Strategy for succession in family owned small businesses as a wicked problem to be tamed

Contemporary strategic-planning processes don’t help family businesses cope with some of the big problems they face. Owner managers admit that they are confronted with issues, such as those associated with succession and inter-generational transfer that cannot be resolved merely by gathering additional data, defining issues more clearly, or breaking them down into small problems. Preparing for succession is often put off or ignored, many planning techniques don’t generate fresh ideas and implementing solutions is often fraught with political peril. This paper presents a framework to explore the idea of wicked problems, its relevance to succession planning in family businesses and its implications for practice and policy. A wicked problem has many and varied elements, and is complex as well as challenging. These problems are different to hard but ordinary problems, which people can solve in a finite time period by applying standard techniques. In this paper the authors argue that the wicked problem of family business succession requires a different approach to strategy, founded on social planning processes to engage multiple stakeholders and reconcile family/business interests to foster a joint commitment to possible ways of resolution. This requires academics and practitioners to re-frame traditional business strategic planning processes to achieve more sustainable family business futures.

Financial Characteristics of Family Businesses and Financial Aspects of Succession

Family businesses are special in many respects. By examining their financial characteristics one can come to unique conclusions/results. This paper explores the general characteristics of the financial behaviour of family businesses, presents the main findings of the INSIST project’s company case studies concerning financing issues and strategies, and intends to identify the financial characteristics of company succession. The whole existence of family businesses is characterized by a duality of the family and business dimensions and this remains the case in their financial affairs. The financial decisions in family businesses (especially SMEs) are affected by aspects involving a duality of goals rather than exclusively profitability, the simultaneous presence of family and business financial needs, and the preferential handling of family needs at the expense of business needs (although it has to be said that there is evidence of family investments being postponed for the sake of business, too. Family businesses, beyond their actual effectiveness, are guided by individual goals like securing living standards, ensuring workplaces for family members, stability of operation, preservation of the company’s good reputation, and keeping the company’s size at a level that the immediate family can control and manage. The INSIST project’s company case studies revealed some interesting traits of family business finances like the importance of financial support from the founder’s family during the establishment of the company, the use of bootstrapping techniques, the financial characteristics of succession, and the role of family members in financial management.

Managing Succession and Knowledge Transfer in Family Businesses: Lessons from a Comparative Research

The most natural mode of family firm succession is the intergenerational ownership transfer. Statistical evidence, however, suggests that in most cases the succession process fails. There can be several reasons as a lot of personal, emotional and structural factors can act as an inhibitor to succession. The effectiveness of the implementation of any succession strategy is strongly dependent on the efficiency of intergenerational knowledge transfer, which is related to the parties’ absorptive capacity and willingness to learn. The paper is based on the experiences learned from the INSIST project. In the framework of the project different aspects of family business succession have been investigated in three participating countries (Hungary, Poland and the United Kingdom). The aim of the paper is to identify the patterns of management, succession, knowledge transfer and learning in family businesses. Issues will be examined in detail such as the succession strategies of companies investigated and the efforts family businesses and their managers make in order to harmonize family goals (such as emotional stability, harmony, and reputation) with business- related objectives (e.g. survival, growth or profitability).

Moneyless business exchange - Practitioners' attitudes to business-to-business barter in Australia

In recent years, domestic business-to-business barter has become institutionalized as an alternative marketing exchange system in Australia, and elsewhere. This article reports the findings of a survey of 164 members of Australia's largest trade exchange, Bartercard There are few, if any, published empirical studies on this topic. This study is exploratory. Most firms surveyed are small firms in the services sectors. Although Bartercard has an extensive membership, trading within the system is limited with most members trading less than once per week and with barter transactions contributing less than 5% of their annual gross sales. The main benefits of membership include new customers and increased sales and networking opportunities. The main limitations include the limited functionality of the trade dollar limited trading opportunities, and practical trading difficulties. In selling, there appears to be no differential between the cash and trade prices, whereas trade dollars are discounted in purchasing. Participants acknowledge that business-to-business barter will remain and grow regardless of cyclical macroeconomic changes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Inc.

Analyses of Individual and Organizational Competences Associated with Knowledge Management Practice

The research analyzed critical aspects of the knowledge management process based on the analyses of knowledge, abilities and attitudes required to individual knowledge workers and to organizations responsible for the management process. In the present work a characterization of the knowledge management process was developed and information and knowledge wokers defined. Competence concept was discussed and specialists gave opinions about critical competences to knowledge management process. The opinions were organized and analyzed by the Delphi method. The results aggregate to the management context by discussing an extremely important resource to organizations - knowledge - and because they support its management process. The research identified wide critical aspects that are compatible with current organizational challenges, directing the process management to important themes as: the worker able to create, the organization able to convert individual knowledge into organizational knowledge, knowledge sharing while still tacit, the maximization organizational knowledge use, information and knowledge generation and preservation, among others important topics to be observed by knowledge workers and by administrators responsible for the knowledge management process.

