Essays on pricing of risk and international linkage of Russian stock market

Last two decades have seen a rapid change in the global economic and financial situation; the economic conditions in many small and large underdeveloped countries started to improve and they became recognized as emerging markets. This led to growth in the amounts of global investments in these countries, partly spurred by expectations of higher returns, favorable risk-return opportunities, and better diversification alternatives to global investors. This process, however, has not been without problems and it has emphasized the need for more information on these markets. In particular, the liberalization of financial markets around the world, globalization of trade and companies, recent formation of economic and regional blocks, and the rapid development of underdeveloped countries during the last two decades have brought a major challenge to the financial world and researchers alike. This doctoral dissertation studies one of the largest emerging markets, namely Russia. The motivation why the Russian equity market is worth investigating includes, among other factors, its sheer size, rapid and robust economic growth since the turn of the millennium, future prospect for international investors, and a number of important major financial reforms implemented since the early 1990s. Another interesting feature of the Russian economy, which gives motivation to study Russian market, is Russia’s 1998 financial crisis, considered as one of the worst crisis in recent times, affecting both developed and developing economies. Therefore, special attention has been paid to Russia’s 1998 financial crisis throughout this dissertation. This thesis covers the period from the birth of the modern Russian financial markets to the present day, Special attention is given to the international linkage and the 1998 financial crisis. This study first identifies the risks associated with Russian market and then deals with their pricing issues. Finally some insights about portfolio construction within Russian market are presented. The first research paper of this dissertation considers the linkage of the Russian equity market to the world equity market by examining the international transmission of the Russia’s 1998 financial crisis utilizing the GARCH-BEKK model proposed by Engle and Kroner. Empirical results shows evidence of direct linkage between the Russian equity market and the world market both in regards of returns and volatility. However, the weakness of the linkage suggests that the Russian equity market was only partially integrated into the world market, even though the contagion can be clearly seen during the time of the crisis period. The second and the third paper, co-authored with Mika Vaihekoski, investigate whether global, local and currency risks are priced in the Russian stock market from a US investors’ point of view. Furthermore, the dynamics of these sources of risk are studied, i.e., whether the prices of the global and local risk factors are constant or time-varying over time. We utilize the multivariate GARCH-M framework of De Santis and Gérard (1998). Similar to them we find price of global market risk to be time-varying. Currency risk also found to be priced and highly time varying in the Russian market. Moreover, our results suggest that the Russian market is partially segmented and local risk is also priced in the market. The model also implies that the biggest impact on the US market risk premium is coming from the world risk component whereas the Russian risk premium is on average caused mostly by the local and currency components. The purpose of the fourth paper is to look at the relationship between the stock and the bond market of Russia. The objective is to examine whether the correlations between two classes of assets are time varying by using multivariate conditional volatility models. The Constant Conditional Correlation model by Bollerslev (1990), the Dynamic Conditional Correlation model by Engle (2002), and an asymmetric version of the Dynamic Conditional Correlation model by Cappiello et al. (2006) are used in the analysis. The empirical results do not support the assumption of constant conditional correlation and there was clear evidence of time varying correlations between the Russian stocks and bond market and both asset markets exhibit positive asymmetries. The implications of the results in this dissertation are useful for both companies and international investors who are interested in investing in Russia. Our results give useful insights to those involved in minimising or managing financial risk exposures, such as, portfolio managers, international investors, risk analysts and financial researchers. When portfolio managers aim to optimize the risk-return relationship, the results indicate that at least in the case of Russia, one should account for the local market as well as currency risk when calculating the key inputs for the optimization. In addition, the pricing of exchange rate risk implies that exchange rate exposure is partly non-diversifiable and investors are compensated for bearing the risk. Likewise, international transmission of stock market volatility can profoundly influence corporate capital budgeting decisions, investors’ investment decisions, and other business cycle variables. Finally, the weak integration of the Russian market and low correlations between Russian stock and bond market offers good opportunities to the international investors to diversify their portfolios.

