Mourning becomes Electra d'Eugene O'Neill: Èsquil i Plató per a crear un drama fosc?

The fundamental debt of E. O'Neill's Mourning Becomes Electra to Aeschylus, and to a lesser degree to Sophocles and Euripides, has been always recognised but, according to the author's hypothesis, O'Neill might have taken advantage of the Platonic image of the cave in order to magnify his both Greek and American drama. It is certainly a risky hypothesis that stricto sensu cannot be proved, but it is also reader's right to evaluate the plausibility and the possible dramatic benefit derived from such a reading. Besides indicating to what degree some of the essential themes of Platonic philosophy concerning darkness, light or the flight from the prison of the material world are not extraneous to O'Neill's work, the author proves he was aware of the Platonic image of the cave thanks to its capital importance in the work of some of his intellectual mentors such as F. Nietzsche or Oscar Wilde. Nevertheless, the most significant aim of the author's article is to emphasize both the dramatic benefits and the logical reflections derived, as said before, from reading little by little O'Neill's drama bearing in mind the above mentioned Platonic parameter.

Mourning becomes Electra de Eugene O'Neill: ¿Esquilo y la caverna de Platón para crear un drama oscuro?

The fundamental debt of E. O'Neill's Mourning Becomes Electra to Aeschylus, and to a lesser degree to Sophocles and Euripides, has been always recognised but, according to the author's hypothesis, O'Neill might have taken advantage of the Platonic image of the cave in order to magnify his both Greek and American drama. It is certainly a risky hypothesis that stricto sensu cannot be proved, but it is also reader's right to evaluate the plausibility and the possible dramatic benefit derived from such a reading. Besides indicating to what degree some of the essential themes of Platonic philosophy concerning darkness, light or the flight from the prison of the material world are not extraneous to O'Neill's work, the author proves he was aware of the Platonic image of the cave thanks to its capital importance in the work of some of his intellectual mentors such as F. Nietzsche or Oscar Wilde. Nevertheless, the most significant aim of the author's article is to emphasize both the dramatic benefits and the logical reflections derived, as said before, from reading little by little O'Neill's drama bearing in mind the above mentioned Platonic parameter.

Verí sense antídot per al Sòcrates històric i la tragèdia barroca al Verí del teatre de Rodolf Sirera. (Una dosi extrema de sadisme per aturar els excessos de la ficció teatral).

Socrates' serene attitude before his death -although this is questioned-, as described by Xenophon in his Apologia Socratis becomes for the playwright Rodolf Sirera a useful reference in an effort to reflect boldly on the limits of theatrical fiction in another clear example of the Classical Tradition, including that derived from Baroque Tragedy. However, in this case, it is judged severely to make us more conscious of the risk of turning life into a mere theatrical performance and human beings into actors and actresses in a play they did not write.

Cassandra's Dream de Woody Allen. La contemporaneïtat de la tragèdia grega

Cassandra's Dream, de Woody Allen (2007), no tingué les crítiques excel·lents de pel·lícules anteriors com ara Crimes and Misdemeanors i Match Point, on s'abordaven temes semblants. Tanmateix, segons l'opinió de l'autor d'aquest article, analitzada des de la perspectiva del llegat de la tragèdia grega en la cultura occidental, els mèrits d¿aquest film no són pas menyspreables. Les nombroses referències a la tragèdia grega, ja siguin títols o personatges, demostren la voluntat del director americà d'il·lustrar la contemporaneïtat del gènere esmentat, com també de presentar els homes i les dones d¿avui com a víctimes d'una gairebé omnipotent i sorneguera ironia tràgica. L'autor es proposa també de mostrar-hi les relacions evidents d'aquest guió amb el de Match Point i, sobretot, amb el que considera guió matriu de totes tres: Crimes and Misdemeanors.

Gorgias y el final del Ion de Eurípides

En las últimas décadas, los estudios de narratología han subrayado la función estructuradora que cumple el final de una obra en el conjunto de la trama, advirtiendo que, desde la lógica de una narración que progresa hacia un final, es éste el que da sentido al proceso. En tragedia griega el fenómeno resulta especialmente sensible en Sófocles, que ha diseñado sus propias pautas genéricas, las que mejor responden a nuestro concepto de intriga conclusiva. Eurípides resulta desde esta perspectiva un radical innovador del género trágico , pues el final de la performance es, con frecuencia, una pausa arbitraria en la acción. F.M. Dunn ha estudiado minuciosamente cómo esa suspensión del final de la tragedia en Eurípides viene acompañada de una «formal rhetoric of closure» (p. 7), consistente en una serie de recursos como el deus ex machina , el relato etiológico o profecía final, el discurso de aquiesciencia y la declaración de salida del coro («Closing Gestures», pp. 13-64). Tales mecanismos convencionales, afirma, son exteriores a la acción dramática y zanjan el argumento al tiempo que lo abren a soluciones múltiples, anticipando el camino a la novela.

