What Happened to the ‘Development’ in Sustainable Development? Business Guidelines Two Decades After Brundtland

Over twenty years ago ‘Our Common Future’ presented a conceptualization and explanation of the concept of sustainable development. Since then numerous alternative definitions of the concept have been offered, of which at least some are exclusive to each other. At the same time, the role of business in the transition to sustainable development has increasingly received attention. Bringing these two trends in sustainable development together, this paper returns to the Brundtland version of the concept to examine to what extent the original principles of sustainable development are still embedded within key business guidelines, namely the UN Global Compact, the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises, the ICC Business Charter for Sustainable Development, the CAUX Principles, the Global Sullivan Principles and the CERES Principles. The findings suggest that these business guidelines tend to emphasize environmental rather than social aspects of sustainable development, in particular to the detriment of the original Brundtland prioritization of the needs of the poorest. Furthermore, the attention to environmental aspects stresses win-win situations and has a clear managerialist focus; whereas more conceptual environmental issues concerning systems interdependencies, critical thresholds or systemic limits to growth find little attention. The normative codes and principles targeted at the private sector thus not only add another voice to the multiple discourses on sustainable development but also contribute to a reinterpretation of the original agenda set by Brundtland towards conceptualizations of sustainable development around the needs of industrialised rather than developing countries. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and ERP Environment

Desenvolvimento sustentável: uma análise a partir do Relatório Brundtland

Pós-graduação em Ciências Sociais - FFC

Positive development and assessment

Purpose – There has been a tendency in sustainability science to be passive. The purpose of this paper is to introduce an alternative positive framework for a more active and direct approach to sustainable design and assessment that de-couples environmental impacts and economic growth. Design/methodology/approach – This paper deconstructs some systemic gaps that are critical to sustainability in built environment management processes and tools, and reframes negative “sustainable” decision making and assessment frameworks into their positive counterparts. In particular, it addresses the omission of ecology, design and ethics in development assessment. Findings – Development can be designed to provide ecological gains and surplus “eco-services,” but assessment tools and processes favor business-as-usual. Despite the tenacity of the dominant paradigm (DP) in sustainable development institutionalized by the Brundtland Report over 25 years ago, these omissions are easily corrected. Research limitations/implications – The limitation is that the author was unable to find exceptions to the omissions cited here in the extensive literature on urban planning and building assessment tools. However, exceptions prove the rule. The implication is that it is not too late for eco-positive retrofitting of cities to increase natural and social capital. The solutions are just as applicable in places like China and India as the USA, as they pay for themselves. Originality/value – Positive development (PD) is a fundamental paradigm shift that reverses the negative models, methods and metrics of the DP of sustainable development. This paper provides an example of how existing “negative” concepts and practices can be converted into positive ones through a PD prism. Through a new form of bio-physical design, development can be a sustainability solution.

Desenvolvimento, sustentabilidade e relações internacionais: uma análise dos indicadores de desenvolvimento sustentável e sua aplicação ao caso brasileiro

O desenvolvimento sustentável foi definido pelo Relatório Brundtland como o desenvolvimento que satisfaz as necessidades presentes, sem comprometer a capacidade das gerações futuras de suprir suas próprias necessidades. Esse tipo de desenvolvimento abarca tanto a questão do crescimento econômico com distribuição de renda, quanto a necessidade de se preservar os recursos escassos do planeta, além de seus ecossistemas. O desenvolvimento sustentável é um tema que aborda dois conceitos-chave que afetam as relações entre os países: a necessidade de desenvolvimento de muitas nações que ainda não atingiram o patamar de riqueza dos países desenvolvidos e o imperativo da sustentabilidade, que restringe a possibilidade do desenvolvimento econômico ao interferir no processo produtivo das nações. Dessa forma, torna-se necessário abordar o desenvolvimento sustentável na perspectiva das Relações Internacionais. Acordos cooperativos em relação ao meio ambiente têm sido assinados muito mais como forma de cooperação bilateral do que global. O contexto histórico nos leva a um ponto de inflexão no cenário internacional, iniciado no ano de 2002 e que perdura até os dias atuais. Neste início de século XXI, a convergência dos países ao desenvolvimento sustentável passa a ser analisada pelo esforço unilateral de cada nação, explicitando o uso dos indicadores de desenvolvimento sustentável e justificando sua apreciação. É neste período em que se dará a análise da economia brasileira, conforme proposto pela dissertação. A partir da análise dos dados fornecidos pelos indicadores para a situação do desenvolvimento sustentável no Brasil, tem-se elaborada a questão central que esta dissertação procurará responder: a efetividade no uso destes indicadores para o direcionamento das políticas de desenvolvimento sustentável das nações. A valoração do desenvolvimento sustentável é de vital importância para o posicionamento das nações frente ao tema ambiental no mundo. Como diferentes conceitos são aceitos para o tema, a possibilidade de um grande acordo multilateral acerca do mesmo fica prejudicada. A maneira encontrada por alguns países foi redirecionar suas economias unilateralmente à sustentabilidade. O que isso irá provocar nas Relações Internacionais só o tempo poderá dizer. O que é certo é que a frágil relação entre os países será afetada por esse fato. O Brasil desponta como um expoente do desenvolvimento sustentável, pelo menos na intenção, e é através do uso de ferramentas como os indicadores de desenvolvimento sustentável que podemos mensurar o quanto seu discurso se converte em prática.

