The accumulation of financial and social capital as a means to achieve a sustained competitive advantage for consumer co-operatives

By so far, scholars have discussed how the characteristics of consumer co-operatives (cooperative principles, values and the dual role of members as the users and owners) can potentially give them a competitive advantage over investor-owned firms (IOFs). In addition, concern for the community (as partly derived from locality and regionality) has been seen as a potential source of success for consumer co-operatives. On the other hand, the geographicbound purpose of consumer co-operation causes that consumer co-operative can be regarded as a challenging company form to manage. This is because, according to the purpose of consumer co-operation, co-operatives are obligated to 1) provide the owners with services and goods that are needed and do so at more affordable prices than their competitors do and/or 2) to operate in areas in which competitors do not want to operate (for example, because of the low profitability in certain area of business or region). Thus, consumer co-operatives have to operate very efficiently in order to execute this geographic-bound corporate purpose (e.g. they cannot withdraw from the competition during the declining stages of business). However, this efficiency cannot be achieved by any means; as the acceptance from the important regional stakeholders is the basic operational precondition and lifeline in the long run. Thereby, the central question for the survival and success of consumer co-operatives is; how should the consumer co-operatives execute its corporate purpose so it can be the best alternative to its members in the long run? This question has remained unanswered and lack empirical evidence in the previous studies on the strategic management of consumer cooperation. In more detail, scholars have not yet empirically investigated the question: How can consumer co-operatives use financial and social capital to achieve a sustained competitive advantage? It is this research gap that this doctoral dissertation aims to fulfil. This doctoral dissertation aims to answer the above questions by combining and utilizing interview data from S Group co-operatives and the central organizations in S Group´s network (overall, 33 interviews were gathered), archival material and 56 published media articles/reports. The study is based on a qualitative case study approach that is aimed at theory development, not theory verification (as the theory is considered as nascent in this field of study). Firstly, the findings of this study indicate that consumer co-operatives accumulate financial capital; 1) by making profit (to invest and grow) and 2) by utilizing a network-based organizational structure (local supply chain economies). As a result of financial capital accumulation, consumer co-operatives are able to achieve efficiency gains but also remain local. In addition, a strong financial capital base increases consumer co-operatives´ independence, competitiveness and their ability to participate in regional development (which is in accordance with their geographically bound corporate purpose). Secondly, consumer cooperatives accumulate social capital through informal networking (with important regional stakeholders), corporate social responsibility (CSR) behaviour and CSR reporting, pursuing common good, and interacting and identity sharing. As a result of social capital accumulation, consumer co-operatives are able to obtain the resources for managing; 1) institutional dependencies and 2) customer relations. By accumulating both social and financial capital through the above presented actions, consumer co-operatives are able to achieve sustained competitive advantage. Finally, this thesis provides useful ideas and new knowledge for cooperative managers concerning why and how consumer co-operatives should accumulate financial and social capital (to achieve sustained competitive advantage), while aligning with their corporate purpose.

Enabling Change in Universities: Enhancing Education for Sustainable Development with Tools for Quality Assurance

