Food Safety and Mineral Oil Contaminated Paperboard Packaging: an Analytical Challenge and a Migration Study

Food packaging protects food, but it can sometimes become a source of undesired contaminants. Paper based materials, despite being perceived as “natural” and safe, can contain volatile contaminants (especially if made from recycled paper) able to migrate to food, as mineral oil, phthalates and photoinitiators. Mineral oil is a petroleum product used as printing ink solvent for newspapers, magazines and packaging. From paperboard printing and from recycled fibers (if present), mineral oil migrates into food, even if dry, through the gas phase. Its toxicity is not fully evaluated, but a temporary Acceptable Daily Intake (ADI) of 0.6 mg kg-1 has been established for saturated mineral oil hydrocarbons (MOSH), while aromatic hydrocarbons (MOAH) are more toxic. Extraction and analysis of MOSH and MOAH is difficult due to the thousands of molecules present. Extraction methods for packaging and food have been optimized, then applied for a “shopping trolley survey” on over 100 Italian and Swiss market products. Instrumental analyses were performed with online LC-GC/FID. Average concentration of MOSH in paperboards was 626 mg kg-1. Many had the potential of contaminating foods exceeding temporary ADI tens of times. A long term migration study was then designed to better understand migration kinetics. Egg pasta and müesli were chosen as representative (high surface/weight ratio). They were stored at different temperatures (4, 20, 30, 40 and 60°C) and conditions (free, shelved or boxed packs) for 1 year. MOSH and MOAH kinetic curves show that migration is a fast process, mostly influenced by temperature: in egg pasta (food in direct contact with paperboard), half of MOSH is transferred to food in a week at 40°C and in 8 months at 20°C. The internal plastic bag present in müesli slowed down the startup of migration, creating a “lag time” in the curves.

Designed functional defects in colloidal photonic crystals: switching, biomonitoring and modified photoluminescence

Es werden zwei komplementäre "bottom-up" Methoden präsentiert, die den kontrollierten Einbau von "intelligenten" planaren Defekten in selbstorganisierte kolloidale photonische Kristalle (KPKs) ermöglichen. Die Defektschicht basiert auf einem funktionellen, nanometer-skalierten dünnen Film, der entweder durch schichtweise ("layer-by-layer") Selbstorganisation und Mikrokontakttransferübertragung oder durch Aufschleudern und einer KPK-Opferfüllung hergestellt wird. Die entwickelten Techniken gestatten die Integration von maßgeschneiderten dünnen Defektfilmen bestehend aus einer enorm großen Vielfalt an Materialien; sie sind kostengünstig und können im größeren Maßstab angewendet werden. Optische Untersuchungen zeigen einen engen, durch den Defekt hervorgerufenen Transmissionszustand in der photonischen Bandlücke. Die Defektwellenlänge hängt von der optischen Dicke der Defektschicht ab. Aktives Schalten der Defektwellenlänge wird erreicht, indem Defektschichten aus Makromolekülen hergestellt werden, die über externe Erreger wie Licht, Temperatur, Redoxzyklen und mechanischen Druck adressiert werden können. Die Ergebnisse der Untersuchungen sind im Einklang mit separat durchgeführten Ellipsometrie-Messungen und theoretischen "scalar wave approximation"-Berechnungen. Darüber hinaus werden KPKs mit funktionellen biomolekularen Defekten vorgestellt. Über Verschiebungen der Defektmode können DNA-Konformationsänderungen, die enantioselektive Einlagerung eines chiralen Antitumormedikaments sowie Enzymaktivitäten optisch beobachtet werden. Die Einlagerung von fluoreszierenden Farbstoffen und Quantenpunkten in Defekt-KPKs führt zu einer eindeutigen, durch die photonische Bandlücke und den Defektzustand hervorgerufenen Modifizierung der Photolumineszenz (PL)-Spektren. Schaltbare PL-Modifizierungen werden detektiert, wenn adressierbare Defekt-KPKs verwendet werden.

