For the better or the worse? The impact of business idea changes on new venture performance and novelty

Should new ventures stick to their knitting once they start commercialising or should they engage in frequent changes of their business idea? In this paper we argue that new ventures still need to learn their way in the early phases of commercialisation and that changes are good, but subject to two important contingencies. First is that changes should be aimed at enhancing uniqueness, which in turn enhances new venture performance. Second is that our results show that changes have limited affect on uniqueness and performance for entrepreneurs aiming at maximising opportunities, but that changing the business idea has a significant positive impact for entrepreneurs focusing on minimising losses. Our findings indicate that entrepreneurs aiming at minimising losses may offset their initial disadvantages by engaging in a series of adaptations of the business idea to gain higher performance and a more unique product offering.

Business planning, idea change, flexibility and performance: the best of both worlds?

The relationships between business planning and performance have divided the entrepreneurship research community for decades (Brinckmann et al, 2010). One side of this debate is the assumption that business plans may lock the firm in a specific direction early on, impede the firm to adapt to the changing market conditions (Dencker et al., 2009) and eventually, cause escalation of commitments by introducing rigidity (Vesper, 1993). Conversely, feedback received from the production and presentation of business plans may also lead the firm to take corrective actions. However, the mechanisms underlying the relationships between changes in business ideas, business plans and the performance of nascent firms are still largely unknown. While too many business idea changes may confuse stakeholders, exhaust the firm’s resources and hinder the undergoing legitimization process, some flexibility during the early stages of the venture may be beneficial to cope with the uncertainties surrounding new venture creation (Knight, 1921; March, 1982; Stinchcombe, 1965; Weick, 1979). Previous research has emphasized adaptability and flexibility as key success factors through effectual logic and interaction with the market (Sarasvathy, 2001; 2007) or improvisation and trial-and-error (Miner et al, 2001). However, those studies did not specifically investigate the role of business planning. Our objective is to reconcile those seemingly opposing views (flexibility versus rigidity) by undertaking a more fine-grained analysis at the relationships between business planning and changes in business ideas on a large longitudinal sample of nascent firms.

Institutional constraints on altruism in the formation of a venture idea

This thesis is about the social orientation of new venture ideas and how the degree of social orientation is influenced by the entrepreneur's level of altruism, by industry norms, and by nonprofit work experience. Potential entrepreneurs were asked to generate new venture ideas based on 3D-printing and their ideas were rated for degree of social orientation. It was found that while greater altruism leads to more socially-oriented venture ideas, the influence of altruism on the venture idea is constrained by the profit-maximization norm that is prevalent in most industries.

An evaluation of the Business Model Canvas by technology-oriented startups in Brazil : a qualitative study about the usage of the tool by Brazilian entrepreneurs

The following paper was conducted with the support of several entrepreneurs and startups from Brazil. The aim of the research was to find out which impact the Business Model Canvas, further abbreviated as BMC, has on technology-oriented startups in Brazil. The first step of the study was identify some general concepts of entrepreneurship, as well as the conditions and environment of the country. Afterwards, it was focused on defining and comparing different business model tools and concepts to the BMC. After the literature review and meeting with several professionals in the area of entrepreneurship and startups, a questionnaire was formulated in order to conduct the qualitative study and identify the main impact of the tool. The questionnaire was answered by ten startups. In order to check the validity and credibility of the research outcomes, theory and investigator triangulation was used. As a result, the usage of the BMC could be evaluated by obtaining the outcomes and the theory, which showed that Brazilian tech startups are using Osterwalder’s model for the reason of idea creation and testing, validating and pivoting their business model. Interestingly, the research revealed that the entrepreneurs are using the tool often not in the traditional way of printing it, but rather applying it as a thinking approach. Besides, the entrepreneurs are focusing mostly on developing a strong Value Proposition, Customer Segment and sustainable Revenue Streams, while afterwards the remaining building blocks are built. Moreover, the research showed that the startups are using also other concepts, such as the Customer Development Process or Build-Measure-Learn Feedback Loop. These methodologies are often applied together with the BMC and helps to identify the most sustainable components of the business idea. Keywords: Business

Desarrollo de idea de negocio "TecniHogar"

