Two-year survival of ART restorations placed in elderly patients: A randomised controlled clinical trial

OBJECTIVES: Older dentate adults are a high caries risk group who could potentially benefit from the use of the atraumatic restorative treatment (ART). This study aimed to compare the survival of ART and a conventional restorative technique (CT) using rotary instruments and a resin-modified glass-ionomer for restoring carious lesions as part of a preventive and restorative programme for older adults after 2 years.

METHODS: In this randomised controlled clinical trial, 99 independently living adults (65-90 years) with carious lesions were randomly allocated to receive either ART or conventional restorations. The survival of restorations was assessed by an independent and blinded examiner 6 months, 1 year and 2 years after restoration placement.

RESULTS: Ninety-six (67.6%) and 121 (76.6%) restorations were assessed in the ART and CT groups, respectively, after 2 years. The cumulative restoration survival percentages after 2 years were 85.4% in the ART and 90.9% in the CT group. No statistically significant between group differences were detected (p=0.2050, logistic regression analysis).

CONCLUSIONS: In terms of restoration survival, ART was as effective as a conventional restorative approach to treat older adults after 2 years. This technique could be a useful tool to provide dental care for older adults particularly in the non-clinical setting. (Trial Registration number: ISRCTN 76299321).

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The results of this study show that ART presented survival rates similar to conventional restorations in older adults. ART appears to be a cost-effective way to provide dental care to elderly patients, particularly in out of surgery facilities, such as nursing homes.

Minimal intervention dentistry and older patients part 2: minimally invasive operative interventions

As described in the first paper of this two part series, the expansion of our older population and the concomitant reduction in levels of edentulism will result in an increase in the number of patients presenting in general practice with complex restorative challenges. The application of the concepts of minimal intervention dentistry and minimally invasive operative techniques may offer a powerful armamentarium to the general dentist to provide ethical and conservative treatment to older patients.

Clinical Relevance: When it is unavoidable, operative intervention should be as minimally invasive as practicable in older patients to preserve the longevity of their natural dentition.

Minimal intervention dentistry and older patients Part 1: Risk assessment and caries prevention

Ten million people in the UK today are aged over 65. The latest projections estimate that there will be 5 1/2 million more people aged 65 and older in the next 20 years. This projected pattern of population ageing will have profound consequences for dentistry. Minimal intervention dentistry (MID) is a modern evidence-based approach to caries management in dentate patients that uses the 'medical model' whereby disease is controlled by the 'oral physician'. This approach offers considerable benefits over conventional dentistry for older patients. It encourages patients to be responsible for their oral health through the provision of both knowledge and motivation. MID encompasses risk assessment for dental disease, early detection and control of disease processes, and minimally invasive treatment. 

Clinical Relevance: Risk assessment tools can aid the general dental practitioner and the patient to develop a suitable caries prevention programme for that individual and reduce the need for future operative intervention.

Cost-effectiveness of ART restorations in elderly adults: a randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND: As the world population ages, the requirement for cost-effective methods of treating chronic disease conditions increases. In terms of oral health, there is a rapidly increasing number of dentate elderly with a high burden of maintenance. Population surveys indicate that older individuals are keeping their teeth for longer and are a higher caries risk group. Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART) could be suitable for patients in nursing homes or house-bound elderly, but very little research has been done on its use in adults.

OBJECTIVES: To compare the cost-effectiveness of ART and a conventional technique (CT) for restoring carious lesions as part of a preventive and restorative programme for older adults.

METHODS: In this randomized clinical trial, 82 patients with carious lesions were randomly allocated to receive either ART or conventional restorations. Treatment costs were measured based on treatment time, materials and labour. For the ART group, the cost of care provided by a dentist was also compared to the cost of having a hygienist to provide treatment. Effectiveness was measured using percentage of restorations that survived after a year.

RESULTS: Eighty-two patients received 260 restorations, that is, 128 ART and 132 conventional restorations. 91.1% of the restorations were on one surface only. After a year, 252 restorations were assessed in 80 patients. The average cost for ART and conventional restorations was €16.86 and €28.71 respectively; the restoration survival percentages were 91.1% and 97.7%, respectively. This resulted in a cost-effectiveness ratio of 0.18 (ART) and 0.29 (CT). When the cost of a hygienist to provide ART was inserted in the analysis, the resulting ratio was 0.14.

CONCLUSIONS: Atraumatic restorative treatment was found to be a more cost-effective alternative to treat older adults after 1 year, compared to conventional restorations, especially in out of surgery facilities and using alternative workforce such as hygienists. Atraumatic restorative treatment can be a useful tool to provide dental care for frail and fearful individuals who might not access dental treatment routinely.

