Detener el mar con un haz de juncos : La religión en la filosofía de David Hume

No resulta fácil desentrañar el pensamiento de un escéptico acerca de temas sobre los que prefiere abstenerse de formular juicios. Es el caso de David Hume y la religión.El filósofo escocés nacido en 1711 dejó varios escritos aludiendo al fenómeno, es decir, a la religión tal como existe de hecho, y manifestó su opinión crítica acerca de las distintas posturas intelectuales de su tiempo en torno a cuestiones religiosas. Pero siempre fue ambiguo e irónico cuando le tocó dejar asentado su propio juicio con respecto a este tema. La dificultad principal reside en que, para Hume, a quien podríamos considerar un ?escéptico mitigado?, los juicios correctos son aquellos que se ajustan a la estrecha capacidad del entendimiento humano, que no va más allá de los límites de la experiencia de la vida cotidiana. Muchos aspectos vinculados a la religión ?tales como la posibilidad de conocer de la esencia y los atributos divinos- exceden nuestras limitadas facultades y, si nos aventuramos a argumentar en ese ámbito, corremos el riesgo de caer en el error y la irracionalidad. Nuestra propuesta consiste en examinar cuál es la postura de Hume sobre los distintos problemas que presentan el conocimiento y la práctica vinculados con la religión. Respecto del conocimiento, las dificultades se plantean a la hora de determinar qué estatuto otorgarle a las creencias religiosas, cuál es el origen en nuestra mente de la religiosidad y cómo justificar por medio de argumentos la existencia y atributos de la divinidad. En cuanto a la práctica, Hume formula una serie de críticas a las actitudes e instituciones religiosas tal como se han dado históricamente a partir del análisis de las consecuencias que observa en la sociedad, de las que surge una contradicción entre un conjunto de principios respetables y un sinnúmero de acciones deplorables. Para examinar estas cuestiones es necesario tener en cuenta el punto de vista desde el que efectúa su análisis, que se vincula, como acabamos de mencionar, con el escepticismo mitigado. Finalmente, evaluaremos si es posible proponer alguna forma de religión que tenga el visto bueno de Hume y, en ese caso, qué características debería revestir. Para lograrlo, deberemos abrirnos paso entre su inteligente ironía y su excesiva prudencia.

Detener el mar con un haz de juncos : La religión en la filosofía de David Hume

No resulta fácil desentrañar el pensamiento de un escéptico acerca de temas sobre los que prefiere abstenerse de formular juicios. Es el caso de David Hume y la religión.El filósofo escocés nacido en 1711 dejó varios escritos aludiendo al fenómeno, es decir, a la religión tal como existe de hecho, y manifestó su opinión crítica acerca de las distintas posturas intelectuales de su tiempo en torno a cuestiones religiosas. Pero siempre fue ambiguo e irónico cuando le tocó dejar asentado su propio juicio con respecto a este tema. La dificultad principal reside en que, para Hume, a quien podríamos considerar un ?escéptico mitigado?, los juicios correctos son aquellos que se ajustan a la estrecha capacidad del entendimiento humano, que no va más allá de los límites de la experiencia de la vida cotidiana. Muchos aspectos vinculados a la religión ?tales como la posibilidad de conocer de la esencia y los atributos divinos- exceden nuestras limitadas facultades y, si nos aventuramos a argumentar en ese ámbito, corremos el riesgo de caer en el error y la irracionalidad. Nuestra propuesta consiste en examinar cuál es la postura de Hume sobre los distintos problemas que presentan el conocimiento y la práctica vinculados con la religión. Respecto del conocimiento, las dificultades se plantean a la hora de determinar qué estatuto otorgarle a las creencias religiosas, cuál es el origen en nuestra mente de la religiosidad y cómo justificar por medio de argumentos la existencia y atributos de la divinidad. En cuanto a la práctica, Hume formula una serie de críticas a las actitudes e instituciones religiosas tal como se han dado históricamente a partir del análisis de las consecuencias que observa en la sociedad, de las que surge una contradicción entre un conjunto de principios respetables y un sinnúmero de acciones deplorables. Para examinar estas cuestiones es necesario tener en cuenta el punto de vista desde el que efectúa su análisis, que se vincula, como acabamos de mencionar, con el escepticismo mitigado. Finalmente, evaluaremos si es posible proponer alguna forma de religión que tenga el visto bueno de Hume y, en ese caso, qué características debería revestir. Para lograrlo, deberemos abrirnos paso entre su inteligente ironía y su excesiva prudencia.