Las infraestructuras de recarga y el despegue del vehículo eléctrico.

Este trabajo revisa la evolución y estado actual de la automoción eléctrica; analiza las ventajas ambientales, de eficiencia energética y de costes del motor eléctrico frente al de combustión interna; y presenta como limitaciones para el uso del vehículo eléctrico, el desarrollo actual de las baterías recargables y la lenta implantación de electrolineras. Con el objetivo de contribuir al desarrollo de una actividad económica respetuosa con el medio ambiente y basada en nuevas tecnologías, se proyecta, a partir de experiencias previas, una instalación de puntos de recarga para una ciudad de 50.000 habitantes con un parque de 100 vehículos eléctricos que dispone de dos plazas de recarga rápida (poste trifásico 400V CA), siete plazas de recarga lenta (postes monofásicos 230V CA) y de 50 módulos fotovoltaicos que producen diariamente la energía equivalente a la recarga lenta de un vehículo en los meses fríos y de dos en los meses cálidos.

The design process paradox : traditional design processes vs. eco-design processes

The Brundtland Report (WCED, 1987) best known for its popularisation of the concept of sustainable development, also made recommendations for a new approach to design and production, setting out terms for: ‘a production system that respects... the ecological base’ and ‘a technological system that searches continuously for new solutions’. The industrial production, consumption and waste treatment of products today causes a large amount of various environmental burdens. The development and design of new products with reduced environmental impact is one of the new challenges towards a more sustainable society and is therefore an important task in the near future.

Cenário evolutivo da educação ambiental para o desenvolvimento sustentável no mundo: etapas e promotores

Desde a publicação do livro Silent Spring, 1962, de Rachel Carson, do livro The Limits to Growth, 1972, do Clube de Roma e do impacto provocado pelo Relatório Brundtland, Our Common Future, 1987, pela World Commission on Environment and Development, que os organismos internacionais se envolvem em parcerias e assinam declarações de compromisso com a Educação Ambiental para o Desenvolvimento Sustentável – EADS. O objetivo do presente artigo é realizar uma narrativa sobre os eventos dedicados à EADS, com início na Conferência de Estocolmo até à Conferência do Rio+20. O estudo teve como base metodológica uma revisão crítica da literatura. Concluiu-se que a sociedade tomou maior consciência sobre os problemas ambientais a partir de 1970. Despontaram as primeiras respostas político-administrativas na Conferência de Estocolmo e, mais tarde, publicou-se a Informação Brundtland pela equipa interdisciplinar de experts em meio ambiente. Daqui resultaram o Tratado de Bem-estar (garantia dos direitos mínimos aos cidadãos pelo Estado) e o conceito de Desenvolvimento Sustentável. Surgiu assim a solidariedade social para com o futuro da humanidade, que implicou o princípio de “não hipotecar os recursos das gerações futuras”. Na Conferência do Rio a EADS foi plenamente aceite e divulgada pelo mundo. Todavia, com a entrada do novo milénio, a atenção dada à EADS regrediu significativamente.

