Convergence in Industry Evolution

The objective of the thesis is to enhance understanding of the evolution of convergence. Previous research has shown that the technological interfaces between distinct industries are one of the major sources of new radical cross-industry innovations. Despite the fact that convergence in industry evolution has attracted a substantial managerial interest, the conceptual confusion within the field of convergence exists. Firstly, this study clarifies the convergence phenomenon and its impact to industry evolution. Secondly, the study creates novel patent analysis methods to analyze technological convergence and provide tools for anticipating the early stages of convergence. Overall the study combines the industry evolution perspective and the convergence view of industrial evolution. The theoretical background for the study consists of the industry life cycle theories, technology evolution, and technological trajectories. The study links several important concepts in analyzing industry evolution, technological discontinuities, path-dependency, technological interfaces as a source of industry transformation, and the evolutionary stagesof convergence. Based on reviewing the literature a generic understanding of industry transformation and industrial dynamics was generated. In the convergence studies, the theoretical basis is in the discussion of different convergence types and their impacts on industry evolution, and in anticipating and monitoring the stages of convergence. The study is divided in two parts. The first part gives a general overview, and the second part comprises eight research publications. Our case study is based historically on two very distinct industries of the paper and electronics companies as a test environment to evaluate the importance of emerging business sectors and technological convergence as a source of industry transformation. Both qualitative and quantitative research methodology are utilized. The results of this study reveal that technological convergence and complementary innovations from different fields have significant effect to the emerging new business sector formation. The patent-based indicators in the analysis of technological convergence can be utilized on analyzing technology competition, capability and competence development, knowledge accumulation, knowledge spill-overs, and technology-based industry transformation. The patent-based indicators can provide insights to the future competitive environment. Results and conclusions from empirical part seem not be in conflict with real observations in the industry.

Hihnakuljetinjärjestelmien modulointi

Tämä diplomityö tutkii moduloinnilla saavutettavaa hyötyä kuljetinliiketoiminnassa. Johdanto-osassa kerrotaan yrityksen taustasta ja projektiliiketoiminnan kehitysnäkymistä, hihnakuljetinjärjestelmien historiasta ja nykyisestä kilpailutilanteesta. Lisäksi siinä on mainittu työn tavoitteet, sekä tutkimuksen rajaus. Hihnakuljetinjärjestelmien modulointia käsittelevässä osassa selvitetään moduloinnin historiaa ja on kerrottu siihen liittyviä käsitteitä ja menettelytapoja. Tutkimusosan alussa on esitetty tutkimuskysymykset. Tutkimusmenetelmänä on tapaustutkimus ja siinä on verrattu kahta CASE- tapausta keskenään haastattelujen avulla, sekä pyydetty osallistuneilta jatkotoimenpide-ehdotuksia, koskien modulointia. Toiminnallisen viitekehyksen osassa kuvataan ne tavat, joilla modulointi yrityksessä toteutetaan asiakasvaatimukset ja palveluhallinta huomioiden. Lisäksi siinä kuvataan osaamisen kehittämisen menettely. Tutkimustuloksien tarkastelun yhteydessä on kerrottu CASE- tapauksien perustiedot ja tiedon keräämisen tapa. Tutkimustuloksien analysointi on suoritettu siten, että tuloksista on nostettu esille moduloinnin kannalta oleelliset vastaukset ja ne on analysoitu. Tämän jälkeen suoritettiin pohdinta ja johtopäätökset niistä analysoiduista vastauksista, jotka ovat tärkeitä moduloinnin ja yrityksen kehityksen kannalta. Jatkotoimenpiteet on jaettu kolmeen pääryhmään, joista ensimmäisenä on toiminnan kehittäminen moduloimalla. Toisessa on tarkasteltu sisäisen toiminnan kannalta tärkeitä kohteita ja ehdotettu toimenpiteitä toiminnan tehostamiseksi. Kolmantena ryhmänä ovat tutkimusaiheet, joiden avulla pyritään selvittämään puutteet tai epäkohdat nykyisessä toiminnassa. Yhteenvedossa on tarkasteltu yrityksen strategisten tavoitteiden toteutumista suhteessa hypoteesiin. Siinä on myös esitetty tulevaisuuden haasteita ympäristönsuojelun asettamat vaatimukset huomioiden.

