Estudi per la implantació d'un ERP de codi obert en una empresa de fabricació de mobles

Un sistema ERP és una aplicació informàtica que permet gestionar tots els processos de negoci d’una empresa de forma integrada. Aquest projecte tracta sobre l’estudi previ que s’ha de realitzar en una empresa abans de la implantació d’un sistema ERP. L’empresa escollida per l’estudi és una pyme de fabricació de mobles. En primer lloc, s’inclou una base teòrica sobre els sistemes ERP. Després, s’analitza el funcionament i requeriments de l’empresa escollida. Finalment, s’estudien tres sistemes ERP de codi obert, es selecciona el que millor s’adapta i es fa una proposta de la seva futura implantació.

End User Perspective to ERP Implementation

Toiminnanohjausjärjestelmät ovat oleellinen osa yrityksien liiketoimintaa. Järjestelmän päivittäminen uudempaan versioon tai kokonaan uuden järjestelmän käyttöönotto saattavat yrityksen ydintoiminnot ja prosessit hyvin haavoittuvaiseen asemaan. Järjestelmien kokonaisvaltaisuus yhdessä reaaliaikaisen käyttöönoton kanssa tekevät näistä projekteista erityisen haasteellisia. Tämä pro gradu -tutkielman tapaustutkimuskohteena toimi Andritz Oy. Tapaustutkimuksen tavoitteena oli arvioida kesäkuussa 2005 suoritettua toiminnanohjausjärjestelmän käyttöönottoa ja sitä kuinka hyvin tässä onnistuttiin. Tutkimus toteutettiin loppukäyttäjännäkökulmasta. Loppukäyttäjä omalla työllään voi vaikuttaa miten hyvin järjestelmästä tavoitellut hyödyt pystytään lunastamaan. Tutkimus on laadullinen tapaustutkimus. Tutkimuksessa kiinnitetään huomiota erityisestiprojektitiimin, johdon ja käyttäjien eroaviin näkemyksiin käyttöönoton onnistumisesta.

CREATING A MODEL FOR INVENTORY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

Tutkielman tarkoituksena oli mallintaa varastonhallintajärjestelmä, joka olisi sopiva case yritykselle. Tutkimus aloitettiin case yrityksen varastonhallinan nykytilan kartoituksella, jonka jälkeen tutkittiin varastonhallinnan eri osa-alueisiin. Varastonhallinnan osa-alueista käsiteltiin varastotyyppejä, motiiveja, tavoitteita, kysynnän ennustamista sekä erilaisia varastonhallinnan työkaluja. Sen lisäksi tutkittiin erilaisia varaston täydennysmalleja. Teoriaosuudessa käsiteltiin lisäksi kolmea erilaista tietojärjestelmätyyppiä: toiminnanohjausjärjestelmää, sähköisen kaupankäynnin järjestelmää sekä räätälöityä järjestelmää. Tutkimussuunnitelmassa nämä kolme järjestelmää rajattiin vaihtoehdoiksi, joista jokin valittaisiin case yrityksen varastonhallintajärjestelmäksi. Teorian ja nykytilan pohjalta tehtiin viitekehys, jossa esiteltiin varastonhallintajärjestelmän tieto- ja toiminnallisuusominaisuuksia. Nämä ominaisuudet priorisoitiin neljään eri luokkaan ominaisuuden kriittisyyden mukaan. Järjestelmävaihtoehdot arvioitiin viitekehyksen kriteerien mukaisesti, miten helposti ominaisuudet olisivat toteutettavissa eri vaihtoehdoissa. Tulokset laskettiin näiden arviointien perusteella, jonka jälkeen tulosten analysoinnissa huomattiin, että toiminnanohjausjärjestelmä sopisi parhaiten case yrityksen varastonhallintajärjestelmäksi.

Estudi per a la implantació d'un ERP en una empresa de fabricació de material per a minusvàlids

Un sistema ERP és una aplicació que ens permet fer la gestió dels processos de negoci de una forma àgil. Aquest projecte tracta sobre l’estudi per a la implantació d’un ERP en una empresa de fabricació de material per a minusvàlids. Inicialment es farà una part teòrica sobre el que són els sistemes ERP. A continuació, s’analitza el funcionament de l’empresa on es realitzarà l’estudi. Finalment, s’estudien tres solucions ERP del mercat actual i es selecciona la que millor s’adapta a les necessitats i requeriments en vistes a una possible implantació.

