Modeling and identification of freeplay nonlinearity

A nonlinear analysis is performed for the purpose of identification of the pitch freeplay nonlinearity and its effect on the type of bifurcation of a two degree-of-freedom aeroelastic system. The databases for the identification are generated from experimental investigations of a pitch-plunge rigid airfoil supported by a nonlinear torsional spring. Experimental data and linear analysis are performed to validate the parameters of the linearized equations. Based on the periodic responses of the experimental data which included the flutter frequency and its third harmonics, the freeplay nonlinearity is approximated by a polynomial expansion up to the third order. This representation allows us to use the normal form of the Hopf bifurcation to characterize the type of instability. Based on numerical integrations, the coefficients of the polynomial expansion representing the freeplay nonlinearity are identified. Published by Elsevier Ltd.

Simulazione numerica di fenomeni aeroelastici con applicazione alle strutture civili

Il presente lavoro tratta lo studio dei fenomeni aeroelastici di interazione fra fluido e struttura, con il fine di provare a simularli mediante l’ausilio di un codice agli elementi finiti. Nel primo capitolo sono fornite alcune nozioni di fluidodinamica, in modo da rendere chiari i passaggi teorici fondamentali che portano alle equazioni di Navier-Stokes governanti il moto dei fluidi viscosi. Inoltre è illustrato il fenomeno della formazione di vortici a valle dei corpi tozzi dovuto alla separazione dello strato limite laminare, con descrizione anche di alcuni risultati ottenuti dalle simulazioni numeriche. Nel secondo capitolo vengono presi in rassegna i principali fenomeni di interazione fra fluido e struttura, cercando di metterne in luce le fondamenta della trattazione analitica e le ipotesi sotto le quali tale trattazione è valida. Chiaramente si tratta solo di una panoramica che non entra in merito degli sviluppi della ricerca più recente ma fornisce le basi per affrontare i vari problemi di instabilità strutturale dovuti a un particolare fenomeno di interazione con il vento. Il terzo capitolo contiene una trattazione più approfondita del fenomeno di instabilità per flutter. Tra tutti i fenomeni di instabilità aeroelastica delle strutture il flutter risulta il più temibile, soprattutto per i ponti di grande luce. Per questo si è ritenuto opportuno dedicargli un capitolo, in modo da illustrare i vari procedimenti con cui si riesce a determinare analiticamente la velocità critica di flutter di un impalcato da ponte, a partire dalle funzioni sperimentali denominate derivate di flutter. Al termine del capitolo è illustrato il procedimento con cui si ricavano sperimentalmente le derivate di flutter di un impalcato da ponte. Nel quarto capitolo è presentato l’esempio di studio dell’impalcato del ponte Tsing Ma ad Hong Kong. Sono riportati i risultati analitici dei calcoli della velocità di flutter e di divergenza torsionale dell’impalcato e i risultati delle simulazioni numeriche effettuate per stimare i coefficienti aerodinamici statici e il comportamento dinamico della struttura soggetta all’azione del vento. Considerazioni e commenti sui risultati ottenuti e sui metodi di modellazione numerica adottati completano l’elaborato.

Experimental analysis of a separation control device based on plasma technology

In this thesis effects of plasma actuators based on Dielectric Barrier Discharge (DBD) technology over a NACA 0015 bidimensional airfoil have been analyzed in an experimental way, at low Reynolds number. Work developed on thesis has been carried on in partnership with the Department of Electrical Engineering of Università di Bologna, inside Wind Tunnel of the Applied Aerodynamic Laboratory of Aerospace Engineering faculty. In order to verify the effectiveness of these active control devices, the analysis has shown how actuators succeed in prevent boundary layer separation only in certain conditions af angle of attack and Reynolds numbers. Moreover, in this thesis actuators’ chordwise position effect has been also analyzed, together with the influence of steady and unsteady operations.