Celle ad Ossidi Solidi per Elettrolisi ad Alta Temperatura

Lo scopo di questa tesi è stato la produzione di un elettrolizzatore ad ossidi solidi (SOEC) mediante tecniche economiche e facilmente industrializzabili. Fondamentale a questo scopo è stata la realizzazione di una semicella costituita da un anodo poroso a base di La0.8Sr0.2MnO3-Ce0.8Gd0.2O2-δ (LSM-GDC) ed un elettrolita denso a base di Ce0.8Gd0.2O2-δ (GDC). Le tecniche utilizzate per la produzione di questo sistema sono state il colaggio su nastro e la serigrafia. Anche se generalmente, le celle SOEC vengono prodotte catodo supportate, in questo studio, l’elemento supportante scelto è stato l’anodo poiché questo garantisce una migliore stabilità meccanica all’intera cella. Tale substrato è stato ottenuto mediante colaggio su nastro accoppiato con un metodo innovativo di sinterizzazione denominato sinterizzazione reattiva, processo che prevede la formazione della fase di interesse durante un unico trattamento termico di eliminazione degli additivi organici e consolidamento del manufatto finale. La membrana elettrolitica per l’ottenimento del bilayer anodo-elettrolita, è stata prodotta mediante sia serigrafia che colaggio su nastro. L’accurato studio dell’evoluzione di fase della polvere anodica, l’ottimizzazione della sospensione per colaggio su nastro e dei trattamenti termici hanno permesso l’ottenimento di anodi (fino a dimensioni di 10x10 cm2). Lo studio dei profili di sinterizzazione delle polveri anodica ed elettrolitica e dell’influenza della tecnica di formatura sulla sinterabilità dei layer elettrolitici prodotti hanno inoltre permesso l’ottenimento di una semicella planare costituita da un elettrodo poroso ed una membrana elettrolitica densa adatte per applicazioni SOEC.

Complex materials via colloidal crystallization

The work presented in this thesis deals with complex materials, which were obtained by self-assembly of monodisperse colloidal particles, also called colloidal crystallization. Two main fields of interest were investigated, the first dealing with the fabrication of colloidal monolayers and nanostructures, which derive there from. The second turned the focus on the phononic properties of colloidal particles, crystals, and glasses. For the fabrication of colloidal monolayers a method is introduced, which is based on the sparse distribution of dry colloidal particles on a parent substrate. In the ensuing floating step the colloidal monolayer assembles readily at the three-phase-contact line, giving a 2D hexagonally ordered film under the right conditions. The unique feature of this fabrication process is an anisotropic shrinkage, which occurs alongside with the floating step. This phenomenon is exploited for the tailored structuring of colloidal monolayers, leading to designed hetero-monolayers by inkjet printing. Furthermore, the mechanical stability of the floating monolayers allows the deposition on hydrophobic substrates, which enables the fabrication of ultraflat nanostructured surfaces. Densely packed arrays of crescent shaped nanoparticles have also been synthesized. It is possible to stack those arrays in a 3D manner allowing to mutually orientate the individual layers. In a step towards 3D mesoporous materials a methodology to synthesize hierarchically structured inverse opals is introduced. The deposition of colloidal particles in the free voids of a host inverse opal allows for the fabrication of composite inverse opals on two length scales. The phononic properties of colloidal crystals and films are characterized by Brillouin light scattering (BLS). At first the resonant modes of colloidal particles consisting of polystyrene, a copolymer of methylmethacrylate and butylacrylate, or of a silica core-PMMA shell topography are investigated, giving insight into their individual mechanical properties. The infiltration of colloidal films with an index matching liquid allows measuring the phonon dispersion relation. This leads to the assignment of band gaps to the material under investigation. Here, two band gaps could be found, one originating from the fcc order in the colloidal crystal (Bragg gap), the other stemming from the vibrational eigenmodes of the colloidal particles (hybridization gap).

