Student voice and teacher accountability: possibilities and problematics

The focus in this paper is on a student voice initiative at an English secondary school designed to improve the quality of teaching and learning. The initiative invites Year 8 students to train and work as ‘lesson observers’ who provide feedback to teachers about their practice. The possibilities of this initiative to reflect a rich and intelligent form of teacher accountability are explored in relation to its capacity to (1) enhance students’ understanding and appreciation of teachers, teaching and the learning process; (2) support students to work in partnership with teachers to improve pedagogy and relationships; and (3) develop students’ positive self-image as learners. In its exploration of this initiative the paper also considers matters of authenticity, inclusion and power and highlights ways in which student voice initiatives can be undermined when these matters are not adequately engaged with. Such engagement, it is argued, is imperative in guarding against a misappropriation or undermining of student voice to align with traditional teacher–student power relations or to fit with the dictates of school improvement as framed by narrow and reductive measures.

Gender differences in children's classroom behaviour and teacher-child relationships in early childhood: An Australian Study

Background: In the early school years, children need positive attitudes to school and experiences that promote academic and social competence. Positive relationships between children and teachers make a significant contribution to school achievement and social competence. Girls are more likely to display positive classroom behaviours and positive approaches to learning than boys. Gender differences have also been noted in teacher-child relationships. This study investigated the relationship between gender differences in classroom behaviour and gender differences in teacher-child relationships in the early years. Method: Data were drawn from The Longitudinal Study of Australian Children (LSAC). LSAC is a cross-sequential cohort study funded by the Australian Government. In these analyses, Wave 1 (2004) and Wave 2 (2006) data for 4464 children in the Kindergarten Cohort were used. Children, at Wave 2, were in the early years of formal school. They had a mean age of 6.8 years (SD= 0.24). Measures included a 6-item measure of Approaches to Learning (task persistence, independence) and teacher ratings on the SDQ. Teachers rated their relationships with children on the short form of the STRS. Results: Girls were found to have more positive relationships with their teachers and to display more positive classroom behaviours than boys. Teachers described their relationships with boys as less close than their relationships with girls and rated girls as displaying more positive approaches to learning and fewer problem behaviours than boys. Positive teacher – child relationships were significantly related to more positive classroom behaviours. The quality of the teacher-child relationship at time 1 (Wave 1) was the best predictor of the quality of the teacher-child relationship at time 2 (Wave 2). Conclusions: Findings highlight the importance of developing positive learning related classroom behaviours in understanding successful school transition and the key role played by early positive teacher-child relationships in promoting school adjustment.

Visuacy, imagination, and engagement

Australia’s National Review of Visual Education (DEEWR, 2009) asserts the primacy of visual language ability, or ‘visuacy” in problem-solving. This paper reports on a recent university/schools research project with ‘at risk’ middle school students in which visuacy was promoted as a primary medium for obtaining data relating to issues of immediate concern to the students. Using a students-as-researchers approach, the project investigated middle school students’ perspectives on school engagement and disengagement. In this project, novice researchers used a variety of data gathering methods including photography, video interviews and drawn images as well as more traditional verbal methods, such as interviews, and quantitative methods, such as questionnaires. Engaging student imagination was a key focus of the approach taken by the project, acknowledging that student participants may be reluctant to enter dialogue with teachers and researchers on matters to which they have previously had little input. Students who have previously been marginalized and prevented from contributing their voices to educational forums often have difficulty in adjusting to the novelty of collaborative research with adults (Rudduck, 2003) and may be uncertain of their own place in the relationship that defines teacher/student interactions. It is argued that the project’s promotion of visuacy, alongside more traditional literacies and numeracy in education research, helped to overcome these concerns, engaged the imaginations of the student researchers, and provided a medium for the expression of the voices of marginalised young people.

The relationship between teachers' perceptions of school leadership and their perceptions of the implementation of the National Curriculum

The National Curriculum is an innovation in Australian schooling history and is likely to have a widespread and long-term impact on schools, teachers and students. This research used theoretical frameworks informed by Leithwood (1994) and Fullan (2007), and concepts related to innovation, to contribute to an understanding that may support a better understanding of teachers' perceptions when leading curriculum change such as a National Curriculum in schools. This research concludes that teachers who participated in the research demonstrated that their perceptions of a National Curriculum implementation are influenced by their perceptions of school leadership. Specifically, teachers with positive perceptions of their Principal's leadership also had positive perceptions of their capacity to implement the new National Curriculum.