Stable oxygen and carbon isotope ratios and paleotemperature reconstructions from Inoceramus in Cretaceous sediments of DSDP Sites

Inoceramus is an epibenthic bivalve which lived in a wide variety of paleoenvironments encompassing a broad range of paleodepths. A survey of all Cretaceous sediments from Deep Sea Drilling Project legs 1-69 and 75 revealed over 500 Inoceramus specimens at twenty sites. Of these, 47 well-preserved Late Cretaceous specimens from the South Atlantic, Pacific and Indian Oceans were analyzed for oxygen and carbon isotopes. The specimens exhibit small internal isotopic variability and oxygen isotopic paleotemperatures that are consistent with a deep-sea habitat. Paleotemperatures ranging from 5 to 16°C show that Late Cretaceous oceans were significantly warmer than the present oceans. The data suggest that deep water was formed both by cooling at high latitudes and by evaporation in the subtropics.

Detener el mar con un haz de juncos : La religión en la filosofía de David Hume

No resulta fácil desentrañar el pensamiento de un escéptico acerca de temas sobre los que prefiere abstenerse de formular juicios. Es el caso de David Hume y la religión.El filósofo escocés nacido en 1711 dejó varios escritos aludiendo al fenómeno, es decir, a la religión tal como existe de hecho, y manifestó su opinión crítica acerca de las distintas posturas intelectuales de su tiempo en torno a cuestiones religiosas. Pero siempre fue ambiguo e irónico cuando le tocó dejar asentado su propio juicio con respecto a este tema. La dificultad principal reside en que, para Hume, a quien podríamos considerar un ?escéptico mitigado?, los juicios correctos son aquellos que se ajustan a la estrecha capacidad del entendimiento humano, que no va más allá de los límites de la experiencia de la vida cotidiana. Muchos aspectos vinculados a la religión ?tales como la posibilidad de conocer de la esencia y los atributos divinos- exceden nuestras limitadas facultades y, si nos aventuramos a argumentar en ese ámbito, corremos el riesgo de caer en el error y la irracionalidad. Nuestra propuesta consiste en examinar cuál es la postura de Hume sobre los distintos problemas que presentan el conocimiento y la práctica vinculados con la religión. Respecto del conocimiento, las dificultades se plantean a la hora de determinar qué estatuto otorgarle a las creencias religiosas, cuál es el origen en nuestra mente de la religiosidad y cómo justificar por medio de argumentos la existencia y atributos de la divinidad. En cuanto a la práctica, Hume formula una serie de críticas a las actitudes e instituciones religiosas tal como se han dado históricamente a partir del análisis de las consecuencias que observa en la sociedad, de las que surge una contradicción entre un conjunto de principios respetables y un sinnúmero de acciones deplorables. Para examinar estas cuestiones es necesario tener en cuenta el punto de vista desde el que efectúa su análisis, que se vincula, como acabamos de mencionar, con el escepticismo mitigado. Finalmente, evaluaremos si es posible proponer alguna forma de religión que tenga el visto bueno de Hume y, en ese caso, qué características debería revestir. Para lograrlo, deberemos abrirnos paso entre su inteligente ironía y su excesiva prudencia.

Oligocene to Pliocene palaeoclimate reconstructions from 18 sites in Hungary

A survey of the Neogene flora and vegetation pattern of the Pannonian domain based on 18 selected fossil plant assemblages is given. Flora and vegetation patterns are based on well-documented and studied fossil plant assemblages (macrofloras, primarily leaves). A general but slow cooling trend is definitely observable after the Early Miocene as reflected by both quantitative climate reconstructions and floristic change, i.e. decrease of diversity, slow disappearance of thermophilous and exotic elements, as well as decrease in the variety of vegetation types. A significant decline of coldest month temperatures (as compared to warmest month temperatures) must have played a defining role in forming flora and vegetation through the Neogene.

Holocene sea-surface reconstructions for the Californian margin

Time series of alkenone unsaturation indices gathered along the California margin reveal large (4° to 8°C) glacial-interglacial changes in sea surface temperature (SST) over the past 550,000 years. Interglacial times with SSTs equal to or exceeding that of the Holocene contain peak abundances in the pollen of redwood, the distinctive component of the temperate rainforest of the northwest coast of California. In the region now dominated by the California Current, SSTs warmed 10,000 to 15,000 years in advance of deglaciation at each of the past five glacial maxima. SSTs did not rise in advance of deglaciation south of the modern California Current front. Glacial warming along the California margin therefore is a regional signal of the weakening of the California Current during times when large ice sheets reorganized wind systems over the North Pacific. Both the timing and magnitude of the SST estimates suggest that the Devils Hole (Nevada) calcite record represents regional but not global paleotemperatures, and hence does not pose a fundamental challenge to the orbital ("Milankovitch") theory of the Ice Ages.