Stress – structure correlations in grafted polymer films

In der vorliegenden Arbeit wurden experimentelle Untersuchungen zu gepfropften Polymerfilmen durchgeführt. Dabei wurden endgepfropfte poly-methyl-methacrylate (PMMA) Bürsten hergestellt durch „grafting from“ Methoden und polystyrol (PS)/ poly-vinyl-methyl-ether (PVME) Polymerfilme gepfropft auf UV sensitiven Oberflächen untersucht. Zur Strukturuntersuchung wurden die hergestellten Systeme wurden mit Rasterkraftmikroskopie (engl.: Surface Probe Microscopy, SPM), Röntgen - und Neutronenreflektivitätsmessungen, sowie mit Röntgenstreuung unter streifenden Einfall (engl.: Grazing Incidence Small Angle X-Ray Scattering, GISAXS) untersucht. rnEs wurde gezeigt, dass ein aus der Transmissionsstreuung bekanntes Model auch für auch für die GISAXS Analyse polydisperser Polymerdomänen und Kolloidsysteme verwendet werden kann. Der maximale Fehler durch die gemachten Näherungen wurde auf < 20% abgeschätzt.rnErgebnisse aus der Strukturanalyse wurden mit mechanischen Filmeigenschaften verknüpft. Dazu wurden mechanische Spannungsexperimente durchgeführt. Hierzu wurden die zu untersuchenden Filme selektiv auf einzelne Mikro-Federbalken-Sensoren (engl.: Micro Cantilever Sensor, MCS) der MCS Arrays aufgebracht. Dies wurde durch Maskierungstechniken und Mikro-Kontaktdrucken bewerkstelligt. rnPhasenübergansexperimente der gepfropften PS/PVME Filme haben gezeigt, dass die Möglichkeit einer Polymer/Polymer Phasenseparation stark von Propfpunktdichte der gebundenen Polymerketten mit der Oberfläche abhängt. PS/PVME Filmsysteme mit hohen Pfropfpunktdichten zeigten keinen Phasenübergang. Bei niedrig gepfropften Filmsystemen waren hingegen Polymer/Polymer Phasenseparationen zu beobachten. Es wurde geschlussfolgert, dass die gepfropften Polymersysteme einen hinreichenden Grad an entropischen Freiheitsgraden benötigen um eine Phasenseparation zu zeigen. Mechanische Spannungsexperimente haben dabei das Verstehen der Phasenseparationsmechanismen möglich gemacht.rnAus Quellexperimenten dichtgepfropfter PMMA Bürsten, wurden Lösungsmittel-Polymer Wechselwirkungsparameter (-Parameter) bestimmt. Dabei wurde festgestellt, dass sich die erhaltenen Parameter aufgrund von Filmbenetzung und entropischen Effekten maßgeblich von den errechneten Bulkwerten unterscheiden. Weiterhin wurden nicht reversible Kettenverschlaufungseffekt beobachtet.

New design of polyphenylene dendrimers for full-color light-emitting diodes

Dendritic systems, and in particular polyphenylene dendrimers, have recently attracted considerable attention from the synthetic organic chemistry community, as well as from photophysicists, particularly in view of the search for synthetic model analogies to photoelectric materials to fabricate organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), and even more advanced areas of research such as light-harvesting system, energy transfer and non-host device. Geometrically, dendrimers are unique systems that consist of a core, one or more dendrons, and surface groups. The different parts of the macromolecule can be selected to give the desired optoelectronic and processing properties. Compared to small molecular or polymeric light-emitting materials, these dendritic materials can combine the benefits of both previous classes. The high molecular weights of these dendritic macromolecules, as well as the surface groups often attached to the distal ends of the dendrons, can improve the solution processability, and thus can be deposited from solution by simple processes such as spin-coating and ink-jet printing. Moreover, even better than the traditional polymeric light-emitting materials, the well-defined monodisperse distributed dendrimers possess a high purity comparable to that of small molecules, and as such can be fabricated into high performance OLEDs. Most importantly, the emissive chromophores can be located at the core of the dendrimer, within the dendrons, and/or at the surface of the dendrimers because of their unique dendritic architectures. The different parts of the macromolecule can be selected to give the desired optoelectronic and processing properties. Therefore, the main goals of this thesis are the design and synthesis, characterization of novel functional dendrimers, e.g. polytriphenylene dendrimers for blue fluorescent, as well as iridium(III) complex cored polyphenylene dendrimers for green and red phosphorescent light emitting diodes. In additional to the above mentioned advantages of dendrimer based OLEDs, the modular molecular architecture and various functionalized units at different locations in polyphenylene dendrimers open up a tremendous scope for tuning a wide range of properties in addition to color, such as intermolecular interactions, charge mobility, quantum yield, and exciton diffusion. In conclusion, research into dendrimer containing OLEDs combines fundamental aspects of organic semiconductor physics, novel and highly sophisticated organic synthetic chemistry and elaborate device technology.rn

