Multiscale sensing of antibody - antigen interactions by organic transistors and single-molecule force spectroscopy

Fundação de Amparo à Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP)

Each one teaches one: characterizing active forms of proteins by single molecule force spectroscopy

This Ph.D. candidate thesis collects the research work I conducted under the supervision of Prof.Bruno Samor´ı in 2005,2006 and 2007. Some parts of this work included in the Part III have been begun by myself during my undergraduate thesis in the same laboratory and then completed during the initial part of my Ph.D. thesis: the whole results have been included for the sake of understanding and completeness. During my graduate studies I worked on two very different protein systems. The theorical trait d’union between these studies, at the biological level, is the acknowledgement that protein biophysical and structural studies must, in many cases, take into account the dynamical states of protein conformational equilibria and of local physico-chemical conditions where the system studied actually performs its function. This is introducted in the introductory part in Chapter 2. Two different examples of this are presented: the structural significance deriving from the action of mechanical forces in vivo (Chapter 3) and the complexity of conformational equilibria in intrinsically unstructured proteins and amyloid formation (Chapter 4). My experimental work investigated both these examples by using in both cases the single molecule force spectroscopy technique (described in Chapter 5 and Chapter 6). The work conducted on angiostatin focused on the characterization of the relationships between the mechanochemical properties and the mechanism of action of the angiostatin protein, and most importantly their intertwining with the further layer of complexity due to disulfide redox equilibria (Part III). These studies were accompanied concurrently by the elaboration of a theorical model for a novel signalling pathway that may be relevant in the extracellular space, detailed in Chapter 7.2. The work conducted on -synuclein (Part IV) instead brought a whole new twist to the single molecule force spectroscopy methodology, applying it as a structural technique to elucidate the conformational equilibria present in intrinsically unstructured proteins. These equilibria are of utmost interest from a biophysical point of view, but most importantly because of their direct relationship with amyloid aggregation and, consequently, the aetiology of relevant pathologies like Parkinson’s disease. The work characterized, for the first time, conformational equilibria in an intrinsically unstructured protein at the single molecule level and, again for the first time, identified a monomeric folded conformation that is correlated with conditions leading to -synuclein and, ultimately, Parkinson’s disease. Also, during the research work, I found myself in the need of a generalpurpose data analysis application for single molecule force spectroscopy data analysis that could solve some common logistic and data analysis problems that are common in this technique. I developed an application that addresses some of these problems, herein presented (Part V), and that aims to be publicly released soon.

Single-molecule force spectroscopy of membrane proteins from membranes freely spanning across nanoscopic pores.

Single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) provides detailed insight into the mechanical (un)folding pathways and structural stability of membrane proteins. So far, SMFS could only be applied to membrane proteins embedded in native or synthetic membranes adsorbed to solid supports. This adsorption causes experimental limitations and raises the question to what extent the support influences the results obtained by SMFS. Therefore, we introduce here SMFS from native purple membrane freely spanning across nanopores. We show that correct analysis of the SMFS data requires extending the worm-like chain model, which describes the mechanical stretching of a polypeptide, by the cubic extension model, which describes the bending of a purple membrane exposed to mechanical stress. This new experimental and theoretical approach allows to characterize the stepwise (un)folding of the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin and to assign the stability of single and grouped secondary structures. The (un)folding and stability of bacteriorhodopsin shows no significant difference between freely spanning and directly supported purple membranes. Importantly, the novel experimental SMFS setup opens an avenue to characterize any protein from freely spanning cellular or synthetic membranes.

The (Un)Folding of Multidomain Proteins Through the Lens of Single-molecule Force-spectroscopy and Computer Simulation

Proteins are specialized molecules that catalyze most of the reactions that can sustain life, and they become functional by folding into a specific 3D structure. Despite their importance, the question, "how do proteins fold?" - first pondered in in the 1930's - is still listed as one of the top unanswered scientific questions as of 2005, according to the journal Science. Answering this question would provide a foundation for understanding protein function and would enable improved drug targeting, efficient biofuel production, and stronger biomaterials. Much of what we currently know about protein folding comes from studies on small, single-domain proteins, which may be quite different from the folding of large, multidomain proteins that predominate the proteomes of all organisms.

