Deliberative Democracy and Precautionary Public Reasoning : Exploratory Thoughts

article

Synthesis, structure, and redox states of homoleptic d-block metal complexes with bis-1,2,4-triazin-3-yl-pyridine and 1,2,4-triazin-3-yl-bipyridine extractants

it has been established that triazinyl bipyridines (hemi-BTPs) and bis-triazinyl pyridines (BTPs), ligands which are currently being investigated as possible ligands for the separation of actinides from lanthanides in nuclear waste, are able to form homoleptic complexes with first row transition metals such as cobalt(IT), copper(II), iron(II), manganese(II), nickel(II) and zinc(II). The metal complexes exhibit six-co-ordinate octahedral structures and redox states largely analogous to those of the related terpyridine complexes. The reactivity of the different redox states of cobalt bis-hemi-BTP complex in aqueous environments has been studied with two-phase electrochemistry by immobilisation of the essentially water-insoluble metal complexes on graphite electrodes and the immersion of this modified electrode in an aqueous electrolyte. It was found that redox potentials for the metal-centred reactions were pH-independent whereas the potentials for the ligand-centred reactions were strongly pH-dependent. The reductive degradation of these complexes has been investigated by computational methods. Solvent extraction experiments have been carried out for a range of metals and these show that cobalt(II) and nickel(II) as well as palladium(II), cadmium(II) and lead(II) were all extracted with the ligands 1e and 2c with higher distribution ratios that was observed for americium(III) under the same conditions. The implications of this result for the use of these ligands to separate actinides from nuclear waste are discussed. (c) 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

QSAR studies of multidentate nitrogen ligands used in lanthanide and actinide extraction processes

Quantitative structure activity relationships (QSARs) have been developed to optimise the choice of nitrogen heterocyclic molecules that can be used to separate the minor actinides such as americium(III) from europium(III) in the aqueous PUREX raffinate of nuclear waste. Experimental data on distribution coefficients and separation factors (SFs) for 47 such ligands have been obtained and show SF values ranging from 0.61 to 100. The ligands were divided into a training set of 36 molecules to develop the QSAR and a test set of 11 molecules to validate the QSAR. Over 1500 molecular descriptors were calculated for each heterocycle and the Genetic Algorithm was used to select the most appropriate for use in multiple regression equations. Equations were developed fitting the separation factors to 6-8 molecular descriptors which gave r(2) values of >0.8 for the training set and values of >0.7 for the test set, thus showing good predictive quality. The descriptors used in the equations were primarily electronic and steric. These equations can be used to predict the separation factors of nitrogen heterocycles not yet synthesised and/or tested and hence obtain the most efficient ligands for lanthanide and actinide separation. (C) 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

An overview and historical look back at the solvent extraction using nitrogen donor ligands to extract and separate An(III) from Ln(III)

The partitioning of minor trivalent actinides (An) from lanthanides (Ln) is one of the challenges in the chemical treatment of nuclear waste. The optimal ligand to carry out the separation of An(III) and Ln(III) using solvent extraction has to meet several important criteria: high selectivity towards the solute, chemical and radiolytic stability, stripping possibilities and recycling of the organic phase, high separation factors and good distribution ratio, to name just a few of them. A chronological line can be drawn along the development of each extraction ligand family and some milestones are emphasized in this overview. Further developments in organic synthesis of extracting ligands are expected.

On the catalytic hydrogenation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons into less toxic compounds by a facile recoverable catalyst

Here we present the catalytic hydrogenation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) to less toxic mixtures of saturated and partial unsaturated polycyclic hydrocarbons under mild reaction conditions using a magnetically recoverable rhodium catalyst and molecular hydrogen as the exclusive H source. The catalyst is easily recovered after each reaction by placing a permanent magnet on the reactor wall and it can be reused in successive runs without any significant loss of catalytic activity. As an example, anthracene was totally converted into the saturated polycyclic hydrocarbon form (ca. 60%) and the partially hydrogenated form, 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8-octahydroanthracene (ca. 40%). The catalyst operates in a broad range of temperature and H(2) pressure in both organic and aqueous/organic solutions of anthracene and it also exhibits significant activity at low substrate concentrations (20 ppm). This can be an efficient recycling process for hydrogenation of PAHs present in contaminated fluid waste streams. (C) 2009 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Sociologin, hybriderna och den sociala verkligheten : exemplet kärnavfall

