ARCHITECTING USER-CENTRIC PRIVACY-AS-A-SET-OF-SERVICES: DIGITAL IDENTITY RELATED PRIVACY FRAMEWORK

AbstractDigitalization gives to the Internet the power by allowing several virtual representations of reality, including that of identity. We leave an increasingly digital footprint in cyberspace and this situation puts our identity at high risks. Privacy is a right and fundamental social value that could play a key role as a medium to secure digital identities. Identity functionality is increasingly delivered as sets of services, rather than monolithic applications. So, an identity layer in which identity and privacy management services are loosely coupled, publicly hosted and available to on-demand calls could be more realistic and an acceptable situation. Identity and privacy should be interoperable and distributed through the adoption of service-orientation and implementation based on open standards (technical interoperability). Ihe objective of this project is to provide a way to implement interoperable user-centric digital identity-related privacy to respond to the need of distributed nature of federated identity systems. It is recognized that technical initiatives, emerging standards and protocols are not enough to guarantee resolution for the concerns surrounding a multi-facets and complex issue of identity and privacy. For this reason they should be apprehended within a global perspective through an integrated and a multidisciplinary approach. The approach dictates that privacy law, policies, regulations and technologies are to be crafted together from the start, rather than attaching it to digital identity after the fact. Thus, we draw Digital Identity-Related Privacy (DigldeRP) requirements from global, domestic and business-specific privacy policies. The requirements take shape of business interoperability. We suggest a layered implementation framework (DigldeRP framework) in accordance to model-driven architecture (MDA) approach that would help organizations' security team to turn business interoperability into technical interoperability in the form of a set of services that could accommodate Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA): Privacy-as-a-set-of- services (PaaSS) system. DigldeRP Framework will serve as a basis for vital understanding between business management and technical managers on digital identity related privacy initiatives. The layered DigldeRP framework presents five practical layers as an ordered sequence as a basis of DigldeRP project roadmap, however, in practice, there is an iterative process to assure that each layer supports effectively and enforces requirements of the adjacent ones. Each layer is composed by a set of blocks, which determine a roadmap that security team could follow to successfully implement PaaSS. Several blocks' descriptions are based on OMG SoaML modeling language and BPMN processes description. We identified, designed and implemented seven services that form PaaSS and described their consumption. PaaSS Java QEE project), WSDL, and XSD codes are given and explained.

Development of a new tool for assessing health-related quality of life in patients with primary hyperparathyroidism.

BACKGROUND Several studies in recent years have evaluated Health Related Quality of Life (HRQoL) of patients with primary hyperparathyroidism (PHPT). No disease specific questionnaires are available to assess the impact of the disease. The aim of this research is to describe the development of a new disease specific Quality of Life (QoL) questionnaire for use specifically with PHPT patients. METHODS A conceptual model was developed describing the impact of the disease and its symptoms on QoL domains. A literature review was conducted to identify the most relevant domains. A focus group with experts was used to validate the domains; 24 patients were also interviewed to complement the information from the patient's perspective. A content analysis of the interviews was performed to identify items related with the impact of the disease, leading to PHPQoL-V.1 which was presented to a sample of 67 patients. Reliability was assessed by Cronbach's coefficient alpha and item-total score correlations. Validity was assessed by a factor analysis performed to determine the number of domains. Rasch analysis was carried out in order to refine the questionnaire items. RESULTS 259 items were extracted from the interviews that were subsequently reduced to 34 items. Cronbach's coefficient alpha was 0.92. The factor analysis extracted two domains (physical and emotional). After Rasch analysis the questionnaire PHPQoL-V.2 kept 16 items (9 physical and 7 emotional). The questionnaire was developed in a Spanish population and the final version was translated to English through translation and back-translation. CONCLUSION The first disease specific HRQoL questionnaire for PHPT patients (PHPQoL-16) has been developed. Validation studies designed to assess measurement properties of this tool are currently underway.

