Recensões

Revista do IHA, N.4 (2007), pp.323-328

Entrevista com Suzanne Cotter

Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT), Fundação Millennium bcp

La série, la crise, le monde

Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT), Fundação Millennium bcp

Pourquoi nous avons besoin de la critique?

Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT), Fundação Millennium bcp

Breaking Down and Breaking Out: Beckett’s ‘Absolute Liminality’ in the Third Age of Capitalist Traumas

Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (FCT), Fundação Millennium bcp

History of Art and Art Criticism: A System in Crisis

This article aims to reconstruct the critical debate regarding the examination of the crisis in the disciplines of art history and criticism with a particular focus on the proposal formulated by U.S. theorists who contributed to October journal. The discrediting of many modernist critical methods, particularly that of Clement Greenberg – the formalist diktat – marked the birth of the journal and gave rise to proposals set forth by critics committed to a new approach. Their divergent positions, nonetheless, have contributed to undermining the traditional concepts of the autonomy of art and criticism. The proposals discussed over the course of publication were the result of a reappraisal of the disciplinary instruments of art history and criticism pursuant to the crucial cultural changes which took place in the 1980s.

Breaking the Pattern and Creating New Paths – Feminist Mizrahi Women Artists in Israel

This article addresses the work of Mizrahi women artists, i.e., Israeli-Jewish women of Asian or African ethnic origin, using the artist Vered Nissim as a case study. Nissim seeks to affirm the politics of identity and recognition, as well as feminism in order to create a paradigm shift with regards to the local regime of cultural representations in the Israeli art scene. Endeavouring to find ways of undermining the rigid imbalances between different social groups, she calls for a comprehensive reform of the status quo through artistic activism. Nissim employs a style, content, and medium that disrupts the accepted social order, using humour and irony as unique weapons with which she takes liberties with conventional moral, social, and economic values. Placing issues of race, class and gender at the centre of her work, she seeks to undermine and problematize essentialist attitudes, highlighting the political intersections of different identity categories as the critical analysis of intersectionality unfolds.

Revolution in Crisis: The Ruptures of Revolution and Ruptured Revolutions Through the Ruptures of Artistic Practice

This article proposes an investigation of the history and memory of the Carnation Revolution through the lens of contemporary art. Drawing upon the argument according to which history and memory are investigated by visual artists by means other, but no less relevant, than those of professional historians, this article will argue for the importance of attending to the visual, auditory, textual, object- and research-based ways in which artists from several generations and geographies have been unearthing the repressed histories and memories of the Carnation Revolution in Portugal and of anticolonial struggles, decolonization and post-independence nation-building in Mozambique, Guinea-Bissau and Angola. The discussion focuses on several works by Ângela Ferreira, but attention will also be paid to precursors in imaging the Revolution, such as Ana Hatherly, and to a younger generation of artists such as Filipa César, Kiluanji Kia Henda and Daniel Barroca.

Éléments pour une approche de la philosophie orteguienne de la crise

La thèse que nous soutenons et que nous nous proposons de démontrer dans cet article est que la crise, chez Ortega y Gasset, loin d’instituer une rupture dans le processus de l’histoire, et de menacer ainsi sa continuité, en est la condition de possibilité. L’hypothèse que nous nous proposons de vérifier est que l’idée même d’un « sens » de l’histoire – nous reviendrons sur la manière bien particulière dont le philosophe madrilène entend cette expression – est garantie par la crise. Nous explorerons pour cela très précisément la tension qui réside entre l’affirmation ortéguienne selon laquelle la crise est le moteur de l’histoire d’une part, et la description à laquelle procède le philosophe madrilène de l’homme en crise comme acteur de l’histoire paralysé d’autre part.

In Search of the Origins of Modernism: Venice and the Crisis of Classical Architecture in the mid-eighteenth century

This paper attempts to prove that in the years 1735 to 1755 Venice was the birthplace and cradle of Modern architectural theory, generating a major crisis in classical architecture traditionally based on the Vitruvian assumption that it imitates early wooden structures in stone or in marble. According to its rationalist critics such as the Venetian Observant Franciscan friar and architectural theorist Carlo Lodoli (1690-1761) and his nineteenth-century followers, classical architecture is singularly deceptive and not true to the nature of materials, in other words, dishonest and fallacious. This questioning did not emanate from practising architects, but from Lodoli himself– a philosopher and educator of the Venetian patriciate – who had not been trained as an architect. The roots of this crisis lay in a new approach to architecture stemming from the new rationalist philosophy of the Enlightenment age with its emphasis on reason and universal criticism.

