Electron spectroscopy of novel charge transfer systems based on polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Organische Ladungstransfersysteme weisen eine Vielfalt von konkurrierenden Wechselwirkungen zwischen Ladungs-, Spin- und Gitterfreiheitsgraden auf. Dies führt zu interessanten physikalischen Eigenschaften, wie metallische Leitfähigkeit, Supraleitung und Magnetismus. Diese Dissertation beschäftigt sich mit der elektronischen Struktur von organischen Ladungstransfersalzen aus drei Material-Familien. Dabei kamen unterschiedliche Photoemissions- und Röntgenspektroskopietechniken zum Einsatz. Die untersuchten Moleküle wurden z.T. im MPI für Polymerforschung synthetisiert. Sie stammen aus der Familie der Coronene (Donor Hexamethoxycoronen HMC und Akzeptor Coronen-hexaon COHON) und Pyrene (Donor Tetra- und Hexamethoxypyren TMP und HMP) im Komplex mit dem klassischen starken Akzeptor Tetracyanoquinodimethan (TCNQ). Als dritte Familie wurden Ladungstransfersalze der k-(BEDT-TTF)2X Familie (X ist ein monovalentes Anion) untersucht. Diese Materialien liegen nahe bei einem Bandbreite-kontrollierten Mottübergang im Phasendiagramm.rnFür Untersuchungen mittels Ultraviolett-Photoelektronenspektroskopie (UPS) wurden UHV-deponierte dünne Filme erzeugt. Dabei kam ein neuer Doppelverdampfer zum Einsatz, welcher speziell für Milligramm-Materialmengen entwickelt wurde. Diese Methode wies im Ladungstransferkomplex im Vergleich mit der reinen Donor- und Akzeptorspezies energetische Verschiebungen von Valenzzuständen im Bereich weniger 100meV nach. Ein wichtiger Aspekt der UPS-Messungen lag im direkten Vergleich mit ab-initio Rechnungen.rnDas Problem der unvermeidbaren Oberflächenverunreinigungen von lösungsgezüchteten 3D-Kristallen wurde durch die Methode Hard-X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (HAXPES) bei Photonenenergien um 6 keV (am Elektronenspeicherring PETRA III in Hamburg) überwunden. Die große mittlere freie Weglänge der Photoelektronen im Bereich von 15 nm resultiert in echter Volumensensitivität. Die ersten HAXPES Experimente an Ladungstransferkomplexen weltweit zeigten große chemische Verschiebungen (mehrere eV). In der Verbindung HMPx-TCNQy ist die N1s-Linie ein Fingerabdruck der Cyanogruppe im TCNQ und zeigt eine Aufspaltung und einen Shift zu höheren Bindungsenergien von bis zu 6 eV mit zunehmendem HMP-Gehalt. Umgekehrt ist die O1s-Linie ein Fingerabdruck der Methoxygruppe in HMP und zeigt eine markante Aufspaltung und eine Verschiebung zu geringeren Bindungsenergien (bis zu etwa 2,5eV chemischer Verschiebung), d.h. eine Größenordnung größer als die im Valenzbereich.rnAls weitere synchrotronstrahlungsbasierte Technik wurde Near-Edge-X-ray-Absorption Fine Structure (NEXAFS) Spektroskopie am Speicherring ANKA Karlsruhe intensiv genutzt. Die mittlere freie Weglänge der niederenergetischen Sekundärelektronen (um 5 nm). Starke Intensitätsvariationen von bestimmten Vorkanten-Resonanzen (als Signatur der unbesetzte Zustandsdichte) zeigen unmittelbar die Änderung der Besetzungszahlen der beteiligten Orbitale in der unmittelbaren Umgebung des angeregten Atoms. Damit war es möglich, präzise die Beteiligung spezifischer Orbitale im Ladungstransfermechanismus nachzuweisen. Im genannten Komplex wird Ladung von den Methoxy-Orbitalen 2e(Pi*) und 6a1(σ*) zu den Cyano-Orbitalen b3g und au(Pi*) und – in geringerem Maße – zum b1g und b2u(σ*) der Cyanogruppe transferiert. Zusätzlich treten kleine energetische Shifts mit unterschiedlichem Vorzeichen für die Donor- und Akzeptor-Resonanzen auf, vergleichbar mit den in UPS beobachteten Shifts.rn