Intraocular penetration of penciclovir after oral administration of famciclovir: a population pharmacokinetic model.

OBJECTIVES: We developed a population model that describes the ocular penetration and pharmacokinetics of penciclovir in human aqueous humour and plasma after oral administration of famciclovir. METHODS: Fifty-three patients undergoing cataract surgery received a single oral dose of 500 mg of famciclovir prior to surgery. Concentrations of penciclovir in both plasma and aqueous humour were measured by HPLC with fluorescence detection. Concentrations in plasma and aqueous humour were fitted using a two-compartment model (NONMEM software). Inter-individual and intra-individual variabilities were quantified and the influence of demographics and physiopathological and environmental variables on penciclovir pharmacokinetics was explored. RESULTS: Drug concentrations were fitted using a two-compartment, open model with first-order transfer rates between plasma and aqueous humour compartments. Among tested covariates, creatinine clearance, co-intake of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors and body weight significantly influenced penciclovir pharmacokinetics. Plasma clearance was 22.8 ± 9.1 L/h and clearance from the aqueous humour was 8.2 × 10(-5) L/h. AUCs were 25.4 ± 10.2 and 6.6 ± 1.8 μg · h/mL in plasma and aqueous humour, respectively, yielding a penetration ratio of 0.28 ± 0.06. Simulated concentrations in the aqueous humour after administration of 500 mg of famciclovir three times daily were in the range of values required for 50% growth inhibition of non-resistant strains of the herpes zoster virus family. CONCLUSIONS: Plasma and aqueous penciclovir concentrations showed significant variability that could only be partially explained by renal function, body weight and comedication. Concentrations in the aqueous humour were much lower than in plasma, suggesting that factors in the blood-aqueous humour barrier might prevent its ocular penetration or that redistribution occurs in other ocular compartments.

Human capital and regional development

We investigate the determinants of regional development using a newly constructed database of 1569 sub-national regions from 110 countries covering 74 percent of the world s surface and 97 percent of its GDP. We combine the cross-regional analysis of geographic, institutional, cultural, and human capital determinants of regional development with an examination of productivity in several thousand establishments located in these regions. To organize the discussion, we present a new model of regional development that introduces into a standard migration framework elements of both the Lucas (1978) model of the allocation of talent between entrepreneurship and work, and the Lucas (1988) model of human capital externalities. The evidence points to the paramount importance of human capital in accounting for regional differences in development, but also suggests from model estimation and calibration that entrepreneurial inputs and possibly human capital externalities help understand the data.

Activation mechanisms of the protease MALT1 and cleavage of one of its targets - the ribonuclease Regnase-1- in lymphocytes and lymphoma cell lines