Enabling Change in Universities: Enhancing Education for Sustainable Development with Tools for Quality Assurance This thesis deals with enabling change in universities, more explicitly enhancing education for sustainable development with tools for quality assurance. Change management is a discipline within management that was developed in the 1980s because business changed from being predictable to unpredictable. The PEST mnemonic is a method to categorize factors enabling change; such as political, economic, socio-cultural and technological factors, which all affect higher education. A classification of a change, in either hard or soft, can help understanding the type of change that an organization is facing. Hard changes are more applied to problems that have clear objectives and indicators, with a known cause of the problem. Soft changes are applied to larger problems that affect the entire organization or beyond it. The basic definition for sustainable development is: the future generations should have similar opportunities as the previous. The UN has set as a global goal an integration of education for sustainable development (ESD) at all levels of education during 2005- 2014. The goal is set also in universities, the graduates of which are future leaders for all labor markets. The objective for ESD in higher education is that graduates obtain the competence to take economic, social and environmental costs and benefits into account when making decisions. Knowledge outcomes should aim for systematic and holistic thinking, which requires cross disciplinary education. So far, the development of ESD has not achieved its goals. The UN has identified a need for more transdisclipnary research in ESD. A joint global requirement for universities is quality assurance, the aim of which is to secure and improve teaching and learning. Quality, environmental and integrated management systems are used by some universities for filling the quality assurance requirements. The goal of this thesis is to open up new ways for enhancing ESD in universities, beyond the forerunners; by exploring how management systems could be used as tools for promoting ESD. The thesis is based on five studies. In the first study, I focus on if and how tools for quality assurance could be benefitted for promoting ESD. It is written from a new perspective, the memetic, for reaching a diversity of faculty. A meme is an idea that diffuses from brain to brain. It can be applied for cultural evolution. It is a theory that is based on the evolutionary theory by Darwin, applied for social sciences. In the second Paper, I present the results from the development of the pilot process model for enhancing ESD with management systems. The development of the model is based on a study that includes earlier studies, a survey in academia and an analysis of the practice in 11 universities in the Nordic countries. In the third study, I explore if the change depends on national culture or if it is global. It is a comparative study on both policy and implementation level, between the Nordic countries and China. The fourth study is a single case study based on change management. In this study, I identify what to consider in order to enable the change: enhancing ESD with tools for quality assurance in universities. In the fifth Paper, I present the results of the process model for enhancing ESD with management systems. The model was compared with identified drivers and barriers for enhancing ESD and for implementing management systems. Finally, the process model was piloted and applied for identifying sustainability aspects in curricula. Action research was chosen as methodology because there are not already implemented approaches using quality management for promoting ESD, why the only way to study this is to make it happen. Another reason for choosing action research is since it is essential to involve students and faculty for enhancing ESD. Action based research consists of the following phases: a) diagnosing, b) planning action, c) taking action and d) evaluating action. This research was made possible by a project called Education for Sustainable Development in Academia in the Nordic countries, ESDAN, in which activities were divided into these four phases. Each phase ended with an open seminar, where the results of the study were presented. The objective for the research project was to develop a process for including knowledge in sustainable development in curricula, which could be used in the quality assurance work. Eleven universities from the Nordic countries cooperated in the project. The aim was, by applying the process, to identify and publish examples of relevant sustainability aspects in different degree programs in universities in the Nordic countries. The project was partly financed by the Nordic Council of Ministers and partly by the participating pilot universities. Based on the results of my studies, I consider that quality, environmental and integrated management systems can be used for promoting ESD in universities. Relevant sustainability aspects have been identified in different fields of studies by applying the final process model. The final process model was compared with drivers and barriers for enhancing ESD and for implementing management systems in universities and with succeeding with management systems in industry. It corresponds with these, meaning that drivers are taken into account and barriers tackled. Both ESD and management systems in universities could be considered successful memes, which can reflect an effective way of communication among individuals. I have identified that management systems could be used as tools for hard changes and to support the soft change of enhancing ESD in universities with management system. Based on the change management study I have summarized recommendations on what to consider in order to enable the studied change. The main practical implications of the results are that the process model could be applied for assessment, benchmarking and communication of ESD, connected to quality assurance, when applied. This is possible because the information can be assembled in one picture, which facilitates comparison. The memetic approach can be applied for structuring. It is viable to make comparative studies between cultures, for getting insight in special characteristics of the own culture. Action based research is suitable for involving faculty. Change management can be applied for planning a change, which both enhancing ESD and developing management systems are identified to be.

Risk Management in Sustainable Supply Chain

Growing awareness in corporate responsibility and issues related to sustainability is seen to increase innovativeness in a company as well as in its supply chain. The stakeholders’ awareness on sustainability has increased, and they demand the companies to identify sustainability risks and adapt procedures for mitigating them. The purpose of this thesis is to examine how risks are managed in sustainable supply chain. Definition of sustainability risks and risk management procedures construct the framework of the study. It is done through an empirical study conducted on 95 Finnish companies operating in the manufacturing industry. The data is acquired via an online questionnaire. The research has been conducted as a quantitative study utilizing the methods of statistical analysis, such as correlation analysis and factor analysis. The essential results of this thesis are identified risk-procedure connections, and the importance of different risks and procedures in the respondent companies.