Homogeneous analysis of a sample of Open Clusters in the context of the BOCCE project and the Gaia-ESO Survey

The open clusters (OC) are gravitationally bound systems of a few tens or hundreds of stars. In our Galaxy, the Milky Way, we know about 3000 open clusters, of very different ages in the range of a few millions years to about 9 Gyr. OCs are mainly located in the Galactic thin disc, with distances from the Galactic centre in the range 4-22 kpc and a height scale on the disc of about 200 pc. Their chemical properties trace those of the environment in which they formed and the metallicity is in the range -0.5<[Fe/H]<+0.5 dex. Through photometry and spectroscopy it is possible to study relatively easily the properties of the OCs and estimate their age, distance, and chemistry. For these reasons they are considered primary tracers of the chemical properties and chemical evolution of the Galactic disc. The main subject of this thesis is the comprehensive study of several OCs. The research embraces two different projects: the Bologna Open Cluster Chemical Evolution project (BOCCE) and the Gaia-ESO Survey. The first is a long-term programme, aiming at studying the chemical evolution of the Milky Way disc by means of a homogeneous sample of OCs. The latter is a large public spectroscopy survey, conducted with the high-resolution spectrograph FLAMES@VLT and targeting about 10^5 stars in different part of the Galaxy and 10^4 stars in about 100 OCs. The common ground between the two projects is the study of the properties of the OCs as tracers of the disc's characteristics. The impressive scientific outcome of the Gaia-ESO Survey and the unique framework of homogeneity of the BOCCE project can propose, especially once combined together, a much more accurate description of the properties of the OCs. In turn, this will give fundamental constraints for the interpretation of the properties of the Galactic disc.

Modifizierungen des Enzyms Silicatein alpha zur direkten Immobilisierung auf verschiedenen Oberflächen : neuartige Herstellung von Kompositmaterialien unter physiologischen Bedingungen

