Supervision of Community Health Agents in the Family Health Strategy: the perspective of nurses

Objective Analyzing the conceptions of supervision of nurses in the Family Health Strategy (ESF - Estratégia Saúde da Família) in relation to community health workers (ACS – Agente Comunitário de Saúde), taking for reference the work process and the power relations. Method A qualitative study, in which 18 interviews were carried out with nurses from the ESF in the countryside of the state of Goiás. Following transcription, the data were subjected to thematic content analysis and the following categories were identified: Supervision with that sees it all and Supervision is participating and working together. Results Among the findings, it is clear the character of control and monitoring that is carried out primarily through printed instruments and home visits, which constitute vertical and impositive relations, and suffer influence of the local health management. Another finding is the supervision as acting together and with the educational perspective. Conclusion The supervision carried out does not provide the changes intended by the ESF.

Higher education in nursing: the faculty work process in different institutional contexts

Objective To analyze the characteristics of faculty work in nursing higher education. Method An exploratory qualitative study with a theoretical-methodological framework of dialectical and historical materialism. The faculty work process was adopted as the analytical category, grounded on conceptions of work and professionalism. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 24 faculty members from three higher education institutions in the city of São Paulo, classified according to the typology of institutional contexts. Results The faculty members at these higher education institutions are a heterogeneous group, under different working conditions. Intensification and precarious conditions of the faculty work is common to all three contexts, although there are important distinctions in the practices related to teaching, research and extension. Conclusion Faculty professionalization can be the starting point for analyzing and coping with such a distinct reality of faculty work and practice.


In the context of a daycare center: nursing and their representations of child care as an educational act

This study aimed to analyze the social representations in the professionals of technical staff, who work with children at USP daycare centers. Eight professionals of the nursing field underwent a semi-structured interview. The interviews were recorded and transcribed in their entirety and the content of the discourse was subjected to thematic-categorical analysis. The categories were transformed into variables and processed by the software Classification Hiérarchique Classificatoire et Cohésitive (CHIC®) and analyzed by the hierarchical similarity tree. The results indicate that actions to promote health are reported as educational and transformative, in which health care gains new meaning through contextualized conceptions in the field of child education. We conclude that professionals attribute new meanings to their practices in the health care environment of daycare centers as their representations shifts from the logic of the biomedical field to a logic of educational care. In this sense, they perceive themselves as being challenged to establish an interaction with the children in terms of their activities related to the promotion of health and in an educational act.

Identity of care in a Psychosocial Care Center for Children and Adolescents who uses drugs

Objective To associate the territory of identity with the production of care within a PCC focusing on children and adolescents with drug abuse and their institutional identity. Method We used the “ process tracing methodology” in four research categories: focus groups, characterization of professionals, observing the everyday and interviewing two members of emblematic cases of the service. Results territory of identity of the institution, which operates the production of care is crossed by the difficulty of dealing with the complexity brought by the users and the performance of the PCC network. This paper is also permeated by different conceptions of care and small problematization of these issues in collective spaces of service. Conclusion The discussion in focus groups and other devices can be powerful resources to reframe the meaning of care and identity of collective service.

Development of premature children: caregivers' understanding according to the Bioecological Theory

Abstract OBJECTIVE Understanding the conceptions of premature children caregivers on child development and associated factors. METHOD An exploratory-descriptive qualitative study of 12 families with children under three years of age. Interviews were submitted to thematic content analysis, systematized into the categories of Bioecological Theory of Human Development: Process, Person, Context and Time, and in the Functional Development category. RESULTS There are concerns about impairment in the current and future development of a Person/child defined as fragile as a result of premature birth (Time dimension), minimized by the scope of observable competencies such as motor skills. The Context, especially family and health services, and Proximal Processes, described as one-way caregiver interactions, are considered determinants of development. Functional Development is considered a natural consequence and result of education. The support network is crucial, supporting or limiting care. CONCLUSION Concerns about the development mobilize caregivers to stimulate the premature child/person and requests family and healthcare assistance.

