Causal Warrant for Realism about Particle Physics

While scientific realism generally assumes that successful scientific explanations yield information about reality, realists also have to admit that not all information acquired in this way is equally well warranted. Some versions of scientific realism do this by saying that explanatory posits with which we have established some kind of causal contact are better warranted than those that merely appear in theoretical hypotheses. I first explicate this distinction by considering some general criteria that permit us to distinguish causal warrant from theoretical warrant. I then apply these criteria to a specific case from particle physics, claiming that scientific realism has to incorporate the distinction between causal and theoretical warrant if it is to be an adequate stance in the philosophy of particle physics.

Independencia y educación. Reflexiones en torno al Bicentenario

[spa]El trabajo que presentamos plantea una visión de la educación tras la llamada sublevación de los Pasquines que aparecieron en la ciudad de Santa Fe de Bogotá en 1794. En el artículoanalizamos las propuestas quese ofrecieron por parte de lasautoridades coloniales para hacer frentea los problemasque afectaron al virreinato.Una de las soluciones propuestas para acabar con las opiniones adversas a la corona y al colonialismo pasaba por cambiar los sistemas educativos. Se pretendía volver al sistema anterior a la ilustración y a los nuevos filósofos ya que se temía que en España pasara lo que había sucedido en Francia. La Nueva Filosofía acabó cuestionando los derechos de la monarquía y el descontento social acabó con la vida del monarca y la proclamación de la república. Estas ideas pasaron a las colonias españolas donde algunos ilustrados comenzaban a pensar en repúblicas, poco definidas, cuestionando el orden monárquico. Para evitar el conflicto desde el arzobispado, y la Audiencia se propone acabar con los estudios de la Nueva Filosofía, cerrar las imprentas y la Biblioteca; así mismo, se propone intervenir en el catecismo de la doctrina para introducir preguntas y respuestas que refuercen el papel dela corona y la fidelidad de los súbditos. Este sistema de fidelización de súbditos será empleado posteriormente por las recientes repúblicas para incrementar el patriotismo entre los nuevos ciudadanos.

Forensic science culture

Heretofore the issue of quality in forensic science is approached through a quality management policy whose tenets are ruled by market forces. Despite some obvious advantages of standardization of methods allowing interlaboratory comparisons and implementation of databases, this approach suffers from a serious lack of consideration for forensic science as a science. A critical study of its principles and foundations, which constitutes its culture, enables to consider the matter of scientific quality through a new dimension. A better understanding of what pertains to forensic science ensures a better application and improves elementary actions within the investigative and intelligence processes as well as the judicial process. This leads to focus the attention on the core of the subject matter: the physical remnants of the criminal activity, namely, the traces that produce information in understanding this activity. Adapting practices to the detection and recognition of relevant traces relies on the apprehension of the processes underlying forensic science tenets (Locard, Kirk, relevancy issue) and a structured management of circumstantial information (directindirect information). This is influenced by forensic science education and training. However, the lack of homogeneity with regard to the scientific nature and culture of the discipline within forensic science practitioners and partners represents a real challenge. A sound and critical reconsideration of the forensic science practitioner's roles (investigator, evaluator, intelligence provider) and objectives (prevention, strategies, evidence provider) within the criminal justice system is a means to strengthen the understanding and the application of forensic science. Indeed, the whole philosophy is aimed at ensuring a high degree of excellence, namely, a dedicated scientific quality.

Let's share perspectives! Mentalistic skills involved in cooperation = ¿A tu Izquierda o a la Mía? Habilidades Mentalistas Implicadas en la Cooperación

Previous research has found a link between theory of mind and cooperation. The aim of this study is to deepen into this relationship, to identify which theory of mind skills are more related to the cooperative capacity on a referential communication task. A total of 50 children from first and fifth grade completed a battery of theory of mind tasks, and also a cooperative task where children worked in pairs to build block models. Each pair was composed by a builder and a guide, who gave instructions to his partner about how to build a replica of the model. The results show a significant relationship between the theory of mind skills and cooperation. Specifically, we found that the second-order false-belief task was the variable most related to cooperation after controlling the effect of age. In addition, we observed that the mentalist skills were more important for cooperation in the builders than in the guides. Finally, we discuss the findings of this study and make suggestions for the future

Semantics-supported cooperative learning for enhanced awareness

Awareness is required for supporting all forms of cooperation. In Computer Supported Collaborative Learning (CSCL), awareness can be used for enhancing collaborative opportunities across physical distances and in computer-mediated environments. Shared Knowledge Awareness (SKA) intends to increase the perception about the shared knowledge, students have in a collaborative learning scenario and also concerns the understanding that this group has about it. However, it is very difficult to produce accurate awareness indicators based on informal message exchange among the participants. Therefore, we propose a semantic system for cooperation that makes use of formal methods for knowledge representation based on semantic web technologies. From these semantics-enhanced repository and messages, it could be easier to compute more accurate awareness.