La asistencia y reparación del hogar es un servicio fundamental que cualquier persona puede a llegar a necesitar ante cualquier emergencia o necesidad. En Colombia la presentación de estos servicios ha venido presentando inconvenientes, debido a que las personas no encuentran fácil la manera de contactar y contratar a un técnico que les ofrezca confianza y seguridad. Igualmente los precios varían mucho, ya que juegan con la necesidad y cara del cliente y por lo tanto cada día se evidencian más inconformidades por parte de las personas. En el sector se evidencia claramente un problema, el cual debe ser atendido y es por ese motivo que se desarrollara una nueva idea de negocio que consiste en la implementación de una aplicación móvil que brinda a usuarios una alternativa innovadora para solicitar y contratar servicios técnicos para la asistencia del hogar, y así mismo a los técnicos se les ofrece una oportunidad diferente para incrementar sus servicios diarios y beneficios. TecniHogar es la aplicación móvil más fácil y amigable de manejar para los usuarios y prestadores de servicios, conecta a los clientes con los técnicos de una manera rápida y fácil. El proyecto se llevó a cabo por medio de una investigación cuantitativa, complementada a nivel analítico y comprensivo con cada una de las respuestas encontradas en las encuestas que se realizaron tanto a personas como a técnicos. De esta manera se pudo concluir que con la aplicación de TecniHogar usuarios y técnicos obtendrán un servicio más fácil, rápido, confiable y seguro que finalmente cambiara la forma de consumo y prestación de estos servicios

Do strategy choices matter for nascent firms? A study on effectuation and causation impacts on new ventures outcomes

Principal Topic : Nascent entrepreneurship has drawn the attention of scholars in the last few years (Davidsson, 2006, Wagner, 2004). However, most studies have asked why firms are created focussing on questions such as what are the characteristics (Delmar and Davidsson, 2000) and motivations (Carter, Gartner, Shaver & Reynolds, 2004) of nascent entrepreneurs, or what are the success factors in venture creation (Davidsson & Honig; 2003; Delmar and Shane, 2004). In contrast, the question of how companies emerge is still in its infancy. On a theoretical side, effectuation, developed by Sarasvathy (2001) offers one view of the strategies that may be at work during the venture creation process. Causation, the theorized inverse to effectuation, may be described as a rational reasoning method to create a company. After a comprehensive market analysis to discover opportunities, the entrepreneur will select the alternative with the higher expected return and implement it through the use of a business plan. In contrast, effectuation suggests that the future entrepreneur will develop her new venture in a more iterative way by selecting possibilities through flexibility and interaction with the market, affordability of loss of resources and time invested, development of pre-commitments and alliances from stakeholders. Another contrasting point is that causation is ''goal driven'' while an effectual approach is ''mean driven'' (Sarasvathy, 2001) One of the predictions of effectuation theory is effectuation is more likely to be used by entrepreneurs early in the venture creation process (Sarasvathy, 2001). However, this temporal aspect and the impact of the effectuation strategy on the venture outcomes has so far not been systematically and empirically tested on large samples. The reason behind this research gap is twofold. Firstly, few studies collect longitudinal data on emerging ventures at an early enough stage of development to avoid severe survivor bias. Second, the studies that collect such data have not included validated measures of effectuation. The research we are conducting attempts to partially fill this gap by combining an empirical investigation on a large sample of nascent and young firms with the effectuation/causation continuum as a basis (Sarasvathy, 2001). The objectives are to understand the strategies used by the firms during the creation process and measure their impacts on the firm outcomes. Methodology/Key Propositions : This study draws its data from the first wave of the CAUSEE project where 28,383 Australian households were randomly contacted by phone using a specific methodology to capture emerging firms (Davidsson, Steffens, Gordon, Reynolds, 2008). This screening led to the identification of 594 nascent ventures (i.e., firms that are not operating yet) and 514 young firms (i.e., firms that have started operating from 2004) that were willing to participate in the study. Comprehensive phone interviews were conducted with these 1108 ventures. In a likewise comprehensive follow-up 12 months later, 80% of the eligible cases completed the interview. The questionnaire contains specific sections designed to distinguish effectual and causal processes, innovation, gestation activities, business idea changes and ventures outcomes. The effectuation questions are based on the components of effectuation strategy as described by Sarasvathy (2001) namely: flexibility, affordable loss and pre-commitment from stakeholders. Results from two rounds of pre-testing informed the design of the instrument included in the main survey. The first two waves of data have will be used to test and compare the use of effectuation in the venture creation process. To increase the robustness of the results, temporal use of effectuation will be tested both directly and indirectly. 1. By comparing the use of effectuation in nascent and young firms from wave 1 to 2, we will be able to find out how effectuation is affected by time over a 12-month duration and if the stage of venture development has an impact on its use. 2. By comparing nascent ventures early in the creation process versus nascent ventures late in the creation process. Early versus late can be determined with the help of time-stamped gestation activity questions included in the survey. This will help us to determine the change on a small time scale during the creation phase of the venture. 3. By comparing nascent firms to young (already operational) firms. 4. By comparing young firms becoming operational in 2006 with those first becoming operational in 2004. Results and Implications : Wave 1 and 2 data have been completed and wave 2 is currently being checked and 'cleaned'. Analysis work will commence in September, 2009. This paper is expected to contribute to the body of knowledge on effectuation by measuring quantitatively its use and impact on nascent and young firms activities at different stages of their development. In addition, this study will also increase the understanding of the venture creation process by comparing over time nascent and young firms from a large sample of randomly selected ventures. We acknowledge the results from this study will be preliminary and will have to be interpreted with caution as the changes identified may be due to several factors and may not only be attributed to the use/not use of effectuation. Meanwhile, we believe that this study is important to the field of entrepreneurship as it provides some much needed insights on the processes used by nascent and young firms during their creation and early operating stages.