Aromatherapy and nursing: historical and theoretical conception

Abstract Aromatherapy is a Practical or Complementary Health Therapy that uses volatile concentrates extracted from plants called essential oils, in order to improve physical, mental and emotional well-being. Aromatherapy has been practiced historically and worldwide by nurses and, as in Brazil is supported by the Federal Nursing Council, it is relevant to discuss this practice in the context of Nursing through Theories of Nursing. This study of theoretical reflection, exploratory and descriptive, aims to discuss the pharmacognosy of essential oils, the historical trajectory of Aromatherapy in Nursing and the conceptions to support Aromatherapy in light of eight Nursing Theorists (Florence Nightingale, Myra Levine, Hildegard Peplau, Martha Rogers, Callista Roy, Wanda Horta, Jean Watson and Katharine Kolcaba), contributing to its inclusion as a nursing care practice.

The structural nature of perceptual experiences

Intuitively, we think of perception as providing us with direct cognitive access to physical objects and their properties. But this common sense picture of perception becomes problematic when we notice that perception is not always veridical. In fact, reflection on illusions and hallucinations seems to indicate that perception cannot be what it intuitively appears to be. This clash between intuition and reflection is what generates the puzzle of perception. The task and enterprise of unravelling this puzzle took, and still takes, centre stage in the philosophy of perception. The goal of my dissertation is to make a contribution to this enterprise by formulating and defending a new structural approach to perception and perceptual consciousness. The argument for my structural approach is developed in several steps. Firstly, I develop an empirically inspired causal argument against naïve and direct realist conceptions of perceptual consciousness. Basically, the argument says that perception and hallucination can have the same proximal causes and must thus belong to the same mental kind. I emphasise that this insight gives us good reasons to abandon what we are instinctively driven to believe - namely that perception is directly about the outside physical world. The causal argument essentially highlights that the information that the subject acquires in perceiving a worldly object is always indirect. To put it another way, the argument shows that what we, as perceivers, are immediately aware of, is not an aspect of the world but an aspect of our sensory response to it. A view like this is traditionally known as a Representative Theory of Perception. As a second step, emphasis is put on the task of defending and promoting a new structural version of the Representative Theory of Perception; one that is immune to some major objections that have been standardly levelled at other Representative Theories of Perception. As part of this defence and promotion, I argue that it is only the structural features of perceptual experiences that are fit to represent the empirical world. This line of thought is backed up by a detailed study of the intriguing phenomenon of synaesthesia. More precisely, I concentrate on empirical cases of synaesthetic experiences and argue that some of them provide support for a structural approach to perception. The general picture that emerges in this dissertation is a new perspective on perceptual consciousness that is structural through and through.

A Escrita em Língua Francesa no 2º Ciclo do Ensino Secundário em Cabo Verde: Análise do Manual Escolar e de Concepções e Práticas dos Supervisores

A relevância do ensino da escrita na educação em línguas estrangeiras decorre do papel que ela assume no desenvolvimento expressivo e cognitivo do aluno, sendo fundamental para a sua integração em diversos contextos sociais, incluindo o contexto escolar. No entanto, o processo de aprendizagem da escrita não ocorre espontaneamente e requer um ensino explícito e sistematizado, o que nem sempre acontece. O estudo efectuado centra-se em concepções e práticas de escrita em língua estrangeira – Francês – no contexto do ensino secundário em Cabo Verde. O programa de Língua Francesa para este nível de ensino reconhece a importância da escrita, mas não a perspectiva como processo nas propostas de actividades de produção textual que apresenta. O estudo incide na análise do manual adoptado e nas concepções de supervisores de estágio, no sentido de compreender em que medida num e noutro caso se atende a uma concepção actualizada da escrita. Teve como objectivos: 1. Caracterizar as propostas de aprendizagem da escrita num manual escolar de Francês do 2º ciclo do ensino secundário; 2. Caracterizar as concepções de escrita de um grupo de supervisores de estágio de Francês, da universidade e da escola; 3. Comparar as concepções de escrita patentes no manual analisado com as concepções de escrita dos supervisores; 4. Caracterizar práticas supervisivas de promoção do ensino da escrita. Os resultados obtidos na análise do manual evidenciam o predomínio de uma concepção redutora das práticas de escrita, essencialmente concebida como produto, em detrimento da escrita como processo, com provável reflexo nas práticas pedagógicas dos professores. As concepções dos supervisores aproximam-se de uma visão mais actual da escrita, mas verifica-se algum desfasamento entre essas concepções e as suas percepções das práticas supervisivas, nomeadamente no que diz respeito a alguma falta de apoio aos estagiários em termos de informação sobre a escrita e análise de práticas à luz de referenciais teóricos. Concluindo, verifica-se a necessidade de maior formação neste domínio, que possibilite um olhar crítico sobre os manuais e as práticas escolares, por referência a uma concepção actualizada do que significa ensinar e aprender a escrever.

