Bystander Narratives: The Fiction of J.M. Coetzee and the Holocaust

J.M. Coetzee’s novels are suffused with a pervasive, though often oblique, Holocaust awareness. Direct references to the event and to the historical era to which it belongs, subtle stylistic and thematic echoes of Holocaust writing, and the recurrent mobilization of Holocaust imagery in Coetzee’s novels all contribute to suggest the significance of the event to the author’s work and thought. Providing Coetzee with a lens through which to view the contemporary situation, both local and global, the Holocaust offers Coetzee a means by which difficult and complex questions of ethics and historiographical truth may be approached. Above all, the Holocaust and its representation contribute to Coetzee’s exploration of the dilemmas of translating the traumatic lived experience of atrocity – including, but not limited to, life in apartheid South Africa – into narrative form. Taken as a whole, Coetzee’s oeuvre initially anticipates and later responds to, in characteristically oblique fashion, the narrative project(s) facing post-apartheid South Africa as the newly-democratic nation sought to make sense of its past through a variety of means, the most important of which was the country’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission. Implicitly challenging the TRC’s findings as well as its narrative assumptions, the Coetzean oeuvre accordingly invites being read as offering a continuous and evolving counter-narrative to the TRC and its construction of a narrative of the apartheid past for the post-apartheid nation. In utilizing the Holocaust, its representations, and the reception thereof to frame his response to apartheid, Coetzee implicates both in a critique of the Western model of modernity, suggesting, in the process, the importance of reconfiguring modernity in a more ethical shape.

‘Wooden Man’? : Masculinities in the Work of J. M. Coetzee (Boyhood, Youth and Summertime)

In seeking to advance the possibility of justice, gender and postcolonial studies have argued for the importance of the study of masculinities, through the acknowledgment that a richer understanding of such gendered formations may provide the basis for recognition of the Other and that, left uncriticised, such formations may be continuously delineated by the reproduction of systems of domination. The current study finds as its object the representations of masculinities in J. M. Coetzee’s Boyhood (1997), Youth (2002) and Summertime (2009). As works of transition in terms of Coetzee’s oeuvre - post-apartheid and post-Disgrace - the trilogy provides an account of the development of a man through several stages of life. While portraying the tensions of different geographical and cultural locations, such as apartheid South Africa and the London of the Sixties, the trilogy articulates the various norms that impact in the formation of gender, particularly of masculinities, through a complex system of power relations. The adherence to such norms is never linear, as the trilogy provides imaginative accounts of the contradictions that assist in the formulation of gender, depicting both the allure and the terror that constitute hegemonic masculinity. Located in the intersection of gender and postcolonial studies, the present study is based on the works by Raewyn Connell on masculinities. Animated by such a critical framework, the main research question of the present study is whether the trilogy advances a notion of masculinity that differs from the traditional rigid model, that is, whether there is resistance to hegemonic masculinity and what the spaces inhabited by the subaltern are. It is suggested that the trilogy presents the reader with instances of resistance to normative formulations of masculinity, by contrasting domination with the possibility of justice, and advancing an understanding of the often fatal consequences of gender norms to one’s sense of being in the world.

A Higher Life : A Postcolonialist Analysis of Coetzee's Disgrace

J M Coetzee’s Disgrace deals with race and power in contemporary, post-colonial South Africa. This prize-winning novel is written after the country's first all-race elections, in 1994. It has therefore most often been analyzed as a representative for the writing of the new South Africa, where the social problems relating binary oppositions such as black – white, native – immigrant, powerless – powerful, are stressed. More specifically the shift of power within the above mentioned pairs is in focus. This is also the case for this essay, but instead of analyzing the realistic elements in the book it will examine the imaginary complexity of the opera Byron in Italy, which is created by the protagonist, David Lurie. This essay aims to widen the concept of “native” regarding post-colonial theory by looking at the peculiarity of Lurie’s situation; him being a representative of the white population in South Africa. By using post-colonial theory this essay aims at showing that Lurie can be seen as a white native, and that his process of writing the opera can be seen as symbolizing the evolutionary phases a colonized nation goes through in order to develop a national culture, as described by Franz Fanon.

The Secret Aria on Shame : An Analysis of Narrative Structure and Theme in Coetzee's "Diary of a Bad Year"

Coetzee’s last novel Diary of a Bad Year (2007) has an intriguing triple-voiced narrative structure and deals with the grey area of shame. The narrative is divided between a writer, his written contribution to a book called “Strong Opinions”, and his secretary’s thoughts about both the opinions in the manuscript and her employer’s circumstances. This essay explores the relation between form and theme in Diary of a Bad Year; to see in what way these two fundamental elements of the novel intervene and support each other. By doing so the narrative structure is read through Freud’s structural model of personality, whereby each narrator’s voice is related to the notions of the super-ego, the ego and the id. In other words, this essay argues that the specific threefold narrative structure in Diary of a Bad Year, by reflecting the interrelated parts of human identity, helps in creating and developing the theme of shame, which only exists connected to the human psyche. This connection in turn gives special meaning to the entire narratology of the novel.

