Prevention or repression? The false dilemma of citizen security

Includes bibliography

Trading democracy for security? The effects of the international drug war on the quality of democracy in the Dominican Republic, 1996–2008

The purpose of the research is to study the relationship between international drug interdiction policies and domestic politics in fragile democracies, and to demonstrate how international drug control policies and the use of force fit the rhetoric of war, are legitimized by the principles of a just war, but may also cause collateral damage and negative unintended consequences. The method used is a case study of the Dominican Republic. The research has found that international drug control regimes, primarily led by the U.S. and narrowly focused on interdiction, have influenced an increasingly militarized approach to domestic law enforcement in the Dominican Republic. The collateral damage caused by militarized enforcement comes in the form of negative perceptions of citizen security, loss of respect for the rule of law and due process, and low levels of civil society development. The drug war has exposed the need for significant reform of the institutions charged with carrying out enforcement, the police force and the judicial system in particular. The dissertation concludes that the extent of drug trafficking in the Dominican Republic is beyond the scope of domestic reform efforts alone, but that the programs implemented do show some potential for future success. The dissertation also concludes that the framework of warfare is not the most appropriate for the international problems of drug traffic and abuse. A broader, multipronged approach should be considered by world policy makers in order to address all conditions that allow drugs to flourish without infringing upon democratic and civil rights in the process.

Consolidating Security and Development in Colombia: Lessons for Peru and Panama

Colombia's increasingly effective efforts to mitigate the power of the FARC and other illegitimately armed groups in the country can offer important lessons for the Peruvian government as it strives to prevent a resurgence of Sendero Luminoso and other illegal non-state actors. Both countries share certain particular challenges: deep economic, social, and in the case of Peru ethnic divisions, the presence of and/or the effects of violent insurgencies, a large-scale narcotics production and trafficking, and a history of weak state presence in large tracts of isolated and scarcely-populated areas. Important differences exist, however in the nature of the insurgencies in the two countries, the government response to them and the nature of government and society that affects the applicability of Colombia's experience to Peru. The security threat to Panama from drug trafficking and Colombian insurgents --often a linked phenomenon-- are in many ways different from the drug/insurgent factor in Colombia itself and in Peru, although there are similar variables. Unlike the Colombian and Peruvian cases, the security threat in Panama is not directed against the state, there are no domestic elements seeking to overthrow the government -- as the case of the FARC and Sendero Luminoso, security problems have not spilled over from rural to urban areas in Panama, and there is no ideological component at play in driving the threat. Nor is drug cultivation a major factor in Panama as it is in Colombia and Peru. The key variable that is shared among all three cases is the threat of extra-state actors controlling remote rural areas or small towns where state presence is minimal. The central lesson learned from Colombia is the need to define and then address the key problem of a "sovereignity gap," lack of legitimate state presence in many part of the country. Colombia's success in broadening the presence of the national government between 2002 and the presence is owed to many factors, including an effective national strategy, improvements in the armed forces and police, political will on the part of government for a sustained effort, citizen buy-in to the national strategy, including the resolve of the elite to pay more in taxes to bring change about, and the adoption of a sequenced approach to consolidated development in conflicted areas. Control of territory and effective state presence improved citizen security, strengthened confidence in democracy and the legitimate state, promoted economic development, and helped mitigate the effect of illegal drugs. Peru can benefit from the Colombian experience especially in terms of the importance of legitimate state authority, improved institutions, gaining the support of local citizens, and furthering development to wean communities away from drugs. State coordinated "integration" efforts in Peru as practiced in Colombia have the potential for success if properly calibrated to Peruvian reality, coordinated within government, and provided with sufficient resources. Peru's traditionally weak political institutions and lack of public confidence in the state in many areas of the country must be overcome if this effort is to be successful.