Psychothérapie et mécanismes de défense = Psychotherapy and defense mechanisms

Dans cet article, les auteurs mettent en dialogue deux facettes des mécanismes de défense en situation psychothérapeutique : la psychopathologie et le changement. Pour commencer, les instruments de mesure les plus utilisés sont présentés, avec un accent sur les échelles d'évaluation par un juge externe. Les conceptions de Vaillant et de Perry sont présentées et discutées. L'article se continue avec une synthèse des travaux empiriques de recherche en psychothérapie se focalisant sur les changements des mécanismes de défense au cours des psychothérapies, principalement d'orientation psychanalytique. Une réflexion autour du lien avec le concept d'alliance thérapeutique, ainsi qu'avec celui du coping complète cette synthèse. Des travaux récents concernant des psychothérapies de courte et de longue durée sont ensuite abordés. Les défenses sont également discutées du point de vue de la psychopathologie, à travers deux exemples d'études empiriques mettant en évidence des spécificités dans des troubles psychiatriques. Les retombées de ces résultats de recherche pour la pratique psychanalytique sont mentionnées tout au long de cet article de synthèse. With the present article, we aim to develop a dialogue between two aspects of defense mechanisms in psychotherapy : psychopathology and change. First, the most frequently used instruments will be presented, with a particular focus on observer-rated scales, and Vaillant's and Perry's models are sketched and discussed. Then, we review empirical research on changes in defense mechanisms over the course of psychotherapy, mainly psychoanalytic. An elaboration on the links with the concept of therapeutic alliance and the concept of coping completes this overview. Recent studies on change in short- and long-term psychotherapy are then discussed. Defense mechanisms are then examined from a psychopathology point of view, using two examples of empirical studies pointing to distinctive characteristics of mental disorders. Clinical implications for psychoanalytic practice are discussed throughout the article.

Concepções, Práxis e Tendências de Desenvolvimento Curricular no Ensino Superior Público em Cabo Verde: um Estudo de Caso Sobre a Universidade de Cabo Verde

