The Cost of ownership in the governance of interfirm collaborations

This paper investigates the selection of governance forms in interfirm collaborations taking into account the predictions from transaction costs and property rights theories. Transaction costs arguments are often used to justify the introduction of hierarchical controls in collaborations, but the ownership dimension of going from “contracts” to “hierarchies” has been ignored in the past and with it the so called “costs of ownership”. The theoretical results, tested with a sample of collaborations in which participate Spanish firms, indicate that the cost of ownership may offset the benefits of hierarchical controls and therefore limit their diffusion. Evidence is also reported of possible complementarities between reputation effects and forms of ownership that go together with hierarchical controls (i.e. joint ventures), in contrast with the generally assumed substitutability between the two.

Interfirm Knowledge Transfer in Coopetitive Relationships

Tämä tutkimuskeskittyy yritysten väliseen samanaikaiseen kilpailuun ja yhteistyöhön. Suurin mielenkiinto tässä tutkimuksessa kohdistuu yritysten väliseen tietämyksen siirtoon. Tietämyksen siirto samanaikaisissa kilpailu- ja yhteistyösuhteissa voi olla erityisen hyödyllistä samankaltaisten toimintalogiikoiden ja ymmärryksen takia. Toisaalta, mahdollinen kriittisen tiedon vuotaminen kilpailevalle yritykselle onriski, joka täytyy ottaa huomioon, kun yhteistyötä kilpailijan kanssa suunnitellaan. Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena on selvittää, kuinka tietämystä siirretään samanaikaisissa kilpailu- ja yhteistyösuhteissa välttäen kuitenkin tähän liittyvät riskit. Tutkimuksen empiirinen osa sisältää kolme erilaista case-esimerkkiä samanaikaisista kilpailu- ja yhteistyösuhteista. Empiirisessä osassa tehdyt havainnot tukevat pääasiassa teoriaosuudessa käsiteltyjä asioita. Tietämyksen siirron motiivit, suhdekohtaiset tietämyksen omaksumiskyvyt, tietojohtamiskäytännöt ja luottamus ovat tekijöitä, jotka vaikuttavat tietämyksen siirron tehokkuuteen. Pääasialliset keinot tietämyksen siirron riskin välttämiseksi samanaikaisissa kilpailu- ja yhteistyösuhteissa ovat hierarkkisen hallintomuodon käyttäminen tai horisontaalisesti ja vertikaalisesti rajattu yhteistyön laajuus.

Interfirm Information System for Supply Chain Management from the Cloud: An Exploratory Case Study from the Telecom Industry

This study examines the practice of supply chain management problems and the perceived demand information distortion’s (the bullwhip effect) reduction with the interfirm information system, which is delivered as a cloud service to a company operating in the telecommunications industry. The purpose is to shed light in practice that do the interfirm information system have impact on the performance of the supply chain and in particularly the reduction of bullwhip effect. In addition, a holistic case study of the global telecommunications company's supply chain is presented and also the challenges it’s facing, and this study also proposes some measures to improve the situation. The theoretical part consists of the supply chain and its management, as well as increasing the efficiency and introducing the theories and related previous research. In addition, study presents performance metrics for the bullwhip effect detection and tracking. The theoretical part ends in presenting cloud -based business intelligence theoretical framework used in the background of this study. The research strategy is a qualitative case study, supported by quantitative data, which is collected from a telecommunication sector company's databases. Qualitative data were gathered mainly with two open interviews and the e-mail exchange during the development project. In addition, other materials from the company were collected during the project and the company's web site information was also used as the source. The data was collected to a specific case study database in order to increase reliability. The results show that the bullwhip effect can be reduced with the interfirm information system and with the use of CPFR and S&OP models and in particularly combining them to an integrated business planning. According to this study the interfirm information system does not, however, solve all of the supply chain and their effectiveness -related problems, because also the company’s processes and human activities have a major impact.

