Orbital debris mitigation through deorbiting with passive electrodynamic drag

The increase of orbital debris and the consequent proliferation of smaller objects through fragmentation are driving the need for mitigation strategies. The issue is how to deorbit the satellite with an efficient system that does not impair drastically the propellant budget of the satellite and, consequently, reduces its operating life. We have been investigating, in the framework of a European-Community-funded project, a passive system that makes use of an electrodynamics tether to deorbit a satellite through Lorentz forces. The deorbiting system will be carried by the satellite itself at launch and deployed from the satellite at the end of its life. From that moment onward the system operates passively without requiring any intervention from the satellite itself. The paper summarizes the results of the analysis carried out to show the deorbiting performance of the system starting from different orbital altitudes and inclinations for a reference satellite mass. Results can be easily scaled to other satellite masses. The results have been obtained by using a high-fidelity computer model that uses the latest environmental routines for magnetic field, ionospheric density, atmospheric density and a gravity field model. The tether dynamics is modelled by considering all the main aspects of a real system as the tether flexibility and its temperature-dependent electrical conductivity. Temperature variations are computed by including all the major external and internal input fluxes and the thermal flux emitted from the tether. The results shows that a relatively compact and light system can carry out the complete deorbit of a relatively large satellite in a time ranging from a month to less than a year starting from high LEO with the best performance occurring at low orbital inclinations.

Analog mitigation of out of band strong interferers in wide band acquisition for multiband HF transmissions

It is clear that in the near future much broader transmissions in the HF band will replace part of the current narrow band links. Our personal view is that a real wide band signal is infeasible in this environment because the usage is typically very intensive and may suffer interferences from all over the world. Therefore, we envision that dynamic multiband transmissions may provide better satisfactory performance. From the very beginning, we observed that real links with our broadband transceiver suffered interferences out of our multiband but within the acquisition bandwidth that degrade the expected performance. Therefore, we concluded that a mitigation structure is required that operates on severely saturated signals as the interference may be of much higher power. In this paper we address a procedure based on Higher Order Crossings (HOC) statistics that are able to extract most of the signal structure in the case where the amplitude is severely distorted and allows the estimation of the interference carrier frequency to command a variable notch filter that mitigates its effect in the analog domain.

Spatial domain mitigation of out of band strong interferers in HF wide band acquisition using analog beamforming principles

We envision that dynamic multiband transmissions taking advantage of the receiver diversity (even for collocated antennas with different polarization or radiation pattern) will create a new paradigm for these links guaranteeing high quality and reliability. However, there are many challenges to face regarding the use of broadband reception where several out of band (with respect to multiband transmission) strong interferers, but still within the acquisition band, may limit dramatically the expected performance. In this paper we address this problem introducing a specific capability of the communication system that is able to mitigate these interferences using analog beamforming principles. Indeed, Higher Order Crossing (HOCs) joint statistics of the Single Input ? Multiple Output (SIMO) system are shown to effectively determine the angle on arrival of the wavefront even operating over highly distorted signals.

Experimental results on multicarrier SIMO HF communications

Achieving reliable communication over HF channels is known to be challenging due to the particularly hostile propagation medium. To address this problem, diversity techniques were shown to be promising. In this paper, we demonstrate through experimental results the benefits of different diversity strategies when applied to multi-input-multi-output (MIMO) multicarrier systems. The performance gains of polarisation, space and frequency diversities are quantified using different measurement campaigns.

Efficiency improvement of HF communications using cognitive radio principles

Cognitive Radio principles can be applied to HF communications to make a more efficient use of the extremely scarce spectrum. In this contribution we focus on analyzing the usage of the available channels done by the legacy users, which are regarded as primary users since they are allowed to transmit without resorting any smart procedure, and consider the possibilities for our stations -over the HFDVL (HF Data+Voice Link) architecture- to participate as secondary users. Our goal is to enhance an efficient use of the HF band by detecting the presence of uncoordinated primary users and avoiding collisions with them while transmitting in different HF channels using our broad-band HF transceiver. A model of the primary user activity dynamics in the HF band is developed in this work. It is based on Hidden Markov Models (HMM) which are a powerful tool for modelling stochastic random processes, and is trained with real measurements from the 14 MHz band.