A tese enquadra-se nas discussões sobre as concepções do currículo, como problemática central nos processos de educação e formação, e o papel da Universidade ao longo dos tempos, mormente nos contextos actuais da globalização, conferindo especial relevo às concepções, práxis e tendências que caracterizam a experiência de desenvolvimento curricular na Universidade de Cabo Verde (Uni-CV), desde a sua criação, em Novembro de 2006, no seguimento de um percurso de quase três décadas do ensino superior público cabo-verdiano Com o enquadramento teórico da problemática da investigação faz-se uma ampla cartografia da literatura relevante no campo científico dos estudos curriculares, numa abordagem que patenteia a diversidade de conceptualizações do currículo e do desenvolvimento curricular, os principais traços característicos das teorias curriculares que se têm sucedido e ou que rivalizam na busca de hegemonia no sector da educação, bem como as políticas educativas e curriculares que vêm sendo concebidas e realizadas à escala global, dispensando atenção particular às dimensões instituinte e instituída do processo curricular. Ainda que fortemente condicionado pelas concepções e políticas de globalização da educação, a tendência para a uniformização educativa e curricular não constitui uma inevitabilidade, demonstrando-se, pelo contrário, que o processo de desenvolvimento curricular deixa espaços de apropriação e inovação ao nível das instituições educativas, atendendo à diversidade de contextos, expectativas e perspectivas inerentes à dinâmica da realização do currículo. Ainda no plano teórico, ao analisar-se a evolução do conceito ou ideia de Universidade, desde a sua génese até aos tempos actuais, coloca-se em relevo a natureza específica da instituição no âmbito do ensino superior, patenteando o modo como, nos diferentes contextos, a mesma tem procurado afirmar a centralidade do conhecimento e do currículo no cumprimento da sua missão, a despeito de factores e condicionalismos diversos, de entre os quais releva o tipo de relacionamento predominante entre a Universidade, o Estado e o mercado, no âmbito do qual se deve entender a complexidade da crise institucional, na triplicidade das suas manifestações (crise de legitimidade, de hegemonia e de identidade) que atravessa a academia, com reflexos ao nível das tendências para o condicionamento da autonomia, missão e funções da academia, assim como da própria natureza do conhecimento universitário. Na procura de saídas para a crise, que é global e, como tal, se reflecte nas universidades do continente africano, em que se insere Cabo Verde, a Universidade é desafiada a afirmar a sua especificidade institucional, enquanto promotora da alta cultura e da capacidade de pensamento de longo prazo, conciliando, deste modo, as suas funções essenciais ou simbólicas com as que se prendem com a satisfação das necessidades imediatas ou de curto prazo da economia e do mercado. Com base nos pertinentes subsídios teóricos, os estudos empíricos desenvolvem-se segundo a abordagem metodológica de estudo de caso, em que a análise documental e as técnicas de investigação qualitativa e quantitativa permitiram consolidar as evidências sobre: (i) os antecedentes da criação da Uni-CV, através do mapeamento do percurso académico e curricular dos diversos estabelecimentos públicos de ensino superior que precederam a universidade pública, legando a esta o seu património científico, tecnológico e logístico, com as inerentes potencialidades e limitações; (ii) o processo de institucionalização da Uni-CV, com a referencialização das opções estruturantes da organização e gestão da Universidade assim como da política educativa e curricular da Universidade; (iii) a experiência multifacetada de desenvolvimento curricular na novel instituição durante os cinco primeiros anos de funcionamento (2006-2011), correlacionando opções e práxis e evidenciando tendências da sua evolução. Da análise interpretativa dos estudos empíricos realizados, mediante a triangulação dos dados de arquivo e de perspectiva, resulta que a Uni-CV, não obstante as fragilidades persistentes no processo de seu desenvolvimento institucional, tem cumprido a sua missão de forma satisfatória, facto que fica a dever-se quer à adequação das opções, normas e directivas conformadoras da dimensão instituinte do processo curricular, quer ao esforço de realização das prescrições curriculares, sendo, todavia, evidentes os desafios a serem vencidos tendo em vista a consecução da almejada excelência académica, que os Estatutos propugnam, e que passa, nomeadamente, pela melhoria do nível da qualificação do seu corpo docente, pela implementação ou funcionamento efectivo de alguns dos órgãos da academia e pela afirmação da investigação científica como função incontornável para o desempenho cabal das funções de ensino e extensão. De entre as conclusões, sustenta-se que, no processo de integração de Cabo Verde nas redes internacionais de investigação e excelência científica e tecnológica, como, de resto, propugnam os Estatutos da Uni-CV, deve atender-se à especificidade deste pequeno país do Atlântico Médio, tendo em conta as suas fragilidades estruturais, pelo que se impõe algum distanciamento crítico em relação à incorporação de certas opções de política educativa e curricular que emanam de instâncias internacionais, independentemente do seu carácter inovador ou mesmo da sua possível consistência científica e técnica, comprovada em outros contextos.

