Facilitating coordination improvement efforts in cross-functional process development programs

Business process improvement is a common approach in increasing the effectiveness of an organization. It can be seen as an effort to increase coordination between units. Process improvement has proved to be challenging, and most management consultation firms facilitate organizations in this kind of initiatives. Cross-functional improvement is one of the main areas for internal consultants as well. However, the needs, challenges and means of cross-functional help have been rarely discussed in the literature. The objective of this thesis is on one hand to present a conceptual and descriptive framework to help understand the challenges of facilitating coordination improvement efforts in cross-functional improvement programs, and on the other hand to develop and test feasible solutions for some facilitation situations. The research questions are: 1. Why and in what kind of situations do organizations need help in developing coordination in cross-functional processes? 2. How can a facilitator help organizations in improving coordination to develop cross-functional processes? The study consists of two parts. The first part is an overview of the dissertation, and the second part comprises six research publications. The theoretical background for the study are the differentiation causing challenges in cross-functional settings, the coordination needed to improve processes, change management principles, methods and tools, and consultation practises. Three of the publications introduce tools for helping in developing prerequisites, planning responsibilities and supporting learning during the cross-functional program. The three other papers present frameworks to help understand and analyse the improvement situation. The main methodological approaches used in this study are design science research, action research and case research. The research data has been collected from ten cases representing different kinds of organizations, processes and developing situations. The data has been collected mainly by observation, semi-structured interviews and questionnaires. The research contributes to the rare literature combining coordination theories and process improvement practises. It also provides additional understanding of a holistic point of view in process improvement situations. The most important contribution is the addition to the theories of facilitating change in process improvement situations. From the managerial point of view, this study gives advice to managers and consultants in planning and executing cross-functional programs. The main factors increasing the need for facilitation are the challenges for differentiation, challenges of organizational change in general, and the novelty of initiatives and improvement practices concerning process development. Organizations need help in creating the prerequisites to change, in planning initiatives, easing conflict management and collaboration between groups, as well as supporting the learning of cross-functional improvement. The main challenges of facilitation are combining the different roles as a consultant, maintaining the ownership for the improvement project with the client, and supporting learning in the client organization.

Challenges and Means for the Front End Activities of Software Development

The front end of innovation is regarded as one of the most important steps in building new software products or services, and the most significant benefits in software development can be achieved through improvements in the front end activities. Problems in the front end phase have an impact on customer dissatisfaction with delivered software, and on the effectiveness of the entire software development process. When these processes are improved, the likelihood of delivering high quality software and business success increases. This thesis highlights the challenges and problems related to the early phases of software development, and provides new methods and tools for improving performance in the front end activities of software development. The theoretical framework of this study comprises two fields of research. The first section belongs to the field of innovation management, and especially to the management of the early phases of the innovation process, i.e. the front end of innovation. The second section of the framework is closely linked to the processes of software engineering, especially to the early phases of the software development process, i.e. the practice of requirements engineering. Thus, this study extends the theoretical knowledge and discloses the differences and similarities in these two fields of research. In addition, this study opens up a new strand for academic discussion by connecting these research directions. Several qualitative business research methodologies have been utilized in the individual publications to solve the research questions. The theoretical and managerial contribution of the study can be divided into three areas: 1) processes and concepts, 2) challenges and development needs, and 3) means and methods for the front end activities of software development. First, the study discloses the difference and similarities between the concepts of the front end of innovation and requirements engineering, and proposes a new framework for managing the front end of the software innovation process, bringing business and innovation perspectives into software development. Furthermore, the study discloses managerial perceptions of the similarities and differences in the concept of the front end of innovation between the software industry and the traditional industrial sector. Second, the study highlights the challenges and development needs in the front end phase of software development, especially challenges in communication, such as linguistic problems, ineffective communication channels, a communication gap between users/customers and software developers, and participation of multiple persons in software development. Third, the study proposes new group methods for improving the front end activities of software development, especially customer need assessment, and the elicitation of software requirements.