Trading Democracy for Security? The Effects of the International Drug War on the Quality of Democracy in the Dominican Republic, 1996 -2008

The purpose of the research is to study the relationship between international drug interdiction policies and domestic politics in fragile democracies, and to demonstrate how international drug control policies and the use of force fit the rhetoric of war, are legitimized by the principles of a just war, but may also cause collateral damage and negative unintended consequences. The method used is a case study of the Dominican Republic. The research has found that international drug control regimes, primarily led by the U.S. and narrowly focused on interdiction, have influenced an increasingly militarized approach to domestic law enforcement in the Dominican Republic. The collateral damage caused by militarized enforcement comes in the form of negative perceptions of citizen security, loss of respect for the rule of law and due process, and low levels of civil society development. The drug war has exposed the need for significant reform of the institutions charged with carrying out enforcement, the police force and the judicial system in particular. The dissertation concludes that the extent of drug trafficking in the Dominican Republic is beyond the scope of domestic reform efforts alone, but that the programs implemented do show some potential for future success. The dissertation also concludes that the framework of warfare is not the most appropriate for the international problems of drug traffic and abuse. A broader, multipronged approach should be considered by world policy makers in order to address all conditions that allow drugs to flourish without infringing upon democratic and civil rights in the process.

Segurança na Organização dos Estados Americanos (OEA): uma análise crítica dos discursos sobre segurança cidadã e direitos humanos

A segurança cidadã é apresentada nos dias de hoje como um novo modelo de segurança, forjado a partir da necessidade de aliar direito à segurança e proteção de direitos humanos. A expressão segurança cidadã habita planos de segurança nacionais e estratégias hemisféricas sobre segurança de forma bastante consensual, representando um avanço na atuação estatal frente às ameaças do campo da segurança pública, refletida em uma atuação humanizada. No desdobramento do conteúdo em ações, bem como na legitimação e propagação da terminologia e estratégias associadas a este modelo de segurança, a OEA se destaca como um importante espaço jurídico-político de caráter interamericano. O modelo de segurança cidadã é a conformação mais recente do conceito de segurança, que, entretanto, teve início na OEA - ainda anos 80 - por meio do desenvolvimento de documentos estratégicos de combate às drogas. Neste sentido, este trabalho quer entender, concretamente, em que medida esta novo modelo de segurança realmente oferece novas abordagens e/ou outras condições que representem uma ampliação na garantia de direitos humanos. Para tanto, considerasse relevante à análise dos mais relevantes documentos sobre segurança, nos quais é possível identificar conceitos-chave e estratégias de ação e como estes foram atualizados ao longo do tempo. Esta análise é feita a partir de uma perspectiva da criminologia crítica, que com seus conceitos e categorias equaciona aspectos da realidade político-criminal, bem como fatores socioeconômicos e da realidade carcerária da região, que usualmente não integram os modelos de segurança, embora tenham relação direta com uma mais ampla garantia de direitos humanos.

Alcances y limitaciones de la implementación de políticas públicas en materia de convivencia ciudadana en la ciudad de Bogotá. Estudio de caso Programa Goles en Paz. Periodo de estudio 1999-2011

Este Trabajo de Grado se refiere al análisis de los alcances y limitaciones de una de las políticas públicas más interesantes que ha adelantado las autoridades de Bogotá en materia de convivencia ciudadana: El Programa Goles en Paz durante el periodo 1999-2011. Dicha política pública fue creada en la administración de Enrique Peñalosa, luego en la Alcaldía de Antanas Mockus se le dio continuidad al proceso y en las Alcaldías de Luis Eduardo Garzón y Samuel Moreno se fortaleció el proceso que se había iniciado en el año de 1999. Hay que tener en cuenta que Goles en Paz es una política pública Distrital que le apuesta a la convivencia y la seguridad ciudadana, dentro y fuera de los estadios, en las localidades y los barrios de Bogotá y precisamente a lo largo de este documento se pretende realizar un recuento de los principales alcances y limitaciones que ha tenido el Programa en estos doce años de estudio. Para esto el trabajo de grado cuenta con tres capítulos. En el primero se da a conocer y se analiza el fenómeno de las barras bravas en la ciudad. En el segundo capítulo se define qué es una política pública y se reconoce los elementos de dicha definición en el Programa Goles en Paz. Finalmente, en el tercer capítulo se concretan los alcances y limitaciones que ha venido presentando Goles en Paz durante estos doce años de estudio.