Separation control by means of oriented DBD plasma actuators: an experimental analysis in a wind tunnel

This thesis provides an experimental analysis of the effectiveness of oriented DBD plasma actuators over a NACA 0015 airfoil at low Reynolds numbers. Tests were performed in partnership with the Department of Electrical Engineering of Bologna University, in the wind tunnel of the Applied Aerodynamics Laboratory of Aerospace Engineering faculty. Lift coefficient measurements were carried out in order to verify how an oriented plasma jet succeeds in prevent boundary layer separation. Both actuators’ chord wise position and plasma jet orientation angle have been investigated to examine which configurations lead to the best results. A particular attention has been paid also to the analysis of results in steady and unsteady plasma actuation. Questa tesi offre un’analisi sperimentale sull’efficacia di attuatori al plasma orientabili, basati su una tecnologia DBD, installati su un profilo alare NACA 0015, a bassi numeri di Reynolds. Le prove sono state condotte in collaborazione con il Dipartimento di Ingegneria Elettrica dell’Università di Bologna, nella galleria del vento del Laboratorio di Aerodinamica Applicata della Facoltà di Ingegneria Aerospaziale di Forlì. Per verificare come un getto orientabile di plasma riesca a prevenire la separazione dello strato limite, sono state eseguite misure sul coefficiente di portanza. Sono state indagate sia la posizione degli attuatori lungo la corda che l’angolo con cui è orientato il getto di plasma, per vedere quali configurazioni conducono ai migliori risultati. Una particolare attenzione è stata riservata all’analisi dei risultati ottenuti con plasma continuo e pulsato.

Structural response and dynamics of fluid-structure-control interaction in wind turbine blades

Reducing the uncertainties related to blade dynamics by the improvement of the quality of numerical simulations of the fluid structure interaction process is a key for a breakthrough in wind-turbine technology. A fundamental step in that direction is the implementation of aeroelastic models capable of capturing the complex features of innovative prototype blades, so they can be tested at realistic full-scale conditions with a reasonable computational cost. We make use of a code based on a combination of two advanced numerical models implemented in a parallel HPC supercomputer platform: First, a model of the structural response of heterogeneous composite blades, based on a variation of the dimensional reduction technique proposed by Hodges and Yu. This technique has the capacity of reducing the geometrical complexity of the blade section into a stiffness matrix for an equivalent beam. The reduced 1-D strain energy is equivalent to the actual 3-D strain energy in an asymptotic sense, allowing accurate modeling of the blade structure as a 1-D finite-element problem. This substantially reduces the computational effort required to model the structural dynamics at each time step. Second, a novel aerodynamic model based on an advanced implementation of the BEM(Blade ElementMomentum) Theory; where all velocities and forces are re-projected through orthogonal matrices into the instantaneous deformed configuration to fully include the effects of large displacements and rotation of the airfoil sections into the computation of aerodynamic forces. This allows the aerodynamic model to take into account the effects of the complex flexo-torsional deformation that can be captured by the more sophisticated structural model mentioned above. In this thesis we have successfully developed a powerful computational tool for the aeroelastic analysis of wind-turbine blades. Due to the particular features mentioned above in terms of a full representation of the combined modes of deformation of the blade as a complex structural part and their effects on the aerodynamic loads, it constitutes a substantial advancement ahead the state-of-the-art aeroelastic models currently available, like the FAST-Aerodyn suite. In this thesis, we also include the results of several experiments on the NREL-5MW blade, which is widely accepted today as a benchmark blade, together with some modifications intended to explore the capacities of the new code in terms of capturing features on blade-dynamic behavior, which are normally overlooked by the existing aeroelastic models.

Measurements of ocean microstructure, physical oceanography and current in the Weddell Sea, Antarctica, during the RRS Ernest Shackleton cruises ES033 and ES060

Turbulence profile measurements made on the upper continental slope and shelf of the southeastern Weddell Sea reveal striking contrasts in dissipation and mixing rates between the two sites. The mean profiles of dissipation rates from the upper slope are 1-2 orders of magnitude greater than the profiles collected over the shelf in the entire water column. The difference increases toward the bottom where the dissipation rate of turbulent kinetic energy and the vertical eddy diffusivity on the slope exceed 10?7 W kg?1 and 10?2 m2 s?1, respectively. Elevated levels of turbulence on the slope are concentrated within a 100 m thick bottom layer, which is absent on the shelf. The upper slope is characterized by near-critical slopes and is in close proximity to the critical latitude for semidiurnal internal tides. Our observations suggest that the upper continental slope of the southern Weddell Sea is a generation site of semidiurnal internal tide, which is trapped along the slope along the critical latitude, and dissipates its energy in a inline image m thick layer near the bottom and within inline image km across the slope.