Mg/Ca ratios in planktonic foraminifera

The primary Mg/Ca ratio of foraminiferal shells is a potentially valuable paleoproxy for sea surface temperature (SST) reconstructions. However, the reliable extraction of this ratio from sedimentary calcite assumes that we can overcome artifacts related to foraminiferal ecology and partial dissolution, as well as contamination by secondary calcite and clay. The standard batch method for Mg/Ca analysis involves cracking, sonicating, and rinsing the tests to remove clay, followed by chemical cleaning, and finally acid-digestion and single-point measurement. This laborious procedure often results in substantial loss of sample (typically 30-60%). We find that even the earliest steps of this procedure can fractionate Mg from Ca, thus biasing the result toward a more variable and often anomalously low Mg/Ca ratio. Moreover, the more rigorous the cleaning, the more calcite is lost, and the more likely it becomes that any residual clay that has not been removed by physical cleaning will increase the ratio. These potentially significant sources of error can be overcome with a flow-through (FT) sequential leaching method that makes time- and labor-intensive pretreatments unnecessary. When combined with time-resolved analysis (FT-TRA) flow-through, performed with a gradually increasing and highly regulated acid strength, produces continuous records of Mg, Sr, Al, and Ca concentrations in the leachate sorted by dissolution susceptibility of the reacting material. Flow-through separates secondary calcite from less susceptible biogenic calcite and clay, and further resolves the biogenic component into primary and more resistant fractions. FT-TRA reliably separates secondary calcite (which is not representative of original life habitats) from the more resistant biogenic calcite (the desired signal) and clay (a contaminant of high Mg/Ca, which also contains Al), and further resolves the biogenic component into primary and more resistant fractions that may reflect habitat or other changes during ontogeny. We find that the most susceptible fraction of biogenic calcite in surface dwelling foraminifera gives the most accurate value for SST and therefore best represents primary calcite. Sequential dissolution curves can be used to correct the primary Mg/Ca ratio for clay, if necessary. However, the temporal separation of calcite from clay in FT-TRA is so complete that this correction is typically <=2%, even in clay-rich sediments. Unlike hands-on batch methods, that are difficult to reproduce exactly, flow-through lends itself to automation, providing precise replication of treatment for every sample. Our automated flow-through system can process 22 samples, two system blanks, and 48 mixed standards in <12 hours of unattended operation. FT-TRA thus represents a faster, cheaper, and better way to determine Mg/Ca ratios in foraminiferal calcite.

Pollen and spores record, and paleotemperature reconstructions for mid-Holocene sediments of the Northwest Pacific

Sannai-Maruyama is one of the most famous and best-researched mid-Holocene (mid-Jomon) archaeological sites in Japan, because of a large community of people for a long period. Archaeological studies have shown that the Jomon people inhabited the Sannai-Maruyama site from 5.9-4.2 +/- 0.1 cal. kyr B.P. However, a continuous record of the terrestrial and marine environments around the site has not been available. Core KT05-7 PC-02, was recovered from Mutsu Bay, only 20 km from the site, for the reconstruction of high-resolution time series of environmental records, including sea surface temperature (SST). C37 alkenone SSTs showed clear fluctuations, with four periods of high (8.4-7.9, 7.0-5.9, 5.1-4.1, and 2.3-1.4 cal. kyr B.P.) and four of low (-8.4, 7.9-7.0, 5.9-5.1, and 4.1-2.3 cal. kyr B.P.) SST. Thus, each SST cycle lasted 1.0-2.0 kyr, and the amplitude of fluctuation was about 1.5-2.0 °C. Total organic carbon (TOC) and C37 alkenone contents, and the TOC/total nitrogen ratio indicate that marine biogenic production was low before 7.0 cal. kyr B.P., but was clearly increased between 5.9 and 4.0 cal. kyr B.P., because of stronger vertical mixing. During the period when the community at the site prospered (between 5.9 and 4.2 +/- 0.1 cal. kyr B.P.), the terrestrial climate was relatively warm. The high relative abundance of pollen of both Castanea and Quercus subgen. Cyclobalanopsis supports the interpretation that the local climate was optimal for human habitation. Between 5.9 and 5.1 cal. kyr B.P., in spite of warm terrestrial climates, the C37 alkenone SST was low; this apparent discrepancy may be attributed to the water column structure in the Tsugaru Strait, which differed from the modern condition. The evidence suggests that at about 5.9 cal. kyr B.P, high productivity of marine resources such as fish and shellfish and a warm terrestrial climate led to the establishment of a human community at the Sannai-Maruyama site. Then, at about 4.1 +/- 0.1 cal. kyr B.P., abrupt marine and terrestrial cooling, indicated by a decrease of about 2 °C in the C37 alkenone SST and an increase in pollen of taxa of cooler climates, led to a reduced terrestrial food supply, causing the people to abandon the site. The timing of the abandonment is consistent with the timing (around 4.0-4.3 cal. kyr B.P.) of the decline of civilizations in north Mesopotamia and along the Yangtze River. These findings suggest that a temperature rise of ~2 °C in this century as a result of global warming could have a great impact on the human community and especially on agriculture, despite the advances of contemporary society.

