Interpreting Judgements using Knowledge Representation Methods and Computational Models of Argument

The goal of the present research is to define a Semantic Web framework for precedent modelling, by using knowledge extracted from text, metadata, and rules, while maintaining a strong text-to-knowledge morphism between legal text and legal concepts, in order to fill the gap between legal document and its semantics. The framework is composed of four different models that make use of standard languages from the Semantic Web stack of technologies: a document metadata structure, modelling the main parts of a judgement, and creating a bridge between a text and its semantic annotations of legal concepts; a legal core ontology, modelling abstract legal concepts and institutions contained in a rule of law; a legal domain ontology, modelling the main legal concepts in a specific domain concerned by case-law; an argumentation system, modelling the structure of argumentation. The input to the framework includes metadata associated with judicial concepts, and an ontology library representing the structure of case-law. The research relies on the previous efforts of the community in the field of legal knowledge representation and rule interchange for applications in the legal domain, in order to apply the theory to a set of real legal documents, stressing the OWL axioms definitions as much as possible in order to enable them to provide a semantically powerful representation of the legal document and a solid ground for an argumentation system using a defeasible subset of predicate logics. It appears that some new features of OWL2 unlock useful reasoning features for legal knowledge, especially if combined with defeasible rules and argumentation schemes. The main task is thus to formalize legal concepts and argumentation patterns contained in a judgement, with the following requirement: to check, validate and reuse the discourse of a judge - and the argumentation he produces - as expressed by the judicial text.

Sparse Signal Representation of Ultrasonic Signals for Structural Health Monitoring Applications

Assessment of the integrity of structural components is of great importance for aerospace systems, land and marine transportation, civil infrastructures and other biological and mechanical applications. Guided waves (GWs) based inspections are an attractive mean for structural health monitoring. In this thesis, the study and development of techniques for GW ultrasound signal analysis and compression in the context of non-destructive testing of structures will be presented. In guided wave inspections, it is necessary to address the problem of the dispersion compensation. A signal processing approach based on frequency warping was adopted. Such operator maps the frequencies axis through a function derived by the group velocity of the test material and it is used to remove the dependence on the travelled distance from the acquired signals. Such processing strategy was fruitfully applied for impact location and damage localization tasks in composite and aluminum panels. It has been shown that, basing on this processing tool, low power embedded system for GW structural monitoring can be implemented. Finally, a new procedure based on Compressive Sensing has been developed and applied for data reduction. Such procedure has also a beneficial effect in enhancing the accuracy of structural defects localization. This algorithm uses the convolutive model of the propagation of ultrasonic guided waves which takes advantage of a sparse signal representation in the warped frequency domain. The recovery from the compressed samples is based on an alternating minimization procedure which achieves both an accurate reconstruction of the ultrasonic signal and a precise estimation of waves time of flight. Such information is used to feed hyperbolic or elliptic localization procedures, for accurate impact or damage localization.

Multimodal (EEG-fMRI) functional connectivity study of levodopa effect in Parkinson’s disease

Aim: To assess if the intake of levodopa in patients with Parkinson’s Disease (PD) changes cerebral connectivity, as revealed by simultaneous recording of hemodynamic (functional MRI, or fMRI) and electric (electroencephalogram, EEG) signals. Particularly, we hypothesize that the strongest changes in FC will involve the motor network, which is the most impaired in PD. Methods: Eight patients with diagnosis of PD “probable”, therapy with levodopa exclusively, normal cognitive and affective status, were included. Exclusion criteria were: moderate-severe rest tremor, levodopa induced dyskinesia, evidence of gray or white matter abnormalities on structural MRI. Scalp EEG (64 channels) were acquired inside the scanner (1.5 Tesla) before and after the intake of levodopa. fMRI functional connectivity was computed from four regions of interest: right and left supplementary motor area (SMA) and right and left precentral gyrus (primary motor cortex). Weighted partial directed coherence (w-PDC) was computed in the inverse space after the removal of EEG gradient and cardioballistic artifacts. Results and discussion: fMRI group analysis shows that the intake of levodopa increases hemodynamic functional connectivity among the SMAs / primary motor cortex and: sensory-motor network itself, attention network and default mode network. w-PDC analysis shows that EEG connectivity among regions of the motor network has the tendency to decrease after the intake the levodopa; furthermore, regions belonging to the DMN have the tendency to increase their outflow toward the rest of the brain. These findings, even if in a small sample of patients, suggest that other resting state physiological functional networks, beyond the motor one, are affected in patients with PD. The behavioral and cognitive tasks corresponding to the affected networks could benefit from the intake of levodopa.