Value at Risk in Foreign Exchange Risk Management

This thesis examines the suitability of VaR in foreign exchange rate risk management from the perspective of a European investor. The suitability of four different VaR models is evaluated in respect to have insight if VaR is a valuable tool in managing foreign exchange rate risk. The models evaluated are historical method, historical bootstrap method, variance-covariance method and Monte Carlo simulation. The data evaluated are divided into emerging and developed market currencies to have more intriguing analysis. The foreign exchange rate data in this thesis is from 31st January 2000 to 30th April 2014. The results show that the previously mentioned VaR models performance in foreign exchange risk management is not to be considered as a single tool in foreign exchange rate risk management. The variance-covariance method and Monte Carlo simulation performs poorest in both currency portfolios. Both historical methods performed better but should also be considered as an additional tool along with other more sophisticated analysis tools. A comparative study of VaR estimates and forward prices is also included in the thesis. The study reveals that regardless of the expensive hedging cost of emerging market currencies the risk captured by VaR is more expensive and thus FX forward hedging is recommended

Reagointitavat markkinariskin vähentämiseksi pk-yrityksissä

Tutkielman tavoitteena oli etsiä PK-yrittäjien reagointitapoja markkinariskiin va¬rautumiseen. Tutkielman teoriaosa jakautui kahteen osaan, jossa ensimmäisessä osassa haettiin markkinariskeille alttiita yrityksen kasvukohtia. Teorian toisessa osassa etsittiin teoriasta reagointitapoja suhteessa markkinariskeihin. Tutkimusmenetelmäksi valittiin teemahaastattelu. Tutkimusaineisto koostui Ky¬menlaakson alueen eri toimialan PK-yrittäjän haastattelusta. Haastattelun teemoina olivat korko-, valuutta- ja hyödykehintariski. Edellä mainittuja teemoja käsi¬teltiin yrityksen oston, varastoinnin ja myynnin näkökulmista. Kahdeksan yrittäjän haastattelujen lisäksi haastateltiin kolmea pankissa toimivaa asiakasvastuullista johtajaa tai neuvojaa. Asiakasvastuullisten haastattelujen tarkoituksena oli saada tutkimuksen analysointiin myös rahoittajan näkökulma. Kerätty haastatteluaineisto analysoitiin kvalitatiivisin menetelmin. Tutkielmassa havaittiin PK-yrittäjien käyttävän hyödykseen teoriamalleja eniten korkoriskin hallintaan. Valuutta- ja hyödykehintariskeihin ei tutkielman mukaan esitellyt teoriat soveltuneet vaan niihin yrittäjät pyrkivät varautumaan käytännössä muilla keinoilla.

Tests of International Asset Pricing Models in Scandinavian Stock Markets

This thesis examines whether global, local and exchange risks are priced in Scandinavian countries’ equity markets by using conditional international asset pricing models. The employed international asset pricing models are the world capital asset pricing model, the international asset pricing model augmented with the currency risk, and the partially segmented model augmented with the currency risk. Moreover, this research traces estimated equity risk premiums for the Scandinavian countries. The empirical part of the study is performed using generalized method of moments approach. Monthly observations from February 1994 to June 2007 are used. Investors’ conditional expectations are modeled using several instrumental variables. In order to keep system parsimonious the prices of risk are assumed to be constant whereas expected returns and conditional covariances vary over time. The empirical findings of this thesis suggest that the prices of global and local market risk are priced in the Scandinavian countries. This indicates that the Scandinavian countries are mildly segmented from the global markets. Furthermore, the results show that the exchange risk is priced in the Danish and Swedish stock markets when the partially segmented model is augmented with the currency risk factor.