Optimization of Arq Parameters of Stanag 5066 for the HFDVL Modem

The reliability of bidirectional communication link can be guaranteed with Automatic Repeat Request Procedures (ARQ). The standard STANAG 5066 describes the ARQ procedure for HF communications that can either be applied to existing HF physical layers modems or adapted to future physical layer designs. In this contribution the physical layer parameters of an HF modem (HFDVL), developed by the authors over the last decade, are chosen to optimize the performance of the ARQ procedure described in STANAG 5066. Besides the interleaving length, constellation size and coding type, the OFDM-based HFDVL modem permits the selection of the number of receiver antennas. It will be shown that this parameter gives additional degrees of freedom and permits reliable communication over low SNR HF communication links.

Selection of CSI-based precoding techniques in the HF channel

Multi-carrier modulations are widely employed in ionospheric communications to mitigate the adverse effects of the HF channel. In this paper we show how performance achieved by these modulations can be further increased by means of CSIbased precoding techniques in the context of our research on interactive digital voice communications. Depending on communication constraints and channel parameters, we will show which of the studied modulations and precoding techniques to select so that to maximise performance.

A new basic effect in retarding potential analyzers

The Retarding Potential Analyzer (RPA) is the standard instrument for in situ measurement of ion temperature and other ionospheric parameters. The fraction of incoming ions rejected by a RPA produces perturbations that reach well ahead of a thin Debye sheath, a feature common to all collisionless, hypersonic flows past ion-rejecting bodies. This phenomenon is here found to result in a correction to Whipple’s classical law for the current characteristic of an ideal RPA sheath thin; inverse ram ion Mach number M-1, and ram angle of RPA aperture u, small or moderately small.