In this thesis I will discuss my work to fill this gap in understanding by studying the unfolding and refolding of large, multidomain proteins using the powerful combination of single-molecule force-spectroscopy experiments and molecular dynamic simulations.

The three model proteins studied - Luciferase, Protein S, and Streptavidin - lend insight into the inter-domain dependence for unfolding and the subdomain stabilization of binding ligands, and ultimately provide new insight into atomistic details of the intermediate states along the folding pathway.

Stretching single-domain proteins: Phase diagram and kinetics of force-induced unfolding

Single-molecule force spectroscopy reveals unfolding of domains in titin on stretching. We provide a theoretical framework for these experiments by computing the phase diagrams for force-induced unfolding of single-domain proteins using lattice models. The results show that two-state folders (at zero force) unravel cooperatively, whereas stretching of non-two-state folders occurs through intermediates. The stretching rates of individual molecules show great variations reflecting the heterogeneity of force-induced unfolding pathways. The approach to the stretched state occurs in a stepwise “quantized” manner. Unfolding dynamics and forces required to stretch proteins depend sensitively on topology. The unfolding rates increase exponentially with force f till an optimum value, which is determined by the barrier to unfolding when f = 0. A mapping of these results to proteins shows qualitative agreement with force-induced unfolding of Ig-like domains in titin. We show that single-molecule force spectroscopy can be used to map the folding free energy landscape of proteins in the absence of denaturants.

Iron-regulated surface determinant protein a mediates adhesion of staphylococcus aureus to human corneocyte envelope proteins

The ability of Staphylococcus aureus to colonize the human nares is a crucial prerequisite for disease. IsdA is a major S. aureus surface protein that is expressed during human infection and required for nasal colonization and survival on human skin. In this work, we show that IsdA binds to involucrin, loricrin, and cytokeratin K10, proteins that are present in the cornified envelope of human desquamated epithelial cells. To measure the forces and dynamics of the interaction between IsdA and loricrin (the most abundant protein of the cornified envelope), single-molecule force spectroscopy was used, demonstrating high-specificity binding. IsdA acts as a cellular adhesin to the human ligands, promoting whole-cell binding to immobilized proteins, even in the absence of other S. aureus components (as shown by heterologous expression in Lactococcus lactis). Inhibition experiments revealed the binding of the human ligands to the same IsdA region. This region was mapped to the NEAT domain of IsdA. The NEAT domain also was found to be required for S. aureus whole-cell binding to the ligands as well as to human nasal cells. Thus, IsdA is an important adhesin to human ligands, which predominate in its primary ecological niche.

Eigenschaften von thermoresponsiven Bürstenpolymeren

In dieser Doktorarbeit werden die Eigenschaften von thermoresponsiven Bürstenpolymeren untersucht. Hierbei konnten erstmalig thermische Konformationsübergänge von zylindrischen Bürstenmolekülen auf Oberflächen beobachtet werden. Der Einfluss der Oberfläche auf die Umkehrbarkeit und die Kinetik der Übergänge wurde untersucht. Die dabei erhaltenen Erkenntnisse konnten verwendet werden, um das Verhalten der Polymere auf anderen Oberflächen vorherzusagen. Im zweiten Projekt wurde gezeigt, dass Einzelmolekül-Kraftspektroskopie eine gute Methode für die Untersuchung der mechanischen Eigenschaften von Bürstenpolymeren in guten Lösungsmitteln ist. Mit kleinen Substanzmengen kann die Persistenzlänge der Polymere bestimmt werden. Es ist möglich zu zeigen, dass die Persistenzlänge der Polymerbürsten von ihrer Seitenkettenlänge abhängt. Überraschenderweise funktioniert das Experiment nicht, wenn man die Bürsten aus einem Polymerfilm zieht anstatt ein Einzelmolekülexperiment durchzuführen. In diesem Fall zeigen die Kraft-Abstands-Kurven zu lange Kontur- und Persistenzlängen. Diese Beobachtung ist für lineare Polymere nicht gültig. Im dritten Teil der Doktorarbeit werden Kraft-Abstands-Experimente an einzelnen kollabierten Polymeren untersucht. In schlechten Lösungsmitteln zeigen die Bürsten ein moleküllängenabhängiges Kraft-Plateau, welches theoretisch vorausgesagt wurde und einen Phasenübergang von einem kollabierten zu einem entspannten Zustand der Polymerkette anzeigt. In Fly-Fishing-Experimenten kann man eine Hysterese zwischen den beiden Messkurven beobachten, welche bei mehrfachem Ziehen kleiner wird. Alle Experimente in schlechten Lösungsmitteln wurden mit linearen Polymeren reproduziert, um den Einfluss der Molekülarchitektur von den generellen Eigenschaften von Polymeren in schlechten Lösungsmitteln unterscheiden zu können. Zum Abschluss wird die Abhängigkeit der Polymerentfaltung von der Laderate des Experiments gemessen.