Persistent infection induces an adaptive immune response that is mediated by T and B lymphocytes. Upon triggering with an antigen, these cells become activated and turn into fast expanding cells able to efficiently defend the host. Lymphocyte activation is controlled by a complex composed of CARMA1, BCL10 and MALT1 which regulates the NF-KB signaling pathway upon antigen triggering. Abnormally high expression or activity of either one of these three proteins can favor the development of lymphomas, while genetic defects in the pathway are associated with immunodeficiency. MALT1 was identified as a paracaspase sharing homology with other cysteine proteases, namely caspases and metacaspases. In order to be active, caspases need to dimerize. Based on their sequence similarity with MALT1, we hypothesized that dimerization might also be a mechanism of activation employed by MALT1. To address this assumption, we performed a bioinformatics modelling based on the crystal structures of several caspases. Our model suggested that the MALT1 caspase-like domain can indeed form dimers. This finding was later confirmed by several published crystal structures of MALT1. In the dimer interface of our model, we noticed the presence of charged amino acids that could potentially form salt bridges and thereby hold both monomers together. Mutation of one of these residues, E549, into alanine completely blocked the catalytic activity of MALT1. Additionally, we provided evidence for a role of E549 in promoting the MALTl-dependent growth of cells derived from diffuse large B cell lymphoma (DLBCL) of the aggressive B cell-like type (ABC). To our initial surprise, the E549A mutation showed only a partial defect in dimerization, indicating that additional residues are essential to form a stable dimer. The MALT1 crystal structures revealed a key function for E549 in stabilizing the catalytic site of the protease via its interaction with an arginine which is located next to the catalytic active cysteine. In an additional study, we discovered that MALT1 monoubiquitination is required for the catalytic activity of the protease. Interestingly, we found that the MALT1 dimer interface mutant E549A could not be monoubiquitinated. Based on these findings, we suggest that correct formation of the dimer interface is a prerequisite for monoubiquitination. In a second project, we discovered a novel target of the protease MALT1, the ribonuclease Regnase¬la It was described that the RNase activity of Regnase-1 negatively regulates immune responses. We could show that in ABC DLBCL cell lines, Regnase-1 is not only cleaved by MALT1 but also phosphorylated, at least in part, by the inhibitor of KB kinase (IKK). Both regulations appear to restrain the RNase function of Regnase-1 and thereby allow the production of pro-survival proteins. In conclusion, our studies further highlight and explain the importance of the catalytic activity of MALT1 for the activation of lymphocytes and provide additional knowledge for the development of specific drugs targeting the catalytic activity of MALT1 for immunomodulation and treatment of lymphomas.  SUMMARY IN FRENCH PhD Thesis Katrin Cabalzar 2 SUMMARY IN FRENCH Une infection persistante induit une réponse immunitaire adaptative par l'intermédiaire des lymphocytes T et B. Quand elles reconnaissent l'antigène, ces cellules sont activées et se multiplient très rapidement pour défendre efficacement l'hôte. L'activation des lymphocytes est transmise par un complexe composé de trois protéines, CARMA1, BCL10 et MALT1, qui régule la voie de signalisation NF-KB lorsque l'antigène est reconnu. L'expression ou l'activité anormalement élevée de l'une de ces trois protéines peut favoriser le développement de lymphomes, tandis que des défauts génétiques de cette voie de signalisation sont associés à l'immunodéficience. MALT1 a été identifiée comme étant une paracaspase qui partage des séquences homologues avec d'autres protéases à cystéine, comme les caspases et les métacaspases. Pour être actives, les caspases ont besoin de dimériser. Etant donné leur similarité de séquence avec MALT1, nous avons supposé que la dimérisation pouvait aussi être un mécanisme d'activation utilisé par MALT1. Pour vérifier cette hypothèse, nous avons conçu un modèle bioinformatique à partir des structures cristallographiques de plusieurs caspases. Et notre modèle a suggéré que le domaine catalytique de MALT1 était effectivement capable de former des dimères. Cette découverte a été confirmée plus tard par des publications qui montrent des structures cristallographiques dimériques de MALT1. Dans l'interface du dimère de notre modèle, nous avons remarqué la présence d'acides aminés chargés qui pouvaient former des liaisons ioniques et ainsi réunir les deux monomères. La mutation de l'un de ces résidus, E549, pour une alanine, a complètement inhibé l'activité catalytique de MALT1. De plus, nous avons mis en évidence un rôle d'E549 dans la croissance dépendante de MALT1, des cellules dérivées de lymphomes B diffus à grandes cellules (DLBCL) de sous-type cellules B actives (ABC). Dans un premier temps nous avons été surpris de constater que cette mutation révélait seulement un défaut partiel de dimérisation, ce qui indique que des acides aminés supplémentaires sont indispensables pour former un dimère stable. Les structures cristallographiques de MALT1 ont révélé un rôle primordial d'E549 dans la stabilisation du site catalytique de la protéase via son interaction avec une arginine qui se trouve à côté de la cystéine du site actif. Dans une autre étude, nous avons découvert que la monoubiquitination de MALT1 est requise pour l'activité catalytique de la protéase. A remarquer que nous avons trouvé que le mutant E549A de l'interface dimère de MALT1 n'a pas pu être monoubiquitiné. Sur la base de ces résultats, nous suggérons que la formation correcte de l'interface du dimère est une condition préalable pour la monoubiquitination. Dans un second projet, nous avons découvert une nouvelle cible de la protéase MALT1, la ribonucléase Regnase-1. Il a été décrit que l'activité RNase de Regnase-1 régulait négativement les réponses immunitaires. Nous avons pu montrer que dans les lignées cellulaires ABC DLBCL, la Regnase-1 n'était pas seulement clivée par MALT1 mais également phosphorylée, au moins en partie, par la kinase de l'inhibiteur de KB (IKK). Les deux régulations semblent supprimer la fonction RNase de Regnase-1 et permettre ainsi la stabilisation de certains ARN messagers et la production de protéines favorisant la survie. En conclusion, nos études mettent en évidence le rôle-clé de la dimérisation de MALT1 et expliquent l'importance de l'activité catalytique de MALT1 pour l'activation des lymphocytes. Ainsi, nos résultats apportent des connaissances supplémentaires pour le développement de médicaments spécifiques ciblant l'activité catalytique de MALT1, qui pourraient être utiles pour modifier les réponses immunitaires et traiter des lymphomes.

