Modelagem paramétrica de curvas de crédito no mercado brasileiro

Após a crise financeira de 2008, é perceptível a intensificação de esforços globais para aperfeiçoar métodos de avaliação de risco e ajuste de exposição de capital para tornar o sistema financeiro mundial mais sólido e consistente. O objetivo deste trabalho é propor um modelo de estimação de curvas de crédito privado no Brasil, aplicando a modelagem paramétrica de Nelson & Siegel (1987) a uma amostra de preços de debêntures. Os resultados obtidos poderão ser utilizados para auxiliar reguladores e profissionais de mercado com análises de risco, apreçamento de ativos ilíquidos e percepção de expectativas.

Determinants of credit default swap spread: evidence from european credit derivatives market

Tämän tutkielman tavoitteena on selvittää, mitkä tekijät vaikuttavat yrityksen ja valtion velkakirjojen väliseen tuottoeroon. Strukturaalisten luottoriskin hinnoittelumallien mukaan luottoriskiin vaikuttavia tekijöitä ovat yrityksen velkaantumisaste, volatiliteetti ja riskitön korkokanta. Tavoitteena on erityisesti tutkia, kuinka hyvin nämä teoreettiset tekijät selittävät tuottoeroja ja onko olemassa muita tärkeitä selittäviä tekijöitä. Luottoriskinvaihtosopimusten noteerauksia käytetään tuottoerojen määrittämiseen. Selittävät tekijät koostuvat sekä yrityskohtaisista että markkinalaajuisista muuttujista. Luottoriskinvaihtosopimusten ja yrityskohtaisten muuttujien data on kerätty yhteensä 50 yritykselle Euroalueen maista. Aineisto koostuu kuukausittaisista havainnoista aikaväliltä 01.01.2003-31.12.2006. Empiiriset tulokset osoittavat, että strukturaalisten mallien mukaiset tekijät selittävät vain pienen osan tuottoeron muutoksista yli ajan. Toisaalta nämä teoreettiset tekijät selittävät huomattavasti paremmin tuottoeron vaihtelua yli poikkileikkauksen. Muut kuin teoreettiset tekijät pystyvät selittämään suuren osan tuottoeron vaihtelusta. Erityisen tärkeäksi tuottoeron selittäväksi tekijäksi osoittautui yleinen riskipreemio velkakirjamarkkinoilla. Tulokset osoittavat, että luottoriskin hinnoittelumalleja on kehitettävä edelleenniin, että ne ottaisivat huomioon yrityskohtaisten tekijöiden lisäksi myös markkinalaajuisia tekijöitä.

Determinants of credit default swap spread, the effect of the financial crisis in the us markets

The purpose of this study is to define what determinants affect the Credit spread. There are two theoretical frameworks to study this: structural models and reduced form models. Structural models indicate that the main determinants are company leverage, volatility and risk-free interest rate, and other market and firm-specific variables. The purpose is to determine which of these theoretical determinants can explain the CDS spread and also how these theoretical determinants are affected by the financial crisis in 2007. The data is collected from 30 companies in the US Markets, mainly S&P Large Cap. The sample time-frame is 31.1.2004 – 31.12.2009. Empirical studies indicate that structural models can explain the CDS spreads well. Also, there were significant differences between bear and bull markets. The main determinants explaining CDS spreads were leverage and volatility. The other determinants were significant, depending on the sample period. However, these other variables did not explain the spread consistently.

Valoración de credit default swaps: una aplicación del modelo de Hull-White al mercado español

En este trabajo se presenta una aplicación empírica del modelo de Hull-White (2000) al mercado de renta fija español. Este modelo proporciona la expresión por el cálculo de los pagos hechos por el comprador de un credit default swap (CDS), bajo la hipótesis de que no existe riesgo de contrapartida. Se supone, además, que la curva cupón cero, la tasa de recuperación constante y el momento del suceso de crédito son independientes. Se utilizan bonos del Banco Santander Central Hispano para mesurar la probabilidad neutra al riesgo de quiebra y, bajo hipótesis de no arbitraje, se calculan las primas de un CDS, por un bono subyacente con la misma calificación crediticia que la entidad de referencia. Se observa que las primas se ajustan bien a los spreads crediticios del mercado, que se acostumbran a utilizar como alternativa a las mismas.