Cooperative strategy in emerging markets - analysis of interfirm r&d cooperation and performance in Russian manufacturing companies

Emerging markets have come to play a significant role in the world, not only due to their strong economic growth but because they have been able to foster an increasing number of innovative high technology oriented firms. However, as the markets continue to change and develop, there remain many companies in emerging markets that struggle with their competitiveness and innovativeness. To improve competitive capabilities, many scholars have come to favor interfirm cooperation, which is perceived to help companies access new knowledge and complementary resources and, by so doing, enables them to catch up quickly with Western competitors. Regardless of numerous attempts by strategic management scholars, the research field remains very fragmented and lacks understanding on how and when interfirm cooperation contributes to firm performance and competiveness in emerging markets. Furthermore, the reasons why interfirm R&D sometimes succeeds but fails at other times frequently remain unidentified. This thesis combines the extant literature on competitive and cooperative strategy, dynamic capabilities, and R&D cooperation while studying interfirm R&D relationships in and between Russian manufacturing companies. Employing primary survey data, the thesis presents numerous novel findings regarding the effect of R&D cooperation and different types of R&D partner on firms’ exploration and exploitation performance. Utilizing a competitive strategy framework enables these effects to be explained in more detail, and especially why interfirm cooperation, regardless of its potential, has had a modest effect on the general competitiveness of emerging market firms. This thesis contributes especially to the strategic management literature and presents a more holistic perspective on the usefulness of cooperative strategy in emerging markets. It provides a framework through which it is possible to assess the potential impacts of different R&D cooperation partners and to clarify the causal relationships between cooperation, performance, and long term competitiveness.

Relational incentive policies in cross-border interfirm relationships

How an exporter can effectively craft a distributor agreement that encourages its network of foreign distributors to respond in pro-relational ways? This is an important issue as previous research has shown that relationship quality was linked to export performance. However, research failed to propose managerial tools that allowed exporters to foster relational phenomena in cross-border relationships. In this study, we suggest that exporters can influence importers' attitudes and behaviors with relational incentives policies. We also show that the impact of these policies is impervious to the noise, i.e., psychic distance and information asymmetry, that characterizes international business relationships. Our hypotheses are tested via structural equations modeling with data from a sample of French exporters.

Knowledge mediation and overlapping in interfirm networks

Purpose – The literature on interfirm networks devotes scant attention to the ways collaborating firms combine and integrate the knowledge they share and to the subsequent learning outcomes. This study aims to investigate how motorsport companies use network ties to share and recombine knowledge and the learning that occurs both at the organizational and dyadic network levels. Design/methodology/approach – The paper adopts a qualitative and inductive approach with the aim of developing theory from an in-depth examination of the dyadic ties between motorsport companies and the way they share and recombine knowledge. Findings – The research shows that motorsport companies having substantial competences at managing knowledge flows do so by getting advantage of bridging ties. While bridging ties allow motorsport companies to reach distant and diverse sources of knowledge, their strengthening and the formation of relational capital facilitate the mediation and overlapping of that knowledge. Research limitations/implications – The analysis rests on a qualitative account in a single industry and does not take into account different types of inter-firm networks (e.g. alliances; constellations; consortia etc.) and governance structures. Cross-industry analyses may provide a more fine-grained picture of the practices used to recombine knowledge and the ideal composition of inter-firm ties. Practical implications – This study provides some interesting implications for scholars and managers concerned with the management of innovation activities at the interfirm level. From a managerial point of view, the recognition of the different roles played by network spanning connections is particularly salient and raises issues concerning the effective design and management of interfirm ties. Originality/value – Although much of the literature emphasizes the role of bridging ties in connecting to diverse pools of knowledge, this paper goes one step further and investigates in more depth how firms gather and combine distant and heterogeneous sources of knowledge through the use of strengthened bridging ties and a micro-context conducive to high quality relationships.

Industrial district effects and innovation in the Tuscan shipbuilding industry

The aim of the present work is to investigate innovative processes within a geographical cluster, and thus contribute to the debate on the effects of industrial clusters on innovation capacity. In particular, we would like to ascertain whether the advantages of industrial districts in promoting innovation, as already revealed by literature (diffusion of knowledge, social capital and trust, efficient networking), are also keys to success in the Tuscan shipbuilding industry of pleasure and sporting boats. First, we verify the existence of clusters of shipbuilding in Tuscany, using a specific methodology. Next, in the identified clusters, we analyse three innovative networks financed in a policy to support innovation, and examine whether the typical features of a cluster for promoting innovation are at work, using a questionnaire administered to 71 actors. Finally, we develop a performance analysis of the cluster firms and ascertain whether their different behaviours also lead to different performances. The analysis results show that our case records effects of industrial clustering on innovation capacity, such as the important role given to trust and social capital, the significant worth put in interfirm relations and in each partner’s specific competencies, or even the distinctive performance of firms belonging to a cluster.

