From Education to Technology Commercialization

Report published in the Proceedings of the National Conference on "Education and Research in the Information Society", Plovdiv, May, 2016

Commercializing technology in transitional economies. Case: Nanotechnology in Russia

The aim of the study is to find out “What are the challenges to overcome for the successful nanotechnology commercialization in Russia?” Working closely with the case country was definitely an advantage when it comes to the understanding of the research subject. The thesis is divided to two parts: first part examines the concept of technology commercialization and identifies unique aspects of the process in context of nanotechnology. Second part is dedicated to an empirical research, investigating current status of nanotechnology commercialization in Russia. For the purpose of this study, Russian and international scientists, researchers, entrepreneurs, industry and government representatives were interviewed systematically during 2007 – 2009. Based on the research done it can be concluded that immense public funding provides necessary support for the development of Russian nanotechnology industry. However, investments alone do not address important structural shortcomings of a national innovation system, which in turn slow down the progress. Taking into consideration gap between science and business and challenging IPR legislation, expected significant economic impact in Russia may be overestimated. Nevertheless it should be noted that development of nanotechnology is advancing rapidly and therefore, the state of commercialization is changing accordingly, even while this lines are written.

TecMinho- Associação Universidade- Empresa para o Desenvolvimento : a comunicação estratégica aplicada a Ideias de negócio

O estágio curricular, inserido na componente não-lectiva do mestrado em Comunicação Estratégica é a ferramenta principal no desenvolvimento deste relatório. A TecMinho- Associação Universidade -Empresa para o Desenvolvimento, onde decorreu o estágio, é uma instituição de vanguarda, que promove a inovação, o empreendedorismo e o desenvolvimento de diferentes competências. Foca-se em diversas vertentes, desde a investigação e tecnologias, à formação, o empreendedorismo e a planos de negócio para empresas. Uma atividade particularmente relevante é o programa IdeaLab, um acelerador de ideias de negócio, que oferece aos promotores conhecimentos e ferramentas que lhes permite melhorar a concepção de produtos e serviços, e de ideias inovadoras, de modo a reforçar a sua proposta de valor. Neste programa são destacadas as competências empreendedoras através de workshops temáticos, coaching, networking e pré-incubação.

Innovation and new business through mutually beneficial collaboration and proactive procurement

ABSTRACT This dissertation focuses on new technology commercialization, innovation and new business development. Industry-based novel technology may achieve commercialization through its transfer to a large research laboratory acting as a lead user and technical partner, and providing the new technology with complementary assets and meaningful initial use in social practice. The research lab benefits from the new technology and innovation through major performance improvements and cost savings. Such mutually beneficial collaboration between the lab and the firm does not require any additional administrative efforts or funds from the lab, yet requires openness to technologies and partner companies that may not be previously known to the lab- Labs achieve the benefits by applying a proactive procurement model that promotes active pre-tender search of new technologies and pre-tender testing and piloting of these technological options. The collaboration works best when based on the development needs of both parties. This means that first of all the lab has significant engineering activity with well-defined technological needs and second, that the firm has advanced prototype technology yet needs further testing, piloting and the initial market and references to achieve the market breakthrough. The empirical evidence of the dissertation is based on a longitudinal multiple-case study with the European Laboratory for Particle Physics. The key theoretical contribution of this study is that large research labs, including basic research, play an important role in product and business development toward the end, rather than front-end, of the innovation process. This also implies that product-orientation and business-orientation can contribute to basic re-search. The study provides practical managerial and policy guidelines on how to initiate and manage mutually beneficial lab-industry collaboration and proactive procurement.