Valoración de credit default swaps: una aplicación del modelo de Hull-White al mercado español

En este trabajo se presenta una aplicación empírica del modelo de Hull-White (2000) al mercado de renta fija español. Este modelo proporciona la expresión por el cálculo de los pagos hechos por el comprador de un credit default swap (CDS), bajo la hipótesis de que no existe riesgo de contrapartida. Se supone, además, que la curva cupón cero, la tasa de recuperación constante y el momento del suceso de crédito son independientes. Se utilizan bonos del Banco Santander Central Hispano para mesurar la probabilidad neutra al riesgo de quiebra y, bajo hipótesis de no arbitraje, se calculan las primas de un CDS, por un bono subyacente con la misma calificación crediticia que la entidad de referencia. Se observa que las primas se ajustan bien a los spreads crediticios del mercado, que se acostumbran a utilizar como alternativa a las mismas.

The impact of liquidity on senior credit index spreads during the subprime crisis

This paper examines the effects of liquidity during the 2007–09 crisis, focussing on the Senior Tranche of the CDX.NA.IG Index and on Moody's AAA Corporate Bond Index. It aims to understand whether the sharp increase in the credit spreads of these AAA-rated credit indices can be explained by worse credit fundamentals alone or whether it also reflects a lack of depth in the relevant markets, the scarcity of risk-capital, and the liquidity preference exhibited by investors. Using cointegration analysis and error correction models, the paper shows that during the crisis lower market and funding liquidity are important drivers of the increase in the credit spread of the AAA-rated structured product, whilst they are less significant in explaining credit spread changes for a portfolio of unstructured credit instruments. Looking at the experience of the subprime crisis, the study shows that when the conditions under which securitisation can work properly (liquidity, transparency and tradability) suddenly disappear, investors are left highly exposed to systemic risk.

Sticky credit spreads, macroeconomic activity and equity market volatility

We uncover high persistence in credit spread series that can obscure the relationship between the theoretical determinants of credit risk and observed credit spreads. We use a Markovswitching model, which also captures the stability (low frequency changes) of credit ratings, to show why credit spreads may continue to respond to past levels of credit risk, even though the state of the economy has changed. A bivariate model of credit spreads and either macroeconomic activity or equity market volatility detects large and significant correlations that are consistent with theory but have not been observed in previous studies. © 2010 Nova Science Publishers, Inc. All rights reserved.

Credit risk & forward price models

Doutoramento em Gestão

Determinantes del spread financiero del sector cooperativo de ahorro y crédito ecuatoriano

Esta investigación analiza los determinantes del spread financiero del sector cooperativo de ahorro y crédito ecuatoriano. La base teórica corresponde al modelo expuesto por Ho y Saunders (1981). Se construyeron variables micro y macroeconómicas para recoger los efectos que estas tienen sobre el margen de intermediación financiera. Se empleó un panel de datos mensuales para el periodo 2007-2014. Las estimaciones fueron realizadas mediante la metodología de errores estándar corregidos para datos de panel. Los resultados explican que el spread financiero del sector cooperativo depende particularmente de los niveles de morosidad, la eficiencia en sus gastos operacionales y el grado de endeudamiento público externo de la economía. Además, la concentración de mercado, los niveles de liquidez y la incertidumbre en los mercados internacionales inciden levemente en la determinación del spread.

