Ferroelasticity in CSIO4

Optical examination of orthorhombic CsIO4 crystals has revealed the existence of ferroelastic domains. That they are ferroelastic domains was confirmed by subjecting the crystal to external stresses. Our results strongly suggest that the transition at 150°C is of the species 4/mmmFmmm in Aim's terminology.

Ferroelastic phase transition in CslO4

An optical investigation of the high-temperature structural phase transition in gel-grown single crystals of CslO4 is reported. This crystal undergoes a phase transition from the room-temperature orthorhombic phase of symmetry Pnma to a tetragonal phase at 150°C. The birefringence Δn = |na-nb| falls abruptly at Tc, indicating the first-order nature of the phase transition. Microscopic examination has revealed the existence of ferroelastic domains in the crystal. The domain structure and its dependence on temperature was studied in detail. The experimental results suggest that this crystal can be assigned to the ferroelastic Aizu species 4/mmmFmmm (p).

HNbWO6 and HTaWO6: Novel layered oxides related to the rutile structure. Synthesis and investigation of ion-exchange and intercalation behaviour

New protonated layered oxides, HMWO6·1.5H2O (M=Nb or Ta), have been synthesized by topotactic exchange of lithium in trirutile LiMWO6 with protons by treatment with dilute HNO3. The tetragonal cell constants are a=4.71 (2) and c=25.70 (8)Å for HNbWO6·1.5H2O and a=4.70 (2) and c=25.75 (9) Å for HTaWO6·1.5H2O. Partially hydrated compounds, HMWO6·0.5H2O and anhydrous compounds, HMWO6 retain the layered structure. The structure of these oxides consists of MWO6 sheets built up of M/W-oxygen octahedra with rutile type corner- and edge-sharing. Interlayer protons in HMWO6 are exchanged with Li+, Na+, K+ and Tl+. HMWO6 exhibit Brønsted acidity intercalating n-alkylamines and pyridine.

Optimization of sample preparation for next-generation sequencing with Illumina Genome Analyzer II

The growing interest for sequencing with higher throughput in the last decade has led to the development of new sequencing applications. This thesis concentrates on optimizing DNA library preparation for Illumina Genome Analyzer II sequencer. The library preparation steps that were optimized include fragmentation, PCR purification and quantification. DNA fragmentation was performed with focused sonication in different concentrations and durations. Two column based PCR purification method, gel matrix method and magnetic bead based method were compared. Quantitative PCR and gel electrophoresis in a chip were compared for DNA quantification. The magnetic bead purification was found to be the most efficient and flexible purification method. The fragmentation protocol was changed to produce longer fragments to be compatible with longer sequencing reads. Quantitative PCR correlates better with the cluster number and should thus be considered to be the default quantification method for sequencing. As a result of this study more data have been acquired from sequencing with lower costs and troubleshooting has become easier as qualification steps have been added to the protocol. New sequencing instruments and applications will create a demand for further optimizations in future.

Diabetic cardiomyopathy and post-infarct ventricular remodelling : Effects of levosimendan in a rodent model of type II diabetes

