El Plan Colombia o el desarrollo como seguridad: un análisis documental entre la primera versión del Plan Colombia y la definitiva

El Plan Colombia fue diseñado como un paquete de ayuda internacional para la búsqueda de la paz en un marco de colaboración multilateral. Tras una negociación bilateral de dos años entre Colombia y Estados Unidos, el Plan concentró sus objetivos en la lucha contra el narcotráfico. Este trabajo pretende mostrar en qué consistió este cambio y describir el significado de la política del Plan. Se plantea que la política está determinada por la concepción del desarrollo como seguridad (Duffield, 2001 y 2002). Para ello, se realiza un análisis comparativo documental entre el primer texto del Plan Colombia, incluido en el Plan Nacional de Desarrollo de 1998, y el texto definitivo hecho por el gobierno en el 2000. La monografía argumenta que la ayuda otorgada está determinada por la lucha internacional contra las drogas y un nuevo modelo de Estado que implica tanto replantear las relaciones sociales a nivel local como una reflexión acerca de la soberanía estatal en el marco de nuevas tendencias globales.

Efectos de la ayuda internacional para el desarrollo en la consolidación de Somalia (1969-1991)

Esta monografía tiene como objetivo analizar los efectos de la transferencia de ayuda internacional para el desarrollo en el proceso de consolidación de Somalia. Dicha ayuda surgió como política pública en el contexto de la Guerra Fría y su instrumentalización dependió de los conflictos e intereses de las potencias de la época. En la década de los 60, Somalia fue receptora de millones de dólares en ayuda, que minaron el proceso de state-building dado que las transferencias no dependieron del desempeño económico, social ni político del Estado. El cual, dirigido por el General Barre, se convirtió en un ente cuyo único fin era la captación de la ayuda y cuyo control era la única forma de asegurar la supervivencia física. Los enfrentamientos entre clanes por el poder llevaron no sólo al colapso del Estado, sino también al surgimiento del período de anarquía más largo conocido por un Estado moderno.

Hacia un nuevo marco interpretativo de la asistencia internacional para el desarrollo (Artículos Varios)

Este artículo intenta construir una perspectiva alternativa al estudio de la asistencia internacional para el desarrollo. Para ello, el autor analiza las variables internacionales que han determinado la trayectoria y el cambio de la misma, desde sus inicios en 1948 hasta el presente. Estas variables tendrían que ver con los intereses de los donantes, la dinámica organizacional de las agencias canalizadoras de la asistencia,y las ideas y teorías que sobre el desarrollo internacional han predominado en cada momento. El artículo concluye con la presentación de un marco interpretativo de la asistencia, el cual busca explicar su origen, carácter y cambio en las últimas décadas, de un paradigma centrado en la formación de capital al paradigma del desarrollo humano sustentable.

Reconstruction in Aceh: building whose capacity?

One of the dominant themes in development programmes over the last fifteen years has been a commitment to capacity building. This paper investigates the forms of capacity building in Aceh, Indonesia, since the devastating earthquake and tsunami that hit the province on 26 December 2004. Despite the preference of the Acehnese people for reconstruction processes based on the principles of community development, local people have been largely marginalized by both the Indonesian government and the international aid and development agencies. The paper suggests some of the reasons for this marginalization.

Managing heritage in the wake of war and conflict in Cyprus

In the wake of a Greece-inspired coup against the Greek Cypriot President of Cyprus in 1974, the Turkish military occupied the northern third of the island and continues to do so. Ethnic communities are still separated: Greek Cypriots moved to the south and Turkish Cypriots to the north. This paper covers issues raised by the bi-communal conservation projects resulting from the European Union’s Partnership for the Future Programme being implemented by the United Nations Development Programme. The projects require co-operation between mutually distrustful, fearful and disdainful communities for the sake of common objectives – social and economic wellbeing. Cyprus has apparently opted for conflict management rather than resolution, with both sides focused on achieving prosperity. Heritage conservation has become a tool for peaceful co-existence and mutual pride. Initially the projects involved places of shared heritage rather than places reinforcing the separate cultural identities of the communities. Loss of cultural identity is a concern of both communities. Ongoing operational issues derive from the illegality of the Turkish government in the north and the repercussions of this for international aid. The paper will contribute to the conference theme by exploring the professional challenges related to these issues and their possible resolution.

Post-disaster coping in Aceh : sociocultural factors and emotional response

This chapter describes how disaster survivors in the Indonesian province of Aceh responded to the unprecedented level of international aid following the Indian Ocean tsunami of 2004. It is based on research conducted by Ismet fanany, as part of an Outside Studies program supported by Deakin University, and centers on the conceptualization of disasterr of the survivors, the role religion and traditional culture played in their ability to cope, and their emotional state in relation to their perception of the cause of the event.

