Il ruolo della Narrative in Medical Ethics, Medical Practice e Medical Education. Elementi di ricerca

La mia tesi di dottorato ha ad oggetto lo studio e l’analisi del ruolo della Narrative all’interno di tre ambiti, quali Medical Ethics, Clinical Practice e Medical Education. La tesi è strutturata in 4 capitoli: i primi tre vanno a comporre la parte teorica mentre nel quarto capitolo viene riportata una ricerca sul campo da me svolta negli Stati Uniti. Nel primo capitolo, analizzo il ruolo della narrative all’interno della Medical Ethics specificando che cosa si intenda con etica narrativa, quali sono le motivazione alla base del suo sviluppo e chi sono i suoi principali esponenti. In questo capitolo, inoltre, esamino i problemi che l’etica narrativa solleva suggerendo un nuovo modo in cui essa si integra alla riflessione bioetica. Il secondo capitolo è dedicato al contributo della narrative nella Medical Practice investigando sia le modalità attraverso le quali il paziente può avvalersi della narrazione per analizzare la sua esperienza di malattia sia la cosiddetta Medicina Narrativa. Il terzo capitolo è dedicato all'analisi delle Medical Humanities, ossia di quelle discipline che all’interno della Medical Education si stanno rivelando strumenti efficaci per una formazione più equilibrata e completa dei professionisti della salute. Il quarto capitolo, invece, è dedicato alla descrizione di una ricerca svolta presso l’University of California – Irvine . Durante questa esperienza ho frequentato i corsi del Program in Medical Humanities and Arts diretto dalla Prof.ssa J. Shapiro, (programma in vigore da 13 anni e implementato allo scopo di migliorare alcune competenze nei futuri medici quali: l'empatia, l’altruismo, la compassione e la predisposizione alla cura verso i pazienti, oltre che per affinare le comunicazione clinica e la capacità di osservazione) e intervistato gli studenti che hanno preso parte a queste lezioni.

Patient-Therapeut-Bindung bei Drogenabhängigen: Instrumentenvalidierung und Therapieevaluation

In der vorliegenden Arbeit wird zum einen ein Instrument zur Erfassung der Patient-Therapeut-Bindung validiert (Client Attachment to Therapist Scale, CATS; Mallinckrodt, Coble & Gantt, 1995), zum anderen werden Hypothesen zu den Zusammenhängen zwischen Selbstwirksamkeitserwartung, allgemeinem Bindungsstil, therapeutischer Beziehung (bzw. Therapiezufriedenheit), Patient-Therapeut-Bindung und Therapieerfolg bei Drogen-abhängigen in stationärer Postakutbehandlung überprüft. In die Instrumentenvalidierung (einwöchiger Retest) wurden 119 Patienten aus 2 Kliniken und 13 Experten einbezogen. Die Gütekriterien des Instrumentes fallen sehr zufriedenstellend aus. An der naturalistischen Therapieevaluationsstudie (Prä-, Prozess-, Post-Messung: T0, T1, T2) nahmen 365 Patienten und 27 Therapeuten aus 4 Kliniken teil. Insgesamt beendeten 44,1% der Patienten ihren stationären Aufenthalt planmäßig. Auf Patientenseite erweisen sich Alter und Hauptdiagnose, auf Therapeutenseite die praktizierte Therapierichtung als Therapieerfolgsprädiktoren. Selbstwirksamkeitserwartung, allgemeiner Bindungsstil, Patient-Therapeut-Bindung und Therapiezufriedenheit eignen sich nicht zur Prognose des Therapieerfolgs. Die zu T0 stark unterdurchschnittlich ausgeprägte Selbstwirksamkeits-erwartung steigert sich über den Interventionszeitraum, wobei sich ein Moderatoreffekt der Patient-Therapeut-Bindung beobachten lässt. Es liegt eine hohe Prävalenz unsicherer allgemeiner Bindungsstile vor, welche sich über den Therapiezeitraum nicht verändern. Die patientenseitige Zufriedenheit mit der Therapie steigt von T1 zu T2 an. Die Interrater-Konkordanz (Patient/Therapeut) zur Einschätzung der Patient-Therapeut-Bindung erhöht sich leicht von T1 zu T2. Im Gegensatz dazu wird die Therapiezufriedenheit von Patienten und Therapeuten zu beiden Messzeitpunkten sehr unterschiedlich beurteilt. Die guten Testgütekriterien der CATS sprechen für eine Überlegenheit dieses Instrumentes gegenüber der Skala zur Erfassung der Therapiezufriedenheit. Deshalb sollte die Patient-Therapeut-Bindung anhand dieses Instrumentes in weiteren Forschungsarbeiten an anderen Patientenkollektiven untersucht werden, um generalisierbare Aussagen zur Validität treffen zu können.