Type 2 diabetes is a risk factor for the development of cardiovascular disease. Recently, the term diabetic cardiomyopathy has been proposed to describe the changes in the heart that occur in response to chronic hyperglycemia and insulin resistance. Ventricular remodelling in diabetic cardiomyopathy includes left ventricular hypertrophy, increased interstitial fibrosis, apoptosis and diastolic dysfunction. Mechanisms behind these changes are increased oxidative stress and renin-angiotensin system activation. The diabetic Goto-Kakizaki rat is a non-obese model of type 2 diabetes that exhibits defective insulin signalling. Recently two interconnected stress response pathways have been discovered that link insulin signalling, longevity, apoptosis and cardiomyocyte hypertrophy. The insulin-receptor PI3K/Ak pathway inhibits proapoptotic FOXO3a in response to insulin signalling and the nuclear Sirt1 deacetylase inhibits proapoptotic p53 and modulates FOXO3a in favour of survival and growth. --- Levosimendan is a calcium sensitizing agent used for the management of acute decompensated heart failure. Levosimendan acts as a positive inotrope by sensitizing cardiac troponin C to calcium and exerts vasodilation by opening mitochondrial and sarcolemmal ATP-sensitive potassium channels. Levosimendan has been described to have beneficial effects in ventricular remodelling after myocardial infarction. The aims of the study were to characterize whether diabetic cardiomyopathy associates with cardiac dysfunction, cardiomyocyte apoptosis, hypertrophy and fibrosis in spontaneously diabetic Goto-Kakizaki (GK) rats, which were used to model type 2 diabetes. Protein expression and activation of the Akt FOXO3a and Sirt1 p53 pathways were examined in the development of ventricular remodelling in GK rats with and without myocardial infarction (MI). The third and fourth studies examined the effects of levosimendan on ventricular remodelling and gene expression in post-MI GK rats. The results demonstrated that diabetic GK rats develop both modest hypertension and features similar to diabetic cardiomyopathy including cardiac dysfunction, LV hypertrophy and fibrosis and increased apoptotic signalling. MI induced a sustained increase in cardiomyocyte apoptosis in GK rats together with aggravated LV hypertrophy and fibrosis. The GK rat myocardium exhibited decreased Akt- FOXO3a phosphorylation and increased nuclear translocation of FOXO3a and overproduction of the Sirt1 protein. Treatment with levosimendan decreased cardiomyocyte apoptosis, senescence and LV hypertrophy and altered the gene expression profile in GK rat myocardium. The findings indicate that impaired cardioprotection via Akt FOXO3a and p38 MAPK is associated with increased apoptosis, whereas Sirt1 functions in counteracting apoptosis and the development of LV hypertrophy in the GK rat myocardium. Overall, levosimendan treatment protects against post-MI ventricular remodelling and alters the gene expression profile in the GK rat myocardium.

Human parvovirus infections during pregnancy : Special reference to the child-care employees

Human parvovirus B19 (B19V) is known to cause anemia, hydrops fetalis, and fetal death especially during the first half of pregnancy. Women who are in occupational contact with young children are at increased risk of B19V infection. The role of the recently discovered human parvovirus, human bocavirus (HBoV), in reproduction is unknown. The aim of this research project was to establish a scientific basis for assessing the work safety of pregnant women and for issuing special maternity leave regulations during B19V epidemics in Finland. The impact of HBoV infection on the pregnant woman and her fetus was also defined. B19V DNA was found in 0.8% of the miscarriages and in 2.4% of the intrauterine fetal death (IUFD; fetal death after completed 22 gestational weeks). All control fetuses (from induced abortions) were B19V-DNA negative. The findings on hydropic B19V DNA-positive IUFDs with evidence of acute or recent maternal B19V infection are in line with those of previous Swedish studies. However, the high prevalence of B19V-related nonhydropic IUFDs noted in the Swedish studies was mostly without evidence of maternal B19V infection and was not found during the third trimester. HBoV was not associated with miscarriages or IUFDs. Almost all of the studied pregnant women were HboV-IgG positive, and thus most probably immune to HBoV. All preterm births, perinatal deaths, smallness for gestational age (SGA) and congenital anomaly were recorded among the infants of child-care employees in a nationwide register-based cohort study over a period of 14 years. Little or no differences in the results were found between the infants of the child-care employees and those of the comparison group. The annual B19V seroconversion rate was over two-fold among the child-care employees, compared to the women in the comparison group. The seropositivity of the child-care employees increased with age, and years from qualification/joining the trade union. In general, the child-care employees are not at increased risk for adverse pregnancy outcome. However, at the population level, the risk of rare events, such as adverse pregnancy outcomes attributed to infections, could not be determined. According to previous studies, seronegative women had a 5 10% excess risk of losing the fetus during the first half of their pregnancy, but thereafter the risk was very low. Therefore, an over two-fold increased risk of B19V infection among child-care employees is considerable, and should be taken into account in the assessment of the occupational safety of pregnant women, especially during the first half of their pregnancy.

