The evolution of universities' relations with the business sector in Brazil: What national publications between 1980 and 2012 reveal

ABSTRACT This paper addresses the changes in university-industry relations in Brazil regarding innovation activities. It is based on a survey of articles published in major national journals or presented at the most relevant Brazilian and regional conferences, between 1980 and 2012. The year 1980 was chosen due to the creation of the Technological Innovation Offices (NITs), which was the first government initiative to encourage knowledge transfer from universities to companies; the second was the Innovation Act of 2004. Our assumption was that after the Act the number of academic papers on this subject would increase, bringing new ideas and propositions of models to enhance this relationship. The methodology employed a qualitative, exploratory approach, using bibliographical research and a bibliometric analysis of 247 papers. Literature review of international studies shows the discussion of problems and suggestions for improvements, while in Brazil there is still a debate on whether this collaboration should occur, and if this is a legitimate role for the university. Despite the numerical growth, the content analysis showed few papers on new configurations and procedures for partnership management. We conclude that university-industry relations are not a regular and totally accepted process in Brazilian public universities, which reflect an ideological bias against cooperation with firms.

Evolution of Ba and Role of Absorptive Capacity in Collaboration between MNCs and Chinese Universities in China

During the recent years, collaboration with Chinese universities has aroused growing interest among multinational companies (MNCs). Cross-cultural university-industry (U-I) collaboration creates various challenges in collaborative knowledge creation and innovation due to the differences e.g. between university and company motivation, objectives and activities. Also different values, norms, and means of actions result often in collisions and misunderstandings. This thesis examines the establishment of the relationships and the evolution of the collaboration between MNCs and Chinese universities. Empirical findings underscore that the partners in collaboration are required to possess research interest as well as capability to acquire, assimilate and exploit new external knowledge. Time and communication have a critical role in the evolution of the collaboration. In China the personal relationships, guanxi, play an important role. Collaborative knowledge creation requires a platform, Ba, which enables the creation of common understanding, commitment, trust and mutual respect. Empirical data has been collected through interviewing company experts and academe of Chinese universities from ICT and forest industries as well as attending panel discussions and meetings with the experts from the field of study.

Teknologiansiirto vuorovaikutuksena yliopistojen ja yritysten välillä - Systemaattinen kirjallisuuskatsaus

Tutkielman tavoitteena oli selvittää teknologiansiirrosta vuorovaikutusnäkökulmasta tehdyt empiiriset tutkimukset systemaattisen kirjallisuuskatsauksen avulla. Teoreettinen näkökulma perustui vuorovaikutteisten innovaatioverkostojen rakentamista yliopistojen, yritysten ja valtion välille korostavaan Triple Helix -viitekehykseen. Valtion ohjaava rooli rajattiin tutkielman ulkopuolelle. Tutkimuskysymykset olivat miten teknologiansiirtoa on empiirisesti tutkittu yliopistojen ja yritysten välisenä vuorovaikutuksena, mitkä ovat yliopistojen ja yritysten väliset vuorovaikutusmuodot ja miten teknologiansiirtoa kannattaisi tutkia. Tutkimuksista koostuva aineisto hankittiin systemaattisella kirjallisuushaulla. Aineisto rajattiin teknologiansiirtoa vuorovaikutusnäkökulmasta tutkineisiin empiirisiin tutkimuksiin. Analysointimenetelmänä käytettiin sisällönanalyysiä. Tulosten perusteella teknologiansiirron tutkimisen teoreettisia lähestymistapoja olivat yrittäjyyssuuntautuneisuuteen yliopistoissa kannustava ”entrepreneurial university” -suuntaus, innovaatiot ja innovaatiojärjestelmät, tutkijoiden ominaisuudet ja sosiaalinen pääoma, vuorovaikutus- ja tiedonsiirtoprosessit, organisationaalinen oppiminen ja yliopiston teknologiansiirtopolitiikat. Teknologiansiirtoa oli tutkittu enemmän yliopisto- kuin yritysnäkökulmasta. Tutkimuksista puolet otti huomioon hiljaisen tiedon siirrettävyyden vain vuorovaikutuksen avulla. Tutkielman tuloksena tunnistettiin 34 erilaista vuorovaikutusmuotoa teknologiansiirrossa yliopistojen ja yritysten välillä. Tutkituimmat vuorovaikutusmuodot olivat patentit ja lisenssit, asiantuntija-apu ja konsultointi, epämuodolliset kontaktit ja verkostot, yliopistojen spin-off-yritykset ja sopimustutkimus. Tutkimusyhteistyötä oli tutkittu suhteellisen vähän. Teknologiansiirron tehokkuutta kannattaisi tutkia yritysnäkökulmasta selvittämällä tutkimusyhteistyön ja innovaatioiden välinen yhteys. Teknologiansiirtoa vuorovaikutusprosessina kannattaisi tutkia kaikkien siihen osallistuvien sidosryhmien näkökulmista. Teknologiansiirtoprojektien onnistumiseen vaikuttavia tekijöitä voisi selvittää vertailevien tapaustutkimusten avulla. Tiedonsiirtoprosessiin liittyvää vuorovaikutusta ei prosessina kannattaisi tutkia irrallisena ilmiönä siihen liittyvistä tiedonsiirto-olosuhteista. Vuorovaikutusmuotojen määrä suomalaisessa teknologiansiirrossa olisi tutkimisen arvoinen asia. Vuorovaikutusmuotojen lukumäärän selvittämisellä voisi arvioida yhteistyösuhteen syvyyttä yliopistojen ja yritysten välillä. Yritykset tulisi nähdä aktiivisina toimijoina teknologiansiirrossa, ja teknologiansiirtoa tulisi tutkia myös yritysten näkökulmasta.

