Efficacité relative des grilles de correction d’un test de jugement situationnel pour la sélection du personnel de centres d’appels

Dans le domaine des centres d’appels, l’affectation d’agents au service à la clientèle efficaces et satisfaits représente une activité cruciale pour toute direction dédiée aux ressources humaines de ces unités d’affaires. Or, pour parvenir à prendre de bonnes décisions d’embauche et de rejet, des instruments de mesure et d’évaluation des compétences sont souvent mis à contribution. À cet effet, les tests de jugement situationnel (TJS) sont de plus en plus utilisés pour la sélection du personnel. L’objet de cette thèse est donc de vérifier l’efficacité relative des différentes méthodes d’élaboration des grilles de correction des TJS. En effet, jusqu’à présent, trois méthodes ont été privilégiées par les concepteurs de tests (Weekley, Ployhart, & Holtz, 2006) : (1) l’approche rationnelle ou théorique (2) l’approche empirique et (3) le recours à des experts. La possibilité qu’une combinaison de ces différentes approches puisse conduire à de meilleurs résultats est également explorée. Pour y parvenir, le résultat total obtenu à un TJS a été mis en lien avec une évaluation du rendement global effectuée par un supérieur immédiat en y appliquant huit grilles de correction différentes. Au total, un échantillon de 312 employés œuvrant dans des emplois de téléopérateurs au sein d’une grande institution financière québécoise ont participé à cette recherche. Dans l’ensemble, les résultats indiquent qu’une approche empirique permet généralement d’obtenir de meilleures statistiques descriptives en termes de distribution et de dispersion des scores pour un processus de sélection. Cependant, des analyses corrélationnelles indiquent qu’une approche multiple ou méthode hybride, basée sur une intégration des informations fournies par différentes sources d’informations (empirique, théorique et basé sur les experts) pour l’élaboration d’une grille de correction d’un TJS, permet de mieux prédire le rendement des employés (r=0,247**) comparativement à l’utilisation de la théorie pour définir les attentes (r=0,162**), le recours à des experts de contenu œuvrant dans le domaine de pratique (r=0,164**) ou l’utilisation d’une approche empirique (r=0,154*). Mots clés : Test de jugement situationnel, grilles de correction, validité critériée, centre d’appels.

Une nouvelle perspective sur la personnalité comme variable prévisionnelle du rendement individuel au travail : l'approche holistique comparée à l'approche traditionnelle centrée sur les variables

Thèse numérisée par la Division de la gestion de documents et des archives de l'Université de Montréal

Pour réussir dans la vie professionnelle, a-t-on besoin d'un bon quotient intellectuel (QI) ou d'un bon quotient émotionnel (QÉ)?

Après avoir présenté brièvement deux courants conceptuels à propos de l’intelligence émotionnelle (IÉ), nous abordons l’impact de celle-ci sur sept aspects du monde du travail : le leadership, la formation du personnel, la sélection du personnel, le rendement à la tâche, la gestion des conflits, les attitudes au travail et le bien-être au travail. Alors que l’intelligence émotionnelle promettait au départ de bouleverser le monde du travail, un grand nombre d’études montre que celle-ci ne fait pas le poids, particulièrement au plan de sa validité. Comparée à la valeur prédictive du quotient intellectuel (QI), l’intelligence émotionnelle montre un faible pouvoir prédicteur, en dépit des instruments judicieux que ses promoteurs ont mis au point pour mesurer ses effets.

Pour réussir dans la vie professionnelle, a-t-on besoin d'un bon quotient intellectuel (QI) ou d'un bon quotient émotionnel (QÉ)?

Après avoir présenté brièvement deux courants conceptuels à propos de l’intelligence émotionnelle (IÉ), nous abordons l’impact de celle-ci sur sept aspects du monde du travail : le leadership, la formation du personnel, la sélection du personnel, le rendement à la tâche, la gestion des conflits, les attitudes au travail et le bien-être au travail. Alors que l’intelligence émotionnelle promettait au départ de bouleverser le monde du travail, un grand nombre d’études montre que celle-ci ne fait pas le poids, particulièrement au plan de sa validité. Comparée à la valeur prédictive du quotient intellectuel (QI), l’intelligence émotionnelle montre un faible pouvoir prédicteur, en dépit des instruments judicieux que ses promoteurs ont mis au point pour mesurer ses effets.