Software Development Process Modeling. Developers Perspective to Contemporary Modeling Techniques

Formal software development processes and well-defined development methodologies are nowadays seen as the definite way to produce high-quality software within time-limits and budgets. The variety of such high-level methodologies is huge ranging from rigorous process frameworks like CMMI and RUP to more lightweight agile methodologies. The need for managing this variety and the fact that practically every software development organization has its own unique set of development processes and methods have created a profession of software process engineers. Different kinds of informal and formal software process modeling languages are essential tools for process engineers. These are used to define processes in a way which allows easy management of processes, for example process dissemination, process tailoring and process enactment. The process modeling languages are usually used as a tool for process engineering where the main focus is on the processes themselves. This dissertation has a different emphasis. The dissertation analyses modern software development process modeling from the software developers’ point of view. The goal of the dissertation is to investigate whether the software process modeling and the software process models aid software developers in their day-to-day work and what are the main mechanisms for this. The focus of the work is on the Software Process Engineering Metamodel (SPEM) framework which is currently one of the most influential process modeling notations in software engineering. The research theme is elaborated through six scientific articles which represent the dissertation research done with process modeling during an approximately five year period. The research follows the classical engineering research discipline where the current situation is analyzed, a potentially better solution is developed and finally its implications are analyzed. The research applies a variety of different research techniques ranging from literature surveys to qualitative studies done amongst software practitioners. The key finding of the dissertation is that software process modeling notations and techniques are usually developed in process engineering terms. As a consequence the connection between the process models and actual development work is loose. In addition, the modeling standards like SPEM are partially incomplete when it comes to pragmatic process modeling needs, like light-weight modeling and combining pre-defined process components. This leads to a situation, where the full potential of process modeling techniques for aiding the daily development activities can not be achieved. Despite these difficulties the dissertation shows that it is possible to use modeling standards like SPEM to aid software developers in their work. The dissertation presents a light-weight modeling technique, which software development teams can use to quickly analyze their work practices in a more objective manner. The dissertation also shows how process modeling can be used to more easily compare different software development situations and to analyze their differences in a systematic way. Models also help to share this knowledge with others. A qualitative study done amongst Finnish software practitioners verifies the conclusions of other studies in the dissertation. Although processes and development methodologies are seen as an essential part of software development, the process modeling techniques are rarely used during the daily development work. However, the potential of these techniques intrigues the practitioners. As a conclusion the dissertation shows that process modeling techniques, most commonly used as tools for process engineers, can also be used as tools for organizing the daily software development work. This work presents theoretical solutions for bringing the process modeling closer to the ground-level software development activities. These theories are proven feasible by presenting several case studies where the modeling techniques are used e.g. to find differences in the work methods of the members of a software team and to share the process knowledge to a wider audience.

Laadullinen tutkimus ohjelmistotestauksen tehokkuuteen vaikutavista tekjöistä

Tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli selvittää ohjelmistotestauksen tehokkuuteen vaikuttavia tekijöitä tutkimalla yritysten ohjelmistotestausta, hyviä toimintatapojasekä toiminnan ongelmia. Tutkimalla yritysten ohjelmistotestausta on mahdollista kehittää ohjelmistotestauksen tehokkuutta parantavia toimenpiteitä ja malleja. Tutkimuksen ensimmäisessä vaiheessa oli mukana 26 yritystä, joista valittiin viisi case-yritystä tutkimuksen jatkovaiheisiin. Työn teoriaosuudessa esitetään sekä ohjelmistotestauksen teoria että käytetyn tutkimusmenetelmän teoriaa. Tässä diplomityössä keskitytään valittuihin viiteen case-yritykseen. Näiden viiden yrityksen sekä aiemman vaiheen 26 yrityksen kohdalla tehtiin kvalitatiivinen tutkimus käyttäen grounded-teorian mukaista tutkimusmenetelmää. Tämän kvalitatiivisen eli laadullisen tutkimuksen näkökulmat perustuivat aiempiin teknologiaselvitysvaiheen tuloksiin. Tämän diplomityön näkökulmana oli prosessien kehittäminen. Työn tuloksena löytyi tekijöitä, joilla näyttää olevan vaikutuksia testauksen tehokkuuteen. Tulosten avulla pystytään muodostamaan parannusehdotuksia testauksen tehokkuuden parantamiseksi yhdessä tutkimushankkeen muiden osa-alueiden tulosten kanssa. Testauksen tehokkuuteen vaikuttavatprosessinäkökulmasta mm. aikataulupaineet, lisääntyvä monimutkaisuus sekä ulkoahankittujen ohjelmiston osien testaamisen hankaluus. Ongelmia voidaan ratkaistatestauksen aikaisella mukanaololla projekteissa, ohjelmistotuotannon luonteen huomioimisella testauksessa, testauksen priorisoinnilla sekä ulkoisten komponenttien testattavuuden parantamisella.