On the development of novel cocaine-analogues for in vivo imaging of the dopamine transporter status

The present thesis is concerned with the development of novel cocaine-derived dopamine transporter ligands for the non-invasive exploration of the striatal and extra-striatal dopamine transporter (DAT) in living systems. The presynaptic dopamine transporter acquires an important function within the mediation of dopaminergic signal transduction. Its availability can serve as a measure for the overall integrity of the dopaminergic system. The DAT is upregulated in early Parkinson’s disease (PD), resulting in an increased availability of DAT-binding sites in the striatal DAT domains. Thereby, DAT imaging has become an important routine diagnostic tool for the early diagnosis of PD in patients, as well as for the differentiation of PD from symptomatically similar medical conditions. Furthermore, the dopaminergic system is involved in a variety of psychiatric diseases. In this regard, DAT-selective imaging agents may provide detailed insights into the scientific understanding of the biochemical background of both, the progress as well as the origins of the symptoms. DAT-imaging may also contribute to the determination of the dopaminergic therapeutic response for a given medication and thereby contribute to more convenient conditions for the patient. From an imaging point of view, the former demands a high availability of the radioactive probe to facilitate broad application of the modality, whereas the latter profits from short-lived probes, suitable for multi-injection studies. Therefore, labelling with longer-lived 18F-fluoride and in particular the generator nuclide 68Ga is worthwhile for clinical routine imaging. In contrast, the introduction of a 11C-label is a prerequisite for detailed scientific studies of neuronal interactions. The development of suitable DAT-ligands for medical imaging has often been complicated by the mixed binding profile of many compounds that that interact with the DAT. Other drawbacks have included high non-specific binding, extensive metabolism and slow accumulation in the DAT-rich brain areas. However, some recent examples have partially overcome the mentioned complications. Based on the structural speciality of these leads, novel ligand structures were designed and successfully synthesised in the present work. A structure activity relationship (SAR) study was conducted wherein the new structural modifications were examined for their influence on DAT-affinity and selectivity. Two of the compounds showed improvements in in vitro affinity for the DAT as well as selectivity versus the serotonin transporter (SERT) and norepinephrine transporter (NET). The main effort was focussed on the high-affinity candidate PR04.MZ, which was subsequently labelled with 18F and 11C in high yield. An initial pharmacological characterisation of PR04.MZ in rodents revealed highly specific binding to the target brain structures. As a result of low non-specific binding, the DAT-rich striatal area was clearly visualised by autoradiography and µPET. Furthermore, the radioactivity uptake into the DAT-rich brain regions was rapid and indicated fast binding equilibrium. No radioactive metabolite was found in the rat brain. [18F]PR04.MZ and [11C]PR04.MZ were compared in the primate brain and the plasma metabolism was studied. It was found that the ligands specifically visualise the DAT in high and low density in the primate brain. The activity uptake was rapid and quantitative evaluation by Logan graphical analysis and simplified reference tissue model was possible after a scanning time of 30 min. These results further reflect the good characteristics of PR04.MZ as a selective ligand of the neuronal DAT. To pursue 68Ga-labelling of the DAT, initial synthetic studies were performed as part of the present thesis. Thereby, a concept for the convenient preparation of novel bifunctional chelators (BFCs) was developed. Furthermore, the suitability of novel 1,4,7-triazacyclononane based N3S3-type BFCs for biomolecule-chelator conjugates of sufficient lipophilicity for the penetration of the blood-brain-barrier was elucidated.

Il consenso informato come strumento di esercizio del diritto alla salute per i pazienti stranieri?

