Intelin, Toshiban ja Samsungin patenttipolitiikka 1990-luvun alusta lähtien

Tämä kandidaatintyö käsittelee puolijohdeteollisuusyritysten Intelin, Toshiban ja Samsungin patenttipolitiikkaa 1990-luvun alusta lähtien. Työn tarkoituksena on antaa vastauksia siihen, miksi patentointiaktiivisuudet (patenttiaineiston määrät) vaihtelevat niin suuresti yrityksestä toiseen saman alan sisällä. Yrityksiä tarkastellaan erityisesti kotimaidensa suhteen. Patentointiaktiivisuuden analyysissä käytetään IPC-luokittain jaoteltua patenttiaineistoa sekä patentointiin liittyviä artikkeleita ja kirjallisuutta. Yritysten sijainti ja paikallinen yrityskulttuuri vaikuttavat merkittävästi yritysten patenttipolitiikkaan. Vertailuyrityksillä on omat arvot ja toimintatavat, joilla patentointiin liittyviä asioita hoidetaan. Puolijohdeteollisuudessa ja yleisesti informaatioteknologiateollisuudessa, joissa käytetään paljon patentointia, on tärkeää, että maan johto suhtautuu positiivisesti immateriaalioikeuksiin. Kyseisen alan merkitys maiden hyvinvoinnille kasvaa koko ajan. Empiria-aineiston mukaan Intelin patentit ovat eteen- ja taaksepäin viittausten perusteella laadukkaimpia. 1990-luvulla Etelä-Korea panosti suuresti immateriaalioikeuksien kehittämiseen, mikä näkyy Samsungin patenttimäärän nousuna. Samsungilla on vertailuyrityksistä eniten patentteja, mutta ne ovat heikkolaatuisimpia. Toshiban patentit eivät saavuta määrällisesti Intelin taakse- ja eteenpäinviittauksia. Laadullisesti Toshiban patentit ovat kuitenkin parempia kuin Samsungin patentit. Kaikkiaan patentointi on lisääntynyt 1990-luvulla lähtien muun muassa parantuneen patenttisuojan ja helpottuneiden hakuprosessien ansiosta. Aasiassa on yleisempää käyttää strategista patentointia, muun muassa portfolion maksimointia. Yhdysvalloissa suhtaudutaan patentointiin enemmän taloudelliselta kannalta, kun taas puolestaan Aasiassa t&k-toiminta on pitkäjänteisempää.

Verkostomaisen asiantuntijayhteisön sopimusverkko

Tutkielmassa kartoitettiin avoimen innovoinnin menetelmin toimivan asiantuntijayhteisön keskeiset oikeudelliset ongelmakentät erään aloittavan yrityksen näkökulmasta. Näkökulmaa pyrittiin laajentamaan sovellettavaksi myös muihin avoimen innovoinnin hankkeisiin. Tutkimuksen tavoitteena on antaa verkoston avainhenkilöille riittävästi tietoa siitä, miten näitä osa-alueita voidaan hallita. Pakottavat työoikeudelliset normit voivat tulla vahingossa voimaan projektityössä ja synnyttää työsuhteen. Työsuhteen status vaikuttaa voimakkaasti myös patenttioikeuksien saamiseen verkostoyhteisön käyttöön. Yrityssalaisuuksien monitahoinen hallinta on myös keskeisessä asemassa verkoston toiminnassa. Työsuhteen syntyminen on hallittavissa oikein toimien, mutta aineettoman omaisuuden sekä yrityssalaisuuksien monimuotoisuuksien vuoksi ne on hyvin haastavaa ennakoivasti hallita.

