De la dignité de la vie à la dignité de la personne humaine : quelques distinctions dans le débat sur les techniques génétiques

Dans les discussions sur les biotechnologies, l’argument de la dignité humaine conduit souvent à l’impasse. Le philosophe et sociologue allemand, Jürgen Habermas, craint que le débat, qui s’est ouvert récemment autour de la recherche sur les embryons, les diagnostics prénatal et préimplantatoire, et le clonage, se polarise, de nouveau comme c’était déjà le cas, en Allemand et dans les autres pays occidentaux, au sujet de l’avortement. La seule façon de sortir de cette polarisation – et c’est là un des apports importants de Habermas – est de distinguer nettement la dignité humaine, d’une part et d’autre part, la dignité de la vie humaine. D’un point de vue éthique et juridique, l’argument de la dignité humaine ne saurait nécessairement s’étendre au fœtus ou embryon. Car, la dignité humaine est liée à la symétrie qui détermine la relation liant les membres d’une communauté morale. Elle n’est pas un fait naturel, une propriété qu’on a par nature comme l’intelligence ou le fait d’avoir les yeux bleus. Au contraire, la dignité humaine désigne cette «inviolabilité» qui ne peut avoir de sens que dans les relations interpersonnelles de reconnaissance mutuelle et dans un rapport d’égal à égal des personnes entre elles. Néanmoins, le fœtus ou l’embryon peut, d’une certaine manière, échapper à notre contrôle et disposition en référence à la dignité que nous devons à la vie de l’espèce humaine. De ce point de vue, nos conceptions modernes de la vie anté-personnelle et la façon dont nous voulons nous comporter par rapport à cette vie forment, pour ainsi dire, un environnement éthique stabilisant de l’espèce pour la morale rationnelle des sujets de droits moraux.

Quand les gendarmes font la loi : la pénalisation du droit des réfugiés au Canada

La recherche analyse le traitement réservé aux demandeurs d'asile au Canada.Plus spécialement, elle se penche sur l'interprétation et l’application de l’article 7 de la Charte canadienne des droits et libertés. La réflexion observe que la mise en œuvre des droits fondamentaux des revendicateurs du statut de réfugié est affectée, selon les époques, par des considérations à dominance « humanitaires » [arrêt Singh, 1985] ou, comme cela est le cas depuis le 11 septembre 2001, par des impératifs allégués de sécurité nationale [arrêt Suresh, 2002]. D’un point de vue analytique, la thèse considère que lorsqu'il s'agit de protéger des populations vulnérables – ce que le Canada s'est juridiquement engagé à faire – le droit public ne peut pas se limiter à la communauté de ses propres membres, citoyens et résidents. D'ailleurs, la Charte reconnaît la protection de ses droits fondamentaux à « toute personne » du fait de sa seule qualité de personne, qu'elle soit ou non citoyenne et la garde des abus. Des exceptions aux droits reconnus à l’article 7 doivent être considérées à la mesure du principe démocratique qui guide nos sociétés. Sur ce fondement, l’analyse interroge l’argumentation et les motivations de certaines décisions judiciaires et législatives qui ont déconsidérées les implications de notions porteuses de valeurs impératives, telles que l'équité, la dignité humaine, la liberté et la sécurité de l'individu, en privilégiant les intérêts étatiques conforment à la conception classique de la souveraineté.

“Can’t you at least die with a little dignity?” The Right to Die Debates and Normative Dignity

Article

La instrumentalización del derecho fundamental a la salud a través de la prestación del servicio público

La salud además de ser un derecho fundamental también es un servicio público, el cual debe brindarse adecuadamente en términos de oportunidad, cobertura y calidad. Al entender la salud como un derecho fundamental autónomo, significa, que requiere por parte del Estado la garantía de su goce efectivo para todos los habitantes del territorio nacional, el cual es susceptible de limitaciones, con sujeción a los principios de eficiencia, universalidad y solidaridad, dentro del marco de la dignidad humana. Por otro lado, el análisis de la salud como un servicio público puede abordarse desde la prestación del mismo por parte de los particulares, lo que significa analizar la figura de la descentralización por colaboración en un Estado Unitario, lo que implica: 1. La actuación de particulares en la prestación del servicio público, previa autorización legal 2. La implementación de sistemas de control, inspección y vigilancia, por parte del Estado sobre dicha prestación. 3. La expedición de instrumentos de regulación y reglamentación normativa que regulen la prestación del servicio público de salud. A través de la interpretación integradora podemos afirmar que la salud es un derecho de la persona que se materializa mediante la prestación de un servicio público de carácter obligatorio. Es decir, los servicios públicos se constituyen como instrumentos para garantizar el logro de la plena vigencia y eficacia de los derechos constitucionales y por ende de la realización de los fines del Estado Social de Derecho.