L’elaborato propone una riflessione rispetto all’atto giuridico del consenso informato quale strumento garante dell’esercizio del diritto alla salute per i migranti. Attraverso una riflessione antropologica rispetto alla natura, alla costruzione e alla logica dei diritti universali, verranno analizzate le normative nazionali, europee ed internazionali a tutela del diritto alla salute per i migranti; l’obiettivo della ricerca è indagare l’eventuale scarto tra normative e politiche garantiste nei confronti della salute migrante e l’esistenza di barriere strutturali che impediscono un pieno esercizio del diritto alla salute. L’ipotesi di ricerca si basa sulla reale capacità performativa del consenso informato, proposto solitamente sia come strumento volto ad assicurare la piena professionalità dell’operatore sanitario nell’informare il paziente circa i rischi e i benefici di un determinato trattamento sanitario, sia come garante del principio di autonomia. La ricerca, attraverso un’analisi quanti-qualitativa, ha interrogato il proprio campo, rappresentato da un reparto di ginecologia ed ostetrica, rispetto alle modalità pratiche di porre in essere la firma nei moduli del consenso informato, con particolare attenzione alle specificità proprie delle pazienti migranti. Attraverso l’osservazione partecipante è stato quindi possibile riflettere su aspetti rilevanti, quali le dinamiche quotidiane che vengono a crearsi tra personale sanitario e pazienti, le caratteristiche e i limiti del servizio di mediazione sanitaria, le azioni pratiche della medicina difensiva. In questo senso il tema del “consenso informato”, indagato facendo interagire discipline quali l’antropologia, la bioetica, la filosofia e la sociologia, si è posto sia come lente di lettura privilegiata per comprendere le dinamiche relazionali ad oggi esistenti tra professionisti sanitari e popolazione migrante, ancora vittima di diseguaglianze strutturali, ma altresì come “innesco potenziale” di nuove modalità di intendere la relazione medico-paziente.

Untersuchungen zur autoimmunen Genese der thrombotisch thrombozytopenischen Purpura

Untersuchungen zur autoimmunen Genese der thrombotisch thrombozytopenischen Purpura. rnEinführung: Die idiopathische thrombotisch thrombozytopenische Purpura (TTP) ist eine lebensbedrohliche Mikroangiopathie und wird durch ein Autoantikörper-induziertes Defizit der ADAMTS13-Protease ausgelöst. Eine Assoziation zwischen Krankheitsprädisposition und Vorliegen bestimmter humaner Leukozytenantigene (HLA) wird vermutet. Untersuchungen zu diesem Zusammenhang stellen einen Teil dieser Arbeit dar. rnAutoimmunkrankheiten tendieren zum gemeinsamen Auftreten innerhalb eines Individuums. Im zweiten Teil dieser Arbeit wird untersucht, ob eine solche Kookkurrenz verschiedener Autoimmunkrankheiten auch bei Patienten mit idiopathischer TTP beobachtet werden kann.rnMethodik: Zur Untersuchung der ersten Fragestellung werden die HLA-Klasse I und II-Merkmale von 54 deutschen TTP-Patienten bestimmt. Alle Patienten weisen Autoantikörper gegen ADAMTS13 und eine Protease-Aktivität <5% vor. Die Blutproben werden mittels Sequence Specific Primer-Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) und Sequence Specific Oligonucleotid-PCR auf HLA-DRB1, -DRB3-5 und –DQB1 untersucht. Als Referenz dienen die Werte deutscher Knochenmark- und Blutspender, erhalten über www.allelefrequencies.net. Die statistische Auswertung erfolgt mittels zweiseitigem Binomialtest und die resultierenden p-Werte werden nach Benjamini-Hochberg korrigiert.rnZur Beantwortung der zweiten Fragestellung werden 76 deutsche TTP-Patienten anhand eines standardisierten Fragebogens nach Begleiterkrankungen befragt. Als Vergleichswerte dient die Prävalenz der jeweiligen Erkrankung in der Allgemeinbevölkerung. Die statistische Auswertung erfolgt mittels zweiseitigem Binomialtest. Da die p-Werte nicht korrigiert werden, sind die Ergebnisse nur deskriptiv zu verstehen.rnErgebnis: Der Vergleich der HLA-Frequenzen ergibt ein signifikant gehäuftes Vorkommen von HLA-DQB1*02:02 (p<0,001) und -DRB1*11 (p=0,003) innerhalb des Patientenkollektivs. 20% (DQB1*02:02) bzw. 48,1% (DRB1*11) der TTP-Patienten sind im Gegensatz zu nur 1,2% (DQB1*02:02) bzw. 23,5% (DRB1*11) innerhalb der Vergleichsgruppe für das jeweilige HLA-Merkmal positiv.rnDie Befragung der TTP-Patienten bezüglich weiterer Erkrankungen ergab im Vergleich mit der Allgemeinbevölkerung fünf auffällig häufig im Patientenkollektiv vorkommende Autoimmunkrankheiten: Hashimoto Thyreoiditis (23,5% in der Patientengruppe zu 0,7% in der Allgemeinbevölkerung; p<0,001), systemischer Lupus erythematodes (6,5% der Patienten im Gegensatz zu 0,025% in der Allgemeinbevölkerung, p<0,001), Immunthrombozytopenie (6,3% der Patienten zu 0,02% in der Allgemeinbevölkerung; p<0,001), Psoriasis (9,4% der Patienten zu 2,5% in der Allgemeinbevölkerung; p=0,005) und glutensensitive Enteropathie (3,1% der Patienten zu 0,2% in der Allgemeinbevölkerung; p=0,007). rnSchlussfolgerung: Das vermehrte Vorkommen bestimmter HLA-Merkmale im Patientenkollektiv spricht für eine prädisponierende Wirkung dieser Antigene im Krankheitsgeschehen. Eine mögliche HLA-vermittelte Assoziation zwischen TTP und den genannten Autoimmunkrankheiten wird vermutet, kann jedoch nicht in allen Fällen die beobachtete Kookkurrenz ausreichend erklären. Insgesamt bestätigt die vorliegende Arbeit die Assoziation verschiedener Autoimmunkrankheiten untereinander und spricht für eine genetische Prädisposition zur Ausbildung autoimmuner Störungen. rn