Business Intelligencen hyödyntäminen autoalan liiketoiminnassa

Tämän pro gradu -tutkielman tavoitteena on selvittää, miten Business Intelligencea voidaan hyödyntää autoalan liiketoiminnassa Suomessa. Työssä tutkitaan erityisesti autoalan tietotarpeita, tietolähteitä, tiedon analysointia sekä tiedon hyödynnettävyyttä liiketoiminnan ohjaamisessa ja päätöksenteossa. Työn tutkimusstrategiana käytettiin tapaustutkimusta, jonka kohderyhmänä oli viisi suomalaista autoalan suuryritystä. Tutkimuksen empiirinen aineisto hankittiin haastattelemalla yritysten Business Intelligence -toiminnoista vastaavia henkilöitä. Tutkimuksen tulosten perusteella Business Intelligence merkitsi yrityksille ensisijaisesti toiminnanohjausta ja sen seurantaa, sekä korkealaatuisen tiedon tuottamista päätöksentekoa varten. Keskeisiksi tietotarpeiksi luokiteltiin asiakkaisiin, ajoneuvoihin, sisäisiin prosesseihin, liiketoimintatapahtumiin, kilpailijoihin, toimialaan ja asiakastyytyväisyyteen liittyvät tiedot. Tutkimuksen tulosten perusteella tiedon hankinnassa tulee huomioida sekä sisäisen liiketoimintatiedon analyyttinen hyödyntäminen että systemaattinen tiedon hankinta myös ulkoisista lähteistä. Yritykset kokivat Business Intelligence -toimintojen parantaneen tiedon laatua, tehostaneen toiminnanohjausta sekä mahdollistaneen yhteneväisen liiketoiminnan johtamisen organisaation eri tasoilla.

Innovaatioprosessi Balanced Scorecard johtamisjärjestelmässä - Tärkeimmät tekijät prosessin onnistumiseksi

Työn tarkoituksena on tutkia, mitkä ovat tärkeimpiä tekijöitä, joita Balanced Scorecard johtamisjärjestelmää käyttävän organisaatioiden tulee huomioida innovaatioprosessinsa suunnittelussa ja toteutuksessa. Lisäksi työssä tutkitaan, millaisia kytkentöjä innovaatioprosessilla on BSC-johtamisjärjestelmän muihin osa-alueisiin sekä onko BSC ylipäätään sopiva johtamisjärjestelmä innovatiivisuutta tavoittelevalla organisaatiolle. Tutkimusstrategiana on kvalitatiivinen tutkimus ja tutkimusmetodina puolestaan puolistrukturoimaton haastattelu. Työn tärkein tutkimustulos on, että BSC-johtamisjärjestelmää käyttävän organisaation innovaatioprosessin onnistuminen ratkaistaan pitkälti aivan muualla kuin prosessin sisällä itsessään. Organisaation tulee ensinnäkin keskittyä edistämään innovaatioille suotuisaa kulttuuria, tässä organisaation arvot ovat yksi tärkein työväline. Toiseksi, organisaation tulee systemaattisesti kehittää yhteistyötä eri funktioiden ja niissä työskentelevien ihmisten välillä. Kolmanneksi, organisaation tulee mitata systemaattisesti niitä asioita, jotka indikoivat innovaatioiden edellytyksistä ja itse innovaatioprosessin toimivuudesta. Kaikki kolme mainittua tulosta liitetään työssä kirjoittajan toimesta yläkäsitteen johtaminen alle. Työssä tuodaan myös esille se, että organisaatioiden on syytä tarkastella edellä mainittuja kolmea teemaa kahdessa aikaulottuvuudessa – ajassa ennen innovaatioita ja varsinaisen innovaation jälkeen. Siten kunkin kolmen teeman olennaisin sisältö riippuukin aikaperspektiivistä. Yhtenä olennaisena johtopäätöksenä työn tekijä esittää, että BSC-johtamisjärjestelmää käyttävän organisaation ei tulisi investoida merkittävästi varsinaiseen innovaatioprosessiinsa ennen kuin se on kyennyt luomaan innovatiivisuutta tukevaa kulttuuria oppimisen ja kasvun näkökulmassa. Ilman innovaatioita tukevaa kulttuuria prosessissa itsessään tuskin on laadukasta sisältöä. Tämä johtopäätös on selkeä viesti organisaatioille toiminnan priorisoinnin kannalta.

