NMR studies on supramolecular aggregates in solution and the solid state

The aim of this work presented here is the characterization of structure and dynamics of different types of supramolecular systems by advanced NMR spectroscopy. One of the characteristic features of NMR spectroscopy is based on its high selectivity. Thus, it is desirable to exploit this technique for studying structure and dynamics of large supramolecular systems without isotopic enrichment. The observed resonance frequencies are not only isotope specific but also influenced by local fields, in particular by the distribution of electron density around the investigated nucleus. Barbituric acid are well known for forming strongly hydrogen-bonded complexes with variety of adenine derivatives. The prototropic tautomerism of this material facilitates an adjustment to complementary bases containing a DDA(A = hydrogen bond acceptor site, D = hydrogen bond donor site) or ADA sequences, thereby yielding strongly hydrogen-bonded complexes. In this contribution solid-state structures of the enolizable chromophor "1-n-butyl-5-(4-nitrophenyl)-barbituric acid" that features adjustable hydrogen-bonding properties and the molecular assemblies with three different strength of bases (Proton sponge, adenine mimetic 2,6-diaminopyridine (DAP) and 2,6-diacetamidopyridine (DAC)) are studied. Diffusion NMR spectroscopy gives information over such interactions and has become the method of choice for measuring the diffusion coefficient, thereby reflecting the effective size and shape of a molecular species. In this work the investigation of supramolecular aggregates in solution state by means of DOSY NMR techniques are performed. The underlying principles of DOSY NMR experiment are discussed briefly and more importantly two applications demonstrating the potential of this method are focused on. Calix[n]arenes have gained a rather prominent position, both as host materials and as platforms to design specific receptors. In this respect, several different capsular contents of tetra urea calix[4]arenes (benzene, benzene-d6, 1-fluorobenzene, 1-fluorobenzene-d5, 1,4-difluorobenzene, and cobaltocenium) are studied by solid state NMR spectroscopy. In the solid state, the study of the interaction between tetra urea calix[4]arenes and guest is simplified by the fact that the guests molecule remains complexed and positioned within the cavity, thus allowing a more direct investigation of the host-guest interactions.

Structural transformations related to organic solid-state reactions: correlation studies of NMR and X-ray analysis

Eine zielgerichtete Steuerung und Durchführung von organischen Festkörperreaktionen wird unter anderem durch genaue Kenntnis von Packungseffekten ermöglicht. Im Rahmen dieser Arbeit konnte durch den kombinierten Einsatz von Einkristallröntgenanalyse und hochauf-lösender Festkörper-NMR an ausgewählten Beispielen ein tieferes Verständnis und Einblicke in die Reaktionsmechanismen von organischen Festkörperreaktionen auf molekularer Ebene gewonnen werden. So konnten bei der topotaktischen [2+2] Photodimerisierung von Zimt-säure Intermediate isoliert und strukturell charakterisiert werden. Insbesondere anhand statischer Deuteronen- und 13C-CPMAS NMR Spektren konnten eindeutig dynamische Wasserstoffbrücken nachgewiesen werden, die transient die Zentrosymmetrie des Reaktions-produkts aufheben. Ein weiterer Nachweis gelang daraufhin mittels Hochtemperatur-Röntgen-untersuchung, sodass der scheinbare Widerspruch von NMR- und Röntgenuntersuchungen gelöst werden konnte. Eine Veresterung der Zimtsäure entfernt diese Wasserstoffbrücken und erhält somit die Zentrosymmetrie des Photodimers. Weiterhin werden Ansätze zur Strukturkontrolle in Festkörpern basierend auf der molekularen Erkennung des Hydroxyl-Pyridin (OH-N) Heterosynthon in Co-Kristallen beschrieben, wobei vor allem die Stabilität des Synthons in Gegenwart funktioneller Gruppen mit Möglichkeit zu kompetetiver Wasserstoffbrückenbildung festgestellt wurde. Durch Erweiterung dieses Ansatzes wurde die molekulare Spezifität des Hydroxyl-Pyridin (OH-N) Heterosynthons bei gleichzeitiger Co-Kristallisation mit mehreren Komponenten erfolgreich aufgezeigt. Am Beispiel der Co-Kristallisation von trans--1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethylen (bpe) mit Resorcinol (res) in Gegenwart von trans-1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethan (bpet) konnten Zwischenprodukte der Fest-körperreaktionen und neuartige Polymorphe isoliert werden, wobei eine lückenlose Aufklärung des Reaktionswegs mittels Röntgenanalyse gelang. Dabei zeigte sich, dass das Templat Resorcinol aus den Zielverbindungen entfernbar ist. Ferner gelang die Durchführung einer seltenen, nicht-idealen Einkristall-Einkristall-Umlagerung von trans--1,2-bis(4-pyridyl)ethylen (bpe) mit Resorcinol (res). In allen Fällen konnten die Fragen zur Struktur und Dynamik der untersuchten Verbindungen nur durch gemeinsame Nutzung von Röntgenanalyse und NMR-Spektroskopie bei vergleichbaren Temperaturen eindeutig und umfassend geklärt werden.