Development of research networks : the case of social capital

The aim of this study is to explore how a new concept appears inscientific discussion and research, how it diffuses to other fields and out of the scientific communities, and how the networks are formed around the concept. Text and terminology take the interest of a reader in the digital environment. Texts create networks where the terminology used is dependent on the ideas, viewsand paradigms of the field. This study is based mainly on bibliographic data. Materials for bibliometric studies have been collected from different databases. The databases are also evaluated and their quality and coverage are discussed. The thesauri of those databases that have been selected for a more in depth study have also been evaluated. The material selected has been used to study how long and in which ways an innovative publication, which can be seen as a milestone in a specific field, influences the research. The concept that has been chosen as a topic for this research is Social Capital, because it has been a popular concept in different scientific fields as well as in everyday speech and the media. It seemed to be a `fashion concept´ that appeared in different situations at the Millennium. The growth and diffusion of social capital publications has been studied. The terms connected with social capital in different fields and different stages of the development have also been analyzed. The methods that have been used in this study are growth and diffusion analysis, content analysis, citation analysis, coword analysis and cocitation analysis. One method that can be used tounderstand and to interpret results of these bibliometric studies is to interview some key persons, who are known to have a gatekeeper position in the diffusion of the concept. Thematic interviews with some Finnish researchers and specialists that have influenced the diffusion of social capital into Finnish scientificand social discussions provide background information. iv The Milestone Publications on social capital have been chosen and studied. They give answers to the question "What is Social Capital?" By comparing citations to Milestone Publications with the growth of all social capital publications in a database, we can drawconclusions about the point at which social capital became generally approved `tacit knowledge´. The contribution of the present study lies foremost in understanding the development of network structures around a new concept that has diffused in scientific communities and also outside them. The network means both networks of researchers, networks of publications and networks of concepts that describe the research field. The emphasis has been on the digital environment and onthe socalled information society that we are now living in, but in this transitional stage, the printed publications are still important and widely used in social sciences and humanities. The network formation is affected by social relations and informal contacts that push new ideas. This study also gives new information about using different research methods, like bibliometric methods supported by interviews and content analyses. It is evident that interpretation of bibliometric maps presupposes qualitative information and understanding of the phenomena under study.

Working Capital Management: a Bibliometric Study

This thesis is a study of articles published in scientific journals about working capital management using bibliometric methods. The study was restricted to articles published in 1990–2010 that deal with the whole working capital management topic not a single sub-area of it. Working capital is defined as current assets minus current liabilities; sometimes also a definition of inventory plus accounts receivable minus accounts payable is used. The data was retrieved from the databases ISI Web of Science and Sciverse Scopus. Articles about working capital management were found 23. Content analysis, statistical analysis and citation analysis was performed to the articles. The most cited articles found in citation analysis were also analyzed by nearly same methods. This study found that scientific research of working capital management seems not to be concentrated to specific persons, organizations or journals. The originality and novelty in many articles is low. Many articles studied relation between working capital management and profitability in firms or working capital management practices of firms using statistical analyses. Data in articles was firms of all sizes, except in developing economies only big firms were used. Interesting areas for future research could be surveys made about working capital management practices in firms, finding of best practices, tools for working capital management, inventing or improving alternative views to working capital management like process-oriented view and firm or industry specific studies.

Escaping the flybottle: solipsism and method in Wittgenstein's Philosophical Remarks

The paper supports a dialectical interpretation of Wittgenstein's method focusing on the analysis of the conditions of experience presented in his Philosophical Remarks. By means of a close reading of some key passages dealing with solipsism I will try to lay bare their self-subverting character: the fact that they amount to miniature dialectical exercises offering specific directions to pass from particular pieces of disguised nonsense to corresponding pieces of patent nonsense. Yet, in order to follow those directions one needs to allow oneself to become simultaneously tempted by and suspicious of their all-too-evident "metaphysical tone" - a tone which, as we shall see, is particularly manifest in those claims purporting to state what can or cannot be the case, and, still more particularly, those purporting to state what can or cannot be done in language or thought, thus leading to the view that there are some (determinate) things which are ineffable or unthinkable. I conclude by suggesting that in writing those remarks Wittgenstein was still moved by an ethical project, which gets conspicuously displayed in these reiterations of his attempts to cure the readers (and himself) from some of the temptations expressed by solipsism.

