Influence of Cutting Conditions on Tool Life, Tool Wear and Surface Finish in the Face Milling Process

The main goal of this work is to study the influence of cutting conditions - cutting speed, feed velocity and feed per tooth - on tool life and surface finish of the workpiece in the face milling of flat surfaces. Aiming to achieve this goal, several milling experiments were carried out with different cutting speeds, feed velocities and feeds per tooth. In the first phase of the experiments, cutting speed was varied without varying feed velocity, which caused a variation in feed per tooth. In the second phase of the experiments, cutting speed and feed velocity were varied in such a way that feed per tooth was kept constant. Tool flank wear and surface roughness of the workpiece were measured as cutting time elapsed. The main conclusions of this work are that a) cutting speed has a strong influence on tool life, regardless of whether feed velocity or feed per tooth varies and b) an increase in surface roughness of the workpiece is not closely related to an increase in wear of the primary cutting edge.

Parameters for tool life optimisation with respect to face milling

DUE TO COPYRIGHT RESTRICTIONS, ONLY AVAILABLE FOR CONSULTATION AT ASTON UNIVERSITY LIBRARY WITH PRIOR ARRANGEMENT

Tool wear aspects when applying high-speed tapping on grey cast iron

Tool wear is a very important subject affecting the economics of machining, especially in tapping, since it is one of the last operations to be performed within most operation sequences. In the present study, some aspects of tapping such as the mechanisms and types of wear were investigated in taps working at conventional and high-speed cutting (HSC). Additionally, different types of coatings and cooling /lubrication conditions were used. The tapping operation (M8 x 1.25) was performed in through holes with two cutting speeds (30 and 60 m/min) in grey cast iron GG25. Lubrication conditions tested were dry and with minimal quantity of lubricant. Tap materials were manufactured by powder metallurgy and coated with (TiAl)N and with TiCN. A go-non-go gauge criterion was used to assess tool life. The wear and surface aspects of the tools and workpiece were evaluated by scanning electron microscopy and energy dissipation spectroscopy. Torque signals were also measured during the tests. The main wear mechanism observed was adhesion, although some abrasion and diffusion may also have occurred, and the main type of wear was flank wear. The adhesion of workpiece material on the tool was the main and decisive factor ending tool life. Tool coatings proved to be an efficient way to minimize adhesion. Torque signals followed the same pattern as the flank wear and no significant change was observed when the cutting speed was increased.

Reliability concepts applied to cutting tool change time

This paper presents a reliability-based analysis for calculating critical tool life in machining processes. It is possible to determine the running time for each tool involved in the process by obtaining the operations sequence for the machining procedure. Usually, the reliability of an operation depends on three independent factors: operator, machine-tool and cutting tool. The reliability of a part manufacturing process is mainly determined by the cutting time for each job and by the sequence of operations, defined by the series configuration. An algorithm is presented to define when the cutting tool must be changed. The proposed algorithm is used to evaluate the reliability of a manufacturing process composed of turning and drilling operations. The reliability of the turning operation is modeled based on data presented in the literature, and from experimental results, a statistical distribution of drilling tool wear was defined, and the reliability of the drilling process was modeled. (C) 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Evaluation of the performance of α-SiAlON tool when turning Ti-6Al-4V alloy without coolant

Due to their high hardness and wear resistance, Si3N4 based ceramics are one of the most suitable cutting tool materials for machining cast iron, nickel alloys and hardened steels. However, their high degree of brittleness usually leads to inconsistent results and sudden catastrophic failures. This necessitates a process optimization when machining superalloys with Si3N4 based ceramic cutting tools. The tools are expected to withstand the heat and pressure developed when machining at higher cutting conditions because of their high hardness and melting point. This paper evaluates the performance of α-SiAlON tool in turning Ti-6Al-4V alloy at high cutting conditions, up to 250 m min-1, without coolant. Tool wear, failure modes and temperature were monitored to access the performance of the cutting tool. Test results showed that the performance of α-SiAl0N tool, in terms of tool life, at the cutting conditions investigated is relatively poor due probably to rapid notching and excessive chipping of the cutting edge. These facts are associated with adhesion and diffusion wear rate that tends to weaken the bond strength of the cutting tool.