Ambiti applicativi dell'EEG e della fMRI nello studio dei processi cognitivi

L’obiettivo della mia tesi è quello di presentare e confrontare due tipologie di tecniche di indagine cerebrale, l’EEG (Elettroencefalogramma) e la fMRI (Risonanza Magnetica funzionale), evidenziandone i vantaggi e gli svantaggi, e le loro applicazioni in campo medico. Successivamente è presentato lo sviluppo di un modello sperimentale volto allo studio del fenomeno della sinestesia, a partire da dati estratti mediante le tecniche precedenti.

Representation theorems for indefinite quadratic forms and applications

Diese Arbeit widmet sich den Darstellungssätzen für symmetrische indefinite (das heißt nicht-halbbeschränkte) Sesquilinearformen und deren Anwendungen. Insbesondere betrachten wir den Fall, dass der zur Form assoziierte Operator keine Spektrallücke um Null besitzt. Desweiteren untersuchen wir die Beziehung zwischen reduzierenden Graphräumen, Lösungen von Operator-Riccati-Gleichungen und der Block-Diagonalisierung für diagonaldominante Block-Operator-Matrizen. Mit Hilfe der Darstellungssätze wird eine entsprechende Beziehung zwischen Operatoren, die zu indefiniten Formen assoziiert sind, und Form-Riccati-Gleichungen erreicht. In diesem Rahmen wird eine explizite Block-Diagonalisierung und eine Spektralzerlegung für den Stokes Operator sowie eine Darstellung für dessen Kern erreicht. Wir wenden die Darstellungssätze auf durch (grad u, h() grad v) gegebene Formen an, wobei Vorzeichen-indefinite Koeffzienten-Matrizen h() zugelassen sind. Als ein Resultat werden selbstadjungierte indefinite Differentialoperatoren div h() grad mit homogenen Dirichlet oder Neumann Randbedingungen konstruiert. Beispiele solcher Art sind Operatoren die in der Modellierung von optischen Metamaterialien auftauchen und links-indefinite Sturm-Liouville Operatoren.

The Importance of Quality LGBT Representation in Popular Television Shows: Orange Is the New Black and Orphan Black

Il seguente elaborato analizza l'importanza di un'adeguata rappresentazione di personaggi appartenenti allo spettro LGBT all'interno di programmi televisivi nordamericani, in particolare Orange Is The New Black e Orphan Black. Lo scopo della tesi è quello di provare l'importanza della rappresentazione nella costruzione dell'identità personale di ognuno, e nella lotta contro le discriminazioni di genere e orientamento sessuale. Le tesi si apre con un excursus teorico sul termine e il concetto di rappresentazione, soprattutto relativo all'ambito della televisione. Successivamente, vengono analizzati i vari tipi di rappresentazione all'interno nei due programmi televisivi presi in esame. La ricerca si conclude con una valutazione degli effetti e delle reazioni del pubblico a entrambi i telefilm e, infine, con alcune considerazioni personali.

Sviluppo di un sistema bci eeg-based per il controllo del movimento di un modello di arto superiore

Nel presente lavoro di tesi è stato sviluppato e testato un sistema BCI EEG-based che sfrutta la modulazione dei ritmi sensorimotori tramite immaginazione motoria della mano destra e della mano sinistra. Per migliorare la separabilità dei due stati mentali, in questo lavoro di tesi si è sfruttato l'algoritmo CSP (Common Spatial Pattern), in combinazione ad un classificatore lineare SVM. I due stati mentali richiesti sono stati impiegati per controllare il movimento (rotazione) di un modello di arto superiore a 1 grado di libertà, simulato sullo schermo. Il cuore del lavoro di tesi è consistito nello sviluppo del software del sistema BCI (basato su piattaforma LabVIEW 2011), descritto nella tesi. L'intero sistema è stato poi anche testato su 4 soggetti, per 6 sessioni di addestramento.