Homéostasie, marqueurs somatiques et intentionnalité : le statut de la représentation et ses implications en psychanalyse et en neuroscience

Résumé : Si la psychanalyse est régulièrement remise en cause pour son manque de fondement scientifique, de nombreux travaux issus des neurosciences en appellent paradoxalement à un retour aux thèses freudiennes. Cette étude se propose, dans ce contexte, de revisiter les bases neurobiologiques de la métapsychologie et de montrer comment celle-ci repose sur une conception homéostatique du vivant. On en tire plusieurs conséquences. Premièrement, contre Brentano, selon qui l'intentionnalité est la marque du psychologique, on propose que celle-ci s'avère être, plus originellement, la marque des régulations biologiques. Deuxièmement, on montre comment Freud et Damasio développent des conceptions similaires sur le fonctionnement homéostatique de la cognition. Sur le plan épistémologique, on plaide en faveur de la complémentarité de ces deux approches. Si Damasio met au jour les variables somatiques permettant de mesurer les effets de la vie psychique, la théorie pulsionnelle permet de dépasser les problèmes liés à l'ambiguïté de la notion de «représentation cérébrale ». C'est à partir de cette thèse que l'on peut, selon nous, appréhender la psychanalyse comme un double projet visant à articuler une naturalisation de l'appareil psychique à une herméneutique de ses productions. On considère cette double visée comme une réponse à la difficulté centrale que rencontrent les sciences de l'esprit quant aux conditions de possibilité d'une naturalisation de l'intentionnalité. A partir de cette problématique, il devient pertinent d'évaluer la solution freudienne à la lumière de la posture intentionnelle dennettienne et de la théorie gazzaniguienne de l'interpreter. II ne s'agit pas, selon ces dernières approches, de naturaliser directement l'intentionnalité, au risque de commettre une erreur de catégorie. Il est question, au contraire, d'utiliser les principes du fonctionnement homéostatique comme autant de «règles »interprétatives permettant, sur le plan psychologique, de construire du sens. On trouve enfin dans le modèle de l'espace global de travail un moyen de remettre au goût du jour la conception freudienne, dynamique et conflictuelle, du fonctionnement psychique. On avance enfin, à partir de ce modèle, des hypothèses sur les mécanismes cérébraux susceptibles de sous-tendre l'efficacité thérapeutique de la cure analytique. Abstract : While Psychoanalysis' scientific basis is open to question, some neuroscience works are paradoxically calling for a return to Freud. Therefore, the first aim of our study consists in revisiting metapychology's neurobiological roots and to show how it is grounded on a homeostatic theory of life. Several consequences can be drawn from this statement. Firstly, in opposition to Brentanian definition of intentionality, as the specific mark of psychology, we argue that it is more specifically the mark of biological balance. Secondly, this statement allows to show how Freud's and Damasio's theories share common views on the homeostatic functioning of cognition. From an epistemological point of view, they complete one another. If Damasio has highlighted the measurable somatic variables from which we can infer psychic life, the theory of drives allows conceptual difficulties linked to the use of the ambiguous notion of "cerebral representation" to be overcome. According to us, this thesis leads psychoanalysis to be approached as a twin project aiming to articulate psyche naturalization, to a hermeneutic of its productions. It maybe seen as a way to respond to the central issue of mind sciences, that is, to account for the naturalization of intentionality. Given this theoretical framework, it seems relevant to reconsider freudism in the light of the dennettian intentional stance and the gazzanigan theory of interpreter. Then, freudism can be seen as a way to avoid a category mistake. Its solution rejects direct intentionality naturalization in favor of a construction of sense. In this framework, interpretation is regulated by the rules abstracted from the homeostatic functioning of life. Furthermore, we show how the dynamic and conflictual Freudian psyche can be evaluated using the Global workspace model, which allows us to put forth hypotheses on the cerebral mechanisms that may underlie the efficiency of analytical cure.

The three strands of intercultural polities: a comprehensive view. A critical review of Bouchard and Cantle recent books on interculturalism

Within the emerging policy debate on interculturalism we critically review two recent books in 2012: Bouchard’s L’interculturalisme: un point de vue quebecois, and Cantle’s Interculturalism: The New Era of Cohesion and Diversity. In my view, both contribute very directly to open a foundational debate on interculturalism. In addressing the point of convergence and the dividing lines of these two contributions, I will claim that in spite of having one core concept of interculturalism, there are, however, at least two basic conceptions that have to be interpreted in complementary ways: Bouchard’s essay represents the contractual strand, Cantle’s book the cohesion strand. At the end I would also suggest that these two strands do not manage to express explicitly that diversity can also be seen as a resource of innovation and creativity, and so can drive individual and social development. This view is based on the diversity advantage literature already informing most of the diversity debate in Europe and elsewhere. This is what I will call the constructivist strand. My ultimate purpose is to defend a comprehensive view, grounded on the argument that no one can have the sole authority to define intercultural policy, since the three strands can be applied at different moments, according to different purposes and policy needs. The challenge now is that policy managers be able to achieve a balance between these three policy drivers.