Étude comparative entre la Batterie Générale des Tests d'Aptitudes et la graphoanalyse

Depuis le début des années '30, nous remarquons un intérêt marqué de la part de certains chercheurs pour explorer la fiabilité et la validité de l'analyse de l'écriture; toutefois, nous constatons que la méthode de la graphologie demeure jusqu'à présent la plus étudiée et la plus répandue. Comme principal champs d'intérêt, ces études n'ont jusqu'alors tenté que de démontrer si l'analyse de l'écriture se voyait un instrument de mesure valide 1). pour la sélection du personnel, 2). comme prédicteur de succès pour un poste donné, ou encore, 3). comme substitut aux tests de personnalité. Cependant, à notre connaissance, aucune recherche scientifique n'a présenté d'étude comparative entre l'analyse de l'écriture (graphoanalyse) et les tests dits d'aptitudes, couramment utilisés par les conseillers et conseillères d'orientation. Le présent essai soulève donc essentiellement cette interrogation: la graphoanalyse peut-elle servir d'instrument de mesure valide comme test d'aptitudes pour les conseillers et conseillères d'orientation? De façon plus précise, nous comparerons la graphoanalyse à la Batterie Générale des Tests d'Aptitudes (B.G.T.A.); test bien connu des conseillers et conseillères d'orientation.

Adaptive and maladaptive coping strategies predict posttrauma outcomes in ambulance personnel

Attending potentially dangerous and traumatic incidents is inherent in the role of emergency workers, yet there is a paucity of literature aimed at examining variables that impact on the outcomes of such exposure. Coping has been implicated in adjusting to trauma in other contexts, and this study explored the effectiveness of coping strategies in relation to positive and negative posttrauma outcomes in the emergency services environment. One hundred twenty-five paramedics completed a survey battery including the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory (PTGI; Tedeschi & Calhoun, 1996), the Impact of Events Scale–Revised (IES-R; Weiss & Marmar, 1997), and the Revised-COPE (Zuckerman & Gagne, 2003). Results from the regression analysis demonstrated that specific coping strategies were differentially associated with positive and negative posttrauma outcomes. The research contributes to a more comprehensive understanding regarding the effectiveness of coping strategies employed by paramedics in managing trauma, with implications for their psychological well-being as well as the training and support services available.

Attitudes to living and working in pandemic conditions among emergency prehospital medical care personnel

Introduction: Little is known about the risk perceptions and attitudes of healthcare personnel, especially of emergency prehospital medical care personnel, regarding the possibility of an outbreak or epidemic event. Problem: This study was designed to investigate pre-event knowledge and attitudes of a national sample of the emergency prehospital medical care providers in relation to a potential human influenza pandemic, and to determine predictors of these attitudes. Methods: Surveys were distributed to a random, cross-sectional sample of 20% of the Australian emergency prehospital medical care workforce (n = 2,929), stratified by the nine services operating in Australia, as well as by gender and location. The surveys included: (1) demographic information; (2) knowledge of influenza; and (3) attitudes and perceptions related to working during influenza pandemic conditions. Multiple logistic regression models were constructed to identify predictors of pandemic-related risk perceptions. Results: Among the 725 Australian emergency prehospital medical care personnel who responded, 89% were very anxious about working during pandemic conditions, and 85% perceived a high personal risk associated with working in such conditions. In general, respondents demonstrated poor knowledge in relation to avian influenza, influenza generally, and infection transmission methods. Less than 5% of respondents perceived that they had adequate education/training about avian influenza. Logistic regression analyses indicate that, in managing the attitudes and risk perceptions of emergency prehospital medical care staff, particular attention should be directed toward the paid, male workforce (as opposed to volunteers), and on personnel whose relationship partners do not work in the health industry. Conclusions: These results highlight the potentially crucial role of education and training in pandemic preparedness. Organizations that provide emergency prehospital medical care must address this apparent lack of knowledge regarding infection transmission, and procedures for protection and decontamination. Careful management of the perceptions of emergency prehospital medical care personnel during a pandemic is likely to be critical in achieving an effective response to a widespread outbreak of infectious disease.

The health and cost implications of high body mass index in Australian Defence Force personnel.