Credit spreads and monetary policy in a small open economy: an analysis of the colombian economy

This paper estimates Bejarano and Charry (2014)’s small open economy with financial frictions model for the Colombian economy using Bayesian estimation techniques. Additionally, I compute the welfare gains of implementing an optimal response to credit spreads into an augmented Taylor rule. The main result is that a reaction to credit spreads does not imply significant welfare gains unless the economic disturbances increases its volatility, like the disruption implied by a financial crisis. Otherwise its impact over the macroeconomic variables is null.

O crédito concedido às empresas: antes e no decorrer da crise mundial. Análise e gestão do risco de crédito

O tema do trabalho de investigação é a análise do risco de crédito às empresas antes e durante a actual crise financeira, bem como a sua gestão. A gestão de risco de crédito das instituições financeiras tem-se transformado cada vez mais numa peça chave para toda a actividade bancária, tendo ainda mais significado no mundo actual, em constante mudança e globalização. A concessão de crédito às empresas tornou-se numa tarefa cada vez mais árdua, para as instituições financeiras devido ao risco de crédito. A presente dissertação foi desenvolvida visando os objectivos de efectuar uma avaliação na concessão de crédito a empresas durante a crise, com ênfase na gestão do risco de crédito, bem como na utilização do Acordo de Basileia II. Para atingir os objectivos traçados a metodologia utilizada foi o inquérito por questionário a colaboradores da Caixa Geral de Depósitos (CGD). O questionário foi efectuado, de forma a captar quer os desenvolvimentos passados, como recentes, bem como a evolução esperada. Relativamente à evolução passada, as perguntas respeitam aos anos anteriores à crise, enquanto as perguntas prospectivas se referem aos anos seguintes. O trabalho desenvolvido permitiu-nos concluir que as instituições financeiras mundiais, desde o início da recessão, têm restringido ao máximo a concessão de crédito às empresas. Muitas instituições têm-no feito através da exigência de mais garantias, aumento do spread, bem como a diminuição de maturidades. Todas estas situações geram um ciclo vicioso, na medida em que as empresas que se vêem confrontadas na restrição do acesso ao crédito, não têm condições para sobreviver, gerando assim várias falências.

Market risk charge of the trading book: a comparison of the Basel II and Basel III

This paper aims to investigate if the market capital charge of the trading book increased in Basel III compared to Basel II. I showed that the capital charge rises by 232% and 182% under the standardized and internal model, respectively. The varying liquidity horizons, the calibration to a stress period, the introduction of credit spread risk, the restrictions on correlations across risk categories and the incremental default charge boost Basel III requirements. Nevertheless, the impact of Expected shortfall at 97.5% is low and long term shocks decrease the charge. The standardized approach presents advantages and disadvantages relative to internal models.