Health cosmopolitanism: melding universality and difference – the case of childbirth in post-conflict Timor Leste

ABSTRACTThis study will consider the case of TBAs (traditional birth attendants) under the health cosmopolitan banner. Fifteen interviews with health administrators, obstetricians, midwives, traditional birth attendants and women in Timor Leste, provide evidence : (1) that the WHO (1992) directive to dismiss the inclusion of TBAs within the formal maternity care system has been precipitous (2) that TBAs could, with adequate training in emergency obstetric techniques and hygienic practices, assist in meeting MDG No 5, and (3) that TBAs may assist in sustaining hybrid cosmologies and serving other cultural aims. Although Millennium Development Goals embrace the idea of the universal right to health, a human rights framework remains abstract and legalistic. I argue that health cosmopolitanism offers a more inclusive lens. Applied to maternity care it shifts childbirth to a central focus of government policy, obliges all nations to contribute international aid yet recognises the interpretation of complex needs at the local level. It defines a philosophy of care that is person-centred (not professional or institution-centred), ensures equal access to quality care (based not on ability to pay or other obstacles such as geographical distance) and choice of carer and modality (Western, traditional or hybrid). It underlines the argument here that TBAs trained in emergency obstetric care and hygiene and funded by international agencies would ensure every woman has a known carer, plus choice of location, modality and provider. Health cosmopolitanism thus embraces universality, individual autonomy, reciprocal respect and global responsibility.

Una arquitectura internacional difícil de imitar: el caso de Filipinas

ResumenLas guerras en el siglo XXI son la continuación de conflictos armados internos surgidos a mediados del siglo XX, y otras son el resultado de la segunda gran descolonización en algunos territoriosde Asia y África ocurridos por la misma época. En ambos casos se reflejan problemas estructurales de los estados, generalmente los llamados del tercer mundo. Después de la caída del muro de Berlín y la unificación alemana a finales de los 80, el inicio de la lucha contra el narcotráfico y la actual lucha contra el terror a finales de los 90 e inicios del 2000. Los países en situación de guerra interna reciben apoyo de actores de la comunidad internacional, comolos que les interesa negociar conflictos y como los que deben contribuir a la paz y la seguridad internacional. Filipinas, estado ubicado en el sudeste asiático, sostiene un conflicto armado interno de casi 60 años. Durante el 2010, ha sostenido un proceso de paz entre el gobierno nacional y la guerrillamusulmana MILF (Frente Moro de Liberación Nacional), en donde varios actores de la comunidad internacional como los Estados Unidos, los países vecinos y la Unión Europea han jugado un papel importante para el restablecimiento de la paz.Palabras clave: paz, conflictos armados internos, comunidad internacional, negociación, Filipinas. AbstractWars during the 21st century are extension of Internal Armed Conflicts which began in the middle of the 20th century. Others conflicts are the result of the second de-colonization of some Asian and African territories. In both cases, they reflect the state’s structural problems; commonly known as the “third world.” After the fall of the Berlin Wall and the German unification in the late 1980s, the beginning of war against drug trafficking and the war against terrorism in the late 1990s and early 2000s, the countries in a Internal Armed Conflict situation have received International Aid from states that are interested in resolution of wars and their own interest in global peace and security.The Philippines is a country in southeastern Asia. It has been involved in an Internal Armed Conflict for more than 50 years. In 2010, the National Government and the Moro Islamic Liberation Fronthave developed a round tables/ peace panels, where some international community actors such as the United States, neighboring countries, and European Union, have played a very important role for establishment of peace.Keywords: peace, internal armed conflicts, international community, negotiation, Filipines.

Right to Food, Food Security and Food Aid Under International Law, or the Limits of a right-based approach

The right to food has become a pillar of international humanitarian and human rights law. The increasing number of food-related emergencies and the evolution of the international order brought the more precise notion of food security and made a potential right to receive food aid emerge. Despite this apparent centrality, recent statistics show that a life free from hunger is for many people all over the world still a utopian idea. The paper will explore nature and content of the right to food, food security and food aid under international law in order to understand the reasons behind the substantial failure of this right-centred approach, emphasising the lack of legal effects of many food-related provisions because of excessive moral connotations of the right to be free from hunger. Bearing in mind the three-dimensional nature of food security, the paper will also suggest that all attention has been focused on the availability of food, while real difficulties arise in terms of accessibility and adequacy. Emergency situations provide an excellent example of this unbalance, as the emerging right to receive food aid focus itself on the availability of food, without improving local production and adequacy. Looking at other evolving sectors of international law, such as the protection of the environment, and particularly the safeguard of biological diversity, alternative solutions will be envisaged in order to “feed” the right to food.