Theodicies, Utilitarianism, and Respect for Persons

Most theodicy responses to the problem of evil have in common the claim that God legitimately allows some evil such that greater good may come. This response is puzzling because the seemingly overwhelming consensus (at least amongst Christian apologists) is that 1) morality is deontological in nature (e.g. our duty of obedience to God’s commands, or acting in accordance with God’s purpose), and 2) relatedly, that humans are made in God’s image (i. e. are rational beings) and thus are worthy of respect. I shall argue that theodicy defenses that claim that God allows some evil such that greater good may come are untenable because they either unnecessarily bifurcate Christian morality in an ad hoc manner, or entail that God cannot have respect for persons.

1925 Mary Dennie

Queen of the Quill 1925-1926

1928 Hortense Miller

1928-1929 Queen of the Quill

1926 Bertha Johnson

1926-1927 Miss Lincoln

1929 Zenobia A. James

1929-1930 Queen of the Quill

1930 Edith Greene

1930-1931 Queen of the Quill

1935 Almeta Verginia Crockett

1935-1936 Miss Homecoming

1937 Eloise Jackson Taylor

1937-1938 Miss Homecoming

1938 Pauline Julianne Combs

1938-1939 Miss Homecoming

1952 Barbara Jo Wells

1952-1953 Miss Homecoming

1951 Harlene Anderson

1951-1952 Miss Homecoming

1954 Shirley White

1954-1955 Miss Homecoming

1953 Barbara Johnson

1953-1954 Miss Homecoming

1957 Elise Frazier

1957-1958 Miss Lincoln

1956 Billie Bradshaw

1956-1957 Miss Lincoln