Customer satisfaction data utilization: identifying value drivers and information use practices

The objective of this master’s thesis was twofold: first to examine the concept of customer value and its drivers and second to identify information use practices. The first part of the study represents explorative research that was carried out by examining a case company’s customer satisfaction data that was used to identify sales and technical customer service related value drivers on a detailed attribute level. This was followed by an examination of whether these attributes had been commented on in a positive or a negative light and what were the reasons why the case company had received higher or lower ratings than its competitor. As a result a classification of different sales and technical customer service related attributes was created. The results indicated that the case company has performed well, but that the results varied on the company’s business segment level. The case company’s staff, service and the benefits from a long-lasting relationship came up in a positive light whereas attitude, flexibility and reaction time came up in a negative light. The reasons for a higher or lower score in comparison to competitor varied. The results indicated that a customer’s satisfaction with the company’s performance did not always mean that the company was outperforming the competition. The second part of the study focused on customer satisfaction information use from the viewpoints of information access, dissemination and reaction. The study was conducted by running an internal survey among the case company’s staff. The results showed that information use practices varied across the company and some units or teams had taken a more proactive approach to the information use than others.

Arinakattilalaitoksen polttoainekäytön tarkastelu

Tässä diplomityössä on tutustuttu Lahti Energia Oy:n Heinolan voimalaitoksen energiantuotantoon. Heinolan voimalaitos on vanha, mutta sen pääkattilana toimiva arinakattila on uusittu 2004. Voimalaitoksen toimintaa halutaan kehittää nykyaikaisemmaksi ja energiatehokkaammaksi. Voimalaitoksella on nykyään kolme asiakasta, joista uusin on liittynyt höyryverkkoon vuonna 2011. Työssä on tutkittu miten voimalaitoksen polttoaineiden käyttö muuttuu uuden asiakkaan myötä. Diplomityön teoriaosassa on keskitytty antamaan tietoa erilaisista polttoaineista sekä arinapolttamisesta polttotekniikkana. Työssä on laskettu voimalaitoksen asiakkaiden käyttämä energiavuositasolla, voimalaitoksen kattilahyötysuhde, prosessihyötysuhde ja niiden avulla laitoksen tarvitsema polttoaine-energia vuodessa. Laskelmat antavat hyvän yleisen kuvan voimalaitoksen käytöstä tällä hetkellä. Käyttöennusteen avulla voidaan arvioida myös laitoksen taloudellista tilaa polttoaineseoksen näkökulmasta.

Optimizing Customer Energy Invoice Calculation with Parallel Computation

Diplomityön tarkoituksena on optimoida asiakkaiden sähkölaskun laskeminen hajautetun laskennan avulla. Älykkäiden etäluettavien energiamittareiden tullessa jokaiseen kotitalouteen, energiayhtiöt velvoitetaan laskemaan asiakkaiden sähkölaskut tuntiperusteiseen mittaustietoon perustuen. Kasvava tiedonmäärä lisää myös tarvittavien laskutehtävien määrää. Työssä arvioidaan vaihtoehtoja hajautetun laskennan toteuttamiseksi ja luodaan tarkempi katsaus pilvilaskennan mahdollisuuksiin. Lisäksi ajettiin simulaatioita, joiden avulla arvioitiin rinnakkaislaskennan ja peräkkäislaskennan eroja. Sähkölaskujen oikeinlaskemisen tueksi kehitettiin mittauspuu-algoritmi.

Information integration and its impacts on logistics performance - Using information technology and systems to facilitate information integration

Fast changing environment sets pressure on firms to share large amount of information with their customers and suppliers. The terms information integration and information sharing are essential for facilitating a smooth flow of information throughout the supply chain, and the terms are used interchangeably in research literature. By integrating and sharing information, firms want to improve their logistics performance. Firms share information with their suppliers and customers by using traditional communication methods (telephone, fax, Email, written and face-to-face contacts) and by using advanced or modern communication methods such as electronic data interchange (EDI), enterprise resource planning (ERP), web-based procurement systems, electronic trading systems and web portals. Adopting new ways of using IT is one important resource for staying competitive on the rapidly changing market (Saeed et al. 2005, 387), and an information system that provides people the information they need for performing their work, will support company performance (Boddy et al. 2005, 26). The purpose of this research has been to test and understand the relationship between information integration with key suppliers and/or customers and a firm’s logistics performance, especially when information technology (IT) and information systems (IS) are used for integrating information. Quantitative and qualitative research methods have been used to perform the research. Special attention has been paid to the scope, level and direction of information integration (Van Donk & van der Vaart 2005a). In addition, the four elements of integration (Jahre & Fabbe-Costes 2008) are closely tied to the frame of reference. The elements are integration of flows, integration of processes and activities, integration of information technologies and systems and integration of actors. The study found that information integration has a low positive relationship to operational performance and a medium positive relationship to strategic performance. The potential performance improvements found in this study vary from efficiency, delivery and quality improvements (operational) to profit, profitability or customer satisfaction improvements (strategic). The results indicate that although information integration has an impact on a firm’s logistics performance, all performance improvements have not been achieved. This study also found that the use of IT and IS have a mediocre positive relationship to information integration. Almost all case companies agreed on that the use of IT and IS could facilitate information integration and improve their logistics performance. The case companies felt that an implementation of a web portal or a data bank would benefit them - enhance their performance and increase information integration.