BACKGROUND: Frequent illness and injury among workers with high body mass index (BMI) can raise the costs of employee healthcare and reduce workforce maintenance and productivity. These issues are particularly important in vocational settings such as the military, which require good physical health, regular attendance and teamwork to operate efficiently. The purpose of this study was to compare the incidence of injury and illness, absenteeism, productivity, healthcare usage and administrative outcomes among Australian Defence Force personnel with varying BMI. METHODS: Personnel were grouped into cohorts according to the following ranges for (BMI): normal (18.5-24.9 kg/m²; n = 197), overweight (25-29.9 kg/m²; n = 154) and obese (≥30 kg/m²) with restricted body fat (≤28 % for females, ≤24 % for males) (n = 148) and with no restriction on body fat (n = 180). Medical records for each individual were audited retrospectively to record the incidence of injury and illness, absenteeism, productivity, healthcare usage (i.e., consultation with medical specialists, hospital stays, medical investigations, prescriptions) and administrative outcomes (e.g., discharge from service) over one year. These data were then grouped and compared between the cohorts. RESULTS: The prevalence of injury and illness, cost of medical specialist consultations and cost of medical scans were all higher (p <0.05) in both obese cohorts compared with the normal cohort. The estimated productivity losses from restricted work days were also higher (p <0.05) in the obese cohort with no restriction on body fat compared with the normal cohort. Within the obese cohort, the prevalence of injury and illness, healthcare usage and productivity were not significantly greater in the obese cohort with no restriction on body fat compared with the cohort with restricted body fat. The number of restricted work days, the rate of re-classification of Medical Employment Classification and the rate of discharge from service were similar between all four cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: High BMI in the military increases healthcare usage, but does not disrupt workforce maintenance. The greater prevalence of injury and illness, greater healthcare usage and lower productivity in obese Australian Defence Force personnel is not related to higher levels of body fat.

Position, privacy and personnel : concerns for the (digital) future

Firms are moving away from decentralized regional offices. Last year the author spoke with a valuer working on the Sunshine Coast for a Brisbane firm. In years past this valuer would have left home in the morning to go to the office, as well as travelling during the day to client sites. Now they get up, have breakfast, change out of their pyjamas (if they have meetings!) and walk into their employer set-up home office to ‘punch-in’. Apart from travel for essential meetings at head office, or for the purpose of on-site inspections, they can attend work, engage with colleagues and clients and never leave home. While this practice may be a cost saving to the firm and a commuter-friendly way of working, it raises a range of issues to be managed.

"They did not believe me" : Adult survivors' perspectives of child sexual abuse by personnel in Christian Institutions

Executive Summary Child sexual abuse (CSA) in Christian Institutions continues to be of serious concern in public, criminal justice and institutional discourse. This study was conducted in conjunction with Project Kidsafe Foundation and sought the perspectives of Australian survivors of CSA by Personnel in Christian Institutions (PICIs). In total, 81 individual survivors responded to an online survey which asked them a range of questions about their current and childhood life circumstance; the nature, extent and location of abuse; grooming strategies utilised by perpetrators; their experiences of disclosure; and outcomes of official reporting to both criminal justice agencies and also official processes Christian institutions. Survey participants were given the option to further participate in a qualitative interview with the principal researcher. These interviews are not considered within this report. In summary, survey data examined here indicate that: • Instances of abuse included a range of offences from touching outside of clothing to serious penetrative offences. • The onset of abuse occurred at a young age: between 6 and 10 years for most female participants, and 11 and 13 years for male participants. • In the majority of cases the abuse ceased because of actions by survivors, not by adults within families or the Christian institution. • Participants waited significant time before disclosing their abuse, with many waiting 20 years or more. • Where survivors disclosed to family members or PICIs, they were often met with disbelief and unhelpful responses aimed at minimising the harm. • Where an official report was made, it was most often made to police. In these cases 53% resulted in an official investigations. • The primary reasons for reporting were to protect others from the perpetrator and make the Christian institution accountable to an external agency. • Where reports to Christian institutions were made, most survivors were dissatisfied with outcomes, and a smaller majority was extremely dissatisfied. This report reflects the long-held understanding that responding to CSA is a complex and difficult task. If effective and meaningful responses are not made, however, trauma to the survivor is most often compounded and recovery delayed. This report demonstrates the need for further independent analysis and oversight of responses made to CSA by both criminal justice, religious and social institutions. Meaningful change will only be accessible, however, if family, community and institutional environments are safe places for survivors to disclose their experiences of abuse and begin to seek ways of healing. There is much to be learnt from survivors that have already made this journey.

Identity, forgiveness and power in the management of child sexual abuse by personnel in Christian Institutions

The ongoing crises of child sexual abuse by Christian institutions leaders across the Anglophone world continue to attract public attention and public inquiries. The pervasiveness of this issue lends credence to the argument that the prevailing ethos functioning within some Christian Institutions is one which exercises influence to repeatedly mismanage allegations of child sexual abuse by Church leaders. This work draws on semistructured interviews conducted with 15 Personnel in Christian Institutions (PICIs) in Australia who were identified as being pro-active in their approach to addressing child sexual abuse by PICIs. From these data, themes of power and forgiveness are explored through a Foucaultian conceptualising of pastoral power and ‘truth’ construction. Forgiveness is viewed as a discourse which can have the power effect of either silencing or empowering victim/survivors. The study concludes that individual PICIs’ understandings of the role ofpower in their praxis influences outcomes from the deployment of forgiveness.