Yhteiskuntavastuullinen toimittajavalinta

Yritysten yhteiskuntavastuu on viime vuosina noussut merkittäväksi osaksi yritysten jokapäiväistä toimintaa. Yhteiskuntavastuun aseman kehittymiseen yritysten strategiseksi valinnaksi on edesauttanut internetin sidosryhmille tarjoama lähes rajaton informaatio, joka on pakottanut yritykset muuttamaan toimintatapojaan kestävämpään suuntaan. Nykyinen asetelma on myös pakottanut yritykset miettimään uudestaan mitä he yhteiskuntavastuullaan haluavat sidosryhmilleen viestiä, ja miten he sen tekevät. Vastauksena tähän yritykset ovat kehittäneet voimakkaasti yhteiskuntavastuuraportointikäytäntöjään viime vuosien aikana, mikä näkyy muun muassa erialaisten raportointiohjeistusten hyödyntämisen yleistymisenä yhteiskuntavastuuraportoinnin apuvälineenä. Tämän tutkielman tarkoituksena on selvittää mitä yhteiskuntavastuu on, ja millaisia keinoja yrityksillä on integroida yhteiskuntavastuullinen toiminta osaksi hankintatoimeen kuuluvaa toimittajavalintaa. Työn empiriaosuus on toteutettu laadullisena tutkimuksena vertailemalla kahden suomalaisen eri toimialoilla toimivan yrityksen yhteiskuntavastuuraportteja, ja sen tavoitteena on löytää teemoja ja työkaluja, joiden avulla yritykset implementoivat yhteiskuntavastuuta toimittajavalinnassaan. Tutkimuksen yksi merkittävimmistä löydöistä oli yritysten tarve nostaa sekä yhteiskuntavastuu että toimittajavalinta strategisiksi toiminnoiksi, mitä tukee molempien empiriaosuudessa käytettyjen yritysten yhteiskuntavastuuraporteista löytynyt maininta toimitusketjujen sekä toimittajavalinnan suuresta merkityksestä yritysten yhteiskuntavastuun toteuttamisen välineenä.

Analyzing the learning of the taking personal and social responsibility model within a new physical education undergraduate degree program in El Salvador

EI Salvador presents an unfortunate history that includes a military regime and a civil war that together created a legacy of violence in which the country still struggle nowadays. Salud Escolar Integral (SEI) was created in 2005 as a program to combat youth violence throughout the re-formulation of physical education (PE) classes in public schools, promoting life skills learning that supports the resolution of conflicts with nonviolent ways. In 2007, SEI supported the creation of a physical e~ucation teacher education (PETE) degree at the Universidad Pedag6gica de EI Salvador (UPES), having the goal to assist pre-service teachers with a better understanding of humanistic principles. The present research analyzed if after attending all three years ofUPES PETE program, students presented high self-perception levels of competence and confidence related to attitude, skills and knowledge to teach PE within humanistic principles. Taking Personal and Social Responsibility (TPSR) was the theoretical framework used to analyze the development of humanistic principles. The study had a mixed-method longitudinal design that included questionnaires, reflection templates and interviews. In conclusion, although it is suggested that UPES should provide better support for the development of the teaching principles of empowering students and transfer learning, most of the humanistic principles were highly promoted by the program. At last, it is suggested that future research should track teachers' progress while teaching in schools, in order to analyze if the theory of promoting humanistic principles have also become a daily practice.

Ethique sur le marché : comment permettre le succès de produit intégrant une démarche éthique. Le cas de l’éco conception

Nous proposons dans ce texte de définir les vecteurs de valorisation marketing pour une entreprise proposant des produits éco-conçus. Nous commencerons par définir l’éco- conception en montrant en quoi c’est une innovation technique et managériale. Ensuite, nous présenterons notre cadre d'analyse : la RSE du point de vue de l'entreprise et la perception de la valeur environnementale par les consommateurs. Enfin, nous étudierons comment mettre sur le marché les produits éco-conçus.

Conséquences de l’interdépendance entre commerce équitable, développement durable et responsabilité sociétale de l’entreprise sur la normalisation du commerce équitable

Les résultats du processus de normalisation du commerce équitable – demandé par les associations de consommateurs agréées – peuvent être approchés, au moins, de deux manières complémentaires. Une première chercherait à comprendre pourquoi les acteurs impliqués n’ont pas réussi à obtenir le consensus utile pour la publication d’une norme. La seconde argumentant que l’intentionnalité des acteurs est primordiale dans tout changement économique. Aussi, en mobilisant la théorie de la dépendance au sentier cet article montre comment l’association, désormais, établie entre le commerce équitable, et des « systèmes plus vastes et plus complexes » comme la responsabilité sociétale des entreprises et le développement durable a contribué, partiellement, à rendre improbable la normalisation du commerce équitable dans le court terme, en France (AFNOR) et à un niveau international (ISO).