Bacteria colonizing paper machines

Bacteria growing in paper machines can cause several problems. Biofilms detaching from paper machine surfaces may lead to holes and spots in the end product or even break the paper web leading to expensive delays in production. Heat stable endospores will remain viable through the drying section of paper machine, increasing the microbial contamination of paper and board. Of the bacterial species regularly found in the end products, Bacillus cereus is the only one classified as a pathogen. Certain B. cereus strains produce cereulide, the toxin that causes vomiting disease in food poisonings connected to B. cereus. The first aim of this thesis was to identify harmful bacterial species colonizing paper machines and to assess the role of bacteria in the formation of end product defects. We developed quantitative PCR methods for detecting Meiothermus spp. and Pseudoxanthomonas taiwanensis. Using these methods I showed that Meiothermus spp. and Psx. taiwanensis are major biofoulers in paper machines. I was the first to be able to show the connection between end product defects and biofilms in the wet-end of paper machines. I isolated 48 strains of primary-biofilm forming bacteria from paper machines. Based on one of them, strain K4.1T, I described a novel bacterial genus Deinobacterium with Deinobacterium chartae as the type species. I measured the transfer of Bacillus cereus spores from packaging paper into food. To do this, we constructed a green fluorescent protein (GFP) labelled derivative of Bacillus thuringiensis and prepared paper containing spores of this strain. Chocolate and rice were the recipient foods when transfer of the labelled spores from the packaging paper to food was examined. I showed that only minority of the Bacillus cereus spores transferred into food from packaging paper and that this amount is very low compared to the amount of B. cereus naturally occurring in foods. Thus the microbiological risk caused by packaging papers is very low. Until now, the biological function of cereulide for the producer cell has remained unknown. I showed that B. cereus can use cereulide to take up K+ from environment where K+ is scarce: cereulide binds K+ ions outside the cell with high affinity and transports these ions across cell membrane into the cytoplasm. Externally added cereulide increased the growth rate of cereulide producing strains in medium where potassium was growth limiting. In addition, cereulide producing strains outcompeted cereulide non-producing B. cereus in potassium deficient environment, but not when the potassium concentration was high. I also showed that cereulide enhances biofilm formation of B. cereus.

Optical Tweezers for Single Molecule Biology

Molecular machinery on the micro-scale, believed to be the fundamental building blocks of life, involve forces of 1-100 pN and movements of nanometers to micrometers. Micromechanical single-molecule experiments seek to understand the physics of nucleic acids, molecular motors, and other biological systems through direct measurement of forces and displacements. Optical tweezers are a popular choice among several complementary techniques for sensitive force-spectroscopy in the field of single molecule biology. The main objective of this thesis was to design and construct an optical tweezers instrument capable of investigating the physics of molecular motors and mechanisms of protein/nucleic-acid interactions on the single-molecule level. A double-trap optical tweezers instrument incorporating acousto-optic trap-steering, two independent detection channels, and a real-time digital controller was built. A numerical simulation and a theoretical study was performed to assess the signal-to-noise ratio in a constant-force molecular motor stepping experiment. Real-time feedback control of optical tweezers was explored in three studies. Position-clamping was implemented and compared to theoretical models using both proportional and predictive control. A force-clamp was implemented and tested with a DNA-tether in presence of the enzyme lambda exonuclease. The results of the study indicate that the presented models describing signal-to-noise ratio in constant-force experiments and feedback control experiments in optical tweezers agree well with experimental data. The effective trap stiffness can be increased by an order of magnitude using the presented position-clamping method. The force-clamp can be used for constant-force experiments, and the results from a proof-of-principle experiment, in which the enzyme lambda exonuclease converts double-stranded DNA to single-stranded DNA, agree with previous research. The main objective of the thesis was thus achieved. The developed instrument and presented results on feedback control serve as a stepping stone for future contributions to the growing field of single molecule biology.

