Sex discrimination and occupational segregation in the Australian labour market

This paper explores the implications of the difference between the occupational distribution for males and females in a joint model determining earnings and occupation. The male/female wage differential is evaluated for a number of broad occupational classifications. This is followed by an evaluation of the role and relative importance of inter-occupational and intra-occupational effects as contributors to the overall male/female wage differential The main conclusion following from the econometric results is that intra-occupational effects dominate Thus, policies which attempt to address the gender wage differential by re-allocation of labour across occupations are unlikely to solve the problem.

Wage differentials between permanent and temporary workers: Firm and occupational segregation

Published as an article in: Moneda y Crédito (2004), 219, pp.: 43-68.

Occupational Access and Wage Discrimination

This article presents a study on the quantification of the level of occupational access and wage discrimination in Great Britain. The traditional approach to quantifying the level of sex discrimination is to distinguish gender differences in productive characteristics from the unequal treatment of characteristics according to gender. The role of inter- versus intra-occupational effects in determining the magnitude of wage differences between men and women was examined. The econometric results provided estimates of the wage differential in six broad occupational classifications together with an aggregate picture of how important the occupational distribution of females is in explaining their lower average wage. In summary, the results of the study suggest that the vast majority of the male and female wage differential arises from intra-occupation effects. The results provide evidence to suggest that occupational segregation is not a major contributor to the observed male/female wage differential.

A distributional analysis of the native-immigrant wage gap : the importance of employment discrimination

It is well documented that immigrants earn less than natives in the United States, and various attempts have been made to determine whether these earnings differentials reflect underlying differences in skill or ethnic discrimination in the labor market. The earnings of immigrants and ethnic minorities is an extensively studied area focusing on the economic integration of immigrants (e.g., Chiswick (1978), Lalonde and Topel (1993), Borjas (1995)). Yet, the role of occupational segregation as a mechanism for discrimination is yet to be addressed (to our knowledge). Discrimination can be effective at either of two stages in the earnings process – in the assignment of earnings to people within occupational groups (henceforth referred to as wage discrimination) or in the allocation of people to occupations (henceforth referred to as employment discrimination). While it would be premature to attribute the underlying cause to discriminatory hiring policies of employers, it would be of social-political and economic interest to investigate the possibility.

Gender-based undervaluation and the equal remuneration powers of Fair Work Australia

We investigate gender-based wage undervaluation in light of FairWork Australia’s major recent decision for social and community service workers. Using regression methods, we demonstrate that wages for employees in female-dominated occupations are significantly lower than for comparable employees in male-dominated and integrated occupations. This undervaluation is present for both male and female employees, and persists after controlling for industry of employment. We then estimate the undervaluation within industry and juxtapose the results with evidence on the industry distribution of award reliance, a proxy for Fair Work Australia’s equal remuneration powers. There is not a strong relationship within industries between the extent of gender-based undervaluation and award reliance. This suggests that ‘equal remuneration for work of equal or comparable value’ is unlikely to be achieved universally by Fair Work Australia without substantial spillovers between awards and non-award agreements.

She'll be right mate : inclusivity experiences of men and women working in projects

Occupational segregation is a major source of labour market rigidity and economic inefficiency due to a waste of human resources. Organisations are repeatedly recognised as gendered constructs exhibiting sustained work segregation, income and status inequality, as well as cultural and individual images of gender, and these are perpetuated through their processes, practices and pressures (Acker, 1990). A large percentage of Australia’s workforce is now employed in project-based or project-oriented organisations, leading to the claim that Australia is a project-based economy. For a continued strong performance in this economy, organisations that employ project personnel will need to consider how they address inclusivity and equality in diversity in project based temporary organisations to ensure the supply of high quality project professionals into the future. This paper investigates the inclusion processes experienced and exercised by men and women working in temporary organisations in project situations through a review of reports on the inclusion processes experienced by 60 project managers and project workers in three project based industries in Australia. Results indicate that temporary organisations are not implementing equality and diversity management strategies at the macro level and project workers are accepting this lack of recognition. However inclusivity and equality at the micro level of the team is seen as vital.

Decomposing the Gender Wage Gap: The effect of firms, occupations and Job Stratification

This paper presents new evidence on the role of segregation into firms, occupations within a firm and stratification into professional categories within firm-occupations in explaining the gender wage gap. I use a generalized earnings model that allows observed and unobserved group characteristics to have different impact on wages of men and women within the same group. The database is a large sample of individual wage data from the 1995 Spanish Wage Structure Survey. Results indicate that firm segregation in our sample accounts for around one-fifth of the raw gender wage gap. Occupational segregation within firms accounts for about one-third of the raw wage gap, and stratification into different professional categories within firms and occupations explains another one-third of it. The remaining one-fifth of the overall gap arises from better outcomes of men relative to women within professional categories. It is also found that rewards to both observable and unobservable skills, particularly those related to education, are higher for males than for females within the same group. Finally, mean wages in occupations or job categories with a higher fraction of female co-workers are lower, but the negative impact of femaleness in higher for women.

