Value for Money and Policy Review of the Economic Cost and Charges Associated with Private and Semi-Private Treatment Services in Public Hospitals - Final Report

This Value for Money and Policy Review (VFM&PR) of the Economic Cost and Charges Associated with Private and Semi-Private Treatment Services in Public Hospitals was initiated by the Department of Health and Children in June 2009 and was conducted under the auspices of the Governmentâ?Ts Value for Money & Policy Review Initiative 2009-2011. The Review was overseen by an independently chaired National Steering Group comprised of senior representatives from the Department of Health and Children, the Department of Finance, and the Health Service Executive (HSE). Download document here Download Explanatory Note  

Value for Money and Policy Review of the Economic Cost and Charges Associated with Private and Semi-Private Treatment Services in Public Hospitals - Interim Report

This report sets out a revised costing methodology and an estimate of the gap which currently exists between private and semi-private bed charges and the average economic cost. While the Steering Group considers the costing methodology proposed as an improvement on the approach taken in previous years and a good overall approximation of the difference on average between economic costs and current charges, it recognises that the current charging regime does not take sufficient account of the variation between different categories of patient. Download document here Note to Readers

New genetic models and mesenchymal cells as tools to ameliorate anti-tumor immunity

Résumé Le but final de ce projet est d'utiliser des cellules T ou des cellules souches mésenchymateuses modifiées génétiquement afin de surexprimer localement les deux chémokines CXCL13 et CCL2 ensemble ou chacune séparément à l'intérieur d'une tumeur solide. CXCL13 est supposé induire des structures lymphoïdes ectopiques. Un niveau élevé de CCL2 est présumé initier une inflammation aiguë. La combinaison des deux effets amène à un nouveau modèle d'étude des mécanismes régulateur de la tolérance périphérique et de l'immunité tumorale. Les connaissances acquises grâce à ce modèle pourraient permettre le développement ou l'amélioration des thérapies immunes du cancer. Le but premier de ce travail a été l'établissement d'un modèle génétique de la souris permettant d'exprimer spécifiquement dans la tumeur les deux chémokines d'intérêt à des niveaux élevés. Pour accomplir cette tâche, qui est en fait une thérapie génétique de tumeurs solides, deux types de cellules porteuses potentielles ont été évaluées. Des cellules CD8+ T et des cellules mésenchymateuses de la moelle osseuse transférées dans des receveurs portant une tumeur. Si on pouvait répondre aux besoins de la thérapie génétique, indépendamment de la thérapie immune envisagée, on posséderait là un outil précieux pour bien d'autres approches thérapeutiques. Plusieurs lignées de souris transgéniques ont été générées comme source de cellules CD8+ T modifiées afin d'exprimer les chémokines d'intérêt. Dans une approche doublement transgénique les propriétés de deux promoteurs spécifiques de cellules T ont été combinées en utilisant la technologie Cre-loxP. Le promoteur de granzyme B confère une dépendance d'activation et le promoteur distal de lck assure une forte expression constitutive dès que les cellules CD8+ T ont été activées. Les transgènes construits ont montré une bonne performance in vivo et des souris qui expriment CCL2 dans des cellules CD8+ T activées ont été obtenues. Ces cellules peuvent maintenant être utilisées avec différents protocoles pour transférer des cellules T cytotoxiques (CTL) dans des receveurs porteur d'une tumeur, permettant ainsi d'évaluer leur capacité en tant que porteuse de chémokine d'infiltrer la tumeur. L'établissement de souris transgéniques, qui expriment pareillement CXCL13 est prévu dans un avenir proche. L'évaluation de cellules mésenchymateuses de la moelle osseuse a démontré que ces cellules se greffent efficacement dans le stroma tumoral suite à la co-injection avec des cellules tumorales. Cela représente un outil précieux pour la recherche, vu qu'il permet d'introduire des cellules manipulées dans un modèle tumoral. Les résultats confirment partiellement d'autres résultats rapportés dans un modèle amélioré. Cependant, l'efficacité et la spécificité suggérées de la migration systémique de cellules mésenchymateuses de la moelle osseuse dans une tumeur n'ont pas été observées dans notre modèle, ce qui indique, que ces cellules ne se prêtent pas à une utilisation thérapeutique. Un autre résultat majeur de ce travail est l'établissement de cultures de cellules mésenchymateuses de la moelle osseuse in vitro conditionnées par des tumeurs, ce qui a permis à ces cellules de s'étendre plus rapidement en gardant leur capacité de migration et de greffe. Cela offre un autre outil précieux, vu que la culture in vitro est un pas nécessaire pour une manipulation thérapeutique. Abstract The ultimate aim of the presented project is to use genetically modified T cells or mesenchymal stem cells to locally overexpress the two chemokines CXCL13 and CCL2 together or each one alone inside a solid tumor. CXCL13 is supposed to induce ectopic lymphoid structures and a high level of CCL2 is intended to trigger acute inflamation. The combination of these two effects represents a new model for studying mechanisms that regulate peripheral tolerance and tumor immunity. Gained insights may help developing or improving immunotherapy of cancer. The primary goal of the executed work was the establishment of a genetic mouse model that allows tumor-specific expression of high levels of the two chemokines of interest. For accomplishing this task, which represents gene therapy of solid tumors, two types of potentially useful carrier cells were evaluated. CD8+ T cells and mesenchymal bone marrow cells to be used in adoptive cell transfers into tumor-bearing mice. Irrespectively of the envisaged immunotherapy, satisfaction of so far unmet needs of gene therapy would be a highly valuable tool that may be employed by many other therapeutic approaches, too. Several transgenic mouse lines were generated as a source of CD8+ T cells modified to express the chemokines of interest. In a double transgenic approach the properties of two T cell-specific promoters were combined using Cre-loxP technology. The granzyme B promoter confers activation-dependency and the lck distal promoter assures strong constitutive expression once the CD8+ T cell has been activated. The constructed transgenes showed a good performance in vivo and mice expressing CCL2 in activated CD8+ T cells were obtained. These cells can now be used with different protocols for adoptively transferring cytotoxic T cells (CTL) into tumor-bearing recipients, thus allowing to study their capacity as tumor-infiltrating chemokine carrier. The establishment of transgenic mice likewisely expressing CXCL13 is expected in the near future. In addition, T cells from generated single transgenic mice that have high expression of an EGFP reporter in both CD4+ and CD8+ cells can be easily traced in vivo when setting up adoptive transfer conditions. The evaluation of mesenchymal bone marrow cells demonstrated that these cells can efficiently engraft into tumor stroma upon local coinjection with tumor cells. This represents a valuable tool for research purposes as it allows to introduce manipulated stromal cells into a tumor model. Therefore, the established engraftment model is suited for studying the envisaged immunotherapy. These results confirm to some extend previously reported results in an improved model, however, the suggested systemic tumor homing efficiency and specificity of mesenchymal bone marrow cells was not observed in our model indicating that these cells may not be suited for therapeutic use. Another major result of the presented work is the establishment oftumor-conditioned in vitro culture of mesenchymal bone marrow cells, which allowed to more rapidly expand these cells while maintaining their tumor homing and engrafting capacities. This offers another valuable tool as in vitro culture is a necessary step for therapeutic manipulations.

