A cost-minimization analysis of the societal costs of realtime teledermatology compared with conventional care: results from a randomized controlled trial in New Zealand

A randomized controlled trial was carried out to measure the societal costs of realtime teledermatology compared with those of conventional hospital care in New Zealand. Two rural health centres were linked to a specialist hospital via ISDN at 128 kbit/s. Over 10 months, 203 patients were referred for a specialist dermatological consultation and 26 were followed up, giving a total of 229 consultations. Fifty-four per cent were randomized to the teledermatology consultation and 46% to the conventional hospital consultation. A cost-minimization analysis was used to calculate the total costs of both types of dermatological consultation. The total cost of the 123 teledermatology consultations was NZ$34,346 and the total cost of the 106 conventional hospital consultations was NZ$30,081. The average societal cost of the teledermatology consultation was therefore NZ$279.23 compared with NZ$283.79 for the conventional hospital consultation. The marginal cost of seeing an additional patient was NZ$135 via teledermatology and NZ$284 via conventional hospital appointment. From a societal viewpoint, and assuming an equal outcome, teledermatology was a more cost-efficient use of resources than conventional hospital care.

A randomized controlled trial assessing the health economics of realtime teledermatology compared with conventional care: an urban versus rural perspective

A randomized controlled trial was carried out to measure the cost-effectiveness of realtime teledermatology compared with conventional outpatient dermatology care for patients from urban and rural areas. One urban and one rural health centre were linked to a regional hospital in Northern Ireland by ISDN at 128 kbit/s. Over two years, 274 patients required a hospital outpatient dermatology referral -126 patients (46%) were randomized to a telemedicine consultation and 148 (54%) to a conventional hospital outpatient consultation. Of those seen by telemedicine, 61% were registered with an urban practice, compared with 71% of those seen conventionally. The clinical outcomes of the two types of consultation were similar - almost half the patients were managed after a single consultation with the dermatologist. The observed marginal cost per patient of the initial realtime teledermatology consultation was f52.85 for those in urban areas and f59.93 per patient for those from rural areas. The observed marginal cost of the initial conventional consultation was f47.13 for urban patients and f48.77 for rural patients. The total observed costs of teledermatology were higher than the costs of conventional care in both urban and rural areas, mainly because of the fixed equipment costs. Sensitivity analysis using a real-world scenario showed that in urban areas the average costs of the telemedicine and conventional consultations were about equal, while in rural areas the average cost of the telemedicine consultation was less than that of the conventional consultation.

Influenza surveillance using data from a telemedicine centre.

OBJECTIVES: This study aimed at investigating whether data from medical teleconsultations may contribute to influenza surveillance. METHODS: International Classification of Primary Care 2nd Edition (ICPC-2) codes were used to analyse the proportion of teleconsultations due to influenza-related symptoms. Results were compared with the weekly Swiss Sentinel reports. RESULTS: When using the ICPC-2 code for fever we could reproduce the seasonal influenza peaks of the winter seasons 07/08, 08/09 and 09/10 as depicted by the Sentinel data. For the pandemic influenza 09/10, we detected a much higher first peak in summer 2009 which correlated with a potential underreporting in the Sentinel system. CONCLUSIONS: ICPC-2 data from medical teleconsultations allows influenza surveillance in real time and correlates very well with the Swiss Sentinel system.

Investigação da eficácia da teleconsulta na programação do implante coclear

A demanda crescente de usuários de implante coclear (IC) e a distribuição irregular de profissionais especializados no país, tornam necessário o deslocamento de pacientes por longas distâncias para os atendimentos, com consequente aumento dos custos diretos e indiretos do tratamento. A teleconsulta pode ser vista como uma alternativa em potencial para o acesso desta população a estes serviços. O presente ensaio clínico, randomizado, controlado, avaliou a eficácia da teleconsulta síncrona na programação dos sistemas de IC em usuários acompanhados em um Programa de Implante Coclear credenciado pelo Sistema Único de Saúde. Participaram do estudo 79 indivíduos com idades entre nove e 68 anos (média de 21,6), 41 do sexo masculino e 38 do sexo feminino, usuários de IC por um período de 0,58 a 24,75 anos. Estes indivíduos foram divididos em dois grupos, de acordo com o modo de programação do IC: controle (n=40), que realizou o procedimento face a face e experimental (n=39) que realizou a teleconsulta síncrona. Treze fonoaudiólogos sem experiência na programação do dispositivo atuaram como facilitadores das teleconsultas. Os procedimentos de programação do IC englobaram a telemetria de impedância, definição dos níveis de estimulação elétrica, varredura e balanceamento dos eletrodos e ajuste fino da programação. Como medidas de avaliação de resultados foram utilizados o tempo dispendido na consulta, a audiometria em campo livre, o percentual de reconhecimento de sentenças no silêncio e no ruído, o limiar de reconhecimento de sentenças no silêncio e ruído (HINT-Brasil), a avaliação da satisfação com a consulta (escala MISS-21) e de aspectos pertinentes à teleconsulta. Os facilitadores responderam as questões abertas referentes à suas impressões dos atendimentos. Os dados foram analisados por meio de estatística inferencial (testes t de Student, Wilcoxon, Mann-Whitney e correlação de Spearman). Os resultados mostraram que após a programação do IC, em média, os participantes apresentaram limiares audiométricos abaixo de 30 dB NA. O reconhecimento da fala pós atendimento, respectivamente para os grupos experimental e controle, foram de 81,3% e 83,8% (silêncio) e 57,9% e 58,1% (ruído). No HINT-Brasil os resultados foram, respectivamente, para os grupos experimental e controle 61,4 dB NA e 61,8 dB NA (silêncio) e relação S/R de 9,5 dB NA e 10,4 dB NA (ruído). Os participantes estiveram satisfeitos com a consulta. Não houve diferença estatisticamente significativa entre os grupos em nenhuma das medidas de resultado. Todos os participantes relataram que teleconsulta pode ser vista como uma alternativa viável ao atendimento face a face e sua aplicação clínica facilitaria a rotina de pacientes usuários de IC. Os facilitadores destacaram a sua importância para o aprendizado e como ferramenta de formação continuada. A teleconsulta síncrona foi eficaz na programação dos sistemas de IC e amplamente aceita pelos usuários e profissionais.