Valuuttasuojaus kansainvälisissä osakeportfolioissa - eurosijoittajan näkökulma

Tämän tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on selvittää eurosijoittajan näkökulmasta tehokkain strategia kansainvälisen osakeportfolion valuuttariskin suojaamiseen. Tutkimuksessa tarkastellaan akateemisissa tutkimuksissa eniten käsiteltyjä valuuttasuojausstrategioita ja pyritään tunnistamaan niistä tieteellisesti valideimmat metodit tutkimuksen empiiriseen osioon. Valuuttasuojauksen tehokkuutta tullaan mittaamaan niin riskin kuin tuoton näkökulmista. Empiirisessä osiossa käytetään aineistona kahdeksan eri valtion osakemarkkinaindeksien ja valuuttojen spot- ja termiinikurssien kuukausittaisia tuottoja niin, että tarkastelu tapahtuu euroalueen sijoittajan näkökulmasta. Tutkimuksen aikaväli on 31.12.2004 - 31.12.2010. Tutkimuksessa päädyttiin suosittamaan 50 % valuuttariskin suojausastetta eurosijoittajan näkökulmasta. Kyseinen strategia alensi parhaiten kansainvälisen sijoittajan portfolion riskiä tutkitulla aikavälillä, eikä strategia myöskään heikentänyt merkittävästi portfolion tuottoa. Absoluuttisella kumulatiivisella tuotolla mitattuna suojaamaton osakeportfolio oli tutkimuksen aikavälillä paras, johtuen pääosin vuoden 2010 eurokriisistä, jonka vuoksi euro heikentyi voimakkaasti muita valuuttoja vastaan. Ennen kriisiä ”selektiivinen” valuuttasuojausstrategia oli tuotoilla (sekä kumulatiivinen että riskikorjattu) mitattuna paras.

Interdependence of Emerging Eastern European stock markets

One of the main developments in the global economy during the past decades has been the growth of emerging economies. Projections for their long-term growth, changes in the investment climate, corporate transparency and demography point to an increasing role for these emerging economies in the global economy. Today, emerging economies are usually considered as financial markets offering opportunities for high returns, good risk diversification and improved return-to-risk ratios. However, researchers have noted that these advantages may be in decline because of the increasing market integration. Nevertheless, it is likely that certain financial markets and specific sectors will remain partially segmented and somewhat insulated from the global economy for the year to come. This doctoral dissertation investigates several stock markets in Emerging Eastern Europe (EEE), including the ones in Russia, Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic, Bulgaria and Slovenia. The objective is to analyze the returns and financial risks in these emerging markets from international investor’s point of view. This study also examines the segmentation/integration of these financial markets and the possibilities to diversify and hedge financial risk. The dissertation is divided into two parts. The first includes a review of the theoretical background for the articles and a review of the literature on EEE stock markets. It includes an overview of the methodology and research design applied in the analysis and a summary of articles from the second part of this dissertation and their main findings. The second part consists of four research publications. This work contributes to studies on emerging stock markets in four ways. First, it adds to the body of research on the pricing of risk, providing new empirical evidence about partial stock market segmentation in EEE. The results suggest that the aggregate emerging market risk is a relevant driver for stock market returns and that this market risk can be used to price financial instruments and forecast their performance. Second, it contributes to the empirical research on the integration of stock markets, asset prices and exchange rates by identifying the relationships between these markets through volatility and asset pricing. The results show that certain sectors of stock markets in EEE are not as integrated as others. For example, the Polish consumer goods sector, the Hungarian telecommunications sector, and the Czech financial sector are somewhat isolated from their counterparts elsewhere in Europe. Nevertheless, an analysis of the impact of EU accession in 2004 on stock markets suggests that most of the EEE markets are becoming increasingly integrated with the global markets. Third, this thesis complements the scientific literature in the field of shock and volatility spillovers by examining the mechanism of spillover distribution among the EU and EEE countries. The results illustrate that spillovers in emerging markets are mostly from a foreign exchange to the stock markets. Moreover, the results show that the effects of external shocks on stock markets have increased after the enlargement of the EU in 2004. Finally, this study is unique because it analyzes the effects of foreign macroeconomic news on geographically closely related countries. The results suggest that the effects of macroeconomic announcements on volatility are significant and have effect that varies across markets and their sectors. Moreover, the results show that the foreign macroeconomic news releases, somewhat surprisingly, have a greater effect on the EEE markets than the local macroeconomic news. This dissertation has a number of implications for the industry and for practitioners. It analyses financial risk associated with investing in Emerging Eastern Europe. Investors may use this information to construct and optimize investment portfolios. Moreover, this dissertation provides insights for investors and portfolio managers considering asset allocation to protect value or obtain higher returns. The results have also implications for asset pricing and portfolio selection in light of macroeconomic news releases.