Ricostruzione delle sorgenti corticali da segnali EEG in task di discriminazione visiva: Effetto di training multisensoriale

I neuroni in alcune regioni del nostro cervello mostrano una risposta a stimoli multisensoriali (ad es. audio-visivi) temporalmente e spazialmente coincidenti maggiore della risposta agli stessi stimoli presi singolarmente (integrazione multisensoriale). Questa abilità può essere sfruttata per compensare deficit unisensoriali, attraverso training multisensoriali che promuovano il rafforzamento sinaptico all’interno di circuiti comprendenti le regioni multisensoriali stimolate. Obiettivo della presente tesi è stato quello di studiare quali strutture e circuiti possono essere stimolate e rinforzate da un training multisensoriale audio-visivo. A tale scopo, sono stati analizzati segnali elettroencefalografici (EEG) registrati durante due diversi task di discriminazione visiva (discriminazione della direzione di movimento e discriminazione di orientazione di una griglia) eseguiti prima e dopo un training audio-visivo con stimoli temporalmente e spazialmente coincidenti, per i soggetti sperimentali, o spazialmente disparati, per i soggetti di controllo. Dai segnali EEG di ogni soggetto è stato ricavato il potenziale evento correlato (ERP) sullo scalpo, di cui si è analizzata la componente N100 (picco in 140÷180 ms post stimolo) verificandone variazioni pre/post training mediante test statistici. Inoltre, è stata ricostruita l’attivazione delle sorgenti corticali in 6239 voxel (suddivisi tra le 84 ROI coincidenti con le Aree di Brodmann) con l’ausilio del software sLORETA. Differenti attivazioni delle ROI pre/post training in 140÷180 ms sono state evidenziate mediante test statistici. I risultati suggeriscono che il training multisensoriale abbia rinforzato i collegamenti sinaptici tra il Collicolo Superiore e il Lobulo Parietale Inferiore (nell’area Area di Brodmann 7), una regione con funzioni visuo-motorie e di attenzione spaziale.

Association of individual resting state EEG alpha frequency and cerebral blood flow

Cognitive task performance differs considerably between individuals. Besides cognitive capacities, attention might be a source of such differences. The individual's EEG alpha frequency (IAF) is a putative marker of the subject's state of arousal and attention, and was found to be associated with task performance and cognitive capacities. However, little is known about the metabolic substrate (i.e. the network) underlying IAF. Here we aimed to identify this network. Correlation of IAF with regional Cerebral Blood Flow (rCBF) in fifteen young healthy subjects revealed a network of brain areas that are associated with the modulation of attention and preparedness for external input, which are relevant for task execution. We hypothesize that subjects with higher IAF have pre-activated task-relevant networks and thus are both more efficient in the task-execution, and show a reduced fMRI-BOLD response to the stimulus, not because the absolute amount of activation is smaller, but because the additional activation by processing of external input is limited due to the higher baseline.

Peri-ictal correlation dynamics of high-frequency (80-200 Hz) intracranial EEG

To assess (1) how large-scale correlation of intracranial EEG signals in the high-frequency range (80-200Hz) evolves from the pre-ictal, through the ictal into the postictal state and (2) whether the contribution of local neuronal activity to large-scale EEG correlation differentiates epileptogenic from non-epileptogenic brain tissue.

EEG correlation and power during maintenance of wakefulness test after sleep-deprivation

To investigate whether there are any objective EEG characteristics that change significantly between specific time periods during maintenance of wakefulness test (MWT) and whether such changes are associated with the ability to appropriately communicate sleepiness.

Personal neglect-a disorder of body representation?

The cognitive mechanisms underlying personal neglect are not well known. One theory postulates that personal neglect is due to a disorder of contralesional body representation. In the present study, we have investigated whether personal neglect is best explained by impairments in the representation of the contralesional side of the body, in particular, or a dysfunction of the mental representation of the contralesional space in general. For this, 22 patients with right hemisphere cerebral lesions (7 with personal neglect, 15 without personal neglect) and 13 healthy controls have been studied using two experimental tasks measuring representation of the body and extrapersonal space. In the tasks, photographs of left and right hands as well as left and right rear-view mirrors presented from the front and the back had to be judged as left or right. Our results show that patients with personal neglect made more errors when asked to judge stimuli of left hands and left rear-view mirrors than either patients without personal neglect or healthy controls. Furthermore, regression analyses indicated that errors in interpreting left hands were the best predictor of personal neglect, while other variables such as extrapersonal neglect, somatosensory or motor impairments, or deficits in left extrapersonal space representation had no predictive value of personal neglect. These findings suggest that deficient body representation is the major mechanism underlying personal neglect.

Forbidden ordinal patterns of periictal intracranial EEG indicate deterministic dynamics in human epileptic seizures

Epileptic seizures typically reveal a high degree of stereotypy, that is, for an individual patient they are characterized by an ordered and predictable sequence of symptoms and signs with typically little variability. Stereotypy implies that ictal neuronal dynamics might have deterministic characteristics, presumably most pronounced in the ictogenic parts of the brain, which may provide diagnostically and therapeutically important information. Therefore the goal of our study was to search for indications of determinism in periictal intracranial electroencephalography (EEG) studies recorded from patients with pharmacoresistent epilepsy.