Reduced order models for industrial thermo-fluid problems

A new method is presented to generate reduced order models (ROMs) in Fluid Dynamics problems of industrial interest. The method is based on the expansion of the flow variables in a Proper Orthogonal Decomposition (POD) basis, calculated from a limited number of snapshots, which are obtained via Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Then, the POD-mode amplitudes are calculated as minimizers of a properly defined overall residual of the equations and boundary conditions. The method includes various ingredients that are new in this field. The residual can be calculated using only a limited number of points in the flow field, which can be scattered either all over the whole computational domain or over a smaller projection window. The resulting ROM is both computationally efficient(reconstructed flow fields require, in cases that do not present shock waves, less than 1 % of the time needed to compute a full CFD solution) and flexible(the projection window can avoid regions of large localized CFD errors).Also, for problems related with aerodynamics, POD modes are obtained from a set of snapshots calculated by a CFD method based on the compressible Navier Stokes equations and a turbulence model (which further more includes some unphysical stabilizing terms that are included for purely numerical reasons), but projection onto the POD manifold is made using the inviscid Euler equations, which makes the method independent of the CFD scheme. In addition, shock waves are treated specifically in the POD description, to avoid the need of using a too large number of snapshots. Various definitions of the residual are also discussed, along with the number and distribution of snapshots, the number of retained modes, and the effect of CFD errors. The method is checked and discussed on several test problems that describe (i) heat transfer in the recirculation region downstream of a backwards facing step, (ii) the flow past a two-dimensional airfoil in both the subsonic and transonic regimes, and (iii) the flow past a three-dimensional horizontal tail plane. The method is both efficient and numerically robust in the sense that the computational effort is quite small compared to CFD and results are both reasonably accurate and largely insensitive to the definition of the residual, to CFD errors, and to the CFD method itself, which may contain artificial stabilizing terms. Thus, the method is amenable for practical engineering applications. Resumen Se presenta un nuevo método para generar modelos de orden reducido (ROMs) aplicado a problemas fluidodinámicos de interés industrial. El nuevo método se basa en la expansión de las variables fluidas en una base POD, calculada a partir de un cierto número de snapshots, los cuales se han obtenido gracias a simulaciones numéricas (CFD). A continuación, las amplitudes de los modos POD se calculan minimizando un residual global adecuadamente definido que combina las ecuaciones y las condiciones de contorno. El método incluye varios ingredientes que son nuevos en este campo de estudio. El residual puede calcularse utilizando únicamente un número limitado de puntos del campo fluido. Estos puntos puede encontrarse dispersos a lo largo del dominio computacional completo o sobre una ventana de proyección. El modelo ROM obtenido es tanto computacionalmente eficiente (en aquellos casos que no presentan ondas de choque reconstruir los campos fluidos requiere menos del 1% del tiempo necesario para calcular una solución CFD) como flexible (la ventana de proyección puede escogerse de forma que evite contener regiones con errores en la solución CFD localizados y grandes). Además, en problemas aerodinámicos, los modos POD se obtienen de un conjunto de snapshots calculados utilizando un código CFD basado en la versión compresible de las ecuaciones de Navier Stokes y un modelo de turbulencia (el cual puede incluir algunos términos estabilizadores sin sentido físico que se añaden por razones puramente numéricas), aunque la proyección en la variedad POD se hace utilizando las ecuaciones de Euler, lo que hace al método independiente del esquema utilizado en el código CFD. Además, las ondas de choque se tratan específicamente en la descripción POD para evitar la necesidad de utilizar un número demasiado grande de snapshots. Varias definiciones del residual se discuten, así como el número y distribución de los snapshots,el número de modos retenidos y el efecto de los errores debidos al CFD. El método se comprueba y discute para varios problemas de evaluación que describen (i) la transferencia de calor en la región de recirculación aguas abajo de un escalón, (ii) el flujo alrededor de un perfil bidimensional en regímenes subsónico y transónico y (iii) el flujo alrededor de un estabilizador horizontal tridimensional. El método es tanto eficiente como numéricamente robusto en el sentido de que el esfuerzo computacional es muy pequeño comparado con el requerido por el CFD y los resultados son razonablemente precisos y muy insensibles a la definición del residual, los errores debidos al CFD y al método CFD en sí mismo, el cual puede contener términos estabilizadores artificiales. Por lo tanto, el método puede utilizarse en aplicaciones prácticas de ingeniería.

