Are We Sims? How Computer Simulations Represent and What this Means for the Simulation Argument

N. Bostrom’s simulation argument and two additional assumptions imply that we are likely to live in a computer simulation. The argument is based upon the following assumption about the workings of realistic brain simulations: The hardware of a computer on which a brain simulation is run bears a close analogy to the brain itself. To inquire whether this is so, I analyze how computer simulations trace processes in their targets. I describe simulations as fictional, mathematical, pictorial, and material models. Even though the computer hardware does provide a material model of the target, this does not suffice to underwrite the simulation argument because the ways in which parts of the computer hardware interact during simulations do not resemble the ways in which neurons interact in the brain. Further, there are computer simulations of all kinds of systems, and it would be unreasonable to infer that some computers display consciousness just because they simulate brains rather than, say, galaxies.

Socrates on the Moral Mischief of Misology

In Plato’s dialogues, the Phaedo, Laches, and Republic, Socrates warns his interlocutors about the dangers of misology. Misology is explained by analogy with misanthropy, not as the hatred of other human beings, but as the hatred of the logos or reasonable discourse. According to Socrates, misology arises when a person alternates between believing an argument to be correct, and then refuting it as false. If Socrates is right, then misanthropy is sometimes instilled when a person goes from trusting people to learning that others sometimes betray our reliance and expectations, and finally not to placing any confidence whatsoever in other people, or, in the case of misology, in the correctness or trustworthiness of arguments. A cynical indifference to the soundness of arguments generally is sometimes associated with Socrates’ polemical targets, the Sophists, at least as Plato represents Socrates’ reaction to these itinerant teachers of rhetoric, public speaking and the fashioning of arguments suitable to any occasion. Socrates’ injunctions against misology are largely moral, pronouncing it ‘shameful’ and ‘very wicked’, and something that without further justification we must ‘guard against’, maintaining that we will be less excellent persons if we come to despise argument as lacking the potential of leading to the truth. I examine Socrates’ moral objections to misology which I show to be inconclusive. I consider instead the problem of logical coherence in the motivations supposedly underlying misology, and conclude that misology as Socrates intends the concept is an emotional reaction to argumentation on the part of persons who have not acquired the logical dialectical skills or will to sort out good from bad arguments. We cannot dismiss argument as directed toward the truth unless we have a strong reason for doing so, and any such argument must itself presuppose that at least some reasoning can be justified in discovering and justifying belief in interesting truths. The relevant passages from Socrates’ discussion of the soul’s immortality in the Phaedo are discussed in detail, and set in scholarly background against Socrates’ philosophy more generally, as represented by Plato’s dialogues. I conclude by offering a suggestive list of practical remedies to avoid the alienation from argument in dialectic with which Socrates is concerned.

The TIM translocase in T. brucei contains Rhomboid-like proteins that are essential for mitochondrial protein import

The parasitic protozoon Trypanosoma brucei is one of the earliest branching eukaryotes that have mitochondria capable of oxidative phosphorylation. Their protein import systems are of similar complexity yet different composition than those in other eukaryotes. To elucidate the composition of the trypanosomal translocase of the inner mitochondrial membrane (TIM) we performed CoIPs of epitope-tagged TbTim17 and two other candidates in combination with SILAC-based quantitative mass spectrometry. This led to the identification of ten candidates for core TIM subunits. Eight of them were present in the previously determined inner membrane proteome and four show homology to small Tim chaperones. Three candidates, a trypanosomatid-specific 42 kDa protein (Tim42) and two putative orthologues of inactive rhomboid proteases were analyzed further. All three proteins are essential in both life cycle stages and their ablation results in a strong protein import defect in vivo and in vitro. Blue native PAGE revealed their presence in a high molecular weight complex. Unlike anticipated, trypanosomes have a highly complex TIM translocase that has extensively been redesigned. None of the three novel TIM subunits has ever been associated with mitochondrial protein import. Two of them belong to the rhomboid protease family, a member of which recently has been implicated in the ERAD translocation system. This suggests an exciting analogy between protein translocases of mitochondria and the ER.