Asiakasohjautuvan kokoonpanon vaikutus huonekalualan yrityksen kannattavuuteen

Työn tavoitteena oli selvittää, miten tuotantomuodon muutos varasto-ohjautuvasta ns. litteiden pakettien tuotannosta asiakasohjautuvaan kokoonpanoon, vaikuttaa tutkittavan tuoteryhmän kannattavuuteen. Tutkimuksen avulla pyrittiin saamaan vastaukset kysymyksiin: Kuinka paljon varastoon sitoutunut pääoma pienenee? Riittääkö nykyinen tuotantokapasiteetti uudessa mallissa? Miten tuotantoa ja varastoja ohjataan uudessa mallissa? Tutkimus koostuu teorian tarjoamien keinojen ja syiden soveltamisesta kohdeyrityksen tarpeisiin ja muutoksen laskennallisen kannattavuuden selvityksestä, jota mitataan absoluuttisen ja suhteellisen mittarien avulla. Lisäksi teorian avulla luodaan periaatteellinen malli uuden tuotantomuodon kapasiteetinhallinnalle sekä tuotannon- ja varastonohjaukselle. Saadut tulokset osoittavat, että tuotantomuodon muutos lisää yrityksen suhteellista kannattavuutta ja mahdollistaa absoluuttisen kannattavuuden lisäyksen, joka riippuu vapautuvien resurssien uudelleenohjauksesta. Lisäksi voidaan todeta, että tutkimuksessa laadullisina muuttujina pidetyt kuljetuskustannukset ja asiakastyytyväisyys, eivät ole lähtökohtainen este muutokselle.

The role of advance payments in working capital management and profitability

The objective of this thesis is to study the role of received advance payments in working capital management by creating a new measurement and to study the relationship between advance payments and profitability. The study has been conducted using narrative literature review and quantitative research methods. The research was made analyzing 108 companies listed in Helsinki Stock Exchange. The results indicate that 68 % of the studied companies are receiving advance payments and the average cycle time for received advance payments is 13 days. A new key figure is created to include received advance payments into the calculation of working capital. Received advance payments shorten the working capital cycle, by 13 days, when they are used in the calculation. The role of advance payments is not as significant as the role of receivables and inventories but advance payments may have a larger role than payables if the company is receiving noticeable amounts of advance payments. There are three branches where companies are receiving more advance payments than average companies. The branches are project business and ICT and publishing sectors. There is a negative correlation between profitability and advance payments based on the results of this study.

Developing customer need based services in personal security service industry

The purpose of this thesis is to examine how services can be developed and how the voice of the customer can be incorporated to the strategic planning of services. Furthermore, the objective is to investigate the methods of customer need analysis and service bundling. The data is collected from secondary and primary sources by reviewing the existing academic literature and by conducting in-depth interviews and surveys. The main findings of this research indicate that the service development in personal security service industry should be conducted through a formalized process and the process should begin with setting the strategic objectives. Moreover, the voice of the customer should be incorporated into all stages of the development process, especially into the front-end of the process. Furthermore, the information on customer needs should be gathered in a manner tailored for the purposes of service development.

The Impact of Service Quality and Relationship Quality on Customer Loyalty in Business-to-Business Context

The main objective of this Master’s Thesis was to examine the interrelations of service quality and relationship quality (customer satisfaction, trust and commitment), and find out are they antecedents for customer loyalty in business-to-business context. Literature review revealed some research gaps concerning these focal concepts, which should be studied more closely. The theoretical basis for this research was collected for evaluating a strategic increase of customer’s perceptions of service quality and relationship quality as well as customer loyalty in business-to-business environment, and it was tested empirically in a sample of 164 corporate customers, who responded to the Internet-based survey. The measures, used in the survey, were first assessed by using confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), and then the hypothesized relationships were further verified using structural equation modeling (SEM) in LISREL 8.80. There was found support for a half of the hypothesized construct relations. The results of the research confirm the direct influence of trust and commitment on customer loyalty. Also, service quality turned out to have an indirect impact on customer loyalty through trust. No support, however, was offered for the proposed impact of customer satisfaction on loyalty in this case. The research provides managerially relevant and actionable results that may help service providers execute more specific customer relationship quality strategies that lead to higher customer loyalty.