Hybridityökoneiden markkinapotentiaali

Työn tavoitteena on selvittää menetelmiä hybridityökoneiden markkinapotentiaalin määrittämiseen, työkonemarkkinoiden kokoa ja kasvupotentiaalia, hybridityökoneiden markkinapotentiaalia sekä uuden teknologian kaupallistamisen teorioita. Vuonna 2010 liikkuvien työkoneiden markkinat arvioitiin olevan noin 94–98 miljardia dollaria. Markkinat kasvavat keskimäärin noin 5 prosenttia vuodessa. Alan suurimmat markkinat löytyvät Kiinasta, Euroopasta ja Yhdysvalloista.Hybridityökoneiden markkinapotentiaalia Kiinassa nostaa markkinoiden suuri koko ja nopea kasvuvauhti. Yhdysvaltojen valtti on tukijärjestelmät jotka parantavat hybridiratkaisujen kilpailukykyä. Euroopan potentiaalia nostavat tiukat päästönormit sekä korkea polttoaineen hinta. Markkinapotentiaalin määrittämisen on olemassa useita matemaattisia menetelmiä. Niiden soveltamista hybridityökoneisiin rajoittaa eniten riittävän datan hankinnan haasteellisuus. Vertailemalla yrityksiä teknologian kaupallistamisen teorioissa esiteltyjen menestystä edistävien piirteiden suhteen on teknisen ratkaisun kehittäjän mahdollista valita paras mahdollinen yhteistyökumppani. Soveltamalla kaupallistamisprosessissa kurinalaista mallia, johon kuuluvat sekä teknologiaettä tuotekehitys ja niiden välillä teknologiansiirtovaihe, on teknisen ratkaisun soveltaminen hybriditeknologiaan ja työkoneisiin mahdollista toteuttaa onnistuneesti ja tuoda siten markkinoille kaupallisesti kilpailukykyinen tuote.

Uuden teknologian kaupallistaminen - elektroniikan ja optiikan integrointi 2k-ruiskuvaluprosessissa

Tutkimuksen tarkoituksena oli löytää keinoja uudella teknologialla valmistettujen tuotteiden kaupallistamiseen. Uudella teknologialla tarkoitetaan elektroniikan ja optiikan integrointia 2k-ruiskuvaluprosessissa. Työn teoreettisessa viitekehyksessä kuvattiin elektroniikan ja optiikan integrointi 2-komponenttiruiskuvalumenetelmällä. Toisena tarkastelun kohteena oli uuden teknologian kaupallistaminen. Empiirisessä osuudessa keskityttiin tarkastelemaan elektroniikan ja optiikan komponentteja sisältävän muovituotteen kaupallistamismahdollisuuksia Realplast Oy:ssa. Tutkimuksessa selvisi, kuinka ruiskuvalumuotin rungon tuotteistaminen alentaa muotista aiheutuvien kuoletusten osuutta tuotteen hinnassa. EEMO-teknologian vahvuudet ovat: edullisemmat valmistuskustannukset, tuotteiden vesitiiveys ja iskunkestävyys. Vahvuuksia kannattaa hyödyntää teknologian kaupallistamisessa. EEMO-teknologian kaupallistaminen kannattaa jakaa kolmeen vaiheeseen, koemarkkinointiin protomallien avulla, myyntiin teollisuus- ja kuluttaja-asiakkaille. Strateginen kumppani auttaa kaupallistamisessa etenkin kuluttaja-asiakkaiden tavoittelussa.

Teknologiasta liiketoimintaa. Julkisen tutkimuksen kaupallistaminen - Case VTT

Tässä tutkielmassa perehdyttiin julkisen tutkimuksen kaupallistamiseen tutkimusorganisaatio VTT:n tapauksen kautta. Tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli selvittää, kuinka julkista tutkimusta voidaan yleensä kaupallistaa, mitkä ovat kaupallistamisprosessin vaiheet, haasteet sekä kriittiset onnistumistekijät. Tutkimus on luonteeltaan laadullinen ja se toteutettiin henkilöhaastatteluina, joita täydennettiin kirjallisilla lähteillä. Tutkimuksessa ilmeni, että VTT:llä julkisrahoitteisen tutkimuksen tuloksia kaupallistetaan lisensoimalla, toimeksianto- eli sopimustutkimuksen kautta, spin-off toimilla, allianssien ja erilaisten palvelujen, kuten valmistus-, testaus-, ja analyysipalvelujen kautta. VTT:n näkökulmasta katsottuna merkittävin kaupallistamiskanava on sopimus- eli toimeksiantotutkimus, jota seuraavat lisensointi sekä spin-off toiminta. Kaupallistamistavan valinta riippuu lukuisista tekijöistä, kuten organisaation kaupallistamisstrategiasta, innovaatiotyypistä, teknologian kypsyydestä, tiedon luonteesta, toimialojen ja markkinoiden ominaisuuksista, innovaation hyödynnettävyydestä ja suojauksesta, arvonmuodostuspotentiaalista kuin yksittäisten henkilöiden motivaatiostakin.Valinta onkin tehtävä tapauskohtaisesti. Julkisesta tutkimuksesta lähtöisin olevien teknologioiden tie markkinoille voi olla haastava, sillä teknologiat ovat kehitetty ei-kaupallisessa ympäristössä. Tutkimuksessa kävi ilmi, että kriittisimmiksi koetut kaupallistamisen onnistumistekijät liittyivät organisaatioon, teknologiaan, markkina- ja asiakastarpeeseen, aineettoman omaisuuden suojaukseen sekä markkinoille menon nopeuteen.