The TIM translocase in T. brucei contains Rhomboid-like proteins that are essential for mitochondrial protein import

The parasitic protozoon Trypanosoma brucei is often considered as one of the earliest branching eukaryotes that have mitochondria capable of oxidative phosphorylation. Its protein import systems are therefore of great interest. Recently, it was shown that the outer mitochondrial membrane protein translocase is of similar complexity yet different composition than in other eukaryotes (1). In the inner membrane however, only a single orthologue of the pore forming Tim17/22/23 protein family was identified and termed TbTim17. Based on this finding it has been suggested that, instead of separate TIM22 and TIM23 complexes as in other eukaryotes, trypanosomes may have a single multifunctional translocase of the inner mitochondrial membrane (TIM) of reduced complexity. To elucidate the composition of the trypanosomal TIM complex we performed co-immunoprecipitations (CoIP) of epitope-tagged TbTim17 in combination with SILAC-based quantitative mass spectrometry. This led to the identification of 22 highly enriched TbTim17-interacting proteins. We tagged two of the top-scoring proteins for reciprocal CoIP analyses and recovered a set of ten proteins that are highly enriched in all three CoIPs. These proteins are excellent candidates for core subunits of the trypanosomal TIM complex. Eight of them were present in the previously determined inner membrane proteome and four show homology to small Tim chaperones. Three candidates, a novel trypanosomatid-specific 42 kDa protein, termed Tim42, and two putative orthologues of probably inactive rhomboid proteases were chosen for further analysis. All three proteins are essential in both life cycle stages and in a cell line that can grow in the absence of mitochondrial DNA. Additionally, their ablation by RNAi results in a strong protein import defect both in vivo and in vitro. Blue native PAGE reveals that Tim42, like TbTim17 is present in a high molecular weight complex. Moreover, ablation of either Tim42 or TbTim17 leads to a destabilization of the complex containing the other protein, suggesting a tight interaction of the two proteins. In summary our study shows that unlike anticipated trypanosomes have a highly complex TIM translocase that has extensively been redesigned. We have characterized three novel TIM subunits that have never been associated with mitochondrial protein import before. Two of them belong to the rhomboid protease family, a member of which recently has been implicated in the ERAD translocation system. Our study provides insight into mitochondrial evolution over large phylogenetic distances and suggests an exciting analogy between protein translocation systems of mitochondria and the ER.

Polar Nature of Biomimetic Fluorapatite/Gelatin Composites: A Comparison of Bipolar Objects and the Polar State of Natural Tissue

The correspondence of the state of alignment of macromolecules in biomimetic materials and natural tissues is demonstrated by investigating a mechanism of electrical polarity formation: An in vitro grown biomimetic FAp/gelatin composite is investigated for its polar properties by second harmonic (SHGM) and scanning pyroelectric microscopy (SPEM). Hexagonal prismatic seed crystals formed in gelatin gels represent a monodomain polar state, due to aligned mineralized gelatin molecules. Later growth stages, showing dumbbell morphologies, develop into a bipolar state because of surface recognition by gelatin functionality: A reversal of the polar alignment of macromolecules, thus, takes place close to that basal plane of the seed. In natural hard tissues (teeth and bone investigated by SPEM) and the biomimetic FAp/gelatin composite, we find a surprising analogy in view of growth-induced states of polarity: The development of polarity in vivo and in vitro can be explained by a Markov-type mechanism of molecular recognition during the attachment of macromolecules.

Newton-Cartan supergravity with torsion and Schrödinger supergravity

We derive a torsionfull version of three-dimensional N=2 Newton-Cartan supergravity using a non-relativistic notion of the superconformal tensor calculus. The “superconformal” theory that we start with is Schrödinger supergravity which we obtain by gauging the Schrödinger superalgebra. We present two non-relativistic N=2 matter multiplets that can be used as compensators in the superconformal calculus. They lead to two different off-shell formulations which, in analogy with the relativistic case, we call “old minimal” and “new minimal” Newton-Cartan supergravity. We find similarities but also point out some differences with respect to the relativistic case.

