Process Monitoring and Defect Detection of Additive Manufacturing Using Inline Coherent Imaging

With applications ranging from aerospace to biomedicine, additive manufacturing (AM) has been revolutionizing the manufacturing industry. The ability of additive techniques, such as selective laser melting (SLM), to create fully functional, geometrically complex, and unique parts out of high strength materials is of great interest. Unfortunately, despite numerous advantages afforded by this technology, its widespread adoption is hindered by a lack of on-line, real time feedback control and quality assurance techniques. In this thesis, inline coherent imaging (ICI), a broadband, spatially coherent imaging technique, is used to observe the SLM process in 15 - 45 $\mu m$ 316L stainless steel. Imaging of both single and multilayer builds is performed at a rate of 200 $kHz$, with a resolution of tens of microns, and a high dynamic range rendering it impervious to blinding from the process beam. This allows imaging before, during, and after laser processing to observe changes in the morphology and stability of the melt. Galvanometer-based scanning of the imaging beam relative to the process beam during the creation of single tracks is used to gain a unique perspective of the SLM process that has been so far unobservable by other monitoring techniques. Single track processing is also used to investigate the possibility of a preliminary feedback control parameter based on the process beam power, through imaging with both coaxial and 100 $\mu m$ offset alignment with respect to the process beam. The 100 $\mu m$ offset improved imaging by increasing the number of bright A-lines (i.e. with signal greater than the 10 $dB$ noise floor) by 300\%. The overlap between adjacent tracks in a single layer is imaged to detect characteristic fault signatures. Full multilayer builds are carried out and the resultant ICI images are used to detect defects in the finished part and improve upon the initial design of the build system. Damage to the recoater blade is assessed using powder layer scans acquired during a 3D build. The ability of ICI to monitor SLM processes at such high rates with high resolution offers extraordinary potential for future advances in on-line feedback control of additive manufacturing.

Expanding the Design Space: Forging the Transition from 3D Printing to Additive Manufacturing

Thesis (Master's)--University of Washington, 2016-08

A Study of the State of the Art of Process Planning for Additive Manufacturing

In the manufacturing industry the term Process Planning (PP) is concerned with determining the sequence of individual manufacturing operations needed to produce a given part or product with a certain machine. In this technical report we propose a preliminary analysis of scientific literature on the topic of process planning for Additive Manufacturing (AM) technologies (i.e. 3D printing). We observe that the process planning for additive manufacturing processes consists of a small set of standard operations (repairing, orientation, supports, slicing and toolpath generation). We analyze each of them in order to emphasize the most critical aspects of the current pipeline as well as highlight the future challenges for this emerging manufacturing technology.

AIR SIDE HEAT TRANSFER ENHANCEMENT IN HEAT EXCHANGERS UTILIZING INNOVATIVE DESIGNS AND THE ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING TECHNIQUE

Over the last decade, rapid development of additive manufacturing techniques has allowed the fabrication of innovative and complex designs. One field that can benefit from such technology is heat exchanger fabrication, as heat exchanger design has become more and more complex due to the demand for higher performance particularly on the air side of the heat exchanger. By employing the additive manufacturing, a heat exchanger design was successfully realized, which otherwise would have been very difficult to fabricate using conventional fabrication technologies. In this dissertation, additive manufacturing technique was implemented to fabricate an advanced design which focused on a combination of heat transfer surface and fluid distribution system. Although the application selected in this dissertation is focused on power plant dry cooling applications, the results of this study can directly and indirectly benefit other sectors as well, as the air-side is often the limiting side for in liquid or single phase cooling applications. Two heat exchanger designs were studied. One was an advanced metallic heat exchanger based on manifold-microchannel technology and the other was a polymer heat exchanger based on utilization of prime surface technology. Polymer heat exchangers offer several advantages over metals such as antifouling, anticorrosion, lightweight and often less expensive than comparable metallic heat exchangers. A numerical modeling and optimization were performed to calculate a design that yield an optimum performance. The optimization results show that significant performance enhancement is noted compared to the conventional heat exchangers like wavy fins and plain plate fins. Thereafter, both heat exchangers were scaled down and fabricated using additive manufacturing and experimentally tested. The manifold-micro channel design demonstrated that despite some fabrication inaccuracies, compared to a conventional wavy-fin surface, 15% - 50% increase in heat transfer coefficient was possible for the same pressure drop value. In addition, if the fabrication inaccuracy can be eliminated, an even larger performance enhancement is predicted. Since metal based additive manufacturing is still in the developmental stage, it is anticipated that with further refinement of the manufacturing process in future designs, the fabrication accuracy can be improved. For the polymer heat exchanger, by fabricating a very thin wall heat exchanger (150μm), the wall thermal resistance, which usually becomes the limiting side for polymer heat exchanger, was calculated to account for only up to 3% of the total thermal resistance. A comparison of air-side heat transfer coefficient of the polymer heat exchanger with some of the commercially available plain plate fin surface heat exchangers show that polymer heat exchanger performance is equal or superior to plain plate fin surfaces. This shows the promising potential for polymer heat exchangers to compete with conventional metallic heat exchangers when an additive manufacturing-enabled fabrication is utilized. Major contributions of this study are as follows: (1) For the first time demonstrated the potential of additive manufacturing in metal printing of heat exchangers that benefit from a sophisticated design to yield a performance substantially above the respective conventional systems. Such heat exchangers cannot be fabricated with the conventional fabrication techniques. (2) For the first time demonstrated the potential of additive manufacturing to produce polymer heat exchangers that by design minimize the role of thermal conductivity and deliver a thermal performance equal or better that their respective metallic heat exchangers. In addition of other advantages of polymer over metal like antifouling, anticorrosion, and lightweight. Details of the work are documented in respective chapters of this thesis.