Electrodynamic Tethers For Planetary And De-orbiting Missions

Nuevas aplicaciones tecnológicas y científicas mediante amarras electrodinámicas son analizadas para misiones planetarias. i) Primero, se considera un conjunto de amarras cilíndricas en paralelo (veleros electrosolares) para una misión interplanetaria. Los iones provenientes del viento solar son repelidos por el alto potencial de dichas amarras generando empuje sobre el velero. Para conocer el intercambio de momento que provocan los iones sobre las amarras se ha considerado un modelo de potencial estacionario. Se ha analizado la transferencia orbital de la Tierra a Júpiter siguiendo un método de optimización de trayectoria indirecto. ii) Una vez que el velero se encuentra cerca de Júpiter, se ha considerado el despliegue de una amarra para diferentes objetivos científicos. iia) Una amarra podría ser utilizada para diagnóstico de plasmas, al ser una fuente efectiva de ondas, y también como un generador de auroras artificiales. Una amarra conductora que orbite en la magnetosfera jovial es capaz de producir ondas. Se han analizado las diferentes ondas radiadas por un conductor por el que circula una corriente constante que sigue una órbita polar de alta excentricidad y bajo apoápside, como ocurre en la misión Juno de la NASA. iib) Además, se ha estudiado una misión tentativa que sigue una órbita ecuatorial (LJO) por debajo de los intensos cinturones de radiación. Ambas misiones requiren potencia eléctrica para los sistemas de comunicación e instrumentos científicos. Las amarras pueden generar potencia de manera más eficiente que otros sistemas que utlizan paneles solares o sistemas de potencia de radioisótopos (RPS). La impedancia de radiación es necesaria para determinar la corriente que circula por todo el circuito de la amarra. En un modelo de plasma frío, la radiación ocurre principalmente en los modos de Alfven y magnetosónica rápida, mostrando un elevado índice de refracción. Se ha estudiado la impedancia de radiación en amarras con recubrimiento aislante para los dos modos de radiación y cada una de las misiones. A diferencia del caso ionosférico terrestre, la baja densidad y el intenso campo magnético que aparecen en el entorno de Júpiter consiguen que la girofrecuencia de los electrones sea mucho mayor que la frecuencia del plasma; esto hace que el espectro de potencia para cada modo se modifique substancialmente, aumentando la velocidad de Alfven. Se ha estimado también la impedancia de radiación para amarras sin aislante conductor. En la misión LJO, un vehículo espacial bajando lentamente la altitud de su órbita permitiría estudiar la estructura del campo magnético y composición atmosférica para entender la formación, evolución, y estructura de Júpiter. Adicionalmente, si el contactor (cátodo) se apaga, se dice que la amarra flota eléctricamente, permitiendo emisión de haz de electrones que generan auroras. El continuo apagado y encendido produce pulsos de corriente dando lugar a emisiones de señales, que pueden ser utilizadas para diagnóstico del plasma jovial. En Órbita Baja Jovial, los iones que impactan contra una amarra polarizada negativamente producen electrones secundarios, que, viajando helicoidalmente sobre las líneas de campo magnético de Júpiter, son capaces de alcanzar su atmósfera más alta, y, de esta manera, generar auroras. Se han identificado cuáles son las regiones donde la amarra sería más eficiente para producir auroras. iic) Otra aplicación científica sugerida para la misión LJO es la detección de granos cargados que orbitan cerca de Júpiter. Los electrones de alta energía en este ambiente pueden ser modelados por una distribucción no Maxwelliana conocida como distribución kappa. En escenarios con plasmas complejos, donde los campos eléctricos en Júpiter pueden acelerar las cargas hasta velocidades que superen la velocidad térmica, este tipo de distribuciones son muy útiles. En este caso las colas de las distribuciones de electrones siguen una ley de potencias. Se han estudiado las fluctuaciones de granos cargados para funciones de distribución kappa. iii) La tesis concluye con el análisis para deorbitar satélites con amarras electrodinámicas que siguen una Órbita Baja Terrestre (LEO). Una amarra debe presentar una baja probabilidad de corte por pequeño debris y además debe ser suficientemente ligero para que el cociente entre la masa de la amarra y el satélite sea muy pequeño. En este trabajo se estiman las medidas de la longitud, anchura y espesor que debe tener una amarra para minimizar el producto de la probabilidad de corte por el cociente entre las masas de la amarra y el satélite. Se presentan resultados preliminares del diseño de una amarra con forma de cinta para deorbitar satélites relativamente ligeros como Cryosat y pesados como Envisat. Las misiones espaciales a planetas exteriores y en el ámbito terrestre plantean importantes retos científico-tecnológicos que deben ser abordados y solucionados. Por ello, desde el inicio de la era espacial se han diseñando novedosos métodos propulsivos, sistemas de guiado, navegación y control más robustos, y nuevos materiales para mejorar el rendimiento de los vehículos espaciales (SC). En un gran número de misiones interplanetarias y en todas las misiones a planetas exteriores se han empleado sistemas de radioisótopos (RPS) para generar potencia eléctrica en los vehículos espaciales y en los rovers de exploración. Estos sistemas emplean como fuente de energía el escaso y costoso plutonio-238. La NASA, por medio de un informe de la National Academy of Science (5 de Mayo del 2009), expresó una profunda preocupación por la baja cantidad de plutonio almacenado, insuficiente para desarrollar todas las misiones de exploración planetaria planeadas en el futuro [81, 91]. Esta circustancia ha llevado a dicha Agencia tomar la decisión de limitar el uso de estos sistemas RPS en algunas misiones de especial interés científico y una recomendación de alta prioridad para que el Congreso de los EEUU apruebe el reestablecimiento de la producción de plutonio-238, -son necesarios cerca de 5 kg de este material radiactivo al año-, para salvaguardar las misiones que requieran dichos sistemas de potencia a partir del año 2018. Por otro lado, la Agencia estadounidense ha estado considerando el uso de fuentes de energía alternativa; como la fisión nuclear a través del ambicioso proyecto Prometheus, para llevar a cabo una misión de exploración en el sistema jovial (JIMO). Finalmente, dicha misión fue desestimada por su elevado coste. Recientemente se han estado desarrollando sistemas que consigan energía a través de los recursos naturales que nos aporta el Sol, mediante paneles solares -poco eficientes para misiones a planetas alejados de la luz solar-. En este contexto, la misión JUNO del programa Nuevas Fronteras de la NASA, cuyo lanzamiento fue realizado con éxito en Agosto de 2011, va a ser la primera misión equipada con paneles solares que sobrevolará Júpiter en el 2015 siguiendo una órbita polar. Anteriormente se habían empleado los antes mencionados RPS para las misiones Pioneer 10,11, Voyager 