Structure, organization and dynamics of functional supramolecular materials studied by solid-state NMR

Functional materials have great importance due to their many important applications. The characterization of supramolecular architectures which are held together by non-covalent interactions is of most importance to understand their properties. Solid-state NMR methods have recently been proven to be able to unravel such structure-property relations with the help of fast magic-angle spinning and advanced pulse sequences. The aim of the current work is to understand the structure and dynamics of functional supramolecular materials which are potentially important for fuel-cell (proton conducting membrane materials) and solar-cell or plastic-electronic applications (photo-reactive aromatic materials). In particular, hydrogen-bonding networks, local proton mobility, molecular packing arrangements, and local dynamics will be studied by the use of advanced solid-state NMR methods. The first class of materials studied in this work is proton conducting polymers which also form hydrogen-bonding network. Different materials, which are prepared for high 1H conduction by different approaches are studied: PAA-P4VP, PVPA-ABPBI, Tz5Si, and Triazole-functional systems. The materials are examples of the following major groups; - Homopolymers with specific functional groups (Triazole functional polysiloxanes). - Acid-base polymer blends approach (PAA-P4VP, PVPA-ABPBI). - Acid-base copolymer approach (Triazole-PVPA). - Acid doped polymers (Triazole functional polymer doped with H3PO4). Perylenebisimide (PBI) derivatives, a second type of important functional supramolecular materials with potent applications in plastic electronics, were also investigated by means of solid-state NMR. The preparation of conducting nanoscopic fibers based on the self-assembling functional units is an appealing aim as they may be incorporated in molecular electronic devices. In this category, perylene derivatives have attracted great attention due to their high charge carrier mobility. A detailed knowledge about their supramolecular structure and molecular dynamics is crucial for the understanding of their electronic properties. The aim is to understand the structure, dynamics and packing arrangements which lead to high electron conductivity in PBI derivatives.

Solid-state NMR investigation of phosphonic acid based proton conducting materials