The Controllership Relevance or Risk Management in non-Financial Companies: a study of risk managers` and controllers` perceptions

The purpose of this study is to analyze the Controllership relevance as support risk management in non-financial companies. Risk management is a widely discussed and disseminated subject amongst financial institutions. It is obvious that economic uncertainties and, consequently, prevention and. control must also exist in non-financial companies. To enable managers to take safe-decisions, it is essential for them to be able to count on instrumental support that provides timely and adequate information, to ensure lower levels of mistakes and risk exposure. However, discussion concerning risk management in non-financial companies is still in its early stages in Brazil. Considering this gap, this study aims at assessing how Controllership has been acting in? companies under the insight of risk and how it can contribute to risk management in non-financial companies. To achieve the proposed goal, a field research was. carried-out with non-financial companies that are located in the city Sao Paulo and listed in the Sao Paulo Stock Exchange (Bovespa). The research was carried out using questionnaires, which were sent do Risk Officers and Controllers of those companies with the purpose of evaluating their perception on the subject. The results,of the research allow us to conclude that Controllership offers support to risk management, through information that contributes to the mitigation of the risks in non-financial companies.

Supply chain management as beyond operational efficiency

The orthodoxy of supply chain management (SCM) emphasises competitive advantage through increased operational efficiency and market responsiveness from production and distribution processes into the hands of consumers. It anticipates that future competition will be between chains rather than between firms. While well established in other industry sectors, the SCM concept is newly developed in the Australian agri-food sector. Critical review of the concept has identified key issues of power among channel members, processes of chain initiation and innovation, and the inability of SCM to offer a viable business strategy for some firms. Building on those insights, this paper examines the supply chain concept for horticulture. Horticultural products are characterised by perishability, heterogeneity and lags in production response to market signals. Producers’ profits are vulnerable to quantity, timing of supply and product specification. Many supply chains in smaller industries are loose, fragmented, interwoven, unstable and unique! Firms operating within these environments need an astute understanding of the chains, the hierarchy of channel members and their relative position. Effective business strategies – for individual firms and supply chains - need to be developed and redeveloped to accommodate the dynamic nature of horticulture. Two case studies are discussed as contributions to this early stage of the theoretical development of supply chain management. The SCM concept also has implications for horticultural researchers, involving a wider range of industry stakeholders, technical problems and research skills. As for business management, the usefulness of the concept will depend on its capacity to increase responsiveness to customers’ preferences and customer value.

Mecanismos de governança corporativa na pequena empresa familiar

Esta dissertação tem como objetivo descrever e analisar como o fenômeno da governança corporativa articula mecanismos de gestão e impacta na dinâmica de uma pequena organização familiar. Para isso, utilizou-se as perspectivas de Fan (2001) e Silva Junior (2006), que tratam da governança corporativa, e de Chandler (1994), para empresas familiares. Através de abordagem qualitativa com ênfase em um estudo de caso, uma triangulação de dados foi realizada, utilizando a entrevista semiestruturada, observação assistemática ou livre e pesquisa de documentos, e a análise dos dados foi realizada por análise de conteúdo. Verificou-se a presença do fenômeno da governança por intermédio da identificação dos fatores de diferenciação, resultando na implantação de mecanismos de governança ao longo do ciclo de vida da organização familiar, o que possibilitou mudanças em seu controle, no seu processo sucessório e na sua profissionalização. Quanto ao controle, foram verificados que os mecanismos de “manutenção do status quo”, “aconselhamento profissional”, “sinergia de interesses”, “regulamentação financeira da sociedade”, “atribuições e responsabilidades”, “alinhamento de interesses do negócio” e “proteção do empreendimento familiar” possibilitaram a modificação e manutenção do controle da empresa com os sócios. Quanto ao eixo da profissionalização, foi verificado que os mecanismos de “regulamentação financeira da sociedade”, “atribuições e responsabilidades”, “alinhamento de interesses do negócio”, “proteção do empreendimento familiar” e “atenção aos interesses dos stakeholders” foram responsáveis por prover as modificações neste quesito e indicar que a empresa caminha no sentido de se profissionalizar. Quanto ao processo sucessório, verificou-se que a terceira geração não tem interesse na empresa, o que podem resultar na contratação de um profissional externo para gerir a mesma, respeitando a questão dos valores familiares e a cultura organizacional ou conduzir à sucessão recursiva. Aparentemente, observou-se que a segunda questão foi mais evidente, visto que a saída do último irmão do negócio culmina com a venda da empresa familiar, gerando duas alternativas: a compra da empresa por um grupo de sócios ou outra empresa não familiar, o que resultaria na “morte” da empresa enquanto empresa familiar; ou a sua compra por outra família ou empresa familiar, preservando sua classificação inicial.