Networks in Argentine agriculture: a multiple-case study approach

Argentina is among the four largest producers of soybeans, sunflower, corn, and wheat, among other agricultural products. Institutional and policy changes during the 1990s fostered the development of Argentine agriculture and the introduction of innovative process and product technologies (no-till, agrochemicals, GMO, GPS) and new investments in modern, large-scale sunflower and soybean processing plants. In addition to technological changes, a "quiet revolution" occurred in the way agricultural production was carried out and organized: from self-production or ownership agriculture to a contract-based agriculture. The objective of this paper is to explore and describe the emergence of networks in the Argentine crop production sector. The paper presents and describes four cases that currently represent about 50% of total grain and oilseed production in Argentina: "informal hybrid form", "agricultural trust fund", "investor-oriented corporate structure", and "network of networks". In all cases, hybrid forms involve a group of actors linked by common objectives, mainly to gain scale, share resources, and improve the profitability of the business. Informal contracts seem to be the most common way of organizing the agriculture process, but using short-term contracts and sequential interfirm collaboration. Networks of networks involve long-term relationships and social development, and reciprocal interfirm collaboration. Agricultural trust fund and investor-oriented corporate structures have combined interfirm collaboration and medium-term relationships. These organizational forms are highly flexible and show a great capacity to adapt to challenges; they are competitive because they enjoy aligned incentives, flexibility, and adaptability.

Multimarket contact externalities: the effect of rival's multimarket contacts on focal firm performance

Given that firms develop their activities in a network of multiple players, interfirm rivalry is not only a matter of direct competitors, but also of indirect competition. In spite of this, the literature on competitive dynamics tends to focus on analyzing rivalry as an exclusive function of the competitive relationship between a focal firm and its direct rivals. In this article, we extend competitive dynamics literature by considering how focal firms are affected by the relationships of their rivals with third-party firms. Specifically, we study the effect that the multimarket contacts of rivals produces on the performance of the focal firm. Additionally, we incorporate the idea that there are different strategic options for operating in an industry that affect the intensity of multimarket contact externalities. Our results show that multimarket contact among firms causes externalities that indirectly affect firms that are not directly involved in this competitive relationship. We find that multimarket contact externalities differ between and within strategic groups.

Firm's network capability and innovation performance: evidences from China hi-tech industry

ABSTRACT : A firm's competitive advantage can arise from internal resources as well as from an interfirm network. -This dissertation investigates the competitive advantage of a firm involved in an innovation network by integrating strategic management theory and social network theory. It develops theory and provides empirical evidence that illustrates how a networked firm enables the network value and appropriates this value in an optimal way according to its strategic purpose. The four inter-related essays in this dissertation provide a framework that sheds light on the extraction of value from an innovation network by managing and designing the network in a proactive manner. The first essay reviews research in social network theory and knowledge transfer management, and identifies the crucial factors of innovation network configuration for a firm's learning performance or innovation output. The findings suggest that network structure, network relationship, and network position all impact on a firm's performance. Although the previous literature indicates that there are disagreements about the impact of dense or spare structure, as well as strong or weak ties, case evidence from Chinese software companies reveals that dense and strong connections with partners are positively associated with firms' performance. The second essay is a theoretical essay that illustrates the limitations of social network theory for explaining the source of network value and offers a new theoretical model that applies resource-based view to network environments. It suggests that network configurations, such as network structure, network relationship and network position, can be considered important network resources. In addition, this essay introduces the concept of network capability, and suggests that four types of network capabilities play an important role in unlocking the potential value of network resources and determining the distribution of network rents between partners. This essay also highlights the contingent effects of network capability on a firm's innovation output, and explains how the different impacts of network capability depend on a firm's strategic choices. This new theoretical model has been pre-tested with a case study of China software industry, which enhances the internal validity of this theory. The third essay addresses the questions of what impact network capability has on firm innovation performance and what are the antecedent factors of network capability. This essay employs a structural equation modelling methodology that uses a sample of 211 Chinese Hi-tech firms. It develops a measurement of network capability and reveals that networked firms deal with cooperation between, and coordination with partners on different levels according to their levels of network capability. The empirical results also suggests that IT maturity, the openness of culture, management system involved, and experience with network activities are antecedents of network capabilities. Furthermore, the two-group analysis of the role of international partner(s) shows that when there is a culture and norm gap between foreign partners, a firm must mobilize more resources and effort to improve its performance with respect to its innovation network. The fourth essay addresses the way in which network capabilities influence firm innovation performance. By using hierarchical multiple regression with data from Chinese Hi-tech firms, the findings suggest that there is a significant partial mediating effect of knowledge transfer on the relationships between network capabilities and innovation performance. The findings also reveal that the impacts of network capabilities divert with the environment and strategic decision the firm has made: exploration or exploitation. Network constructing capability provides a greater positive impact on and yields more contributions to innovation performance than does network operating capability in an exploration network. Network operating capability is more important than network constructing capability for innovative firms in an exploitation network. Therefore, these findings highlight that the firm can shape the innovation network proactively for better benefits, but when it does so, it should adjust its focus and change its efforts in accordance with its innovation purposes or strategic orientation.