O Elvis de Macau. Relatos de uma distopia na China

A explosão de Macau nos últimos dez anos deve-se a um conjunto de factores, que este texto procura descrever, propondo uma necessária reflexão. Depois da liberalização do jogo em 2001/2002, o Sands Macau inaugura, em 2004, como o primeiro casino da nova vaga. Em 2005, Macau é Património Mundial da Humanidade pela UNESCO. O Cotai é inicialmente um projecto da administração portuguesa como uma nova cidade para 150 000 habitantes. O Cotai Strip nasce de uma epifania de Sheldon Adelson, chairman da Las Vegas Sands Corporation, em 2003. Em 2007, o Venetian inaugura como “flagship” do Cotai Strip e, em 2011, o Galaxy amplia a dimensão delirante da arquitectura do jogo. No pós-Portugal, a condição de Macau como espaço híbrido, colonizado, transitório, aumenta exponencialmente enquanto “Região Administrativa Especial” da República Popular da China. Macau é hoje uma distopia suave, corporizada nos casinos; uma vida subterrânea que se expressa no skyline.

La Cène ou la figure du banquet comme image de crise morale chez Zeng Fanzhi

Les yeux et les masques sont prévalents dans les oeuvres du peintre chinois contemporain Zeng Fanzhi (né en 1964), comme métaphore du jeu de pouvoir qui oppose les individus à l’appareil social et politique. Son oeuvre La Cène, d’après Leonard de Vinci, est un exemple frappant de cette préoccupation. Cet essai examine l’utilisation par l’artiste de cette représentation occidentale d’une crise morale (une trahison qui mène à la mort du Christ) pour exprimer la dystopie qui marque la Chine contemporaine. L’interprétation par Zeng de l’oeuvre de Vinci témoigne d’une compréhension profonde de sa signification à la Renaissance comme conflit entre le pouvoir terrestre et spirituel, auquel il surimpose la fonction du banquet dans la culture chinoise comme lieu de lutte politique. Un nihilisme détaché imprègne ce travail, à l’instar de l’interprétation métaphorique du banquet de Platon par Søren Kierkegaard, In Vino Veritas.

Sensory turn. Quando o sujeito se torna o centro da História da Arte

Nas últimas décadas, as ciências sociais e humanas têm despertado para a acção modeladora das estruturas sobre a percepção humana. O debate académico sobre o relativismo cultural dos modelos de percepção tem levado investigadores das várias áreas a debruçarem-se sobre o estudo dos sentidos. Correntes disciplinares como a antropologia ou história dos sentidos vêm sintetizando a dimensão estrutural e fenomenológica, a partir da compreensão do carácter biológico e cultural da experiência sensorial. Nesse sentido, tem emergido uma nova história da arte que contraria as últimas décadas de predomínio da linguística e semiótica, em função da compreensão da performance das imagens ligada à percepção sensorial. Questiona-se o totalitarismo que o método iconográfico/iconológico de Panofsky tem encontrado na historiografia da arte, a partir da ideia de que as imagens antes de um significado são uma acção, antes de uma função são um uso.

Arshile Gorky: An Armenian in New York

Born in Armenia, the oldest Christian country in the world but nevertheless one of the youngest reinstated republics (1991) after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Arshile Gorky flew to the United States in 1920, where he chose to reinvent himself in the struggle to become an artist. This reinvention meant the creation of a persona with, or behind, which Gorky kept alive the artistic flame inside himself. Gorky became one of the most learned voices lecturing on contemporary European modernist artists and movements of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries in the United States (New York) without ever visiting Europe. Moreover, he was able to survive the traumatic events he underwent during the Armenian Genocide (1915-1919) to adapt to his new country and identity, to live through the years of the Depression and, eventually, to become the protagonistof a major artistic breakthrough. This paper proposes an insight into the experience of life and frame of work of this Armenian-American artist, whose simultaneously rich, traumatic, dislocated and reenacted life and work established one of the most fertile links between his middle‑eastern origins, his dreamed of Europe and the particular transit of his American artistic creation.

O xadrez como metáfora para pensar a crise nas humanidades

As últimas décadas foram marcadas por fortes tensões entre os “discursos oficiais historiográficos” e outras formas alternativas de narrar os acontecimentos humanos. No campo da arte esta tensão foi particularmente evidente, levando ao surgimento de diversas estratégias distintas para enfrentar o modelo oficial e/ou para tentar integrar os discursos e contribuições da alteridade. Ao longo deste texto procurar-se-á analisar algumas dessas estratégias que foram usadas neste período de crise, recorrendo para o efeito a um conjunto de conceitos escaquísticos – “jogar de negras”, “ataque das minorias”, “xadrez 960” – que, funcionando como metáforas, poderão acrescentar valor heurístico para a compreensão dos fenómenos sociais e humanos. Ao optar-se por este tipo de abordagem, pretende-se valorizar um tipo de análise que prolifera atualmente nas ciências sociais e humanas e que procura pensar a complexidade humana a partir de modelos alternativos, baseados em analogias.