Sociology, hybrids and social reality: the case of nuclear waste The continuing technological transformation of nature means that sociology’s traditional vision of a sharp divide between nature and society is becoming ever harder to defend. Starting from Bruno Latour’s critique of modernity, and Nikolas Rose’s explorations of political power beyond the state, this article presents a framework for analysing the expanding wealth of hybrids of nature and society surrounding us today, and the problems of government they pose. These hybrids confront us with the need to rethink sociology’s conception of ‘the social’. With Latour’s help, the interplay of nature and society can be understood as subject to technical mediation, opening the way for studies of the varying arrangements through which different configurations of nature and society are produced. Rather than alternative social constructions of nature, what sociologists should be at pains to analyse and question are different programmes and strategies for bringing together natural and social forces in durable combinations. In the article, the geological disposal of nuclear waste serves as a useful example for exploring the fruitfulness of the analytical framework put forward. This complex undertaking constitutes just one component in a larger field of technoscientific endeavour that has irrevocably transformed nature while simultaneously re-making society. Addressing this case, we seek to reveal the promise of a sociology that does not bound ‘the social’ in advance, but rather makes the co-production of technology and society one of its most important objects of study.

Selective Synthesis of Oxacalix[6]arenes and Mixed Oxacalix[4]arenes

Calixarenesare macrocycles composed of benzene rings meta linked to each other by one carbon atom. These exotic compounds can be used for a variety of purposes including metalleaching for environmental cleanup, surface technology, luminescent probes, nuclear waste treatment, among others. A variety of calixarenesexist, including azacalix[n]arenesthiocalix[n]arenes(where n = the number of benzene rings) and oxacalix[n]arenes; these macrocycles use nitrogen, sulfur and oxygen, respectively, as the atom whichlinks the benzene rings together. My research has focused on synthesizing oxacalix[6]arenes (“hexamer”) in high yield, which is a synthetic challenge because it is generally accepted that oxacalix[n>4]arenes will thermodynamically decompose to the oxacalix[4]arene (“tetramer”); i.e. heating the reaction mixture will yield the tetramer, not the hexamer. To generate the hexamer, “trimer”precursors have been synthesized, in the hopes of facilitating hexamer ring closure.

Bioremediation of direct dyes in simulated textile effluents by a paramorphogenic form of Aspergillus oryzae

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES)

Bioremediation of direct dyes in simulated textile effluents by paramorphogenic form of Aspergillus oryzae

Azo dyes are extensively used for coloring textiles, paper, food, leather, drink, pharmaceutical products, cosmetics and inks. The textile industry consumes the largest amount of azo dyes, and it is estimated that approximately 10 - 15% of dyes used for coloring textiles might be lost in waste streams. Almost all azo dyes are synthetic and resist biodegradation, however, they can be readly reduced by a number of chemical and biological reducing systems. Biological treatment is advantageous over physical and chemical method as result of its low cost and little disturbance to the environment. This research focuses on the utilization of Aspergillus oryzae, to remove some kinds of azo dyes from aqueous solutions. The fungi, physically induced in its paramorphogenic form (called, pellets), were used in the dyes biosorption studies with both non autoclave and autoclaved hyphas, at differents pH values. Thus the goals are the removal of dyes by biosorption and the decrease of its toxicity.