Die Rolle der Topoisomerase 2 beta in der normalen Herzfunktion sowie in der Entstehung der Herzinsuffizienz

Die Herzinsuffizienz (HI) ist eine der häufigsten und teuersten medizinischen Indikationen in der heutigen Zeit. rnIn der vorliegenden Arbeit konnte zum ersten Mal die Topoisomerase 2b (Top2b) in Zusammenhang mit der Entstehung einer dilatativen Kardiomyopathie gebracht werden. rnIn einem speziellen Mausmodell war es möglich, die Top2b gewebsspezifisch und zeitspezifisch nur in Kardiomyozyten zu deletieren. Dies geschah mittels eines Tamoxifen-induzierten Cre-Rekombinase-Gendeletionsmodells. Phänotypisch zeigten die Top2b-deletierten Mäuse 8 Wochen nach der Tamoxifen-Gabe signifikant reduzierte kardiale Ejektionsfraktionen sowie erhöhte linksventrikuläre enddiastolische und endsystolische Volumina. Weder Schlagvolumen noch Körpergewicht waren verändert. Die natriuretischen Peptide ANP und BNP waren in den Top2b-deletierten Tieren ebenfalls signifikant erhöht. Zusätzlich zeigten sowohl elektronenmikroskopische Untersuchungen als auch klassische histologische Verfahren fibrotische Veränderungen und erhöhte Kollagenablagerungen in Top2b-deletierten Tieren. Begleitend dazu stiegen die mRNA-Expressionslevel von Col1a1, Col3a1, Tgfβ1 und Tgfβ2 in den deletierten Tieren 8 Wochen nach der Implementierung der Deletion signifikant an. rnIn einer genomweiten Hochdurchsatz-Sequenzierung waren bereits 2 Wochen nach Tamoxifen-Gabe 128 Gene mindestens 2-fach gegenüber der Kontrollgruppe differentiell exprimiert. Eine genauere Analyse der veränderten Genexpression ließ bereits 14 Tage nach Implementierung der Deletion kardiale Verschlechterungen vermuten. So waren neben dem atrialen natriuretischen Peptid ANP die beiden häufigsten Kollagenarten im Herzen, Col3a1 und Col1a1, hochreguliert. rnInteressanterweise beinhalteten die 37 herunterregulierten Gene 11 Transkriptionsfaktoren. Da der Top2b in den letzten Jahren eine immer stärker werdende Bedeutung in der Transkription zugesprochen wird, sollte mittels Chromatin-Immunpräzipitation ein direkter Zusammenhang zwischen der Top2b-Deletion und der Herunterregulierung der 11 Transkriptionsfaktoren sowie die Bindung der Top2b an Promotoren ausgewählter, differentiell-exprimierter Gene untersucht werden. Generell konnte keine vermehrte Bindung von Top2b an Promotorbereiche gezeigt werden, was aber nicht dem generellen Fehlen einer Bindung gleichkommen muss. Vielmehr gab es methodische Schwierigkeiten, weshalb die Bedeutung der Top2b in der Transkription im Rahmen der vorliegenden Arbeit nicht ausreichend geklärt werden konnte.rnEine Kardiomyozyten-spezifische Top2b-Deletion mündete 8 Wochen nach Tamoxifen-Gabe in eine dilatative Kardiomyopathie. Zum gegenwärtigen Zeitpunkt sind keine klaren Aussagen zum zugrundeliegenden Mechanismus der entstehenden Herzschädigung in Folge einer Top2b-Deletion zu treffen. Es gibt jedoch Hinweise darauf, dass der Tumorsuppressormarker p53 eine wichtige Rolle in der Entstehung der dilatativen Kardiomyopathie spielen könnte. So konnte 8 Wochen nach der Top2b-Deletion mittels Chromatin-Immunpräzipitation eine erhöhte Bindung von p53 an Promotorregionen von Col1a1, Tgfβ2 und Mmp2 detektiert werden. Die Bedeutung dieser Bindung, und ob aufgrund dessen die Entstehung der Fibrose erklärt werden könnte, ist zum jetzigen Zeitpunkt unklar.rn