As Artes de Fazer no Cotidiano Escolar

Este trabalho tem como objetivo analisar as artes de fazer no cotidiano da Escola Municipal Levi Carneiro, ou seja, as diferentes maneiras de fazer de alunos, professores e demais profissionais da escola que possibilitaram novas formas de relação com o outro, novos modos de criatividade, favorecendo a produção de subjetividades singulares, através da dança, da música e das artes cênicas. Trata-se de uma análise que tem como tema gerador a questão da disciplina, explicitada por professores, alunos e funcionários no cotidiano escolar, o que permitiu desencadear projetos e quebras de paradigmas. Para a problematização dessas vivências utilizou-se da discussão acerca dos mecanismos de controle a partir do conceito de disciplina, abordou-se a concepção de cultura e a produção de subjetividades, assim como se investiu nas práticas cotidianas a partir do debate sobre as artes de fazer. A dissertação baseia-se nas experiências da autora como professora, coordenadora e diretora de escola pública, cuja gestão está pautada numa concepção participativa. Dessa forma, a perspectiva metodológica está centrada na narrativa, como afirma Benjamin, cujas experiências são tecidas nas relações cotidianas. As diversas maneiras de fazer de crianças, e jovens, pedagogos e professores, e demais pessoas envolvidas com a comunidade escolar possibilitaram a reinvenção de muitas experiências na escola. As artes cênicas, a música, a dança, ressignificaram o espaço escolar, enquanto lugar praticado privilegiado para o desenvolvimento da sensibilidade através da arte.

Um percurso nacional - 20 anos de estudos sobre altas habilidades / superdotação: a contribuição discente dos programas de pós-graduação

Esta investigação, no campo da produção acadêmica dos programas de pós-graduação de universidades brasileiras, sobre a temática altas habilidades/superdotação, teve como objetivos: mapear um conjunto significativo de trabalhos elaborados sob as formas de tese e dissertação, nas duas últimas décadas; e apresentar as contribuições desses estudos para o atendimento educacional aos portadores de altas habilidades/superdotados. A contextualização teórica da presente pesquisa refere-se à busca de uma teoria mais completa e abrangente sobre a inteligência humana, e da melhor compreensão das altas habilidades/superdotação, mencionando a legislação educacional mais recente sobre o atendimento a esses alunos especiais. A metodologia de pesquisa bibliográfica foi utilizada na sistematização da leitura e releitura dos textos, em vários níveis, para a exploração de seus conteúdos. O objetivo almejado foi a adequada identificação das linhas de pensamento dos autores, procurando-se manter o máximo possível de imparcialidade e respeito a cada um dos posicionamentos. Os assuntos foram categorizados por afinidade temática, em três capítulos, que em sua estrutura apresentam uma introdução, as sínteses descritivas dos trabalhos analisados e uma conclusão. Os resultados alcançados permitiram uma análise elucidativa da produção acadêmica em pauta, nas décadas de 80 e 90, estendendo-se aos anos 2000 e 2001. Sinalizaram evoluções conceituais concernentes às altas habilidades/superdotação. Pontuaram conclusões sobre: a identificação precoce; a estimulação ambiental; a auto-alfabetização precoce; a identificação e atendimento a crianças das classes populares e a preparação de professores; a elaboração de instrumento de observação a ser utilizado pelos professores. Mais conclusões puderam ser registradas em relação a: percepções da escola, pais e professores; percepção de professores universitários; autopercepção e os relacionamentos interpessoais de adultos e jovens adultos; incidentes e comportamentos críticos observados na escola; representação social da escola segundo os alunos; relação professora-aluno portador de altas habilidades; autopercepção e a percepção dos olhares da família, escola e companheiros, por adolescentes. Outras conclusões ainda foram evidenciadas sobre: estratégias educativas para estimulação e identificação de talentos na escola regular, no ensino fundamental e educação infantil; subsídios para a realização escolar no ensino fundamental; a capacidade acadêmica elevada no ensino fundamental; a avaliação de um curso de educação do pensamento por professores participantes. Incluem-se também neste conjunto de resultados: dados históricos sobre a questão das altas habilidades/superdotação; reflexões sobre a profissionalização na área tecnológica; uma crítica ao atendimento educacional aos portadores de altas habilidades/superdotados; e o estudo da trajetória escolar de alunos que receberam atendimento em escolas da rede pública de ensino.