Three essays in international finance

Executive Summary The first essay of this dissertation investigates whether greater exchange rate uncertainty (i.e., variation over time in the exchange rate) fosters or depresses the foreign investment of multinational firms. In addition to the direct capital financing it supplies, foreign investment can be a source of valuable technology and know-how, which can have substantial positive effects on a host country's economic growth. Thus, it is critically important for policy makers and central bankers, among others, to understand how multinationals base their investment decisions on the characteristics of foreign exchange markets. In this essay, I first develop a theoretical framework to improve our knowledge regarding how the aggregate level of foreign investment responds to exchange rate uncertainty when an economy consists of many firms, each of which is making decisions. The analysis predicts a U-shaped effect of exchange rate uncertainty on the total level of foreign investment of the economy. That is, the effect is negative for low levels of uncertainty and positive for higher levels of uncertainty. This pattern emerges because the relationship between exchange rate volatility and 'the probability of investment is negative for firms with low productivity at home (i.e., firms that find it profitable to invest abroad) and the relationship is positive for firms with high productivity at home (i.e., firms that prefer exporting their product). This finding stands in sharp contrast to predictions in the existing literature that consider a single firm's decision to invest in a unique project. The main contribution of this research is to show that the aggregation over many firms produces a U-shaped pattern between exchange rate uncertainty and the probability of investment. Using data from industrialized countries for the period of 1982-2002, this essay offers a comprehensive empirical analysis that provides evidence in support of the theoretical prediction. In the second essay, I aim to explain the time variation in sovereign credit risk, which captures the risk that a government may be unable to repay its debt. The importance of correctly evaluating such a risk is illustrated by the central role of sovereign debt in previous international lending crises. In addition, sovereign debt is the largest asset class in emerging markets. In this essay, I provide a pricing formula for the evaluation of sovereign credit risk in which the decision to default on sovereign debt is made by the government. The pricing formula explains the variation across time in daily credit spreads - a widely used measure of credit risk - to a degree not offered by existing theoretical and empirical models. I use information on a country's stock market to compute the prevailing sovereign credit spread in that country. The pricing formula explains a substantial fraction of the time variation in daily credit spread changes for Brazil, Mexico, Peru, and Russia for the 1998-2008 period, particularly during the recent subprime crisis. I also show that when a government incentive to default is allowed to depend on current economic conditions, one can best explain the level of credit spreads, especially during the recent period of financial distress. In the third essay, I show that the risk of sovereign default abroad can produce adverse consequences for the U.S. equity market through a decrease in returns and an increase in volatility. The risk of sovereign default, which is no longer limited to emerging economies, has recently become a major concern for financial markets. While sovereign debt plays an increasing role in today's financial environment, the effects of sovereign credit risk on the U.S. financial markets have been largely ignored in the literature. In this essay, I develop a theoretical framework that explores how the risk of sovereign default abroad helps explain the level and the volatility of U.S. equity returns. The intuition for this effect is that negative economic shocks deteriorate the fiscal situation of foreign governments, thereby increasing the risk of a sovereign default that would trigger a local contraction in economic growth. The increased risk of an economic slowdown abroad amplifies the direct effect of these shocks on the level and the volatility of equity returns in the U.S. through two channels. The first channel involves a decrease in the future earnings of U.S. exporters resulting from unfavorable adjustments to the exchange rate. The second channel involves investors' incentives to rebalance their portfolios toward safer assets, which depresses U.S. equity prices. An empirical estimation of the model with monthly data for the 1994-2008 period provides evidence that the risk of sovereign default abroad generates a strong leverage effect during economic downturns, which helps to substantially explain the level and the volatility of U.S. equity returns.

Time varying price discovery

We show how multivariate GARCH models can be used to generate a time-varying “information share” (Hasbrouck, 1995) to represent the changing patterns of price discovery in closely related securities. We find that time-varying information shares can improve credit spread predictions.

Kreditderivate

Als Grundtypen von Kreditderivaten gelten der Credit Default Swap (CDS), der Total Return Swap (TRS) sowie die Credit Spread Option (CSO). Diese drei Kreditderivate können Kreditrisiken auf andere Vertragsparteien übertragen. Sie unterscheiden sich untereinander in der Art der Anknüpfung an das zu übertragende Kreditrisiko. Das Kreditrisiko ist nun ein dem Vertragsrecht unbekannter Gegenstand, und seine Übertragung ein unbekannter Vorgang. Die vertragsrechtliche Erfassung des Kreditrisikos hat unter Rückbesinnung auf vertragsrechtliche Grundsätze zu erfolgen. Das Kreditrisiko als Gegenstand von Kreditderivaten definiert sich im vertragli-chen Rahmen einzig durch eine entsprechende Strukturierungen von Zahlungsströmen. Diese sind dann auch als die einzigen Leistungspflichten aufzufassen. Der Risikotransfer ist nur Vertragszweck, welcher im Rahmen der Auslegung beachtlich wird und nach der vorliegenden Ansicht auch bei der Qualifikation als Dauerschuldverhältnis hinzugezogen werden soll. Aufsichtsrechtlich erfasst werden Kreditderivate im Rahmen ihres Einsatzes durch bereits einer Aufsicht unterstellte Unternehmen oder durch die Anlagevehikel der kollektiven Kapitalanlage.