Nanographene als funktionale Materialien und synthetische Herausforderung

Im Rahmen dieser Arbeit wurden neuartige funktionale Nanographene synthetisiert und hinsichtlich ihrer strukturellen und elektronischen Eigenschaften charakterisiert. Basierend auf dem Strukturmotiv des Graphens konnten anellierte polyzyklische aromatische Kohlenwasserstoffe (PAKs) mit unterschiedlichen Seitenverhältnissen strukturdefiniert erhalten und gezielt in der Peripherie funktionalisiert werden. Basierend auf dem Synthesekonzept einer „Vorplanarisierung“ konnten Nanographen-Scheiben mit einem Durchmesser von bis zu 3 nm in hoher Reinheit erhalten werden. Durch die Entwicklung von Polyphenylen-Vorläufern mit einem gewinkelten Rückgrat konnten erstmals defektfreie und lösliche Nanographen-Streifen (GNRs) mit Breiten von 1,0 - 2,1 nm und Längen von über 40 nm synthetisiert werden.rnrnAm Hexa-peri-hexabenzocoronen (HBC) war es möglich, durch die Einführung kurzer linearer Alkylreste in der Peripherie den inter- und intrakolumnaren Abstand nach Selbstorganisation zu reduzieren. In Mischungen mit Perylentetracarboxydiimid (PDI) als Akzeptor konnte durch eine erhöhte Dichte und eine verbesserte Ladungsträgermobilität eine relative Steigerung der Effizienz von Donor-Akzeptor-Heteroübergangs-Solarzellen um 9 % erreicht werden. Eine kovalente Verknüpfung von HBC und PDI erlaubte hier die vollständige Kontrolle der supramolekularen Organisation, des Phasenverhaltens sowie des Abstandes zwischen Donor und Akzeptor.rnrnBasierend auf den im Rahmen dieser Arbeit entwickelten Synthesekonzepten, eröffnen sich nun zahlreiche Möglichkeiten zur Entwicklung weiterer Nanographene, die entsprechend der gewünschten Anwendung funktionalisiert werden können und ein besseres Verständnis der Eigenschaften graphenartiger Materialien erlauben werden.

Studies of degradation of organic solar cell materials using electrical scanning probe microscopy

Intense research is being done in the field of organic photovoltaics in order to synthesize low band-gap organic molecules. These molecules are electron donors which feature in combination with acceptor molecules, typically fullerene derivarntives, forming an active blend. This active blend has phase separated bicontinuous morphology on a nanometer scale. The highest recorded power conversionrnefficiencies for such cells have been 10.6%. Organic semiconductors differ from inorganic ones due to the presence of tightly bonded excitons (electron-hole pairs)resulting from their low dielectric constant (εr ≈2-4). An additional driving force is required to separate such Frenkel excitons since their binding energy (0.3-1 eV) is too large to be dissociated by an electric field alone. This additional driving force arises from the energy difference between the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the donor and the acceptor materials. Moreover, the efficiency of the cells also depends on the difference between the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) of the donor and LUMO of the acceptor. Therefore, a precise control and estimation of these energy levels are required. Furthermore any external influences that change the energy levels will cause a degradation of the power conversion efficiency of organic solar cell materials. In particular, the role of photo-induced degradation on the morphology and electrical performance is a major contribution to degradation and needs to be understood on a nanometer scale. Scanning Probe Microscopy (SPM) offers the resolution to image the nanometer scale bicontinuous morphology. In addition SPM can be operated to measure the local contact potential difference (CPD) of materials from which energy levels in the materials can be derived. Thus SPM is an unique method for the characterization of surface morphology, potential changes and conductivity changes under operating conditions. In the present work, I describe investigations of organic photovoltaic materials upon photo-oxidation which is one of the major causes of degradation of these solar cell materials. SPM, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) and UV-Vis spectroscopy studies allowed me to identify the chemical reactions occurring inside the active layer upon photo-oxidation. From the measured data, it was possible to deduce the energy levels and explain the various shifts which gave a better understanding of the physics of the device. In addition, I was able to quantify the degradation by correlating the local changes in the CPD and conductivity to the device characteristics, i.e., open circuit voltage and short circuit current. Furthermore, time-resolved electrostatic force microscopy (tr-EFM) allowed us to probe dynamic processes like the charging rate of the individual donor and acceptor domains within the active blend. Upon photo-oxidation, it was observed, that the acceptor molecules got oxidized first preventing the donor polymer from degrading. Work functions of electrodes can be tailored by modifying the interface with monomolecular thin layers of molecules which are made by a chemical reaction in liquids. These modifications in the work function are particularly attractive for opto-electronic devices whose performance depends on the band alignment between the electrodes and the active material. In order to measure the shift in work function on a nanometer scale, I used KPFM in situ, which means in liquids, to follow changes in the work function of Au upon hexadecanethiol adsorption from decane. All the above investigations give us a better understanding of the photo-degradation processes of the active material at the nanoscale. Also, a method to compare various new materials used for organic solar cells for stability is proposed which eliminates the requirement to make fully functional devices saving time and additional engineering efforts.

