Cultural Biases in Public Service Delivery : Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Approach

What determines the share of public employment, at a given size of the State, in countries of similar levels of economic development? While the theoretical and empirical literature on this issue has mostly considered technical dimensions (efficiency and political considerations), this paper emphasizes the role of culture and quantifies it. We build a representative database for contracting choices of municipalities in Switzerland and exploit the discontinuity at the Swiss language border at identical actual set of policies and institutions to analyze the causal e↵ect of culture on the choice of how public services are provided. We find that French-speaking border municipalities are 50% less likely to contract with the private sector than their German-speaking adjacent municipalities. Technical dimensions are much smaller by comparison. This result points out that culture is a source of a potential bias that distorts the optimal choice for public service delivery. Systematic differences in the level of confidence in public administration and private companies potentially explain this discrepancy in private sector participation in public services provision.

Value added logistical support service. Part 1 : Trends and new concept model

The aim of `Valssi' study was to find out the service requirements in `business-to-business' (B2B) markets and to present a new logistics service concept, where the traditional logistics service is expanded with significant manufacturing and value addedfacilities. The traditional third-party logistics service providers are not necessarily able to offer services, which cover widely the needs of potential customers. The study has been outlined to spare part markets in metal industry. In the second phase of the Valssi-project the aim is to examine the economical conditions and potentiality of the new logistics business concept. This research report (Part 1) concentrates on examining current trends in global and domestic logistics markets. Based on detailed survey among the participating companies, the study presents basis for a new logistics business concept model. The developed concept consists of 12 different service modules, which are split into deeper details of processes. The integration of worldwide supplier and service provider network together with customer companies systems is a challenge. The report focuses on evaluating the requirements for the new business concept from the customer-companies point of view. The study paints an overall picture of distribution and service provider network including an abstract about the software and system integration possibilities. As a result of the survey, it can be concluded that thereis need for the new business concept among the participating companies, and a modular service concept meets the requirements of them, because the new sophisticated concept considers the specialities involved in spare part logistics in metal industry.

Value added logistical support service: logistiikan palveluiden tarjoajat Suomessa. osa 4

Tämä osatutkimus on VALSSI- tutkimusprojektin (Value Added Logistical Support Service) neljäs osavaihe. VALSSI- tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on ollut selvittää logistiikkapalveluiden vaatimuksia business-to-business (B2B) ympäristössä ja määrittää logistiikkapalveluiden palvelukonsepti, jossa perinteiset logistiikkapalvelut on laajennettu tuotannollisilla ja lisäarvoa tuottavilla palveluilla. Tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on ollut tuottaa ulkoistamista helpottavaa materiaalia erityisesti varastoinnin ja kuljetusten osalta. Edellisistä osavaiheista on saatavilla tutkimusraportit yliopiston Internet-sivuilta(www.lut.fi/tutkimus/valore). Tämän tutkimuksen tarkoituksena oli kartoittaa Suomessa toimivien logistiikkapalveluyritysten palvelutarjonta. Tutkimus on keskittynyt palveluntarjoajiin, jotka tarjoavat erikoistunutta logistiikkaa (mm. tuotannollisia palveluita, hankintoja ja pakkauspalveluita) asiakkailleen. Tutkimukseen osallistuneet yritykset olivat suomalaisia ja kansainvälisiä sekä kuljetuspalveluita tarjoavia että logistiikkapalveluyrityksiä sekä alihankkijoina/tukkureina toimivia palveluntarjoajia. Huomionarvoista onkin, että moni yrityksistä käytti markkinoilta saatavia kuljetuspalveluita eikä toiminut itse kuljetusoperaattorina. Logistiikkapalveluyrityksissä huomattiin eroavaisuuksia asiakaspalvelun laajuudessa, ICT strategioissa, hankintojen ja kotiinkutsujen organisoinnissa, tuotannollisissa palveluissa sekä paluulogistiikassa. Varsinaiset varastointipalvelut ovat homogeenisia ja varastointiin liittyvät pakkaamispalvelut ovat pääasiassasamankaltaisia. Markkinoilla toimivien tukkukauppiaiden logistiikkaprosessit eroavat perinteisistä palveluntarjoajista. Tukkurit hoitavat laajasti mm. asiakaspalvelua, teknistä tukea sekä erikoistuneita tuotannollisia palveluita. Nykypäivänä asiakkaat asettavat enemmän vaatimuksia logistiikkapalveluyrityksen prosesseille ja prosessien johtamiselle. Tulevaisuudessa Suomessa ja maailmalla toimivat logistiikkapalveluyritykset tulevat toimimaan yhteistyöverkoissa Itä- Euroopan maat ovat entistä suuremmassa roolissa uusia jakelukanavia ja palveluita mietittäessä. Jo nyt on huomattavissa, että asiakkaat vaativat logistiikan palvelutarjoajia tarjoamaan entistä monipuolisempia ja tuotteistetumpia palveluita.