La diversidad de los modelos de participación laboral de las mujeres en la UE-27

[ESP] El objetivo de este artículo es relacionar las características de la inserción laboral femenina con su grado de participación en el mercado laboral en los países de la Unión Europea a través de los datos proporcionados por Eurostat. Nos interesa conocer si una mayor participación laboral entre las mujeres va aparejada con un modelo laboral “femenino”, esto es, con empleos a tiempo parcial, temporales, de baja remuneración y en determinados sectores y ocupaciones. O si por el contrario, en los países en los cuales la tasa de empleo femenina es elevada y hay menor brecha con respecto a la de los hombres, el modelo de inserción laboral de mujeres y hombres es similar. La diversidad de los mercados de trabajo y también de las políticas públicas y de las estructuras productivas en un área tan amplia como al UE27, nos impide establecer modelos de inserción laboral femenina claros, aunque sí hemos podido apuntar rasgos comunes con respecto a las desigualdades de género entre países.

Social mobility in Ireland in the 1990s: Evidence from the 1994 living in Ireland survey

In this paper we seek to update findings relating to class mobility outcomes and processes in the Republic of Ireland employing data from the Living in Ireland Survey which was carried out in 1994. We also provide an evaluation of a measured variable model of the mobility process developed on an earlier data set. Our findings confirm that transformation of the class structure has been associated with substantial levels of social mobility. At the same time inequalities of opportunity as reflected in the underlying patterns of social fluidity remain substantial and are constant across cohorts. Gender differences are almost entirely a consequence of occupational segregation and there is no evidence that the underlying processes of class disadvantage operate differently for men and women.

Programme d’accès à l’égalité : réactions managériales au cadre légal québécois pour combattre la discrimination

En 1985, la Charte des droits et libertés de la personne (L.R.Q., ch. C-12) du Québec était amendée afin d’inclure une nouvelle section consacrée aux programmes d’accès à l’égalité (PAE). Cet ajout résulte du constat d’une situation d’inégalité sur le marché du travail québécois pour les membres de certains groupes, en raison de motifs illicites de discrimination. Concrètement, on observe une certaine ségrégation professionnelle, de faibles revenus moyens et des conditions précaires d’emploi. L’objectif des PAE est de redresser la situation de groupes victimes de discrimination; pour réaliser cet objectif, ils autorisent la mise en œuvre de mesures spécifiques à l’intention de ces derniers. Plusieurs types de PAE ont été mis en place par les gouvernements québécois successifs afin d’élargir leur champ d’application. Parmi ces différents types de PAE, cette étude se concentre sur ceux associés à l’obligation contractuelle qui obligent toutes les organisations qui emploient 100 employés ou plus et qui obtiennent un contrat ou une subvention du gouvernement du Québec d’une valeur de 100 000 $ et plus, à développer et à mettre en œuvre un PAE. Il s’agit de la principale forme de PAE touchant les organisations privées. Quatre groupes cibles sont identifiés dans ces PAE : les femmes, les membres des minorités visibles, les Autochtones et les personnes handicapées. Parmi ceux-ci, compte tenu de la croissance importante de ce groupe et des situations souvent aiguës de discrimination qu’ils vivent sur le marché du travail québécois, l’attention sera portée sur le groupe des minorités visibles. Très peu de recherches ont été réalisées sur ces PAE en raison d’une obligation de confidentialité de résultats complète. Les rares études effectuées jusqu’à présent ont constaté des progrès très inégaux entre les employeurs : alors qu’un petit nombre d’organisations semblaient progresser rapidement dans l’atteinte de leurs objectifs, la vaste majorité stagnait ou encore progressait très lentement. Ce constat menait à s’interroger sur les facteurs, autres que le cadre juridique, qui peuvent expliquer le niveau de conformité aux objectifs. En se basant sur une analyse de contenu d’entrevues semi-dirigées menées auprès de gestionnaires responsables des PAE dans 31 organisations privées de la région de Montréal, plusieurs facteurs des environnements externes et internes des organisations, ont été identifiés pour expliquer les niveaux de conformité aux objectifs qualitatifs. Parmi les facteurs positivement reliés, on remarque l’engagement des membres de la haute direction en faveur des PAE, la mise en place d’un système d’imputabilité et la perception de certains bénéfices liés à la diversification des effectifs. Au contraire, la confusion entre l’égalité et l’équité, le fait de privilégier les mouvements internes de personnel et les biais des gestionnaires de première ligne semblent être négativement reliés à l’atteinte des objectifs qualitatifs. Ces résultats démontrent l’importance que prennent les facteurs liés à l’environnement interne, surtout lorsque le cadre juridique est peu contraignant et que les gestionnaires croient que les probabilités de sanctions sont faibles. En se basant sur ces résultats, une série de recommandations est proposée, afin d’améliorer les PAE, mais aussi afin d’améliorer la compréhension des gestionnaires des ressources humaines sur ce qu’est la discrimination en emploi et les moyens les plus appropriés pour la combattre.