A sala de aula no contexto da cibercultura: formação docente e discente em atos de currículo

Este trabalho de tese tem como temática a formação docente situada no contexto da cibercultura. Parte do pressuposto de que professores formadores e em formação precisam dialogar com saberes/fazeres que potencializem suas aprendizagens em um novo espaço/tempo da sala de aula e que a pesquisa no ensino superior se tece no exercício da reflexão sobre/na prática em um processo plural de auto-hetero-ecoformação. Tem como objetivo construir atos de currículo, utilizando as potencialidades dos ambientes virtuais, das redes sociais e da internet para ressignificar o aprender/ensinar situado nas vivências dos praticantes culturais dentro/fora da universidade. Como problemáticas central e secundária da pesquisa-formação na cibercultura, temos, respectivamente: como a criação de atos de currículo com o uso das tecnologias digitais em espaços multirreferencias de aprendizagem podem potencializar as práticas formativas docente e discente no Curso de Pedagogia da UERN no contexto da cibercultura? Quais dispositivos engendram práticas formativas autorais, no presencial e no online, com o uso das tecnologias digitais em rede? Como construir uma relação pedagógica de interação colaborativa, docente e discente, mediada pelo uso das tecnologias digitais? A criação de atos de currículo utilizando as tecnologias digitais contribui com novos letramentos digitais dos praticantes na cibercultura? Tomamos como inspirações teórico-metodológicas a pesquisa-formação (SANTOS; MACEDO; NÓVOA) multirreferencial (ARDOINO, BARBOSA, MACEDO) com os cotidianos (CERTEAU, ALVES, FERRAÇO, OLIVEIRA), situada no contexto da cibercultura (SANTOS, SILVA, LEMOS, SANTAELLA, LEVY), entrelaçadas aos sentidos dos autores da pesquisa deste trabalho de tese. A pesquisa foi desenvolvida no cenário formativo do Curso de Pedagogia da Universidade do Estado do Rio Grande do Norte UERN nas disciplinas de Didática e Estágio Supervisionado I. Como resultado, apresentamos que as ambiências formativas criadas nos atos de currículo no ensino presencial e online, apontam perspectivas que vão ao encontro de uma formação docente e discente do ciberautorcidadão, uma postura em processo, em devir, que se constrói na relação cidade/ciberespaço, em espaços/tempos de aprendizagens plurais, referenciadas nas experiências tecidas nesses contextos.

An examination of student and provider perceptions of voluntary sector social work placements in Northern Ireland

Practice based learning in Northern Ireland is a core element of social work education and comprising 50% of the degree programme for undergraduate and postgraduate students. This article presents evidence about the perceptions of practice learning from voluntary sector/non-government organisation (NGO) placement providers and final year social work students on social work degree programmes in Northern Ireland in 2011. It draws on data from 121 respondents from189 final year students and focus group interviews with voluntary sector providers offering 16% (85) of the total placements available to students. The agencies who participated in the research study provide a total of 55 PLOs to social work students, and are therefore fairly representative in terms of voluntary sector (NGO) provision. The article locates these data in the context of practice learning pedagogy and the changes introduced by the Regional Strategy for Practice Learning Provision in Northern Ireland 2010–2015. Several themes emerged including; induction, support and guidance, practice educator/student relationship, professional identity and confidence in risk assessment and decision-making. Social work educators, placement providers and employers must be cognisant of newly qualified social workers’ needs in terms of consolidating knowledge within the formative stages of their professional development.

Estilos de liderança em contexto de sala de aula:implicações na supervisão e orientação pedagógica

Dissertação apresentada para a obtenção do grau de Mestre em Ciências da Educação/Supervisão e Orientação Pedagógica. Orientador: Professor Doutor António Mesquita Guimarães