Development of an Fn14 agonistic antibody as an anti-tumor agent.

TWEAK, a TNF family ligand with pleiotropic cellular functions, was originally described as capable of inducing tumor cell death in vitro. TWEAK functions by binding its receptor, Fn14, which is up-regulated on many human solid tumors. Herein, we show that intratumoral administration of TWEAK, delivered either by an adenoviral vector or in an immunoglobulin Fc-fusion form, results in significant inhibition of tumor growth in a breast xenograft model. To exploit the TWEAK-Fn14 pathway as a therapeutic target in oncology, we developed an anti-Fn14 agonistic antibody, BIIB036. Studies described herein show that BIIB036 binds specifically to Fn14 but not other members of the TNF receptor family, induces Fn14 signaling, and promotes tumor cell apoptosis in vitro. In vivo, BIIB036 effectively inhibits growth of tumors in multiple xenograft models, including colon (WiDr), breast (MDA-MB-231), and gastric (NCI-N87) tumors, regardless of tumor cell growth inhibition response observed to BIIB036 in vitro. The anti-tumor activity in these cell lines is not TNF-dependent. Increasing the antigen-binding valency of BIB036 significantly enhances its anti-tumor effect, suggesting the contribution of higher order cross-linking of the Fn14 receptor. Full Fc effector function is required for maximal activity of BIIB036 in vivo, likely due to the cross-linking effect and/or ADCC mediated tumor killing activity. Taken together, the anti-tumor properties of BIIB036 validate Fn14 as a promising target in oncology and demonstrate its potential therapeutic utility in multiple solid tumor indications.

The fate and persistence of Leishmania major in mice of different genetic backgrounds: an example of exploitation of the immune system by intracellular parasites.

Leishmania spp. are intracellular protozoan parasites that are delivered within the dermis of their vertebrate hosts. Within this peripheral tissue and the draining lymph node, they find and/or rapidly create dynamic microenvironments that determine their ultimate fate, namely their more or less successful expansion, and favour their transmission to another vertebrate host though a blood-feeding vector. Depending on their genetic characteristics as well as the genetic make-up of their hosts, once within the dermis Leishmania spp. very rapidly drive and maintain sustained T cell-dependent immune responses that arbitrate their ultimate fate within their hosts. The analysis of the parasitism exerted by Leishmania major in mice of different genetic backgrounds has allowed us to recognize some of the early and late mechanisms driven by this parasite that lead to either uncontrolled or restricted parasitism. Uncontrolled parasitism by Leishmania major characterizing mice from a few inbred strains (e.g. BALB/c) is associated with the expansion of parasite reactive Th2 CD4 lymphocytes and results from their rapid and sustained activity. In contrast, restricted parasitism characteristic of mice from the majority of inbred strains results from the development of a polarized parasite-specific Th1 CD4 response. This murine model of infection has already been and will continue to be particularly instrumental in dissecting the rules controlling the pathway of differentiation of T cells in vivo. In the long run, the understanding of these rules should contribute to the rational development of novel immunotherapeutic interventions against severe infectious diseases.