1,2, Ulysses, Cassini-Huygens y Galileo (todas sobrevuelos excepto Galileo). Dicha misión seguirá una órbita elíptica de alta excentricidad con un periápside muy cercano a Júpiter, y apoápside lejano, evitando que los intensos cinturones de radiación puedan dañar los instrumentos de navegación y científicos. Un tether o amarra electrodinámica es capaz de operar como sistema propulsivo o generador de potencia, pero también puede ser considerado como solución científicotecnológica en misiones espaciales tanto en LEO (Órbita Baja Terrestre) como en planetas exteriores. Siguiendo una perspectiva histórica, durante las misiones terrestres TSS-1 (1992) y TSS-1R (1996) se emplearon amarras estandard con recubrimiento aislante en toda su longitud, aplicando como terminal anódico pasivo un colector esférico para captar electrones. En una geometría alternativa, propuesta por J. R. Sanmartín et al. (1993) [93], se consideró dejar la amarra sin recubrimiento aislante (“bare tether”), y sin colector anódico esférico, de forma que recogiera electrones a lo largo del segmento que resulta polarizado positivo, como si se tratara de una sonda de Langmuir de gran longitud. A diferencia de la amarra estandard, el “bare tether” es capaz de recoger electrones a lo largo de una superficie grande ya que este segmento es de varios kilómetros de longitud. Como el radio de la amarra es del orden de la longitud de Debye y pequeño comparado con el radio de Larmor de los electrones, permite una recolección eficiente de electrones en el régimen OML (Orbital Motion Limited) de sondas de Langmuir. La corriente dada por la teoría OML varía en función del perímetro y la longitud. En el caso de una cinta delgada, el perímetro depende de la anchura, que debe ser suficientemente grande para evitar cortes producidos por debris y micrometeoritos, y suficientemente pequeño para que la amarra funcione en dicho régimen [95]. En el experimento espacial TSS-1R mencionado anteriormente, se identificó una recolección de corriente más elevada que la que predecía el modelo teórico de Parker- Murphy, debido posiblemente a que se utilizaba un colector esférico de radio bastante mayor que la longitud de Debye [79]. En el caso de una amarra “bare”, que recoge electrones a lo largo de gran parte de su longitud, se puede producir un fenómeno conocido como atrapamiento adiabático de electrones (adiabatic electron trapping) [25, 40, 60, 73, 74, 97]. En el caso terrestre (LEO) se da la condición mesotérmica en la que la amarra se mueve con una velocidad muy superior a la velocidad térmica de los iones del ambiente y muy inferior a la velocidad térmica de los electrones. J. Laframboise y L. Parker [57] mostraron que, para una función de distribución quasi-isotrópica, la densidad de electrones debe entonces ser necesariamente inferior a la densidad ambiente. Por otra parte, debido a su flujo hipersónico y a la alta polarización positiva de la amarra, la densidad de los iones es mayor que la densidad ambiente en una vasta región de la parte “ram” del flujo, violando la condición de cuasi-neutralidad,-en una región de dimensión mayor que la longitud de Debye-. La solución a esta paradoja podría basarse en el atrapamiento adiabático de electrones ambiente en órbitas acotadas entorno al tether. ABSTRACT New technological and scientific applications by electrodynamic tethers for planetary missions are analyzed: i) A set of cylindrical, parallel tethers (electric solar sail or e-sail) is considered for an interplanetary mission; ions from the solar wind are repelled by the high potential of the tether, providing momentum to the e-sail. An approximated model of a stationary potential for a high solar wind flow is considered. With the force provided by a negative biased tether, an indirect method for the optimization trajectory of an Earth-to-Jupiter orbit transfer is analyzed. ii) The deployment of a tether from the e-sail allows several scientific applications in Jupiter. iia) It might be used as a source of radiative waves for plasma diagnostics and artificial aurora generator. A conductive tether orbiting in the Jovian magnetosphere produces waves. Wave radiation by a conductor carrying a steady current in both a polar, highly eccentric, low perijove orbit, as in NASA’s Juno mission, and an equatorial low Jovian orbit (LJO) mission below the intense radiation belts, is considered. Both missions will need electric power generation for scientific instruments and communication systems. Tethers generate power more efficiently than solar panels or radioisotope power systems (RPS). The radiation impedance is required to determine the current in the overall tether circuit. In a cold plasma model, radiation occurs mainly in the Alfven and fast magnetosonic modes, exhibiting a large refraction index. The radiation impedance of insulated tethers is determined for both modes and either mission. Unlike the Earth ionospheric case, the low-density, highly magnetized Jovian plasma makes the electron gyrofrequency much larger than the plasma frequency; this substantially modifies the power spectrum for either mode by increasing the Alfven velocity. An estimation of the radiation impedance of bare tethers is also considered. iib) In LJO, a spacecraft orbiting in a slow downward spiral under the radiation belts would allow determining magnetic field structure and atmospheric composition for understanding the formation, evolution, and structure of Jupiter. Additionally, if the cathodic contactor is switched off, a tether floats electrically, allowing e-beam emission that generate auroras. On/off switching produces bias/current pulses and signal emission, which might be used for Jovian plasma diagnostics. In LJO, the ions impacting against the negative-biased tether do produce secondary electrons, which racing down Jupiter’s magnetic field lines, reach the upper atmosphere. The energetic electrons there generate auroral effects. Regions where the tether efficiently should produce secondary electrons are analyzed. iic) Other scientific application suggested in LJO is the in-situ detection of charged grains. Charged grains naturally orbit near Jupiter. High-energy electrons in the Jovian ambient may be modeled by the kappa distribution function. In complex plasma scenarios, where the Jovian high electric field may accelerate charges up superthermal velocities, the use of non-Maxwellian distributions should be considered. In these cases, the distribution tails fit well to a power-law dependence for electrons. Fluctuations of the charged grains for non-Mawellian distribution function are here studied. iii) The present thesis is concluded with the analysis for de-orbiting satellites at end of mission by electrodynamic tethers. A de-orbit tether system must present very small tether-to-satellite mass ratio and small probability of a tether cut by small debris too. The present work shows how to select tape dimensions so as to minimize the product of those two magnitudes. Preliminary results of tape-tether design are here discussed to minimize that function. Results for de-orbiting Cryosat and Envisat are also presented.