The challenges and success factors of commercializing cleaner technologies

Cleaner technologies include products, services, technologies, processes and systems that in use create less environmental hazard than the existing alternatives. Rapidly growing cleantech sector possesses an essential competitive advantage in the future. However, no profound research has been conducted on the characteristics of cleaner technologies and their effect on the commercialization process. This thesis aims at synthesizing scattered information and creating a basis for accelerating cleaner technology commercialization in Finnish context. Two research questions are defined: 1. What are the key challenges and success factors in the commercialization of cleaner technologies based on the existing literature? 2. What kind of lessons can be learned from the Finnish success stories of cleantech commercialization? The research was conducted as a literature review and supported with three case interviews. The results suggest that literature-based challenges are mostly related to, for example, difficulty in gathering customer information, unrealistic customer expectations, lack of resources, networks and proper success indicators, legislation, and unstructured strategy planning stemming from company culture. Handling the barriers require, above all, open communication from all stakeholders, management commitment and accurate goal setting, government-driven funding and incentives, and cooperation with educational facilities. Finnish success cases emphasize especially customer attention: listening to customers and receiving feedback from them during the whole commercialization process to correct the errors early and save resources, visionary in fulfilling customer needs, ability to question company’s own business performance, not being afraid of making mistakes but learning from them, and continuously observing and evaluating the commercialization process.

Patent nonnuse: are patent pools as possible solution?

Studies have depicted that the rate of unused patents comprises a high portion of patents in North America, Europe and Japan. Particularly, studies have identified a considerable share of strategic patents which are left unused due to pure strategic reasons. While such patents might generate strategic rents to their owner, they may have harmful consequences for the society if by blocking alternative solutions that other inventions provide they hamper the possibility of better solutions. Accordingly, the importance of the issue of nonuse is highlighted within the literature on strategic patenting, IPR policy and innovation economics. Moreover, the current literature has emphasized on the role of patent pools in dealing with potential issues such as excessive transaction cost caused by patent thickets and blocking patents. In fact, patent pools have emerged as policy tools facilitating technology commercialization and alleviating patent litigation among rivals holding overlapping IPRs. In this dissertation I provide a critical literature review on strategic patenting, identify present gaps and discuss some future research paths. Moreover, I investigate the drivers of strategic non-use of patents with particular focus on unused strategic play patents. Finally, I examine if participation intensity in patent pools by pool members explains their willingness to use their non-pooled patents. I also investigate which characteristics of the patent pools are associated to the willingness to use non-pooled patents through pool participation. I show that technological uncertainty and technological complexity are two technology environment factors that drive unused play patents. I also show that pool members participating more intensively in patent pools are more likely to be willing to use their non-pooled patents through pool participation. I further depict that pool licensors are more likely to be willing to use their non-pooled patents by participating in pools with higher level of technological complementarity to their own technology.

H.R. 4226--Renewable Energy and Energy Conservation Commercialization and Development Act [microform] : hearing before the Subcommittee on Energy Research and Development of the Committee on Science, Space, and Technology, House of Representatives, One Hundredth Congress, second session, June 30, 1988.

"No. 126."

Technology transfer and commercialization : technology transfer report, 1994 /

Mode of access: Internet.