La spettroscopia di forza basata sull'AFM nello studio dello spazio conformazionale e dei processi aggregativi di proteine prioniche

Le malattie neurodegenerative sono caratterizzate da aggregazione proteica, dipendente dalla perdita della usuale struttura fisiologica funzionale delle proteine coinvolte, a favore di conformazioni tossiche (patologiche). Il modello corrente descrive questi cambiamenti conformazionali come eventi rari e ritiene che non esista una sola conformazione patogena, ma che tali possibili conformazioni siano piuttosto eterogenee. La caratterizzazione di queste strutture è, di conseguenza, difficile con le tradizionali tecniche in bulk che permettono di studiare solo la conformazione media e non rendono possibile il riconoscimento delle caratteristiche dei conformeri individuali. Lo sviluppo delle tecniche di singola molecola ha permesso di studiare in modo approfondito le conformazioni possibili. In questo lavoro la spettroscopia di forza di singola molecola basata sull'AFM viene applicata a PrP (proteina responsabile delle encefalopatie spongiformi trasmissibili). Si studiano gli equilibri conformazionali del monomero e quelli di costrutti oligomerici, allo scopo di caratterizzare gli step iniziali dei processi aggregativi. Nel corso di questo lavoro di tesi è stato, in particolare, sviluppato un sistema di analisi dati, al fine di studiare in modo quantitativo le distribuzioni di eventi ottenute. Grazie a tale strumento è stato possibile riconoscere i segnali di unfolding della conformazione nativa del monomero e notare come essa sia presente anche in costrutti oligomerici, ad indicare come questo ripiegamento sia stabile anche in presenza di più monomeri ravvicinati. Si è osservato l'effetto del pH sulla stabilità di tale struttura, notando come pH acidi destabilizzino il ripiegamento nativo. Inoltre si è studiato il ruolo dell'orientazione dei monomeri nella formazione di strutture dimeriche. Monomeri e oligomeri di PrP sono stati descritti come proteine parzialmente strutturate il cui panorama energetico contiene molti minimi locali, dando origine a parecchie conformazioni transienti.

Peptide transporter DtpA has two alternate conformations, one of which is promoted by inhibitor binding

Peptide transporters (PTRs) of the large PTR family facilitate the uptake of di- and tripeptides to provide cells with amino acids for protein synthesis and for metabolic intermediates. Although several PTRs have been structurally and functionally characterized, how drugs modulate peptide transport remains unclear. To obtain insight into this mechanism, we characterize inhibitor binding to the Escherichia coli PTR dipeptide and tripeptide permease A (DtpA), which shows substrate specificities similar to its human homolog hPEPT1. After demonstrating that Lys[Z-NO2]-Val, the strongest inhibitor of hPEPT1, also acts as a high-affinity inhibitor for DtpA, we used single-molecule force spectroscopy to localize the structural segments stabilizing the peptide transporter and investigated which of these structural segments change stability upon inhibitor binding. This characterization was done with DtpA embedded in the lipid membrane and exposed to physiologically relevant conditions. In the unbound state, DtpA adopts two main alternate conformations in which transmembrane α-helix (TMH) 2 is either stabilized (in ∼43% of DtpA molecules) or not (in ∼57% of DtpA molecules). The two conformations are understood to represent the inward- and outward-facing conformational states of the transporter. With increasing inhibitor concentration, the conformation characterized by a stabilized TMH 2 becomes increasingly prevalent, reaching ∼92% at saturation. Our measurements further suggest that Lys[Z-NO2]-Val interacts with discrete residues in TMH 2 that are important for ligand binding and substrate affinity. These interactions in turn stabilize TMH 2, thereby promoting the inhibited conformation of DtpA.