Aerodynamic study of airfoils geometric imperfections at low Reynolds number

The interest of this study is based on the observation that some manufacturing processes of various vehicles wings, such as unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV), or blades, such as wind turbine blades, or other devices that use aerodynamic profiles, produce imperfections in the leading edge or open trailing edge with bigger thickness than original airfoil, because, for example, they are manufactured in two parts, top surface and bottom surface and subsequently joined. In this last step might appear a sliding between the top surface and the bottom surface having a small step on the leading edge or a small thickness gain can occur on the trailing edge. Normally these imperfections are corrected through a refill and/or sanding processes using many hours of manual labor. Therefore the initial objective of this research is to determine the level of influence in the aerodynamic characteristics at low Reynolds numbers (Lissaman, 1981, Carmichael, 1981, Nagamatsu and Cuche, 1981, Schmitz, 1957, Cebeci, 1989, Mueller and Batill, 1982) of these imperfections in the manufacture, and determine whether there may be a value for which it would not be necessary to correct them

Análisis de la influencia del borde de salida abierto en perfiles aerodinámicos a bajos números de Reynolds

El objetivo del presente trabajo es analizar la influencia que tiene sobre el comportamiento aerodinámico del perfil el hecho de que este presente un borde de salida más grueso que el perfil original del que se partía. Este estudio se ha centrado fundamentalmente en la influencia sobre su sustentación aerodinámica, resistencia aerodinámica y, especialmente, sobre la eficiencia aerodinámica del perfil, es decir sobre la relación entre la sustentación y la resistencia aerodinámica. También se ha analizado su influencia en otros aspectos aerodinámicos de los perfiles, como la entrada en pérdida, el ángulo de ataque de sustentación máxima, el ángulo de ataque de eficiencia máxima, el coeficiente de momento aerodinámico y la posición del centro aerodinámico. Estas imperfecciones en el borde de salida pueden aparecer en algunos procesos de fabricación de determinados elementos aerodinámicos, como alas de aviones no tripulados o palas de aeroturbina. Este fenómeno no ha sido analizado en profundidad en la literatura científica, aunque si que se ha analizado por varios autores la influencia sobre el perfil con el borde de salida truncado, o perfiles con la parte final regruesada, utilizados en otras aplicaciones. Para la realización de este estudio se han analizado perfiles de distinto tipo, laminares y no laminares, perfiles simétricos y con curvatura, así como perfiles con distinto espesor, a fin de comparar el grado de influencia del fenómeno estudiado sobre cada tipo de perfil para comparar su grado de sensibilidad a dicha anomalía geométrica. El estudio se ha realizado experimentalmente utilizando una cámara de ensayos diseñada específicamente a tal efecto, así como una balanza electrónica para medir las fuerzas y los momentos sobre el perfil, y un escáner de presiones para medir la distribución de presiones en determinados casos. También se ha abordado el estudio del comportamiento de perfiles con borde de salida más grueso que el nominal pero redondeado en vez de romo, con el objeto de analizar la eficacia de redondear el borde de salida, que es uno de los métodos que se puede utilizar para mitigar este efecto. Por otro lado, como el comportamiento de los perfiles aerodinámicos tiene una fuerte dependencia del número de Reynolds, el estudio se ha centrado en el análisis del comportamiento a bajos números de Reynolds debido a su uso reciente en una amplia gama de aplicaciones, desde vehículos aéreos no tripulados (UAV) hasta palas de aeroturbinas de baja potencia, e incluso debido a su uso potencial en aeronaves diseñadas para volar en atmósferas de baja densidad como la que existe en Marte. El interés de este estudio está orientado al establecimiento de criterios para cuantificar la influencia que