El discurso de los DDHH como herramienta para justificar el embargo económico de EEUU a Cuba, 1993 – 2001

El tema central de esta monografía, es el ejercicio de construcción discursiva en torno a los Derechos Humanos (DDHH) que tiene lugar en el periodo de 1993 – 2001 con ocasión de la aprobación de la Ley Helms-Burton en los EEUU. Se trata de considerar los elementos en virtud de los cuales los DDHH pueden instrumentalizarse y politizarse con fines de reivindicación que no necesariamente coinciden con la esencia misma que los caracteriza. Ello, empleando como base teórica la proposición metodológica del Análisis Crítico del Discurso y la hegemonía, como concepto de imposición moral, intelectual y politica, de conformidad con la postulación teórica desarrollada por Antonio Gramsci.

A posição jurídica do recluso face à reforma penitenciária de 2009

Since the beginning of the last century several laws have gradually reformed the prison system. In spite of their adequacy during the periods of their enforcement some of the measures have never been put into practice. Nevertheless it is worth mentioning the legislator main concern regarding the taking care of prisoners, namely with the Prison Reform of 1979 pioneer in the building of the new European prison law. The Law no. 115/2009 of 12th of October currently in force ensures the prisoners’ rights towards the administration by reformulating their legal status and by reinforcing their privileges when serving prison sentence. Those rights are focused on the human dignity and on the effective cooperation with the community.

O desafio de reconhecimento do sujeito cego em espaços públicos de representação

This work is funded based on the uneasiness with the concept of State as a public machine for development. Of State as a public machine to deliberate valid practices for valid methods and to limit valid subjects in valid spaces. In midst of this specific context, this work dedicates itself to investigate the following research problem: the mistaken recognition of the blind subject in public spaces of representation. For this reason, it was addressed the following question: how the blind subject is recognized in public spaces of representation? To answer the question, it was necessary to contextualize how the blind subject is being recognized in various public spaces of representation. In the international scope, the human rights debate held between the National States was analyzed (BRAND, 2005; KOERNER, 2002; UN, 2006). In the national arena, constitutional rights, federal laws, public policies and institutions representing the blind subject were examined (CABRAL, 2008; SARAVIA, 2006). Finally, in a local context, the fundaments of the concept of citizen for the subject recognition were investigated (AGAMBEN, 2002; RORTY, 1999, DELEUZE AND GUATTARI, 1996). The methodology included reports of national and international representatives in the Lusophone Countries Meeting for Dissemination and Implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and, mainly, interviews with blind subjects. The data was processed by content analysis and was discussed based on the following categories: representation spaces; representation modes; representation amplitude; representation premises. The results show, regarding such spaces of representation, the growing importance of thinking the rights of persons with disabilities ¿ group in which belongs the blind subject ¿ as of the international and national scenario. However, the blind subjects announced alternative local spaces for representation: church, internet, radio, etc. Regarding the representation modes, the role of law and standards has been advocated specially in the human rights field. The importance of the cooperation between the States and the civil society to ensure, in practice, the rights achieved was also emphasized. But other forms of representation, directly linked to each interviewee¿ history, was important. Regarding the representation amplitude, there were arguments in defense of a conception of human dignity and freedom to all inhabitants of the globe. The lusophone event highlighted the concern of the cultural peculiarities of those involved in the meeting. The blind interviewees argued for citizenship as construction of instruments for freedom and autonomy, but recognized that this is not a clear desire between the blind people in general, and even less in society as a whole. With respect to the representation premises, the fundaments for the recognition of the blind subject were based on the primacy of reason at the expense of personal experimentation. Experimentation that serves as the foundation of a new form of recognition of the blind subject in public spaces of representation, one more interested in singularities, impenetrable by reason, unmovable to another, and which are irreducible to each subject. The final considerations suggest that if the State has a reason to be, this is not another than to offer instruments to manifest as many as the existential possibilities of the subject. This is the concept of State for development.