Modeling hydrothermal system: deriving observables and hydrothermal instability in volcanic and non-volcanic setting

Hydrothermal fluids are a fundamental resource for understanding and monitoring volcanic and non-volcanic systems. This thesis is focused on the study of hydrothermal system through numerical modeling with the geothermal simulator TOUGH2. Several simulations are presented, and geophysical and geochemical observables, arising from fluids circulation, are analyzed in detail throughout the thesis. In a volcanic setting, fluids feeding fumaroles and hot spring may play a key role in the hazard evaluation. The evolution of the fluids circulation is caused by a strong interaction between magmatic and hydrothermal systems. A simultaneous analysis of different geophysical and geochemical observables is a sound approach for interpreting monitored data and to infer a consistent conceptual model. Analyzed observables are ground displacement, gravity changes, electrical conductivity, amount, composition and temperature of the emitted gases at surface, and extent of degassing area. Results highlight the different temporal response of the considered observables, as well as the different radial pattern of variation. However, magnitude, temporal response and radial pattern of these signals depend not only on the evolution of fluid circulation, but a main role is played by the considered rock properties. Numerical simulations highlight differences that arise from the assumption of different permeabilities, for both homogeneous and heterogeneous systems. Rock properties affect hydrothermal fluid circulation, controlling both the range of variation and the temporal evolution of the observable signals. Low temperature fumaroles and low discharge rate may be affected by atmospheric conditions. Detailed parametric simulations were performed, aimed to understand the effects of system properties, such as permeability and gas reservoir overpressure, on diffuse degassing when air temperature and barometric pressure changes are applied to the ground surface. Hydrothermal circulation, however, is not only a characteristic of volcanic system. Hot fluids may be involved in several mankind problems, such as studies on geothermal engineering, nuclear waste propagation in porous medium, and Geological Carbon Sequestration (GCS). The current concept for large-scale GCS is the direct injection of supercritical carbon dioxide into deep geological formations which typically contain brine. Upward displacement of such brine from deep reservoirs driven by pressure increases resulting from carbon dioxide injection may occur through abandoned wells, permeable faults or permeable channels. Brine intrusion into aquifers may degrade groundwater resources. Numerical results show that pressure rise drives dense water up to the conduits, and does not necessarily result in continuous flow. Rather, overpressure leads to new hydrostatic equilibrium if fluids are initially density stratified. If warm and salty fluid does not cool passing through the conduit, an oscillatory solution is then possible. Parameter studies delineate steady-state (static) and oscillatory solutions.

Spurenanalyse von Uran und Plutonium sowie Speziationsuntersuchungen an Plutonium mit massenspektrometrischen und kapillarelektrophoretischen Methoden