Arvoperusteinen hinnoittelu työvälineteollisuudessa - mahdollisuudet ja haasteet

Tutkimuksessa selvitetään miten työvälineiden valmistajat käyttävät arvo-perusteista hinnoittelua teknologiaosaamisen palvelutuotteissa ja mikä vaikuttaa siihen, että sitä käytetään tai ei käytetä. Kirjallisuuskatsauksessa perehdytään markkinoinnin ja laskentatoimen kirjallisuuteen palveluliiketoiminnan, asiakasarvon ja arvoperusteisen hinnoittelun osalta. Palveluliiketoimintaa avataan nimenomaan teollisuuden palveluliiketoiminnan näkökulmasta. Asiakasarvoa puolestaan käsitellään näkökulmina missä asiakasarvo muodostuu ja ketkä sitä luovat. Arvoperusteista hinnoittelua tarkastellaan lähtökohtana sen erityispiirteet asiakkaan ja myynnin suhteen sekä esitetään arvoperusteisen hinnoittelumallin käytön esteitä ja hyötyjä. Empiirisessä osiossa tutkitaan miten Työvälineiden valmistajien toimiala-ryhmän jäsenet käyttävät omissa palvelutuotteissaan arvoperusteista hin-noittelua. Aineisto kerättiin web-kyselyn avulla. Tutkimuksessa nousi esiin, että kyseistä hinnoittelumallia on alettu käyttää joissakin palveluissa. Koetut hyödyt ja esteet osoittautuvat olevan paljolti samat kuin aikaisemmassa tutkimuskirjallisuudessa on havaittu. Suurimpina hyötyinä nähtiin pysyvämmät asiakassuhteet, suurempi voittomarginaali ja positiivinen pakko perehtyä asiakkaan ansaintalogiikkaan. Suurimpina esteinä koettiin palvelusta syntyvän arvon määrittämisen vaikeus ja sen viestiminen asiakkaalle sekä asiakkaan haluttomuus sitoutua pitkiin sopimuksiin.

Open-book accounting - hyödyt ja haasteet erityyppisissä liiketoimintasuhteissa

Tutkimuksessa tarkastellaan OBA:n soveltamisen hyötyjä ja haasteita erityyppisissä yritysten välisissä suhteissa.Tutkimuksen tavoitteena on vastata kysymykseen, mitä erilaisia tavoitteita liiketoimintasuhteiden taustalla esiintyy, tyypitellä liiketoimintasuhteet tavoitteiden ja yritysten välisten toimintojen näkökulmasta ja arvioida miten OBA voi auttaa erityyppisien suhteiden johtamista tukevan informaation tuottamisessa ja hyödyntämisessä. Markkinaperustaisissa suhteissa vaihdannan avulla tavoitellaan tehokkuutta jonka perustana on markkinoilla vallitsevan kilpailun tehokkuus. Neuvotteluvoimaan perustuvissa suhteissa tavoitteena on hankkia resursseja sisäisiä tuotantokustannuksia edullisemmin markkinavoimaa hyväksikäyttämällä. Yhteistyösuhteissa toimittajan kyky tuottaa resurssi sisäisiin tuotantokustannuksiin nähden kilpailukykyisellä hinnalla perustuu vallitseviin mittakaavaetuihin tai erikoistumisen tuomaan osaamiseen ja niissä pyritään saavuttamaan kilpailuetua yritysten osaamista ja resursseja yhdistämällä. Yhteistyösuhteet voidaan jakaa operatiivisiin, taktisiin ja strategisiin yritysten välisten toimintojen integroituneisuuden ja strategisen merkityksen perusteella. Tutkimus antaa viitteitä siitä että OBA:n soveltamisen suurin potentiaali liittyy taktisiin ja strategisiin yhteistyösuhteisiin, koska niissä yritysten välisten toimintojen määrä on merkittävä ja yhteiset tavoitteet lisäävät yritysten välistä luottamusta.