Measuring effects of strategic utilization of social media in business-to-business marketing: Case Greenlux Finland Oy

Utilization of social media is increasingly common in B2B marketing. Social media is an efficient and cheap marketing and communication channel available for everyone, and thus extremely attractive marketing medium. The more companies get involved in social media the more failures are reported. It is not enough for a company to just be present in social media. Succeeding on it requires hard work, investing time and money, and ability to measure and to monitor performance. With an increasing number of companies failing in utilizing social media, together with lack of research on strategic utilization of social media focusing on B2B marketing, measuring, and monitoring create a purpose for this research. The aim of this research is to discover methods for measuring and monitoring effects of strategic utilization of social media in B2B marketing. Most relevant financial and non-financial indicators are discussed, and the methods by which these can be monitored and measured. In addition, effects of strategic utilization of social media on the case company are measured and analyzed. The research methodology used in this research is a participatory action research, which includes elements of both qualitative and quantitative research methods. The case company examined in the research provides a unique opportunity to follow through all phases of strategic utilization of social media for B2B marketing purposes concluding real effects of social media to the case company, and thus gain a deep understanding about this new marketing medium in the perspective of B2B marketing. Duration of the research period is seven months. During this time, information is collected, measured, and analyzed. Case company does not have any other marketing activities simultaneously which makes it possible to examine social media apart from effects of other visible marketing activities. Effects of strategic utilization of social media can be monitored and measured in many ways. Methods that should be used depend on goals set for social media. Fundamental nature of social media requires multidimensional assessment, and thus effects should be measured, and monitored considering both financial and non-financial indicators. The results implicates that effects of strategic utilization of social media are relatively wide ranged. According to the findings, social media affects positively on brand, number of web page visitors, visitor behavior, and on distribution of awareness. According to investment calculations social media is a legitimate investment for case company. Results also implicate that by using social media case company gains conversation, arouses interest, gets attention, and creates interactivity. In addition and as a side note, winter holiday season appears to have a great effect on social media activity of B2B companies’ representatives.

Julkiset palveluhankinnat - Hankintayksikön velvollisuudet tarjoajia kohtaan hankintapäätöksen tekemisen jälkeen

Hankintalainsäädäntö säätelee julkisia hankintoja pääasiassa kilpailutusprosessin ajan. Hankintasopimuksen tekemisen jälkeen julkisia hankintoja säätelevät tietyt hankintalain oikeussuojakeinot, julkisten hankintojen periaatteet, muu pakottava lainsäädäntö sekä yleinen sopimusoikeus. Tutkimuksen tavoitteena on selvittää niitä velvollisuuksia, joita hankintayksiköllä on tarjoajia kohtaan hankintapäätöksen syntymisen jälkeen. Tutkimuksessa käsitellään myös velvollisuuksien toteutumatta jäämisestä syntyviä tehosteita eli sanktioita. Tutkimusmenetelmänä käytetään lainoppia. Aihetta havainnollistetaan oikeustapauksilla markkinaoikeudesta, yleisistä oikeuksista sekä Euroopan yhteisön tuomioistuimesta.

DEVELOPING SOCIAL CAPITAL WITHIN COMPANIES THROUGH ENTERPRISE 2.0

Whereas external social media has been studied, hyped and integrated into companies´ strategies, an insignificant concentration has been put on internal social solutions, which companies provide increasingly to their personnel. An enterprise focusing solely on the benefits of external social media might end up underestimating the true potential embedded in social business. The purpose of this thesis was to examine how social collaboration can be depicted as a structuration process in an Enterprise 2.0 environment. Furthermore, this thesis sought to reveal the benefits, challenges and possibilities of social business. This thesis focused on researching Enterprise 2.0 at the workplace. The studied Enterprise 2.0 solution was IBM Connections. The qualitative research methodology was an extensive case study. Three companies took part into this thesis and all in all 12 employees were interviewed. Additionally, seven IBM Social Business Experts were interviewed in order to receive a better understanding of the phenomenon. Three research questions were designed to fulfill the purpose of this thesis. The research questions were: 1. How are the dimensions of social capital structured through collaboration? 2. How does agency form in Enterprise 2.0? 3. How does social collaboration emerge as a result of the interplay between agency and dimensions of social capital in an Enterprise 2.0 environment and creates outcomes such as trust, identification and knowledge? The main research findings indicate that social collaboration increases trust, identification and knowledge by giving employees more capabilities to do their work. Consequently, social collaboration increases company performance by making individuals and groups more effective. The support of top management is crucial in making Enterprise 2.0 successful, because it is more a cultural than a technological change. Power agency, the lack of top management support and old established work ways such as email and databases work as barriers to social collaboration.