No complementation between TP53 or RB-1 and v-src in astrocytomas of GFAP-v-src transgenic mice.

Human low-grade astrocytomas frequently recur and progress to states of higher malignancy. During tumor progression TP53 alterations are among the first genetic changes, while derangement of the p16/p14ARF/RB-1 system occurs later. To probe the pathogenetic significance of TP53 and RB-1 alterations, we introduced a v-src transgene driven by glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) regulatory elements (which causes preneoplastic astrocytic lesions and stochastically astrocytomas of varying degrees of malignancy) into TP53+/- or RB-1+/- mice. Hemizygosity for TP53 or RB-1 did not increase the incidence or shorten the latency of astrocytic tumors in GFAP-v-src mice over a period of up to 76 weeks. Single strand conformation analysis of exons 5 to 8 of non-ablated TP53 alleles revealed altered migration patterns in only 3/16 tumors analyzed. Wild-type RB-1 alleles were retained in all RB-1+/-GFAP-v-src mice-derived astrocytic tumors analyzed, and pRb immunostaining revealed protein expression in all tumors. Conversely, the GFAP-v-src transgene did not influence the development of extraneural tumors related to TP53 or RB-1 hemizygosity. Therefore, the present study indicates that neither loss of RB-1 nor of TP53 confer a growth advantage in vivo to preneoplastic astrocytes expressing v-src, and suggests that RB-1 and TP53 belong to one single complementation group along with v-src in this transgenic model of astrocytoma development. The stochastic development of astrocytic tumors in GFAP-v-src, TP53+/- GFAP-v-src, and RB-1+/- GFAP-v-src transgenic mice indicates that additional hitherto unknown genetic lesions of astrocytes contribute to tumorigenesis, whose elucidation may prove important for our understanding of astrocytoma initiation and progression.

First level ontology - case study

The file contains the ontology created and instantiated according to a case study as well as a little explanation of the framework in which it is included.

Managing FOSS during development: preventive and curative approaches

Today, most software development teams use free and open source software (FOSS) components, because it increases the speed and the quality of the development. Many open source components are the de facto standard of their category. However, FOSS has licensing restrictions, and corporate organizations usually maintain a list of allowed and forbidden licenses. But how do you enforce this policy? How can you make sure that ALL files in your source depot, either belong to you, or fit your licensing policy? A first, preventive approach is to train and increase the awareness of the development team to these licensing issues. Depending on the size of the team, it may be costly but necessary. However, this does not ensure that a single individual will not commit a forbidden icon or library, and jeopardize the legal status of the whole release... if not the company, since software is becoming more and more a critical asset. Another approach is to verify what is included in the source repository, and check whether it belongs to the open-source world. This can be done on-the-fly, whenever a new file is added into the source depot. It can also be part of the release process, as a verification step before publishing the release. In both cases, there are some tools and databases to automate the detection process. We will present the various options regarding FOSS detection, how this process can be integrated in the "software factory", and how the results can be displayed in a usable and efficient way.