Value added logistical support service: logistics cost structure and performance in the new concept. Part 3

The aim of this study is to present an Activity-Based Costing spreadsheet tool for analyzing the logistics costs. The tool can be used both by customer-companies and logistics service providers. The study discusses the influence of different activity models on costs. Additionally this paper discusses about the logistical performance across the total supply chain This study is carried out using ananalytical research approach and literature material has been used for supplementing the concerned research approach. Cost structure analysis was based on the theory of activity-based management. This study was outlined to spare part logistics in machine-shop industry. The outlines of logistics services and logisticalperformance discussed in this report are based on the new logistics business concept (LMS-concept), which has been presented earlier in the Valssi-project. Oneof the aims of this study is to increase awareness of different activity modelson logistics costs. The report paints an overall picture about the business environment and requirements for the new logistics concept.

Value added logistics in supply and demand chain. Smile. Part 2. eBusiness in a service business. Case: A maintenance and operations network in forest industry

VVALOSADE is a research project of professor Anita Lukka's VALORE research team in the Lappeenranta University of Technology. The VALOSADE includes the ELO technology program of Tekes. SMILE is one of four subprojects of the VALOSADE. The SMILE study focuses on the case of the company network that is composed of small and micro-sized mechanical maintenance service providers and forest industry as large-scale customers. The basic principle of the SMILE study is the communication and ebusiness in supply and demand networks. The aim of the study is to develop ebusiness strategy, ebusiness model and e-processes among the SME local service providers, and onthe other hand, between the local service provider network and the forest industry customers in a maintenance and operations service business. A literature review, interviews and benchmarking are used as research methods in this qualitative case study. The first SMILE report, 'Ebusiness between Global Company and Its Local SME Supplier Network', concentrated on creating background for the SMILE study by studying general trends of ebusiness in supply chains and networks of different industries. This second phase of the study concentrates on case network background, such as business relationships, information systems and business objectives; core processes in maintenance and operations service network; development needs in communication among the network participants; and ICT solutions to respond needs in changing environment. In the theory part of the report, different ebusiness models and frameworks are introduced. Those models and frameworks are compared to empirical case data. From that analysis of the empirical data, therecommendations for the development of the network information system are derived. In process industry such as the forest industry, it is crucial to achieve a high level of operational efficiency and reliability, which sets up great requirements for maintenance and operations. Therefore, partnerships or strategic alliances are needed between the network participants. In partnerships and alliances, deep communication is important, and therefore the information systems in the network also are critical. Communication, coordination and collaboration will increase in the case network in the future, because network resources must be optimised to improve competitive capability of the forest industry customers and theefficiency of their service providers. At present, ebusiness systems are not usual in this maintenance network. A network information system among the forest industry customers and their local service providers actually is the only genuinenetwork information system in this total network. However, the utilisation of that system has been quite insignificant. The current system does not add value enough either to the customers or to the local service providers. At present, thenetwork information system is the infomediary that share static information forthe network partners. The network information system should be the transaction intermediary, which integrates internal processes of the network companies; the network information system, which provides common standardised processes for thelocal service providers; and the infomediary, which share static and dynamic information on right time, on right partner, on right costs, on right format and on right quality. This study provides recommendations how to develop this system in the future to add value to the network companies. Ebusiness scenarios, vision, objectives, strategies, application architecture, ebusiness model, core processes and development strategy must be considered when the network information system will be developed in the next development step. The core processes in the case network are demand/capacity management, customer/supplier relationship management, service delivery management, knowledge management and cash flow management. Most benefits from ebusiness solutions come from the electrifying of operational level processes, such as service delivery management and cash flow management.