Dynamic Capabilities and Firm Performance

Firms operating in a changing environment have a need for structures and practices that provide flexibility and enable rapid response to changes. Given the challenges they face in attempts to keep up with market needs, they have to continuously improve their processes and products, and develop new products to match market requirements. Success in changing markets depends on the firm's ability to convert knowledge into innovations, and consequently their internal structures and capabilities have an important role in innovation activities. According 10 the dynamic capability view of the firm, firms thus need dynamic capabilities in (he form ofassets, processes and structures that enable strategic flexibility and support entrepreneurial opportunity sensing and exploitation. Dynamic capabilities are also needed in conditions of rapid change in the operating environment, and in activities such as new product development and expansion to new markets. Despite the growing interest in these issues and the theoretical developments in the field of strategy research, there are still only very few empirical studies, and large-scale empirical studies in particular, that provide evidence that firms'dynamic capabilities are reflected in performance differences. This thesis represents an attempt to advance the research by providing empirical evidence of thelinkages between the firm's dynamic capabilities and performance in intenationalization and innovation activities. The aim is thus to increase knowledge and enhance understanding of the organizational factors that explain interfirm performance differences. The study is in two parts. The first part is the introduction and the second part comprises five research publications covering the theoretical foundations of the dynamic capability view and subsequent empirical analyses. Quantitative research methodology is used throughout. The thesis contributes to the literature in several ways. While a lot of prior research on dynamic capabilities is conceptual in nature, or conducted through case studies, this thesis introduces empirical measures for assessing the different aspects, and uses large-scale sampling to investigate the relationships between them and performance indicators. The dynamic capability view is further developed by integrating theoretical frameworks and research traditions from several disciplines. The results of the study provide support for the basic tenets of the dynamic capability view. The empirical findings demonstrate that the firm's ability to renew its knowledge base and other intangible assets, its proactive, entrepreneurial behavior, and the structures and practices that support operational flexibility arepositively related to performance indicators.

Kilpailukyvyn kehittäminen yritystenvälisen yhteistyön avulla. Case: Etelä-Karjalan metsäteollisuus ja pk-sektori

Tutkimuksen tarkastelukohteena oli yritystenvälinen yhteistyö ja yritysten kilpailukyvyn kehittäminen Etelä-Karjalan maakunnassa tämän yhteistyön avulla. Tutkimuksessa hyödynnettiin konstruktiivista ja käsiteanalyyttista tutkimusotetta. Päätavoitteena oli selvittää kuinka Etelä-Karjalassa toimivan suuren metsäteollisuuden alihankintojen paikallisuusastetta voitaisiin lisätä tulevaisuudessa. Keskeisinä alatavoitteina tutkimuksessa oli selvittää alueen suuren metsäteollisuuden merkitystä alueen muille toimialoille sekä tutkia mitä yritystenvälisiä yhteistyömuotoja on käytössä tällä hetkellä Etelä-Karjalan maakunnassa. Tutkielma jakaantui teoreettiseen ja empiiriseen osaan. Teoriaosassa muodostettiin viitekehys yritystenvälisen yhteistyön ymmärtämiseksi ja erilaisten yritystenvälisten yhteistyömuotojen jaottelemiseksi. Työn empiirisessä osassa tätä viitekehystä hyödynnettiin kysely- ja haastattelututkimuksen pohjana. Tutkimustulosten joukossa korostui yritystenvälisen yhteistyön merkitys alueen suuryritysten alihankintojen paikallisuusasteen lisäämisessä. Lisäksi yritystenvälisen yhteistyön nähtiin lisäävän yritysten kilpailukykyä varsin laaja-alaisesti tutkimuspopulaation joukossa. Erityisen hyödyllisiksi yritykset näkivät yhteistyömuodot, joissa toiminta perustui pitkäjänteisyyteen ja yhteisen hyödyn tavoitteluun.