Data Collection Agent Framework

Ohjelmistoteollisuudessa pitkiä ja vaikeita kehityssyklejä voidaan helpottaa käyttämällä hyväksi ohjelmistokehyksiä (frameworks). Ohjelmistokehykset edustavat kokoelmaa luokkia, jotka tarjoavat yleisiä ratkaisuja tietyn ongelmakentän tarpeisiin vapauttaen ohjelmistokehittäjät keskittymään sovelluskohtaisiin vaatimuksiin. Hyvin suunniteltujen ohjelmistokehyksien käyttö lisää suunnitteluratkaisujen sekä lähdekoodin uudelleenkäytettävyyttä enemmän kuin mikään muu suunnittelulähestymistapa. Tietyn kohdealueen tietämys voidaan tallentaa ohjelmistokehyksiin, joista puolestaan voidaan erikoistaa viimeisteltyjä ohjelmistotuotteita. Tässä diplomityössä kuvataan ohjelmistoagentteihin (software agents) perustuvaa ohjelmistokehyksen suunnittelua toteutusta. Pääpaino työssä on vaatimusmäärittelyä vastaavan suunnitelman sekä toteutuksen kuvaaminen ohjelmistokehykselle, josta voidaan erikoistaa erilaiseen tiedonkeruuseen kykeneviä ohjelmistoja Internet ympäristöön. Työn kokeellisessa osuudessa esitellään myös esimerkkisovellus, joka perustuu työssä kehitettyyn ohjelmistokehykseen.

Siltanosturin mallinnusmenetelmien kehittäminen

Työn tarkoituksena oli selvittää kaupallisen dynamiikan simulointiohjelmiston (Adams) soveltuvuus siltanosturin mallintamiseen. Työn kohteena oli kaksipalkkinen siltanosturi, joka sijaitsi KCI:n tiloissa Hyvinkäällä. Nosturin jänneväli oli noin 19.5 metriä ja nostokyky 16 tonnia. Mallintamisessa keskityttiin nosturin dynamiikkaan sekä ohjausvoimiin nosturin kantopyörissä. Simulointitulokset verifioitiin mittauksin. Koska mallista haluttiin mahdollisimman yksinkertainen, mallinnettiin ainoastaan pääkannattajat ja köydet joustavina. Muut osat mallinnettiin jäykkinä. Yksinkertaisuuteen pyrittiin sen vuoksi, että mallia oli tarkoitus käyttää perustana komponenttikirjaston luomiseksi myöhempää käyttöä varten. Tuloksista todettiin mallin soveltuvan hyvin nosturin dynamiikan mallintamiseen. Mallista saatavat tulokset vastasivat hyvin mitattuja liikkeitä. Ohjausvoimia ei kuitenkaan saatu verifioitua. Käytetty mittausmenetelmä osoittautui sopimattomaksi.

Spectral Color Appearance Modeling

Kuvien laatu on tutkituimpia ja käytetyimpiä aiheita. Tässä työssä tarkastellaan värin laatu ja spektrikuvia. Työssä annetaan yleiskuva olemassa olevista pakattujen ja erillisten kuvien laadunarviointimenetelmistä painottaen näiden menetelmien soveltaminen spektrikuviin. Tässä työssä esitellään spektriväriulkomuotomalli värikuvien laadunarvioinnille. Malli sovelletaan spektrikuvista jäljennettyihin värikuviin. Malli pohjautuu sekä tilastolliseen spektrikuvamalliin, joka muodostaa yhteyden spektrikuvien ja valokuvien parametrien välille, että kuvan yleiseen ulkomuotoon. Värikuvien tilastollisten spektriparametrien ja fyysisten parametrien välinen yhteys on varmennettu tietokone-pohjaisella kuvamallinnuksella. Mallin ominaisuuksien pohjalta on kehitetty koekäyttöön tarkoitettu menetelmä värikuvien laadunarvioinnille. On kehitetty asiantuntija-pohjainen kyselymenetelmä ja sumea päättelyjärjestelmä värikuvien laadunarvioinnille. Tutkimus osoittaa, että spektri-väri –yhteys ja sumea päättelyjärjestelmä soveltuvat tehokkaasti värikuvien laadunarviointiin.