Temperature and thiol-induced desensitization of a Ca2+-sensitive cyclic-3',5'-nucleotide phosphodiesterase from sheep lung

Ca2+-sensitivity of sheep lung cyclic-3',5'-nucleotide phosphodiesterase is provided by endogenous tightly bound calmodulin. The calcium sensitivity of a highly purified enzyme was desensitized by increasing the assay temperature. It could also be desensitized to Ca2+-activation by thiols such as dithiothreitol. The thiol-induced desensitization could be partially reversed by dialysis and almost completely reversed by dilution. The results presented in this paper indicate that thiols are possibly involved in the interaction of calmodulin with cyclic-3',5'-nucleotide phosphodiesterase. This is the first report on temperature and thiol-induced desensitization of Ca2+-sensitivity of a cyclic-3',5'-nucleotide phosphodiesterase.

Suomenhevosorien osteokondroosin vaikutus seuraavan sukupolven ravikilpailumenestykseen

Osteokondroosi (OC) on hevosten ortopedisistä kehityshäiriöistä yleisin kirurgiaa vaativa sairaustila. Se on sairautena monelta osin vielä hyvin epäselvä. Perinnöllisyyden osuus sen ilmentymisessä on noin 25 %. Suomenhevosilla OC:n esiintyvyyttä ei ole tutkittu, mutta sen osuuden epäillään kasvavan jatkuvasti. Suomessa pääsääntöisesti vain juoksijasuuntaan kantakirjatun suomenhevosorin jälkeläinen voi saada ravikilpailuoikeuden. Kantakirjauksen yhteydessä tehdyn röntgentutkimuksen avulla OC:ta sairastavat yksilöt voidaan hylätä ja siten sulkea pois jalostuksesta. Tästä käytännöstä voidaan poiketa, mikäli orilla on poikkeuksellisen hyviä kilpailutuloksia. Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli selvittää, onko OC:ta sairastavien orien hyväksyminen kantakirjaan riski suomenhevosravureiden tulevien sukupolvien kilpailumenestykselle. Tutkimusta oli kohorttitutkimus, jossa kilpailumenestyksen mittareina käytettiin starttistatusta, starttien määrää, sijoituksia, voittosummia, ennätysaikoja, hylkäyksiä, keskeytyksiä sekä kilpailupöytäkirjoihin kirjattuja laukka- ja epäpuhdas ravi – merkintöjä. Tutkimuksessa verrattiin suomenhevosravurien, joiden isällä on OC, kilpailumenestystä niiden suomenhevosravurien kilpailumenestykseen, joiden isäoriit oli kantakirjauksen yhteydessä todettu jaloistaan terveiksi (OC-vapaiksi). OC:lle altistuneista jälkeläisistä koostuvan ryhmän isäoreiksi valittiin kaikki juoksijasuuntaiset, OC:ta sairastavat suomenhevosoriit. OC:ta sairastavien orien jälkeläisiä oli tutkimuksessa mukana 435 ja OC-vapaiden orien jälkeläisiä 863. Aineistolle tehtiin tilastollinen analyysi Pearsonin χ²-testiä ja varianssianalyysia käyttäen. Voima-analyysi tehtiin jälkikäteen, jolloin todettiin, että tutkimuksen voima todeta havaittuja eroja oli parhaimmillaankin vain 50 % tasolla. Tuloksista ainoa tilastollisesti merkitsevä ero löytyi verrattaessa ravikilpailuissa startanneiden jälkeläisten osuuksia edellä mainituissa ryhmissä. OC:ta sairastavien isäorien jälkeläisistä yhteen tai useampaan ravikilpailulähtöön oli osallistunut 40,2 % hevosista, kun vastaava luku OC-vapaiden isäorien jälkeläisryhmässä oli 34,6 % (p=0,049). Vaikka muut tulokset olivatkin tilastollisesti merkityksettömiä, saattavat ne antaa viitteitä siitä, että OC:ta sairastavien orien jälkeläisten ura on lyhyempi, mutta mahdollisesti menestyksekkäämpi kuin OC-vapaiden orien jälkeläisillä. Tutkimuksen tulokset ja erityisesti niiden vertaaminen aiempiin tutkimuksiin tukevat käsitystä siitä, että OC periytyy mahdollisesti yhdessä hyvään juoksukykyyn liittyvien ominaisuuksien kanssa. Lisäksi tutkimus kyseenalaistaa, onko suomenhevosravurien kantakirjauksesta poissulkeminen tarkoituksenmukaista OC:n perusteella. Kyseessä on etiologialtaan ja diagnoosin kannalta hyvin haastava sairaus, jolla ei aina ole kliinistä merkitystä.