tiene el hecho de que el borde de salida sea más grueso que el nominal en la degradación de su eficiencia aerodinámica máxima, con el objeto de poder establecer los límites de aceptación o rechazo de estas piezas una vez fabricadas, según el tipo de perfil aerodinámico utilizado. Del resultado del análisis de los casos estudiados se puede concluir que según aumenta el espesor del borde de salida, dentro del intervalo de estudio, la sustentación aerodinámica aumenta, así como la sustentación máxima, pero aumenta en mayor proporción la resistencia aerodinámica, por lo que se produce una reducción de la eficiencia aerodinámica, en particular de su valor máximo. Por otro lado, el hecho de redondear el borde de salida del perfil ayuda ligeramente a reducir este efecto. ABSTRACT The aim of this thesis is to analyze the effects of airfoil trailing edges thickness when this is thicker than the airfoil nominal. Several factors may lead to an airfoil trailing edge being thicker than the nominal airfoil, and this may affect various aerodynamic parameters. This study has focus on its influence on the airfoil’s aerodynamic lift, drag and, particularly on the aerodynamic efficiency of the airfoil, that is, the relationship between the aerodynamic lift and drag. It has also been studied how this fact may alter some other aerodynamic aspects of airfoils, such as stall, angle of attack of maximum lift, angle of maximum efficiency, aerodynamic moment coefficient and aerodynamic center position. These imperfections in the trailing edge may appear in some manufacturing processes of certain aerodynamic elements, such as unmanned aircraft wings or wind turbine blades. This phenomenon has not been deeply analyzed in the literature, although several authors have discussed its influence on airfoil with truncated trailing edge, or airfoils with thickened end, used in other applications. Various types of airfoils have been analyzed, laminar and non-laminar, symmetric and curved airfoils, and airfoils with different thickness, in order to compare the degree of influence of the phenomenon studied on each airfoil type and thus, to estimate the degree of sensitivity to the anomaly geometry. The study was carried out experimentally using a test chamber designed specifically for this purpose, as well as an electronic balance to measure the forces and moments on the airfoil, and a pressure scanner to measure distribution of pressures in certain cases. It has also been investigated the behavior of airfoils with trailing edge thicker than the nominal, but rounded instead of blunt, in order to analyze the effectiveness of the trailing edge rounding, which is one of the methods that can be used to mitigate this phenomenon. Moreover, as the behavior of the airfoil is highly dependent on the Reynolds number, the study has been focused on the analysis of the behavior at low Reynolds numbers due to recent use of low Reynolds numbers airfoils in a wide range of applications, from unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) to low power wind turbine blades, or even due to their potential use in aircraft designed to fly in low density atmospheres as the one existing in Mars. The main purpose of this research is to establish a set of criteria for quantifying the influence that a thicker-than–nominal-trailing edge has in the degradation of maximum aerodynamic efficiency, aiming at establishing the acceptance limits for these pieces when they are manufactured, according to the type of airfoil used. Based on the results obtained from the analysis of the cases under study it can be concluded that increasing the thickness of the trailing edge, within the range of study, increases aerodynamic lift, as well as maximum lift, but the aerodynamic drag increases in a higher proportion, and consequently there is a reduction of aerodynamic efficiency, particularly, of its maximum value. On the other hand, rounding the trailing edge of the airfoil slightly helps to reduce this effect.

Análisis de la influencia de imperfecciones en el borde de ataque en perfiles aerodinámicos a bajos números de Reynolds