Coetzee's haunting of Australian literature

In June 2006, the Good Weekend, the magazine supplementing Saturday’s the Age in Melbourne, ran the following cover story by Catharine Lumby: “Worried TV will turn your child into a zombie?” The cover featured a science-fiction image of a boy’s upturned face. Televisions were reflected in his pupils, giving them the effect of being square instead of round. The message, though, was ultimately non-alarmist with the subheading already instructing “Relax. It’s all good”. Stories like this appear regularly in the press, and while I am not interested in debating whether TV is good or bad for children, I am interested in the popular image of children—or, for that matter, adults—as being akin to zombies when they watch TV, if only because something similar happens when we read books. Although it is not as fashionable to talk about it, we become emptied of ourselves, possessed by something other.

Per un'etica della letteratura: la cornice il doppio legame nell'opera di J. M. Coetzee

The elusive fiction of J. M. Coetzee is not a work in which you can read fixed ethical stances. I suggest testing the potentialities of a logic based on frames and double binds in Coetzee's novels. A double bind is a dilemma in communication which consists on tho conflicting messages, with the result that you can’t successfully respond to neither. Jacques Derrida highlighted the strategic value of a way of thinking based on the double bind (but on frames as well), which enables to escape binary thinking and so it opens an ethical space, where you can make a choice out of a set of fixed rules and take responsibility for it. In Coetzee’s fiction the author himself can be considered in a double bind, seeing that he is a white South African writer who feels that his “task” can’t be as simply as choosing to represent faithfully the violence and the racism of the apartheid or of choosing to give a voice to the oppressed. Good intentions alone do not ensure protection against entering unwittingly into complicity with the dominant discourse, and this is why is important to make the frame in which one is always situated clearly visible and explicit. The logic of the double bind becomes the way in which moral problem are staged in Coetzee’s fiction as well: the opportunity to give a voice to the oppressed through the same language which co-opted to serve the cause of oppression, a relation with the otherness never completed, or the representability of evil in literature, of the secret and of the paradoxical implications of confession and forgiveness.

Ecriture romanesque post-apartheid chez J.M. Coetzee et Nadine Gordimer

Which changes has the official dismantling of apartheid brought in the novel writing of the two South African Nobel Prize winners? Focussing on Gordimer’s Get a life and Coetzee’s Elizabeth Costello, this study tries to reflect that main question. Theoretically, some elements of the cultural studies such as the popular, the liberalism and the fiction as a political work, help me develop my work. Narratology and structuralism help me for the literary study of the narratives, which constitute the core of my reflexion. From my study it appears that the post-apartheid novel as written by Coetzee and Gordimer has the same ideological orientation as their writing during the apartheid era. They write from the dominant perspective and dominant group. This situation challenges as Gordimer’s as Coetzee’s popularity on the ground of South African literature.

John Maxwell Coetzee. Costas extrañas; ensayos, 1986-1999. Trad. de Pedro Tena. Buenos Aires, Debate, 2005

Fil: Colombi, Pablo Darío.

Verdades poéticas e imaginadas em vera, DE J.M. Coetzee

A obra Verao, do escritor sul-africano J.M. Coetzee, lançada em 2010, é a terceira da trilogia Cenas da vida na província, composta também por Infância e Juventude. Em Verao os relatos se concentram nos anos da volta de Coetzee para a Africa do Sul, de 1971 até 1977 e se desenvolvem em metanarrativas que abrangem temas locais e globais que vao desde a vida pessoal do escritor até a violência do Apartheid na Africa do Sul. Neste híbrido entre fatos e ficçao, os limites entre o público e o privado e entre vida e obra surgem como questoes importantes a serem pensadas no que se refere nao só a construçao da obra, mas também como caminhos a serem percorridos pela crítica biográfica atual. Esta obra estaria inscrita como autobigrafia ou autoficçao? Haveria fronteiras rígidas entre estes gêneros? E a partir destes questionamentos que se pretende abordar a obra de Coetzee, levando-se em conta o estilo único do escritor, numa narrativa que é uma mostra do trabalho de escrita em processo e que propoe a discussao de temas que vao do particular ao universal.

Verdades poéticas e imaginadas em vera, DE J.M. Coetzee

A obra Verao, do escritor sul-africano J.M. Coetzee, lançada em 2010, é a terceira da trilogia Cenas da vida na província, composta também por Infância e Juventude. Em Verao os relatos se concentram nos anos da volta de Coetzee para a Africa do Sul, de 1971 até 1977 e se desenvolvem em metanarrativas que abrangem temas locais e globais que vao desde a vida pessoal do escritor até a violência do Apartheid na Africa do Sul. Neste híbrido entre fatos e ficçao, os limites entre o público e o privado e entre vida e obra surgem como questoes importantes a serem pensadas no que se refere nao só a construçao da obra, mas também como caminhos a serem percorridos pela crítica biográfica atual. Esta obra estaria inscrita como autobigrafia ou autoficçao? Haveria fronteiras rígidas entre estes gêneros? E a partir destes questionamentos que se pretende abordar a obra de Coetzee, levando-se em conta o estilo único do escritor, numa narrativa que é uma mostra do trabalho de escrita em processo e que propoe a discussao de temas que vao do particular ao universal.