Das Silicatein α ist ein 24 kDa großes Enzym, welches im Schwamm Suberites domuncula für die Synthese von Biosilikat verantwortlich ist. Vorhergehende Studien haben gezeigt, dass Silicatein auch die Synthese anderer Metalloxide wie Titandioxid, Galliumoxid und Zirkoniumdioxid katalysieren kann. Diese Fähigkeiten machen das Silicatein α für biomedizinische und biotechnologische Anwendungen interessant, da die Synthese unter nahezu physiologischen Bedingungen ablaufen kann, was die Herstellung neuartiger Kompositmaterialien mit einzigartigen Eigenschaften erleichtern würde. Zur Immobilisierung des Silicatein α auf verschiedenen Oberflächen wurde bislang ein Nickel-NTA-Kopolymer eingesetzt. Diese Art der Immobilisierung bietet eine Reihe von Möglichkeiten in der Nanobiotechnologie, stößt aber in der Biomedizin an ihre Grenzen, da sich nicht alle Oberflächen für ein solches Coating eignen. Zudem können die zur Aktivierung des Polymers nötigen Lösungsmittel und die über die Zeit freigesetzten Monomere aus dem Polymergerüst toxische oder mutagene Wirkung auf das umliegende Gewebe haben. Deshalb wurde das Silicatein α in dieser Arbeit mit zwei Affinitäts-Tags so modifiziert, dass es an verschiedene Oberflächen immobilisiert werden kann und dabei seine Aktivität beibehält. Zuerst wurde das Silicatein mit einem Glu-tag am N-terminalen Ende modifiziert. Dadurch gelang die direkte Immobilisierung an Hydroxyapatit und die folgende, enzymkatalysierte Synthese von Biosilikat-Beschichtungen auf diesem Träger. Die Eigenschaften eines solchen HA-Kompositmaterials können zum Beispiel zu einem verbesserten, schnelleren und stabileren Einwachsen von Knochenimplantaten führen, da Biosilikat die Reifung und Differenzierung von Osteoblasten beschleunigt. rnMit dem an Hydroxyapatit-Plättchen immobilisierten Glu-tag-Silicatein wurde ein modifizierter Pull-down Assay etabliert, wodurch bekannte, aber auch bis dahin noch unbekannte Protein-Interaktionspartner identifiziert werden konnten. rnUm zu zeigen, dass der entwickelte Glu-tag an präformierte, calciumhaltige Oberflächen binden kann, wurden die Nadeln des Kalkschwammes Paraleucilla magna als Modellorganismus verwendet. Die Nadeln konnten durch das immobilisierte Silicatein mit einer Titandioxid-Schicht überzogen werden und unter Verwendung des Interaktionspartners Silintaphin-1 konnte diese Beschichtung noch verstärkt werden. Solche CaCO3-Kompositmaterialien könnten sowohl in der Biomedizin als auch in der Biotechnologie zum Einsatz kommen. Neben den erwähnten calciumhaltigen Materialien finden auch andere Stoffe wie TiO2-Nanodrähte Verwendung in der Forschung. In weiterführenden Experimenten konnte gezeigt werden, dass der entwickelte Glu-tag auch Affinität zu Titandioxid-Oberflächen vermittelt. Auch hier konnte durch das oberflächenimmobilisierte Enzym eine Biosilikatbeschichtung synthetisiert werden. rnMit der zweiten Modifikation - einem Cys-tag - konnte Silicatein direkt auf Goldoberflächen immobilisiert werden. Durch die Verwendung eines Polydimethylsiloxan (PDMS)-Stempels wurde das Cys-getaggte Silicatein in einem linienförmigen Muster auf das Gold übertragen und die Synthese von Titandioxid dort nachgewiesen.rnDie Experimente und Ergebnisse dieser Arbeit haben gezeigt, dass Silicatein α durch einfache Modifikationen an verschiedene Oberflächen immobilisiert werden kann und dabei immer noch seine Aktivität behält. rnHierdurch ergibt sich die Möglichkeit, unter Normalbedingungen verschiedenste Kompositmaterialien herzustellen.rn

Druckgeschichte und Wissenschaft

In dem Beitrag unternimmt der Autor eine methodisch-theoretische Einordnung der bisher wenig betrachteten Druckgeschichte als historisches Untersuchungsfeld. Das entwickelte Modell differenziert dabei in den Druckakteur, die Drucktechnik und das Druckobjekt, die in einem historischen, sozialen, kulturellen und politischen Kontext interagieren. Anhand von zahlreichen Beispielen wird aufgezeigt, welcher Erkenntnisgewinn sich bei der Auseinandersetzung mit der Druckgeschichte für alle das gedruckte Buch thematisierenden wissenschaftlichen Disziplinen ergeben können.

Riprogettazione dei processi e informatizzazione di un reparto manutenzione. Il caso de "il Resto del Carlino"

In un contesto dinamico come quello odierno la competitività delle imprese è profondamente legata alla capacità di gestire i propri processi aziendali e di intervenire su di essi. Ciò presuppone un cambio di paradigma, da “qual è il mio ruolo nell’azienda?” a “qual è il mio ruolo nei processi aziendali?”, ovvero l’abbandono della logica funzionale a favore di quella per processi. Tale progetto di tesi, nato dal mio tirocinio in Poligrafici Printing S.p.a. (polo industriale del quotidiano “Il Resto del Carlino”), si pone l’obiettivo di illustrare, facilitare e promuovere la gestione per processi e la riprogettazione di questi ultimi come strumento per raggiungere flessibilità, controllo ed efficienza operativa, con particolare riferimento all’informatizzazione di un reparto manutenzione.