Metsäpirulainen : Liikemies Erik Johan Längman (1799-1863) talousjärjestelmän murroksessa

The Forest devil. Businessman Erik Johan Längman (1799 1863) in the transition of economic system In Finnish historiography, Erik Johan Längman (1799-1863) bears a bad reputation of his own level: a mean, profit-seeking businessman who did not care too much about methods in his operations. Although little known, Längman has been praised as one of the pioneers of modern industry in the Grand Duchy of Finland, which belonged to the Russian Empire. From the mid 1830s Längman owned iron mill and several sawmills around the country. The growing demand of the markets in the 1830s, especially in Great Britain, marked a strong stimulus to Finnish lumber industry. At the same time claims for stricter rule over the sawmill industry were raised by high officials. The momentum of the conflict, the Forest Act of 1851, brought an end to illegal overproduction. In this biography, particular emphasis is laid on the entrepreneurial behaviour of Längman, but also on the effect the entrepreneurs had on the Crown s policies. On the other hand, how did the limitations imposed by the Crown guide the actions of the sawmill owners? The solutions adopted by the sawmill owners and the manoeuvring of the government are in a constant dialogue in this study. The Finnish sawmill industry experienced a major change in its techniques and methods of acquiring timber during the 1830s. Längman particularly, with his acquisition organisation, was able to find and reach faraway forests with unexpected results. The official regulating system with its strict producing quotas couldn t follow the changes. When the battle against the sawmill industry really started on, in 1840, it didn t happen for the benefit of iron industry, as argued previously, but to save Crown forests from depletion. After the mid 1840s Längman and the leader of the Finnish nationalistic movement, J. V. Snellman questioned the rationality of the entire regulation system and in doing so they also posed a threat against the aristocratic power. The influential but now also badly provoked chairman of the economic division of senate, Lars Gabriel von Haartman, accused the sawmill-owners harder than ever and took the advantage of the reactionary spirit of imperial Russia to launch the state forest administration. Längman circumvented the conditions of privileges, felled Crown forests illegally and accusations were brought against him for destroying his competitors. The repeated conflicts spoke primarily about a superior business idea and organisational ability. Although Längman spent his last years mostly abroad he still had interests in Finnish timber business when the liberation of sawmill-industry was established, in 1861. Surprisingly, the antagonism around the Crown forests continued, probably even more heated.