Two levels of MCT1 and CD147 expression in the equine red blood cells and muscle

Monocarboxylate transporters (MCTs), especially the isoforms MCT1 - MCT4, cotransport lactate and protons across the cell membranes. They are thus essential for pH regulation and homeostasis in glycolytic cells such as red blood cells (RBCs), and skeletal muscle cells during intense exercise. In 70% of the Standardbred horses the lactate transport activity (TA) in RBCs is high and transport is mediated mainly by MCTs. In the rest 30% of the Standardbreds MCT mediated transport route is not active and the TA is low. MCTs need an ancillary protein for their proper localization and functioning in the plasma membrane. The ancillary protein for MCT1 and MCT4 is a member of immunoglobulin superfamily, CD147. Here we determined the expression of MCT isoforms and CD147 in equine RBCs and gluteal muscle. We sequenced the cDNA of horse MCT1 and CD147 to achieve horse-specific antibodies and to reveal sequence variations that may affect the TA of RBCs. The amount of MCT1 and CD147 mRNA in muscle were also studied. ---- In all, 73 horses representing different breeds were used. Blood samples were drawn from the jugular vein and muscle samples were taken either from gluteal muscle using biopsy needle or during castration from expendable cremaster muscle. The TA of RBCs was studied using radiolabeled lactate and the amount of MCT isoforms and CD147 in the plasma membranes using Western blotting. The level of mRNA in muscle cells was determined using qPCR. Isoforms MCT1 and MCT2 were found in the RBCs and isoforms MCT1 and MCT4 in the muscle cells of horses. The TA of RBCs was dependent on the expression of CD147 and MCT1 in the plasma membrane. Sequence variations were found in the cDNA of both MCT1 and CD147, but they did not explain the inactivity of MCT1 mediated transport route. The single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) Met125Val in CD147 that existed parallel with an SNP in 3´-untranslated region explained, however, attenuation in CD147 expression in Standardbreds. A single mutation Ile51Val also decreased the expression of CD147 in one Warmblood. The MCT1 and CD147 mRNA concentrations in the gluteal muscle were higher in horses with higher MCT1 and CD147 expression in RBCs and lower in horses with minor expression of CD147 and MCT1. This suggests that the bimodal distribution of TA is due to differences in transcriptional regulation that is functioning in parallel in MCT1 and CD147 gene.

Psychologically-Based and Content-Oriented Experience in Entertainment Virtual Environments