Additive Manufacturing: Current Status and Future Prospects

Part 10: Sustainability and Trust

The role of additive manufacturing in patient specific solutions

This dissertation investigates de role of the new additive manufacturing techniques in the treatment of pathologies with a patient-specific approach. Throughout this work the development methodology of these said products is explained in order to understand the different stages required to achieve a tailor made solution. The goal is to demonstrate the importance of the manufacturing technique and its capabilities to tailor-fit devices to patients and the adaptability of the process to tackle the most diverse situations. Three real cases are documented in order to prove the viability of the method and to showcase its advantages. Whenever possible patient-specific solutions are compared to their “off-the-shelf” counterparts in order to establish the pros and cons of each one of them. The dissertation is an insight into a possible future for the medical devices industry, where customization is expected to be the standard approach in the treatment of patients.

Processing and additive manufacturing of bones for the teaching of human anatomy

Traditionally, the teaching of human anatomy in health sciences has been based on the use of cadaveric material and bone parts for practical study. The bone materials get deteriorated and hardly mark the points of insertion of muscles. However, the advent of new technologies for 3D printing and creation of 3D anatomical models applied to teaching, has enabled to overcome these problems making teaching more dynamic, realistic and attractive. This paper presents some examples of the construction of three-dimensional models of bone samples, designed using 3D scanners for posterior printing with addition printers or polymer injection printers.

Additive Manufacturing by LPBF and WAAM of metals: correlation between production process, microstructure and mechanical properties

In the most recent years, Additive Manufacturing (AM) has drawn the attention of both academic research and industry, as it might deeply change and improve several industrial sectors. From the material point of view, AM results in a peculiar microstructure that strictly depends on the conditions of the additive process and directly affects mechanical properties. The present PhD research project aimed at investigating the process-microstructure-properties relationship of additively manufactured metal components. Two technologies belonging to the AM family were considered: Laser-based Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) and Wire-and-Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM). The experimental activity was carried out on different metals of industrial interest: a CoCrMo biomedical alloy and an AlSi7Mg0.6 alloy processed by LPBF, an AlMg4.5Mn alloy and an AISI 304L austenitic stainless steel processed by WAAM. In case of LPBF, great attention was paid to the influence that feedstock material and process parameters exert on hardness, morphological and microstructural features of the produced samples. The analyses, targeted at minimizing microstructural defects, lead to process optimization. For heat-treatable LPBF alloys, innovative post-process heat treatments, tailored on the peculiar hierarchical microstructure induced by LPBF, were developed and deeply investigated. Main mechanical properties of as-built and heat-treated alloys were assessed and they were well-correlated to the specific LPBF microstructure. Results showed that, if properly optimized, samples exhibit a good trade-off between strength and ductility yet in the as-built condition. However, tailored heat treatments succeeded in improving the overall performance of the LPBF alloys. Characterization of WAAM alloys, instead, evidenced the microstructural and mechanical anisotropy typical of AM metals. Experiments revealed also an outstanding anisotropy in the elastic modulus of the austenitic stainless-steel that, along with other mechanical properties, was explained on the basis of microstructural analyses.

