Added Value of Combining Value and Momentum Indicators in the Swiss Stock Market

The purpose of the thesis is to examine the added value of combining value and momentum indicators in the Swiss stock exchange. Value indicators employed are P/E, EV/EBITDA, P/CF, P/B ja P/S. Momentum indicators examined are 52-week high, acceleration rate, 12-month past return and 6-month past return. The thesis examines whether the composite value measures based on the above mentioned ratios can add value and whether the inclusion of momentum can further improve the risk return profile of the value portfolios. The data is gathered from the Swiss equity market during the sample period from May 2001 to May 2011. Previous studies have shown that composite value measures can somewhat add value to the value portfolio strategy. Similarly, recent academic literature have found evidence that momentum works well as a timing indicator for time to entry to value stocks. This study indicates that the added value of composite value measures exists. It also shows that momentum combined to acceleration rate can significantly improve the risk adjusted performance of value-only portfolios.

Mutual Fund Performance and the Market Timing Ability - Finnish Evidence

The purpose of this thesis is to examine the performance of Finnish equity funds and their market timing ability. Fund performance is evaluated by using annual returns and various risk-adjusted measures, including Sharpe ratio, DDSR, SKASR, Treynor ratio and Jensen’s alpha, whereas portfolio manager’s timing ability is examined with Treynor-Mazuy model and Henriksson-Merton model. The data is collected from the Finnish fund market during the sample period from January 1997 to February 2010. Results show that Finnish equity funds have been able to outperform the market return on a risk-adjusted basis, but these results are influenced heavily by the exceptionally good performance during the IT-bubble. Market timing models show that fund managers have been, to some degree, able to time the market but not a single fund have been able to possess security selection ability and market timing ability simultaneously.

Hedge-rahastojen menestyksen pysyvyys ja suhteellinen suoriutuminen sijoittajan näkökulmasta

The purpose of the thesis is to examine the long-term performance persistence and relative performance of hedge funds during bear and bull market periods. Performance metrics applied for fund rankings are raw return, Sharpe ratio, mean variance ratio and strategy distinctiveness index calculated of the original and clustered data correspondingly. Four different length combinations for selection and holding periods are employed. The persistence is examined using decile and quartile portfolio formatting approach and on the basis of Sharpe ratio and SKASR as performance metrics. The relative performance persistence is examined by comparing hedge portfolio returns during varying stock market conditions. The data is gathered from a private database covering 10,789 hedge funds and time horizon is set from January 1990 to December 2012. The results of this thesis suggest that long-term performance persistence of the hedge funds exists. The degree of persistence also depends on the performance metrics employed and length combination of selection and holding periods. The best results of performance persistence were obtained in the decile portfolio analysis on the basis of Sharpe ratio rankings for combination of 12-month selection period and the holding period of equal length. The results also suggest that the best performance persistence occurs in the Event Driven and Multi strategies. Dummy regression analysis shows that a relationship between hedge funds and stock market returns exists. Based on the results, Dedicated Short Bias, Global Macro, Managed Futures and Other strategies perform well during bear market periods. The results also indicate that the Market Neutral strategy is not absolutely market neutral and the Event Driven strategy has the best performance among all hedge strategies.

VAIC-menetelmän soveltuvuus osaketuottojen ennustamiseen Nasdaq Helsinki -pörssissä

Aineeton pääoma on tärkeä osa yritysten kilpailukykyä ja sijoittajan näkökulmasta olisi mielenkiintoista pystyä vertailemaan yritysten aineettoman pääoman käytön tehokkuutta. Tutkimuksessa tarkasteltava VAIC-menetelmä tuottaa vertailuluvun tähän arviointiin tilinpäätöksestä saatavien tietojen avulla. Tutkimuksessa käsitellään kahden toimialakokonaisuuden (IT ja kulutustavarat ja -palvelut) yrityksiä Nasdaq Helsingin päälistalta tarkasteluperiodilla 2006¬-2013. Yrityksille laskettiin vuosittain VAIC-luvut, joiden perusteella muodostetaan ylä- ja alakvartiiliportfoliot. Näiden portfolioiden tuottoja verrattiin toisiinsa sekä kvartiiliportfolioiden ulkopuolelle jääneiden yritysten ja koko toimialan keskimääräiseen tuottoon. Tuottoja tarkasteltiin myös riskisuhteutetusti Sharpen ja vinous-ja huipukkuuskorjatun Sharpen (SKASR) luvulla. Lisäksi VAIC-arvon ja osaketuottojen välistä korrelaatiota tarkasteltiin sekä vuosittain että koko tarkasteluperiodin osalta. Ensimmäinen hypoteesi oletti korkeampien VAIC-arvojen johtavan korkeampiin portfoliotuottoihin, mutta hypoteesi jouduttiin hylkäämään molempien toimialojen osalta. Toinen hypoteesi tarkasteli korrelaatiota VAIC-arvojen ja osaketuottojen välillä, mutta saatujen tulosten mukaan se ei ollut tilastollisesti merkitsevää. VAIC-menetelmä edellyttäisikin jatkokehitystä tai sitä tulisi käyttää yhdessä muiden suorituskykymittareiden kanssa taloudellisesti hyödynnettävissä olevan tiedon tuottamiseksi sijoittajille.