Conséquences de l’interdépendance entre commerce équitable, développement durable et responsabilité sociétale de l’entreprise sur la normalisation du commerce équitable

Les résultats du processus de normalisation du commerce équitable – demandé par les associations de consommateurs agréées – peuvent être approchés, au moins, de deux manières complémentaires. Une première chercherait à comprendre pourquoi les acteurs impliqués n’ont pas réussi à obtenir le consensus utile pour la publication d’une norme. La seconde argumentant que l’intentionnalité des acteurs est primordiale dans tout changement économique. Aussi, en mobilisant la théorie de la dépendance au sentier cet article montre comment l’association, désormais, établie entre le commerce équitable, et des « systèmes plus vastes et plus complexes » comme la responsabilité sociétale des entreprises et le développement durable a contribué, partiellement, à rendre improbable la normalisation du commerce équitable dans le court terme, en France (AFNOR) et à un niveau international (ISO).

Droits de l’homme, principes éthiques et industrie pétrolière

L’influence des multinationales pétrolières dans la société contemporaine est devenue un élément central de la problématique relative aux droits de l’homme et au développement durable. Elles sont maintenant très nombreuses à opérer dans le secteur public et privé avec des stratégies et objectifs particulièrement divers. Grâce à des budgets conséquents, et une technologie complexe et avant-gardiste, elles sont responsables de l’exploration, de la production, du raffinage et de la distribution du pétrole brut. Cela dit, dans le but de pointer du doigt les déséquilibres importants dans les relations entre l’industrie pétrolière et les pays en développement, la commission mondiale sur l’environnement et le développement a très tôt mis en avant le terme de « développement durable », se caractérisant par un « développement qui répond aux besoins du présent sans compromettre la capacité des générations futures à répondre aux leurs ». Le secteur pétrolier et gazier est déjà depuis un certain temps un leader en matière de responsabilité sociale. Les compagnies pétrolières attachent de plus en plus d’importance à leur impact économique, social et environnemental et elles font aussi de plus en plus attention à leur image. En plus d’autres éléments, ce phénomène se démontre par l’extraordinaire augmentation des codes de conduite et par des initiatives relatives à la responsabilité sociale comme le « global compact » de Kofi Annan. Cela dit, l’efficacité de ces initiatives est souvent remise en question et il existe un certain nombre de preuves attestant du fossé existant entre les déclarations de principes et le véritable comportement des acteurs sur le terrain. Toute la question est donc de savoir si une conciliation est possible. Mots-

Perspectives of Urban Growth Management and Sustainable Development In West Bank, Hebron District as a case Study

The main objective of this PhD research study is to provide a perspective on the urban growth management and sustainable development in Palestine, and more specifically in Hebron district as a case study. Hebron is located 36 km south of Jerusalem, with an overall population size of around 600,000 people living in a total area around1246km2. Hebron is the biggest Palestinian district that has 16 municipalities and 154 localities. The research discusses and analyzes the urban planning system, economical and environmental policies and the solution required to manage and integrate the development elements to develop a sustainable development plan for Hebron. The research provides answers for fundamental questions such as what kind and definition of sustainable development are applicable to the Palestinian case?. What are the sustainability problems there and how the Israeli occupation and unstable political condition affect the sustainable development in Palestine? What are the urban growth management and sustainability policies and actions required from government, public and privets sector in Palestine? The fast urban growth in Palestine is facing many problems and challenges due to the increase in the population size and the resulting impact of this increase including, but not limited to, the demand of new houses, need for more infrastructure services, demands on new industrial, commercial, educational and health projects, which in turn reduces the area of agricultural lands and threatens the natural resources and environment. There are also other associated sustainability problems like the absence of effective plans or regulations that control urban expansion, the absence of sufficient sustainable development plans at the national levels for the district, new job requirements, Israeli restrictions and occupation for more than 60 years, existence of construction factories near residential areas, poor public awareness and poor governmental funds for service projects and development plans. The study consists of nine chapters. Chapter One includes an introduction, study objectives, problems and justifications, while Chapter Two has a theoretical background on sustainability topic and definitions of sustainability. The Palestinian urban planning laws and local government systems are discussed in Chapter Three and the methodology of research is detailed in Chapter Four. As for Chapter Five, it provides a general background on Hebron District including demographical and economical profiles, along with recommendations related to sustainable development for each profile Chapter Six addresses the urban environment, sustainability priorities and policies required. Chapter Seven discusses and analyzes infrastructure services including transportation, water and wastewater. As for Chapter Eight, it addresses the land use, housing and urban expansion beside the cultural heritage, natural heritage with relevant sustainable development polices and recommendations. Finally, Chapter Nine includes a conclusion and comprehensive recommendations integrating all of urban and sustainability event in one map. Hebron has a deep history including a rich cultural heritage aged by thousands of years, with 47% of Hebron district population under 14 years old. Being the biggest Palestinian district, Hebron has thousands of industrial and economical organizations beside a large agricultural sector at Palestine level. This gives Hebron a potential to play major roles in developing a national sustainability plan, as the current urban planning system in Palestine needs urgent reform and development to fulfill the sustainability requirement. The municipalities and ministers should find permanent financial aid for urban planning and development studies so as to face future challenges. The Palestinian government can benefit from available local human resources in development projects; hence Palestinian people have sufficient qualifications in most sectors. The Palestinian people also can invest in the privet sector in Palestine in case businessmen have been encouraged and clear investment laws and plans have been developed. The study provides recommendations associated to the sustainable development in Palestine in general and Hebron, as a case study, in specific. Recommendations include increasing the privet sector as well as the public involvement in urban growth management, and stopping unplanned urban expansion, subjecting granting building permits of new projects to the no-harm environmental impact assessment, increasing the coordination and cooperation between localities and central bodies, protection and renovation of old cites and green areas, increasing the quality and quantity of infrastructure services, establishing district urban planning department to coordinate and organize urban planning and sustainable development activities. Also, among recommendations come dividing Hebron into three planning and administrative areas (north, central and south), and dividing the sustainable development and implementation period (2010 to 2025) into three main phases. Finally, the study strongly recommends benefiting from the same urban development plans in similar districts at national and international levels, also to use new technologies and information systems in urban planning process.