OMXH 25-yhtiöiden valuuttariski ja siltä suojautuminen

Tämän kandidaatintutkielman tavoitteena on selvittää OMXH 25-yhtiöiden altistumista valuuttariskille ja kuinka nämä yhtiöt suojautuvat siltä. Tässä tutkimuksessa on lisäksi selvitetty näiden yhtiöiden tärkeimmät ulkomaanvaluutat ja yhtiöiden suojausstrategioita. Valuuttariskin suuruuden selvittämiseksi yhtiöiden vieraan valuuttaista liikevaihtoa verrattiin yhtiön kokonaisliikevaihtoon. Tutkimuksen aineistona on käytetty yhtiöiden vuosien 2013 ja 2014 tilinpäätöksiä. Aineistosta on lisäksi rajattu pois OMXH 25-yhtiöiden joukosta Nordea, Sampo, Elisa ja Telia Sonera. Nämä yhtiöt rajattiin pois, koska ne soveltuivat huonosti tämän tutkimuksen kohteiksi. Tutkimuksen teoriakehys on rakennettu keskeisten teorioiden ja käsitteiden avulla. Valuuttariski voidaan jakaa kolmeen osaan: transaktioriskiin, ekonomiseen riskiin ja translaatioriskiin. Valuuttariskin suojauksessa käytettävät instrumentit ovat termiinit, optiot, swap-sopimukset ja vieraan valuuttainen velka. Myös suojaamatta jättämisen mahdollisuutta on tutkittu. Tutkimuksessa kävi ilmi yhtiöiden merkittävä altistuminen valuuttariskille liikevaihdolla mitattuna. Yhtiöiden liikevaihdosta lähes 50% tapahtui jossain muussa valuutassa kuin euroissa. Yhtiöt käyttävät valuuttariskiltä suojautumiseen pääasiassa termiinejä, mutta myös muita instrumentteja käytetään jonkin verran. Yhtiöt keskittyvät eniten transaktioriskin suojaamiseen ekonomisen riskin ja tranlaatioriskin jäädessä pienemmälle huomiolle. Myös aikaisemmissa tutkimuksissa on saatu samankaltaisia tuloksia. Viime vuosien voimakkaat valuuttakurssimuutokset ovat vaikuttaneet yhtiöiden tuloksiin negatiivisesti ja erityisesti ruplan arvon voimakas heikentyminen suhteessa euroon aiheutti joillekkin yhtiöille merkittäviä valuuttakurssitappioita. Tärkein vieras valuutta tutkituille yhtiöille oli USA:n dollari. Korkeasta suojausasteesta huolimatta suurinosa tutkituista yhtiöistä kärsi valuuttakurssitappiota kumpanakin tarkasteltuna vuonna.

The Effectiveness of Currency Hedging Strategies. Case: Imatra Boards Business Unit of Stora Enso Corp.

Tutkimus tarkastelee vaihtoehtoisia termiinisuojaustrategioita metsäteollisuuden alan tulosyksikössä. Jälkitestauksen tarkoituksena on arvioida vaihtoehtoisten strategioiden tuloksellisuutta suojata case-yrityksen kassavirtoja seuraavan kolmen arviointikriteerin avulla: yksittäisten vieraan valuutan määräisten kassavirtojen vaihtelu; koko vieraan valuutan määräisen kassavirran vaihtelu; suojausvoitot ja -tappiot. Tutkimuksen teoreettinen viitekehys tarkastelee yrityksen päätöksentekoa, valuuttariskien suojausprosessia sekä esittelee yrityksen vaihtoehtoisia suojausstrategioita. Tutkimuksen empiirinen aineisto pohjautuu case- yrityksen historiallisiin myyntilukuihin ja on kerätty yrityksen tietojärjestelmästä. Muu tutkimuksessa käytetty dataon kerätty eri tietokannoista. Tutkimuksen tulokset osoittavat, että suojaaminen vähentää kassavirtojen vaihtelua. Suojaamisen taloudelliset tulokset ovat kuitenkin erittäin riippuvaisia valitusta suojausstrategiasta, joka voi johtaa merkittäviin suojausvoittoihin, mutta yhtä hyvin myos merkittäviin tappioihin. Johdon näkemykset ja riskitoleranssi määrittelevät mitä strategiaa yrityksessä tullaan viime kädessä noudattamaan.