In daily life, rich experiences evolve in every environmental and social interaction. Because experience has a strong impact on how people behave, scholars in different fields are interested in understanding what constitutes an experience. Yet even if interest in conscious experience is on the increase, there is no consensus on how such experience should be studied. Whatever approach is taken, the subjective and psychologically multidimensional nature of experience should be respected. This study endeavours to understand and evaluate conscious experiences. First I intro-duce a theoretical approach to psychologically-based and content-oriented experience. In the experiential cycle presented here, classical psychology and orienting-environmental content are connected. This generic approach is applicable to any human-environment interaction. Here I apply the approach to entertainment virtual environments (VEs) such as digital games and develop a framework with the potential for studying experiences in VEs. The development of the methodological framework included subjective and objective data from experiences in the Cave Automatic Virtual Environment (CAVE) and with numerous digital games (N=2,414). The final framework consisted of fifteen factor-analytically formed subcomponents of the sense of presence, involvement and flow. Together, these show the multidimensional experiential profile of VEs. The results present general experiential laws of VEs and show that the interface of a VE is related to (physical) presence, which psychologically means attention, perception and the cognitively evaluated realness and spatiality of the VE. The narrative of the VE elicits (social) presence and involvement and affects emotional outcomes. Psychologically, these outcomes are related to social cognition, motivation and emotion. The mechanics of a VE affect the cognitive evaluations and emotional outcomes related to flow. In addition, at the very least, user background, prior experience and use context affect the experiential variation. VEs are part of many peoples lives and many different outcomes are related to them, such as enjoyment, learning and addiction, depending on who is making the evalua-tion. This makes VEs societally important and psychologically fruitful to study. The approach and framework presented here contribute to our understanding of experiences in general and VEs in particular. The research can provide VE developers with a state-of-the art method (www.eveqgp.fi) that can be utilized whenever new product and service concepts are designed, prototyped and tested.

The role of inflammation and matrix proteins in airway remodelling

Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disorder of the airways. Remodelling in asthma is defined as the structural changes seen in the airways of asthmatics in comparison to healthy controls. Progressive loss of lung function also seen in asthma might be caused by remodelling. The research aims of this thesis were to investigate inflammation and remodelling in the airways of different types of asthmatics and smokers. The association between inflammation and remodelling was also examined in a mouse model of allergic airway inflammation. Healthy smokers showed increased numbers of macrophages in the BAL with no changes in the inflammatory cells in biopsies. Macrophages seemed to be quite quiescent, since mRNA expression for a wide variety of inflammatory mediators, especially chemokines CCL3, CCL4, CCL5 and CCL20, secreted by macrophages was significantly lower than in healthy non-smokers. Attenuated macrophage activity in the airway lumen may render smokers more susceptible to airway infections and have an impact on the development of other airway pathology. Patients with diisocyanate-induced asthma (DIA) on inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) who still had non-specific bronchial hyperreactivity (NSBHR) at the end of the follow-up showed increased expression of TNF-α, IL-6 and IL-15 mRNA in BAL cells compared to those without NSBHR. In addition to being markers for poor prognosis and possible slight glucocorticoid resistance, these cytokines might aid in guiding the treatment of DIA. The increase in the thickness of tenascin-C layer in the bronchial basement membrane (BM) was much less than usually seen in other types of asthma, which might not make tenascin-C a good marker for DIA. OVA-induced tenascin-C expression in the lung was attenuated in STAT4-/- mice with impaired Th1-type immunity compared to WT mice. Interestingly, STAT6-/- mice with impaired Th2-type immunity showed tenascin-C expression levels similar to those of WT mice. The clearest difference between these two knockout strains in response to OVA was that STAT4-/- mice exhibited no upregulation of IFN-γ and TNF-α mRNA expression. Thus, tenascin-C expression was unexpectedly more related to Th1 type reactions. In vitro studies confirmed the results. Human fibroblasts stimulated by TNF-α and IFN-γ showed increased expression of tenascin-C. Patients with newly diagnosed asthma showed increased expression of laminin α2 in the bronchial BM in comparison to patients with asthma symptoms only and healthy controls. Both patients with asthma and those with only asthma symptoms showed increased expression of the laminin β2 chain in comparison to controls. Thus, laminin α2 expression differentiated patients with clinical asthma from patients with symptoms only. Furthermore, the expression of laminin α2 and β2 was associated with NSBHR, linking very specific remodelling events to clinical findings.