Commercialization of Modern Renewable Energy

The threat of global warming and its consequences are widely recognized, and the question of how to proceed with the long transition towards fossil fuel -neutral economies concerns many nations and people. At the same time the world’s primary energy use is predicted to increase significantly during the next decades as a result of global population and welfare increase. Improved energy efficiency and increased use of renewable energy sources in the world’s energy mix play important roles in the future energy production and consumption. The objective of this thesis is to study how novel renewable energy technologies, such as distributed small-scale bio-fueled combined heat and power production and wind power technologies could be commercialized efficiently. A wide array of attributes may contribute to the diffusion of new products. In general, the bioenergy and wind power technologies are in emerging phases, and the diffusion stage varies from country to country. The effects of firms’ technology choices, collaboration and alliances are studied in this thesis. Furthermore, the roles of national energy infrastructure and energy support schemes in the commercialization of new renewable energy products are explored. The empirical data is based on energy expert interviews, financial and patent data, and literature reviews of different case studies. The thesis comprises two parts. The first part provides an overview of the study, and the second part includes six research publications. The results reveal that small-scale bio-fueled combined heat and power production and wind power technologies are still in emerging phases in their life cycles, and energy support schemes are crucial in the market diffusion. The study contributes to earlier findings in the literature and industry by confirming that adequate energy policies and energy infrastructure are fundamental in the commercialization of novel renewable energy technologies. Firm-specific issues, including business relationships and new business models, and market-related issues will have a more significant role in the market penetration in the future, when the technologies mature and become competitive without political support schemes.

High-Tech Commercialization Research Projects: A Pragmatic View

In the Finnish university society the commercialization research projects has not been a focus of interest until now. The reasons for the growing interest towards commercialization research projects are their possibility to develop our economy simultaneously by providing new technologies and products. This study focuses on the examination of what kind of high-technology oriented research can be commercialized and how. The aim is to generate understanding of how commercialization research projects should proceed and to find concrete ways of improving the of commercialization research projects. As its research method, the study analyzes four different university high-technology research projects which have been commercially oriented and have to some degree been able to commercialize the product or technology developed during the research phase. The data has been gathered mainly by semi-structured interviews of people involved in these particular projects or cases. The findings from the interviews have been reflected to the final reports of the projects, provided by TEKES, and later on the data gained has been compared to each other. Also a literature review has been produced about the subject of commercializing university research with the purpose of providing known theories and framework connected with the subject. The study reveals five main factors related to commercializing high-tech research. These factors are: The Team, Market potential and competitiveness, Product and technology, Funding and Steering Group. Also the uncertainties related to these factors have been addressed. As a conclusion the study provides the main aspects that should be considered when starting a commercialization research project. Also a combining hierarchical framework has been provided related to the five factors presented. In Chapter 5 the study addresses the main tasks or steps to be taken in order to get public funding for a commercially oriented research project and later on the actual steps to be executed in order to successfully commercialize these high-tech research projects.

Conflict of Interest in University Technology Transfer

Étude de cas / Case study

The Effect of Support Measures on Involvement in Technology Transfer

The present PhD dissertation is dedicated to the general topic of knowledge transfer from academia to industry and the role of various measures at both institutional and university levels in support of commercialization of university research. The overall contribution of the present dissertation work refers to presenting an in-depth and comprehensive analysis of the main critical issues that currently exist with regard to commercial exploitation of academic research, while providing evidence on the role of previously underexplored areas (e.g. strategic use of academic patents; female academic patenting) in a general debate on the ways to successful knowledge transfer from academia to industry. The first paper, included in the present PhD dissertation, aims to address this gap by developing a taxonomy of literature, based on a comprehensive review of the existing body of research on government measures in support of knowledge transfer from academia to industry. The results of the review reveal that there is a considerable gap in the analysis of the impact and relative effectiveness of the public policy measures, especially in what regards the measures aimed at building knowledge and expertise among academic faculty and technology transfer agents. The second paper, presented as a part of the dissertation, focuses on the role of interorganizational collaborations and their effect on the likelihood of an academic patent to remain unused, and points to the strategic management of patents by universities. In the third paper I turn to the issue of female participation in patenting and commercialization; in particular, I find evidence on the positive role of university and its internal support structures in closing the gender gap in female academic patenting. The results of the research, carried out for the present dissertation, provide important implications for policy makers in crafting measures to increase the efficient use of university knowledge stock.