Modeling information in software languages

Ohjelmiston kehitystyökalut käyttävät infromaatiota kehittäjän tuottamasta lähdekoodista. Informaatiota hyödynnetään ohjelmistoprojektin eri vaiheissa ja eri tarkoituksissa. Moderneissa ohjelmistoprojekteissa käytetyn informaation määrä voi kasvaa erittäin suureksi. Ohjelmistotyökaluilla on omat informaatiomallinsa ja käyttömekanisminsa. Informaation määrä sekä erilliset työkaluinformaatiomallit tekevät erittäin hankalaksi rakentaa joustavaa työkaluympäristöä, erityisesti ongelma-aluekohtaiseen ohjelmiston kehitysprosessiin. Tässä työssä on analysoitu perusinformaatiometamalleja Unified Modeling language kielestä, Python ohjelmointikielestä ja C++ ohjelmointikielestä. Metainformaation taso on rajoitettu rakenteelliselle tasolle. Ajettavat rakenteet on jätetty pois. ModelBase metamalli on yhdistetty olemassa olevista analysoiduista metamalleista. Tätä metamallia voidaan käyttää tulevaisuudessa ohjelmistotyökalujen kehitykseen.

Developing Supply Management Processes in a Global Process Automation Organization

Tämän työn tarkoituksena on tutkia prosessien uudelleensuunnittelua ja erityisesti hankintaprosessien uudistamista kansainvälisessä prosessiautomaatioyrityksessä. Työn aihealuetta tutkitaan sekä henkilöstön, uuden teknologian että prosessien kehittämisen näkökulmasta. Prosessien kehittämisessä työkaluna on käytetty tunnettua laatutyökalua, Six Sigmaa. Työn päätavoitteena on luoda uudet toimintamallit kehitettäville prosesseille. Kirjallisuuden lisäksi työ perustuu kirjoittajan kokemuksiin ja havaintoihin projektitiimin jäsenenä. Prosessien kehittämistä tarkastellaan myös muutoksenhallinnan näkökulmasta. Tämä on alue, jota ei saisi koskaan jättää huomiotta kehityshankkeissa. Kehitettäessä liiketoimintaprosesseja muutoksenhallinta on menestyksen kannalta ensisijaisen tärkeää. Muutoksenhallintaa tutkitaan työssä sekä organisaation että yksilön kannalta. Tässä työssä esitellään lisäksi maailmanlaajuisesti tunnettu ja käytetty laatutyökalu, Six Sigma. Six Sigmaa on käytetty myös työn lopussa tarkasteltavassa case-osuudessa. Case-osuudessa prosesseja tutkitaan aina nykytilasta uusiin toimintamalleihin saakka. Prosesseja ja niiden suorituskykyä analysoidaan yhtäjaksoisesti kehitysprojektien edetessä.

Process Interfaces in an After Sales Organization

Työn tavoitteena oli selvittää Larox Oy:n, Lappeenranta, palveluorganisaation prosessit ja prosessien väliset rajapinnat. Prosesseja ja prosessien kehittämistä ja innovointia tarkasteltiin ensin kirjallisuuden perusteella. Rajapintojen selkeää esittämistä varten kehitettiin yksinkertainen metodologia mind mapping -tekniikan pohjalta. Nykyisten prosessien tila ja rajapinnat analysoitiin ja dokumentoitiin haastattelemalla Larox Oy:n työntekijöitä ja asiakkaita sekä tutustumalla prosessikuvauksiin ja muihin olennaisiin dokumentteihin. Analyysin tulosten perusteella tunnistettiin suurimmat ongelmakohdat rajapinnoissa ja pohdittiin mahdollisia ratkaisuja niihin. Pieniä prosessinkehitysaloitteita kehitettiin yhteistyössä Larox Oy:n työntekijöiden kanssa. Työn lopussa on pohdittu mahdollisia tulevaisuuden malleja Larox Oy:n palveluorganisaation toimintamalleiksi.