Climate reconstructions from the Tibet Plateau (PKDB286426)

Fluid inclusions of protogenous halite, which were collected from two boreholes in the Charhan Salt Lake in the north part of the Qinghai-Xizang Plateau, werea nalyzed for their hydrogen and oxygen isotopes and for their Na, Mg etc. ions.On these grounds, the evolution of lake environment in this region during the last 50 000 years are discussed in this paper. The emphasis is to discuss the time range of extremely arid and cold climate at the last Glacial stage and the geological event of playa associated with such a climate.The guanidine hydrochloride method was used for measurement of hydrogen and oxygen stable isotopes. The measurement of Na, Mg etc. ions were achieved by determination of crystallization temperature of hydrohalite under microscope and then by calculation of chemical compositions of inclusion fluid using a thermodynamic model.The results obtained show that protogenous halite in the Charhan Lake area was formed in three different environment conditions: (1) In fluid inclusions of halite formed in the early period (50 000-30 000 a B. P. ), dD averages -14.9 per mil, d(18)O averages 8.37 per mil, and Mg(2+)ranges from 0.42 to 1.59 mol/L. Their plotting points fall on the right top part of the evaporation line of the present Charhan Lake area, indicating that the Lake water at that time had a higher concentration of brine, and the climate was hot and dry. (2) In fluid inclusions of halite formed in the middle period (30 000-15 000 a B. P.), SD average -66.0 per mil, d(18)O averages 1.00 pr mil, and Mg(2+) 1 mol/L. Their plotting points fall on the left low part of the evaporation line, indicating that the lake water at that time had a concentration of brine lower than that in the early period, and the environment was cold and dry. (3) In fluid inclusions of halite formed in the late period (15 000-present), dD averages 30.8 per mil, d(18)O averages 5.85 per mil, and Mg(2+) M 1 mol/L. Their plotting fall on the evaporation line, indicating that the climate environment at that time was warm and dry, almost the same as the present.The temperature variation of the last 50 000 years in the Charhan Lake area was calculated using the conversion equation proposed by Lorious et al. The time range of the Great ice age of the Last Glacial Stage is about 21 000-15 000 a B.P., which basically coincides with the time of a worldwide low sea level. The temperature in that period was below 0°C and 6-7°C lower than now. Because of lower temperatures, water supply to the lake area decreased rapidly and the concentration of lake water increased sharply. Therefore the Mg(2+) concentration in inclusion fluid reaches or closes to 2mol/L and the Mg/Na ratio varies within a very wide range. These show that the Charhan Lake at that time entered its playa stage. The Charhan Salt Lake is a typical one in the north part of the Qinghai-Xizang Plateau. It can be supposed that the extremely arid and cold climate of the Great Ice Age made most lakes in the north part of the Qinghai-Xizang Plateau enter their playa stage. This event is of importance for formation of salt resources.