"Suksi mafioso kuuseen ja tunge varastettu musasi syvälle!" : Tekijänoikeusalan etujärjestöjen peruskoululaisille tuottaman oppimateriaalin tekijänoikeusdiskurssien problematisointia

Problematisoin pro gradu -tutkielmassani tekijänoikeusdiskurssia. Aineistona käytän peruskoululaisille tuotettuja Piraatti-tehdas (2006) sekä Tekijänoikeus suojaa luovaa työtä (2008) –oppimateriaaleja. Tarkastelen kuinka tekijänoikeuksien haltijat pyrkivät aineiston kautta vaikuttamaan koululaisiin. Toteutan analyysini käyttäen hyväksi Arja Jokisen retoristen keinojen viitekehystä lähtökohtanani Bourdieun ajatus siitä, että kieli ei ole ainoastaan väline kommunikointiin, vaan myös vallankäytön väline. Lähestyn tekijänoikeuksia yhteiskunnallisena prosessina, sosiaalisena luomuksena. Lähtökohtani on, että tekijänoikeudet eivät ole luonnonoikeuksia vaan yhteiskunnallisen neuvottelun tuloksena syntyneitä. Tekijänoikeudessa on kyse arvovalinnoista ja vallasta: siitä kenen ääni kuuluu ja kuinka perustelut vahvistavat valta-asetelmia ja tuottavat sosiaalista todellisuutta. Esittelen tekijänoikeuspolitiikan kontekstin ymmärtämiseksi immateriaalioikeuksien ympärillä käytävää keskustelua, jonka yhtenä perimmäisistä kysymyksistä on, kuinka paljon yhteisiä hyödykkeitä on tarpeen aidata, me-neekö edelle yksilön vai yhteisön etu ja ovatko nämä keskenään, ja jos ovat niin millä perustein, yhteen sovitettavia. Oppimateriaalia voidaan kuvata sen laatijoiden pyrkimykseksi tuottaa neutralisoitua tekijänoikeuskuvaa. Tekijänoikeuden ajatellaan sääntelevän ja turvaavan vain omistusta ilman konflikteja muiden yhteiskunnallisten intressien kanssa. Materiaalista nousee esille vastakkainasettelu laillisen ja laittoman sekä moraalisuuden ja moraalittomuuden välillä. Materiaalin tuottajat ottavat oppiainemateriaalissa aseman, joka peilautuu suhteessa ei-toivottuun tilaan: laittomaan ja moraalittomaan. Retoriikassa pyritään asettamaan koululaiset lakia noudattavien moraalisten kansalaisten muottiin. Tämän muotin tekijänoikeuden etujärjestöt pyrkivät määrittämään, eikä muotin ulkopuolella ole tilaa. Etujärjestöjen maailmassa asiat ovat mustavalkoisia ja tekijöiden taloudelliset intressit koetaan kaikkien yhteisinä intresseinä. Argumentoinnin kautta hälvennetään sosiaalisen todellisuuden konstruktiivista rakennetta ja tuotetaan todellisuutta, jossa ei ole sijaa piraateille, joiden toimillaan arvioidaan saattavan kaiken uuden kulttuurin tuottamisen vaaranalaiseksi. Sen sijaan että tekijänoikeuskasvatuksellinen tehtävä suodaan tekijänoikeusalan järjestöille, olisi tarvetta moniääniselle kriittiselle yhteiskunnalliselle keskustelulle, jossa ovat mukana eri intressiryhmät ja joka tunnustaa sekä tekijänoikeuden esillä oleviin kysymyksiin liittyvät hyödyt että haitat. Oppimateriaali ilmentää ongelmallista ja pitkälti kyseenalaistamaton-ta tilannetta, jossa käytävä keskustelu noudattaa tekijänoikeusalan etujärjestöjen logiikkaa. Pohjimmiltaan kyse on siitä, että kuka hyötyy tekijänoikeudesta ja mikä on sen tehtävä? Vahvat tekijänoikeudet eivät välttämättä ole yhteiskunnan etu, niin jonkinlaiselle tekijänoikeudelle on kuitenkin myös tarve.