Utilización de la lógica borrosa en la selección de personas e ideas para la participación en programas públicos de ayuda a la creación de empresas

[ES] Se propone en este trabajo un modelo de control borroso que ayude a filtrar y seleccionar las solicitudes de subvención que pueda recibir una institución pública en un programa de fomento para la creación y desarrollo de nuevas iniciativas empresariales. Creemos que la utilización de la lógica borrosa presenta ventajas sobre los procedimientos ordinarios ya que nos movemos en un escenario de actuación complejo y vago. El control borroso introduce el conocimiento de los expertos de un modo muy natural mediante variables lingüísticas y procesos de inferencia propios del lenguaje ordinario, lo que facilita la toma de decisiones en situaciones complejas. Nuestro modelo considera por un lado la idea empresarial y por otro la persona . Los indicadores y criterios que los expertos consideran relevantes para la evaluación de la subvención son modelados mediante variables lingüísticas y tratados como antecedentes y consecuentes de un motor de inferencia borroso, cuya salida nos proporciona la valoración final de la solicitud. Al final de nuestro trabajo resolvemos un caso práctico sencillo para aclarar el procedimiento.

O Design, a Gestão e a Comunicação da Marca: Caso de estudo spryou

Dissertação apresentada ao Instituto Politécnico de Castelo Branco para cumprimento dos requisitos necessários à obtenção do grau de Mestre em Design Gráfico pela Escola Superior de Artes Aplicadas do Instituto Politécnico de Castelo Branco em associação com a Faculdade de Arquitetura da Universidade de Lisboa.

A practical approach to execute and test a lean startup

This paper practically applies the “Lean Startup Approach” by identifying, analyzing and executing a newly developed web-based business idea. Hypotheses were designed and tested with the construction of a minimum viable product – i.e. a landing page. In-depth interviews allowed deciding either to pivot or persevere the initial launch strategy. Overall, the aim was to collect as much valuable response as possible from customers and ultimately decide for a superior strategy while devoting the smallest amount of time and money.

Plan de empresa : Nanas y Niñeras

El presente Plan de Empresa tiene como objetivo primordial concretar y cuantificar la idea de negocio Nanas y Niñeras para determinar su viabilidad en el mercado. Esta idea de negocio se basa en crear una empresa que se dedique a prestar el servicio de nanas y niñeras profesionales a domicilio en distintas modalidades de servicio, enmarcada en el concepto de brindar un servicio que contribuya al desarrollo integral y formación de los niños y niñas con amor, comprensión y responsabilidad.

Plan de empresa "Dorcé"

Dorcé es una idea de negocio que responde de manera directa a la necesidad de vestir de las mujeres a través de su innovador sistema operativo “Diseño y confección a tu manera” el cual tiene como objetivo revolucionar la tradicional forma de adquirir prendas de vestir femeninas en la ciudad de Villavicencio. Desde su creación y ejecución, se ha observado una gran aceptación de dicho sistema operativo por parte de los clientes antiguos generando muy buenos resultados económicos partiendo de sus actividades principales, el diseño, la confección y venta de prendas de vestir femeninas. Es por esto que el desarrollo de este trabajo de grado va dirigido a organizar de una manera más administrativa los diferentes procesos que se llevan a cabo dentro de la organización a fin de conseguir incrementar la producción y llegar así a un grupo más amplio de clientes con base en sus necesidades y a las actuales tendencias de la moda. Esta labor tiene como fin, responder y satisfacer a la mujer villavicense en términos de moda, servicio y confección, agregándole un valor adicional en cuanto a menores tiempos de entrega, altos estándares de calidad y exclusividad. Todo lo anterior, en un solo lugar. El sistema operativo (factor diferenciador) de esta idea de negocio consiste en ofrecer a los clientes, diferentes modelos de las partes (cuello, manga, contorno, falda y panty) que componen las prendas que fabrica Dorcé (Blusa, vestido y traje de baño). Con el fin de que el cliente pueda armar la prenda a su gusto teniendo el plus de ir “a la medida”. Dicha prenda de carácter exclusivo, es confeccionada y entregada al cabo de un máximo de 3 días dependiendo de la complejidad que tenga para ser elaborada, garantizándole al cliente no solo la originalidad del diseño de su prenda sino también fabricarla en menor tiempo que la competencia. Es un producto y un servicio innovador que va dirigido a mujeres de quince a setenta años de edad de la ciudad de Villavicencio, mujeres de media y alta sociedad que se caracterizan por su gusto por la moda y la calidad. Una vez se satisfacen las necesidades de nuestros clientes se da lugar a nuevas ventas dentro del grupo social de cada una de ellas, una vez nos refieran de manera positiva con sus amigas y conocidas. Este tipo de publicidad (voz a voz) es la que ha llevado a Dorcé a crecer a través de los años sin perder la exclusividad de su mercado; sin embargo, en la actualidad, la idea de negocio carece de estructura empresarial adecuada, de estrategias que garanticen su crecimiento y sostenibilidad, también carece de recursos financieros inmediatos que faciliten la ampliación y adecuación de la planta de producción y del almacén. Es por ello que las actuales empresarias de esta idea de negocio tienen como objetivo, mediante la elaboración de este plan de empresa, desarrollar, organizar y mejorar las estrategias, acciones, objetivos, alianzas, cambios, inversiones, que se tienen y necesitan para el mejoramiento interno y externo de la compañía. Para el desarrollo de dicho plan, Dorcé cuenta con Doris Blanco, una diseñadora de modas de 25 años de experiencia en el sector textil y confección en la ciudad de Villavicencio, quien está a cargo del área de producción de la empresa, dos estudiantes de Administración de Negocios Internacionales, Fernanda Montes y Juliana Villamizar, quienes están a cargo de la parte administrativa, comercial y estratégica de la empresa. De igual forma cuenta con el conocimiento del mercado textil y de confección, así mismo amplias relaciones que se han venido fortaleciendo a través del tiempo con los diferentes proveedores de materia prima en la ciudad, maquinaria y materia prima inicial, cerca de sesenta mujeres que se han vinculado a la empresa como clientes fieles a la idea de negocio promocionándolo de manera positiva día a día, así como también el interés, empuje y compromiso por parte de las involucradas en desarrollar, ejecutar y sostener esta idea de negocio como proyecto de vida.