Advanced Functional Organic-Inorganic Hybrid (Nano)Materials: from Theranostics to Organic Electronics and Additive Manufacturing

This work is going to show the activities performed in the frame of my PhD studies at the University of Bologna, under the supervision of Prof. Mauro Comes Franchini, at the Department of Industrial Chemistry “Toso Montanari”. The main topic of this dissertation will be the study of organic-inorganic hybrid nanostructures and materials for advanced applications in different fields of materials technology and development such as theranostics, organic electronics and additive manufacturing, also known as 3D printing. This work is therefore divided into three chapters, that recall the fundamentals of each subject and to recap the state-of-the-art of scientific research around each topic. In each chapter, the published works and preliminary results obtained during my PhD career will be discussed in detail.

Additive manufacturing e ottimizzazione topologica: massimizzare le prestazioni di una pinza freno per applicazioni motorsport

I veicoli ad alte prestazioni sono soggetti ad elevati carichi per piccoli intervalli di tempo. Questo comporta diverse criticità sulle componenti che costituiscono la vettura: una di queste è la pinza freno. Al fine di renderla performante è necessario il possesso di due proprietà. In primo luogo, la pinza freno deve essere il più leggera possibile poiché essa conferisce un'inerzia nella risposta della sospensione del veicolo, procurando il distacco dello pneumatico dal suolo e causando perdita di aderenza. In secondo luogo, è necessario contenere le deformazioni della pinza freno garantendo un determinato feeling per il pilota. Il compito del progettista è ottimizzare questi due parametri che hanno effetti antitetici. Questa difficoltà porta il progettista a creare design molto complessi per raggiungere l’ottimale e non sempre le geometrie ottenute sono realizzabili con tecnologie convenzionali. Questo studio riguarda il miglioramento prestazionale di una pinza freno costruita con una lega di alluminio 7075-T6 e lavorato dal pieno. Gli obbiettivi sono quello di produrre il nuovo corpo in titanio TI6Al4V, dal momento che le temperature di esercizio portano a grandi decadute di caratteristiche meccaniche dell’alluminio, contenere il più possibile la massa a fronte dell’aumento di densità di materiale e ovviamente limitare le deformazioni. Al fine di ottenere gli obbiettivi prefissati sono utilizzati metodi agli elementi finiti in diverse fasi della progettazione: per acquisire una geometria di partenza (ottimizzazione topologica) e per la validazione delle geometrie ottenute. Le geometrie ricavate tramite l’ottimizzazione topologica devono essere ricostruite tramite software CAD affinché possano essere ingegnerizzate. Durante la modellazione è necessario valutare quale tecnologia è più vantaggiosa per produrre il componente. In questo caso studio si utilizza un processo di addizione di materiale, più specificatamente una tecnica Selective Laser Melting (SLM).

L'additive manufacturing nel planning pre-operatorio in chirurgia maxillofacciale

Il 3D printing è presente da tempo in molti settori economici e da sempre ha nella sanità uno dei principali ambiti di applicazione. Durante il corso del presente lavoro sono state esaminate le principali applicazioni in campo sanitario con particolare focus sulla fase di planning in caso di chirurgia complessa. La pianificazione risulta essere la fase maggiormente impattante nel contesto più globale di gestione del paziente in quanto una maggior accuratezza nella visualizzazione del caso clinico consente di ottimizzare l’identificazione di un adeguato approccio chirurgico con ovvie conseguenti ripercussioni positive sulla totalità della degenza del paziente all’interno della struttura clinica ospitante. Nel dettaglio è stato valutato l’utilizzo di un innovativo protocollo di pre-planning e follow-up operatorio tramite la realizzazione di modelli stampati 3D a partire da immagini di diagnostica classica (TAC, MRI, 3Dscan) che hanno consentito di poter fornire allo specialista clinico di riferimento un prodotto che riproducendo perfettamente l’anatomia del soggetto (morfologia-proprietà fisiche del tessuto) ha consentito allo stesso un miglioramento delle usuali pratiche chirurgiche e terapeutiche in casi di elevata complessità in un arco temporale ristretto. I parametri utilizzati per la valutazione dei reali benefici dell’approccio esposto sono stati: tempi di pianificazione chirurgica e tempi di intervento all’interno di una più globale analisi dei costi associati. A fronte di un’indagine interna preventiva presso l’azienda ospedaliera ospitante sono stati designati i seguenti reparti come settori pilota: maxillofacciale, neurochirurgia e radiologia interventistica. Lo studio è stato svolto in collaborazione con l’ospedale M.Bufalini di Cesena in qualità di referente clinico e l’azienda Aid4Med Srl in qualità di azienda leader in pianificazione operatoria tramite ausili realizzati tramite tecniche di additive manufacturing.