Ernährungssicherheit in der Schweiz

Viele Länder verankern die Versorgungs- oder Ernährungssicherheit als staatspolitisches Ziel in ihrem Grundgesetz. Neuerdings wird auch das Recht auf Nahrung und auf die Erfüllung weiterer Grundbedürfnisse aufgeführt. Das Schweizer Parlament hat darüber hinaus sogar den Grundsatz der Ernährungssouveränität im Landwirtschaftsgesetz verankert. Die zur Förderung dieser Ziele genannten Aufgaben und Eingriffsrechte des Staates sind jeweils unterschiedlich und unterschiedlich präzise formuliert. Dabei gibt es für jedes Land eigentlich nur zwei Möglichkeiten zur Ernährung: Inlandproduktion und Einfuhr. Eine zusätzliche Option ist die Bildung von Nahrungsmittelreserven zur Überbrückung von Versorgungsengpässen. Die Schweiz benützt und fördert alle drei Möglichkeiten zu ihrer Ernährungssicherheit, im Wesentlichen mit vier Politiken: Versorgungs-, Aussenwirtschafts-, Agrar- und Entwicklungspolitik. Bei Störungen sollen die durch Grenzabgaben finanzierten Pflichtlager während rund sechs Monaten die Inlandnachfrage sichern. Die Optimierung und die Abstimmung unter den verschiedenen Sektorpolitiken, welche unter Berücksichtigung der internationalen Rahmenbedingungen eine grösstmögliche Ernährungssicherheit herbeiführen, gehört zu den Kernaufgaben jedes Staates. Die Umsetzung der genannten Sektorpolitiken ist jedoch in der Praxis nicht immer kohärent, geschweige denn konfliktfrei. Dieser Artikel beschreibt zunächst die internationalen rechtlichen und ökonomischen Parameter für die Schweizer Versorgungspolitik und ihre Beziehung zur Wirtschaftsfreiheit im Allgemeinen, und speziell auf ihre Zweckmässigkeit hinsichtlich der Ernährungssicherheit. Die Analyse der Wechselwirkungen und der Konflikte bei der Umsetzung zeigt, dass die Schweizer Ernährungssicherheitspolitik (food security) in Wirklichkeit eine Politik zur einheimischen Produzentensicherheit ist (farm security). Den Abschluss bilden einige Vorschläge zur Minderung der sektorpolitischen Inkohärenzen und der festgestellten negativen Auswirkungen der Agrarpolitik auf die Schweizer und globale Ernährungssicherheit.