O questionamento como elemento integrador do blogue nas aulas de ciências

A investigação sobre a promoção do questionamento na relação pedagógica revela ser uma estratégia que valoriza o papel do aluno enquanto aquele que aprende, alterando a forma como as aulas são vividas por alunos e professores. Perante a inexistência de estudos que ensaiem o estímulo ao questionamento e, simultaneamente, integrem a Web 2.0 no processo de ensino e de aprendizagem no Ensino Básico, delineou-se a presente investigação. O estudo situa-se, assim, na interseção de dois campos: por um lado, as potencialidades do incentivo ao questionamento no processo pedagógico e, por outro, a integração educativa das TIC. A questão de Investigação que orientou este estudo foi a de avaliar de que forma é que o incentivo ao questionamento poderia contribuir para integrar o blogue de disciplina no trabalho em sala de aula de Ciências Naturais. Assim, concebemos, implementámos e avaliámos uma intervenção didática centrada na promoção da competência de questionamento, dando voz aos alunos, estimulando-os a formularem perguntas sobre os conteúdos, tanto presencialmente como no blogue da disciplina, denominado por “Mentes Curiosas”, utilizando essas perguntas como elementos integradores dos dois espaços. O estudo seguiu uma metodologia de investigação-ação e envolveu 36 alunos do 9.º ano de escolaridade, divididos em duas turmas, na disciplina de Ciências Naturais. Os instrumentos e métodos de recolha de dados foram diversificados, tendo todos os dados sido submetidos a uma análise de conteúdo. O estudo revela que os alunos utilizaram o blogue respondendo aos desafios colocados escrevendo comentários, respostas e, sobretudo, fazendo perguntas para as quais gostariam de obter respostas. O docente integrou essas perguntas na prática letiva dando continuidade às discussões de um ambiente para o outro, utilizando, desta forma, as perguntas dos alunos para a integração dos dois ambientes. A análise do questionamento registado revela que as perguntas online estão mais centradas nos conteúdos científicos e apresentam maior qualidade cognitiva quando comparadas com as formuladas em sala de aula. Por sua vez, no contexto presencial, as perguntas escritas são de maior nível de complexidade do que as perguntas orais. Através das diversas estratégias implementadas, quer para a promoção da capacidade de escrever perguntas, quer no trabalho realizado com o blogue, transformou-se a dinâmica do trabalho em sala de aula, melhorando-se o empenhamento dos alunos na aprendizagem. A estratégia de incentivo ao questionamento pelos alunos revelou-se, assim, como um fator que permite integrar de forma profícua o ambiente online no ambiente presencial neste nível de ensino. Por fim, a reflexão que fomos fazendo sobre as potencialidades do questionamento na relação professor-alunos-conteúdos, tanto no ambiente presencial como no virtual, levou-nos a perspetivar as perguntas segundo duas dimensões: Competência Cognitiva e Estratégia Didática. Enquanto Competência, o questionamento assume a função de ferramenta cognitiva e de regulador do processo de ensino e de aprendizagem. Enquanto Estratégia, a pergunta pode ser encarada como uma ferramenta didática na relação dialógica que se estabelece entre professor e alunos.

A speculative systems model of the dynamic interaction among students, faculty and administration in the community college, with particular reference to intrinsic motivation and the teacher-administrator interface

The challenge the community college faces in helping meet the needs of the living open system of society is examined in this study. It is postulated that internalization student outcomes are required by society to reduce entropy and remain self-renewing. Such behavior is characterized as having an intrinsically motivated energy source and displays the seeking and conquering of challenge, the development of reflective knowledge and skill, full use of all capabilities, internal control, growth orientation, high self-esteem, relativistic thinking and competence. The development of a conceptual systems model that suggests how transactions among students, faculty and administration might occur to best meet the needs of internalization outcomes in students, and intrinsic motivation in faculty is a major purpose of this study. It is a speculative model that is based on a synthesis of a wide variety of variables. Empirical evidence, theoretical considerations, and speculative ideas are gathered together from researchers and theoretici.ans who are working on separate answers to questions of intrinsic motivation, internal control and environments that encourage their development. The model considers the effect administrators·have on faculty anq the corresponding effect faculty may have on students. The major concentration is on the administrator--teacher interface.For administrators the model may serve as a guide in planning effective transactions, and establishing system goals. The teacher is offered a means to coordinate actions toward a specific overall objective, and the administrator, teacher and researcher are invited to use the model to experiment, innovate, verify the assumptions on which the model is based, and raise additional hypotheses. Goals and history of the community colleges in Ontario are examined against current problems, previous progress and open system thinking. The nature of the person as a five part system is explored with emphasis on intrinsic motivation. The nature, operation, conceptualization, and value of this internal energy source is reviewed in detail. The current state of society, education and management theory are considered and the value of intrinsically motivating teaching tasks together with "system four" leadership style are featured. Evidence is reviewed that suggests intrinsically motivated faculty are needed, and "system four" leadership style is the kind of interaction-influence system needed to nurture intrinsic motivation in faculty.