Tool wear monitoring using neuro-fuzzy techniques: a comparative study in a turning process

Tool wear detection is a key issue for tool condition monitoring. The maximization of useful tool life is frequently related with the optimization of machining processes. This paper presents two model-based approaches for tool wear monitoring on the basis of neuro-fuzzy techniques. The use of a neuro-fuzzy hybridization to design a tool wear monitoring system is aiming at exploiting the synergy of neural networks and fuzzy logic, by combining human reasoning with learning and connectionist structure. The turning process that is a well-known machining process is selected for this case study. A four-input (i.e., time, cutting forces, vibrations and acoustic emissions signals) single-output (tool wear rate) model is designed and implemented on the basis of three neuro-fuzzy approaches (inductive, transductive and evolving neuro-fuzzy systems). The tool wear model is then used for monitoring the turning process. The comparative study demonstrates that the transductive neuro-fuzzy model provides better error-based performance indices for detecting tool wear than the inductive neuro-fuzzy model and than the evolving neuro-fuzzy model.

An investigation of the relationship between temperature, forces and tool wear in turning and drilling

Developing a means of predicting tool life has been and continues to be a focus of much research effort. A common experience in attempting to replicate such efforts is an inability to achieve the levels of agreement between theory and practice of the original researcher or to extrapolate the work to different materials or cutting conditions to those originally used. This thesis sets out to examine why most equations or models when replicated do not give good agreements. One reason which was found is that researchers in wear prediction, their predictions are limited because they generally fail to properly identify the nature of wear mechanisms operative in their study. Also they fail to identify or recognise factors having a significant influence on wear such as bar diameter. Also in this research the similarities and differences between the two processes of single point turning and drilling are examined through a series of tests. A literature survey was undertaken in wear and wear prediction. As a result it was found that there was a paucity in information and research in the work of drilling as compared to the turning operation. This was extended to the lack of standards that exist for the drilling operation. One reason for this scarcity in information on drilling is due to the complexity of the drilling and the tool geometry of the drill. In the comparative drilling and turning tests performed in this work, the same tool material; HSS, and similar work material was used in order to eliminate the differences which may occur due to this factor. Results of the tests were evaluated and compared for the two operations and SEM photographs were taken for the chips produced. Specific test results were obtained for the cutting temperatures and forces of the tool. It was found that cutting temperature is influenced by various factors like tool geometry and cutting speed, and the temperature itself influenced the tool wear and wear mechanisms that act on the tool. It was found and proven that bar diameter influences the temperature, a factor not considered previously.

Integrated optimisation of surface roughness and tool performance when face milling 416 SS

Tool life is an important factor to be considered during the optimisation of a machining process since cutting parameters can be adjusted to optimise tool changing, reducing cost and time of production. Also the performance of a tool is directly linked to the generated surface roughness and this is important in cases where there are strict surface quality requirements. The prediction of tool life and the resulting surface roughness in milling operations has attracted considerable research efforts. The research reported herein is focused on defining the influence of milling cutting parameters such as cutting speed, feed rate and axial depth of cut, on three major tool performance parameters namely, tool life, material removal and surface roughness. The research is seeking to define methods that will allow the selection of optimal parameters for best tool performance when face milling 416 stainless steel bars. For this study the Taguchi method was applied in a special design of an orthogonal array that allows studying the entire parameter space with only a number of experiments representing savings in cost and time of experiments. The findings were that the cutting speed has the most influence on tool life and surface roughness and very limited influence on material removal. By last tool life can be judged either from tool life or volume of material removal.

Influence of cutting parameters and tool wear on martensitic stainless steel surface integrity after a face milling process

Surface finish is one of the most relevant aspects of machining operations, since it is one of the principle methods to assess quality. Also, surface finish influences mechanical properties such as fatigue behavior, wear, corrosion, etc. The feed, the cutting speed, the cutting tool material, the workpiece material and the cutting tool wear are some of the most important factors that affects the surface roughness of the machined surface. Due to the importance of the martensitic 416 stainless steel in the petroleum industry, especially in valve parts and pump shafts, this material was selected to study the influence of the feed per tooth and cutting speed on tool wear and surface integrity. Also the influence of tool wear on surface roughness is analyzed. Results showed that high values of roughness are obtained when using low cutting speed and feed per tooth and by using these conditions tool wear decreases prolonging tool life. Copyright © 2009 by ASME.