In this work, new promising proton conducting fuel cell membrane materials were characterized in terms of their structure and dynamic properties using solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. Structurally different, phosphonic acid (PA) containing materials were systematically evaluated for possible high-temperature operation (e.g. at T>100°C). Notably, 1H, 2H and 31P magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR provided insight into local connectivities and dynamics of the hydrogen bonded network, while packing arrangements were identified by means of heteronuclear dipolar recoupling techniques.rnThe first part of this work introduced rather crystalline, low molecular weight ionomers for proton conducting membranes, where six different geometries such as line, triangle, screw, tetrahedron, square and hexagon, were investigated. The hexagon was identified as the most promising geometry with high-temperature bulk proton conductivities in the range of 10-3 Scm-1 at a relative humidity of 50%. However, 2H NMR and TGA-MS data suggest that the bulk proton transport is mainly due to the presence of crystal water. Single crystal X-ray data revealed that in the tetrahedron phosphonic acids form tetrameric clusters isolating the mobile protons while the phosphonic acids in the hexagon form zigzag-type pathways through the sample.rnThe second part of this work demonstrates how acid-base pairing and the choice of appropriate spacers may influence proton conduction. Different ratios of statistical copolymers of poly (vinylphosphonic acid) and poly (4-vinylpyridine) were measured to derive information about the local structure and chemical changes. Though anhydrous proton conductivities of all statistical copolymers are rather poor, the conductivity increases to 10-2 S cm-1 when exposing the sample to relative humidity of 80%. In contrast to PVPA, anhydride formation of phosphonic acids in the copolymer is not reversible even when exposing the sample to a relative humidity of 100%.rnIn addition, the influence of both spacers and degree of backbone crystallinity on bulk proton conductivity was investigated. Unlike in systems such as poly benzimidazole (PBI), spacers were inserted between the protogenic groups along the backbone. It was found that dilution of the protogenic groups decreases the conductivity, but compared to PVPA, similar apparent activation energies for local motions were obtained from both variable temperature 1H NMR and impedance spectroscopy data. These observations suggest the formation of phosphonic acid clusters with high degrees of local proton motion, where only a fraction of motions contribute to the observable bulk proton conductivity. Additionally, it was shown that gradual changes of the spacer length lead to different morphologies.rnIn summary, applying advanced solid-state NMR and X-ray analysis, structural and dynamic phenomena in proton conducting materials were identified on a molecular level. The results were discussed with respect to different proton conduction mechanisms and may contribute to a more rational design or improvement of proton conducting membranes.rn

Solid-state NMR on columnar supramolecular structures

The present work deals with the characterisation of three columnar self-assembled systems, that is, benzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamides, a peripherally thioalkyl-substituted phthalocyanine, and several oligo-(p-phenylenevinylene)s. In order to probe the supramolecular organisation solid-state NMR has been used as the main technique, supported by X-ray measurements, theoretical methods, and thermal analysis. rnrnBenzene-1,3,5-tricarboxamides (BTAs) turned out to be well suited model compounds to study various fundamental supramolecular interactions, such as π-π-interactions, hydrogen bonding, as well as dynamic and steric effects of attached side chains. Six BTAs have been investigated in total, five with a CO-centred amide group bearing different side chains and one with an inverted N-centred amide group. The physical properties of these BTAs have been investigated as a function of temperature. The results indicated that in case of the CO-centred BTAs the stability of the columnar mesophase depends strongly on the nature of the side chains. Further experiments revealed a coplanar orientation of adjacent BTA molecules in the columnar assembly of CO-centred BTAs, whereas the N-centred BTA, showed a deviating not fully coplanar arrangement. These differences were ascribed to distinct hydrogen bonding schemes, involving a parallel alignment of hydrogen bonds in case of CO-centred BTAs and an antiparallel alignment in case of the N-centred counterpart.rnrn The fundamental insights of the supramolecular organisation of BTAs could be partially adapted to an octa-substituted phthalocyanine with thiododecyl moieties. Solid-state NMR in combination with chemical shift calculations determined a tilted herringbone arrangement of phthalocyanine rings in the crystalline phase as well as in the mesophase. Moreover, 1H NMR measurements in the mesophase of this compound suggested an axial rotation of molecules, which is inhibited in the crystalline phase.rnrnAs a third task, the supramolecular assembly of oligo-(p-phenylenevinylene)s of varying length and with different polar head groups have been investigated by a combined X-ray and solid-state NMR study. The results revealed a columnar structure formation of these compounds, being promoted by phase separation of alkyl side chains and aromatic rigid rods. In this system solid-state NMR yielded meaningful insight into the isotropisation process of butoxy and 2-S-methylbutoxy substituted oligo-(p-phenylenevinylene) rods.rn