Supporting Solution Business with an Integrated Enterprise System

Some of the world’s leading companies now compete by providing integrated solutions to identify and solve each customer’s business problem by providing services to design, integrate, operate and finance a product or system during its life cycle. At the same time, because of the requirements of new global economy, companies are implementing new integrated ERP systems. The objective of this thesis was to define how solution offering can be implemented in the integrated ERP system so that it is possible to sell, deliver and maintain solution offering with the new enterprise applications. The research was conducted as a qualitative case study research consisting of literature review, theme-interviews and an analysis phase. For a start this study introduces new insight for combining solution business, offering modeling and modern ERP system theories. The results of this research illustrate the limitations of an integrated ERP system to support solution business and show the need to develop a commercial product model in order to improve the combination of solution offering and IT systems.

ERP-järjestelmän käytön laajentaminen yrityksen toimitusketjun hallinnan kehittämiseksi

Tavoitteena tässä diplomityössä on selvittää, hyödyntääkö kohdeyritys jo olemassa olevaa ERP-järjestelmäänsä riittävästi ja kuinka ERP-järjestelmä implementoidaan hallitusti yrityksen kahteen uuteen toimipisteeseen. Tavoitteen saavuttamiseksi, työssä tarkastellaan yrityksen ERP-järjestelmällä toteutettavaa toiminnanohjausta ja tarkastelussa havaittuihin epäkohtiin sekä puutteellisuuksiin pyritään löytämään korjaava kehitystoimenpide. Toiminnanohjauksen kehittämisen jälkeen työssä perehdytään ERP-järjestelmän implementointiprosessiin. Työ alkaa teoriaosuudella, jossa käsitellään aluksi ERP-järjestelmiä koskevia perusasioita kirjallisuutta hyödyntäen. Teoriaosuuden toisessa luvussa paneudutaan ERP-järjestelmien implementointiprosessiin laajan kirjallisuusaineiston pohjalta. Työn empiriaosuuden aloittaa kohdeyrityksen toiminnanohjauksen nykytilan kartoitus, jota seuraa kartoituksessa tunnistettujen epäkohtien kehitysehdotukset. Empiriaosuuden viimeinen luku kuvaa kohdeyrityksen uuteen toimipisteeseen aloitettua ERP-järjestelmän implementointiprosessia. Työn tulokset osoittavat, millaisilla toimenpiteillä kohdeyrityksen toiminnanohjausta voidaan kehittää entisestään. Tulokset ohjaavat yritystä ERP-järjestelmänsä tehokkaampaan hyödyntämiseen. Työstä ilmenee lisäksi, kuinka vaativa prosessi ERP-järjestelmän implementointi uuteen toimipisteeseen on ja mitkä tekijät vaikuttavat eniten implementointiprosessissa onnistumiseen.

ERP implementation in SMEs : Consultant – Client Views On Critical Success Factors

ERP system is now attracting the SMEs, as it is now economical and affordable for them. The current research emphasizes on “how to make ERP successful for SMEs”. The researchers have identified various critical success factors in implementation of ERP. The research gap noticed by author is the missing point of view of ERP consultant. This thesis investigates the answer of research question “What are the critical success factors in implementation of ERP system in SMEs in opinion of ERP consultants and acquiring organizations”. The purpose of this study is to identify the highly important and less important factors. The study results will suggest the ERP managers where they have to concentrate more in order to achieve success. Literature is reviewed in order to setup a base for empirical study. Aplenty of work is found related to CSFs, SMEs and ERP. The authors and factors are organized in form of a table that tells which author is agreed upon which factor. Final result of literature review is a list of 14 CSFs. The qualitative research methodology is used to investigate the ERP in Pakistani SMEs. A case study approach is selected because of unified nature of SMEs in Pakistan. A rice mill is selected as a case because it contains maximum SME attributes. The opinion of a Microsoft certified consultant is obtained by a semi-structured interview. Similarly a semi-structured interview is conducted with CIO of SME that acquired ERP. Both the interviewees are asked about all 14 factors, whether they are agree or not and why. The collected evidences then analyzed by tabulation. The factors upon which both the participants found agreed, taken as highly important. Similarly the factors upon which both participants found disagree, taken as less important. Study results present a grid with four quadrants, the CSFs highly important in opinion of both, the CSFs less important in opinion of both, CSFs important in opinion of consultant but not client, CSFs important in opinion of client but not consultant. In discussion part, the significance of each factor is discussed individually. It is discussed that why some factors are high/less important for SMEs in Pakistan. The study output communicates a message that the success of ERP system in SMEs is linked with careful management of five important factors, the project management, top management support, user training and education, consultant participation and ERP teamwork and composition. The ERP consultants and managers can divert their concentration from less important factors such as user involvement, culture readiness and ERP package selection, toward the highly important factors. The limitations of the study are small number of interviews and less people involved, provide an opportunity for future research in this field of information system.