Improving Product Information Management in Global Project Based Manufacturing

The transition of project based manufacturing business, even more into global networks, sets up challenges for companies to manage their business in this new operating environment. One way to tackle these challenges is the successful management of product information through an extended product’s lifecycle. Thus, one objective of this research is to find ways how product information management in global project based manufacturing can be improved. Another objective is to find a solution how the target company can improve its product information management in the offer-to-procurement business process. Due to the nature of the topic, the study follows constructive research methodology with qualitative methods. By combining literature related to this topic a framework is created to improve product information management in global project based manufacturing. The improvement process in this framework is based on a systematic approach from the current state towards target state. A general aim for improvements should be the integrated product and project lifecycle information management through Lean approach. This introduced framework is applied to the target company through two case projects. Data for building view of current state and analysis is collected mostly by theme interviews and also utilizing other material from the target company. Used tools help to analyzing was the BPMN and the Trace matrix for business chains. Results of the improvement process are collected in a solution proposal which contain the strategic target state as well as long and short term objectives. The strategic target state is defined as controlled customization. Also during the improvement process are created the Information requirements chart in the offer-to-procurement business process, and the Project related initial information questionnaire to customer.

Aineettoman pääoman ilmeneminen verkostolentoyhtiössä strategianäkökulmasta

Tämän tutkimustyön tavoitteena on tutkia strategianäkökulmaan perustuvan aineettoman pääoman ilmenemistä ja arvonluontia verkostolentoyhtiö Finnairissa. Aineeton pääoma koostuu kolmesta pääomaluokasta: inhimillisestä pääomasta, suhdepääomasta ja rakennepääomasta. Aineettomalle pääomalle on luonteenomaista, että sitä on vaikea kopioida, korvata, muuntaa, jakaa, siirtää ja erityisesti – tunnistaa. Yritykset luovat arvoa vasta, kun ne hyödyntävät aineettomia resurssejaan tehokkaasti. Tutkimusmetodiksi valittiin ladullinen sisällönanalyysi. Tutkimusaineistona ovat Finnairin viralliset yritysjulkaisut. Tutkimuksessa ilmeni, että Finnairin yritysstrategiasta löytyi varsin paljon staattisia aineettomia resursseja, mutta johtohenkilöiden teksteistä analysoituna osumien määrä oli huomattavasti pienempi. Tutkittaessa arvonluontia yrityksen strategiasta löytyi vain vähän dynaamisia aineettomia resursseja, ja johtohenkilöiden teksteistä analysoituna osumia ei saatu lainkaan. Aineiston avulla oli kuitenkin mahdollista vastata molempiin tutkimuskysymyksiin. Empiriassa lähteenä käytetyt yritysviestinnän julkaisut antoivat dokumentteina suppeahkon tutkimuspohjan, joiden täydentäminen haastatteluin tai kyselyin antaisi laajemman ja vakaamman näkemyksen tutkittavasta aiheesta.

ERP implementation in SMEs : Consultant – Client Views On Critical Success Factors

ERP system is now attracting the SMEs, as it is now economical and affordable for them. The current research emphasizes on “how to make ERP successful for SMEs”. The researchers have identified various critical success factors in implementation of ERP. The research gap noticed by author is the missing point of view of ERP consultant. This thesis investigates the answer of research question “What are the critical success factors in implementation of ERP system in SMEs in opinion of ERP consultants and acquiring organizations”. The purpose of this study is to identify the highly important and less important factors. The study results will suggest the ERP managers where they have to concentrate more in order to achieve success. Literature is reviewed in order to setup a base for empirical study. Aplenty of work is found related to CSFs, SMEs and ERP. The authors and factors are organized in form of a table that tells which author is agreed upon which factor. Final result of literature review is a list of 14 CSFs. The qualitative research methodology is used to investigate the ERP in Pakistani SMEs. A case study approach is selected because of unified nature of SMEs in Pakistan. A rice mill is selected as a case because it contains maximum SME attributes. The opinion of a Microsoft certified consultant is obtained by a semi-structured interview. Similarly a semi-structured interview is conducted with CIO of SME that acquired ERP. Both the interviewees are asked about all 14 factors, whether they are agree or not and why. The collected evidences then analyzed by tabulation. The factors upon which both the participants found agreed, taken as highly important. Similarly the factors upon which both participants found disagree, taken as less important. Study results present a grid with four quadrants, the CSFs highly important in opinion of both, the CSFs less important in opinion of both, CSFs important in opinion of consultant but not client, CSFs important in opinion of client but not consultant. In discussion part, the significance of each factor is discussed individually. It is discussed that why some factors are high/less important for SMEs in Pakistan. The study output communicates a message that the success of ERP system in SMEs is linked with careful management of five important factors, the project management, top management support, user training and education, consultant participation and ERP teamwork and composition. The ERP consultants and managers can divert their concentration from less important factors such as user involvement, culture readiness and ERP package selection, toward the highly important factors. The limitations of the study are small number of interviews and less people involved, provide an opportunity for future research in this field of information system.