Die Elemente Uran und Plutonium besitzen seit Entdeckung der Kernspaltung und der technischen Nutzung der Kernenergie eine globale Bedeutung. So trägt Pu hauptsächlich zur Radiotoxizität von abgebrannten Brennelementen bei und erfordert im Falle einer Endlagerung in einer tiefen geologischen Formation einen sicheren Verschluss für bis zu einer Million Jahre. Das Wissen über die vorliegenden chemischen Spezies ist dabei entscheidend für das Verständnis der chemisch-physikalischen Wechselwirkungen im jeweiligen geochemischen System, insbesondere mit dem Wirtsgestein (hier Ton) und den allgegenwärtigen Huminstoffen (hier Fulvinsäure). Längerfristig sind so Vorhersagen über einen Transport des hochradioaktiven Abfalls nach Auslaugung und Austritt aus einem Endlager bis in die Biosphäre möglich. Gerade der Ultraspurenbereich, im Fernfeld eines Endlagers zu erwarten, ist dabei von besonderem Interesse. Darüber hinaus machen nuklearforensische Untersuchungen – in Hinblick auf illegal benutztes Nuklearmaterial, Schmuggel oder Nuklearterrorismus – zur Bestimmung der Herkunft, des Alters oder der Radiotoxizität isotopenselektive Nachweismethoden im Ultraspurenbereich notwendig. Im Rahmen dieser Arbeit wurden hierfür die Resonanzionisationsmassenspektrometrie (RIMS) zur isotopenselektiven Spuren- und Ultraspurenanalyse von U und Pu sowie die Kapillarelektrophorese (CE) gekoppelt an die induktiv gekoppelte Plasma (ICP)-Massenspektrometrie (CE-ICP-MS) zur Speziation von Pu eingesetzt. Für den isotopenselektiven Nachweis von Ultraspurenmengen von Uran mittels RIMS wurden vorbereitende Studien durchgeführt und mehrere zweifach resonante Anregungsleitern mit nicht-resonanter Ionisation untersucht. Eine Effizienz von ca. 10^-10 bei einer Nachweisgrenze von 10^12 Atomen U-238 konnte erzielt werden. In Zusammenarbeit mit dem Institut für Radiochemie, TU München, wurde mittels RIMS die Isotopenzusammensetzung von Plutonium, abgetrennt aus einem panzerbrechenden Urangeschoss aus dem Kosovokonflikt, bestimmt und dieses als Waffenplutonium mit einem Gehalt von 15 pg Pu-239/g Uran identifiziert. Rückschlüsse über Herkunft und Alter des Plutoniums konnten daraus gewonnen werden. Für Studien zur Umweltüberwachung von Plutonium in Rheinland-Pfalz wurden Grund-, Oberflächen- und Klärwasserproben mittels RIMS untersucht. Oberhalb der Nachweisgrenze von ca. 10^7 Atomen Pu-239/500 mL konnte kein signifikanter Gehalt bestimmt werden. Zusätzlich wurden Klärschlammproben untersucht, wobei in einer Probe 5,1*10^7 Atome Pu-239/g gemessen wurde, was auf eine Anreicherung von Pu im Klärschlamm aus großen Wasservolumina hindeuten könnte. Speziationsuntersuchungen von Plutonium in Kontakt mit Fulvinsäure und dem Tonmineral Kaolinit wurden in Hinblick auf die Wechselwirkungen im Umfeld eines nuklearen Endlagers durchgeführt. Die Redoxkinetik von Pu(VI) in Kontakt mit Gorleben-Fulvinsäure zeigt eine mit steigendem pH zunehmend schnellere und vollständige Reduktion und ein vergleichbares Verhalten zur Huminsäure. Für ein Plutoniumgemisch aus allen vier umweltrelevanten Oxidationsstufen in Kontakt mit Gorleben-Fulvinsäure konnte nach ca. 1 Monat Kontaktzeit eine fasst vollständige Reduktion zum tri- und tetravalenten Pu beobachtet werden. Sorptionsuntersuchungen der stabilsten Oxidationsstufe, Pu(IV), in Kontakt mit Kaolinit bei pH = 0 bis 13 im Konzentrationsbereich 10^-7 bis 10^-9 mol/L verdeutlichen das ausgeprägte Sorptionsverhalten von Pu(IV) (ca. 60% bis 90% Sorption) im umweltrelevanten pH-Bereich bei einem Einsetzen der Sorption bei pH = 0 bis 2. Im Rahmen des "Colloid and Radionuclide Retardation" (CRR) Experiments im Felslabor Grimsel, Schweizer Alpen, wurde in Zusammenarbeit mit dem Institut für Nukleare Entsorgung, Karlsruhe, die kolloidgetragene Migration von Pu(IV) in einem Grundwasserstrom durch Scherzonen im Granitgestein unter umweltrelevanten Bedingungen untersucht. Bei Zugabe von im Grundwasser stabilen Bentonitkolloiden – Bentonit wird als ein geeignetes Verschlussmaterial für nukleare Abfälle erforscht – konnte ein erhöhter Transport des Pu(IV) beobachtet werden, der durch Sorption des Pu an die mobilen Kolloide hervorgerufen wird. Zur Speziation von Plutonium im Ultraspurenbereich wurde im Rahmen dieser Arbeit an der Entwicklung der Kopplung der CE mit der sehr sensitiven RIMS gearbeitet. Das Prinzip der offline-Kopplung basiert auf dem Sammeln der zu unterschiedlichen Zeiten am Ende der Kapillare eluierten Oxidationsstufen in einzelnen Fraktionen. Aus jeder Fraktion wird ein eigenes Filament hergestellt und mit RIMS auf seinen Plutoniumgehalt untersucht. Eine erste Validierung der Methode konnte durch Bestimmung der Oxidationsstufenzusammensetzung eines bekannten Gemischs erfolgreich für einen Gehalt von ca. 6*10^9 Atome Pu-239 durchgeführt werden. Dies stellt einen möglichen Zugang zu dem erwarteten Konzentrationsbereich im Fernfeld eines Endlagers dar.