Tether radiation in Juno-type and circular-equatorial Jovian orbits

Wave radiation by a conductor carrying a steady current in both a polar, highly eccentric, low perijove orbit, as in NASA's planned Juno mission, and an equatorial low Jovian orbit (LJO) mission below the intense radiation belts, is considered. Both missions will need electric power generation for scientific instruments and communication systems. Tethers generate power more efficiently than solar panels or radioisotope power systems (RPS). The radiation impedance is required to determine the current in the overall tether circuit. In a cold plasma model, radiation occurs mainly in the Alfven and fast magnetosonic modes, exhibiting a large refraction index. The radiation impedance of insulated tethers is determined for both modes and either mission. Unlike the Earth ionospheric case, the low-density, highly magnetized Jovian plasma makes the electron gyrofrequency much larger than the plasma frequency; this substantially modifies the power spectrum for either mode by increasing the Alfven velocity. Finally, an estimation of the radiation impedance of bare tethers is considered. In LJO, a spacecraft orbiting in a slow downward spiral under the radiation belts would allow determining magnetic field structure and atmospheric composition for understanding the formation, evolution, and structure of Jupiter. Additionally, if the cathodic contactor is switched off, a tether floats electrically, allowing e-beam emission that generate auroras. On/off switching produces bias/current pulses and signal emission, which might be used for Jovian plasma diagnostics.

Science with an electrodynamic tether

Ionospheric interaction experiments using a conductive, fully bare tether are discussed. With an optimal design, requiring 1.15 mm diameter and 7.5 km full length for a collected current of 0.87 A at day conditions, the tether radiates 0.33 watts as Fast Magnetosonic waves and 0.16 watts as Alfven waves. Secondary keV electrons are produced over a 6.5 km length, giving raise to noticeable auroral effects in the D-layer, at low geomagnetic latitudes. A preliminary design of the experiment, to be implemented on either a satellite or a Station, has been carried out. An ejector gives an initial velocity to an end mass, a free spool of tether unwinding from that mass during a first stage of deployment; other phases are monitored through the tether velocity, driving a reel with an unwinding device.