Interplay of pi–pi stacking and hydrogen bonding in conjugated supramolecular systems studied by solid-state NMR

In this work supramolecular organic systems based on rigid pi-conjugated building blocks and flexible side chains were studied via solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Specifically, these studies focussed on phenylene ethynylene based macrocycles, polymer systems including polythiophenes, and rod-coil copolymers of oligo(p-benzamide) and poly(ethylene glycol). All systems were studied in terms of the local order and mobility. The central topic of this dissertation was to elucidate the role of the flexible side chains in interplay of different non-covalent interactions, like pi-pi-stacking and hydrogen bonding.Combining the results of this work, it can be concluded that the ratio of the rigid block and the attached alkyl side chains can be crucial for the design of an ordered pi-conjugated supramolecular system. Through alkyl side chains, it is also possible to introduce liquid-crystalline phases in the system, which can foster the local order of the system. Moreover in the studied system longer, unbranched alkyl side chains are better suited to stabilize the corresponding aggregation than shorter, branched ones.The combination of non-covalent interactions such as pi-pi-stacking and hydrogen bonding play an important role for structure formation. However, the effect of pi-pi-stacking interaction is much weaker than the effect of hydrogen bonding and is only observed in systems with a suitable local order. Hence, they are often not strong enough to control the local order. In contrast, hydrogen bonds predominantly influence the structural organization and packing. In comparison the size of the alkyl side chains is only of minor importance. The suppression of certain hydrogen bonds can lead to completely different structures and can induce a specific aggregation behavior. Thus, for the design of a supramolecular ordered system the presence of hydrogen bonding efficiently stabilizes the corresponding structure, but the ratio of hydrogen bond forming groups should be kept low to be able to influence the structure selectively.

Complete resolution of the solid-state NMR spectrum of a uniformly 15N-labeled membrane protein in phospholipid bilayers

Complete resolution of the amide resonances in a three-dimensional solid-state NMR correlation spectrum of a uniformly 15N-labeled membrane protein in oriented phospholipid bilayers is demonstrated. The three orientationally dependent frequencies, 1H chemical shift, 1H–15N dipolar coupling, and 15N chemical shift, associated with each amide resonance are responsible for resolution among resonances and provide sufficient angular restrictions for protein structure determination. Because the protein is completely immobilized by the phospholipids on the relevant NMR time scales (10 kHz), the linewidths will not degrade in the spectra of larger proteins. Therefore, these results demonstrate that solid-state NMR experiments can overcome the correlation time problem and extend the range of proteins that can have their structures determined by NMR spectroscopy to include uniformly 15N-labeled membrane proteins in phospholipid bilayers.

Multiple quantum solid-state NMR indicates a parallel, not antiparallel, organization of β-sheets in Alzheimer's β-amyloid fibrils

Senile plaques associated with Alzheimer's disease contain deposits of fibrils formed by 39- to 43-residue β-amyloid peptides with possible neurotoxic effects. X-ray diffraction measurements on oriented fibril bundles have indicated an extended β-sheet structure for Alzheimer's β-amyloid fibrils and other amyloid fibrils, but the supramolecular organization of the β-sheets and other structural details are not well established because of the intrinsically noncrystalline, insoluble nature of amyloid fibrils. Here we report solid-state NMR measurements, using a multiple quantum (MQ) 13C NMR technique, that probe the β-sheet organization in fibrils formed by the full-length, 40-residue β-amyloid peptide (Aβ1–40). Although an antiparallel β-sheet organization often is assumed and is invoked in recent structural models for full-length β-amyloid fibrils, the MQNMR data indicate an in-register, parallel organization. This work provides site-specific, atomic-level structural constraints on full-length β-amyloid fibrils and applies MQNMR to a significant problem in structural biology.