Vida y muerte empresarial - Estudios empíricos de perdurabilidad, empresas saludables : caso Bodytech

En los últimos años en Colombia se ha visto un crecimiento exponencial de muchos negocios que son nuevos para el Mercado Colombiano y en especial para el consumidor. Esto es el resultado de una sostenibilidad y perdurabilidad de compañías que son factores importantes para un negocio durante tiempos difíciles. Pero hay muchos componentes que son necesarios para conseguir los logros financieros y económicos esperados. Las compañías siempre están en la búsqueda de desarrollar un modelo de crecimiento exitoso para establecer un nombre y un modelo de negocio en el largo plazo. En este caso en particular, existe una compañía Colombiana llamada BODYTECH, que empezó como un negocio pequeño y ahora es una de los centros deportivos número uno de Colombia y uno de los más importantes de Latinoamérica. Los fundadores de BODYTECH lograron crear una idea de negocio completamente nueva para un mercado que nunca había visto algo parecido. Aprovecharon la oportunidad en un sector que nunca había sido explotado de esa manera antes y se convirtieron en los mejores en lo que hacen creando un nombre reconocido a nivel nacional y un excelente lugar de trabajo. Todo lo mencionado anteriormente hacen de BODYTECH una de las compañías más admiradas y consolidadas en Colombia y Latinoamérica.

Estudio de factibilidad para la creación de una planta reencauchadora en la ciudad de Bogotá

El siguiente estudio de factibilidad para el montaje de una planta de reencauche en la ciudad de Bogotá busca dar al lector bases fuertes y solidad para estructurar una idea de negocio con base al reencauche de llantas. El estudio busca analizar que tan factible es el montaje de la planta, además abarca temas relacionados con la historia del reencauche, las normas legales mininas que hay para realizar procesos de este tipo, también dentro del estudio el lector podrá encontrar un estudio de mercados, en donde se especifican las preferencias de los posibles consumidores y de los actuales competidores. En términos generales se hace una clara referencia a los aspectos específicos referentes a la planta y procesos, de este modo se tiene una base solida para realizar un posterior análisis financiero en donde se evalúa la viabilidad del negocio, por medio de un análisis a cada una de las variables financieras más relevantes dentro de una proyección, para así implementar una estrategia que tenga una base solida de donde se espera que sea el punto de partida para la implementación como tal del estudio realizado.

B&C +Emerging Music+ Management+

B&C tiene como idea de negocio representar a músicos emergentes ofreciendo un servicio de asesoría y acompañamiento integral para la construcción de un producto musical altamente competitivo en el mercado global.