Borlänge och Falun Brundtland städer

Development of an infrastructure for Brundtland Renewable Energy Network - BREN är ettEuropean Commission Alterner Project med Contract no XVII/4. 1030/Z96-032.Projektet har sitt ursprung i UN rapporten “Our Common Future” 1989. Grundläggande för att nå de mål som rapporten föreslog var att förändra och minska användningen av energi. I Danmark tog man fram en handlingsplan för hur energiförbrukningen skulle kunna minskas “Energi 2000 - Handlingsplan för en bäredygtig udvikling”. De danska och schleswigholstenske energiministrarna överenskom att starta vars ett energisparprojekt i en mindre stad. Projektet kallades “Brundtlandby” och de två första var Toftlund i Sönderjylland och Bredstedt i Nordfriesland. Efter en kort tid anslöt sig ytterligare två tyska städer, Rheinsberg och Viernheim, samt Rajec i Slovakien. Mellan städerna formades ett nätverk för att utbyta information. Nätverket, Brundtland City Project, var inspirerande för de ingående städerna i det fortsatta arbetet med energisparåtgärder. Brundtland City Project presenterades på en internationell konferens “Cities and Energy” i Trondheim, Norge, december 1995. Projektet väckte intresse och det föreslogs att nätverket, som ett pilotprojekt, skulle utvecklas i norra Europa för att senare utökas med andra europeiska länder. En ledningsgrupp tillsattes medrepresentanter från de nordiska länderna.En ansökan sändes till European Commission, Alterner Program, och denna beviljades i juli 1996. Projektet indelades i (9 Activities. Aktivitet 1, var att sammanfatta erfarenheterna av Brundtland City Project i Toftlund, Danmark och Brundtland Cities Nätverket i Sovakien, Tyskland och Danmark. Den nordiska delen startar med Aktivitet 2, vilket var att engagera kommuner/städer i Finland, Norge och Sverige. Som samordnade för den svenska delen utsågs Solar Energy Research Center SERC vid Högskolan Dalarna. Projektet presenterades vid ett seminarium den 30 september för representanter för Borlänge och Falu kommuner. Den 10 december 1996 accepterade de två kommunerna inbjudan att ingå i det nordiska nätverket. Uppgiftslämnare i Borlänge kommun har varit Pelle Helje, Borlänge Energi och i Falu kommun Anders Goop, stadsbyggnadskontoret samt för underlag till Newsletter Jan Kaans, fastighetskontoret.Rapportering till Brundtland Center Danmark av arbetet i Borlänge och Falu kommuner har skett vid tre tillfällen, Aktiviteterna 2-5, 1997-12-16, Aktivitererna 6-7 inkluderande delar av aktiviterna 8-9, 1998-05-03 samt underlag till Newsletter, 1998-07-01. De nordiska rapporterna har sammanställts vid Brundtland Center Danmark för rapportering till European Commission. Gemensamt språk har varit engelska. Efter rapportering av aktiviterna 2 - 5 inbjöds till ett projektmöte och en studiedag vid Brundtland Center den 23 och 24 mars 1998. Det var första tillfället deltagarna i projektet strålade samman och nätverket tog därmed en mera konkret form. Man beslutade också att nästa projektmöte skulle hållas i Borlänge i augusti 1998 med Borlänge Energi och Solar Energy Research Center SERC som organisatörer. Beroende på att Brundtland Centre Danmark upplösts av ekonomiska skäl blev projektmötet i Borlänge inställt.Sammanställning av Final Report, October 1998, har utförts av Esbensen Consultants.Framtida utveckling av nätverketArbetet med Brundtland City Network avses fortsätta som ett “EU Thermie B-project” och nätverket kommer att utökas med fyra nya Brundtlandstäder från Österrike, Tyskland Italien och Storbritanien. Dessutom kommer samhället Putja i Estland att ingå i nätverket men detta financieras av EU-Phare programme.