Caries and the older patient

Ageing of the population, together with prolonged retention of teeth, has brought new challenges to dentistry. Whereas in the past oral care for the elderly was restricted to provision of dentures, older patients are now presenting with dental caries and failed restorations. These problems may have an impact on their general health and quality of life. Poor oral hygiene, xerostomia and diet are among the risk factors for caries in older patients and need to be addressed in order to achieve control of the disease. Carious lesions can be treated conservatively in many cases or may need surgical management.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Caries is an oral health issue among older patients and can result in tooth loss. Oral health has a great impact on general health and quality of life of elderly people.

Gerodontology--how big is the challenge in Ireland?

Population trends suggest that the Irish population is ageing, and that this population will have substantial treatment needs. These patients will be better informed than previous generations, and will demand treatment aimed at preserving a natural dentition. This will impact upon delivery of oral healthcare and manpower planning needs to consider how to address the increased demand for dental care. Poor oral health is associated with systemic health problems, including cardiovascular disease, respiratory disease and diabetes mellitus. It also has a negative impact upon quality of life, and the World Health Organisation has encouraged public healthcare administrators and decision makers to design effective and affordable strategies for better oral health and quality of life of older adults, which, in turn, are integrated into general health management programmes. Treatment concepts such as minimally invasive dentistry and the shortened dental arch concept are discussed in the context of these demographic changes and recommendations.

The importance of oral health for the systemic well being of an ageing population

The proportion of adults over the age of 60 years is expanding rapidly across European Union countries, including the Republic of Ireland. As the older population has grown faster than the total population, the proportion of older persons relative to the rest of the population has increased considerably (Figure 1). This trend mirrors the arrival of the “baby boomer� generation into early old age and will have wide ranging effects on social, political and economic spheres as well as presenting significant challenges for healthcare delivery and public healthcare policy.

The Use of ART in Elderly Patients after 2 years

Caries experience is high in the elderly, and barriers to care for older adults include fear and cost. Access to care is especially problematic in the case of frail and homebound elderly. Objective: to compare the survival of restorations placed using Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART) and a conventional technique using rotary instruments and a resin-modified glass-ionomer (CT) to treat carious lesions in older patients. Methods: In this randomised clinical trial, 99 independently living adults (65-90 yrs) with carious lesions were recruited from a geriatric day hospital and a community centre and randomly allocated to receive either ART or conventional restorations. They received tailored oral hygiene instructions and scaling and polishing of teeth prior to restoration placement. The survival of restorations was assessed 6, 12 and 24 months after restoration placement by an independent examiner. Results: Ninety-nine patients participated in the trial, 46 males and 53 females, with a mean age of 73.2 (SD: 6.8). In total, 300 restorations were placed, 142 ART in 51 patients and 158 conventional restorations in 48 patients, with an average of 2.8 ART (SD: 1.83) and 3.2 conventional (SD: 2.62) restorations placed per patient. After 2 years, 88 ART and 117 conventional restorations were assessed. The restoration survival percentages were 93.1% and 94%, respectively. Conclusion: ART was found to be as effective as a conventional restorative approach to treat older adults after 2 years and could be a useful tool to provide dental care for older dentate adults.

Economic evaluation and its place in dentistry

Objective: This review intends to examine current research surrounding economic assessment in the delivery of dental care. Economic evaluation is an acknowledged method of analysing dental care systems by means of efficiency, effectiveness, efficacy and availability. Though this is a widely used method in medicine, it is underappreciated in dentistry. As the delivery of health care changes there has been recent demand by the public, the profession, and those funding dental treatment to investigate current practices regarding programs themselves and resource allocation.
Methods: A meta-analysis was conducted regarding health economics. The initial search was carried out using Pubmed, Google Scholar, Science Direct, and The Cochrane Library with search terms “health AND economics AND dentistry”. A secondary search was conducted with the terms “heath care AND dentistry AND”. The third part of the entry was changed to address the aims and included the following terms: “cost benefit analysis”, “efficiency criteria”, “supply & demand”, “cost-effectiveness”, “cost minimisation”, “cost utility”, “resource allocation”, “QALY”, and “delivery and economics”. Limits were applied to all searches to only include papers published in English within the last eight years.
Results: Preliminary results demonstrated a limited number of economic evaluations conducted in dentistry. Those that were carried out were mainly confined to the United Kingdom. Furthermore analysis was mainly restricted to restorative dentistry, followed by orthodontics, and maxillofacial surgery, thereby demonstrating a need for investigation in all fields of dentistry.
Conclusion: Health economics has been overlooked in the past regarding delivery of dental care and resource allocation. Economic appraisal is a crucial part of generating an effective and efficient dental care system. It is becoming increasingly evident that there is a need for economic evaluation in all dental fields.