Promoting Customer Loyalty Through a Telecommunication Specific CRM Framework

The objective of this thesis is to find new methods to promote customer loyalty in the telecommunication industry. The study was made on the appointment of Tecnotree Corporation, which operates in a telecommunication software business. This thesis comprises of a theoretical section, which includes the presentation of relevant theoretical background and of an empirical section, which is mostly based on interviews and professional opinions. One of the most important aspects of customer relationship management (CRM) is building customer loyalty. Telecommunication markets are becoming saturated in an increasing number of markets. Customer acquisition is no longer a way to grow; companies need to hold on to their existing customers. Companies are always looking for new ways to avoid churning customers. These new methods are searched from recent studies and they are discussed with marketing professionals from operators. Current CRM lacks the ability to extract data efficiently from databases. Social media’s utilization is also in its early stages. It contains a lot of possibilities, but also things that can be risky for companies. In order to obtain full advantage of the new methods companies are required to invest considerable amounts of time and money to develop new systems, but not all companies are ready for the change.

Sosiaali- ja terveydenhuollon teknisten palveluiden tuotteistaminen

Tämän tutkimuksen tarkoituksena oli tutkia Päijät-Hämeen sosiaali- ja terveydenhuollon kuntayhtymän Tukipalvelukeskuksen teknisten palveluiden tulosalueen tuotteistamista ja tuottaa kustannusten laskutuksen periaatteellinen toteutusmalli. Työssä otetaan kantaa palveluiden hinnoittelumalleihin eli kuinka kiinteistöistä ja teknisistä ylläpitopalveluista syntyvät kustannukset voidaan osoittaa niitä käyttäville tulosalueille. Palveluiden jäsentäminen ja suoritteiden yhdistäminen muodostavat palvelutuotteen, jota palveluita käyttävälle asiakkaalle tarjotaan. Tuotekäsitteelle on tyypillistä, että sitä voidaan tuottaa saman sisältöisenä nyt ja tulevaisuudessa. Tuotteita tarjoavan palveluiden tuottajan tuotekriteerit sisältävät selkeät tuoteryhmät, tuotteiden määrällisen mitattavuuden, kuvaavat tuotenimikkeet ja tuotteilla on ostajan näkökulmasta selkeä sisältö ja hinnoittelu. Tuotteistamisen tärkein hyöty on organisaation kustannusrakenteen selkeytyminen, jonka vuoksi tuotteiden määrä, laatu ja hinta tulee olla määriteltävissä. Asiakkaalle voidaan tarjota valmiiksi hinnoiteltuja palveluosia, jolloin palveluiden räätälöinti ja modulointi ovat mahdollisia palveluiden niputtamisella. Ei-kaupallisten instanssien, kuten kuntayhtymien sisäinen laskutus ja tuotteistus mahdollistavat palveluiden standardoimisen ja johdon päätöksenteko toimialakohtaisen kustannustietoisuuden vuoksi paranee. Tutkimuksen alkuosassa paneudutaan palvelun alle kuuluviin käsitteisiin, kuten tuotteistamisajatteluun, palvelupaketteihin, palveluiden laadun mittaamiseen ja palveluiden hinnoitteluun. Lisäksi tutkimuksessa käsitellään teknisten palveluiden hinnoitteluun käytettävän toimintoperusteisen kustannuslaskennan sekä sisäisen vuokraamisen periaatteita. Teoreettisessa viitekehyksessä käsiteltyjä asioita käytettiin hyödyksi sairaanhoitopiireille laadittuun kyselytutkimukseen. Yhdessä teorian ja kyselytutkimuksen kanssa kohdeorganisaatiolle luotiin malli palveluiden tuotteistamiseksi.

Theorizing Formal and Informal Feedback Practices in Management Accounting Through Three Dimensions

The purpose of this doctoral thesis is to widen and develop our theoretical frameworks for discussion and analyses of feedback practices in management accounting, particularly shedding light on its formal and informal aspects. The concept of feedback in management accounting has conventionally been analyzed within cybernetic control theory, in which feedback flows as a diagnostic or comparative loop between measurable outputs and pre-set goals (see e.g. Flamholtz et al. 1985; Flamholtz 1996, 1983), i.e. as a formal feedback loop. However, the everyday feedback practices in organizations are combinations of formal and informal elements. In addition to technique-driven feedback approaches (like budgets, measurement, and reward systems) we could also categorize social feedback practices that managers see relevant and effective in the pursuit of organizational control. While cybernetics or control theories successfully capture rational and measured aspects of organizational performance and offer a broad organizational context for the analysis, many individual and informal aspects remain vague and isolated. In order to discuss and make sense of the heterogeneous field of interpretations of formal and informal feedback, both in theory and practice, dichotomous approaches seem to be insufficient. Therefore, I suggest an analytical framework of formal and informal feedback with three dimensions (3D’s): source, time, and rule. Based on an abductive analysis of the theoretical and empirical findings from an interpretive case study around a business unit called Division Steelco, the 3Dframework and formal and informal feedback practices are further elaborated vis-á-vis the four thematic layers in the organizational control model by Flamholtz et al. (1985; Flamholtz 1996, 1983): core control system, organizational structure, organizational culture, and external environment. Various personal and cultural meanings given to the formal and informal feedback practices (“feedback as something”) create multidimensional interpretative contexts. Multidimensional frameworks aim to capture and better understand both the variety of interpretations and their implications to the functionality of feedback practices, important in interpretive research.