Lääkevaihdon ja viitehintajärjestelmän vaikutukset patenttisuojattujen lääkevalmisteiden kohtuullisen tukkuhinnan vahvistamismenettelyyn

Pro gradu-tutkielman ensisijaisena tavoitteena oli selvittää, millaisia muutoksia lääkevaihto ja lääkkeiden viitehintajärjestelmä ovat aiheuttaneet patenttisuojattujen lääkevalmisteiden kohtuullisen tukkuhinnan vahvista-mismenettelyyn. Tätä menettelyä koskevat säännökset sisältyvät sairausvakuutuslain 6. lukuun, joten tutkimuksessa pyrittiin selvittämään kyseisen luvun soveltamista ja siinä mahdollisesti tapahtuneita muutoksia. Lääkevaihto otettiin Suomessa käyttöön 1.4.2003 ja viitehintajärjestelmä 1.4.2009. Lääkevalmisteiden hinnat ovat laskeneet niiden myötä merkittävästi. Tutkimusaineiston muodostivat 241 lääkkeiden hintalautakunnan sairausvakuutuskorvattavuutta ja kohtuullista tukkuhintaa koskevaa päätöstä vuosilta 2000-2010. Lisäksi käytössä oli muita päätöksiin liittyviä dokumentteja. Tutkimusaineisto lääkevaihdon käyttöönottoa edeltäneeltä ajalta jäi niukaksi. Tutkimuksen keskeiset havainnot liittyvätkin nimenomaan viitehintajärjestelmän käyttöönottoon. Nämä havainnot kuvaavat sitä, millaiset muutokset kohtuullisen tukkuhinnan vahvistamisessa ovat johtaneet patenttisuojattujen lääkevalmisteiden hintojen laskuun.

Notes on Emerging Technologies

This dissertation considers the impact of technology foresight in innovation within the context of a technology driven development. The main hypothesis made was that by using different methods of foresight in the industry level significant value could be created. The question was approached through a case study in portable fuel cell technology. The theoretical background of the study draws from Innovation, Product Development, Management of Technology, and Technology Foresight. The connection within the topics is made by analyzing foresight, not in a policy view as often done in Europe, but in a micro-level. Focusing mostly on how a technology driven development scenario could be analyzed. The study is based on a bibliometric, extrapolation and patent analysis within the context of a case study. In addition, a large two-year Delphi study was conducted. The study was finalized with a scenario work on the future possibilities of the case study technology. Original publications also consider several methodological issues. In the context of the case study, the study questions the practicality of establishing a portable fuel cell technology in Finland showing several impractical assumptions has been made. In a more conceptual level, the study makes notions on two underlying factors: policy-push technologies and growth of data. Policy-push questions in which level a policy effort towards a single technology is practical. The European foresight effort is more directed towards policy decisions in contrast to US foresight, which is to some extent corporate driven. Although the policy-based foresight has produced significant results in the European context, policy led efforts towards a single technology are challenging. Growth of data argues on the challenges produced by the large-scale application of quantitative measures of foresight. Bibliometric studies and trend extrapolations have been taken advantage of the increasing number of databases made available, and used these as the basis for forecasts. However, the relationship with actual development and quantitative evidence is still unproven.

Apple, Nokia and RIM – Rivalry and Co-operation between Three Mobile Phone Corporations

The purpose of this paper is to gather enough evidence to speculate the future of Nokia, Rim and Apple. The thesis goes over the history, current events and business model of each company. This paper includes differences between the companies and co-operation and rivalry, such as patent infringement cases. The study is limited to smartphones and their future. The result of this study is that Apple will continue its steady increase in market share, while Nokia will first decrease and after the launch of the Windows Phone it will rise again. RIM‟s result has not been as good as in past years and it has lost market share. The decrease of share price may lead to acquisition by a company interested in RIM technology.