Empirical expression of tool wear when face milling 416 SS

During a machining process, cutting parameters must be taken into account, since depending on them the cutting edge starts to wear out to the point that tool can fail and needs to be change, which increases the cost and time of production. Since wear is a negative phenomenon on the cutting tool, due to the fact that tool life is reduced, it is important to optimize the cutting variables to be used during the machining process, in order to increase tool life. This research is focused on the influence of cutting parameters such as cutting speed, feed per tooth and axial depth of cut on tool wear during a face milling operation. The Taguchi method is applied in this study, since it uses a special design of orthogonal array to study the entire parameters space, with only few numbers of experiments. Also a relationship between tool wear and the cutting parameters is presented. For the studies, a martensitic 416 stainless steel was selected, due to the importance of this material in the machining of valve parts and pump shafts. Copyright © 2009 by ASME.

The Performance Characteristics of a Surface-Modified Cutting Tool

In the past, many papers have been presented which show that the coating of cutting tools often yields decreased wear rates and reduced coefficients of friction. Although different theories are proposed, covering areas such as hardness theory, diffusion barrier theory, thermal barrier theory, and reduced friction theory, most have not dealt with the question of how and why the coating of tool substrates with hard materials such as Titanium Nitride (TiN), Titanium Carbide (TiC) and Aluminium Oxide (Al203) transforms the performance and life of cutting tools. This project discusses the complex interrelationship that encompasses the thermal barrier function and the relatively low sliding friction coefficient of TiN on an undulating tool surface, and presents the result of an investigation into the cutting characteristics and performance of EDMed surface-modified carbide cutting tool inserts. The tool inserts were coated with TiN by the physical vapour deposition (PVD) method. PVD coating is also known as Ion-plating which is the general term of the coating method in which the film is created by attracting ionized metal vapour in this the metal was Titanium and ionized gas onto negatively biased substrate surface. Coating by PVD was chosen because it is done at a temperature of not more than 5000C whereas chemical Vapour Deposition CVD process is done at very high temperature of about 8500C and in two stages of heating up the substrates. The high temperatures involved in CVD affects the strength of the (tool) substrates. In this study, comparative cutting tests using TiN-coated control specimens with no EDM surface structures and TiN-coated EDMed tools with a crater-like surface topography were carried out on mild steel grade EN-3. Various cutting speeds were investigated, up to an increase of 40% of the tool manufacturer’s recommended speed. Fifteen minutes of cutting were carried out for each insert at the speeds investigated. Conventional tool inserts normally have a tool life of approximately 15 minutes of cutting. After every five cuts (passes) microscopic pictures of the tool wear profiles were taken, in order to monitor the progressive wear on the rake face and on the flank of the insert. The power load was monitored for each cut taken using an on-board meter on the CNC machine to establish the amount of power needed for each stage of operation. The spindle drive for the machine is an 11 KW/hr motor. Results obtained confirmed the advantages of cutting at all speeds investigated using EDMed coated inserts, in terms of reduced tool wear and low power loads. Moreover, the surface finish on the workpiece was consistently better for the EDMed inserts. The thesis discusses the relevance of the finite element method in the analysis of metal cutting processes, so that metal machinists can design, manufacture and deliver goods (tools) to the market quickly and on time without going through the hassle of trial and error approach for new products. Improvements in manufacturing technologies require better knowledge of modelling metal cutting processes. Technically the use of computational models has a great value in reducing or even eliminating the number of experiments traditionally used for tool design, process selection, machinability evaluation, and chip breakage investigations. In this work, much interest in theoretical and experimental investigations of metal machining were given special attention. Finite element analysis (FEA) was given priority in this study to predict tool wear and coating deformations during machining. Particular attention was devoted to the complicated mechanisms usually associated with metal cutting, such as interfacial friction; heat generated due to friction and severe strain in the cutting region, and high strain rates. It is therefore concluded that Roughened contact surface comprising of peaks and valleys coated with hard materials (TiN) provide wear-resisting properties as the coatings get entrapped in the valleys and help reduce friction at chip-tool interface. The contributions to knowledge: a. Relates to a wear-resisting surface structure for application in contact surfaces and structures in metal cutting and forming tools with ability to give wear-resisting surface profile. b. Provide technique for designing tool with roughened surface comprising of peaks and valleys covered in conformal coating with a material such as TiN, TiC etc which is wear-resisting structure with surface roughness profile compose of valleys which entrap residual coating material during wear thereby enabling the entrapped coating material to give improved wear resistance. c. Provide knowledge for increased tool life through wear resistance, hardness and chemical stability at high temperatures because of reduced friction at the tool-chip and work-tool interfaces due to tool coating, which leads to reduced heat generation at the cutting zones. d. Establishes that Undulating surface topographies on cutting tips tend to hold coating materials longer in the valleys, thus giving enhanced protection to the tool and the tool can cut faster by 40% and last 60% longer than conventional tools on the markets today.