Fenômeno da governança corporativa : um estudo de caso em uma pequena empresa familiar capixaba

Este estudo tem como objetivo compreender a forma com que os mecanismos de governança corporativa interferem na gestão de uma pequena empresa familiar. Para isso, adotaram-se a perspectiva de Hart (1995), que discorre sobre governança corporativa, e de Leone (2005) para empresas familiares. Para alcançar este objetivo, adotou-se, em relação à condução da pesquisa, uma abordagem qualitativa, por meio do método do estudo de caso. A triangulação de dados foi utilizada como instrumento de coleta de dados por meio de pesquisa documental, observação assistemática e entrevista semiestruturada, e a análise de dados foi realizada através da análise de conteúdo. Como contribuição teórica, este estudo amplia o Modelo de Quatro Círculos com Contexto e Sistema de Valores com a introdução de proprietários formais e informais, gerando o Modelo de Cinco Círculos. A presença da governança corporativa foi identificada através dos fatores de diferenciação e da implantação de onze mecanismos de governança que gerou mudanças no controle da empresa, no processo sucessório, na profissionalização e na captação de recursos. Os mecanismos encontrados foram denominados como: “empresa controladora”; “respeito fraternal”; “projetos pessoais”; “pró-labore dos gestores familiares”; “ausência de remuneração dos familiares não gestores”; “aconselhamento profissional”; “prestação de contas”; “proteção do empreendimento familiar”; “alinhamento de interesses na gestão”; “atribuições e responsabilidades”; e “atenção aos interesses dos stakeholders”. Tais mecanismos não possuem ordem cronológica, pois o respeito fraternal e projetos pessoas já existiam antes da criação da empresa familiar. Quanto ao controle, destaca-se o mecanismo prestação de contas, que possibilitou uma ligação entre a família e a empresa; permitiu clareza, transparência, igualdade entre todos os irmãos, diminuindo a assimetria informacional; facilitou uma comunicação aberta e honesta entre todos os proprietários, transmitindo uma sensação de segurança e previsibilidade; e contribuiu para eliminar e/ou minimizar conflitos entre os proprietários (formais e informais). Quanto à sucessão, os mecanismos proteção do empreendimento familiar, aconselhamento profissional, respeito fraternal estão possibilitando planejar o processo sucessório da empresa; facilitaram a comunicação entre os familiares, e assim, diminuiu a assimetria informacional; e realizaram a manutenção e administração dos bens mobiliários da família empresária. Quanto à profissionalização, os mecanismos proteção do empreendimento familiar e respeito fraternal viabilizaram a participação de todos para decidir sobre a profissionalização da empresa. Com relação à captação de recursos, os mecanismos atribuições e responsabilidades e atenção aos interesses dos stakeholders possibilitaram a empresa, durante todo seu ciclo de vida, a buscar recursos financeiros sem dificuldade, gerando um maior investimento, crescimento e geração de empregos

Empresas familiares vs. Empresas não familiares : evidência empírica em Portugal numa ótica de desempenho e do órgão de gestão

Mestrado em Contabilidade e Análise Financeira

PCV Holding: Who’s next? - Planning the Succession

This paper is a case study on a family business – PCV Holding – established in Mozambique. Having survived three generations and experiencing one of the most intense periods of growth, a tough issue emerges which is capable of compromising the future of the business: The Succession -How to transfer the management and ownership to the next generation while ensuring a fair process. Through several meetings with the board members and owners, I had the opportunity to understand the business and the family history which allowed me to study it taking into consideration family business’s subjects.

Portuguese business groups at the beginning of the 21st century: Trends, characteristics and configurations

This study considers the literature on the persistence of business groups in developed economies and analyzes the Portuguese case. The reconstruction of the largest business groups assembles information relevant to define characteristics that enable them to thrive. Increasing internationalization, more specialization in core activities and family control define these types of big businesses. New sectors also emerge as a characteristic of these business groups when compared to the ones existing 40 years ago.

Logoplaste: Conquering the world one bottle at a time

The “Logoplaste: Conquering the world one bottle at a time” case is based on the real story of the Botton family and their journey to build the globally known company Logoplaste. Famous for its “hole in the wall” strategy within the plastics industry, Logoplaste is not only one of the major plastic bottles manufacturers in the world, but also a company which has been proving us that a shared leadership system can be successful within a family business. This case intendeds to demonstrate the dynamics of a family business, illustrating the complexity of the decision making process and how they have successfully mastered dual management in a family firm. Moreover, it also aims to demonstrate that a family firm can be managed in such way that sustainable growth, as a key pillar, can be enabled through a strong focus on internationalization and innovation. A teaching note is available at the end of the case in order to guide students and teachers in their readings. Discussions questions, for debate in class environment, are also provided together with suggested answers drawn together to increase the critical sense and theoretical application of the themes studied in class.

Sistemas de controlo de gestão, empreendedorismo corporativo, estratégia e performance : contraste entre empresas familiares e não familiares

Mestrado em Contabilidade, Fiscalidade e Finanças Empresariais

Scientific mindfulness: A foundation for future themes in international business.

We conceptualize new ways to qualify what themes should dominate the future international business and management (IB/IM) research agenda by examining three questions: Whom should we ask? What should we ask, and which selection criteria should we apply? What are the contextual forces? Our main findings are the following: (1) wider perspectives from academia and practice would benefit both rigor and relevance; (2) four key forces are climate change, globalization, inequality, and sustainability; and (3) we propose scientific mindfulness as the way forward for generating themes in IB/IM research. Scientific mindfulness is a holistic, cross-disciplinary, and contextual approach, whereby researchers need to make sense of multiple perspectives with the betterment of society as the ultimate criterion.