Convergence in Industry Evolution

The objective of the thesis is to enhance understanding of the evolution of convergence. Previous research has shown that the technological interfaces between distinct industries are one of the major sources of new radical cross-industry innovations. Despite the fact that convergence in industry evolution has attracted a substantial managerial interest, the conceptual confusion within the field of convergence exists. Firstly, this study clarifies the convergence phenomenon and its impact to industry evolution. Secondly, the study creates novel patent analysis methods to analyze technological convergence and provide tools for anticipating the early stages of convergence. Overall the study combines the industry evolution perspective and the convergence view of industrial evolution. The theoretical background for the study consists of the industry life cycle theories, technology evolution, and technological trajectories. The study links several important concepts in analyzing industry evolution, technological discontinuities, path-dependency, technological interfaces as a source of industry transformation, and the evolutionary stagesof convergence. Based on reviewing the literature a generic understanding of industry transformation and industrial dynamics was generated. In the convergence studies, the theoretical basis is in the discussion of different convergence types and their impacts on industry evolution, and in anticipating and monitoring the stages of convergence. The study is divided in two parts. The first part gives a general overview, and the second part comprises eight research publications. Our case study is based historically on two very distinct industries of the paper and electronics companies as a test environment to evaluate the importance of emerging business sectors and technological convergence as a source of industry transformation. Both qualitative and quantitative research methodology are utilized. The results of this study reveal that technological convergence and complementary innovations from different fields have significant effect to the emerging new business sector formation. The patent-based indicators in the analysis of technological convergence can be utilized on analyzing technology competition, capability and competence development, knowledge accumulation, knowledge spill-overs, and technology-based industry transformation. The patent-based indicators can provide insights to the future competitive environment. Results and conclusions from empirical part seem not be in conflict with real observations in the industry.

Intellectual Property Management in a Small Company

Opinnäytetyö keskittyi kriittisiin tapahtumiin, joita on tullut yhtiön tai sen edeltävän yhtiön, joka oli Mobile Screen TV – 4 ALL, tekemien aikaisempien patenttihakemusten yhteydessä . Tutkimus vertasi ja evaluoi yhtiön aikaisemmin tekemien keksintöjen suojausta. Toisaalta opinnäytetyön päämäärä oli tutkia ja selvittää monitapaus-menetelmällä yhtiön aikaisempia keksintöjä ja miten aineettoman oikeuden suojaus toteutui prosessien eri vaiheissa. Tämä päättötyötutkielma vei loppuun asti erittäin suuren patenttien ja hyödyllisyysmallien hakemusten tutkimuksen. LH Communications Oy on tehnyt monia niistä, mutta tutkimus sisälsi myös joitakin kilpailijoiden hakemuksia. Tässä tutkimuksessa oli kaksi pääkysymystä. Miten pieni yhtiö voisi suojella heidän uusia ideoitaan ja keksintöjään ja myös samalla pitää yhtiön talouden hyvällä tasolla. Tämä tutkimus käytti The Critical Incidents Technique (CIT), joka keskittyy kriittisiin tapahtumiin, selvittääkseen sopivia menetelmiä pienelle yhtiölle siitä, miten suojella uusia ajatuksia, ideoita ja keksintöjä ja samanaikaisesti olla tuottava niiden kanssa. Tutkimuksemme käsitteli kaikenlaisia tarvittavia käytäntöjä pienessä yhtiössä ja päähuomio pienessä yhtiössä tulee olla omien keksintöjen suojaamisessa. Paras suojaus on tehdä patentteja, mutta se tulee maksamaan hyvin paljon koko tapahtumasarjan aikana.