En esta tesis se ha analizado la influencia que tienen ciertas imperfecciones en el borde de ataque de un perfil aerodinámico sobre el comportamiento aerodinámico general del mismo, centrándose fundamentalmente en la influencia sobre el coeficiente de sustentación máxima, coeficiente de resistencia y sobre la eficiencia aerodinámica del perfil, es decir sobre la relación entre la sustentación y la resistencia aerodinámicas. También se ha analizado su influencia en otros aspectos, como la entrada en pérdida, ángulo de ataque de sustentación máxima, ángulo de ataque de eficiencia máxima, coeficiente de momento aerodinámico y posición del centro aerodinámico. Estos defectos de forma en el borde de ataque pueden aparecer en algunos procesos de fabricación de determinados elementos aerodinámicos, como pueden ser las alas de pequeños aviones no tripulados o las palas de aeroturbina. Los perfiles se ha estudiado a bajos números de Reynolds debido a su uso reciente en una amplia gama de aplicaciones, desde vehículos aéreos no tripulados (UAV) hasta palas de aeroturbina de baja potencia, e incluso debido a su potencial utilización en aeronaves diseñadas para volar en atmósferas de baja densidad. El objeto de estudio de esta tesis no ha sido analizado en profundidad en la literatura científica, aunque sí que se ha estudiado por varios autores el comportamiento de perfiles a bajos números de Reynolds, con ciertas protuberancias sobre su superficie o también con formación de hielo en el borde de ataque. Para la realización de este estudio se han analizado perfiles de distinto tipo, perfiles simétricos y con curvatura, perfiles laminares, y todos ellos con igual o distinto espesor, con el objeto de obtener y comparar la influencia del fenómeno estudiado sobre cada tipo de perfil y así analizar su grado de sensibilidad a estas imperfecciones en la geometría del borde de ataque. Este trabajo ha sido realizado experimentalmente utilizando una túnel aerodinámico diseñado específicamente a tal efecto, así como una balanza electrónica para medir las fuerzas y los momentos sobre el perfil, y un escáner de presiones para medir la distribución de presiones sobre la superficie de los perfiles en determinados casos de interés. La finalidad de este estudio está orientada al establecimiento de criterios para cuantificar la influencia en la aerodinámica del perfil que tiene el hecho de que el borde de ataque presente una discontinuidad geométrica, con el objeto de poder establecer los límites de aceptación o rechazo de estas piezas en el momento de ser fabricadas. Del análisis de los casos estudiados se puede concluir que según aumenta el tamaño de la imperfección del borde de ataque, la sustentación aerodinámica máxima en general disminuye, al igual que la eficiencia aerodinámica máxima, pues la resistencia aerodinámica aumenta. Sin embargo, en algunos casos, para pequeños defectos se produce un efecto contrario. La sustentación máxima aumenta apreciablemente sin apenas pérdida de eficiencia aerodinámica máxima. ABSTRACT The aim of this thesis is to analyze the effects of leading edge imperfections on the aerodynamic characteristics of airfoils at low Reynolds numbers. The leading edge imperfection here considered being a slight displacement of half airfoil with respect to the other. This study has focus on its influence on the airfoil’s aerodynamic lift, drag and on the aerodynamic efficiency of the airfoil, that is, the relationship between the aerodynamic lift and drag. It has also been studied how this fact may alter some other aerodynamic aspects of airfoils, such as stall, angle of attack of maximum lift, angle of maximum efficiency, aerodynamic moment coefficient and aerodynamic center position. These imperfections in the leading edge may appear in some manufacturing processes of certain aerodynamic elements, such as unmanned aircraft wings or wind turbine blades. The study has focused on the analysis of the behavior at low Reynolds numbers due to recent use of low Reynolds numbers airfoils in a wide range of applications, from unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV) to low power wind turbine blades, or even due to their potential use in aircraft designed to fly in low density atmospheres as the one existing in Mars. This phenomenon has not been deeply analyzed in the literature, although several authors have discussed on airfoils at low Reynolds number, with leading edge protuberances or airfoils with ice accretions. Various types of airfoils have been analyzed, laminar and non-laminar, symmetric and curved airfoils, and airfoils with different thickness, in order to compare the degree of influence of the phenomenon studied on each airfoil type and thus, to estimate the degree of sensitivity to the anomaly geometry. The study was carried out experimentally using a test chamber designed specifically for this purpose, as well as an electronic balance to measure the forces and moments on the airfoil, and a pressure scanner to measure distribution of pressures in certain cases. The main purpose of this research is to establish a criteria for quantifying the influence that a slight displacement of half aerofoil with respect to the other has in the degradation of aerodynamics characteristics, aiming at establishing the acceptance limits for these pieces when they are manufactured, according to the type of airfoil used. Based on the results obtained from the analysis of the cases under study it can be concluded that displacements, within the range of study, decreases maximum aerodynamic lift, but the aerodynamic drag increases, and consequently there is a reduction of aerodynamic efficiency. However, in some cases, for small defects opposite effect occurs. The maximum lift increases significantly with little loss of maximum aerodynamic efficiency.