Non-Linear Journal Bearing Model for Analysis of Superharmonic Vibrations of Rotor Systems

A rotating machine usually consists of a rotor and bearings that supports it. The nonidealities in these components may excite vibration of the rotating system. The uncontrolled vibrations may lead to excessive wearing of the components of the rotating machine or reduce the process quality. Vibrations may be harmful even when amplitudes are seemingly low, as is usually the case in superharmonic vibration that takes place below the first critical speed of the rotating machine. Superharmonic vibration is excited when the rotational velocity of the machine is a fraction of the natural frequency of the system. In such a situation, a part of the machine’s rotational energy is transformed into vibration energy. The amount of vibration energy should be minimised in the design of rotating machines. The superharmonic vibration phenomena can be studied by analysing the coupled rotor-bearing system employing a multibody simulation approach. This research is focused on the modelling of hydrodynamic journal bearings and rotorbearing systems supported by journal bearings. In particular, the non-idealities affecting the rotor-bearing system and their effect on the superharmonic vibration of the rotating system are analysed. A comparison of computationally efficient journal bearing models is carried out in order to validate one model for further development. The selected bearing model is improved in order to take the waviness of the shaft journal into account. The improved model is implemented and analyzed in a multibody simulation code. A rotor-bearing system that consists of a flexible tube roll, two journal bearings and a supporting structure is analysed employing the multibody simulation technique. The modelled non-idealities are the shell thickness variation in the tube roll and the waviness of the shaft journal in the bearing assembly. Both modelled non-idealities may cause subharmonic resonance in the system. In multibody simulation, the coupled effect of the non-idealities can be captured in the analysis. Additionally one non-ideality is presented that does not excite the vibrations itself but affects the response of the rotorbearing system, namely the waviness of the bearing bushing which is the non-rotating part of the bearing system. The modelled system is verified with measurements performed on a test rig. In the measurements the waviness of bearing bushing was not measured and therefore it’s affect on the response was not verified. In conclusion, the selected modelling approach is an appropriate method when analysing the response of the rotor-bearing system. When comparing the simulated results to the measured ones, the overall agreement between the results is concluded to be good.

Tilastollinen tutkimus ohjelmiston laatuun vaikuttavista tekijöistä

Tämä työ on tehty osana MASTO-tutkimushanketta, jonka tarkoituksena on kehittää ohjelmistotestauksen adaptiivinen referenssimalli. Työ toteutettiin tilastollisena tutkimuksena käyttäen survey-menetelmää. Tutkimuksessa haastateltiin 31 organisaatioyksikköä eri puolelta suomea, jotka tekevät keskikriittisiä sovelluksia. Tutkimuksen hypoteeseina oli laadun riippuvuus ohjelmistokehitysmenetelmästä, asiakkaan osallistumisesta, standardin toteutumisesta, asiakassuhteesta, liiketoimintasuuntautuneisuudesta, kriittisyydestä, luottamuksesta ja testauksen tasosta. Hypoteeseista etsittiin korrelaatiota laadun kanssa tekemällä korrelaatio ja regressioanalyysi. Lisäksi tutkimuksessa kartoitettiin minkälaisia ohjelmistokehitykseen liittyviä käytäntöjä, menetelmiä ja työkaluja organisaatioyksiköissä käytettiin, ongelmia ja parannusehdotuksia liittyen ohjelmistotestaukseen, merkittävimpiä tapoja asiakkaan vaikuttamiseksi ohjelmiston laatuun sekä suurimpia hyötyjä ja haittoja ohjelmistokehityksen tai testauksen ulkoistamisessa. Tutkimuksessa havaittiin, että laatu korreloi positiivisesti ja tilastollisesti merkitsevästi testauksen tason, standardin toteutumisen, asiakasosallistumisen suunnitteluvaiheessa sekä asiakasosallistumisen ohjaukseen kanssa, luottamuksen ja yhden asiakassuhteeseen liittyvän osakysymyksen kanssa. Regressioanalyysin perusteella muodostettiin regressioyhtälö, jossa laadun todettiin positiivisesti riippuvan standardin toteutumisesta, asiakasosallistumisesta suunnitteluvaiheessa sekä luottamuksesta.