Photochemically induced nuclear spin polarization in reaction centers of photosystem II observed by 13C-solid-state NMR reveals a strongly asymmetric electronic structure of the P680.+ primary donor chlorophyll

We report 13C magic angle spinning NMR observation of photochemically induced dynamic nuclear spin polarization (photo- CIDNP) in the reaction center (RC) of photosystem II (PS2). The light-enhanced NMR signals of the natural abundance 13C provide information on the electronic structure of the primary electron donor P680 (chlorophyll a molecules absorbing around 680 nm) and on the pz spin density pattern in its oxidized form, P680⨥. Most centerband signals can be attributed to a single chlorophyll a (Chl a) cofactor that has little interaction with other pigments. The chemical shift anisotropy of the most intense signals is characteristic for aromatic carbon atoms. The data reveal a pronounced asymmetry of the electronic spin density distribution within the P680⨥. PS2 shows only a single broad and intense emissive signal, which is assigned to both the C-10 and C-15 methine carbon atoms. The spin density appears shifted toward ring III. This shift is remarkable, because, for monomeric Chl a radical cations in solution, the region of highest spin density is around ring II. It leads to a first hypothesis as to how the planet can provide itself with the chemical potential to split water and generate an oxygen atmosphere using the Chl a macroaromatic cycle. A local electrostatic field close to ring III can polarize the electronic charge and associated spin density and increase the redox potential of P680 by stabilizing the highest occupied molecular orbital, without a major change of color. This field could be produced, e.g., by protonation of the keto group of ring V. Finally, the radical cation electronic structure in PS2 is different from that in the bacterial RC, which shows at least four emissive centerbands, indicating a symmetric spin density distribution over the entire bacteriochlorophyll macrocycle.

Characterization of the Structure and Dynamics of Biomimetic Peptides by Solid-State NMR

Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Washington, 2016-05

The hydration of paper studied with solid-state magnetisation-exchange H-1 NMR spectroscopy

The wide-line H-1 nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrum of paper in equilibrium with ambient humidity consists of super-imposed relatively broad and narrow lines. The narrower line is of the order of 2 kHz wide at half the maximum height, while the broader line is of the order of 40 kHz in width at half height. On the basis of these line widths, the narrow line is assigned to water sorbed to the paper, and the broad line to the polymeric constituents of the paper. It was not possible to distinguish between the various polymeric components of paper contributing to the H-1 NMR spectra. A modified Goldman-Shen pulse sequence was used to generate a spatial magnetisation gradient between the polymer and water phases. The exchange of magnetisation between protons associated with water and those associated with the macromolecules in paper was observed. The exchange of magnetisation is discussed within a heat transfer model for homonuclear dipolar coupling, with exchange being characterised by a spin-diffusion coefficient. Consideration of the magnitude of the initial rate of the exchange process and estimates of the spin-spin relaxation times based on H-1 line widths indicate that some water must exist in a sufficiently immobile state as to allow homonuclear dipolar interactions between adjacent polymer and water protons. Thus, water sorbed onto paper must exist in at least two states in mass exchange with each other. This observation allows certain conclusions to be drawn about the ratio of free/bound water as a function of moisture content and the dispersal of water within the polymer matrix.

Numerical method for determination of the NMR frequency of the single-qubit operation in a silicon-based solid-state quantum computer

A numerical method is introduced to determine the nuclear magnetic resonance frequency of a donor (P-31) doped inside a silicon substrate under the influence of an applied electric field. This phosphorus donor has been suggested for operation as a qubit for the realization of a solid-state scalable quantum computer. The operation of the qubit is achieved by a combination of the rotation of the phosphorus nuclear spin through a globally applied magnetic field and the selection of the phosphorus nucleus through a locally applied electric field. To realize the selection function, it is required to know the relationship between the applied electric field and the change of the nuclear magnetic resonance frequency of phosphorus. In this study, based on the wave functions obtained by the effective-mass theory, we introduce an empirical correction factor to the wave functions at the donor nucleus. Using the corrected wave functions, we formulate a first-order perturbation theory for the perturbed system under the influence of an electric field. In order to calculate the potential distributions inside the silicon and the silicon dioxide layers due to the applied electric field, we use the multilayered Green's functions and solve an integral equation by the moment method. This enables us to consider more realistic, arbitrary shape, and three-dimensional qubit structures. With the calculation of the potential distributions, we have investigated the effects of the thicknesses of silicon and silicon dioxide layers, the relative position of the donor, and the applied electric field on the nuclear magnetic resonance frequency of the donor.