Mechanochemistry for Active Materials and Devices

The coupling of mechanical stress fields in polymers to covalent chemistry (polymer mechanochemistry) has provided access to previously unattainable chemical reactions and polymer transformations. In the bulk, mechanochemical activation has been used as the basis for new classes of stress-responsive polymers that demonstrate stress/strain sensing, shear-induced intermolecular reactivity for molecular level remodeling and self-strengthening, and the release of acids and other small molecules that are potentially capable of triggering further chemical response. The potential utility of polymer mechanochemistry in functional materials is limited, however, by the fact that to date, all reported covalent activation in the bulk occurs in concert with plastic yield and deformation, so that the structure of the activated object is vastly different from its nascent form. Mechanochemically activated materials have thus been limited to “single use” demonstrations, rather than as multi-functional materials for structural and/or device applications. Here, we report that filled polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) elastomers provide a robust elastic substrate into which mechanophores can be embedded and activated under conditions from which the sample regains its original shape and properties. Fabrication is straightforward and easily accessible, providing access for the first time to objects and devices that either release or reversibly activate chemical functionality over hundreds of loading cycles.

While the mechanically accelerated ring-opening reaction of spiropyran to merocyanine and associated color change provides a useful method by which to image the molecular scale stress/strain distribution within a polymer, the magnitude of the forces necessary for activation had yet to be quantified. Here, we report single molecule force spectroscopy studies of two spiropyran isomers. Ring opening on the timescale of tens of milliseconds is found to require forces of ~240 pN, well below that of previously characterized covalent mechanophores. The lower threshold force is a combination of a low force-free activation energy and the fact that the change in rate with force (activation length) of each isomer is greater than that inferred in other systems. Importantly, quantifying the magnitude of forces required to activate individual spiropyran-based force-probes enables the probe behave as a “scout” of molecular forces in materials; the observed behavior of which can be extrapolated to predict the reactivity of potential mechanophores within a given material and deformation.

We subsequently translated the design platform to existing dynamic soft technologies to fabricate the first mechanochemically responsive devices; first, by remotely inducing dielectric patterning of an elastic substrate to produce assorted fluorescent patterns in concert with topological changes; and second, by adopting a soft robotic platform to produce a color change from the strains inherent to pneumatically actuated robotic motion. Shown herein, covalent polymer mechanochemistry provides a viable mechanism to convert the same mechanical potential energy used for actuation into value-added, constructive covalent chemical responses. The color change associated with actuation suggests opportunities for not only new color changing or camouflaging strategies, but also the possibility for simultaneous activation of latent chemistry (e.g., release of small molecules, change in mechanical properties, activation of catalysts, etc.) in soft robots. In addition, mechanochromic stress mapping in a functional actuating device might provide a useful design and optimization tool, revealing spatial and temporal force evolution within the actuator in a way that might also be coupled to feedback loops that allow autonomous, self-regulation of activity.

In the future, both the specific material and the general approach should be useful in enriching the responsive functionality of soft elastomeric materials and devices. We anticipate the development of new mechanophores that, like the materials, are reversibly and repeatedly activated, expanding the capabilities of soft, active devices and further permitting dynamic control over chemical reactivity that is otherwise inaccessible, each in response to a single remote signal.

Force Spectroscopy with Dual-Trap Optical Tweezers: Molecular Stiffness Measurements and Coupled Fluctuations Analysis

ABSTRACT Dual-trap optical tweezers are often used in high-resolution measurements in single-molecule biophysics. Such measurements can be hindered by the presence of extraneous noise sources, the most prominent of which is the coupling of fluctuations along different spatial directions, which may affect any optical tweezers setup. In this article, we analyze, both from the theoretical and the experimental points of view, the most common source for these couplings in dual-trap optical-tweezers setups: the misalignment of traps and tether. We give criteria to distinguish different kinds of misalignment, to estimate their quantitative relevance and to include them in the data analysis. The experimental data is obtained in a, to our knowledge, novel dual-trap optical-tweezers setup that directly measures forces. In the case in which misalignment is negligible, we provide a method to measure the stiffness of traps and tether based on variance analysis. This method can be seen as a calibration technique valid beyond the linear trap region. Our analysis is then employed to measure the persistence length of dsDNA tethers of three different lengths spanning two orders of magnitude. The effective persistence length of such tethers is shown to decrease with the contour length, in accordance with previous studies.