m-Equine : IS support for the horse industry

The horse industry is in many ways still operating the same way as it did in the beginning of the 20th century. At the same time the role of the horse has changed dramatically, from a beast of burden to a top athlete, a production animal or a beloved pet. A racehorse or an equestrian sport horse is trained and taken care of like any other athlete, but unlike its human counterpart, it might end up on our plate. According to European and many other countries’ laws, a horse is a production animal. The medical data of a horse should be known if it is to be slaughtered, to ensure that the meat is safe for human consumption. Today this vital medical information should be noted in the horse’s passport, but this paperbased system is not reliable. If a horse gets sold, depending on the country’s laws, the medical records might not be transferred to the new owner, the horse’s passport might get lost etc. Thus the system is not fool proof. It is not only the horse owners who have to struggle with paperwork; veterinarians as well as other officials often use much time on redundant paperwork. The main research question of this thesis is if IS could be used to help the different stakeholders within the horse industry? Veterinarians in particular who travel to stables to treat horses cannot always take with them their computers, since the somewhat unsanitary environment is not suitable for a sensitive technological device. Currently there is no common medical database developed for horses, although such a database with a support system could help with many problems. These include vaccination and disease control, food-safety, as well as export and import problems. The main stakeholders within the horse industry, including equine veterinarians and horse owners, were studied to find out their daily routines and needs for a possible support system. The research showed that there are different aspects within the horse industry where IS could be used to support the stakeholders daily routines. Thus a support system including web and mobile accessibility for the main stakeholders is under development. Since veterinarians will be the main users of this support system, it is very important to make sure that they find it useful and beneficial in their daily work. To ensure a desired result, the research and development of the system has been done iteratively with the stakeholders following the Action Design Research methodology.

Reframing the relationship between service design and operations: a service engineering approach

The significance of services as business and human activities has increased dramatically throughout the world in the last three decades. Becoming a more and more competitive and efficient service provider while still being able to provide unique value opportunities for customers requires new knowledge and ideas. Part of this knowledge is created and utilized in daily activities in every service organization, but not all of it, and therefore an emerging phenomenon in the service context is information awareness. Terms like big data and Internet of things are not only modern buzz-words but they are also describing urgent requirements for a new type of competences and solutions. When the amount of information increases and the systems processing information become more efficient and intelligent, it is the human understanding and objectives that may get separated from the automated processes and technological innovations. This is an important challenge and the core driver for this dissertation: What kind of information is created, possessed and utilized in the service context, and even more importantly, what information exists but is not acknowledged or used? In this dissertation the focus is on the relationship between service design and service operations. Reframing this relationship refers to viewing the service system from the architectural perspective. The selected perspective allows analysing the relationship between design activities and operational activities as an information system while maintaining the tight connection to existing service research contributions and approaches. This type of an innovative approach is supported by research methodology that relies on design science theory. The methodological process supports the construction of a new design artifact based on existing theoretical knowledge, creation of new innovations and testing the design artifact components in real service contexts. The relationship between design and operations is analysed in the health care and social care service systems. The existing contributions in service research tend to abstract services and service systems as value creation, working or interactive systems. This dissertation adds an important information processing system perspective to the research. The main contribution focuses on the following argument: Only part of the service information system is automated and computerized, whereas a significant part of information processing is embedded in human activities, communication and ad-hoc reactions. The results indicate that the relationship between service design and service operations is more complex and dynamic than the existing scientific and managerial models tend to view it. Both activities create, utilize, mix and share information, making service information management a necessary but relatively unknown managerial task. On the architectural level, service system -specific elements seem to disappear, but access to more general information elements and processes can be found. While this dissertation focuses on conceptual-level design artifact construction, the results provide also very practical implications for service providers. Personal, visual and hidden activities of service, and more importantly all changes that take place in any service system have also an information dimension. Making this information dimension visual and prioritizing the processed information based on service dimensions is likely to provide new opportunities to increase activities and provide a new type of service potential for customers.