Quantenchemische Behandlung von elektronischem Energietransfer

Im Rahmen dieser Dissertation wurden quantenchemische Untersuchungen zum Phänomen des elektronischen Energietransfers durchgeführt. Zum einen wurden theoretische Modelle zur Berücksichtigung temperaturabhängiger Elektron-Phonon-Kopplung in vibronischen Spektren ausgearbeitet und numerischen Tests unterzogen. Zum anderen erfolgte die Bestimmung molekularer Eigenschaften bichromophorer Systeme unter Anwendung etablierter Rechenmethoden. Im Fokus stehen das Zusammenspiel elektronischer Kopplung und statischer Unordnung sowie Energietransferzeiten und der Einfluss molekularer Brücken in Dimeren auf die Kopplung. Da sich elektronischer Energietransfer spektroskopisch nachweisen lässt, wurden temperaturabhängige Simulationen der Linienform von vibronischen Übergängen, die an ein Wärmebad ankoppeln, durchgeführt. Die erforderliche Antwortfunktion zur Bestimmung der spektralen Linienform kann aus einer Kumulantenentwicklung und alternativ aus der Multi-Level Redfieldtheorie abgeleitet werden. Statt der genäherten Schwingungsstruktur des Brownschen Oszillatormodells wurde eine explizit berechnete Zustandsdichte als Ausgangspunkt verwendet. Sowohl reine Elektron-Phonon- als auch Schwingung-Phonon-Kopplung werden für verschiedene Spektraldichten der Badmoden diskutiert. Im Zuge eines Kooperationsprojekts führten wir Untersuchungen zur elektronischen Kopplung an einer homologen Reihe von Rylendimeren mit unterschiedlichen Brückenlängen durch. Zu diesem Zweck wurden Ergebnisse aus Tieftemperatureinzelmolekülmessungen und quantenchemischen Berechnungen auf Grundlage des vibronischen Kopplungsmodells herangezogen und ausgewertet. Die untersuchten Dimere zeigen einen Übergang vom Grenzfall starker Kopplung hin zu schwacher Kopplung und die mittleren Energietransferzeiten konnten in guter Übereinstimmung mit experimentellen Messwerten berechnet werden. Da eine molekulare Brücke zwischen Donor- und Akzeptoreinheit die elektronische Kopplung modifiziert, kann sie sich störend auf experimentelle Messungen auswirken. Daher wurde untersucht, ob das interchromophore Kopplungsverhalten vorwiegend durch die Polarisierbarkeit des verbrückenden Elements oder durch bindungsvermittelte Wechselwirkungen beeinflusst wird und welche Brückentypen sich folglich für experimentelle Studien eignen. Sämtliche untersuchten Brückenelemente führten zu einer Vergrößerung der elektronischen Kopplung und die Kopplungsstärke wurde maßgeblich durch brückenvermittelte Wechselwirkungen bestimmt.