Visualization, manipulation and force spectroscopy of cylindrical polymer brushes

The Ph.D. thesis deals with the conformational study of individual cylindrical polymer brush molecules using atomic force microscopy (AFM). Imaging combined with single molecule manipulation has been used to unravel questions concerning conformational changes, desorption behavior and mechanical properties of individual macromolecules and supramolecular structures. In the first part of the thesis (chapter 5) molecular conformations of cylindrical polymer brushes with poly-(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) side chains were studied in various environmental conditions. Also micelle formation of cylindrical brush-coil blockcopolymers with polyacrylic acid side chains and polystyrene coil have been visualized. In chapter 6 the mechanical properties of single cylindrical polymer brushes with (PNIPAM) side chains were investigated. Assuming that the brushes adopt equilibrium conformation on the surface, an average persistence length of lp= (29 ± 3) nm was determined by the end-to-end distance vs. contour length analysis in terms of the wormlike chain (WLC) model. Stretching experiments suggest that an exact determination of the persistence length using force extension curves is impeded by the contribution of the side chains. Modeling the stretching of the bottle brush molecule as extension of a dual spring (side chain and main chain) explains the frequently observed very low persistence length arising from a dominant contribution of the side chain elasticity at small overall contour lengths. It has been shown that it is possible to estimate the “true” persistence length of the bottle brush molecule from the intercept of a linear extrapolation of the inverse square root of the apparent persistence length vs. the inverse contour length plot. By virtue of this procedure a “true” persistence length of 140 nm for the PNIPAM brush molecules is predicted. Chapter 7 and 8 deal with the force-extension behavior of PNIPAM cylindrical brushes studied in poor solvent conditions. The behavior is shown to be qualitatively different from that in a good solvent. Force induced globule-cylinder conformational changes are monitored using “molecule specific force spectroscopy” which is a combined AFM imaging and SMFS technique. An interesting behavior of the unfolding-folding transitions of single collapsed PNIPAM brush molecules has been observed by force spectroscopy using the so called “fly-fishing” mode. A plateau force is observed upon unfolding the collapsed molecule, which is attributed to a phase transition from a collapsed brush to a stretched conformation. Chapter 9 describes the desorption behavior of single cylindrical polyelectrolyte brushes with poly-L-lysine side chains deposited on a mica surface using the “molecule specific force spectroscopy” technique to resolve statistical discrepancies usually observed in SMFS experiments. Imaging of the brushes and inferring the persistence length from a end-to-end distance vs. contour length analysis results in an average persistence length of lp = (25 ± 5) nm assuming that the chains adopt their equilibrium conformation on the surface. Stretching experiments carried out on individual poly-L-lysine brush molecules by force spectroscopy using the “fly-fishing” mode provide a persistence length in the range of 7-23 nm in reasonable accordance with the imaging results. In chapter 10 the conformational behavior of cylindrical poly-L-lysine brush-sodium dodecyl sulfate complexes was studied using AFM imaging. Surfactant induced cylinder to helix like to globule conformational transitions were observed.

Visualization of unwinding activity of duplex RNA by DbpA, a DEAD box helicase, at single-molecule resolution by atomic force microscopy

The Escherichia coli protein DbpA is unique in its subclass of DEAD box RNA helicases, because it possesses ATPase-specific activity toward the peptidyl transferase center in 23S rRNA. Although its remarkable ATPase activity had been well defined toward various substrates, its RNA helicase activity remained to be characterized. Herein, we show by using biochemical assays and atomic force microscopy that DbpA exhibits ATP-stimulated unwinding activity of RNA duplex regardless of its primary sequence. This work presents an attempt to investigate the action of DEAD box proteins by a single-molecule visualization methodology. Our atomic force microscopy images enabled us to observe directly the unwinding reaction of a DEAD box helicase on long stretches of double-stranded RNA. Specifically, we could differentiate between the binding of DbpA to RNA in the absence of ATP and the formation of a Y-shaped intermediate after its progression through double-stranded RNA in the presence of ATP. Recent studies have questioned the designation of DbpA, in particular, and DEAD box proteins in general as RNA helicases. However, accumulated evidence and the results reported herein suggest that these proteins are indeed helicases that resemble in many aspects the DNA helicases.