Borlänge and Falun Brundtland cities

Development of an infrastructure for Brundtland Renewable Energy Network - BREN is a European Commission Alterner Project with Contract no XVII/4. 1030/Z96-032.The project has its origin in the UN-report “Our Common Future”, 1989. A change in and reduction of the use of energy was fundamental in order to reach the goals which the report proposed. Denmark decided on an action plan on how energy consumption could be reduced “Energi 2000 - Handlingsplan för en bäredygtig udvikling”. The ministries of energy in Denmark and Schleswig Holstein both agreed to start an energy saving project in a smaller town. The project was called “Brundtlandby” and the two first were Toftlund in South Jutland and Bredstedt in North Friesland. After a short period a further two German Cities, Rheinsberg and Viernheim, and Rajec in Slovakia joined the group. A network for the exchange of knowledge and experience between the cities was formed. The network, Brundtland City Project, inspired the participating cities in the continuing work with energy saving measures. The Brundtland City Project was presented at an international conference “Cities and Energy” in Trondheim, Norway,in December 1995. Great interest was shown in the project and it was decided that a network should be developed in northern European countries as a pilot project to be enlarged with other European countries later on. A steering committee was formed with representatives from the nordic countries.An application was sent to the European Commission, Alterner Program, and was approved in Juli 1996. The project was subdivided into nine activities. Activity 1, consisted of summarising the experiences of the Brundtland City Project in Toftlund, Denmark and the Brundtland Cities network in Slovakia, Germany and Denmark. The Scandinavian part started with Activity 2, to engage municipalities/cities in Finland, Norway and Sweden in the project. The Solar Energy Research Center, SERC, Högskolan Dalarna was appointed as co-ordinator for the Swedish part. The project was presented at a seminar on the 30th September for representatives from the municipalities of Borlänge and Falun. On the 10th of December 1996 the two municipalities accepted the invitation to join the Northern network. Pelle Helje, Borlänge Energi, has been informant for the municipality of Borlänge and Anders Goop, Department of Urban Planninginformant for the municipality of Falun with Jan Kaans, Estates department providing information to the basis for the Newsletter.Reports on the work in Borlänge and Falun municipalities have been made to Brundtland Center Denmark on three occasions; Activities 2-5, 16-12-1997, Activities 6-7, including parts of activities 8-9, 03-03-1998, and the basis for the Newsletter, 01-07-1998. The Nordic reports have been compiled at the Brundtland Center Denmark for submission to the European Commission. English has been the common language. After the report of activities 2 - 5 the participants wereinvited to a project meeting and a workshop at Brundtland Center the 23rd and 24th March 1998.This was the first occasion the participants in the project met and the network thus took a moreconcrete form. It also was decided that the next meeting should be in Borlänge in August 1998,with Borlänge Energi and Solar Energy Research Center SERC as organisers. As BrundtlandCentre Denmark was wound up for financial reasons, the project meeting in Borlänge wascancelled.Compilation of the Final Report was carried out by Esbensen Consultants in October 1998Future development of the networkIt is intended to continue the work with the Brundtland City Network as an “EU Thermie Bproject”and the network will be enlarged with the addition of four new Brundtland Cities from Austria, Germany, Italy and Great Britain. In addition the village of Putja in Estonia will join the network but this will be financed by the EU-Phare programme.

Injury prevention in Queensland : report to Queensland Injury Prevention Council

Injury is the fourth leading cause of death in Australia. Injury rates in Queensland are amongst the highest in Australia and 21.5% of people surveyed for this research reported that their lifestyle or that of an immediate family member had been permanently affected by injury. Injury results in over 40,000 hospital admissions and 200,000 attendances at hospital Emergency Departments in Queensland each year. Queensland's death rate from injuries is higher than the national average, with consistently higher rates of deaths related to transport injuries. Queensland statistics also show higher than national average rates of injuries due to falls, homicide and accidental drowning. (Pike, Muller, Baade & Ward, 2000) In 2000-01 injuries represented over $4 billion (or 8%) of total health system expenditure, and 185,000 disability-adjusted life years (DALYs), or 7% of the total morbidity burden of disease and injury in Australia in 2003. (Begg, Vos, Barker, Stevenson, Stanley & Lopez, 2007). Injury is one of seven key health areas identified by the Commonwealth, state and territory governments for priority attention as National Health Priority Areas

The way forward : report on the preparatory phase of prefabricated building design and construction methodology: identifying critical issues and recommending the way forward

This is an initial report of the PolyU SD part of the team to study Pre-fabricated Building Design and Construction Methodology and marks the completion of Phase 1. It follows our first notes prepared for the meeting on 2 February that identified some critical issues including future lifestyles, life expectancy of buildings, sustainability, size, flexibility and planning considerations. It is also an expansion of our presentation in Dongguan on 23 February. It is not a comprehensive survey of existing approaches or possible ways forward, but it has homed in on certain specific issues and does give specific examples to make the suggestions concrete. It is recommended that more comprehensive research be done to establish previous work and experience internationally. It is also recommended that more research be done on lifestyles as a preliminary to developing at least three concepts for evaluation before proceeding to the detailed design of one concept for full prototyping and market testing. The goal at this point is not to define a single direction but to suggest several future trajectories for further consideration. By the same token, this report is not intended as an exhaustive description of the considerable base of knowledge and ideas brought by the PolyU team to this exciting task. Before taking on an issue of this magnitude and importance in the definition of Hong Kong's future, one must carry out a thoughtful analysis of the issues at hand and an informed definition of paradigms, directions, goals and methods whereby our energies can be best used in the next steps. This report is the result of this analysis