Thermoelectric properties in phase-separated half-Heusler materials

The conversion of dissipated heat into electricity is the basic principle of thermoelectricity. In this context, half-Heusler (HH) compounds are promising thermoelectric (TE) materials for waste heat recovery. They meet all the requirements for commercial TE applications, ranging from good efficiencies via environmentally friendliness to being low cost materials. This work focused on the TE properties of Ti0.3Zr0.35Hf0.35NiSn-based HH materials. This compound undergoes an intrinsic phase separation into a Ti-poor and Ti-rich HH phase during a rapid solidification process. The resulting dendritic microstructure causes a drastic reduction of the thermal conductivity, leading to higher TE efficiencies in these materials. The TE properties and temperature dependence of the phase-separated Ti0.3Zr0.35Hf0.35NiSn compound were investigated. The TE properties can be adjusted depending on the annealing treatment. The extension of annealing time for 21 days at 1000 °C revealed a reduction of the thermal conductivity and thus an enhancement of the TE performance in this sample. An increase of annealing temperature caused a change of the phase fraction ratio in favor of the Ti-rich phase, leading to an improvement of the electronic properties. rnInspired by the TE properties of the Ti0.3Zr0.35Hf0.35NiSn HH compound, the performance of different n- and p-type materials, realized via site substitution with donor and acceptor elements was examined. The fabrication of a TE n- and p-type material pair based on one starting compound can guarantee similar TE and mechanical properties and is enormous beneficial for device engineering. As donor dopants V, Nb and Sb were tested. Depending on the lattice position small doping levels were sufficient to attain distinct improvement in their TE efficiency. Acceptor-induced doping with Sc, Y and Co caused a change in the transport behavior from n- to p- type conduction, revealing the highest Seebeck coefficients obtained in the MNiSn system. rnThen, the long-term stability of an exemplary n- and p-type HH compound was proven. Surprisingly, the dendritic microstructure can be maintained even after 500 cycles (1700 h) from 373 to 873 K. The TE performance of both n- and p-type materials showed no significant change under the long-term treatment, indicating the extraordinary temperature stability of these compounds. Furthermore both HH materials revealed similar temperature-dependence of their mechanical properties. This work demonstrates the excellent suitability of phase-separated HH materials for future TE applications in the moderate temperature range.rn

The Role of Hydrogen Bond in Designing Molecular Optical Materials

In this perspective article, we revise some of the empirical and semi-empirical strategies for predicting how hydrogen bonding affects molecular and atomic polarizabilities in aggregates. We use p-nitroaniline and hydrated oxalic acid as working examples to illustrate the enhancement of donor and acceptor functional-group polarizabilities and their anisotropy. This is significant for the evaluation of electrical susceptibilities in crystals; and the properties derived from them like the refractive indices.

Ionization energies of amphoteric-doped Cu2ZnSnS4: Photovoltaic application

The substitution of Cu, Sn or Zn in the quaternary Cu2ZnSnS4 semiconductor by impurities that introduce intermediate states in the energy bandgap could have important implications either for photovoltaic or spintronic applications. This allows more generation–recombination channels than for the host semiconductor. We explore and discuss this possibility by obtaining the ionization energies from total energy first-principles calculations. The three substitutions of Cu, Sn and Zn by impurities are analyzed. From these results we have found that several impurities have an amphoteric behavior with the donor and acceptor energies in the energy bandgap. In order to analyze the role of the ionization energies in both the radiative and non-radiative processes, the host energy bandgap and the acceptor and the donor energies have been obtained as a function of the inward and outward impurity-S displacements. We carried out the analysis for both the natural and synthetic CZTS. The results show that the ionization energies are similar, whereas the energy band gaps are different.

Single-molecule protein folding: Diffusion fluorescence resonance energy transfer studies of the denaturation of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2

We report single-molecule folding studies of a small, single-domain protein, chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2). CI2 is an excellent model system for protein folding studies and has been extensively studied, both experimentally (at the ensemble level) and theoretically. Conformationally assisted ligation methodology was used to synthesize the proteins and site-specifically label them with donor and acceptor dyes. Folded and denatured subpopulations were observed by fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) measurements on freely diffusing single protein molecules. Properties of these subpopulations were directly monitored as a function of guanidinium chloride concentration. It is shown that new information about different aspects of the protein folding reaction can be extracted from such subpopulation properties. Shifts in the mean transfer efficiencies are discussed, FRET efficiency distributions are translated into potentials, and denaturation curves are directly plotted from the areas of the FRET peaks. Changes in stability caused by mutation also are measured by comparing pseudo wild-type CI2 with a destabilized mutant (K17G). Current limitations and future possibilities and prospects for single-pair FRET protein folding investigations are discussed.

