Reframing Public Inquiries as 'Procedural Justice' for Victims of Institutional Child Abuse: Towards a Hybrid Model of Justice

As the number of high profile cases of institutional child abuse mounts internationally, and the demands of victims for justice are heard, state responses have ranged from prosecution, apology, and compensation schemes, to truth commissions or public inquiries. Drawing on the examples of Australia and Northern Ireland as two jurisdictions with a recent and ongoing history of statutory inquiries into institutional child abuse, the article utilises the restorative justice paradigm to critically evaluate the strengths and limitations of the inquiry framework in providing ‘justice’ for victims. It critically explores the normative and pragmatic implications of a hybrid model as a more effective route to procedural justice and suggests that an appropriately designed restorative pathway may augment the legitimacy and utility of the public inquiry model for victims chiefly via improving offender accountability and ‘voice’ for victims. The article concludes by offering some thoughts on the broader implications for other jurisdictions in responding to large-scale historical abuses and seeking to come to terms with the legacy of institutional child abuse.

Cognitive-behavioral group therapy for girls victims of sexual violence in Brazil: Are there differences in effectiveness when applied by different groups of psychologists?: effectiveness of group therapy for girls victims of sexual violence

The effectiveness of a cognitive-behavioral group therapy model for the treatment of girls victims of sexual violence (SV) was investigated when applied by different groups of practitioners: researchers/psychologists who developed it (G1) and psychologists from the public social care network trained by the first group (G2). A quasi-experimental study was carried out, in which the group therapy model was applied by the two groups. A total of 103 girls victims of sexual violence (SV), aged between seven and 16 years (M=11.76 years, SD=2.02 years) were included, with 49 attended by G1, and 54 by G2. The results indicated a significant reduction in the symptoms of depression, anxiety, stress, and PTSD. The comparison between the results obtained by the two groups of practitioners in the application of the model indicated no significant differences in the rates of improvement of the participants. These results indicate the effectiveness of the cognitive-behavioral group therapy model evaluated and the possibility of it being used as a care strategy by psychology practitioners working in public services.

Life quality and the wellness of victims of domestic violence. study case of the Centro Social, Recreativo e Cultural de Vilar de Maçada

This research aims to present an analysis on the absence of social responses that address the problem of domestic violence in Alijó. Our main goal is not only a theoretical approach about the issue of domestic violence, regional conditions in relation to domestic violence, but also present a study on the potentialities of Centro Social Recreativo e Cultural de Vilar de Maçada, our case study, can apply for funding of an emergency housing for victims of domestic violence. This paper is divided into three parts: theoretical framework and characterization of our social organization, according to an exploratory research, structuring a strategic plan of the organization, through field research, and as final result, to present a proposal for funding and implementation of an innovative social response, according to the underlying legislation to Portugal 2020. The sample is focused on the population of Alijó municipality. To conclude, it is important to make this local approach, because of the increasing number of cases not detected and reported. Thus, the quality of life is increased, reducing the incidence of violence in the family.

The Rule of Thumb: A Five Year Overview of Domestic Violence in South Carolina

This Powerpoint presentation gives a five year statistical overview of domestic violence in South Carolina. It covers the years 2004 through 2008.

Who makes the news : Australia : global media monitoring project 2010 national report

The Australian report for the Global Media Monitoring Project 2010 (GMMP 2010) involved a study of 374 stories that were sampled from 26 Australian newspapers, radio and television stations, and internet news services on 10 November 2009. This snapshot of reporting on that day suggests that women are under-represented in the Australian news media as both the sources and creators of news. Females made up only 24% of the 1012 news sources who were heard, read about or seen in the stories that were studied. Neglect of female sources was particularly noticeable in sports news. Women made up only 1% of the 142 sources who were talked about or quoted in sports stories. Female sources of news were disproportionately portrayed as celebrities and victims. Although women made up only 24% of sources overall, they comprised 44% of victims of crimes, accidents, war, health problems, or discrimination. Unsurprisingly, women made up 32% of sources in stories about violent crimes and 29% in stories about disasters, accidents or emergencies – usually in the role of victim. Females were commonly defined in terms of their status as a mother, daughter, wife, sister or other family relationship. Family status was mentioned for 33% of women quoted or discussed in the news stories compared to only 13% of male sources. Women also made up 75% of sources described as homemakers or parents. The Australian GMMP 2010 study also indicates a gender division among the journalists who wrote or presented the news. Only 32% of the stories were written or presented by female reporters and newsreaders. The gender inequality was again most evident in sports journalism. Findings from the Australian report also contributed to the GMMP 2010 Global Report and the Pacific GMMP 2010 Regional Report, which are available at http://whomakesthenews.org/gmmp/gmmp-reports/gmmp-2010-reports

Produção de provas judiciais: verdade e poder nas histórias de crianças abusadas sexualmente

O presente estudo analisa a produção de discursos em torno da idéia de criança abusada sexualmente, analisando mais especificamente os discursos engendrados a partir da circulação dessas crianças ao longo do Sistema de Garantia de Direitos da Criança e do Adolescente. Nesse sentido, as pesquisas de Foucault são tomadas como referência, em sua proposta de realizar o empreendimento de uma história da verdade. Dessa forma, são estudados 9 (nove) processos de uma Vara Criminal da Comarca do Rio de Janeiro, onde crianças figuram como vítimas de crimes qualificados nos art. 213 e 214 (CP), especialmente os documentos nos quais ficam registrados os exames e as inquirições das crianças. Na análise de tais documentos, também são consideradas as discussões estabelecidas pelos historiadores acerca da utilização das fontes orais como ferramenta na produção histórica. Ao término das pesquisas, por um lado, as situações caracterizadas como abuso sexual intrafamiliar aparecem mais fortemente investidas de procedimentos judiciais, tendo produzido mais documentos com a fala das crianças e de outros atores, que falam sobre as crianças. Por outro lado, as crianças envolvidas em situação caracterizada como abuso extrafamiliar são submetidas somente aos procedimentos exigidos pela lei penal, apontando para a capacidade de elementos discursivos, constituintes do abuso sexual infantil, estarem produzindo uma nova figura de criminoso dentro da família: o pedófilo que abusa de seus próprios filhos.