Evaluation of recycled carbon fibers as PLA reinforcement for additive manufacturing applications

The increased exploitation of carbon fiber reinforced polymers (CFRP) is inevitably bringing about an increase in production scraps and end-of-life components, resulting in a sharp increase in CFRP waste. Therefore, it is of paramount importance to find efficient ways to reintroduce waste into the manufacturing cycle. At present, several recycling methods for treating CFRPs are available, even if all of them still have to be optimized. The step after CFRP recycling, and also the key to build a solid and sustainable CFRP recycling market, is represented by the utilization of Re-CFs. The smartest way to utilize recovered carbon fibers is through the manufacturing of recycled CFRPs, that can be done by re-impregnating the recovered fibers with a new polymeric matrix. Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF) is one of the most widely used additive manufacturing (3D printing) techniques that fabricates parts with a polymeric filament deposition process that allows to produce parts adding material layer-by-layer, only where it is needed, saving energy, raw material cost, and waste. The filament can also contain fillers or reinforcements such as recycled short carbon fibers and this makes it perfectly compliant with the re-application of the shortened recycled CF. Therefore, in this thesis work recycled and virgin carbon fiber reinforced PLA filaments have been initially produced using 5% and 10% of CFs load. Properties and characteristics of the filaments have been determined conducting different analysis (TGA, DMA, DSC). Subsequently the 5%wt. Re-CFs filament has been used to 3D print specimens for mechanical characterization (DMA, tensile test and CTE), in order to evaluate properties of printed PLA composites containing Re-CFs and evaluate the feasibility of Re-CFs in 3D printing application.

Produzione di un filamento a base di acido polilattico additivato con rinforzo di origine naturale per additive manufacturing

Scopo dell'elaborato è stato la produzione di un materiale bio-composito formato da PLA ed un rinforzo di origine naturale derivante dal settore agricolo, nell'ottica di diminuire i costi dei manufatti costituiti da tale materiale, riducendo il contenuto di PLA, e rivalorizzare lo scarto di farine in applicazioni di stampa 3D. Inizialmente le farine sono state studiate mediante analisi spettroscopiche (FT-ATR), osservazioni al microscopio ottico e analisi TGA. Dopodiché sono stati prodotti filamenti per stampa 3D di materiale composito al 10% e caratterizzati termicamente (DSC, TGA, Cp) e meccanicamente (DMA). Successivamente alla stampa 3D di questi filamenti, sono stati analizzati comportamenti termici (CTE, DSC) e meccanici (prove di trazione, DMA) dei provini stampati. Si è infine valutata l'influenza del trattamento termico di ricottura sui provini stampati mediante analisi DSC e DMA.

Metal additive manufacturing of soft magnetic material for electric machines

This research work concerns the application of additive manufacturing (AM) technologies in new electric mobility sectors. The unmatched freedom that AM offers can potentially change the way electric motors are designed and manufactured. The thesis investigates the possibility of creating optimized electric machines that exploit AM technologies, with potential in various industrial sectors, including automotive and aerospace. In particular, we will evaluate how the design of electric motors can be improved by producing the rotor core using Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) and how the resulting design choices affect component performance. First, the metallurgical and soft magnetic properties of the pure iron and silicon iron alloy parts (Fe-3% wt.Si) produced by LPBF will be defined and discussed, considering the process parameters and the type of heat treatment. This research shows that using LPBF, both pure iron and iron silicon, the parts have mechanical and magnetic properties different from the laminated ones. Hence, FEM-based modeling will be employed to design the rotor core of an SYN RM machine to minimize torque ripple while maintaining structural integrity. Finally, we suggest that further research should extend the field of applicability to other electrical devices.

Advanced Organic Materials: from Additive Manufacturing to Organic Electronics and Biomedical Applications

This manuscript represents an overview on the studies I was involved in during my PhD at the Industrial Chemistry Department “Toso Montanari”, in the ASOM (Advanced Smart Organic Materials) research group under the supervision of Prof. Letizia Sambri and Prof. Mauro Comes Franchini. Those research have been focused on the development of organic materials for advanced applications in different fields, among which organic electronics, additive manufacturing (3D Printing) and biomedical applications can be underlined.