Vencer en el diálogo. Justicia y retórica en Esquilo y Platón

«Tú (Polo) sostenías que los injustos son felices si no pagan justicia» «Exacto». «Yo en cambio digo que son muy desgraciados, pero los que pagan justicia, menos. ¿Quieres refutar también esto?» «Eso, Sócrates, es aún más difícil de refutar que aquello» « No difícil, Polo, sino imposible, pues lo verdadero jamás puede refutarse» (Gorg. 473b). En este momento del diálogo con Polo, Sócrates introduce el presupuesto que está en la base de su práctica dialogal, a saber, que la verdad no es refutable, y, por tanto, el discurso que vence en el diálogo es el verdadero. Claro que las implicaciones de tal proposición varían considerablemente según se enfatice el sujeto o el predicado: lo primero supone la existencia de una verdad objetiva, que va descubriéndose a través del debate; lo segundo, la dependencia de la noción de verdad de la de triunfo lógico, lo que deja abierta una amplia casuística.

Albert Lewin. Pandora and the Flying Dutchman: the Semiologic Potential of a Greek Myth

Albert Lewin, a well-known Hollywood cinema director who is significantly influenced by the surrealistic movement, brings together the myth f Pandora and the legend of the flying Dutchman in order to create an exemplary love story, a crazy love story which goes beyond the limits of human reason. Bearing in mind, then, that if one wants to believe in this sort of love story must not be guided by human reason stricto sensu, he builds a world of signs, a semiologic world which this article aims at helping to interpret.

Greek misogynist tradition in Andreas Capellanus's De amore

The title of this brief article quite clearly illustrates its aims and evident limitations. In principle, a search for a Greek basis of the misogynist content of Andreas Capellanus's De amore is likely to lead researchers to focus on analysis of the sources -Greek sources, of course. However, there is no doubt that Ovid, the most frequently quoted ancient author, in this case the structural source, above all his Ars Amatoria, Remedia Amoris and Heroides, which is quite logical in light of the remarkable presence and influence of Ovid's works throughout that time. There was also a good knowledge of the works of Cicero, Virgil, Horace and Juvenal. However, other classical authors, even the Greeks -those who were known then-, were undoubtedly read in the schools, but the knowledge of their works was certainly superficial. Furthermore, given the scholastic method followed in De amore, it would be absurd not to consider the use of many quotations that appeared in the Compendia and in handbooks of religious instruction.

John Addington Symonds. A Problem in Greek Ethics. Plutarch's Eroticus quoted only in some footnotes? Why?

It is certainly astonishing that an innovating study about the Greek pederasty in England like the one by John Addington Symonds does not quote Plutarch's Eroticus -in fact, it is only cited in some footnotes-, if one bears in mind that this dialogue is an accurate philosophical reflection on Greek eros, in which very often significant ethical themes are approached. The aim of this article is just to reveal the different reasons for such an omission.

John Addington Symonds. A Problem in Greek Ethics. ¿El Erótico de Plutarco reducido a algunas notas a pie de página? ¿Por qué?

Resulta sorprendente que un estudio pionero en Inglaterra sobre la pederastia griega como el de John Addington Symonds no cite el Erótico de Plutarco, excepción hecha de en algunas notas a pie de página, siendo como es este dialogo una seria reflexión filosófica sobre el eros griego, en que a menudo se abordan cuestiones éticas. El objetivo de este artículo es revelar justamente las razones de índole diversa para una tal omisión.

John Addington Symonds. A Problem in Greek Ethics. ¿L'Eròtic de Plutarc reduït a algunes notes a peu de pàgina? Per què?

Resulta sorprenent que un estudi pioner a Anglaterra sobre la pederàstia grega como el de John Addington Symonds no citi l'Eròtic de Plutarc, llevat de en algunes notes a peu de pàgina, essent com és aquest diàleg una seriosa reflexió filosòfica sobre l'eros grec, en què sovint s'aborden qüestions ètiques. L'objectiu d'aquest article és revelar justament les raons d'índole diversa per a una tal omissió.

L'intégration de l'étranger dans la tragédie athénienne : remarques sur la Médée d'Euripide

Both the civic discourse and the religious ritual present in the festival of Great Dionysia make the question of foreigners and their integration a central issue for the Athenian tragedy. The self-image that Athens builds through the tragedy uses this theme to differentiate itself from barbarians and from other Greek cities. Nevertheless there are situations where the integration of the foreigner becomes problematic even in the tragic Athens. Such is in particular the case when the integration involves the marriage. This paper focuses on a case of incompatibility, by confronting the image of Athens in the third stasimon of Euripides' Medea and that of the infanticidal heroine.