Patenttien vaikutus suomalaisten pörssiyritysten markkina-arvoon - reaalioptiosovellutus

Tutkielman tavoitteena oli tutkia onko patenteilla positiivinen vaikutus yrityksen markkina-arvoon. Aihetta tutkittiin reaalioptionäkökulmasta: miten patentit voidaan nähdä reaalioptioiden ilmentymänä ja millainen vaikutus niillä on yrityksen suoriutumiseen. Lisäksi tutkittiin onko patenttien vaikutuksessa toimialakohtaisia eroja. Tavoitteena oli myös selvittää onko patenttien vaikutus erilainen talouden eri suhdanteissa. Empiriana tutkimuksessa olivat suomalaiset pörssiyritykset ja niiden Suomeen myönnetyt patentit. Tutkittavana ajanjaksona oli 2001–2010. Tutkimusongelmista johdettuja hypoteeseja testattiin regressioanalyysien avulla. Selitettävänä muuttujana oli yrityksen Tobin’s q ja selittävänä muuttujana yrityksen voimassa olleiden patenttien ja tasearvon suhdeluku. Kontrollimuuttujina käytettiin vuotta ja toimialaa. Tulokseksi saatiin, että patenteilla on ollut positiivinen vaikutus suomalaisten pörssiyritysten markkina-arvoon 2000-luvulla. Varsinkin teknologian ja perusmateriaalien toimialoilla yhteys oli vahvempi kuin muilla toimialoilla. Saadut tulokset ovat yhdenmukaisia aiempien tutkimusten kanssa. Aineiston erityispiirteet toivat tutkimukseen omat haasteensa, jotka vaikuttivat muun muassa toimialaryhmien muodostamiseen sekä makroekonomisen ympäristön merkityksen tutkimiseen.

Military crisis management in the next decade (2020-2030) : inducing consent or relying on compliance?

The most outstanding conceptual challenge of modern crisis management is the principle of consent. It is not a problem only at the operational level - it challenges the entire decision-making structures of crisis management operations. In post-cold war times and especially in the 21st century, there has been a transition from peacekeeping with limited size and scope towards large and complex peace operations. This shift has presented peace operations with a dilemma. How to balance between maintaining consent for peace operations, whilst being able to use military force to coerce those attempting to wreck peace processes? To address such a dilemma, this research aims to promote understanding, on what can be achieved by military crisis management operations (peace support operations) in the next decade. The research concentrates on the focal research question: Should military components induce consent or rely on the compliance of conflicting parties in crisis management operations of the next decade (2020 – 2030)? The focus is on military – political strategic level considerations, and especially on the time before political decisions to commit to a crisis management operation. This study does not focus on which actor or organisation should intervene. The framework of this thesis derives from the so called ‘peacebuilding space’, the scope of peace operations and spoiler theory. Feasibility of both peace enforcement and peacekeeping in countering future risk conditions are analysed in this framework. This future-orientated qualitative research uses the Delphi-method with a panel of national and international experts. Citation analysis supports identification of relevant reference material, which consists of contemporary literature, the Delphi-questionnaires and interviews. The research process followed three main stages. In the first stage, plausible future scenarios and risk conditions were identified with the Delphi-panel. In the second stage, operating environments for peace support operations were described and consequent hypotheses formulated. In the third stage, these hypotheses were tested on the Delphi-panel. The Delphi-panel is sufficiently wide and diverse to produce plausible yet different insights. The research design utilised specifically military crisis management and peace operations theories. This produced various and relevant normative considerations. Therefore, one may argue that this research; which is based on accepted contemporary theory, hypotheses derived thereof and utilising an expert panel, contributes to the realm of peace support operations. This research finds that some degree of peace enforcement will be feasible and necessary in at least the following risk conditions: failed governance; potential spillover of ethnic, religious, ideological conflict; vulnerability of strategic chokepoints and infrastructures in ungoverned spaces; as well as in territorial and extra-territorial border disputes. In addition, some form of peace enforcement is probably necessary in risk conditions pertaining to: extremism of marginalised groups; potential disputes over previously uninhabited and resource-rich territories; and interstate rivalry. Furthermore, this research finds that peacekeeping measures will be feasible and necessary in at least risk conditions pertaining to: potential spillover of ethnic, religious, ideological conflict; uncontrolled migration; consequences from environmental catastrophes or changes; territorial and extra-territorial border disputes; and potential disputes over previously uninhabited and resource-rich territories. These findings are all subject to both generic and case specific preconditions that must exist for a peace support operation. Some deductions could be derived from the research findings. Although some risk conditions may appear illogical, understanding the underlying logic of a conflict is fundamental to understanding transition in crisis management. Practitioners of crisis management should possess cognizance of such transition. They must understand how transition should occur from threat to safety, from conflict to stability – and so forth. Understanding transition is imperative for managing the dynamic evolution of preconditions, which begins at the outset of a peace support operation. Furthermore, it is pertinent that spoilers are defined from a peace process point of view. If spoilers are defined otherwise, it changes the nature of an operation towards war, where the logic is breaking the will of an enemy - and surrender. In peace support operations, the logic is different: actions towards spoilers are intended to cause transition towards consent - not defeat. Notwithstanding future developments, history continues to provide strategic education. However, the distinction is that the risk conditions occur in novel futures. Hence, lessons learned from the past should be fitted to the case at hand. This research shows compelling evidence that swaying between intervention optimism and pessimism is not substantiated. Both peace enforcement and peacekeeping are sine qua non for successful military crisis management in the next decade.