Evaluation of an accident and emergency teleconsultation service for north-east Scotland

We evaluated an accident and emergency teleconsultation service provided to 14 community hospitals in north-east Scotland. Each community hospital was equipped with a videoconferencing system and a document camera to allow transmission of radiographs. The network used 384 kbit/s ISDN connections. A total of 1392 teleconsultations were recorded during a 12-month study period. Seventy-seven per cent of patients (n=1072) were managed locally and 23% (n=320) were transferred to Aberdeen. The majority (95%) of teleconsultations were conducted on weekdays, and 90% of these occurred between the hours of 09:00 and 16:00. The mean delay in contacting a doctor was 9 min and the mean consultation time was 10 min. The majority of patients were suffering from fractures or suspected fractures of the limbs. Radiograph transmission was used in 75% of all teleconsultations. A high degree of satisfaction was recorded by all users of the service.

Paediatric telecardiology services in Queensland: a review of three years' experience

Videoconferencing at 384 kbit/s for the transmission of echocardiograms has proved useful for the assessment of children with suspected cardiac disease, in regional areas of Queensland. A retrospective review of patient and management outcomes was conducted on cardiac teleconsultations performed at two regional hospitals during the period November 2000 to February 2004, inclusive. There were 106 echo studies. A subset of 72 cardiac teleconsultations performed between May 2001 and February 2004 was reviewed in detail. The median age of patients at the time of consultation was 3 months (range 1 day-17 years). Sixteen per cent of teleconsultations were classified as urgent and were conducted on the same day as referral. Following the videoconference, 90% of patients could be managed locally and reviewed by the paediatrician or visiting paediatric cardiologist during an outreach clinic. Six children (8%) had significant cardiac lesions that were initially managed locally, with subsequent elective transfer at the appropriate time for treatment. Only one child (1%) required urgent transfer to the tertiary centre for specialist care and surgery. Telecardiology was effective in accurately identifying congenital heart disease. Paediatric telecardiology is an evolving modality of assessment and communication, and is likely to result in continued improvements in patient care, patient outcomes and parental satisfaction, in provincial centres removed from the tertiary cardiac centre.

Evaluation of a pilot telemedicine network for accident and emergency work

A pilot accident and emergency. teleconsulting service was established in Scotland. It was based at the accident and emergency department of the main hospital in Aberdeen. There were three peripheral sites in rural Grampian (Peterhead, Turriff and Huntly) and one in the Shetland Isles. The videoconferencing equipment used was connected by ISDN at 384 kbit/s. During the 15 months of the study, 1998 videoconference calls were made, of which 402 (20%) calls were made to the accident and emergency department for clinical consultations. The majority of the clinical calls (95%) were made between 09:00 and 17:00, and more than 90% were completed within 20 min. During the majority of calls (87%) one or more X-ray images were transmitted. The majority of patients (89%) received treatment without transportation to the main centre in Aberdeen. The present study demonstrated that accident and emergency teleconsultations can be technically reliable, effective in reducing the number of patient transfers and acceptable to the referring clinicians. As a result, approximately pound1.5 million has been made available by the government to develop a national system for Scotland.

Telessaúde como ferramenta de apoio à atenção primária à saúde: um olhar sobre as teleconsultorias em cardiologia

In order to qualify Primary Health Care in Brazil, the Ministry of Health implemented the Brazilian Telehealth Program to provide health support (telecare) and permanent health education (tele-education). In this respect, one of the primary services offered is teleconsultation. As part of the national expansion of the program, a local Telehealth Center, called Telehealth/RN, was created in Rio Grande do Norte state. The aim of this study was to describe the implementation of cardiological teleconsultations at Telehealth/RN, and analyze the characteristics of the teleconsultations in cardiology requested. Formative Second Opinions in cardiology, available at the web site of the Brazilian Telehealth Program, were also examined. This is a quantitative study with a descriptive, observational design. A total of 56 Formative Second Opinions in cardiology were identified, a majority related to hypertension (29%), focused on treatment support (30%), and requested by doctors (59%). At Telehealth/RN, 47 teleconsultations in cardiology were carried out, a majority also related to hypertension (50%), requested by community health workers (45%) and focused directly on treatment (52%). Cardiological teleconsultation, implemented at the Telehealth/RN in April 2014, is a practical and efficient strategy capable of ensuring health services and reaching those who live in remote areas. Knowing the demand for teleconsultations is extremely important, given that they provide the information needed to correct existing inadequacies related to care, management and/or education, as well as providing the basis for public policies that meet the demands of teleconsultation.