Exchange rate volatility and the use of foreign currency derivatives: Impact of 2008 global financial crisis

This thesis examines the impact of foreign exchange rate volatility to the extent of use of foreign currency derivatives. Especially the focus is on the impacts of 2008 global financial crisis. The crisis increased risk level in the capital markets greatly. The change in the currency derivatives use is analyzed by comparing means between different periods and in addition, by linear regression that enables to analyze the explanatory power of the model. The research data consists of financial statements figures from fiscal years 2006-2011 published by firms operating in traditional Finnish industrial sectors. Volatilities of the chosen three currency pairs is calculated from the daily fixing rates of ECB. Based on the volatility the sample period is divided into three sub-periods. The results suggest that increased FX market volatility did not increase the use foreign currency derivatives. Furthermore, the increased foreign exchange rate volatility did not increase the power of linear regression model to estimate the use foreign currency derivatives compared to previous studies.

Currency Carry Trades – Excess Returns and Performance Optimization of G10 Currency Carry Trade Strategies during the Euro Era

This study examines the excess returns provided by G10 currency carry trading during the Euro era. The currency carry trade has been a popular trade throughout the past decades offering excess returns to investors. The thesis aims to contribute to existing research on the topic by utilizing a new set of data for the Euro era as well as using the Euro as a basis for the study. The focus of the thesis is specifically on different carry trade strategies’ performance, risk and diversification benefits. The study finds proof of the failure of the uncovered interest rate parity theory through multiple regression analyses. Furthermore, the research finds evidence of significant diversification benefits in terms of Sharpe ratio and improved return distributions. The results suggest that currency carry trades have offered excess returns during 1999-2014 and that volatility plays an important role in carry trade returns. The risk, however, is diversifiable and therefore our results support previous quantitative research findings on the topic.

POLITICAL RISK IN FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT IN THE RUSSIAN ELECTRIC POWER SECTOR

Russia approved ambitious reform plan for the electricity sector in 2001 including privatisation of the country’s huge thermal generation assets. So far the sector had suffered from power shortages, aging infrastructure, substantial electricity losses, and weak productivity and profitability numbers. There was obvious need for foreign investments and technologies. The reform was rather successful; the generation assets were privatised in auctions in 2007-2008 and three European energy companies, E.On, Enel and Fortum, invested in and obtained together over 10% of the Russian production assets. The novelty of these foreign investments serves unique object for the study. The political risk is involved in the FDI due to the industry’s social and economic importance. The research’s objective was to identify and analyse the political risk that foreign investors face in the Russian electricity sector. The research had qualitative study method and the empirical data was collected by interviewing. The research’s theoretical framework was based on the existing political risk theories and it focused to understand the Russian government in relation to the country’s stability and define both macro-level and micro-level sources of political risk for the foreign direct investments in the sector. The research concludes that the centralised and obscure political decision-making, economic constriction, high level of governmental control in economy and corruption form the country’s internal macro-level risk sources for the foreign investors in the sector. Additionally the retribution due to the companies’ home country actions, possible violent confrontations at the Russian borders and the currency instability are externally originated risk sources. In the electricity industry there is risk of tightened governmental control and increased regulation and taxation. Similarly the company-level risk sources link to the unreformed heating sector, bargaining with the authorities, diplomatic stress between host and home countries and to companies and government’s divergent perspective for the profit-making. The research stresses the foreign companies’ ability to cope with the characteristics of Russian political environment. In addition to frequent political and market risk assessment, the companies need to focus on currency protection against rouble’s rate fluctuation and actively build good company-citizenship in the country. Good relationship is needed with the Russian political authorities. The political risk identification and the research’s conclusive framework also enable political risk study assessments for other industries in Russia