Dynamic behavior analysis of drill-threading process when machining AISI Al-Si-Cu(4) alloy

Conventional threading operations involve two distinct machining processes: drilling and threading. Therefore, it is time consuming for the tools must be changed and the workpiece has to be moved to another machine. This paper presents an analysis of the combined process (drilling followed by threading) using a single tool for both operations: the tap-milling tool. Before presenting the methodology used to evaluate this hybrid tool, the ODS (operating deflection shapes) basics is shortly described. ODS and finite element modeling (FEM) were used during this research to optimize the process aiming to achieve higher stable machining conditions and increasing the tool life. Both methods allowed the determination of the natural frequencies and displacements of the machining center and optimize the workpiece fixture system. The results showed that there is an excellent correlation between the dynamic stability of the machining center-tool holder and the tool life, avoiding a tool premature catastrophic failure. Nevertheless, evidence showed that the tool is very sensitive to work conditions. Undoubtedly, the use of ODS and FEM eliminate empiric decisions concerning the optimization of machining conditions and increase drastically the tool life. After the ODS and FEM studies, it was possible to optimize the process and work material fixture system and machine more than 30,000 threaded holes without reaching the tool life limit and catastrophic fail.

Estudo comparativo do comportamento de diferentes ferramentas na fresagem de aços duplex

A maquinagem por arranque de apara é, na actualidade, um dos processos de fabrico mais utilizados e de maior relevo no panorama da indústria metalomecânica mundial. Para além da forte evolução que se tem registado ao longo das últimas décadas nos equipamentos ligados à maquinagem, também as ferramentas têm visto o seu desempenho fortemente melhorado, graças essencialmente ao desenvolvimento de revestimentos finos, mono e multicamada, que têm proporcionado o conjunto de propriedades mais indicado a cada situação. Por outro lado, os aços inoxidáveis duplex têm registado um forte incremento na sua aplicação, a qual requer, em muitos casos, o uso da maquinagem para a obtenção das formas necessárias. Tendo em consideração estes dois factores, o presente trabalho visa, essencialmente avaliar qual a ferramenta mais adequada para trabalhar este tipo de ligas, em função do tipo de maquinagem e condições de corte. Para tal, foram utilizadas diferentes ferramentas dotadas da mesma geometria, e seleccionados parâmetros que constituíssem um denominador comum entre os valores indicados pelos diferentes fabricantes. Foram consideradas apenas condições de maquinagem com utilização de fluido de corte e realizados percursos de corte previamente determinados na fresagem, utilizando fresas de topo em condições de maquinagem de alta velocidade. A análise comparativa recaiu sobre a qualidade da superfície gerada por maquinagem, avaliada através de perfilometria, e o desgaste registado por cada uma das ferramentas utilizadas.

Keraamisten teräpalojen käyttö niukkaseosteisten terästen lastuamiseen normaaleissa toimitustiloissa

Tämän tutkimuksen tavoitteena oli tutkia keraamisten kääntöterien soveltuvuus niukkaseosteräksille ja M-käsittelyn vaikutus teränkestoaikoihin. Lisäksi tavoitteena oli tutkia keraamiseosten erityisominaisuudet ja muodostaa käsitys keraamisilla kääntöterillä sorvaamisen erityisvaatimuksista. Kirjallisuusosassa selvitettiin tutkimushetkellä saatavissa olleet keraamiset teräaineseokset ja niiden ominaisuudet sekä selvitettiin keraamisten kääntöterien viimeaikaiset kehitystrendit. Lastuamistutkimus toteutettiin standardin ISO 3685:1993 mukaisesti, minkä lisäksi mitattiin lastuamisvoimat ja tehtiin kokeessa käytetyille terille lastunmurtokoe. Koemateriaalit olivat Imatra Steelin GreenCut, Hydax 25, M-käsittelemätön 42CrMo4 ja M-käsitelty MoC410M. Kokeissa käytetyt kääntöterät olivat eri valmistajien alumiinioksiditeriä, titaanikarbidiseostettuja alumiinioksiditeriä, kuituvahvisteisia ja yksi puhdas titaanikarbidiseosteinen terä. Koetulosten perusteella hyvän teränkestoajan saavuttamiseksi on tärkeää valita oikea keraamiseos ja sille soveltuvat parametrit. Oikein valituilla parametreilla M-terästä sorvattaessa tulokset ylittävät kovametalleilla saavutettavissa olevat arvot. Tulosten perusteella niukkaseostettujen terästen sorvaus onnistuu hyvin keraamisilla kääntöterillä, mutta kovametallisorvaukseen verrattuna syöttöä on laskettava ja lastuamisnopeutta lisättävä. Tämän työn tuloksia voidaan soveltaa sopivissa olosuhteissa toteutettavassa kappaletavaratuotannossa. Sovelluksen onnistuminen vaatii tukevat työstöolosuhteet ja riittävien lastuamisnopeuksien saavuttamisen.