Consideration of tip speed limitations in preliminary analysis of minimum COE wind turbines

A relation between Cost Of Energy, COE, maximum allowed tip speed, and rated wind speed, is obtained for wind turbines with a given goal rated power. The wind regime is characterised by the corresponding parameters of the probability density function of wind speed. The non-dimensional characteristics of the rotor: number of blades, the blade radial distributions of local solidity, twist angle, and airfoil type, play the role of parameters in the mentioned relation. The COE is estimated using a cost model commonly used by the designers. This cost model requires basic design data such as the rotor radius and the ratio between the hub height and the rotor radius. Certain design options, DO, related to the technology of the power plant, tower and blades are also required as inputs. The function obtained for the COE can be explored to �nd those values of rotor radius that give rise to minimum cost of energy for a given wind regime as the tip speed limitation changes. The analysis reveals that iso-COE lines evolve parallel to iso-radius lines for large values of limit tip speed but that this is not the case for small values of the tip speed limits. It is concluded that, as the tip speed limit decreases, the optimum decision for keeping minimum COE values can be: a) reducing the rotor radius for places with high weibull scale parameter or b) increasing the rotor radius for places with low weibull scale parameter

Experimental and numerical assessment of the aeroelastic stability of blade pair packages

The stabilizing effect of grouping rotor blades in pairs has been assessed both, numerically and experimentally. The bending and torsion modes of a low aspect ratio high speed turbine cascade tested in the non-rotating test facility at EPFL (Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne) have been chosen as the case study. The controlled vibration of 20 blades in travelling wave form was performed by means of an electromagnetic excitation system, enabling the adjustement of the vibration amplitude and inter blade phase at a given frequency. Unsteady pressure transducers located along the blade mid-section were used to obtain the modulus and phase of the unsteady pressure caused by the airfoil motion. The stabilizing effect of the torsion mode was clearly observed both in the experiments and the simulations, however the effect of grouping the blades in pairs in the minimum damping at the tested frequency was marginal in the bending mode. A numerical tool was validated using the available experimental data and then used to extend the results at lower and more relevant reduced frequencies. It is shown that the stabilizing effect exists for the bending and torsion modes in the frequency range typical of low-pressure turbines. It is concluded that the stabilizing effect of this configuration is due to the shielding effect of the pressure side of the airfoil that defines the passage of the pair on the suction side of the same passage, since the relative motion between both is null. This effect is observed both in the experiments and simulations.

Global Stability Analysis of a Compressible Turbulent Flow around a High-Lift Configuration

The purpose of this work is to analyze a complex high lift configuration for which significant regions of separated flow are present. Current state of the art methods have some diffculty to predict the origin and the progression of this separated flow when increasing the angle of attack. The mechanisms responsible for the maximum lift limit on multi-element wing con?gurations are not clear; this stability analysis could help to understand the physics behind the phenomenon and to find a relation between the flow separation and the instability onset. The methodology presented herein consists in the computation of a steady base flow solution based on a finite volume discretization and a proposal of the solution for a generalized eigenvalue problem corresponding to the perturbed and linearized problem. The eigenvalue problem has been solved with the Arnoldi iterative method, one of the Krylov subspace projection methods. The described methodology was applied to the NACA0012 test case in subsonic and in transonic conditions and, finally, for the first time to the authors knowledge, on an industrial multi-component geometry, such as the A310 airfoil, in order to identify low frequency instabilities related to the separation. One important conclusion is that for all the analyzed geometries, one unstable mode related to flow separation appears for an angle of attack greater than the one correspondent to the maximum lift coe?cient condition. Finally, an adjoint study was carried out in order to evaluate the receptivity and the structural sensitivity of the geometries, giving an indication of the domain region that could be modified resulting in the biggest change of the flowfield.