Lake level reconstructions at Laguna Potrok Aike (southern Patagonia, Argentina) for the last 49 ka

Four seismic surveys and a stratigraphic record from southernmost Patagonia (Argentina) based on 51 AMS-14C dates obtained in the framework of ICDP expedition 5022 "Potrok Aike Maar Lake Sediment Archive Drilling Project" (PASADO) provide a database to compare the 106 m composite profile from the lake centre with piston cores from the littoral and outcrops in the catchment area. Based on event correlation using distinct volcanic ash layers with unique geochemical composition and optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dates on feldspars, sediment records are firmly linked. This approach allows to match the sediment record with water levels during the past ca. 49 ka providing evidence for lake level variations. Reconstructed lake levels were 20 m higher than today during the last Glacial until the early Holocene. With the migration of the Southern Hemispheric Westerlies over this site the lake level dropped ca. 55 m for a period of two millennia. Thereupon the water balance was more positive again causing a stepwise rise of the lake level until the maximum was reached during the Little Ice Age with a subsequent lowering since the 20th century. We suggest that the mid- to late-Holocene lake level variation is caused by intensity changes of the Southern Hemispheric Westerlies.

U-series ages from calcitic cold-water corals from the Amundsen Sea

Radiocarbon and uranium-thorium dating results are presented from a genus of calcitic Antarctic cold-water octocorals (family Coralliidae), which were collected from the Marie Byrd Seamounts in the Amundsen Sea (Pacific sector of the Southern Ocean) and which to date have not been investigated geochemically. The geochronological results are set in context with solution and laser ablation-based element/Ca ratios (Li, B, Mg, Mn, Sr, Ba, U, Th). Octocoral radiocarbon ages on living corals are in excellent agreement with modern ambient deep-water D14C, while multiple samples of individual fossil coral specimens yielded reproducible radiocarbon ages. Provided that local radiocarbon reservoir ages can be derived for a given time, fossil Amundsen Sea octocorals should be reliably dateable by means of radiocarbon. In contrast to the encouraging radiocarbon findings, the uranium-series data are more difficult to interpret. The uranium concentration of these calcitic octocorals is an order of magnitude lower than in the aragonitic hexacorals that are conventionally used for geochronological investigations. While modern and Late Holocene octocorals yield initial d234U in good agreement with modern seawater, our results reveal preferential inward diffusion of dissolved alpha-recoiled 234U and its impact on fossil coral d234U. Besides alpha-recoil related 234U diffusion, high-resolution sampling of two fossil octocorals further demonstrates that diagenetic uranium mobility has offset apparent coral U-series ages. Combined with the preferential alpha-recoil 234U diffusion, this process has prevented fossil octocorals from preserving a closed system U-series calendar age for longer than a few thousand years. Moreover, several corals investigated contain significant initial thorium, which cannot be adequately corrected for because of an apparently variable initial 232Th/230Th. Our results demonstrate that calcitic cold-water corals are unsuitable for reliable U-series dating. Mg/Ca ratios within single octocoral specimens are internally strikingly homogeneous, and appear promising in terms of their response to ambient temperature. Magnesium/lithium ratios are significantly higher than usually observed in other deep marine calcifiers and for many of our studied corals are remarkably close to seawater compositions. Although this family of octocorals is unsuitable for glacial deep-water D14C reconstructions, our findings highlight some important differences between hexacoral (aragonitic) and octocoral (calcitic) biomineralisation. Calcitic octocorals could still be useful for trace element and some isotopic studies, such as reconstruction of ambient deep water neodymium isotope composition or pH, via boron isotopic measurements.

Neogene palaeoclimate reconstructions in Anatolia (Turkey)

Neogene basins are widespread in Turkey and contain important lignite deposits. In this study, we reconstruct quantitatively the Late Oligocene-Miocene climate evolution in western and central Anatolia by applying the Coexistence Approach to the palynoflora. The obtained results are compared with the data derived from the published and ongoing studies in western and central Anatolia palynofloras by application of the Coexistence Approach. The Coexistence Approach results show that the sedimentation mainly developed on terrestrial environment under the warm subtropical climatic conditions and marine influence during the Chattian and Aquitanian period in western Anatolia (16.5-21.3°C of mean annual temperature (MAT) and 5.5-13.3°C of mean temperature of coldest month (CMT)). After the regression of the sea during the Burdigalian period, the vegetation developed under the terrestrial conditions, which had started in the Burdigalian time in western and central Anatolia and continued in the early-middle Serravallian period. Warm subtropical climate is suggested during the Chattian and Aquitanian period in western Anatolia and becomes cooler in subtropical conditions because of decreasing of the P/A-ratio during the latest Burdigalian-Langhian. The climate was subtropical in western and central Anatolia during the Early-Late Serravalian due to the increasing of the subtropical elements (17.2 to 20.8°C of MAT and 9.6 to13.1°C of CMT). Besides, decreasing of the CMT and MAT values in western and central Anatolia supports the latest Chattian-earliest Aquitanian warming and middle Miocene climatic optimum that is also globally observed. Warm temperate climatic conditions are observed in the Late Miocene. During the early-middle Tortonian, the values are 15.6 to 20.8°C for the MAT, 5.5 to 13.3°C for the CMT and 823 and 1520 mm for the mean annual precipitation (MAP). They had also dry seasons due to lower boundary of MAP lying at 823mm during the middle-Late Tortonian. The palaeotopography of central Anatolia was higher when compared to that of western Anatolia because dominance of the mountain forests was present during the Middle-Late Miocene in central Anatolia. This study provides the first quantitative model for Late Oligocene-Miocene palaeoclimatic evolution in western and central Anatolia.