Mitigating uncertainty in logistics outsourcing with ERP systems

Outsourcing is a common strategy for companies looking for cost savings and improvements in performance. This has been especially prevalent in logistics, where warehousing and transporting are typical targets for outsourcing. However, while the benefits from logistics outsourcing are clear on paper, there are several cases companies fail to reach these benefits. The most commonly cited reasons for this are poor information flow between the company and the third party logistics partner, and a lack of integration between the two partners. Uncertainty stems from lack of information, and it can cripple the whole outsourcing operation. This is where enterprise resource planning (ERP) systems step in, as they can have a significant role in improving the flow of information, and integration, which consequently mitigates uncertainty. The purpose of the study is to examine if ERP systems have an effect on a company's decision to outsource logistics operations. Along the rapid advancements in technology during the past decades, ERP systems have also evolved. Therefore, empirical research on the subject needs constant revision as it can quickly become outdated due to ERP systems having more advanced capabilities every year. The research was conducted using a qualitative single-case study of a Finnish manufacturing firm that had outsourced warehousing and transportation operations in the Swedish market. The empirical data was gathered with use of semi-structured interviews with three employees from the case company that were closely related to the outsourcing operation. The theoretical framework that was used to analyze the empirical data was based on Transaction Cost Economics theory. The results of the study were align with the theoretical framework, in that the ERP system of the case company was seen as an enabler for their logistics outsourcing operation. However, the full theoretical benefits from ERP systems concerning extended enterprise functionality and flexibility were not attained due to the case company having an older version of their ERP system. This emphasizes the importance of having up-to-date technology if you want to overcome the shortcomings of ERP systems in outsourcing situations.

ERP Systems as Investments: Analysing Costs vs. Benefits

An ERP system investment analysis method using a Fuzzy Pay-Off approach for Real Option valuation is examined. It is studied, how the investment can be incrementally adopted and analyzed as a compounding Real Option model. The modeling allows follow-up. IS system development model COCOMO is presented as an example for investment analysis. The thesis presents the usage of Real Options as an alternative for the valuation of an investment. An idea is presented to use a continuous investment follow-up during the investment. This analysis can be performed using Real Options. As a tool for the analysis, the Fuzzy Pay-Off method is presented as an alternative for investment valuation.

Competitive advantage through proprietary erp implementation: analysis of the project Väinämö

In the market where companies similar in size and resources are competing, it is challenging to have any advantage over others. In order to stay afloat company needs to have capability to perform with fewer resources and yet provide better service. Hence development of efficient processes which can cut costs and improve performance is crucial. As business expands, processes become complicated and large amount of data needs to be managed and available on request. Different tools are used in companies to store and manage data, which facilitates better production and transactions. In the modern business world the most utilized tool for that purpose is ERP - Enterprise Resource Planning system. The focus of this research is to study how competitive advantage can be achieved by implementing proprietary ERP system in the company; ERP system that is in-house created, tailor made to match and align business needs and processes. Market is full of ERP software, but choosing the right one is a big challenge. Identifying the key features that need improvement in processes and data management, choosing the right ERP, implementing it and the follow-up is a long and expensive journey companies undergo. Some companies prefer to invest in a ready-made package bought from vendor and adjust it according to own business needs, while others focus on creating own system with in-house IT capabilities. In this research a case company is used and author tries to identify and analyze why organization in question decided to pursue the development of proprietary ERP system, how it has been implemented and whether it has been successful. Main conclusion and recommendation of this research is for companies to know core capabilities and constraints before choosing and implementing ERP system. Knowledge of factors that affect system change outcome is important, to make the right decisions on strategic level and implement on operational level. Duration of the project in the case company has lasted longer than anticipated. It has been reported that in cases of buying ready product from vendor, projects are delayed and completed over budget as well. In general, in case company implementation of proprietary ERP has been successful both from business performance figures and usability of system by employees. In terms of future research, conducting a study to calculate statistically ROI of both approaches; of buying ready product and creating own ERP will be beneficial.