Expectations from EMET and OESEE ground listening of possible EM events generated by the TSS 1R

On 22nd February '96, the space mission STS 75 started ,from the NASA facilities at Cape Canaveral. Such a mission consists in the launch of the shuttle Columbia in order to carry out two experiments in the space: the TSS 1R (Tethered Satellite Sistem 1 Refliight) and the USMP (United States Microgravity Payload). The TSS 1R is a replica of a similar mission TSS 1 '92. The TSS space programme is a bilateral scientific cooperation between the USA space agency NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Agency) and the ASI (Italian Space Agency. The TSS 1R system consists on the shuttle Columbia which deploys, up-ward, by means a conducting tether 20 km long, a spherical satellite (1.5 mt diameter) containing scientific instrumentation. This system, orbiting at about 300 km from the Earth's surface, represents, presently, the largest experimental space structure, Due to its dimensions, flexibility and conducting properties of the tether, the system interacts, in a quite complex manner, wih the earth magnetic field and the ionospheric plasma, in a way that the total system behaves as an electromagnetic radiating antenna as well as an electric power generator. Twelve scientific experiments have been assessed by US and Italian scientists in order to study the electro dynamic behaviour of the structure orbiting in the ionos phere. Two experiments have been prepared in the attempt to receive on the Earth's surface possible electromagnetic events radiated by the TSS 1R. The project EMET (Electro Magnetic Emissions from Tether),USA and the project OESEE (Observations on the Earth Surface of Electromagnetic Emissions) Italy, consist in a coordinated programme of passive detection of such possible EM emissions. This detection will supply the verification of some thoretical hypotheses on the electrodynamic interactions between the orbiting system, the Earth's magnetic field and the ionospheric plasma with two principal aims as the technological assesment of the system concept as well as a deeper knowledge of the ionosphere properties for future space applications. A theoretical model that keeps the peculiarities of tether emissionsis being developed for signal prediction at constant tether current. As a step previous to the calculation of the expected ground signal , the Alfven-wave signature left by the tether far back in the ionosphere has been determined. The scientific expectations from the combined effort to measure the entity of those perturbations will be outlined taking in to account the used ground track sensor systems.

Technology of bare tether current collection

The outstanding problem for useful applications of electrodynamic tethers is obtaining sufficient electron current from the ionospheric plasma. Bare tether collectors, in which the conducting tether itself, left uninsulated over kilometers of its length, acts as the collecting anode, promise to attain currents of 10 A or more from reasonably sized systems. Current collection by a bare tether is also relatively insensitive to drops in electron density, which are regularly encountered on each revolution of an orbit. This makes nighttime operation feasible. We show how the bare tether's high efficiency of current collection and ability to adjust to density variations follow from the orbital motion limited collection law of thin cylinders. We consider both upwardly deployed (power generation mode) and downwardly deployed (reboost mode) tethers, and present results that indicate how bare tether systems would perform as their magnetic and plasma environment varies in low earth orbit.

A correction to Whipple's law for ion-trap Current

We have analyzed a phenomenon heretofore ignored in the analyses of ion traps, which are used to determine ion temperature, among other plasma parameters, in planetary ionospheres: ions that are rejected by the trap perturb the plasma well ahead of the Debye sheath at the front of the trap.The determination of the perturbed plasma flow is found to depend on the fact that the ionospheric plasma be stable to quasineutral, ion-acoustic perturbations.

Performance of coupled ED-tether/ion thrsuter system

Use of propulsion systems that couple electyrodynamic tethers to ion thrusters, as suggested in the literature, is discussed. The system establishes electrical contact with the ionospheric plasma, at the anodic end of the tether, by ejecting ions instead of collecting electrons; also, the ion thruster adds its thrust to the Lorentz force on the tether. In this paper, we analyze the performance of this coupled system, as measured by the ratio of mission impulse (thrust times mission duration) to the overall system mass, which includes the power subsystem mass, the tether subsystem mass, and the propellant mass consumed in the ion thruster. It is shown that a tether acting by itself, collecting electrons at its anodic end, substantially outperforms the coupled system for times longer than a characteristic time of the ion thruster, for which propellant mass equals the power subsystem mass; for shorter times performances are shown to be similar.