La RSE : de la incoherencia teórica al incumplimiento intencional de propósitos. Una aproximación en Colombia

La Responsabilidad Social Empresarial, RSE, no es un tema nuevo en América Latina ni en Colombia. En los últimos 30 años el auge que ha tomado la RSE respecto al ser humano es cada vez más creciente. Esto ha hecho del tema un campo prolífico y amplio en planteamientos teóricos, en compromisos y pactos múltiples que involucran a las empresas, los gobiernos, las organizaciones internacionales y los ciudadanos. Por ello es importante abordar la filosofía y aplicación de la RSE, observando los direccionamientos que de una u otra manera han hecho los modelos de desarrollo que priorizan el crecimiento económico y, en sentido opuesto, el centrado en el desarrollo humano. La diversidad de planteamientos tiene similitud en su origen al inspirarse en las necesidades básicas de las personas, en las posturas del desarrollo humano y el desarrollo sostenible, especialmente; y en la filosofía de la RSE que elaboran las organizaciones internacionales, empresariales y las ONG´s. La pertinencia de su aplicación queda a criterio y voluntariedad de las empresas de acuerdo al entorno local que experimentan, lo que ha contribuido a su incongruencia en cuanto a la conceptualización e implementación. En ese escenario la presente investigación se propone aportar una mirada crítica con espacios de reflexión sobre la posición actual de los conceptos más sobresalientes respecto a la RSE.

La actualidad y los retos de la RSE. Un modelo familiar de responsabilidad social empresarial

El presente texto comienza con la definición y explicación de algunos de los conceptos básicos de mayor importancia para la familiarización con el presente trabajo. A continuación construimos tres pilares fundamentales que soportan la idea de una actuación moralmente responsable. Empezamos con el reconocimiento de aportes éticos y filosóficos desde el siglo XVI hasta nuestros días. Seguidamente, examinamos el componente económico y el aspecto ético, en donde encontramos evidencia de la falta de compromiso moral de los actores económicos y hallamos evidencia que soporta al nuevo orden económico mundial. Por último, evaluamos el comportamiento que se debería seguir en el ámbito empresarial. Analizamos la conducta que debería guiar el camino empresarial; se debe buscar un punto medio en donde se es socialmente responsable y se logra incrementar los beneficios financieros. Tras apoyarnos sobre estos tres pilares llegamos al diseño de un modelo de responsabilidad social en el que las empresas deben ser vistas como una familia económica. Con esto intentamos hacer énfasis en la redefinición del contrato social, en el que las empresas vean a los stakeholders y al medio ambiente de la misma forma en que un padre responsable ve a sus hijos y a su familia. Quisimos hacer ver, inicialmente, un panorama extenso acerca del punto crítico en el que nos encontramos hoy buscando una concienciación general para el entendimiento que el bienestar social y ambiental favorece a todos, pues mejora la calidad de vida a nivel mundial y aumente el desempeño empresarial a lo largo del planeta.