ERP-järjestelmän käyttöönoton vaikutuksia johdon laskentatoimeen: näkökulmia suomalaisista yrityksistä

The objective of this study is to examine effects of ERP-system implementations to management accounting in Finnish companies. Study also explores if ERP-system implementation has influenced to development of management accounting role in companies. Theory part of study examines ERP-system projects and ERP-systems influence to management accounting development. Research is qualitative and empirical material has been collected by interviews from three companies and they ERP-system vendor. According to results ERP-system implementation has affected positively to companies management accounting in many different ways and also influenced to development of management accounting role in companies.

An examination of factors influencing ERP key-user satisfaction: A qualitative case study

Several companies are trying to improve their operation efficiency by implementing an enterprise resource planning (ERP) system that makes it possible to control the resources of the company in real time. However, the success of the implementation project is not a foregone conclusion; a significant part of these projects end in a failure, one way or another. Therefore it is important to investigate ERP system implementation more closely in order to increase understanding about factors influencing ERP system success and to improve the probability of a successful ERP implementation project. Consequently, this study was initiated because a manufacturing case company wanted to review the success of their ERP implementation project. To be exact, the case company hoped to gain both information about the success of the project and insight for future implementation improvement. This study investigated ERP success specifically by examining factors that influence ERP key-user satisfaction. User satisfaction is one of the most commonly applied indicators of information system success. The research data was mainly collected by conducting theme interviews. The subjects of the interviews were six key-users of the newly implemented ERP system. The interviewees were closely involved in the implementation project. Furthermore, they act as representative users that utilize the new system in everyday business processes. The collected data was analyzed by thematizing. Both data collection and analysis were guided by a theoretical frame of reference. This frame was based on previous research on the subject. The results of the study aligned with the theoretical framework to large extent. The four principal factors influencing key-user satisfaction were change management, contractor service, key-user’s system knowledge and characteristics of the ERP product itself. One of the most significant contributions of the research is that it confirmed the existence of a connection between change management and ERP key-user satisfaction. Furthermore, it discovered two new sub-factors influencing contractor service related key-user satisfaction. In addition, the research findings indicated that in order to improve the current level of key-user satisfaction, the case company should pay special attention to system functionality improvement and enhancement of the key-users’ knowledge. During similar implementation projects in the future, it would be important to assure the success of change management and contractor service related processes.

ERP-projekti muutosprosessina - Case-yrityksen henkilöstön näkemys muutosjohtamisesta ERP-projektin aikana

Uuden tietojärjestelmän hankinta on paitsi tekninen myös sosiaalinen muutos. Tieteelliset teoriat sekä tutkimukset osoittavat, että uuden tietojärjestelmän onnistunut käyttöönotto edellyttää sosioteknistä systeemiajattelua muutoksen läpivientiin. Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli osallistua yhteiskunnalliseen keskusteluun muutosjohtamisen tärkeydestä otettaessa käyttöön uutta teknologiaa sekä tutkia Case-yrityksen ERP-projektin muutosjohtamisen onnistumista. Tutkimuksen konteksti koostuu sosioteknisestä muutoksesta, jossa muutosjohtaminen nousee keskiöön. Tutkimuksessa kartoitettiin uuden ERP-järjestelmän käyttöönoton onnistumisen kannalta keskeiset muutosjohtamisen elementit: muutostarve, projektitiimi, visio ja tavoitteet, viestintä, koulutus, osallistaminen, sitouttaminen, johdon ja projektiryhmän tuki sekä muutoksen arviointi ja vakiinnuttaminen. Tutkimuksen empiirisessä osassa arvioitiin Case-yrityksen ERP-projektin muutosjohtamista henkilöstön näkökulmasta. Tutkimus toteutettiin laadullisena tapaustutkimuksena, jossa pääasiallisena aineistonkeruumenetelmänä käytettiin sähköistä puolistrukturoitua kyselylomaketta. Tulosten analysoinnin perusteella Case-yrityksen ERP-järjestelmän käyttöönotto sujui tyydyttävästi.