Víctimas de violencia contra la pareja. Desmontando y matizando los mitos más relevantes

[ES]El presente trabajo trata sobre los mitos existentes en materia de violencia en la pareja. Se ha llevado a cabo la identificación, análisis y contrastación de los mismos para poder establecer el nivel de realidad que reflejan. De este modo se pretende evitar la estigmatización a las víctimas con falsos estereotipos por parte tanto de la sociedad, como de las instituciones públicas, que dificultan la superación del trauma. Para ello se ha realizado una revisión bibliográfica en profundidad sobre diversas disciplinas relacionadas con la problemática, así como un estudio exploratorio, no representativo, en el que seis víctimas de delitos de violencia dentro de la pareja han contestado un cuestionario. Por medio de estos cuestionarios se ha tratado de poner voz a las víctimas en el análisis de su propio conflicto. Posteriormente se han propuesto diversas medidas a tener en cuenta a la hora de redactar políticas victimales sobre violencia dentro de la pareja, enfocadas sobre todo a la prevención.

Atención integral a víctimas de delitos. Las oficinas de asistencia a víctimas de delitos (OAVD)

[ES]Este proyecto trata de revisar las diferentes Oficinas de Asistencia a las Víctimas de Delitos (OAVD) de algunas Comunidades Autónomas, desde la situación en la que se encuentran las personas víctimas de delitos que acuden a estos centros, hasta la manera de proceder de los mismos en relación a su labor (asistencia, orientación, protección, ayuda, etc. a éstas); así como de delimitar las funciones que realizan con el fin de subrayar la necesidad de un modelo de atención integral a víctimas de delitos, entendido en un sentido amplio, complejo y diverso

Empowerment et système de justice pénale : l'expérience des victimes d'actes criminels

Thèse numérisée par la Division de la gestion de documents et des archives de l'Université de Montréal

L'influence thérapeutique de la perception de justice informationnelle et interpersonnelle sur les symptômes de stress post-traumatique des victimes d'actes criminels

À la suite d’un crime, les victimes vont ressentir différents besoins et celui d’être informé serait fondamental (Baril, 1984). Les recherches ont permis d’établir que les policiers ont un rôle important à jouer dans la transmission des informations aux victimes puisqu’ils sont les premiers acteurs du système pénal avec lesquels celles-ci sont en contact (Laxminarayan, 2013). De plus, la perception des victimes quant à la façon dont elles ont été traitées par les policiers peut avoir un impact significatif sur leur rétablissement psychologique. Cette étude a pour but de mesurer l’effet thérapeutique des interactions entre les victimes et les policiers ainsi que de la transmission des informations aux victimes à la suite d’un crime sur l’état de stress post-traumatique (ÉSPT). Pour ce faire, l’instrument qui a été administré aux participants (n=188) est l’Échelle modifiée des symptômes du trouble de stress post-traumatique. Cet instrument est une version adaptée et validée en français (Guay, Marchand, Iucci et Martin, 2002) de l’échelle MPSS-SR élaborée par Falsetti, Resnick, Resick et Kilpatrick (1993). Cette échelle permet d’évaluer la présence des symptômes de stress post-traumatique en terme de fréquence et de sévérité. Les résultats de l’étude montrent que l’information est un déterminant important d’un traitement juste et la qualité de ce traitement à un effet thérapeutique sur les symptômes de stress post-traumatique. Une discussion des résultats dans une perspective plus globale concernant les théories en victimologie sur la perception de justice, la problématique de la victimisation secondaire et les implications pour les politiques en matière de droits des victimes sera présentée à la fin de cette recherche.

Práticas e representações sobre os comportamentos femininos. Processos-crime de sedução e rapto (Assis/SP – 1950/1969)

O presente artigo discute as questões relacionadas às práticas das jovens das classes populares envolvidas nos crimes de sedução e rapto, delitos contra os costumes sociais, ocorridos na cidade de Assis nos anos de 1950 a 1969, bem como as representações lançadas pelos membros do Poder Judiciário sobre tais comportamentos. A maioria das vítimas destes delitos estava diretamente envolvida no mercado de trabalho e possuía um menor monitoramento de suas práticas sociais. Diante disto, os membros do Poder Judiciário, os quais preservavam as representações tradicionais sobre o feminino, repreendiam estes comportamentos e os consideravam desviantes da moral e dos bons costumes. Pertencentes a um grupo social específico, essas jovens foram vítimas não apenas dos crimes contra os costumes, mas também da discriminação de uma sociedade machista e conservadora.

The Hispanic victim.

Mode of access: Internet.

Victim compensation and offender restitution : a selected bibliography /

Mode of access: Internet.

Stalking in America : findings from the National Violence Against Women Survey /

"April 1998."

Criminal victimization surveys in 13 American cities : national crime panel surveys in Boston, Buffalo, Cincinnati, Houston, Miami, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, New Orleans, Oakland, Pittsburgh, San Diego, San Francisco, and Washington, D.C..

Mode of access: Internet.