Professionalization of controllers in Finland

Professions are a special category of occupations that possesses exclusive rights over its domain of expertise. Professions apply expert knowledge in their work by using professional discretion and judgment to solve their clients’ problems. With control over their expert knowledge base, professions are able to control the supply of practitioners in their field and regulate the practice in their market. Professionalization is the process during which occupations attempt to gain the status of a profession. The benefits of becoming a profession are extensive – professional autonomy, social and financial rewards, prestige, status, and an exclusive community are only a few of the privileges that established professions possess. Many aspiring occupations have tried and failed to gain the status of a profession and one of these groups is the occupation of controllers in Finland. The objective of this study to uncover, why controllers have not professionalized, which properties of the occupation correspond with the elements generally regarded to pertain to professions, and which aspects of the occupational group may hinder the professionalization project. The professionalization project of controllers is analyzed using a multi-actor model of professionalization, in which practitioners, clients, the state, training institutions, and employing organizations are considered to affect the project. The properties of the occupation of controllers are compared to features generally associated with professions. The research methodology for this thesis is qualitative, and the study is conducted as an exploratory research. The data is primarily gathered using semi-structured interviews, which were conducted between March and May 2013 lasting from 40 minutes to an hour. In total, four controllers were interviewed, who worked for different companies operating in different industries, and whose experience of working as a controller varied between a few years to nearly 15 years. The data in this study indicates that although controllers possess qualities that distinguish professions from other occupational groups, the professionalization of controllers may not be plausible. Controllers enjoy considerable autonomy in organizations, and they possess a strong orientation towards serving their clients. The more profound problem with the occupation is its non-exclusive, indistinct knowledge base that does not rely solely on a single knowledge base. Controllers’ expertise is relatively organization-specific and built on several different fields of knowledge and not just management accounting, which could be considered as their primary knowledge base. In addition, controllers have not organized themselves, which is a quintessential, but by no means a sufficient prerequisite for professionalization.

Sähköisen taloushallinnon kehityksen vaikutukset tilintarkastukseen ammattilehtikirjoittelussa vuosina 2003-2013

Tutkielman tavoitteena on tutkia, miten sähköisen taloushallinnon kehitys on vaikuttanut tilintarkastukseen ja miten se näkyy ammattilehtien kirjoittelussa vuosina 2003-2013. Alatavoitteina tutkitaan, mitä sähköisen taloushallinnon kehityksen tuomia hyötyjä ja haasteita on havaittu tarkastellussa suomalaisessa sekä kansainvälisessä ammattilehtikirjoittelussa tilintarkastuksen näkökulmasta. Kyseessä on laadullinen tutkimus ja tutkimusmetodologiana käytetään sisällönanalyysia. Tietokoneavusteisten tilintarkastuksen tekniikoiden kehityksen seurauksena tekniikoita voidaan kehittää kohti jatkuvaa tilintarkastusta. Kannettavien tietokoneiden ja pilvipalveluiden seurauksena tilintarkastuksesta on tullut enemmän ajasta ja paikasta riippumatonta. XBRL:n avulla tietojen vertailtavuus, luotettavuus ja tarkkuus ovat parantuneet. Haasteina voidaan nähdä tilintarkastajien IT-taitojen kehittämisen tarve sekä asiakkaan ja tilintarkastusyhteisön tietojärjestelmien yhteensopivuus. Hyvätkin ohjelmistot voivat altistaa väärinkäytöksille, jolloin tarvitaan uusia innovatiivisia tekniikoita väärinkäytösten havaitsemiseen. Tutkielman empiirisen osion luotettavuus perustuu ammattilehtien artikkeleiden kirjoittajien näkökulmiin. Tilintarkastusalan kehittyminen tulevaisuudessa on kiinni kehittyvän tekniikan lisäksi asenteista.