The change in hydrogen bond strength accompanying charge rearrangement: Implications for enzymatic catalysis

The equilibrium for formation of the intramolecular hydrogen bond (KHB) in a series of substituted salicylate monoanions was investigated as a function of ΔpKa, the difference between the pKa values of the hydrogen bond donor and acceptor, in both water and dimethyl sulfoxide. The dependence of log KHB upon ΔpKa is linear in both solvents, but is steeper in dimethyl sulfoxide (slope = 0.73) than in water (slope = 0.05). Thus, hydrogen bond strength can undergo substantially larger increases in nonaqueous media than aqueous solutions as the charge density on the donor or acceptor atom increases. These results support a general mechanism for enzymatic catalysis, in which hydrogen bonding to a substrate is strengthened as charge rearranges in going from the ground state to the transition state; the strengthening of the hydrogen bond would be greater in a nonaqueous enzymatic active site than in water, thus providing a rate enhancement for an enzymatic reaction relative to the solution reaction. We suggest that binding energy of an enzyme is used to fix the substrate in the low-dielectric active site, where the strengthening of the hydrogen bond in the course of a reaction is increased.

A comparative molecular similarity indices (CoMSIA) study of peptide binding to the HLA-A3 superfamily

Epitope identification is the basis of modern vaccine design. The present paper studied the supermotif of the HLA-A3 superfamily, using comparative molecular similarity indices analysis (CoMSIA). Four alleles with high phenotype frequencies were used: A*1101, A*0301, A*3101 and A*6801. Five physicochemical properties—steric bulk, electrostatic potential, local hydro-phobicity, hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor abilities—were considered and ‘all fields’ models were produced for each of the alleles. The models have a moderate level of predictivity and there is a good correlation between the data. A revised HLA-A3 supermotif was defined based on the comparison of favoured and disfavoured properties for each position of the MHC bound peptide. The present study demonstrated that CoMSIA is an effective tool for studying peptide–MHC interactions.

Estudio molecular en dos hermanas afectadas por ictiosis congénita autosómica recesiva : descripción de una nueva mutación causal en TGM1

Se describe la variante homocigota c.320-2A>G de TGM1 en dos hermanas con ictiosis congénita autosómica recesiva. El clonaje de los transcritos generados por esta variante permitió identificar tres mecanismos moleculares de splicing alternativos.

Solution-Processable Donor-Acceptor-Donor Oligomers with Cross-Linkable Functionality

Electron-acceptor units, combined with bithiophene substituted with flexible chains end-functionalized with cross-linkable moieties, provide soluble donor-acceptor-donor (DAD) it-conjugated oligomer-type molecules with cross-linking ability and broad absorption in the visible spectrum. A study on the cross-linking conditions of the new oligomers to yield insoluble polymer networks is presented, including conditions for obtaining polymer films over poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene):polystyrene sulfonate-covered substrates. The combination of the DAD molecular design and cross-linking functionality opens prospects for applications in solution-processed small-molecule solar cells with morphologically-stable organic layers.

Phenylethynylarene Based Donor-Acceptor Systems: Design, Synthesis and Photophysical Studies

This thesis Entitled phenylethynylarene based Donor-Acceptor systems:Desigh,Synthesis and Photophysical studies. A strategy for the design of donor-acceptor dyads, wherein decay of the charge separated (CS) state to low lying local triplet levels could possibly be prevented, is proposed. In order to examine this strategy, a linked donor-acceptor dyad BPEPPT with bis(phenylethYlly/)pyrene (BPEP) as the light absorber and acceptor and phenothiazine (PT) as donor was designed and photoinduced electron transfer in the dyad investigated. Absorption spectra of the dyad can be obtained by adding contributions due 10 the BPEP and PT moieties indicating that the constituents do not interact in the ground stale. Fluorescence of the BPEP moiety was efficiently quenched by the PT donor and this was attributed to electron lransfer from PT to BPEP. Picosecond transient absorption studies suggested formation of a charge separated state directly from the singlet excited state of BPEP. Nanosecond flash photolysis experiments gave long-ived transient absorptions assignable to PT radical cation and BPEP radical anion. These assignments were confirmed by oxygen quenching studies and secondary electron transfer experiments. Based on the available data, energy level diagram for BPEP-PT was constructed. The long lifetime of the charge separated state was attributed to the inverted region effects. The CS state did not undergo decay to low lying BPEP triplet indicating the success of our strategy