Verdades poéticas e imaginadas em vera, DE J.M. Coetzee

A obra Verao, do escritor sul-africano J.M. Coetzee, lançada em 2010, é a terceira da trilogia Cenas da vida na província, composta também por Infância e Juventude. Em Verao os relatos se concentram nos anos da volta de Coetzee para a Africa do Sul, de 1971 até 1977 e se desenvolvem em metanarrativas que abrangem temas locais e globais que vao desde a vida pessoal do escritor até a violência do Apartheid na Africa do Sul. Neste híbrido entre fatos e ficçao, os limites entre o público e o privado e entre vida e obra surgem como questoes importantes a serem pensadas no que se refere nao só a construçao da obra, mas também como caminhos a serem percorridos pela crítica biográfica atual. Esta obra estaria inscrita como autobigrafia ou autoficçao? Haveria fronteiras rígidas entre estes gêneros? E a partir destes questionamentos que se pretende abordar a obra de Coetzee, levando-se em conta o estilo único do escritor, numa narrativa que é uma mostra do trabalho de escrita em processo e que propoe a discussao de temas que vao do particular ao universal.

De-authoring or Authoring?: A plunge into the question of authorship and language in J.M. Coetzee's Foe

J. M. Coetzee's Foe is not only a post-colonial novel, but it is also a re-writing of a classic, and its main themes are language, authorship, power and identity. Moreover, Foe is narrated by a woman, while written by a male, Nobel prize winning South African author. The aim of my tesina is to focus on the question of authorship and the role of language in Foe. Without any claim to be exhaustive, in the first section I will examine some selected extracts of Coetzee's book, in order to provide an analysis of the novel. These quotations will mainly be its metalinguistic parts and will be analysed in the “theory” sections of my work, relying on literary theory and on previous works on the novel. Among others, I will cover themes such as the relationship between speech and writing, the connection between writing, history, and memory, the role of silence and alternative ways of communicating and the relationship between literary authority and truth. These arguments will be the foundation for my second section, in which I will attempt to shed a light on the importance of the novel from a linguistic point of view, but always keeping an eye on the implication that this has on authorship. While it is true that it is less politically-permeated than Coetzee's previous works, Foe is above all a “journey of discovery” in the world of language and authorship. In fact, it becomes a warning for any person immersed in the ocean of language since, while everyone naturally tends to trust speech and writing as the only medium through which one can get closer to the truth, authority never is a synonym of reliability, and language is a system of communication behind which structures of power, misconceptions, lies, and treacherous tides easily hide.

¿Esperando a los bárbaros? : la invención del (nos) otro (s) en la literatura de J. M. Coetzee

J. M. Coetzee es uno de los más importantes escritores sudafricanos. Ximena Picallo Visconti contextualiza al autor y sus obras en el marco de un cambio político cuyos basamentos fueron el postapartheid sudafricano y la desarticulación de un discurso dominante sedimentado durante mucho tiempo. En Sudáfrica, los procesos de identificación están plagados de intersticios y negociaciones (muchas veces dispares) en la búsqueda y construcción de significados (Picallo Visconti, 2007). La mirada de Coetzee nos impulsa como lectores a un proceso de deconstrucción y de cuestionamiento constante, superando las construcciones ancladas del eurocentrismo ejercidas por la práctica del colonialismo y por el sistema segregacionista del apartheid. Por ello, este trabajo indagará sobre la mirada del autor, intentando acercar algunas lógicas de su obra respecto de la invención de un "Otro". Se trabajará sobre la novela Esperando a los bárbaros, en la que otro y espacio se tensionan para poner al lector en una disyuntiva superadora, en la cual quizás nosotros (el imperio) seamos los que nos encontramos fuera del muro.

¿Esperando a los bárbaros? : la invención del (nos) otro (s) en la literatura de J. M. Coetzee

J. M. Coetzee es uno de los más importantes escritores sudafricanos. Ximena Picallo Visconti contextualiza al autor y sus obras en el marco de un cambio político cuyos basamentos fueron el postapartheid sudafricano y la desarticulación de un discurso dominante sedimentado durante mucho tiempo. En Sudáfrica, los procesos de identificación están plagados de intersticios y negociaciones (muchas veces dispares) en la búsqueda y construcción de significados (Picallo Visconti, 2007). La mirada de Coetzee nos impulsa como lectores a un proceso de deconstrucción y de cuestionamiento constante, superando las construcciones ancladas del eurocentrismo ejercidas por la práctica del colonialismo y por el sistema segregacionista del apartheid. Por ello, este trabajo indagará sobre la mirada del autor, intentando acercar algunas lógicas de su obra respecto de la invención de un "Otro". Se trabajará sobre la novela Esperando a los bárbaros, en la que otro y espacio se tensionan para poner al lector en una disyuntiva superadora, en la cual quizás nosotros (el imperio) seamos los que nos encontramos fuera del muro.