MOUSE MAMMARY TUMOR VIRUS-RELATED PROTEINS: ISOLATION AND CHARACTERIZATION OF A UNIQUE GLYCOPROTEIN

Mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV) contained six major proteins, identified as gp55, gp33, p25, pp20, p12, and p10. Immunoprecipitation of cytoplasmic extracts from MMTV-infected, pulse-labeled cells identified three MMTV core-specific precursor proteins, termed Pr78('gag), Pr110('gag), Pr110('gag), and Pr180('gag+). The major intracellular core-specific precursor polyprotein, Pr78('gag), contained antigenic determinants and tryptic peptides characteristic of p25, p12, and p10. Pr110('gag) contained all but one of the leucine-containing tryptic peptides of Pr78('gag), plus several additional peptides. In addition to Pr78('gag) and Pr110('gag), monospecific antisera to virion p12 and p25 also precipitated from pulse-labeled cells a small amount of Pr180('gag+). This large polyprotein contained nearly all of the leucine-containing tryptic peptides of Pr78('gag) and Pr110('gag) plus several additional peptides. By analogy to type-C viral systems, Pr180('gag+) is presumed to represent a gag-pol-specific common precursor which is the major translation product in the synthesis of MMTV RNA-dependent-DNA polymerase. Immunoprecipitation of cytoplasmic extracts from pulse-labeled cells with antisera to gp55 identified two envelope-specific proteins, designated gPr76('env) and gP79('env). The major envelope-specific precursor, gPr76('env), could be labeled with radioactive glucosamine and contained antigenic determinants and tryptic peptides characteristic of gp55 and gp33. A quantitatively minor glycoprotein, gP79('env), contained both fucose and glucosamine and was precipitable from cytoplasmic extracts with monospecific serum to gp55. It is suggested that gP79('env) represents fucosylated gPr76('env) which is transiently synthesized and cleaved rapidly into gp55 and gp33.^ A glycoprotein of 130,00 molecular weight (gP130) was precipitable from the cytoplasm of GR-strain mouse mammary tumor cells by a rabbit antiserum (anti-MMTV) to Gr-strain mouse mammary tumors virus (GR-MMTV). Two dimensional thin layer analysis of ('35)S-methionine-containing peptides revealed that five of nine gp33 peptides and one of seven gp55 peptides were shared by gP130 and gPr76('env). Six of ten p25 peptides and four more core-related peptides were shared by Pr78('gag) and gP130. Protein gP130 also contained several tryptic peptides not found in gPr76('env), or in the core protein precursors Pr78('gag), Pr110('gag), or Pr180('gag+). both gP130 and a second protein, p30, were found in immunoprecipitates of detergent disrupted, isotopically labeled GR-MMTV treated with anti-MMTV serum. Results suggest that antibodies to gP130 in the anti-MMTV serum are capable of recognizing those protein sequences which are not related to viral structural proteins. These gP130-unique peptides are evidently host specific. Polyproteins consisting of juxtaposed host- and virus-related protein tracts have been implicated in the process of cell transformation in other mammalian systems. Therefore, gP130 may be instrinsic to the oncogenic potential of MMTV. ^

Equity Markets, the Money Market, and Long-Run Monetary Neutrality

This paper outlines a process for teaching long-run neutrality of money, drawing an analogy between equity markets and the money market. The key points in the discussion include the following: (1) What is the price of money? (2) Why does the long-run demand for money trace out a rectangular hyperbola? (3) Why does the slow adjustment of goods and service prices to changes in the stock of money lead to a different short-run demand for money? and (4) Why does a successful currency reform generate similar short-run movements in the price of money as movements in equity share prices after a change in the supply of shares? I have used this approach successfully for over 30 years at all levels, wherever I need to discuss the money market in a macroeconomic model.

Diatoms, total organic carbon, and total nitrogen of sediment core Dethlingen, Germany

To provide insights into the long-term evolution of aquatic ecosystems without human interference, we here evaluate a decadal- to centennial-scale-resolution diatom record spanning about 12 ka of the Holsteinian interglacial (Marine Isotope Stage 11c). Using a partially varved sediment core from the Dethlingen palaeolake (northern Germany), which has previously been studied for palynological and microfacies signals, we document the co-evolution of the aquatic and surrounding terrestrial environment. The diatom record is dominated by the genera Stephanodiscus, Aulacoseira, Ulnaria and Fragilaria. Based on the diatom assemblages and physical sediment properties, the evolution of the Dethlingen palaeolake can be subdivided into three major phases. During the oldest phase (lasting ~1900 varve years), the lake was ~10-15 m deep and characterized by anoxic bottom-water conditions and a high nutrient content. The following ~5600 years exhibited water depths >20 m, maximum diatom and Pediastrum productivity, and a peak in allochtonous nutrient input. During this phase, water-column mixing became more vigorous, resulting in a breakdown of anoxia. The youngest lake phase (~4000-5000 years) was characterized by decreasing water depth, turbulent water conditions and decreased nutrient loading. Based on our palaeolimnological data, we conclude that the evolution of the Dethlingen palaeolake during the Holsteinian interglacial responded closely to (i) changes within the catchment area (as documented by vegetation and sedimentation) related to the transition from closed forests growing on nutrient-rich soils (mesocratic forest phase) to open forests developing on poor soils (oligocratic forest phase), and (ii) short-term climate variability as reflected in centennial-scale climate perturbations.