Replacing traditional ERP with EAI - the next generation’s ERP

Organizations often consider investing in a new Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system as a way to enhance their business processes, as it allows integrating information used by multiple different departments into a harmonized computing system. The hope of gaining significant business benefits, such as reducing operating costs, is the key reason why organizations have decided to invest in ERP systems since 1990’s. Still, all ERP projects do not end up in success, and deployment of ERP system does not necessarily guarantee the results people were waiting for. This research studies why organizations invest in ERP, but also what downsides ERP projects currently have. Additionally Enterprise Application Integrations (EAI) as next generation’s ERP solutions are studied to challenge and develop traditional ERP. The research questions are: What are the weaknesses in traditional ERP deployment in today’s business? How does the proposed next generation’s ERP answer to these weaknesses? At the beginning of the thesis, as an answer to the first research question, the basics of ERP implementation are introduced with both the pros and cons of investing in ERP. Key concepts such as IS integration and EAI are also studied. Empirical section of the thesis focuses on answering the second research question from the integration approach. A qualitative research is executed by interviewing five experienced IT professionals about EAI benefits, limitations, and problems. The thematic interview and questionnaire follow the presented ERP main elements from literature. The research shows that adopting traditional ERP includes multiple downsides, e.g. inflexibility and requiring big investments in terms of money. To avoid these critical issues, organizations could find a solution from integrations between their current IS. Based on the empirical study a new framework for the next generation’s ERP is created, consisting of a model and a framework that deal with various features regarding IS adoption. With this framework organizations can assess whether they should implement EAI or ERP. The model and framework suggest that there are multiple factors IT managers needs to consider when planning their IT investments, including their current IS, role of IT in the organization, as well as new system’s flexibility, investment level, and number of vendors. The framework created in the thesis encourages IT management to assess holistically their i) organization, ii) its IT, and iii) solution requirements in order to determine what kind of IS solution would suit their needs the best.

Replacing traditional ERP with EAI - the next generation’s ERP

Organizations often consider investing in a new Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system as a way to enhance their business processes, as it allows integrating information used by multiple different departments into a harmonized computing system. The hope of gaining significant business benefits, such as reducing operating costs, is the key reason why organizations have decided to invest in ERP systems since 1990’s. Still, all ERP projects do not end up in success, and deployment of ERP system does not necessarily guarantee the results people were waiting for. This research studies why organizations invest in ERP, but also what downsides ERP projects currently have. Additionally Enterprise Application Integrations (EAI) as next generation’s ERP solutions are studied to challenge and develop traditional ERP. The research questions are: What are the weaknesses in traditional ERP deployment in today’s business? How does the proposed next generation’s ERP answer to these weaknesses? At the beginning of the thesis, as an answer to the first research question, the basics of ERP implementation are introduced with both the pros and cons of investing in ERP. Key concepts such as IS integration and EAI are also studied. Empirical section of the thesis focuses on answering the second research question from the integration approach. A qualitative research is executed by interviewing five experienced IT professionals about EAI benefits, limitations, and problems. The thematic interview and questionnaire follow the presented ERP main elements from literature. The research shows that adopting traditional ERP includes multiple downsides, e.g. inflexibility and requiring big investments in terms of money. To avoid these critical issues, organizations could find a solution from integrations between their current IS. Based on the empirical study a new framework for the next generation’s ERP is created, consisting of a model and a framework that deal with various features regarding IS adoption. With this framework organizations can assess whether they should implement EAI or ERP. The model and framework suggest that there are multiple factors IT managers needs to consider when planning their IT investments, including their current IS, role of IT in the organization, as well as new system’s flexibility, investment level, and number of vendors. The framework created in the thesis encourages IT management to assess holistically their i) organization, ii) its IT, and iii) solution requirements in order to determine what kind of IS solution would suit their needs the best.