Effect of the Addition of a Fused Donor-Acceptor Ligand on a Ru(II) Complex: Synthesis, Characterization, and Photoinduced Electron Transfer Reactions of Ru(TTF-dppz)(2)(Aqphen) (2+)

The synthesis and the photophysical properties of the complex [Ru(TTF-dppz)(2)(Aqphen)](2+) (TTF = tetrathiafulvalene, dppz = dipyrido-[3,2-a:2',3'-c]phenazine, Aqphen = anthraquinone fused to phenanthroline via a pyrazine bridge) are described. In this molecular triad excitation into the metal ligand charge transfer bands results in the creation of a long-lived charge separated state with TTF acting as electron donor and anthraquinone as terminal acceptor. The lifetime of the charge-separated state is 400 ns in dichloromethane at room temperature. A mechanism for the charge separation involving an intermediate charge-separated state is proposed based on transient absorption spectroscopy.

Tetrathiafulvalene and 2,2'-Bipyridine: Bridging both Worlds in the Pursuit of Novel Molecular Materials

The preparation and characterization of two families of building blocks for molecule-based magnetic and conducting materials are described in three projects. In the first project the synthesis and characterization of three bis-imine ligands LI - L3 is reported. Coordination of LI to a series of metal salts afforded the five novel coordination complexes Sn(L4)C4 (I), [Mn(L4)(u-CI)(CI)(EtOH)h (II), [CU(L4)(u-sal) h(CI04)2 (sal = salicylaldehyde anion) (III), [Fe(Ls)2]CI (IV) and [Fe(LI)h(u-O) (V). All complexes have been structurally and magnetically characterized. X-ray diffraction studies revealed that, upon coordination to Lewis acidic metal salts, the imine bonds of LI are susceptible to nucleophilic attack. As a consequence, the coordination complexes (I) - (IV) contain either the cyclised ligand L4 or hydrolysed ligand Ls. In contrast, the dimeric Fe3+ complex (V) comprises two intact ligand LI molecules. In. this complex, the ligand chelates two Fe(III) centres in a bis-bidentate manner through the lone pairs of a phenoxy oxygen and an imine nitrogen atom. Magnetic studies of complexes (II-V) indicate that the dominant interactions between neighbouring metal centres in all of the complexes are antiferromagnetic. In the second project the synthesis and characterization two families of TTF donors, namely the cyano aryl compounds (VI) - (XI) and the his-aryl TTF derivatives (XII) - (XIV) are reported. The crystal structures of compounds (VI), (VII), (IX) and (XII) exhibit regular stacks comprising of neutral donors. The UV -Vis spectra of compounds (VI) - (XIV) present an leT band, indicative of the transfer of electron density from the TTF donors to the aryl acceptor molecules. Chemical oxidation of donors (VI), (VII), (IX) and (XII) with iodine afforded a series of CT salts that where possible have been characterized by single crystal X -ray diffraction. Structural studies showed that the radical cations in these salts are organized in stacks comprising of dimers of oxidized TTF donors. All four salts behave as semiconductors, displaying room temperature conductivities ranging from 1.852 x 10-7 to 9.620 X 10-3 Scm-I. A second series of CT salts were successfully prepared via the technique of electrocrystallization. Following this methodology, single crystals of two CT salts were obtained. The single crystal X-ray structures of both salts are isostructural, displaying stacks formed by trimers of oxidized donors. Variable temperature conductivity measurements carried out on this series of CT salts reveal they also are semiconductors with conductivities ranging from 2.94 x 10-7 to 1.960 X 10-3 S em-I at room temperature. In the third project the synthesis and characterization of a series of MII(hfac)2 coordination complexes of donor ligand (XII) where M2+ = Co2+, Cu2+, Ni2+ and Zn2+ are reported. These complexes crystallize in a head-to-tail arrangement of TTF donor and bipyridine moieties, placing the metal centres and hfac ligands are located outside the stacks. Magnetic studies of the complexes (XV) - (XVIII) indicate that the bulky hfac ligands prevent neighbouring metal centres from assembling in close proximity, and thus they are magnetically isolated.