Democrazia, empatia, letteratura. Incontrare, scoprire, ascoltare l'altro nei contesti di educazione formale

La riflessione sulle competenze democratiche è viva negli ultimi anni (Consiglio d’Europa, 2018; Legge 92/2019; Unesco, 2015) e il ruolo dell’educazione nel promuoverle è considerato cruciale. Lo studio qui presentato si è proposto di indagare empiricamente se e come una specifica competenza democratica – quella empatica – possa essere promossa nei contesti educativi formali grazie a esperienze di lettura di narrativa letteraria. A partire dalla lettura in chiave fenomenologica del concetto di empatia (Boella, 2006, 2018; Stein 1917/2014; Zahavi, 2011, 2014) e dalle evidenze della ricerca – che mettono in evidenza alcuni elementi della lettura di narrativa letteraria in grado di sostenere il processo empatico (Cohen, 2001; Hakemulder, 2000, 2004; Keen, 2006; Kidd & Castano, 2013, 2017) – è stato elaborato un disegno di ricerca empirica avente l’obiettivo di comprendere se le esperienze di lettura in ambito scolastico possano configurarsi come “palestre di empatia” e se vi siano fattori in grado di facilitare (oppure ostacolare) tale processo. È stato utilizzato un approccio qualitativo fenomenologico. Sono stati analizzati (con l’ausilio di un code-book) i testi scritti di studenti (N=356), raccolti in 3 scuole (secondarie di I e II grado) del Nord/Centro Italia, durante gli anni scolastici 20-21 e 21-22. I testi riguardano la relazione instaurata con i personaggi narrativi. I dati mostrano che le esperienze di lettura di narrativa letteraria possono essere occasioni di allenamento delle competenze empatiche, ma sottolineano anche come ciò non sia scontato, lineare o automatico. Il manifestarsi dell’empatia narrativa richiede impegno, tempo, testi capaci di far incontrare la ricchezza e la complessità dell’esperienza umana e spazi di confronto (intimo e con gli altri) critico e riflessivo. La mediazione dell’insegnante è chiamata in causa a più riprese ed emerge l’importanza di specifiche competenze disciplinari, pedagogiche e riflessive, da sviluppare e coltivare incessantemente.

Silence and writing: the voices that inhabit us (Woolf, Duras, Perec, Celati)

My thesis investigates the forms, modalities and issues related to the notion of 'silence' in the texts and poetics of Virginia Woolf, Marguerite Duras, Georges Perec and Gianni Celati. This study relates to the 20th century European context and is set within the framework of music-literary studies, since silence is an acoustic phenomenon that concerns the whole word, thus also the written word. The material is structured according to a distribution that firstly involves the construction of a methodological framework that employs music-literary studies, the philosophy of language, the aesthetics of reception and psychoanalytic trauma studies; secondly, an analysis of some of the autobiographical works of the mentioned writers was undertaken, with a particular focus on the notion of trauma associated with silence; thirdly, the focus was placed on the theme of silence in the novelistic and fictional writings of the same authors; finally, a reflection on the poetics and aesthetics of silence was proposed. This study, which brings together several perspectives on silence, aims to shed light, through a comparative and transmedial approach, on the necessity of silence that is inherent in the word, and not a phenomenon opposed to it.

Audience attitudes towards simil sync: a pilot study

This thesis is based on a pilot investigation which explores the attitudes of a sample of Italian viewers towards the simil sync technique which in Italy is used for the dub of non-fictional television contents. The thesis seeks to analyse and define the characteristics of this dubbing modality which is often considered by scholars and professionals in the dubbing industry a hybrid modality of standard synchronised dubbing and voice-over. In order to investigate viewers’ attitudes, I organised 4 focus groups sessions which, due to the impact of Covid-19 pandemic, were carried out online. The online recruitment of participants, which was a difficult task, resulted in a small sample of eighteen participants (and two interviewees). The four online focus groups revealed that participants were aware of the simil sync technique. They recognised that the clips were dubbed in a different modality from standard synchronised dubbing. The characteristic that was mostly mentioned for detecting simil sync was the original soundtrack that was audible below the dub, followed by the identification of the genre of the programme in the clip and the absence of lip sync. Moreover, while simil sync with a barely audible original soundtrack received neutral or positive attitudes, simil sync with a more audible original soundtrack, instead, was tolerated or considered annoying. Simil sync passed unnoticed in the in-depth interviews in which the discussion about dubbing was not focused on the distinction between two dubbing modalities, for instance simil sync versus standard synchronised dubbing, but rather on the distinction between programmes that originated in Italian and those that were translated into Italian from another language and then dubbed.

Mocku for change: an explorative study on the use of “mockumentary” as a new language for climate change education

In the ‘society of acceleration and uncertainty’ (Rosa, 2013), the young are struggling to interpret our complex and fast-changing world. The entity and the velocity of changes are so enormous that we need new narratives or languages to conceptualise them. Among those changes “Climate Change” is placed in a particular difficult position. As the writer A. Ghosh said: “The current climate crisis is also a crisis of culture, and thus of the imagination”. In fact, in today’s literature and cinema a strong dichotomy exists between fictional and non-fictional works, but none of those extremities seems suitable to picture an “adequate representation” of climate change issues, particularly those that are related to future. The main goal of my study, carried out within FEDORA EU project, was to understand to what extent the hybrid film form called “mockumentary” (a language that adopts the aesthetics of factual production to give an illusion of truth to invented stories) could inspire and help students in overcoming the mentioned dichotomy, working as a tool to foster the development of argumentative and imaginative skills needed to picture “immaginary yet realistic” climate change scenarios.

It's a matter of culture: analyzing worldbuilding in Avatar: The Last Airbender.

This dissertation is going to analyze culture in media and the role it plays in worldbuilding, taking into account one of the most-loved franchises in western animation, Avatar: The Last Airbender. Moreover, it wants to provide a different perspective on culture, posing the focus on the products consumed by many on a daily basis. First of all, this dissertation will start by trying to give “culture” itself a definition, focusing on two works of literature from which it will draw its analysis related to worldbuilding: Agar’s cultures in comparison and Hofstede’s model of culture. Then, it will move on to the concept of worldbuilding – what we define as worldbuilding, and how it mixes with culture. We will comment on how worldbuilding has gotten more attention with growing online communities and how it could make or break a franchise, with the example of the Divergent saga. Finally, it will move on to the main case study, Avatar: The Last Airbender, which will be analyzed from a cultural standpoint, underlining the role worldbuilding plays in it, and there will be a focus on nonverbal communication in animated media.