Ease of Application of Medical Compression-stocking Systems for the Treatment of Venous Ulcers

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the ease of application of two-piece, graduated, compression systems for the treatment of venous ulcers. METHODS: Four kits used to provide limb compression in the management of venous ulcers were evaluated. These have been proven to be non-inferior to various types of bandages in clinical trials. The interface pressure exerted above the ankle by the under-stocking and the complete compression system and the force required to pull the over-stocking off were assessed in vitro. Ease of application of the four kits was evaluated in four sessions by five nurses who put stockings on their own legs in a blinded manner. They expressed their assessment of the stockings using a series of visual analogue scales (VASs). RESULTS: The Sigvaris Ulcer X((R)) kit provided a mean interface pressure of 46 mmHg and required a force in the range of 60-90 N to remove it. The Mediven((R)) ulcer kit exerted the same pressure but required force in the range of 150-190 N to remove it. Two kits (SurePress((R)) Comfort and VenoTrain((R)) Ulcertec) exerted a mean pressure of only 25 mmHg and needed a force in the range of 100-160 N to remove them. Nurses judged the Ulcer X and SurePress kits easiest to apply. Application of the VenoTrain kit was found slightly more difficult. The Mediven kit was judged to be difficult to use. CONCLUSIONS: Comparison of ease of application of compression-stocking kits in normal legs revealed marked differences between them. Only one system exerted a high pressure and was easy to apply. Direct comparison of these compression kits in leg-ulcer patients is required to assess whether our laboratory findings correlate with patient compliance and ulcer healing.

Adequacy of venous thromboprophylaxis in acutely ill medical patients (IMPART): multisite comparison of different clinical decision support systems