Speciation of Pu(III) in the environmental system humic substances-groundwater-kaolinite

For the safety assessments of nuclear waste repositories, the possible migration of the radiotoxic waste into environment must be considered. Since plutonium is the major contribution at the radiotoxicity of spent nuclear waste, it requires special care with respect to its mobilization into the groundwater. Plutonium has one of the most complicated chemistry of all elements. It can coexist in 4 oxidation states parallel in one solution. In this work is shown that in the presence of humic substances it is reduced to the Pu(III) and Pu(IV). This work has the focus on the interaction of Pu(III) with natural occurring compounds (humic substances and clay minerals bzw. Kaolinite), while Pu(IV) was studied in a parallel doctoral work by Banik (in preparation). As plutonium is expected under extreme low concentrations in the environment, very sensitive methods are needed to monitor its presence and for its speciation. Resonance ionization mass spectrometry (RIMS), was used for determining the concentration of Pu in environmental samples, with a detection limit of 106- 107 atoms. For the speciation of plutonium CE-ICP-MS was routinely used to monitor the behaviour of Pu in the presence of humic substances. In order to reduce the detection limits of the speciation methods, the coupling of CE to RIMS was proposed. The first steps have shown that this can be a powerful tool for studies of pu under environmental conditions. Further, the first steps in the coupling of two parallel working detectors (DAD and ICP_MS ) to CE was performed, for the enabling a precise study of the complexation constants of plutonium with humic substances. The redox stabilization of Pu(III) was studied and it was determined that NH2OHHCl can maintain Pu(III) in the reduced form up to pH 5.5 – 6. The complexation constants of Pu(III) with Aldrich humic acid (AHA) were determined at pH 3 and 4. the logß = 6.2 – 6.8 found for these experiments was comparable with the literature. The sorption of Pu(III) onto kaolinite was studied in batch experiments and it was determine dthat the pH edge was at pH ~ 5.5. The speciation of plutonium on the surface of kaolinite was studied by EXAFS/XANES. It was determined that the sorbed species was Pu(IV). The influence of AHA on the sorption of Pu(III) onto kaolinite was also investigated. It was determined that at pH < 5 the adsorption is enhanced by the presence of AHA (25 mg/L), while at pH > 6 the adsorption is strongly impaired (depending also on the adding sequence of the components), leading to a mobilization of plutonium in solution.

Speciation of tetravalent plutonium in contact with humic substances and kaolinite under environmental conditions