Lastuttavuuskokeiden kartoitus ja suunnitelma m-terästen laadun testaamiseen soveltuvasta uudesta lastuttavuuspikakokeesta

Teräksen hyvällä lastuttavuudella tarkoitetaan useita eri tekijöitä, joita ovat esimerkiksi terän pitkä kestoikä, prosessin kannalta edullinen lastun muoto sekä lastuttavan kappaleen hyvä mittatarkkuus ja pinnan laatu. Materiaalin lastuttavuuden mittaamisella teräksen valmistaja pyrkii varmistumaan siitä, että asiakkaan teräkselle asettamat lastuttavuusvaatimukset täyttyisivät mahdollisimman hyvin. Tämä diplomityö on tehty Ovako Bar Oy Ab:lle Imatran terästehtaalle. Diplomityön tavoitteena oli kartoittaa olemassa olevat lastuttavuuskokeet ja laatia suunnitelma M-teräksen laadun testaamiseen soveltuvasta uudesta lastuttavuuskokeesta Ovakon yli 20 vuotta vanhan lastuttavuuskokeen eli Mq-kokeen tilalle. Mq-kokeen toimivuus on erittäin riippuvainen käytettävästä teräpalasta. Kyseisten teräpalojen valmistus on lopetettu eikä vastaavaa teräpalaa ole saatavilla. Tämän vuoksi oli tarve selvittää mahdollisuuksia korvata Mq-koe. Uuden lastuttavuuskokeen suunnittelua ohjaavat lastuttavuuskokeelle asetettavat vaatimukset, joita ovat luotettavuus, nopeus, helppokäyttöisyys ja pieni koemateriaalimäärän tarve. Tämän työn kirjallisuusosuudessa esitetyistä poraamalla, sorvaamalla ja jyrsimällä tehtävistä lastuttavuuskokeista ei löydy suoraa ratkaisua M-teräksen testaamiseen. Työn soveltavassa osuudessa esitetään kolme koevariaatiota uudeksi lastuttavuuskokeeksi. Ensimmäinen on Mq-koe täydennettynä sitä tukevilla lastuttavuuskokeilla ja siihen liittyvien ongelmien poistaminen. Toinen koevariaatio on pistosorvauskoe, ja kolmantena koekappaleen ja teräpalan väliseen resistanssiin perustuva koe. Kokeiden toimivuudesta M-teräksen testaukseen ei tarkalleen tiedetä, joten työssä on laadittu koejärjestely kokeiden toimivuuden testaamiseksi. Työn keskeisimpiä havaintoja on, että M-teräksen ja normaalin teräksen välinen ero terän kestoiässä mitattuna on kaventunut nykyaikaisten pinnoitettujen teräpalojen vuoksi. Tämä asettaa suuren haasteen uuden kokeen laadinnalle. Lyhyessä kokeellisessa osuudessa testattu pistosorvauskoe kuitenkin antoi myönteisiä tuloksia sen kehityspotentiaalista toimia M-teräksen lastuttavuuskokeena. Diplomityö antaa Ovakolle näkemyksiä erilaisista lastuttavuuskoe vaihtoehdoista ja niiden mahdollisista hyödyistä, haitoista ja mahdollisuuksista. Työssä esitettyjen vaihtoehtojen pohjalta pystytään laatimaan uusi lastuttavuuspikakoe.