Los Hot Spots: ¿Una alternativa para reducir los niveles de delincuencia en Bogotá?

El interés de esta monografía es analizar la incidencia de la estrategia de seguridad ciudadana de los Hot Spots en los niveles de delincuencia de Bogotá durante el periodo de la Alcaldía de Samuel Moreno 2009-2011, tomando como casos de estudio la Avenida 19 y la Zona Rosa (Chicó El Lago). Esta investigación se realiza desde los conceptos teórico-prácticos que ha arrojado el modelo de Hot Spot tras su aplicación en 18 ciudades del mundo, y que sirven como herramienta para analizar las transformaciones del delito en las zonas de estudio. De esta manera se avanza hacia el resultado que permite identificar los factores que impidieron que el modelo de Hot Spots se formulara y ejecutara efectivamente y por lo tanto no disminuyera los niveles de delincuencia en Bogotá.

Nuevas perspectivas sobre la seguridad ciudadana en Latinoamérica

Editorial volumen especial en seguridad ciudadana.

La vigilancia comunitaria y la crisis de seguridad ciudadana en Latinoamérica

Traducción del artículo "Community Policing and Latin America's Citizen Security Crisis"

Plan de intervención en seguridad humana 75-cien, un análisis desde la implementación de políticas públicas en materia de seguridad ciudadana en Bogotá. Estudio de caso UPZ Las Cruces

La presente investigación tiene como objetivo principal, explicar la influencia de la línea de intervención de Seguridad Humana del plan 75-cien, en la seguridad ciudadana de la UPZ Las Cruces, con el fin de demostrar que la política pública no influye de manera significativa en la seguridad ciudadana de la UPZ Las Cruces, ante la participación casi nula de la Policía Nacional en el proyecto. A pesar de que la intervención focaliza el territorio y prioriza las necesidades sociales, el vacío que existe en el trabajo conjunto entre la Policía y la Secretaria Distrital de Gobierno, implica que no se establezcan acciones policivas que acompañen las estrategias de desarrollo humano para evitar o disuadir el delito. Por lo tanto a partir de la utilización del método cualitativo, se recolectaran datos de grupos focales, informes de las fuentes primarias y un diagnóstico de la línea de intervención, que permitan un análisis descriptivo y explicativo del fenómeno.

Caribbean forum: Shaping a sustainable development agenda to address the Caribbean reality in the twenty-first century

Includes bibliography.

Segurança na América do Sul: uma abordagem histórico-conceitual

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES)

Micro-governance and citizen-based security in Brazil

Thèse numérisée par la Division de la gestion de documents et des archives de l'Université de Montréal

Experiences, sensations and demands of citizen (in)security: recent complex configurations in Argentina

Over the last decades the issue of insecurity due to an increase in crime rates and its possible impact on the stability of Latin American democracies has sparked an ongoing debate. In this context, the present article studies, for the case of Argentina, how experiences and sensations of insecurity may be articulated to demands for greater punitive rigor. The analysis is based on two types of information. Initially, data from international surveys such as Latinoabarometer are considered. Then, these are compared to data from prolonged on-site observations in a poor neighborhood of a mid-sized Argentine city. The combination of these different types of data shows the complexity of the process. Contrary to what is often assumed, experiences and sensations of insecurity do not lineally lead to demands for greater punitive rigor. The way in which social actors elaborate their experiences of insecurity is highly situational and not systematic. We have found that there is not necessarily a consistent process of ‘meaning construction’ that articulates experiences and sensations of insecurity with political demands.