A structural investigation of the alkali metal site distribution within bioactive glass using neutron diffraction and multinuclear solid state NMR

The atomic-scale structure of Bioglass and the effect of substituting lithium for sodium within these glasses have been investigated using neutron diffraction and solid state magic angle spinning (MAS) NMR. Applying an effective isomorphic substitution difference function to the neutron diffraction data has enabled the Na-O and Li-O nearest-neighbour correlations to be isolated from the overlapping Ca-O, O-(P)-O and O-(Si)-O correlations. These results reveal that Na and Li behave in a similar manner within the glassy matrix and do not disrupt the short range order of the network former. Residual differences are attributed solely to the variation in ionic radius between the two species. Successful simplification of the 2 MAS (3QMAS) NMR data corroborates the split Na-O correlations. The structural sites present will be intimately related to the release properties of the glass system in physiological fluids such as plasma and saliva, and hence to the bioactivity of the material. Detailed structural knowledge is therefore a prerequisite for optimizing material design.

An examination of the calcium and strontium site distribution in bioactive glasses through isomorphic neutron diffraction, X-ray diffraction, EXAFS and multinuclear solid state NMR.

Strontium has been substituted for calcium in the glass series (SiO2)49.46(Na2O)26.38(P2O5)1.07(CaO)23.08x(SrO)x (where x = 0, 11.54, 23.08) to elucidate their underlying atomic-scale structural characteristics as a basis for understanding features related to the bioactivity. These bioactive glasses have been investigated using isomorphic neutron and X-ray diffraction, Sr K-edge EXAFS and solid state 17O, 23Na, 29Si, 31P and 43Ca magic-angle-spinning (MAS) NMR. An effective isomorphic substitution first-order difference function has been applied to the neutron diffraction data, confirming that Ca and Sr behave in a similar manner within the glass network, with residual differences attributed to solely the variation in ionic radius between the two species. The diffraction data provides the first direct experimental evidence of split Ca–O nearest-neighbour correlations in these melt quench bioactive glasses, together with an analogous splitting of the Sr–O correlations; the correlations are attributed to the metal ions correlated either to bridging or to non-bridging oxygen atoms. Triple quantum (3Q) 43Ca MAS NMR corroborates the split Ca–O correlations. Successful simplification of the 2 < r (A) < 3 region via the difference method has also revealed two distinct Na environments. These environments are attributed to sodium correlated either to bridging or to nonbridging oxygen atoms. Complementary multinuclear MAS NMR, Sr K-edge EXAFS and X-ray diffraction data supports the structural model presented. The structural sites present will be intimately related to their release properties in physiological fluids such as plasma and saliva, and hence the bioactivity of the material. Detailed structural knowledge is therefore a prerequisite for optimising material design.

Stereochemistry of Peptides Containing 1-AminocyclopentanecarboxylicA cid ( Am5): Solution and Solid-state Conformations of Boc-Acc '-Acc'-NHMe

The conformational analysis of a protected homodipeptide of 1-aminocyclopentanecarboxylic acid (Acc5) has been carried out. 1H-nmr studies establish a -turn conformation for Boc-Acc5-Acc5-NHMe in chloroform and dimethylsulfoxide solutions involving the methylamide NH in an intramolecular hydrogen bond. Supportive evidence for the formation of an intramolecular hydrogen bond is obtained from ir studies. X-ray diffraction studies reveal a type III -turn conformation in the solid state stabilized by a 4 1 hydrogen bond between the Boc CO and methylamide NH groups. The , values for both Acc5 residues are close to those expected for an ideal 310-helical conformation ( ± 60°, ±30°).