Bahía de Coishco, Chimbote, Perú: una visión integral de sus recursos vivos y su ambiente. 2001 - 2005

Se ha recorrido la Bahía de Coishco a fin de conocer las actividades artesanal e industrial que se desarrollan en esta área, y se han revisado los informes sobre las actividades y proyectos que ejecuta el Laboratorio Costero de Chimbote como parte del Plan Anual de Trabajo Institucional. Se presenta una descripción de la morfología, topografía y sedimentología de la Bahía de Coishco, así como de las características físicas, químicas y biológicas de sus masas de agua. Se hace una descripción de las fuentes y niveles de contaminación, producto del vertimiento de aguas de diferentes tipo de uso: industrial, pesquero, doméstico; de escorrentía y producto de actividades de las embarcaciones que operan en esta bahía. Se mencionan las especies que sustentan la pesca artesanal e industrial, los instrumentos y áreas de pesca, los bancos naturales de invertebrados marinos, los tonelajes de extracción a nivel artesanal y de procesamiento a nivel industrial por cada una de las fábricas que operan en esta bahía. La bahía de Coishco, con un área aproximada de 11.655 km2 es una bahía abierta, rodeada por las islas Santa y Moñaque; en sus profundidades predominan las isóbatas desde 12 a 16 m y en el centro de la bahía existe alta concentración de materia orgánica. Las masas de agua son generalmente Aguas Costeras Frias, de 15 a 20 ºC; la salinidad cerca de la línea litoral es menor a 35 ups, en cambio en el sur de la balúa las salinidades son en promedio del orden de 35,1ups. El vertimiento de aguas de uso industrial pesquero y doméstico influye en el contenido de oxígeno tanto superficial como de fondo, habiéndose detectado situaciones de anoxia; igualmente se afectan los nutrientes, tal es así que los niveles de fosfatos se incrementan durante la época de intensa actividad pesquera y disminuyen durante la época de veda. Se ha identificado 60 especies de organismos planctónicos, destacando las diatomeas de afloramiento Chaetoceros decipiens, Thalassiosira rotula y Skeletonema costatum. Los peces constituyen la principal fuente de pesca artesanal (82% de las capturas), destacando: "lorna" Sciaena deliciosa, "pejerrey" Odonthestes regia regia, "machete" Etmidium maculatum, "cachema" Cynoscion analis, "cabinza" Isacia conceptionís. La anchoveta es la principal materia prima para la elaboración de harina y aceite de pescado. Entre los invertebrados, destacaron "caracol" Stramoníta chocolata, "almeja" Semele spp., "concha de abanico" Argopecten purpu­ratus, "pulpo" Octopus mimus.

Policy attitudes, ideological values and social representations

This article reviews research on policy attitudes and ideological values from the perspective of social representations theory. In the first part of the paper, key features of lay political thinking are presented, its pragmatic imperative, its focus on communication and the social functions of shared knowledge. Objectification transforms abstract and group-neutral ideological values into concrete and socially useful knowledge, in particular stereotypes of value-conforming and value-violating groups. Such shared understandings of intergroup relations provide citizens with common reference knowledge which provides the cognitive and cultural basis of policy attitudes. Social representations theory further suggests that lay knowledge reflects the social context in which it has been elaborated (anchoring), an aspect which allows conceptualising aggregate-level differences in policy attitudes. In the second part of the paper, a model of lay conceptions of social order is outlined which organises four shared conceptions of social order, along with the stereotype-based thinking associated with each conception: Moral order, Free Market, Social diversity and Structural inequality. We conclude by arguing that policy attitudes are symbolic devices expressed to justify or to challenge existing social arrangements.