The Effects of Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction and Customer Perceived Value on Behavioral Intentions

The intent of this research was to develop a model that describes the extent to which customer behavioral intentions are influenced by service quality, customer satisfaction and customer perceived value in the business-to-business service context. Research on customer behavioral intentions is quite fragmented and no generalized model has been presented. Thus, there was need for empirical testing. This study builds on the services marketing theory and assesses the relationships between the identified constructs. The data for the empirical analysis was collected via a quantitative online survey and a total of 226 usable responses were obtained for further analysis. The model was tested in an employment agency service setting. The measures used in this survey were first assessed by using confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) after which the hypothesized relationships were further verified using structural equation modeling (SEM) in LISREL 8.80. The analysis identified that customer satisfaction played a pivotal role in the model as it was the only direct antecedent of customer behavioral intentions, however, customer perceived value showed a strong indirect impact on buying intentions via customer satisfaction. In contrast to what was hypothesized, service quality and customer perceived value did not have a direct positive effect on behavioral intentions. Also, a contradicting finding with current literature was that sacrifice was argued to have a direct but positive impact on customer perceived value. Based on the findings in this study, managers should carefully think of their service strategies that lead to their customers’ favorable behavioral intentions.

Towards Inter-organizational Working Capital Management

Working capital is an investment which is tied up into the inventories and accounts receivable and which is released with accounts payable. Due to the current business landscape with tightened financial conditions and finance markets, organizations emphasize efficient working capital management. With efficient working capital management, a company can reduce the need of finance, free up cash, increase profitability, improve liquidity, increase the efficiency of operations, and decrease (financing) costs. From the perspective of an individual company, efficient working capital management means decreasing inventory levels by shortening the cycle time of inventories, decreasing accounts receivable by shortening the trade credit terms and effective collection procedures, and increasing the level of accounts payable by paying the suppliers later. From an inter-organizational perspective, however, working capital should not be sub-optimized by a single company but holistic view to working capital management through the supply chain should be adopted to create value and improve performance together. The purpose of this research is to take academic research as well as practical management towards inter-organizational working capital management. The thesis discusses the benefits as well as mechanisms of working capital management in the inter-organizational context and has two main objectives: (1) to examine the effect of inter-organizational working capital management on performance in the value chain context and (2) to develop models of working capital management for internal as well as inter-organizational value chains. The results of the archival research conducted in the value chain of the pulp and paper industry and the value chain of the automotive industry indicate that companies can increase relative profitability by managing working capital comprehensively by taking into account all three components, and holistically though the value chain. Companies in the value chain benefit from different strategies in working capital management depending on the position of the company in the value chain. This can be taken into account in inter-organizational working capital management. The effects of inter-organizational working capital management actions on the financing costs of working capital were studied via simulations. Simulations also show that the value chain and individual companies benefit from an inter-organizational view to working capital management. Inter-organizational working capital management actions include for example: shortening the cycle time of inventories, reducing product costs, shifting inventories, shortening payment terms, and considering the cost of capital. The thesis also provides solutions for the practical requirements for tools to control working capital. The design science part of the research introduces the adjusted cash conversion cycle (ACCC) model for internal value chains, as well as models for working capital management in the inter-organizational value chain context: the working capital management model (WCMM) and the financial cycle time model (FCTM) designed in corporation and product levels respectively. This research contributes to literature on working capital management and interorganizational accounting. The research gives a holistic, inter-organizational view to the management of working capital. It advances the knowledge in working capital management on operational level, increases knowledge in the recently risen theme of supply chainoriented, collaborative working capital management, combines management accounting research with supply chain management research, and contributes to the demand of practical inter-organizational accounting methods. In addition, the research has strong practical focus as new managerial methods are introduced.