Men in social work : challenging or reproducing an unequal gender regime?

This article is concerned with the reproduction of gender inequality in social work and the extent to which the presence of men in the profession challenges discriminatory processes and occupational segregation. Although it is argued that men need to take more responsibility for caring roles in professions like social work, many of the rationales for encouraging more men to enter social work are unlikely to support alternative masculinities that will challenge gender inequalities. Only a profeminist commitment informing antisexist practices will enable men to address gender inequality in social work.

Mujeres y trabajo urbano : el caso de las mucamas de hotel (Mar Del Plata, 1960-1980)

A partir del análisis de un caso particular, como lo es el trabajo de las mucamas de hotel en la ciudad de Mar del Plata (entre las décadas de 1960 y 1980), el presente artículo se propone como una contribución al campo de estudios sobre el trabajo urbano femenino. En Mar del Plata, el impulso del turismo de masas a mediados del siglo XX fue acompañado por un importante desarrollo hotelero. Éste supuso una atractiva y amplia oferta de trabajo para hombres y mujeres que encontraron allí una forma de acceso al mercado laboral, principalmente durante la temporada estival. En este espacio, las mujeres se han concentrado en puestos de trabajo determinados. En el artículo observamos cómo las continuidades entre algunas de las labores desarrolladas en el hotel y el trabajo doméstico no remunerado contribuyeron a su feminización e indagamos en las implicancias que conllevó que un empleo presente importantes continuidades con dicho trabajo. El análisis de testimonios orales nos permitió un acercamiento a las experiencias de las trabajadoras y, junto a las sentencias de los Tribunales de Trabajo, contribuyeron a visibilizar los procesos (sociales, culturales y económicos) que intervienen en la generización del trabajo y en la segregación ocupacional que caracteriza al mercado de trabajo urbano.

The evolution of gender inequality in tourism employment in Spain

Evolución de la desigualdad por género del empleo turístico en España. Si bien la inversión en capital laboral femenino en la industria turística ha aumentado en los últimos años y parece que la discriminación en el acceso a puestos directivos ha descendido, se siguen produciendo diferentes situaciones de desigualdad. La mujer mantiene un salario por debajo del hombre y han aparecido nuevas formas de segregación ocupacional entre hombres y mujeres e incluso entre las propias mujeres: la división entre trabajo a tiempo parcial y completo es un buen ejemplo de este proceso. La hipótesis que se plantea este trabajo es que esa combinación entre tiempo de trabajo remunerado (ámbito público) y no remunerado (ámbito privado, doméstico) es un obstáculo que provoca el acceso de los varones a empleos hasta ahora "femeninos"; así mismo, se observará la calidad del empleo turístico desde la perspectiva de género.

“An Ebbing Tide Lowers all Boats” How the great recession of 2008 has affected men and women in Central and Eastern Europe

In this paper we explore the impact of the economic recession of 2008 on gender inequality in the labor force in Central and Eastern European countries. We argue that job and occupational segregation protected women’s employment more than men's in the CEE region as well, but unlike in more developed capitalist economies, women’s level of labor force participation declined and their rates of poverty increased during the crisis years. We also explore gender differences in opinions on the impact of the recession on people’s job satisfaction. For our analysis we use published data from EUROSTAT and our own calculations from EU SILC and ESS 2010.

Discourse on equality in organizations. A case study of the chemical industry in Tarragona

This paper presents a proposal for analyzing discourses on gender equality in organizations. The research is carried out as a case study, focusing on the chemical industry in Tarragona. To the question: why there are still so many differences between women and men in labour market, despite having multiple tools to avoid inequalities? we propose to focus on discourses of equality to find an answer. The viewpoint that companies have on gender is crucial in enabling policies for equality. To ensure that policies are truly aimed at promoting equality, it is needed a gender approach that nowadays is not widespread in organizations. From these considerations, we present a fourfold typology of discourses on equality in organizations.