"V.N. Volochinov en contexte: essai d'épistémologie historique"

Cette thèse de doctorat porte sur la pensée de Valentin Volochinov (1895-1936) et le contexte intellectuel russe du début du XXe siècle dans lequel elle a été élaborée. Le cadre spatial de l'étude est la Russie. Le cadre temporel correspond aux années 1890-1920. Fait dans le cadre des « études bakhtiniennes », ce travail propose une démarche inverse de celle utilisée jusqu'à présent dans ce domaine. Son objectif est d'explorer les conséquences pratiques de trois hypothèses : 1) Valentin Volochinov (et non pas Mikhaïl Bakhtine) est l'auteur des textes parus sous son nom dans les années 1920 ; 2) Valentin Volochinov est un chercheur indépendant de Mikhaïl Bakhtine et de Pavel Medvedev (et non pas seulement un des membres du « Cercle de Bakhtine » ou du « groupe B.M.V. » dont le projet scientifique serait incompréhensible sans le recours aux textes bakhtiniens et/ou de Medvedev) ; 3) la connaissance du contexte intellectuel général dans lequel a travaillé Valentin Volochinov (c'est-à-dire l'ensemble des textes et des discussions scientifiques qui se sont déroulées dans les revues et les institutions scientifiques autour des thèmes abordés dans les textes signés dans les années 1920 par Volochinov) joue un rôle de premier plan dans l'interprétation de sa conception. L'analyse de la terminologie utilisée dans les travaux de Volochinov (en particulier de la notion d'« idéologie » et de méthode « marxiste »), ainsi que l'examen des idées ayant trait à la philosophie du langage (la réception des idées de Saussure, la polémique avec Rozalija Chor sur des principes de la science du langage « marxiste », la critique de la conception du «mot» de Gustav Chpet), psychologiques (la critique de la théorie psychanalytique de Sigmund Freud, l'élaboration de la notion de conscience, la recherche des bases de la psychologie « marxiste ») et sociologiques (l'analyse de l'interaction socio-verbale et l'élaboration de la théorie de l'énoncé) amènent à la conclusion que les hypothèses avancées sont justes et le mode de lecture adopté dans le travail est rentable : il suscite des interprétations différentes de celles proposées jusqu'à présent. Il permet, par exemple, de mettre en évidence les particularités du marxisme russe des années 1920 considéré par les intellectuels de l'époque, d'une part, comme une méthode des recherches dont les principes fondamentaux sont le matérialisme, le monisme, le déterminisme (y compris social), la dialectique et, d'autre part, comme une doctrine sociologique. Compris en ce sens, le marxisme fait partie de l'histoire de la sociologie russe qui comprend également des conceptions dites « bourgeoises » ou « positivistes » comme, par exemple, celle d'Eugène de Roberty, qui insiste dans ses travaux sur le primat du social sur l'individuel, autrement dit qui met en avant le principe du déterminisme social souvent associé uniquement au «sociologisme marxisant». L'oeuvre de Volochinov ne contient pas, par conséquent, d'éléments de «sociologisme vulgaire», elle s'inscrit dans l'histoire des idées sociologiques russes où il n'y a pas de rupture nette entre les conceptions dites «bourgeoises» et marxistes. Le marxisme de Volochinov n'est pas révolutionnaire. Il ne peut pas non plus être associé aux idées psychanalytiques. La preuve est le refus radical de l'existence de l'inconscient (ou plutôt d'une force inconsciente) qui déterminerait le comportement des individus sans qu'ils s'en rendent compte. Le projet scientifique de Volochinov consiste à analyser la conscience (les faits psychiques), ainsi que le langage, l'énoncé et les structures syntaxiques dans lesquelles l'énoncé se réalise en tant qu'éléments constitutifs de l'échange social et/ou verbal, qui se trouve au centre de vives discussions menées à la charnière des XIXe-XXe siècles par les chercheurs russes d'orientation marxiste et non marxiste. Pour comprendre ce projet il n'est pas nécessaire de faire appel aux idées de Bakhtine et de Medvedev : la lecture en contexte des textes signés dans les années 1920 par Volochinov met ainsi en doute l'idée qui domine actuellement dans le monde francophone que Bakhtine serait leur véritable auteur.