Globalización, capitalismo financiero y responsabilidad social empresarial: tensiones estructurales

Los efectos nocivos que el capitalismo financiero y la globalización han tenido sobre los equilibrios sociales y económicos están estrechamente relacionados con los argumentos conceptuales que, como una llamada de atención, han llegado a las corporaciones y las empresas por la responsabilidad social corporativa. Sin embargo, el modelo construido en torno a la acumulación de capital y beneficios han planteado una relación simbiótica en la que ellos mismos son el recurso y el fin de su propia existencia, dando lugar a tensiones estructurales que anula las alternativas de ser sostenible y socialmente responsable al mismo tiempo. El camino que enfrentamos como sociedad, como empresas y como modelo económico sostenible se basa en el trabajo conjunto y los cambios en la manera de abordar el mercado.

El caso de perdurabilidad empresarial de Crepes & Waffles desde una perspectiva de responsabilidad social empresarial e innovación en valor en Colombia

La multinacional Crepes & Waffles posee una historia extraordinaria de emprendimiento y arte en la gestión, con la cual construye un valor agregado diferenciador en la industria gastronómica de Colombia, pues mediante el uso de una estrategia enfocada hacia la Responsabilidad Social Empresarial (RSE) genera Innovación en Valor y por consiguiente la satisfacción de cada uno de sus clientes tanto internos como externos (Stakeholders) estableciendo lazos de confianza y compromiso. El presente trabajo de grado busca incluir como ingrediente clave de la perdurabilidad a la RSE creadora de Innovación en Valor, ya que por medio del estudio del caso Crepes & Waffles, se concluye que una gerencia humana, holística y comprometida con la construcción de su entorno, puede lograr que una empresa sea legitimada por la sociedad en la que está inmersa. Una buena dosis de RSE estratégicamente aplicada se configura hoy por hoy como la receta innegable del éxito y aunque un sinnúmero de teorías organizacionales tratan de establecer las pautas para impulsar el crecimiento de las empresas, únicamente la entidad que logre ingresar al corazón de sus Stakeholders y crear fidelidad, se mantendrá en el tiempo y se sumergirá en un nicho de mercado carente de competidores, o en lo que los escritores W. Chan Kim y Renée Mauborgne (2005) describen en su libro “La estrategia del Océano Azul” como “Un espacio de mercado no disputado donde la competencia es irrelevante”.

Propuesta para la Incorporación del Concepto y la Estructuración del Área de Sostenibilidad en el Fondo Nacional del Ahorro

En el contexto actual en el que las organizaciones buscan generar acciones que respondan por el impacto que tienen sus actividades y decisiones en su entorno más próximo, se realiza un propuesta de incorporación del concepto de la Responsabilidad Social Empresarial (RSE) para el Fondo Nacional del Ahorro (FNA) con el fin de que la entidad involucre dentro de sus procesos acciones socialmente responsables y a su vez contribuya con el desarrollo sostenible. El documento Propuesta Para La Incorporación Del Concepto Y La Estructuración Del Área De Sostenibilidad En El Fondo Nacional Del Ahorro desarrolla en principio una revisión y análisis de documentos que permiten fundamentar teóricamente la propuesta de estructura organizacional para crear un grupo de trabajo de sostenibilidad que lidere acciones de RSE al interior de la organización. La revisión teórica inicia con el análisis de la guía de Responsabilidad Social ISO 26000, continua con el estudio de tres trabajos de grado que describen la estructura de Responsabilidad Social por Helm Bank, Pacific Rubiales, Skanska y ABB y finalmente se revisan dos documentos que cohesionan los conceptos fundamentales de la RSE con metodologías de estructuración para la incorporación y ejecución de la RSE dentro de la organización. Seguida a la revisión, se propone la estructura organizacional del Grupo de Sostenibilidad del FNA, en la cual se define las funciones, los descriptivos de cargo, los procesos a realizar por el grupo y un presupuesto aproximado que se debe tener en cuenta para la creación del Grupo de Trabajo. Con el fin de que el FNA formule acciones de RSE y pueda reportar su contribución con el Desarrollo Sostenible y ser reconocida como una entidad socialmente responsable.