Conflict of Interest Policies at Canadian Universities and Medical Schools: Some Lessons from the AMSA PharmFree Scorecard

Article

Professors and the Management of Unavoidable Conflicts of Interest: Don’t Always Need the Heavy Artillery of Policy

Article

Sistemas de medição de desempenho para projetos de PD&I no Setor de Petróleo e Gás Natural

Organizations are seeking new ideas, tools and methods aiming to improve management process and performance. On the other hand, system performance measurement needs to portray organizational changes and provide managers with a set of true and more appropriate information for the decision-making process. This work aims to propose a performance measurement system in the academic field regarding Research, Development and Innovation (RDI) in the oil and gas industry. The research performed a bibliographic review in a descriptive exploratory manner. A field research was conducted with an expert focus group in order to gather new indicators. As for the validation of these indicators, a survey with experienced professional was also realized. The research surveyed four segments in and outside of the Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte-Brazil such as oil and gas project coordinators, staff at Academic Planning Offices, FUNPEC employees as well as coordinators from Petrobrás. The performance measuring system created from this study features three interrelated performance indicators pointed out as: process indicators, outcome indicators and global indicators. The proposal includes performance indicators that seek to establish more appropriate strategies for effective institution management. It might help policy making of university-industry interaction policies

Proposta de modelo de interação da Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte e empresas do setor de petróleo

Operational procedures may negatively interfere in negotiation and execution regarding universities and business companies. In some cases it may even derail business interaction. Thus, aiming to overcome this and other barriers a university-industry interaction model was structured. The model enhances the appropriation of technological solutions on behalf of enterprises, as well as aim to improve the quality of teaching and research done at the university. In order to conduct a case study, sampling considering the Federal University of Rio Grande do Norte (UFRN) was made as well as the Oil and Gas sector. For data collection questionnaires, classroom observation, document analysis, semi-structured interviews were used. The study describes the companies as well as the internal organization of UFRN in their interaction context. The diagnosis related to past interactions as well as the expectations of the companies and the university s internal subjects regarding the university-industry relationship were also studied. Thus, specific questionnaires were applied for the three types of groups: researchers, managers and business companies. These subjects pointed out that the great deal of barriers they identified were related to issues regarding the university internal management. Given these barriers, the critical factors were then identified in order to overcome this reality. Among the nine critical factors only one belongs to the macro environment, while the remaining factors are related to organizational issues present in the university context. It was possible to formulate a university-business interaction model one the researched focused on the case study results and contribution from a theoretical framework that was enabled trough literature review. The model considers all business collaboration mechanisms; it focuses on a particular strategic productive sector and provides a co-evolution vision over time, according to the sector´s development strategy. The need for institutionalizing the relationship with the companies involved is pointed out. The proposed model considers all the critical factors identified by the research; it aims long-term relationship with the company and integrates teaching, research and extension actions. The model implementation was also considered. It was seen that it must be done in three phases. The phases will be defined by the level of maturity in the relationship between the university and the companies. Thus, a framework was developed in order to assess the interaction level regarding company institutionalization. Whilst structuring the model was a concern with replication came up. It was pointed out that this model should not only serve to this specific case study situation. So the final result is a model of university-industry relationship appropriate in the first instance, for UFRN, but has applicability, in general, to any Brazilian university

A aplicação de uma sequencia didática: caixa eletrônico

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES)

Institutional Complexity and Technology Transfer: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis

This Doctoral Thesis unfolds into a collection of three distinct papers that share an interest in institutional theory and technology transfer. Taking into account that organizations are increasingly exposed to a multiplicity of demands and pressures, we aim to analyze what renders this situation of institutional complexity more or less difficult to manage for organizations, and what makes organizations more or less successful in responding to it. The three studies offer a novel contribution both theoretically and empirically. In particular, the first paper “The dimensions of organizational fields for understanding institutional complexity: A theoretical framework” is a theoretical contribution that tries to better understand the relationship between institutional complexity and fields by providing a framework. The second article “Beyond institutional complexity: The case of different organizational successes in confronting multiple institutional logics” is an empirical study which aims to explore the strategies that allow organizations facing multiple logics to respond more successfully to them. The third work “ How external support may mitigate the barriers to university-industry collaboration” is oriented towards practitioners and presents a case study about technology transfer in Italy.

Relaciones universidad-empresa : ¿y cuando la universidad es la empresa?

En el trabajo se analiza el caso del Laboratorio de Hemoderivados "Presidente Illia" de la Universidad Nacional de Córdoba (UNC- Hemoderivados), el cual resulta una experiencia relevante para reflexionar en torno a la denominada "relación universidad-empresa", uno de los tópicos más abordados por la literatura que se dedica al análisis de las relaciones entre universidad y sociedad.

Relaciones universidad-empresa : ¿y cuando la universidad es la empresa?

En el trabajo se analiza el caso del Laboratorio de Hemoderivados "Presidente Illia" de la Universidad Nacional de Córdoba (UNC- Hemoderivados), el cual resulta una experiencia relevante para reflexionar en torno a la denominada "relación universidad-empresa", uno de los tópicos más abordados por la literatura que se dedica al análisis de las relaciones entre universidad y sociedad.