Direct and adjoint global stability analysis of turbulent transonic flows over a NACA0012 profile

In this work, various turbulent solutions of the two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional compressible Reynolds averaged Navier?Stokes equations are analyzed using global stability theory. This analysis is motivated by the onset of flow unsteadiness (Hopf bifurcation) for transonic buffet conditions where moderately high Reynolds numbers and compressible effects must be considered. The buffet phenomenon involves a complex interaction between the separated flow and a shock wave. The efficient numerical methodology presented in this paper predicts the critical parameters, namely, the angle of attack and Mach and Reynolds numbers beyond which the onset of flow unsteadiness appears. The geometry, a NACA0012 profile, and flow parameters selected reproduce situations of practical interest for aeronautical applications. The numerical computation is performed in three steps. First, a steady baseflow solution is obtained; second, the Jacobian matrix for the RANS equations based on a finite volume discretization is computed; and finally, the generalized eigenvalue problem is derived when the baseflow is linearly perturbed. The methodology is validated predicting the 2D Hopf bifurcation for a circular cylinder under laminar flow condition. This benchmark shows good agreement with the previous published computations and experimental data. In the transonic buffet case, the baseflow is computed using the Spalart?Allmaras turbulence model and represents a mean flow where the high frequency content and length scales of the order of the shear-layer thickness have been averaged. The lower frequency content is assumed to be decoupled from the high frequencies, thus allowing a stability analysis to be performed on the low frequency range. In addition, results of the corresponding adjoint problem and the sensitivity map are provided for the first time for the buffet problem. Finally, an extruded three-dimensional geometry of the NACA0012 airfoil, where all velocity components are considered, was also analyzed as a Triglobal stability case, and the outcoming results were compared to the previous 2D limited model, confirming that the buffet onset is well detected.

Estudio y validación experimental del efecto de aire interno en un perfil aerodinámico hueco

La presente investigación se llevó a cabo en la Universidad Politécnica de Madrid (España) conjuntamente con la Universidad Nacional Experimental del Táchira (Venezuela). El estudio consistió en diseñar una cavidad interna dentro del perfil aerodinámico 2415-3s, el cual fue desarrollado en la Universidad Técnica Checa (Praga, República Checa). Se realizó un estudio computacional, mediante la técnica del CFD, de diferentes modelos de cavidades internas en este perfil, para seleccionar el diseño más adecuado, fabricando un prototipo en 3D; logrando de esta manera validar la simulación computacional con los datos experimentales obtenidos con los ensayos en el túnel de viento AF6109 de la Universidad Nacional Experimental del Táchira. También se aplicaron técnicas de visualización en el túnel de viento, como líneas de corriente de humo y películas de aceite sobre el perfil aerodinámico. Dicho procedimiento permitió corroborar la validación de la simulación computacional. El perfil aerodinámico seleccionado se denominó 2415-3s-TC, cuya característica principal consiste en tres canales independientes entre sí, alojados dentro de la cavidad interna, permitiendo que el flujo de aire forzado a través de la cavidad, cambiara de dirección, para desembocar lo más tangencialmente, así como, lo más perpendicularmente posible al escalón del perfil aerodinámico 2415-3s. Esta configuración de diseñó permitió elevar el coeficiente de sustentación para ángulos de ataque mayores a 8º, así como para ángulos cercanos al ángulo crítico. ABSTRACT This research was conducted at the Polytechnic University of Madrid (Spain) together with the National Experimental University of Táchira (Venezuela). The study was to design an internal cavity within the airfoil 2415-3s, which was developed in the Czech Technical University (Prague, Czech Republic). A computational study was performed using CFD technique, different models of internal cavities in the profile to select the most appropriate design, manufacturing a prototype 3D; thus achieving validate the computer simulation with experimental data obtained from the tests in the wind tunnel AF6109 of the National Experimental University of Táchira. Visualization techniques were also applied in the wind tunnel, as streamlines smoke and oil films on the airfoil. This procedure corroborated validation of computational simulation. The airfoil selected denominated 2415-3s-TC, whose main characteristic consists of three independent channels each other, housed within the inner cavity, allowing the forced air flow through the cavity, change direction, to lead as more tangentially and, as perpendicular as possible to the step 2415-3s aerofoil. This configuration designed allowed increasing the lift coefficient for higher angles of attack to 8º, and for angles near the critical angle.