Introducing Continuous Integration for C and C++ Software Development Projects on Linux Platform

Software integration is a stage in a software development process to assemble separate components to produce a single product. It is important to manage the risks involved and being able to integrate smoothly, because software cannot be released without integrating it first. Furthermore, it has been shown that the integration and testing phase can make up 40 % of the overall project costs. These issues can be mitigated by using a software engineering practice called continuous integration. This thesis work presents how continuous integration is introduced to the author's employer organisation. This includes studying how the continuous integration process works and creating the technical basis to start using the process on future projects. The implemented system supports software written in C and C++ programming languages on Linux platform, but the general concepts can be applied to any programming language and platform by selecting the appropriate tools. The results demonstrate in detail what issues need to be solved when the process is acquired in a corporate environment. Additionally, they provide an implementation and process description suitable to the organisation. The results show that continuous integration can reduce the risks involved in a software process and increase the quality of the product as well.

Performance Measurement of the Logistics Process

The objective of the thesis was to create a performance measurement system for the logistics process of a company. In addition, one goal was to make suggestions for improvements based on description and analysis of the process and current measures. The logistics process was described in detail, and the objectives for it were derived from the company strategy and goals. Suggestions for performance measurement system and process improvement were made based on current state analysis. As a result of the thesis, three new performance measures were decided to take into use. In addition, several improvements were suggested to the ERP system to make process smoother. Some of the improvements have already been added to the system and the rest will be added in the near future.

Utilization of Automatic Meter Reading in the Improvement of a District Heating System

A district heating system comprises production facilities, a distribution network, and heat consumers. The utilization of new energy metering and reading system (AMR) is increasing constantly in district heating systems. This heuristic study shows how the AMR system can be exploited in finding optimization opportunities in district heating system. In this study, the district heating system is mainly considered from the viewpoint of operational optimization. The focus is on the core processes, heat production and distribution. Three objectives were set to this study. The first one was to examine general optimization opportunities in district heating systems. Second, to figure out the benefits of AMR for general optimization opportunities. Finally, to define a methodology for process improvement endeavors. This study shows, through a case study, the usefulness of AMR in specifying current deficiencies in a district heating system. Based on a literature review, the methodology for the improvement of business processes is presented. Additionally, some issues related to future competitiveness of district heating are concerned. As a conclusion, some optimization objectives are considered more desirable than others. Study shows that AMR is useful in the specification of optimization targets in the district heating system. Further steps in optimization process were not examined in detail. That would seem to be interesting topic for further studies.

Process approach in quality management - Case: ECO process development in EMS industry

The aim of the thesis was to study quality management with process approach and to find out how to utilize process management to improve quality. The operating environment of organizations has changed. Organizations are focusing on their core competences and networking with suppliers and customers to ensure more effective and efficient value creation for the end customer. Quality management is moving from inspection of the output to prevention of problems from occurring in the first place and management thinking is changing from functional approach to process approach. In the theoretical part of the thesis, it is studied how to define quality, how to achieve good quality, how to improve quality, and how to make sure the improvement goes on as never ending cycle. A selection of quality tools is introduced. Process approach to quality management is described and compared to functional approach, which is the traditional way to manage operations and quality. The customer focus is also studied, and it is presented, that to ensure long term customer commitment, organization needs to react to changing customer requirements and wishes by constantly improving the processes. In the experimental part the theories are tested in a process improvement business case. It is shown how to execute a process improvement project starting from defining the customer requirements, continuing to defining the process ownership, roles and responsibilities, boundaries, interfaces and the actual process activities. The control points and measures are determined for the process, as well as the feedback and corrective action process, to ensure continual improvement can be achieved and to enable verification that customer requirements are fulfilled.

Ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn mittaaminen ja johtaminen henkilöstön näkökulmasta

Onnistuneesti suoritettu suorituskyvyn mittaaminen ja johtaminen tuovat kirjallisuuden mukaan organisaatiolle monia hyötyjä. Ohjelmistotyön suorituskyky vaikuttaa ohjelmistoyritysten kannattavuuteen ja ohjelmointiprojektien tuloksellisuuteen. Ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn parantamisessa on suurelta osin keskitytty prosessien parantamiseen. Ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn taustalla on kuitenkin paljon muitakin tekijöitä kuin prosessi-indikaattorit. Sitoutuneisuus ja motivoituneisuus nähdään yhä tärkeämpinä tekijöinä ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn taustalla, joten suorituskyvyn johtamisen tulee huomioida nykyistä paremmin myös henkilöstön näkökulma. Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli tutkia suorituskyvyn johtamisen viitekehysten, ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn taustatekijöiden, motivaation merkityksen ja johtamistyylien analysoinnin avulla, millainen suorituskyvyn mittaus- ja johtamisjärjestelmä (PMS) tukisi ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn johtamista huomioiden henkilöstön näkökulman. Tutkimuksessa analysoitiin aiempia aihepiiriä koskevia tutkimuksia ja lisäksi haastateltiin alan yritysasiantuntijoita. Tutkimuksen tuloksena esitettiin tärkeimmät ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn taustatekijät, joiden tilan parantamista suorituskyvyn johtamisen tulee mahdollistaa. Näiden havaittiin olevan läheisessä suhteessa henkilöstön motivaatiotekijöihin, joiden sitouttavaa kehittymistä johtamisen tulee myös tukea. Tulokset kiteytettiin suosituksiin koskien johtamista ja mittaristomallia, joita voidaan hyödyntää ohjelmistotyön suorituskyvyn johtamisessa huomioiden henkilöstön näkökulma. Mallissa on kuvattu mitattavat ja johdettavat tekijät yksilö- ja tiimitasolla, esimiestyössä sekä henkilöstövoimavarojen johtamisessa (HRM).

Improving reporting and internal control with process thinking - case study in a multinational corporation

The aim of this Master’s Thesis is to find applicable methods from process management literature for improving reporting and internal control in a multinational corporation. The method of analysis is qualitative and the research is conducted as a case study. Empirical data collection is carried out through interviews and participating observation. The theoretical framework is built around reporting and guidance between parent company and subsidiary, searching for means to improve them from process thinking and applicable frameworks. In the thesis, the process of intercompany reporting in the case company is modelled, and its weak points, risks, and development targets are identified. The framework of critical success factors in process improvement is utilized in assessing the development targets. Also internal control is analyzed with the tools of process thinking. As a result of this thesis, suggestions for actions improving the reporting process and internal control are made to the case company, the most essential of which are ensuring top management’s awareness and commitment to improvement, creating guidelines and tools for internal control and creating and implementing improved intercompany reporting process.

Invoice process analysis and development. Case: Power and automation technology company

This master’s thesis studies the case company’s current purchase invoice process and the challenges that are related to it. Like most of other master’s thesis this study consists of both theoretical- and empirical parts. The purpose of this work is to combine theoretical and empirical parts together so that the theoretical part brings value to the empirical case study. The case company’s main business is frequency converters for both low voltage AC & DC drives and medium voltage AC Drives which are used across all industries and applications. The main focus of this study is on the current invoice process modelling. When modelling the existing process with discipline and care, current challenges can be understood better. Empirical study relays heavily on interviews and existing, yet fragmented, data. This, along with own calculations and analysis, creates the foundation for the empirical part of this master’s thesis.

Increased profitability and efficiency by improving the Meetings & Events Category S2P-process – Case Company

The purpose of this research was to examine the most optimal way to arrange meetings and events management and source to pay –process in a global company. The research is a qualitative multi-method case study and is a commission from a global company. The theoretical framework of this research structures around two approaches. First approach focus on a purchasing strategy and management that shows the current role of procure-ment and introduce different ways to organize purchasing functions. Second approach focus on purchasing process management and improvement methods. Annual spend analyze, external and internal interviews and internal survey were done to gain compre-hensive knowledge about the current state of operations and possible solutions. Gathered data were then combined to theoretical framework in order to create optimal solution for the case company. Based on the research a source to pay –process and global policy for meeting and event category was created. The solution includes all relevant matters that are needed in order to secure efficient and profitable operations. The results show that optimal way to arrange meetings and events structures around standardized source to pay –processes, central-ized procurement, preferred supplier and clearly defined roles and responsibilities be-tween different stakeholders.