Radiocarbon datings and temperature reconstructions of sediment core GeoB10038-4 off SW Sumatra

Surface and thermocline conditions of the eastern tropical Indian Ocean were reconstructed through the past glacial-interglacial cycle by using Mg/Ca and alkenone-paleothermometry, stable oxygen isotopes of calcite and seawater, and terrigenous fraction performed on sediment core GeoB 10038-4 off SW Sumatra (~6°S, 103°E, 1819 m water depth). Results show that annual mean surface and thermocline temperatures varied differently and independently, and suggest that surface temperatures have been responding to southern high-latitude climate, whereas the more variable thermocline temperatures were remotely controlled by changes in the thermocline temperatures of the North Indian Ocean. Except for glacial terminations, salinity proxies indicate that changing intensities of the boreal summer monsoon did not considerably affect annual mean conditions off Sumatra during the past 133,000 years. Our results do not show a glacial-interglacial pattern in the thermocline conditions and reject a linear response of the tropical Indian Ocean thermocline to mid- and high-latitude climate change. Alkenone-based surface temperature estimates varied in line with the terrigenous fraction of the sediment and the East Asian winter monsoon proxy records at the precession band suggestive of monsoon (sea level) to be the dominant control on alkenone temperatures in the eastern tropical Indian Ocean on sub-orbital (glacial-interglacial) timescales.

Biomarker distributions and calculated sea surface temperatures from the North Pacific Ocean

In order to study the modern sea surface characteristics of the sub-polar North Pacific and the Bering Sea, i.e. sea surface temperature (SST) and sea ice cover, surface sediments recovered during the RV Sonne Expedition 202 in 2009 were analysed. To distinguish between marine and terrestrial organic carbon, hydrogen index values, long chain n-alkanes and specific sterols have been determined. The results show that in the Bering Sea, especially on the sea slope, the organic carbon source is mainly caused by high primary production. In the North Pacific, on the other hand, the organic material originates predominantly from terrestrial higher plants, probably related to dust input from Asia. SST has been reconstructed using the modified alkenone unsaturation index. Calibration from Müller et al. (1998, doi:10.1016/S0016-7037(98)00097-0) offers the most reliable estimate of mean annual temperature in the central North Pacific but does not correlate with mean annual temperature throughout the study area. In the eastern North Pacific and the Bering Sea, the Sikes et al. (1997, doi:10.1016/S0016-7037(97)00017-3) calibration seems to be more accurate and matches summer SST. The distribution of the novel sea ice proxy IP25 (highly branched C25 isoprenoid alkene) in surface sediments is in accord with the modern spring sea ice edge and shows the potential of this proxy to track past variation in sea ice cover in the study area.

Cenozoic palaeoclimate reconstructions from 35 sites in Central Europe

Continental climate evolution of Central Europe has been reconstructed quantitatively for the last 45 million years providing inferred data on mean annual temperature and precipitation, and winter and summer temperatures. Although some regional effects occur, the European Cenozoic continental climate record correlates well with the global oxygen isotope record from marine environments. During the last 45 million years, continental cooling is especially pronounced for inferred winter temperatures but hardly observable from summer temperatures. Correspondingly, Cenozoic cooling in Central Europe is directly associated with an increase of seasonality. In contrast, inferred Cenozoic mean annual precipitation remained relatively stable, indicating the importance of latent heat transport throughout the Cenozoic. Moreover, our data support the concept that changes in atmospheric CO2 concentrations, although linked to climate changes, were not the major driving force of Cenozoic cooling.