Gestão associada de prestação de serviço público jurisdicional nos juizados especiais federais

Por mais que a informatização esteja avançada (interligação por melO da rede internet de computadores entre os órgãos e entidades públicas pelo Estado), máquina alguma substituirá os dramas do homem contemporâneo, principalmente aqueles que sempre estiveram alijados da cidadania. Os problemas do homem, principalmente os hiposuficientes, dentro do caso concreto, nem sempre podem ser solucionados por máquinas distantes uma da outra e, o pior, em locais distantes, sem permitir o acesso direto ao ser humano que comanda a máquina. Esse cidadão, que tem no princípio da dignidade da pessoa humana sua maior proteção e garantia outorgada pelo Estado de Direito, tem o direito de ser tratado com dignidade pelo Estado que monopoliza a pacificação social através da jurisdição, principalmente quando o réu é o próprio Estado, como é o caso do subsistema dos Juizados Especiais Federais (os réus são a União, ou suas entidades autárquicas, ou empresas públicas federais). A humanização no atendimento do cidadão, que busca e deposita no Estado Judiciário (Federal), no subsistema do Juizado Especial Federal, sua última esperança na resposta de seus direitos violados pelo próprio Estado Administração (Federal), se materializará por uma nova proposta de prestação de serviço público - a unitariedade (concentração de todos os partícipes desse subsistema em um único local - Judiciário e Executivo juntos) - de forma permanente e estática, nas cidades de maior demanda social, pela gestão associada de prestação de serviço público jurisdicional entre o Judiciário e Executivo (Legislativo eventualmente) onde a entrega do bem da vida litigioso ou a pacificação (meios alternativos de solução do conflito, como a conciliação) se dê dentro de um ambiente de respeito ao ser humano, ou seja, dentro de um prazo razoável, com padrões de atendimento de eficiência compatíveis com a contemporaneidade e principalmente de forma efetiva (com efetividade plena). Os Juizados Especiais, que foram criados para serem rápidos, ágeis e efetivos, não podem se banalizar e terem os mesmos estigmas da morosidade, da não efetividade e do desapego a qualidade no atendimento ao usuário. Tal humanização, como proposta na dissertação, desse subsistema judiciário - Juizado Especial Federal - com a unitariedade desse serviço público, atende e concretiza os valores e princípios constitucionais, sem necessidade de mudança legislativa, além de reforçar a legitimidade do Estado e solidificar a cidadania. O que se quer nessa dissertação é retirar o Judiciário do isolamento, o que é fundamental sobretudo no plano da efetividade (execução de suas decisões e prevenção e postergação de litígios criando uma mecanismos de conciliação prévia permanente). A dissertação propõe um novo desenho institucional entre Poderes da República para prestação de serviço público jurisdicional buscando contribuir para o aperfeiçoamento das atividades judiciárias em sentido amplo, ou seja, atividades administrativas ou não jurisdicionais (função atípica do Poder Judiciário). O paradigma proposto, além da valorização do consensualismo, implica a efetividade das normas jurídicas e a eficiência do sistema.

Relativização da coisa julgada nas ações declaratórias de paternidade

O presente trabalho objetiva apresentar à problemática envolvendo a existência de dois direitos fundamentais constitucionalmente garantidos (direito à filiação e a coisa julgada) que, devido ao surgimento de uma técnica científica, o exame de DNA, passouse a refletir qual direito deve prevalecer diante do outro e de uma possível relativização da coisa julgada material. Para tanto se faz necessário a análise dos princípios constitucionais envolvidos na relação, o princípio da segurança jurídica e, por outro lado, o princípio da dignidade da pessoa humana. Trata-se de um movimento que envolve uma ampla discussão doutrinária, bem como a jurisprudência competente, que serão devidamente apresentados.

Imagens do medo na mídia: uma análise das representações da violência em Natal-RN

Social violence is one of the phenomena of human life that produce effects on the social imaginary as it is in it that are designed conflicting values concerning what is most vital to humans, such as respect for the strength and the fear of death, pleasure trespass for injury and pain, the rejection of injustice and anger that is born of revolt. The variability of feelings and reasons that constitute violence has required academic knowledge increasingly sensitive reflections that encompass the complexity of its manifestations. The feeling of fear and insecurity which constitute the collective social imagination has caused large changes in the behavior of both individuals and the society as a whole. This study aims to reflect on media representations the social violence in Natal-RN. Through a thematic survey and documentary analysis of three newspapers of Rio Grande do Norte - Tribuna do Norte, Novo Jornal and Jornal Metropolitano - was possible to list events and trace different discursive strategies that lead to receptors ideological interests of class, constitute social and spatial segregations and maximize violations of rights and of the human dignity, with important implications in the construction of social representations concerning the reality of violence

