiin liiketoiminnan mallinnuksen tuottaman informaation pohjalta.

E-PORT. Improving efficiency of Finnish port community by intelligent systems Final report of the Mobile Port project

The management of port-related supply chains is challenging due to the complex and heterogeneous operations of the ports with several actors and processes. That is why the importance of information sharing is emphasised in the ports. However, the information exchange between different port-related actors is often cumbersome and it still involves a lot of manual work and paper. Major ports and port-related actors usually have advanced information systems in daily use but these systems are seldom interoperable with each other, which prevents economies of scale to be reached. Smaller ports and companies might not be equipped with electronic data transmission at all. This is the final report of the Mobile port (MOPO) project, which has sought ways to improve the management and control of port-related sea and inland traffic with the aid of ICT technologies. The project has studied port community systems (PCS) used worldwide, evaluated the suitability of a PCS for the Finnish port operating environment and created a pilot solution of a Finnish PCS in the port of HaminaKotka. Further, the dry port concept and its influences on the transportation system have been explored. The Mobile Port project comprised of several literature reviews, interviews of over 50 port-related logistics and/or ICT professionals, two different kinds of simulation models as well as designing and implementing of the pilot solution of the Finnish PCS. The results of these multiple studies are summarised in this report. Furthermore, recommendations for future actions and the topics for further studies are addressed in the report. The study revealed that the information sharing in a typical Finnish port-related supply chain contains several bottlenecks that cause delays in shipments and waste resources. The study showed that many of these bottlenecks could be solved by building a port community system for the Finnish port community. Almost 30 different kinds of potential services or service entities of a Finnish PCS were found out during the study. The basic requirements, structure, interfaces and operation model of the Finnish PCS were also defined in the study. On the basis of the results of the study, a pilot solution of the Finnish PCS was implemented in the port of HaminaKotka. The pilot solution includes a Portconnect portal for the Finnish port community system (available at https://www.portconnect.fi) and two pilot applications, which are a service for handling the information flows concerning the movements of railway wagons and a service for handling the information flows between Finnish ports and Finland-Russian border. The study also showed that port community systems can be used to improve the environmental aspects of logistics in two different ways: 1) PCSs can bring direct environmental benefits and 2) PCSs can be used as an environmental tool in a port community. On the basis of the study, the development of the Finnish port community system should be continued by surveying other potential applications for the Finnish PCS. It is also important to study if there is need and resources to extend the Finnish PCS to operate in several ports or even on a national level. In the long run, it could be reasonable to clarify whether there would be possibilities to connect the Finnish PCS as a part of Baltic Sea wide, European-wide or even worldwide maritime and port-related network in order to get the best benefit from the system