Geochemistry of minerals from lavas of ODP Leg 135 holes

We use Nomarski differential interference contrast imaging to reveal the wealth of complex detail in plagioclase zoning for selected samples from Sites 834, 839, and 841. All sites contain some plagioclase with the very complex internal core zoning, convolute zoning, or very fine-scale euhedral oscillatory zoning of the sort generally considered typical of island-arc volcanic rocks. Plagioclase with contrasted zoning styles may coexist within a single lithologic unit or even within a single thin section. Especially notable is the presence of scattered plagioclase phenocrysts with complex zoning throughout Unit 7 in Hole 834B, which in other respects is relatively uniform in composition and appears to have had little or no differential sorting of crystals and liquid. Although our study is by no means comprehensive, it is sufficient to indicate that magmatic conditions have been variable during crystallization of these rocks, and mixing or at least minor contamination may be required to explain some of the relations observed. By analogy with experimental studies, it is possible that variations in water content, either over time or within different parts of a chamber or conduit system, have contributed to the observed contrasts in zoning.

“Miram concordia et harmonia" : la relación naturaleza-persona en San Buenaventura

El presente trabajo muestra la analogía bonaventuriana en términos de distancia y espejo, señalando las instancias argumentativas a través de las cuales se llega al concepto de naturaleza entendido como expresión de Dios. Pero además, esta similitudo, a diferencia de la imagen, es cualidad pura común a todos los seres, y designa un modo eminente de participación en la perfección divina, que se imprime en un despliegue trinitario ad intra (Logos) a la vez que se expresa en la creación ad extra. Estos momentos metafísicos de impressio-expressio conforman la propia realidad divina y la posibilidad de acceso a ella por parte de la naturaleza participada. En la Distinción 25 de su Comentario a las Sentencias de Pedro Lombardo, Buenaventura hará uso de un concepto de analogía propio para explicar la relación entre Persona-divina y persona-creatura, en un ámbito ante todo metafísico que sobrepasa los aspectos preteológico y cosmológico. Por ello, además de permitirnos esclarecer la diferencia entre naturaleza y persona-creatura, la importancia de esta analogía planteada por Buenaventura radica en que proporciona una respuesta particular a la oposición naturaleza-Dios, en la que la diferencia no significa exclusión, sino, maravillosa concordia y harmonía".

El conocimiento humano acerca de Dios según el pensamiento de Alberto Magno

La cuestión sobre la posibilidad de conocer naturalmente algo acerca de Dios fue abordada por numerosos pensadores medievales. El tema no era sencillo, pues requería considerar los alcances del intelecto humano, elaborar argumentos sensatos que conduzcan a Dios y encontrar un modo adecuado de expresión. El propósito del presente trabajo es indagar los planteos de Alberto Magno sobre esta inquietante cuestión y exponer algunas de sus ideas más destacadas.

Instituciones y cultura política : un ensayo sobre dificultades de la democracia argentina

Pasados veinte años de la reinstalación de la democracia, se hace una reflexión de los sentidos que la democracia ha tenido en la historia argentina. La analogía con pacto civilizatorio, en el sentido freudiano de reconocimiento de la ley, es un punto de partida metafórico para observar cómo a través del tiempo el pacto originario sufrió no sólo cambios en su significación, sino quiebres y rupturas que condujeron a estados de violencia cada vez más profundos, rompiendo con las formas de convivencia ciudadana. La focalización del último período democrático pondera a través del relato de los procesos políticos, no sólo las expectativas y desilusiones ciudadanas, sino los avances y limitaciones institucionales de los últimos veinte años.

El argumento de contigüidad ontológica : antecedentes neoplatónicos y dionisianos y su resolución en Tomás de Aquino

El argumento de contigüidad ontológica, utilizado en varios pasajes de la Opera Omnia tomasiana, expresa la existencia de una afinidad metafísica entre los seres del universo, según la cual la realidad es comprendida jerárquicamente como una analogía de entes que se ordenan en cascadas descendentes hasta el último grado, en la cual la naturaleza inferior, en lo superior de sí “toca" a lo inferior de la naturaleza superior («Natura inferior secundum supremum sui attingit infimum naturae superioris») cada nivel tiene su origen en la atenuación del grado superior inmediato. El rastreo de este principio y su análisis permitió estructurar la tesis según el esquema expuesto en este trabajo.