BACKGROUND: The adequacy of thromboprophylaxis prescriptions in acutely ill hospitalized medical patients needs improvement. OBJECTIVE: To prospectively assess the efficacy of thromboprophylaxis adequacy of various clinical decision support systems (CDSS) with the aim of increasing the use of explicit criteria for thromboprophylaxis prescription in nine Swiss medical services. METHODS: We randomly assigned medical services to a pocket digital assistant program (PDA), pocket cards (PC) and no CDSS (controls). In centers using an electronic chart, an e-alert system (eAlerts) was developed. After 4 months, we compared post-CDSS with baseline thromboprophylaxis adequacy for the various CDSS and control groups. RESULTS: Overall, 1085 patients were included (395 controls, 196 PC, 168 PDA, 326 eAlerts), 651 pre- and 434 post-CDSS implementation: 472 (43.5%) presented a risk of VTE justifying thromboprophylaxis (31.8% pre, 61.1% post) and 556 (51.2%) received thromboprophylaxis (54.2% pre, 46.8% post). The overall adequacy (% patients with adequate prescription) of pre- and post-CDSS implementation was 56.2 and 50.7 for controls (P = 0.29), 67.3 and 45.3 for PC (P = 0.002), 66.0 and 64.9 for PDA (P = 0.99), 50.5 and 56.2 for eAlerts (P = 0.37), respectively, eAlerts limited overprescription (56% pre, 31% post, P = 0.01). CONCLUSION: While pocket cards and handhelds did not improve thromboprophylaxis adequacy, eAlerts had a modest effect, particularly on the reduction of overprescription. This effect only partially contributes to the improvement of patient safety and more work is needed towards institution-tailored tools.

[Body-packer ; body-stuffer - a medical challenge]

Since the seventies, the practice of drug smuggling in the form of body packing has increased in the Western world. The goal of our study was to present an algorithm for the safe management of intracorporal drug transport based on clinical experience and current evidence. The retrospective study, conducted over the past four years in our hospital prison, analyzes and discusses the diagnostic and therapeutic concepts. Thirty-four patients hospitalized 37 times in a 48-month period were included. In 28 patients drug packages were identified. Only two patients suffered from serious complications. The study demonstrates that following a specifically designed management algorithm based on clinical experience and principles of evidence-based medicine can optimize risk management, improve quality assurance and patient safety.

Bilateral total knee arthroplasty in a patient with hemophilia A, high inhibitor titre and aneurysma spurium of the popliteal artery. A case report

The authors report on bilateral simultaneous knee arthroplasty in a 40-year-old male patient with haemophilia A, high inhibitor titre and an aneurysma spurium of the right popliteal artery. Both knees showed a fixed flexion deformity of 20 degrees. To build up haemostasis, treatment with activated prothrombin complex concentrate (APCC) and recombinant activated factor seven (rFVIIa) was initiated preoperatively. A tourniquet was used on both sides during the operation and factor VIII (FVIII) was administered to further correct coagulopathy. On the eleventh postoperative day the patient complained of increasing pain and pressure in the right knee. An ultrasound suggested aneurysm, which was confirmed by substraction angiography. Under the protection of rFVIIa the aneurysm could be coiled and further rehabilitation was uneventful. At one year post-op the patient presented a range of motion of 90/5/0 degrees for both knees and had returned to full time office work. This case indicates that haemophiliacs with high antibody titre and destruction of both knees can be operated on in one session in order to diminish the operative risk of two consecutive surgical procedures, thus allowing an effective rehabilitation programme. Because of the significant frequency of popliteal aneurysms, preoperative angiography is recommended.

Brain herniation in a patient with apparently normal intracranial pressure: a case report

Introduction Intracranial pressure monitoring is commonly implemented in patients with neurologic injury and at high risk of developing intracranial hypertension, to detect changes in intracranial pressure in a timely manner. This enables early and potentially life-saving treatment of intracranial hypertension. Case presentation An intraparenchymal pressure probe was placed in the hemisphere contralateral to a large basal ganglia hemorrhage in a 75-year-old Caucasian man who was mechanically ventilated and sedated because of depressed consciousness. Intracranial pressures were continuously recorded and never exceeded 17 mmHg. After sedation had been stopped, our patient showed clinical signs of transtentorial brain herniation, despite apparently normal intracranial pressures (less than 10 mmHg). Computed tomography revealed that the size of the intracerebral hematoma had increased together with significant unilateral brain edema and transtentorial herniation. The contralateral hemisphere where the intraparenchymal pressure probe was placed appeared normal. Our patient underwent emergency decompressive craniotomy and was tracheotomized early, but did not completely recover. Conclusions Intraparenchymal pressure probes placed in the hemisphere contralateral to an intracerebral hematoma may dramatically underestimate intracranial pressure despite apparently normal values, even in the case of transtentorial brain herniation.