Do pseudo-absence selection strategies influence species distribution models and their predictions? An information-theoretic approach based on simulated data

Background Multiple logistic regression is precluded from many practical applications in ecology that aim to predict the geographic distributions of species because it requires absence data, which are rarely available or are unreliable. In order to use multiple logistic regression, many studies have simulated "pseudo-absences" through a number of strategies, but it is unknown how the choice of strategy influences models and their geographic predictions of species. In this paper we evaluate the effect of several prevailing pseudo-absence strategies on the predictions of the geographic distribution of a virtual species whose "true" distribution and relationship to three environmental predictors was predefined. We evaluated the effect of using a) real absences b) pseudo-absences selected randomly from the background and c) two-step approaches: pseudo-absences selected from low suitability areas predicted by either Ecological Niche Factor Analysis: (ENFA) or BIOCLIM. We compared how the choice of pseudo-absence strategy affected model fit, predictive power, and information-theoretic model selection results. Results Models built with true absences had the best predictive power, best discriminatory power, and the "true" model (the one that contained the correct predictors) was supported by the data according to AIC, as expected. Models based on random pseudo-absences had among the lowest fit, but yielded the second highest AUC value (0.97), and the "true" model was also supported by the data. Models based on two-step approaches had intermediate fit, the lowest predictive power, and the "true" model was not supported by the data. Conclusion If ecologists wish to build parsimonious GLM models that will allow them to make robust predictions, a reasonable approach is to use a large number of randomly selected pseudo-absences, and perform model selection based on an information theoretic approach. However, the resulting models can be expected to have limited fit.

Economic structure and key sectors analysis of greenhouse gas emissions in Uruguay

This paper identifies the key sectors in greenhouse gas emissions of the Uruguayan economy through input-output analysis. This allows to precisely determine the role played by the different productive sectors and their relationship with other sectors in the relation between the Uruguayan productive structure and atmospheric pollution. In order to guide policy design for GHG reduction, we decompose sectors liability between the pollution generated through their own production processes and the pollution indirectly generated in the production processes of other sectors. The results show that all the key polluting sectors for the different contaminants considered are relevant because of their own emissions, except for the sector Motor vehicles and oil retail trade, which is relevant in CO2 emissions because of its pure, both backward and forward, linkages. Finally, the best policy channels for controlling and reducing GHGs emissions are identified, and compared with the National Climate Change Response Plan (NCCRP) lines of action.