Teollisen alihankintayhteistyön kehittäminen

Tutkimuksen tavoitteena on ollut selvittää millaisia ongelmia teollisessa alihankintayhteistyössä toimivat yritykset kohtaavat suhteen kehittyessä kohti kumppanuutta. Keskeisinä teemoina tutkimuksessa ovat olleet alihankinnan toimintamallien kartoitus, hyötyjen ja haittojen käsittely ostajan ja toimittajan näkökulmista, sekä yritystenvälisen rutiinitiedonkulun tehostamiseen liittyvät asiat. Tutkimus on koostettu teoreettisesta ja empiirisestä osasta. Teoriaosuus muodostaa aiheeseen liittyvästä kirjallisuudesta viitekehyksen, johon empiiristä osaa on peilattu. Empiirisen osuuden lähdeaineisto on hankittu haastatteluilla kahdessa case-yrityksessä, sisäisillä dokumenteilla ja havainnoinnilla. Aineistoa käsitellään laadullisen tutkimuksen keinoin. Tutkimustuloksista selvisi, että pienen ja suuren yrityksen kumppanuussuhteen luominen vaatii paljon aikaa ja ponnisteluja. Muutos kohti kumppanuutta voi tapahtua vain askel kerrallaan. Myös perustoiminnan tulee olla kunnossa, ennen kuin tiiviimpää yhteistyötä voi syntyä. Rutiinitiedonkulku tiiviissä teollisessa yhteistyössä on tehokkainta hoitaa integroiduilla sähköisillä tietojärjestelmillä.

Comovement of stock price risk in strategic alliance — Case: mobile internet

The focus of this study has been comovement of stock price risk level between two companies as they form strategic alliance. Thus the main reason has been to shed more light to possible increased risk level that the stockholder confronts when a company he owns forms a strategic alliance with another company. This study has centralized to interfirm cooperation between mobile and internet companies, which have furthered the development of mobile internet. The study has been divided into theoretical and empirical part. In theoretical part the main concepts riskiness of a stock (volatility), comovement and strategic alliance have been run through. In empirical part seven strategic alliances formed by mobile internet companies have been examined. Based on this, strategic alliance seems to increase comovement of stock price risk in some degree. This comovement seems to be stronger when core businesses or operating environments of cooperating companies differ more from each other.

Yritysyhteistyön muodot

Tässä työssä kuvataan erilaisia yritysyhteistyön muotoja. Työn tavoitteena on saada kokonaiskuva yhteistyöstä yleisesti ja yhteistyömuodoista. Lähtökohtana on yhteistyön määritelmä ja yhteistyön peruselementit. Yhteistyömuotoja voidaan luokitella monesta eri näkökulmasta. Tässä työssä yritysyhteistyön muodot jaetaan kahdenväliseen ja monenkeskiseen yhteistyöhön. Yhteistyömuodoista esitellään seitsemän muotoa, joiden ominaispiirteitä kuvataan. Lisäksi kiinnitetään huomiota yhteistyömuotojen eroavaisuuksiin. Työssä käydään läpi myös yhteistyön hyötyjä ja haittoja. Ei ole olemassa täydellistä yhteistyömuotoa, joka sopisi kaikille yrityksille. Eri yhteistyömuodot soveltuvat erilaisiin tilanteisiin ja yritys voi käyttää useampaa yhteistyömuotoa yhtäaikaisesti. Yhteistyömuodot poikkeavat toisistaan esimerkiksi kestoltaan ja sitoutumisen osalta.