Diferença entre os géneros na análise cinemática e eletromiográfica do membro superior durante uma atividade diária de beber

As diferenças entre os géneros parecem surgir desde a origem da humanidade, quando a função do homem era caçar e da mulher fornecer cuidados às crianças e realizar trabalhos de cariz manual. O membro superior apresenta um papel primordial na execução da maioria das atividades relevantes para o ser humano, sendo pertinente a realização de avaliações mais objetivas do mesmo. Com a realização deste estudo pretendemos verificar se existem diferenças entre os géneros nos parâmetros eletromiográficos e cinemáticos do movimento durante uma atividade diária; perceber se os valores da eletromiografia e da cinemática do membro superior são dependentes do género à medida que a distância do objeto é alterada e ainda, levar a cabo a análise da atividade de beber. Para tal foram avaliados parâmetros de qualidade de movimento e parâmetros de recrutamento muscular em 15 indivíduos do género feminino e 15 indivíduos do género masculino com idades compreendidas entre os 18 e os 30 anos numa atividade de beber em três momentos diferentes. Para a análise cinemática foi utilizado o software Qualysis Motion Capture e para a análise eletromiográfica o software AcqKnowledge Analysis. Com os resultados obtidos constatamos que a percentagem de ativação muscular e os ângulos de flexão do ombro e flexão do cotovelo apresentam diferenças estatisticamente significativas (p<0.05) entre os géneros, sendo o grupo feminino a apresentar valores superiores. Aferiu-se também que a percentagem de ativação do músculo Deltoide Anterior parece ser influenciado pelo género (p<0.05) ao longo das três distâncias em estudo, sendo novamente o grupo feminino a apresentar valores superiores. Para além disto, aquando do movimento de alcançar, verificaram-se evidências estatísticas (p<0.05) do envolvimento do tronco em todas as distâncias de alcance do objeto, inclusive numa distância inferior ao comprimento do braço. Este estudo permitiu a descrição detalhada da eletromiografia e cinemática do movimento do membro superior de alcançar e transportar numa atividade diária, bem como uma comparação da mesma entre o grupo masculino e grupo feminino.

Representações sobre a creche dos pais de crianças que frequentam a creche e dos pais que optaram por outro cuidado

Dissertação apresentada na Escola Superior de Educação de Lisboa, para obtenção do grau de Mestre em Ciências da Educação - Especialidade Intervenção Precoce

Infância Institucionalizada: Narrativas das crianças sobre o antes, o durante e o pós alta hospitalar

Dissertação apresentada à Escola Superior de Educação de Lisboa para a obtenção do grau de Mestre em Ciências da Educação, especialização em Educação Social e Intervenção Comunitária

A participação das crianças em lares de infância e juventude: representações e práticas. um estudo de caso.

Dissertação de 2º Ciclo conducente ao grau de Mestre em Ciências da Educação - especialização em Educação Social e Intervenção Comunitária

As representações dos professores acerca da participação de alunos com necessidades educativas especiais em diversas atividades escolares

Os paradigmas concernentes à educação e ao atendimento de crianças com necessidades educativas especiais têm evoluído ao longo do tempo. De facto, se no paradigma da segregação o foco de incapacidade se situava no indivíduo, com o paradigma da inclusão o foco desloca-se para o ambiente, na medida em que este se deve organizar e preparar para dar resposta aos indivíduos com incapacidade. Por conseguinte, o meio deve assumir-se como facilitador à participação de todas as crianças. Tal fundamento comporta desafios para os professores e educadores, aos quais compete identificar as pressões de exclusão que inibem a participação plena de todos os alunos em todas as atividades inerentes ao meio escolar e acionar os suportes necessários para que tal não suceda. Com a realização deste estudo pretendemos conhecer de modo mais aprofundado as representações dos professores acerca da participação de alunos com diferentes tipos de incapacidade em variadas atividades e contextos escolares, identificando barreiras e facilitadores à sua participação e analisando os possíveis contributos pessoais dos professores para incrementar o nível de participação dos alunos com incapacidade em atividades inerentes ao meio escolar. O estudo operacionalizou-se através da aplicação de um inquérito por questionário, destinado a professores de todos os níveis de ensino e grupos de recrutamento. Através da aplicação deste instrumento, procurámos obter informações sobre os inquiridos, as representações dos professores acerca da participação de alunos com diferentes tipos de incapacidade em diversas atividades escolares, e, por fim, possíveis contributos para incrementar o nível de participação desses mesmos alunos. Os resultados sugerem que o tipo de incapacidade apresentado pelo aluno influencia as expetativas de participação de educadores e professores do ensino regular e da educação especial. Contudo, não confirmámos a existência de diferenças estatisticamente significativas entre os dois grupos de professores. No que concerne a possíveis contributos para incrementar a participação de alunos com incapacidade em diversas atividades escolares, identificámos a necessidade de se fomentar e desenvolver uma cultura de inclusão na escola.