O direito social fundamental de acesso à energia elétrica e a atuação estatal

Electrical energy today is an essential element in the life of any human being. Through the access to electrical energy it is possible to enjoy dignified conditions of life, having in mind the possibility of making use of minimal material conditions of life. The lack of access to electricity is directly linked to poverty and degrading conditions of life, in which are some communities in Brazil, especially the more isolated from urban centers. Access to the electric service is a determining factor for the preservation of human dignity, constitutional principle inscribe in the art.1 of the Federal Constitution, and the promotion of development, being a right of everyone and a duty of the State to promote universal access. For that reason, focuses mainly on the analysis of their setting as a fundamental social right and its importance for national development. For this, the theoretical and descriptive method was used, with normative and literary analysis, in particular the Constitution of 1988. This study also discusses the form of action of the State in the energy sector, to give effect to the fundamental social right of access to electricity, the characteristics of public service and the principles that guide it, in addition to the role of public policies in universalization of access, in particular the analysis of the Program Luz para Todos, and the function of regulation in the implementation of these policies and the provision of adequate public services.

Proteção da relação de emprego sob o prisma da dignidade da pessoa humana

This work aims to show that the protection of the employment relation is one of the determining factors to respect the principle of the human dignity. The goal is initially to show the devaluation of work from antiquity to the early twentieth century, when the constitutions began to standardize protective devices. This way, the consecration of the social labor rights in the Constitution of 1988 represents the culmination of the historical achievements. This work demonstrates that such rights can not be reduced or suppressed by political conveniences, once these rights are included in the list of immutable clauses. It is displayed that to achieve the fundamental right to work is not well advised to encourage the creation of jobs that maculates the worker s dignity. The outsourced work is, therefore, a classic example of the advancement of precarious forms of contemporary labor. It is inferred that the presence of various forms of harassment results in a degradation of working environment, bringing about dire consequences on professional and personal life of the worker. Thus, decent work must be the appropriate benchmark for the creation of new jobs. It is also shown that the flexibilization of the propaganda rights by certain pressure groups has as main goal to reduce or eliminate rights, based on fallacious data depicting an increase of competitiveness and jobs. In addition, the flexibility implies a growth of the precarization of the work - a reality felt by many workers subjected to such a situation due to the unemployment phenomenon whose origin is not in the protectionism of the norms. It is necessary to expand and structure the constitutionally legitimate institutions to monitor and curb the precarized work, as well as all practices that go against the dignity of the worker. It is also shown the loss of power of the sindicates in the last few years as a consequence of the pulverization workes and the capital attacks through the productive restructure whose outsourcings and privatizations are notorious examples

A materialização da dignidade da pessoa humana e o cumprimento das penas privativas de liberdade

The current research come from need to analyze possibilities to materialize human dignity principle during freedom curtail penalties fullfilment, abreast finding that internal and international regulations dictate this is the way to be tread by Brazilian penitentiary system, however, verily, indignity, assistance missing, overcrownding, crime, in the end, barbarie reigns. The work will analyze two strands in order to effective the mentioned principle: the state responsability optics, such in internal scope, as internationally, abreast historical omission in satisfy Constitution, international treaties and laws; and also indicating penal execution alternative methods adoption as a way, bringing to fore a case study - called "apaqueano" method. With such desideratum will bring, first of all, considerations about consolidation process of human dignity principle, its concept and essential content. Furthermore, will address historical and philosophical evolution of freedom curtail penalties. As it follows, will be done an approach about constitutional and underconstitutional legislation that disciplines penalties fullfiling in Brazil, analyzing their main aspects, emphasizing the possibility to charge Brazilian state for disregarding mentioned standards. Next, will also be started a critical analyzis about international regulations, which forbids diminishing or cruel penalties or treatments, approaching human rights international treaties and conventions ratified by Braziland their incorporation and effectiveness in local Law, emphasizing monitoring forms and country international charging possibility for disregarding international regulations. Lastly, will advance to the real possibility to materialize human dignity principle in penalties fullfiling, based in a case study verification - the APAC (Associação de Proteção e Assistência aos Condenados) called method, analyzing the various theories about penalties grounding, with emphasis in their ressocializing function, as well as traditional penitentiary systems, and the theory adopted by vernacular order, in desideratum to contribute to improve national penitentiary system chaotic situation