Tuulivoimateollisuuden tarkastelu patenttianalyysiä hyödyntäen

Työssä luodaan katsaus tuulivoiman käyttöön historiassa sekä tuulivoiman hyödyntämiseen sähköntuotantoon nykyaikaisessa yhteiskunnassa. Lisäksi esitellään modernin kolmilapaisen tuuliturbiinin tekniikkaa. Työssä tarkastellaan kolmen suuren tuulivoimaloita valmistavien yrityksien patentointiaktiivisutta aikavälillä 2000–2010 ja patenttien lukumäärässä, maantieteellisessä vaihtelussa, tyypissä ja luokissa esiintyviä trendejä. Näiden pohjalta luodaan kokonaiskuva tuulivoiman teollisuuden kehityksestä 2000-luvun alussa ja odotetuista tulevaisuuden näkymistä. Vuosituhannen vaihteen jälkeen patentointiaktiivisuus on kasvanut tuulivoimateknologiayrityksillä. Etenkin vuonna 2007 havaitaan piikki patenttien lukumäärässä. Patentointitoiminta on keskittynyt Eurooppaan, Pohjois-Amerikkaan sekä Kiinaan. Tuulivoimateknologian voidaan olettaa kehittyvän sekä koossa että kustannustehokkuudessa.

Síndrome de Prune Belly

Prune Belly Syndrome is a fetal uropathy of unknown etiology with incidence of 1/35000 to 1/50000 alive been born, characterized by a classical triad: abdominal musculature congenital deficiency, bilateral criptorquidia and urinary tract malformations. The authors present a case of this rare pathology associated with a patent urachus. After complementary exams confirmed urinary tract alterations (bilateral ureterohidronefrosis and vesicoureteral reflux degree 5, besides urinary infection), the surgical approach was vesicostomy to decrease urinary infections and sepsis. Definitve surgery should be accomplished around the 12th month of life. Nowadays, the child is asymptomatic , with follow-up every two months, with return consultation bimonthly.

Excisão laparoscópica de úraco remanescente em um adulto

Abnormalities of the urachus in adults are uncommon. Urachal tract remnants, which abnormally remain patent, may be responsible for abdominal pain and infection. The persistence of the urachus can lead to several abnormalities; and the patent urachus is one of the less frequent. A 25-year-old man presented a fluid secretion from the umbilicus that bled once and had three previous episodes of abdominal pain. Magnetic Resonance Imaging revealed a patent urachus, which was confirmed by anatomopathological examination. The goal of this article is to report an urachal excision in a young adult with persistence of a patent urachus fully performed laparoscopically.