Climate Change, Neutrality and the Harm Principle

This paper aims at evaluating the compatibility of coercive climate policies with liberal neutrality. More precisely, it focuses on the doctrine of state neutrality as associated with the "harm principle". It argues that given the difficulty of attributing causal responsibilities for climate harms to individuals, the harm principle doesn't work in this case, at least if one endorses a liberal atomistic ontology. Furthermore, the definition of what constitutes climate harms implies making moral assumptions, which makes it impossible to justify climate policies in a neutral way. Finally, the paper shows another consequence of applying neutrality to the case of climate change, that is the risk of a shift from political forms of decision-making to technocracy. Focusing too much on liberty of choice may (paradoxically) be to the detriment of political freedom. The paper concludes that climate change is an intrinsically moral issue and that it should be the occasion of a political debate about our current values and lifestyles. It should not be reduced to a mere question of carbon metric.

The Challenges Of Implementing High Performance Work Practices In The Nonprofit Sector

The last economic crisis raised huge challenges for nonprofit organizations. It is now critical for nonprofit organizations to show not only their social legitimacy but also their efficiency and competency to claim for grants (Kearns, Bell, Deem, & McShane, 2012). High Performance Work Practices (HPWP) are a way to foster performance and thus to answer challenges nonprofit organizations are currently facing. However, such practices have until then only been considered for the corporate world. The entire philosophy behind nonprofit organizations contrasts radically from the for-profit sector. Human resources management in particular may differ as well. The aim of this article is precisely to analyze the challenges of implementing HPWP in nonprofit organizations. In order to explore those challenges, we study the HR practices of a nonprofit organization based in UK that struggles against poverty. Discussion of results highlights good practices that should be applied along the nonprofit sector.

Educació moral: la via (no només) aristotèlica

Quin és el plantejament essencial que Aristòtil fa de l"educació moral? Podem dir que manté la seva eventual vigència històrica, si més no com a proposta? Es tracta d"un plantejament isolat, o podem trobar-ne epígons (més enllà de la inspiració més o menys aristotèlica que aquests tinguin)? El text que segueix pretén donar una resposta esquemàtica a les anteriors preguntes, i, de retruc, plantejar un repte conceptual (i, al capdavall, també pràctic) a tots aquells que puguin desqualificar la proposta aristotèlica per considerar-la corruptora dels principis liberals.

Finitud y duración

Este artículo presenta una articulación de las ideas de duración, cosmicidad, proximidad y finitud a modo de puntos definidores de un ethos cercano al de la sostenibilidad y contrapuesto al Gestell heideggeriano de la técnica moderna, al nihilismo indistante del consumismo y a la retórica de la innovación tecnológica.

Independencia y educación. Reflexiones en torno al Bicentenario

[spa]El trabajo que presentamos plantea una visión de la educación tras la llamada sublevación de los Pasquines que aparecieron en la ciudad de Santa Fe de Bogotá en 1794. En el artículoanalizamos las propuestas quese ofrecieron por parte de lasautoridades coloniales para hacer frentea los problemasque afectaron al virreinato.Una de las soluciones propuestas para acabar con las opiniones adversas a la corona y al colonialismo pasaba por cambiar los sistemas educativos. Se pretendía volver al sistema anterior a la ilustración y a los nuevos filósofos ya que se temía que en España pasara lo que había sucedido en Francia. La Nueva Filosofía acabó cuestionando los derechos de la monarquía y el descontento social acabó con la vida del monarca y la proclamación de la república. Estas ideas pasaron a las colonias españolas donde algunos ilustrados comenzaban a pensar en repúblicas, poco definidas, cuestionando el orden monárquico. Para evitar el conflicto desde el arzobispado, y la Audiencia se propone acabar con los estudios de la Nueva Filosofía, cerrar las imprentas y la Biblioteca; así mismo, se propone intervenir en el catecismo de la doctrina para introducir preguntas y respuestas que refuercen el papel dela corona y la fidelidad de los súbditos. Este sistema de fidelización de súbditos será empleado posteriormente por las recientes repúblicas para incrementar el patriotismo entre los nuevos ciudadanos.

El mestre ignorant: la filosofia de l'educació de Joseph Jacotot

El mestre ignorant és, per definició, la condició d"impossibilitat de la pedagogia. Potser no de tota, però sí de la pedagogia, almenys tal com l"hem entès fins ara (suposant que es pugui entendre absolutament d"una altra manera sense estar parlant ja d"una altra cosa). És per això que, com a màxim, només en els seus marges hi podria tenir lloc una proposta com la que glossaré aquí. Una proposta que, bo i partint de les idees de Joseph Jacotot (1770-1840), planteja la contingència del mestre, és a dir, que a l"hora d"aprendre uns continguts fa prescindible la figura d"algú que els expliqui. En altres paraules, fa que aquells que volen aprendre alguna cosa no hagin de dependre d"un mestre que ho hagi après abans, ni del mestre que va ensenyar aquell mestre, i així successivament, trencant d"aquesta manera el cercle de la transmissió pedagògica - almenys pel que fa al procés instructiu. Tanmateix, això és només la punta de l"iceberg i més avall hi aprofundirem. Però fem ara una mirada enrere, tot just quan se li van presentar a Jacotot els seus primers deixebles belgues per estudiar francès.