Value added logistical support service Part 2. Outsourcing process of spare part logistics in metal industry

The aim of this research study was to find out guidelines for outsourcing of logistics processes. The study was outlined to spare parts and `business-to-business' (B2B) markets in metal industry. This study can be applied as a manual for outsourcing especially warehousing and transportation activities. The study also touches other important areas of spare part logistics like manufacturing, customer service, procurement, quality control, reverse and recycling logistics, logistics technologies and valueadded services. The method of study consisted of three areas. Firstly exchanging views with logistics experts in participating companies, and secondly compiling material based on author's practical experience in logistics business with several international and domestic logistics service providers and vendors. Thirdlythe study includes also references to literature material. Due to the fact thatthe outsourcing of logistics functions can be handled widely and from differentpoint of views, in this study it is concentrated mainly on giving general levelguidelines for defining logistics strategy, hints both for tendering process and implementation project, and not forgetting the aftercare of business partnership.

Value added logistical support service: logistiikan palveluiden tarjoajat Suomessa. osa 4

Tämä osatutkimus on VALSSI- tutkimusprojektin (Value Added Logistical Support Service) neljäs osavaihe. VALSSI- tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on ollut selvittää logistiikkapalveluiden vaatimuksia business-to-business (B2B) ympäristössä ja määrittää logistiikkapalveluiden palvelukonsepti, jossa perinteiset logistiikkapalvelut on laajennettu tuotannollisilla ja lisäarvoa tuottavilla palveluilla. Tutkimuksen tarkoituksena on ollut tuottaa ulkoistamista helpottavaa materiaalia erityisesti varastoinnin ja kuljetusten osalta. Edellisistä osavaiheista on saatavilla tutkimusraportit yliopiston Internet-sivuilta(www.lut.fi/tutkimus/valore). Tämän tutkimuksen tarkoituksena oli kartoittaa Suomessa toimivien logistiikkapalveluyritysten palvelutarjonta. Tutkimus on keskittynyt palveluntarjoajiin, jotka tarjoavat erikoistunutta logistiikkaa (mm. tuotannollisia palveluita, hankintoja ja pakkauspalveluita) asiakkailleen. Tutkimukseen osallistuneet yritykset olivat suomalaisia ja kansainvälisiä sekä kuljetuspalveluita tarjoavia että logistiikkapalveluyrityksiä sekä alihankkijoina/tukkureina toimivia palveluntarjoajia. Huomionarvoista onkin, että moni yrityksistä käytti markkinoilta saatavia kuljetuspalveluita eikä toiminut itse kuljetusoperaattorina. Logistiikkapalveluyrityksissä huomattiin eroavaisuuksia asiakaspalvelun laajuudessa, ICT strategioissa, hankintojen ja kotiinkutsujen organisoinnissa, tuotannollisissa palveluissa sekä paluulogistiikassa. Varsinaiset varastointipalvelut ovat homogeenisia ja varastointiin liittyvät pakkaamispalvelut ovat pääasiassasamankaltaisia. Markkinoilla toimivien tukkukauppiaiden logistiikkaprosessit eroavat perinteisistä palveluntarjoajista. Tukkurit hoitavat laajasti mm. asiakaspalvelua, teknistä tukea sekä erikoistuneita tuotannollisia palveluita. Nykypäivänä asiakkaat asettavat enemmän vaatimuksia logistiikkapalveluyrityksen prosesseille ja prosessien johtamiselle. Tulevaisuudessa Suomessa ja maailmalla toimivat logistiikkapalveluyritykset tulevat toimimaan yhteistyöverkoissa Itä- Euroopan maat ovat entistä suuremmassa roolissa uusia jakelukanavia ja palveluita mietittäessä. Jo nyt on huomattavissa, että asiakkaat vaativat logistiikan palvelutarjoajia tarjoamaan entistä monipuolisempia ja tuotteistetumpia palveluita.