In vitro cytotoxicity of silver nanoparticles on osteoblasts and osteoclasts at antibacterial concentrations

Abstract Nanoparticulate silver coatings for orthopaedic implants promise to decrease postoperative infection rates. However, silver-induced cytotoxicity on bone cells has not been investigated in detail. This study investigated the cytotoxic effects of silver nano- and microparticles and Ag(+) on osteoblasts (OBs) and osteoclasts (OCs) and correlated their effects with the antibacterial efficacy on Staphylococcus epidermidis. Silver nanoparticles (50 nm) exhibited strong cytotoxic effects on OBs and OCs. Weak cytotoxic effects were observed for silver microparticles (3 μm). The cytotoxicity was primarily mediated by a size-dependent release of Ag(+). Antibacterial effects occurred at Ag(+) concentrations that were 2-4 times higher than those inducing cytotoxic effects. Such adverse effects on OB and OC survival may have deleterious effects on the biocompatibility of orthopaedic implants. Our study represents an important step toward the detailed investigation of orthopaedic implant with nanoparticulate silver coatings prior to their widespread clinical usage.

Private Publishing in Moscow and St. Petersburg: Historical Background, Present Situation and Trends"

This research was a complex study of the economic and socio-cultural aspects of the development of Russian private publishing in the second half of the19th and early 20th centuries, during the periods of 'war communism' and the New Economic Policy of 1917 to 1930, and during the reform of book publishing in 1986-1999. Conclusions about private book publishing in Moscow and St. Petersburg were extrapolated to Russia-wide problems of the development of this field. Svichenskaya sees her main achievement as having identified the economic and legal concepts behind the development of private book publishing over the period in question in the context of state and corporate regulation of publishing. Here the state was the main influence on its development and there was a paradox in the relations between the state authorities and private publishers, in that the latter constantly suffered from repression by the former but at the same time were dependent on state support. The research identified the administrative process of the liquidation of private publishing at the end of the 1920s and showed that its present flourishing is closely linked with the establishment of a preferential mode for the development of this sector. Private publishing now represents around 80% of domestic publishing, in terms both of the number of publishing houses and of the number of volumes published, and so plays the major role in satisfying the demand for books in Russia. Svichenskaya predicts that in the coming years private publishing will see a further concentration of growth and a tendency to monopolies and also the increasing specialisation of the publishing repertoire. She outlines a suggested concept of state management in publishing and ways to optimise this. In the transitional period of adaptation to the market regulation of publishing, these include a continuing degree of state protectionism, the creation of a favourable investment climate, privatisation of the printing companies with the aim of modernising these, and the development of coordinated corporate policies.

Development of the premature infant nose throat-model (PrINT-Model): an upper airway replica of a premature neonate for the study of aerosol delivery

Clinical efficacy of aerosol therapy in premature newborns depends on the efficiency of delivery of aerosolized drug to the bronchial tree. To study the influence of various anatomical, physical, and physiological factors on aerosol delivery in preterm newborns, it is crucial to have appropriate in vitro models, which are currently not available. We therefore constructed the premature infant nose throat-model (PrINT-Model), an upper airway model corresponding to a premature infant of 32-wk gestational age by three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction of a three-planar magnetic resonance imaging scan and subsequent 3D-printing. Validation was realized by visual comparison and comparison of total airway volume. To study the feasibility of measuring aerosol deposition, budesonide was aerosolized through the cast and lung dose was expressed as percentage of nominal dose. The airway volumes of the initial magnetic resonance imaging and validation computed tomography scan showed a relative deviation of 0.94%. Lung dose at low flow (1 L/min) was 61.84% and 9.00% at high flow (10 L/min), p < 0.0001. 3D-reconstruction provided an anatomically accurate surrogate of the upper airways of a 32-wk-old premature infant, making the model suitable for future in vitro testing.

AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF PARTIAL LOW RISK DEPLOYMENT IN A FIXED VEHICLE ENVIRONMENT

This study will look at the passenger air bag (PAB) performance in a fix vehicle environment using Partial Low Risk Deployment (PLRD) as a strategy. This development will follow test methods against actual baseline vehicle data and Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards 208 (FMVSS 208). FMVSS 208 states that PAB compliance in vehicle crash testing can be met using one of three deployment methods. The primary method suppresses PAB deployment, with the use of a seat weight sensor or occupant classification sensor (OCS), for three-year old and six-year old occupants including the presence of a child seat. A second method, PLRD allows deployment on all size occupants suppressing only for the presents of a child seat. A third method is Low Risk Deployment (LRD) which allows PAB deployment in all conditions, all statures including any/all child seats. This study outlines a PLRD development solution for achieving FMVSS 208 performance. The results of this study should provide an option for system implementation including opportunities for system efficiency and other considerations. The objective is to achieve performance levels similar too or incrementally better than the baseline vehicles National Crash Assessment Program (NCAP) Star rating. In addition, to define systemic flexibility where restraint features can be added or removed while improving occupant performance consistency to the baseline. A certified vehicles’ air bag system will typically remain in production until the vehicle platform is redesigned. The strategy to enable the PLRD hypothesis will be to first match the baseline out of position occupant performance (OOP) for the three and six-year old requirements. Second, improve the 35mph belted 5th percentile female NCAP star rating over the baseline vehicle. Third establish an equivalent FMVSS 208 certification for the 25mph unbelted 50th percentile male. FMVSS 208 high-speed requirement defines the federal minimum crash performance required for meeting frontal vehicle crash-test compliance. The intent of NCAP 5-Star rating is to provide the consumer with information about crash protection, beyond what is required by federal law. In this study, two vehicles segments were used for testing to compare and contrast to their baseline vehicles performance. Case Study 1 (CS1) used a cross over vehicle platform and Case Study 2 (CS2) used a small vehicle segment platform as their baselines. In each case study, the restraints systems were from different restraint supplier manufactures and each case contained that suppliers approach to PLRD. CS1 incorporated a downsized twins shaped bag, a carryover inflator, standard vents, and a strategic positioned bag diffuser to help disperse the flow of gas to improve OOP. The twin shaped bag with two segregated sections (lobes) to enabled high-speed baseline performance correlation on the HYGE Sled. CS2 used an A-Symmetric (square shape) PAB with standard size vents, including a passive vent, to obtain OOP similar to the baseline. The A-Symmetric shape bag also helped to enabled high-speed baseline performance improvements in HYGE Sled testing in CS2. The anticipated CS1 baseline vehicle-pulse-index (VPI) target was in the range of 65-67. However, actual dynamic vehicle (barrier) testing was overshadowed with the highest crash pulse from the previous tested vehicles with a VPI of 71. The result from the 35mph NCAP Barrier test was a solid 4-Star (4.7 Star) respectfully. In CS2, the vehicle HYGE Sled development VPI range, from the baseline was 61-62 respectively. Actual NCAP test produced a chest deflection result of 26mm versus the anticipated baseline target of 12mm. The initial assessment of this condition was thought to be due to the vehicles significant VPI increase to 67. A subsequent root cause investigation confirmed a data integrity issue due to the instrumentation. In an effort to establish a true vehicle test data point a second NCAP test was performed but faced similar instrumentation issues. As a result, the chest deflect hit the target of 12.1mm; however a femur load spike, similar to the baseline, now skewed the results. With noted level of performance improvement in chest deflection, the NCAP star was assessed as directional for 5-Star capable performance. With an actual rating of 3-Star due to instrumentation, using data extrapolation raised the ratings to 5-Star. In both cases, no structural changes were made to the surrogate vehicle and the results in each case matched their perspective baseline vehicle platforms. These results proved the PLRD is viable for further development and production implementation.