Economic crisis and recovery: changes in second birth rates within occupational classes and educational groups

This study assesses the decline in second birth rates for men and women across different skill levels in transitional Russia. Changes within educational groups and occupational classes are observed over three distinct time periods: the Soviet era, economic crisis, and economic recovery. The most remarkable finding is the similarity in the extent second birth rates declined within educational groups and occupational classes during the economic crisis. Although further decline occurred in the recovery period, more variation emerged across groups.

Cannabinoid addiction: behavioral models and neural correlates

The use of cannabis sativa preparations as recreational drugs can be traced back to the earliest civilizations. However, animal models of cannabinoid addiction allowing the exploration of neural correlates of cannabinoid abuse have been developed only recently. We review these models and the role of the CB1 cannabinoid receptor, the main target of natural cannabinoids, and its interaction with opioid and dopamine transmission in reward circuits. Extensive reviews on the molecular basis of cannabinoid action are available elsewhere (Piomelli et al., 2000;Schlicker and Kathmann, 2001).

Repression and Protest Structural Models and Strategic Interactions

The recent wave of upheavals and revolts in Northern Africa and the Middle East goes back to an old question often raised by theories of collective action: does repression act as a negative or positive incentive for further mobilization? Through a review of the vast literature devoted to this question, this article aims to go beyond theoretical and methodological dead-ends. The article moves on to non-Western settings in order to better understand, via a macro-sociological and dynamic approach, the causal effects between mobilizations and repression. It pleads for a meso- and micro-level approach to this issue: an approach that puts analytical emphasis both on protest organizations and on individual activists' careers.

New validated prognostic models and prognostic calculators in patients with low-grade gliomas diagnosed by central pathology review: a pooled analysis of EORTC/RTOG/NCCTG phase III clinical trials.

Background In a previous study, the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer (EORTC) reported a scoring system to predict survival of patients with low-grade gliomas (LGGs). A major issue in the diagnosis of brain tumors is the lack of agreement among pathologists. New models in patients with LGGs diagnosed by central pathology review are needed. Methods Data from 339 EORTC patients with LGGs diagnosed by central pathology review were used to develop new prognostic models for progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS). Data from 450 patients with centrally diagnosed LGGs recruited into 2 large studies conducted by North American cooperative groups were used to validate the models. Results Both PFS and OS were negatively influenced by the presence of baseline neurological deficits, a shorter time since first symptoms (<30 wk), an astrocytic tumor type, and tumors larger than 5 cm in diameter. Early irradiation improved PFS but not OS. Three risk groups have been identified (low, intermediate, and high) and validated. Conclusions We have developed new prognostic models in a more homogeneous LGG population diagnosed by central pathology review. This population better fits with modern practice, where patients are enrolled in clinical trials based on central or panel pathology review. We could validate the models in a large, external, and independent dataset. The models can divide LGG patients into 3 risk groups and provide reliable individual survival predictions. Inclusion of other clinical and molecular factors might still improve models' predictions.

Fading models and metrics for contemporary wireless systems

The purpose of this paper is to examine (1) some of the models commonly used to represent fading,and (2) the information-theoretic metrics most commonly used to evaluate performance over those models. We raise the question of whether these models and metrics remain adequate in light of the advances that wireless systems haveundergone over the last two decades. Weaknesses are pointedout, and ideas on possible fixes are put forth.

Transitory Economic Shocks and Civil Conflict

I examine whether civil conflict is triggered by transitory negative economic shocks. My approach follows Miguel, Satyanath, and Sergenti (2004) in using rainfall as an exogenous source of economic shocks in Sub-Saharan African countries. The main difference is that my empirical specifications take into account that rainfall shocks are transitory. Failure to do so may, for example, lead to the conclusion that civil conflict is more likely to break out following negative rainfall shocks when conflict is most probable following years with exceptionally high rainfall levels.

Bridging DSGE models and the raw data

A method to estimate DSGE models using the raw data is proposed. The approachlinks the observables to the model counterparts via a flexible specification which doesnot require the model-based component to be solely located at business cycle frequencies,allows the non model-based component to take various time series patterns, andpermits model misspecification. Applying standard data transformations induce biasesin structural estimates and distortions in the policy conclusions. The proposed approachrecovers important model-based features in selected experimental designs. Twowidely discussed issues are used to illustrate its practical use.

Economic growth and investment in the Arab world

This paper analyses the economic growth performance in the Arab world overthe last forty years. The Arab world has managed to reduce povertyperformance despite its relatively disappointing growth performance. Werelate this poor performance of both oil and non-oil producers toinvestment. Contrary to widespread belief, we do not find evidence that lowquantity of investment is the main of low growth. The decline in theinvestment rate followed rather than preceded the reduction in the aggregategrowth rate. We conclude that the low quality of investment projects is thekey determinant of growth. The excessive reliance on public investment, thelow quality of financial institutions, the bad business environment (due topolitical and social instability and to excessive public intervention andoverregulation) and the low quality of human capital are importantdeterminants of systematically unproductive investment decisions and, thus,low economic growth.