Plutonium represents the major contribution to the radiotoxicity of spent nuclear fuel over storage times of up to several hundred thousand years. The speciation of plutonium in aquifer systems is important in order to assess the risks of high-level nuclear waste disposal and to acquire a deep knowledge of the mobilization and immobilization behavior of plutonium. In aqueous solutions, plutonium can coexist in four oxidation states and each one of them has different chemical and physical behavior. Tetravalent plutonium is the most abundant under natural conditions. Therefore, detailed speciation studies of tetravalent plutonium in contact with humic substances (HS) and kaolinite as a model clay mineral have been performed in this work. Plutonium is present in the environment at an ultratrace level. Therefore, speciation of Pu at the ultratrace level is mandatory. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) coupled to resonance ionization mass spectrometry (RIMS) was used as a new speciation method. CE-RIMS enables to improve the detection limit for plutonium species by 2 to 3 orders of magnitude compared to the previously developed CE-ICP-MS. For understanding the behavior of Pu(IV) in aqueous systems, redox reactions, complexation, and sorption behavior of plutonium were studied. The redox behavior of plutonium in contact with humic acid (HA) and fulvic acid (FA) was investigated. A relatively fast reduction of Pu(VI) in contact with HS was observed. It was mainly reduced to Pu(IV) and Pu(III) within a couple of weeks. The time dependence of the Pu(IV) complexation with Aldrich HA was investigated and a complex constant (logßLC) between 6.4 - 8.4 of Pu(IV) was determined by means of ultrafiltration taking into account the loading capacity (LC). The sorption of tetravalent plutonium onto kaolinite was investigated as a function of pH in batch experiments under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. The sorption edge was found at about pH = 1 and a maximum sorption at around pH = 8.5. In the presence of CO2 at pH > 8.5, the sorption of plutonium was decreased probably due to the formation of soluble carbonate complexes. For comparison, the sorption of Th(IV) onto kaolinite was also investigated and consistent results were found. The Pu(IV) sorption onto kaolinite was studied by XANES and EXAFS at pH 1, 4, 9 and the sorbed species on kaolinite surface was Pu(IV). Depending on the pH, only 1 - 10 % of the sorbed plutonium is desorbed from kaolinite and released into a fresh solution at the same pH value. Furthermore, the sorption of HS onto kaolinite was studied as a function of pH at varying concentrations of HS, as a prerequisite to understand the more complex ternary system. The sorption of HA onto kaolinite was found to be higher than that of FA. The investigation of the ternary systems (plutonium-kaolinite-humic substances) is performed as a function of pH, concentration of HS, and the sequences of adding the reactants. The presence of HS strongly influences the sorption of Pu(IV) onto kaolinite over the entire pH range. For comparison, the influence of HS on the sorption of Th(IV) onto kaolinite was also investigated and a good agreement with the results of Pu(IV) was obtained.

Entwicklung des Laserionenquellen und -fallenprojekts LIST für Ultraspurendetektion und Grundlagenforschung

Die vorliegende Dissertation beschreibt die Realisation des neuartigen Konzepts der Laserionenquellenfalle für die on-line Produktion exotischer Nuklide und für den Nachweis von Spurenisotopen in Proben mit starken Isobarenkontaminationen. Ziel dieser Entwicklung ist eine wesentliche Steigerung der Isobarenselektivität einer herkömmlichen Laserionenquelle, sowie die Erzeugung zeitlich kontrollierter Ionenpulse mit hervorragender Strahlqualität. Es konnte die prizipielle Funktionsfähigkeit des Systems in Kombination mit einem Titan:Saphir-Lasersystem für die Elemente Gallium, Calcium und Nickel demonstriert und Ionenpulse mit einer minimalen Pulslänge von 1 µs erzeugt werden. Nach ersten Abschätzungen ist die Effizienz des Systems etwa einen Faktor 2500 geringer als die einer herkömmlichen Laserionenquelle. Der zweite Teil der Arbeit beschäftigt sich mit dem spurenanalytischen Nachweis von 99-Tc, mit dem Ziel, das Verhalten von 99-Tc in der Umgebung eines möglichen Endlagers für nukleare Abfälle studieren zu können. Hier wurden erste Studien mit dem kurzlebigen Isomer 99m-Tc zur Wechselwirkung von Tc(VII) mit Huminsäure und Kaolinit durchgeführt. Für den Einsatz der Laserionenquellenfalle in der Ultraspurenanalyse, wurde ein effizientes Anregungsschema für Titan:Saphir-Laser entwickelt und 99-Tc in einer herkömmlichen Ionenquelle nachgewiesen. Der letzte Teil der Arbeit beschreibt Machbarkeitsstudien zum Aufbau einer Laserionenquelle auf Basis eines Titan:Sahphir-Lasersystems, die parallel zu oben genannten Entwicklungen am Oak Ridge National Laboratory durchgeführt wurden. Im Rahmen dieser Messungen wurden Anregungsschemata für die resonante Anregung und Ionisation von Kupfer und Palladium für Titan:Saphir-Laser getestet. Dabei konnte zum ersten Mal frequenzvervierfachtes Laserlicht in einer Laserionenquelle eingesetzt werden. Am ORNL wurden Studien zur Zeitstruktur von Laserionenpulsen, sowie Emittanzmessungen von Laser- und Oberflächenionenstrahlen durchgeführt werden.