Exploring the potential of early identification and intervention within a college of applied arts

This study probed for an answer to the question, "How do you identify as early as possible those students who are at risk of failing or dropping out of college so that intervention can take place?" by field testing two diagnostic instruments with a group of first semester Seneca College Computer Studies students. In some respects, the research approach was such as might be taken in a pilot study. Because of the complexity of the issue, this study did not attempt to go beyond discovery, understanding and description. Although some inferences may be drawn from the results of the study, no attempt was made to establish any causal relationship between or among the factors or variables represented here. Both quantitative and qualitative data were gathered during. four resea~ch phases: background, early identification, intervention, and evaluation. To gain a better understanding of the problem of student attrition within the School of Computer Studies at Seneca College, several methods were used, including retrospective analysis of enrollment statistics, faculty and student interviews and questionnaires, and tracking of the sample population. The significance of the problem was confirmed by the results of this study. The findings further confirmed the importance of the role of faculty in student retention and support the need to improve the quality of teacher/student interaction. As well, the need __f or ~~ills as~e:ss_~ent foll,,-~ed }JY supportiv e_c_ounsell~_I'l9_ ~~d_ __ placement was supported by the findings from this study. strategies for reducing student attrition were identified by faculty and students. As part of this study, a project referred to as "A Student Alert project" (ASAP) was undertaken at the School of Computer Studies at Seneca College. Two commercial diagnostic instruments, the Noel/Levitz College Student Inventory (CSI) and the Learning and Study Strategies Inventory (LASSI), provided quantitative data which were subsequently analyzed in Phase 4 in order to assess their usefulness as early identification tools. The findings show some support for using these instruments in a two-stage approach to early identification and intervention: the CSI as an early identification instrument and the LASSI as a counselling tool for those students who have been identified as being at risk. The findings from the preliminary attempts at intervention confirmed the need for a structured student advisement program where faculty are selected, trained, and recognized for their advisor role. Based on the finding that very few students acted on the diagnostic results and recommendations, the need for institutional intervention by way of intrusive measures was confirmed.

Exploring the potential of early identification and intervention within a college of applied arts

This study probed for an answer to the question, "How do you identify as early as possible those students who are at risk of failing or dropping out of college so that intervention can take place?" by field testing two diagnostic instruments with a group of first semester Seneca College Computer ,Studies students. In some respects, the research approach was such as might be taken in a pilot study_ Because of the complexity of the issue, this study did not attempt to go beyond discovery, understanding and description. Although some inferences may be drawn from the results of the study, no attempt was made to establish any causal relationship between or among the factors or variables represented here. Both quantitative and qualitative data were gathered during four resea~ch phases: background, early identification, intervention, and evaluation. To gain a better understanding of the problem of student attrition within the School of Computer Studies at Seneca College, several methods were used, including retrospective analysis of enrollment statistics, faculty and student interviews and questionnaires, and tracking of the sample population. The significance of the problem was confirmed by the results of this study. The findings further confirmed the importance of the role of faculty in student retention and support the need to improve the quality of teacher/student interaction. As well, the need for skills assessmen~-followed by supportive counselling, and placement was supported by the findings from this study. strategies for reducing student attrition were identified by faculty and students. As part of this study, a project referred to as "A Student Alert Project" (ASAP) was undertaken at the School of Computer Studies at Seneca college. Two commercial diagnostic instruments, the Noel/Levitz College Student Inventory (CSI) and the Learning and Study Strategies Inventory (LASSI), provided quantitative data which were subsequently analyzed in Phase 4 in order to assess their usefulness as early identification tools. The findings show some support for using these instruments in a two-stage approach to early identification and intervention: the CSI as an early identification instrument and the LASSI as a counselling tool for those students who have been identified as being at risk. The findings from the preliminary attempts at intervention confirmed the need for a structured student advisement program where faculty are selected, trained, and recognized for their advisor role. Based on the finding that very few students acted on the diagnostic results and recommendations, the need for institutional intervention by way of intrusive measures was confirmed.