Differences in access and patient outcomes across antiretroviral treatment clinics in the Free State province: a prospective cohort study

Objective. To assess differences in access to antiretroviral treatment (ART) and patient outcomes across public sector treatment facilities in the Free State province, South Africa. Design. Prospective cohort study with retrospective database linkage. We analysed data on patients enrolled in the treatment programme across 36 facilities between May 2004 and December 2007, and assessed percentage initiating ART and percentage dead at 1 year after enrolment. Multivariable logistic regression was used to estimate associations of facility-level and patient-level characteristics with both mortality and treatment status. Results. Of 44 866 patients enrolled, 15 219 initiated treatment within 1 year; 8 778 died within 1 year, 7 286 before accessing ART. Outcomes at 1 year varied greatly across facilities and more variability was explained by facility-level factors than by patient-level factors. The odds of starting treatment within 1 year improved over calendar time. Patients enrolled in facilities with treatment initiation available on site had higher odds of starting treatment and lower odds of death at 1 year compared with those enrolled in facilities that did not offer treatment initiation. Patients were less likely to start treatment if they were male, severely immunosuppressed (CD4 count ≤50 cells/μl), or underweight (<50 kg). Men were also more likely to die in the first year after enrolment. Conclusions. Although increasing numbers of patients started ART between 2004 and 2007, many patients died before accessing ART. Patient outcomes could be improved by decentralisation of treatment services, fast-tracking the most immunodeficient patients and improving access, especially for men.

Do new biologics meet the unmet medical need in rheumatoid arthritis? Safety and efficacy of abatacept following B-cell depletion

Sir, anti TNF-α agents (aTNFs) are the most commonly prescribed biological agents in RA. More recently abatacept (ABA), a T-cell costimulation modulator, and rituximab (RTX), a monoclonal antibody directed against CD20, have become available. Observational studies suggest that switching to a new drug class may be more effective in uncontrolled RA than switching to a class of biologics to which the patient had unsuccessfully been exposed [1]. Information about the efficacy and safety of cycling strategies through third-line biologics is lacking. This study aimed to analyse the effectiveness and safety of switching patients to ABA as the third biological class after failure of aTNF plus RTX. The Swiss Clinical Quality Management (SCQM) programme for RA is a longitudinal population-based cohort, which has been approved by the local ethics committees of all participating centres [2]. For this analysis, we collected all the …

Discretionary medical reporting of potentially unfit drivers: a questionnaire-based survey in Southeast Switzerland

In Switzerland, every physician has the right to report a patient that is potentially unfit to drive to the licensing authority without violating medical confidentiality. Verified information regarding physicians' attitudes concerning this discretionary reporting and the frequency of such reports are not available. In order to answer these questions, 635 resident physicians were sent a questionnaire. The response rate was 52%. On average, the responding physicians--for all specialties--reported 0.31 patients (SD 0.64, 95% CI 0.24-0.38) in the year before the survey and 1.00 patient (SD 1.74, 95% CI 0.81-1.20) in the past 5 years. Seventy-nine percent of the responding physicians indicated knowing the current legal requirements for driving in Switzerland. In applied logistic regression analysis, only two factors correlate significantly with reporting: male sex (odds ratio 5.4) and the specialty "general medicine" (odds ratio 3.4). Ninety-seven percent of the physicians were against abolishing medical discretionary reporting and 29% were in favor of introducing mandatory reporting. The great majority of the questioned physicians supported the discretionary reporting of drivers that are potentially unfit to drive as currently practiced in Switzerland. The importance and the necessity of a regular traffic medicine-related continuing education for medical professionals are shown by the low number of reports per physician.

Approach to the patient with drug allergy

Clinicians commonly encounter patients who report to have drug allergy. In a large part, such allergy corresponds to adverse drug reactions, which are not immune mediated. The incriminated drug need not always be avoided for further therapy. On the other hand, drug allergy may manifest in many unexpected clinical pictures and thus not be recognized. There is no single standardized diagnostic test to confirm the immune-mediated mechanism and to identify the causative drug. Therefore, immune-mediated drug hypersensitivity reactions and their causative drugs have to be considered by the constellation of exposure, timing, and clinical features, including the pattern of organ manifestation. Prior experience with the drug is also an important feature. An allergologic workup with additional investigation may provide some help. Patients should be informed carefully about their drug allergy, whereby symptoms, drug that elicits reaction, modes of diagnosis of drug allergy, and possibly alternatives should be indicated in their allergy passport.